Just so you know Rudy, I looked up what instrument was being played at 9:10, I found out through hours of research it’s called a “guitar.” It’s a stringed instrument often used today in various musical genres such as jazz, punk, reggae, rock, metal,m etc. if I found out anymore information on this rare instrument I’ll let you know.
@@katpage9378 FUCK, hours of research wasted. I just found out that that “guitar” I was talking about can have more than 6 strings sometimes. Now I have to research bongos.
Great, now with added sarcasm, we will never really know if a compliment is real or roast... Fantasic. Love that. On a more serious, less sarcastic note, loving the more detailed constructive criticisms coming out of these lately. Very useful!
"Why aren’t you smiling?” Depression bro. Also realising that Rudy has never listened to Blackwater Park by Opeth and that’s why he had no idea that the 'eerie' instrument is a GUITAR.
Ah, you've done it now Rudy. Henceforth, whenever you give your opinion on stuff, it doesn't matter what you say because we will all just feel what we ourselves feel. Kind of like the voice of God, or something. When we feel it's shit, praise will sound like sarcasm. When we feel it's good, a roast will feel like sarcasm. No matter what, forthwith, you will have spoken true to our hearts.
In the Epigram song, sort of mid way with that trumpet was mindblowing. Rudi was right, the first part of the song kinda sucked but from midway was so fkn incredible, some of the best music I've heard in ages.
I think even if you raised the cost to $100 you'd still get flooded with songs. You may have accidentally created a money printing formula. I mean *accidentally,* no way Rudy was smart enough to know this be so successful.
Hey, Hamish Clark here. Thanks so much for having our song on your video, go hard bro. You managed to roast people without roasting them, but I think that says more about the entries roasting themselves 🤔😂 Went nice for as long as you could. Much love RUclips Dad.
Dude were you trying to make the production sound like the first Enslaved album on purpose? It's so bang on that I'm curious what that guitar tone even is
@@brgl61 you know that's such a good point! Genuinely no. It was just messing around in the studio until something sounded good. Awesome comparison, though!
I personally loved it dude. I’d love to sound like that. Super badass and original and not at all basic or generic. Also, you have a great voice. The harmonies were on point too. Might give it a few listens outside of Rubdum’s video. Keep making stuff man. It’s great. Edit: Just found your profile on Apple music. Pictures on the wall is the shit!
@@luciddreams8481 thank you, your comment warms my heart. Its a 2017 record and I just started getting the word out. your feedback encourages to write more songs 💚
@@MichaelVRybakMusic Absolutely man. As an aspiring musician myself, I get the struggle and it always warms my heart to warm up others, especially if they’re an individual as talented as yourself! Keep on keeping on man. Your music deserves recognition.
I personally loved the "Epigram" song. At least some parts of it. You can tell the guitarist is very clearly inspired by Steve vai in nearly everything they do, even using that one "Answers" lick twice there. I'm just a huge Steve vai fan though so that might be it 😭
surprisingly I'm not super well versed in Vai's discography! I'm glad you dig what you do :) this was my first ep and I'm only 18 so I can only get better !
@@elijahstewart3231 it was sick in my opinion! I had assumed you were a vai fan considering the vibe and the way you went about articulating each note to begin with, but you did use one of his licks twice at one point lol. I enjoyed it for sure!
The Mantis mantra had some decent aspects but sounded like a jam session trying to find some good ideas for a song.. while sticking to a specific structure.. which they have yet to write.
Never heard of Ron Minis before, but was very impressed with the track you've got on this video. Just starting to nose through some of his other stuff on YT, and it's SOOOOO GOOD!!! 😀
Shu Cutie Rudy : So…What exactly makes some Music ‘good’ & other Music ‘bad’ ? That question bother’d musical theorists since the time of Pythagoras & still was a big question of Johannes Josephus Fux in his massive Latin student tome on counterpoint (‘Gradus ad Parnassum’) from 1725 -after debating ‘de gustu’ (‘On Musical Taste’ ) at first he admitted ‘when it comes to music & the arts, all I can say is ‘to each his own’ as Cicero wrote [‘on matters of Taste there can be no discussion nor can an Arbiter be found to decide ‘good’ from ‘bad’-for those who like a particular thing, that’s the thing they like’ = de gustibus non disputandum est…] Later he came to the conclusion that Pythagoras came to after studying in Egypt for 19 years & being admitted into the Egyptian mystery cults that ‘Beauty in the Arts is determin’d by its level of adherence to sacred intervals determined by the intervals set by close attention to the carefully measur’d motion of the heavenly ‘spheres’ (planets) mathematical proportions e.g. 1:1 (unison); 2:1 (octave); 3:2 (fifth); 4:3 (fourth); 5:4 (major 3rd) and 6:5 (minor third); To Pythagoras & the Ancient Greek musical theorists (like Anexamender & his ‘school’) the further one strays from the divine perfection of the One (unison 1:1) the farther one gets from the divine One God (in Fux’ Weltanschauung) and the most perfect intervals added together have to be 7 or less (4:3 is the last of the ‘perfect consonants’; the rest in the long series after that are ‘imperfect consonance’s & outright dissonances’ And to Fux there are ‘very stringent rules’ of ‘Motus’ (the tracking-motion between intervals) which when boil’d down to basics means ‘in two or three or four part Harmony you may not play two perfect consonant intervals [or triad-chords] in a row by ‘direct motion’ -ev’rything else (oblique & contrary motion of notes within intervals) is allowable…’ Wow - how open-minded of Fux-but he was specifically speaking of ‘how to compose the most perfect music for use in the Divine Service’ i.e. the Mass or Offertory or the Litany or Oratorio etc. & his rules for secular common everyday musical composition were free of many of his ‘liturgical restrictions’ design’d ‘specifically to honour the great God of Heaven & thus must always be as perfect as possible’ i.e. by emulating the motion of heavenly bodies in the sky… But to return to our own time, with regard to Improvis’d Jazz technique or Heavy Metal ‘sounds’ (which those with perfect pitch or sensitive ears might find offensive or even downright disgusting) it would be hard to find mathematical interval parameters in order to nail down ‘good Jazz’ or ‘good metal’ from ‘bad’ - Maybe instinct should be the guide here to help the listener decide ‘what is good or even great music ’ from ‘what is bad or slipshod - like a dog who can’t tell you exactly what a cat is in any language whatsoever -but he’d sure know it when he saw it !!!’ LoL
Digihell was cool, I liked the chorus. Verse was kinda weirdly structured, like the words didn't fit the rhythm they were going for, but maybe I'm just missing something. I'm not exactly all that aware of what modern metal is like, so maybe that style is more prominent than I realize
Ngl but that guy Vomi seems pretty interesting, gives me Skinny Puppy/Ohgr vibes mixed with metal breakdowns hahaha, weird af in a very good way for me
Just so you know Rudy, I looked up what instrument was being played at 9:10, I found out through hours of research it’s called a “guitar.” It’s a stringed instrument often used today in various musical genres such as jazz, punk, reggae, rock, metal,m etc. if I found out anymore information on this rare instrument I’ll let you know.
Stop lying, it’s clearly a bongo drum
@@katpage9378 FUCK, hours of research wasted. I just found out that that “guitar” I was talking about can have more than 6 strings sometimes. Now I have to research bongos.
it was also being played through most likely an ancient Mayan device called a "Fuzz Pedal"
@@Healcraft Wasn’t a fuzz pedal ;)
@@BatmansButtsack also delay
*a single sustained note with delay*
Rudy: what instrument is this?
Great, now with added sarcasm, we will never really know if a compliment is real or roast... Fantasic. Love that.
On a more serious, less sarcastic note, loving the more detailed constructive criticisms coming out of these lately. Very useful!
your iq has gotta be like under 70 if you can't differentiate sarcasm from genuineness
River fallen has been on my toplist since he featured it. So atleast he will still give you that exposure. 😅
I love rivers fallen. Still listen to it to this day. Keep up the good work.
"Why aren’t you smiling?” Depression bro. Also realising that Rudy has never listened to Blackwater Park by Opeth and that’s why he had no idea that the 'eerie' instrument is a GUITAR.
What time in the video is this part? I love eerie but don’t want to watch the whole video
@@katpage9378 9:10
Blackwater park is a key point of musical development for any metal listener
@@jensenparker5504 For listeners of all music types imo....Blackwater Park is masterpiece across all genres
Opeth has produced amazing music that are the pillars for modern music.
"Nice Rudy" = Passive aggressive Rudy.
Edit: Alright Nice Rudy lasted for less than one song.
The drummer in Ron Minis video is Yogev Gabay - he has a youtube channel and it's great if you'd like to learn about music with clever rhythms.
AND it's Mayshuggah on his channel, now is the T I M E
Yalla, mayshuggah be upon us.
That part in Epigram was really cool reminded me of something from Katatonia, good job.
I'm glad you dig :)
Ok that violenta niebla song absolutely slaps for no reason
“I think it sounds nostalgic” “yeah I’m remembering when I wasn’t alive and I want to go back to that” lolllllll
Ah, you've done it now Rudy. Henceforth, whenever you give your opinion on stuff, it doesn't matter what you say because we will all just feel what we ourselves feel. Kind of like the voice of God, or something. When we feel it's shit, praise will sound like sarcasm. When we feel it's good, a roast will feel like sarcasm. No matter what, forthwith, you will have spoken true to our hearts.
You guys have some strong self esteem to send your music to get roasted
In the Epigram song, sort of mid way with that trumpet was mindblowing. Rudi was right, the first part of the song kinda sucked but from midway was so fkn incredible, some of the best music I've heard in ages.
i'm very glad you dig the end, i also much prefer the last half of the song lol
I know you don't want to make these videos for 8 business days but I love every one of these. Thank you!
Judging from Rudy's general taste in music I'd be pretty disappointed if he liked anything I made.
Why don’t you like his music taste?
You probably make jam metal self taught. Go fish
@@TheCkhutton12 I don't know what that is.
I think even if you raised the cost to $100 you'd still get flooded with songs. You may have accidentally created a money printing formula. I mean *accidentally,* no way Rudy was smart enough to know this be so successful.
I think Arab Dad came up with the idea. 😂
Hey, Hamish Clark here. Thanks so much for having our song on your video, go hard bro. You managed to roast people without roasting them, but I think that says more about the entries roasting themselves 🤔😂
Went nice for as long as you could. Much love RUclips Dad.
Dude were you trying to make the production sound like the first Enslaved album on purpose? It's so bang on that I'm curious what that guitar tone even is
I actually liked it a lot btw, tasty riffs
@@brgl61 you know that's such a good point! Genuinely no. It was just messing around in the studio until something sounded good.
Awesome comparison, though!
@@brgl61 thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed it.
How is your username supposed to be pronounced? Hdhisdh?
I appreciate the review of my tune Epigram!
You give really good advice compared to the other review dudes homie g
*in full non-nasal voice w/o reverb* thank you bro💚yup that's acoustic guitar + cajon, with a touch of electric guitar in choruses.
I personally loved it dude. I’d love to sound like that. Super badass and original and not at all basic or generic. Also, you have a great voice. The harmonies were on point too. Might give it a few listens outside of Rubdum’s video. Keep making stuff man. It’s great.
Edit: Just found your profile on Apple music. Pictures on the wall is the shit!
@@luciddreams8481 thank you, your comment warms my heart. Its a 2017 record and I just started getting the word out. your feedback encourages to write more songs 💚
@@MichaelVRybakMusic Absolutely man. As an aspiring musician myself, I get the struggle and it always warms my heart to warm up others, especially if they’re an individual as talented as yourself! Keep on keeping on man. Your music deserves recognition.
I really liked your track!
@@MichaelVRybakMusic You give me very Breaking Benjamin vibes when you have more power in your voice. Love it!
#5 ... I FFFFF🤬ING LOVE THIS!!!
Nerd Metal and its awesome..
Son of a Pixel, I'm definitely checking them out.
2 years later but... 🤷
Sarcasm is the first thing i expect Abode to do
"violenta niebla" had me thinking my headphones were broken
The Backburner was 100% Anathema. Even the clean guitar tones and ebow leads. The intro is completely "Deep" of Anathema
plz dont stop doing these
The last one by Ron Minis reminds me of Dave Brubeck at times but it went the extra mile with those effects and techniques. Very cool.
Vomi always delivers, jesus....
Son of a Pixel was actually dope
Vilenta Niebla talking recorded on a gamer headset
This video is like a fever dream
I personally loved the "Epigram" song. At least some parts of it. You can tell the guitarist is very clearly inspired by Steve vai in nearly everything they do, even using that one "Answers" lick twice there. I'm just a huge Steve vai fan though so that might be it 😭
surprisingly I'm not super well versed in Vai's discography! I'm glad you dig what you do :) this was my first ep and I'm only 18 so I can only get better !
@@elijahstewart3231 it was sick in my opinion! I had assumed you were a vai fan considering the vibe and the way you went about articulating each note to begin with, but you did use one of his licks twice at one point lol. I enjoyed it for sure!
@@aaronwarner06 thank you so much! id love to hear this lick you’re talking about haha
@@elijahstewart3231 I believe it's 1:18 in "Answers". ruclips.net/video/W143vwHxrfA/видео.html
@@elijahstewart3231 Gives me like Final Fantasy 7 music vibes it's pretty cool sounding
the melody of that Lakesick song (30:54) sounds like a little kid trying to tease/provoke you, "nananana na, nananana na"
I'm glad someone caught that, haha
The Mantis mantra had some decent aspects but sounded like a jam session trying to find some good ideas for a song.. while sticking to a specific structure.. which they have yet to write.
WHO ARE YOU AND WHAT HAVE YOU DONE WITH RUDY ADOBE
This sure isnt Adobe Premiere.
I could actually imagine this series as a podcast
The title of the video is what I've never said about Ruby Ayoub's videos
Oof
I'm subscribed to the drummer in the last song's RUclips channel lol, he's a really skilled and knowledgeable guy.
Never heard of Ron Minis before, but was very impressed with the track you've got on this video. Just starting to nose through some of his other stuff on YT, and it's SOOOOO GOOD!!! 😀
Shu Cutie Rudy :
So…What exactly makes some Music ‘good’ & other Music ‘bad’ ?
That question bother’d musical theorists since the time of Pythagoras & still was a big question of Johannes Josephus Fux in his massive Latin student tome on counterpoint (‘Gradus ad Parnassum’) from 1725 -after debating ‘de gustu’ (‘On Musical Taste’ ) at first he admitted ‘when it comes to music & the arts, all I can say is ‘to each his own’ as Cicero wrote [‘on matters of Taste there can be no discussion nor can an Arbiter be found to decide ‘good’ from ‘bad’-for those who like a particular thing, that’s the thing they like’ = de gustibus non disputandum est…]
Later he came to the conclusion that Pythagoras came to after studying in Egypt for 19 years & being admitted into the Egyptian mystery cults that ‘Beauty in the Arts is determin’d by its level of adherence to sacred intervals determined by the intervals set by close attention to the carefully measur’d motion of the heavenly ‘spheres’ (planets) mathematical proportions e.g. 1:1 (unison); 2:1 (octave); 3:2 (fifth); 4:3 (fourth); 5:4 (major 3rd) and 6:5 (minor third);
To Pythagoras & the Ancient Greek musical theorists (like Anexamender & his ‘school’) the further one strays from the divine perfection of the One (unison 1:1) the farther one gets from the divine One God (in Fux’ Weltanschauung) and the most perfect intervals added together have to be 7 or less (4:3 is the last of the ‘perfect consonants’; the rest in the long series after that are ‘imperfect consonance’s & outright dissonances’
And to Fux there are ‘very stringent rules’ of ‘Motus’ (the tracking-motion between intervals) which when boil’d down to basics means ‘in two or three or four part Harmony you may not play two perfect consonant intervals [or triad-chords] in a row by ‘direct motion’ -ev’rything else (oblique & contrary motion of notes within intervals) is allowable…’
Wow - how open-minded of Fux-but he was specifically speaking of ‘how to compose the most perfect music for use in the Divine Service’ i.e. the Mass or Offertory or the Litany or Oratorio etc. & his rules for secular common everyday musical composition were free of many of his ‘liturgical restrictions’ design’d ‘specifically to honour the great God of Heaven & thus must always be as perfect as possible’ i.e. by emulating the motion of heavenly bodies in the sky…
But to return to our own time, with regard to Improvis’d Jazz technique or Heavy Metal ‘sounds’ (which those with perfect pitch or sensitive ears might find offensive or even downright disgusting) it would be hard to find mathematical interval parameters in order to nail down ‘good Jazz’ or ‘good metal’ from ‘bad’ -
Maybe instinct should be the guide here to help the listener decide ‘what is good or even great music ’ from ‘what is bad or slipshod - like a dog who can’t tell you exactly what a cat is in any language whatsoever -but he’d sure know it when he saw it !!!’ LoL
Really enjoyed the entries this time around
"yeah... I´m not Jacob Collier bR0oOo."😂😂
"Forgot to get water..."
"Oops"
XD omg that was too much my guy haha I felt that one, and that's why I'm here lol
Son of a Pixel features hilarious lyrics, at least.
I kind of liked the song.
I honestly loved the 2nd one. And the 3rd one as well, without the singing.
Digihell was cool, I liked the chorus. Verse was kinda weirdly structured, like the words didn't fit the rhythm they were going for, but maybe I'm just missing something. I'm not exactly all that aware of what modern metal is like, so maybe that style is more prominent than I realize
The last song
OMG!!! Its the blue beard man-bun band again
🤗
It's like jazz... but not.
Like listening to Charlie Brown music on crack..
That last composition is great. Finally :-) That kind of prog I am always for. Actually it reminded me Tigran Hamasyan
"Why Aren't You Smiling" felt like the 90s.
Pretty bad tho
@@zymonx5624 just as bad as Rudy. This whole channel is bad.
"have you listened to SFSGSW before writing this?" LMAO
Eyyyyy, thanks for checking us out bro!!! :)
I scrolled to see if you left a comment! Dope track! 👌🏼
@@SaintTrinasTorch thank you! 🙏🙏
5:06 Rudy's mock accent actually affected my speech in 2022 (before I then touched some grass)
That second one was dope
That must have been a very rare mood. You being nice, I mean.
Best thing I’ve seen all week probably!
14:36 rudy breaking the fourth wall is fucking hilarious
Okay but low-key that song "Get Up" by Rybak is kinda good, definitely the best singer I've heard out of any roast video you've posted
The "get up" song... I like it.
Its different, and it's like a rash that I don't mind having.
??? 😐
12:45 thanks!
awesome song bro
I love Rudy's trump face and gesture he does, hilarious
Timestamp?
The bitemarque band sounded like Golum singing.
Who else love Rudy vids?
#4 ahhhh... Tranque music
Can you do the Philly stoop
I always wonder what you would say if Nirvana was now and they sent in a demo like “endless nameless” It always interests me.
I have PTSD, Violenta Niebla almost made me kill the entire neighbourhood, thank god he resolved it...they are all safe and sound lol
37:22 he sounds like the vocalist of system of a down
Bitemarque seems pretty cool. I liked the comedy and gothiness.
Dude, thanks for the roast bro, good stuff man.
Nice rudy is even more brutal than rude rudy
"nice rudy" oozing with sarcasm, love it.
Son of a Pixel vocal remembers me Destrage
Last one was literal Djazz.
isn't that Yogev Gabay playing drums in 40:47 ? HE IS!
My favourite show on RUclips
lmfao i hope there are more roasts with "nice Rudy"
“Like for example have you heard of a dumpster?” ☠️☠️☠️☠️
Oh shit I didn't know you have a mtb channel! Fuck yeah dude let's get shreddy
Sarcasm :) love it
Even when you're not talking, I'm just laughing anyway! ahahahah God!!! :D
Yo Rudes my dudes you should do some twitch streams...
ps. the wet voice remark killed me lmao
wow last band were incredible
RIP that guys boss ☠️
Ngl but that guy Vomi seems pretty interesting, gives me Skinny Puppy/Ohgr vibes mixed with metal breakdowns hahaha, weird af in a very good way for me
very good c:
30:54 "rain rain go away come again another day"
Based nursery rhyme melody plagiarizers
bet
will need some Yes after this one.
90125.
The Backburner sounded a bit like Anathema , Judgement - Natural Disaster era
Love to watch these, while eating 🍕
GIVE US BACK THE ROASTS WAA
Wow, nice Rudy actually gives me the creeps, spooky 🥶
Ayo thats Yogev Gabay on drums for that last track!! he's a neat dude! idk if youve seen his youtube channel but he makes dope analysis videos
I always knew when the first guy playing guitar with black shirt, my heart just feel right 💀
6:37 Heyyy did you just whistled In The Flash by Pain of Salvation?????
This makes me want to never start making music
Dude it's far more better than roasting songs =)))))))
Vomi didn't make me throw up. Your video did. Again
Sorry i'll try harder next time :(
@@Vomi69 I'll await impatiently then ! (That was full of good chunks btw)
@@reverend_rollmops was that a vomit joke lol
Sarcasm was the special sauce missing from all of the other roasting videos, huh
Someone looks alike has been replaced real ruby abode
Fuck I love passive aggressive rudy lmaooooo
Rudy what kind of music you like- Rihana...Bon jovi?
“everything’s not doing anything that’s relevant to anything”
The last song sounds like a boss battle song.
Yo the Digihell song was actually decent haha