Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Gunners Shot Clips : Five Developments Rattling China / Lt Gen Ata Hasnain / Lt Gen P R Shankar
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 май 2024
- #GUNNERSSHOT #InternationalRelations #UPSC #CSE #StrategicAffairs #defence
Gunners Shot Clips : Five Developments Rattling China / Lt Gen Ata Hasnain / Lt Gen P R Shankar
GUNNERS SHOT IS A CHANNEL FOR DEFENCE & STRATEGIC AFFAIRS, TECHNOLOGY AND WELFARE OF ARMED FORCES PERSONNEL.
GUNNERS SHOT is a channel in which the best of Indian Military and Strategic experts express their views and opinions.
GUNNERS SHOT is a non partisan channel devoted to high quality.
Support Gunners Shot with your contribution through GPay to +91 9384855773
SUBSCRIBE TO GUNNERS SHOT RUclips CHANNEL@ / @gunnersshot
SUBSCRIBE TO GUNNERS SHOT TECH CHANNEL @ / @gunnersshottech-jl6gp
Join the channel as a member @ / @gunnersshot
THIS VIDEO IS AVAILABLE IN PODCAST FORM @ / @gunnersshot
Gunners Shot RUclips Channel has multiple .playlists to enhance your viewing experience.
All articles are available @ www.gunnersshot.com
Follow Gunners Shot WhatsApp Channel @ whatsapp.com/c...
Twitter : @palepurshankar or @gunners_shot1
Join Telegram group @ t.me/gunnersshot
Disclaimer : Views expressed on this channel by this who appear on it are their personal opinions and can not be attributed to GUNNERS SHOT
Sometimes I think are we qualified enough to enjoy a discussion of such strategic magnitude !!! Thank you Sir for bringing in Gen. Ata Hasnain.
Sat sri akaal Honorable Ata Hasnain sahib ji, Shankar sahib ji as well all listeners, thanks a lot for explaining the critical issues in very simple language... JAI HIND, VANDEMATRAM...
We are fortunate that such highly accomplished and illustrious gentlemen like Gen Ata Hasnain, Gen Shanker and others take their valuable time to educate us about geo politics and India's position in these high powered global games. Thank you so much sir. We appreciate this so much. You are serving the cause of India even in retirement after a lifetime spent in scintillating service in the cause of our country.
🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾
General Hasnain and General Shankar , both the gentlemen are eminently highly qualified to discuss and comment on the issues. Thanks.
Excellent discussion. We really feel proud and happy as Indians over our strategic thinking and actions.
Can it will be possible for Congress to Challenge China after making secret agreement with PLA.
Let us see
The likelihood of congress becoming the largest party is quite low. The bjp even if it falls short of majority will be able to cobble together a coalition quite easily. And there is a even chance bjp will get a majority on its own. So this is in my view and humble opinion a moot question.
india is no where in front of china never forget 1962 war where your coward army surrendered to china
I do not give much importance to Tibet or POK. I give importance to Myanmar. Myanmar is a part of India. There is no justification for allowing for a separate statehood to Burma during British rule. Now Myanmar has given COCO Island to China. Too much spirituality is dangerous to any nation. For the survival of any country, the ruler's first responsibility is to protect the borders. The failure of Indian rulers in the past was that they failed to develop new Arms and ammunition. They failed to protect the Passes in the Himalayas. Till 1962 Indian rulers thought Passes were all no man's land. Now the Indian army is the best mountain warfare force in the world and the Govt is not worried about PLA. The 1996 agreement with China is excellent. China can never defeat India. Some encounter is required to alert the troops.
@Govindan7 what rubbish are you talking here. India is not China or Russia. India will not invade and occupy other independent country. India has a long border with Tibet from Ladhak in the west to Arunachal in the east. China has salami sliced thousands of Kilometers of Indian land after the occupation of Tibet by china in 1950. If you like it or not A Free Tibet is India‘s Security; Tibbat Bharat ka Surakska ha! Don‘t talk like a foolish professor. Do you know who are the SFF Battalion? Find for yourself.
I do agree, it's past ruler's mistakes that we couldn't built better relation eastern countries incl Myanmar &neglected Coco Island. We don't have any powerful country in support.Now Pak& china will continue wounding with help of our own internal politicians I.e.presently seen.
@@Bhoetuk. Your reply has exposed your ignorance about the subject. So I do not like to waste my time with people like you.
Jay hind hon'ble sir's 🇮🇳
Yours conversation not only enlighten us but also enhances confidence level.
🐬🐯🐦🤱🌻🌳🌏
China is developing ports in Cambodia, Myanmar, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Maldives. They may construct a channel in Thailand. They are constructing a port in Bangladesh which may or may not be under Chinese control. So understand the Chinese strategy.
As usual just hyping china and underestimating bharat If china is building so much wats the use it can’t capture Taiwan a small nation Forget about Bharat
let us see.
@105vivek
Never mind!
All their ports in Indian Ocean (this side of Malacca straits) are vulnerable. PR can't defend them.
"Construct a 'channel' across Thailand is an impossibility. So, you presume that while they are at work in Thailand. India, USA & other main Western countries simply sit idle, watching them to do that. I think you (whoever you are) must be day dreaming.
Jai hind Jai Bharat
I am proud of our defence forces . They are most disciplined ,mosr talented,committed with conviction for guarding the nation at the cost of their lives. Most importantly they have the talent and ability to execute any operations like thesurgical operations. Butvthe political leadership during congress regime failed to develop their talents for obvious reasons known to it only.Now thisvregime has taken the defence forces into confidenceand work in tandem in order for us to the nation to be safe from the hands of enemies whose strides are faster than us. Keeping this factor in mind this government is encouraging the this sector who are better commited convicted in defending the nation than the politicians who happened to lead the nation.
❤
Jai Hind Sirs...
Respect and pranaams to both of you....
Absolutely correct. A lot of us will not rest until we get Aksai chin back and get kailash back as that always since the beginning of time(kailash) been India’s. What’s more we are trying to convince as many youngsters as possible to follow through as first india has build capacity which may take some time.
What are your plans
I,have served the area under. Discussion from 73 to79 as a ib rept,condensation were very different and difficult in those days,(Arunachal )well informed discussion.
Excellent coverage
Indians should be more worried of developments on the chinese side.
1. Occupation of eastern ladakh especially at depsang plains
2. Chinese presence at doklam too close to siliguri corridor
3. Increasing presence of chinese navy ships and in Bay of Bengal and waters around india
4. The construction of multiple dams across upper flow of brahmaputra river in tibet
5. Illegal occupation of large chunks of bhutan area by china
Hmm
Lt. General Sir, if it is possible, can you talk about Army doctrine? how does it think? How does Indian army organize itself? Stuff you will learn from a War College. Does Army follow an Indian equivalent of Clausewitz?
Let us not expose ourselves
Excellent
The aids of PM that is those heading the ministries of external affairs,finance , defence and home are gems supporting the cause of India in the efforts of the PM. Above all the defence personnel are more loyal to the nation.. so only the fast strides of India in international arena
For them it is worse than is in the public domain
There is a distinctly new Naval strategy evolving, especially by India is becoming apparent. Are Missiles going to dominate naval strategy.
Connect the dots. The havoc caused by Houtis with rudimentary missiles, India’s slow down on third aircraft carrier and shift towards submarines, development of Andamans and Lakshadweep as bases, Bramhos, India is testing a major missile test at least once a month and to cap it all the recent the recent successful testing of the missile launched torpedo with a range of 900 km.
Indian Missiles will become a potent offensive tool to keep Chinese ships at check. It we have these missile deployed all along the coast in the mainland and Andaman’s, every Chinese ships/submarine in every single square km within a radius of 1000 km of Andaman will be within our range. They dare not try anything aggressive in this zone. Best part is we need not risk our ships and submarines. The missiles will give India a very powerful Offence Defence capacity in a few years time.
Let me pray for the long life of Modi Sarkar who keeps the Defence force of India at the proper place they deserve for praise so that they are the one to keep us safe at this point ofvtime when international forces are threatening our souverignity
Hmm
🙏🙏🙏
♥️🙏
Jai Hind 🙏
Jay Hind🕉️🇮🇳🚩
Jai Hind 🇮🇳 🇮🇳 Sir
Ok
INDIA COULD NOT LIVE PEACEFULLY ATALL UNLESS AND UNTILL HE SOLVE THE BORDER ISSUE AND OCCUPING AREA OF CHINA AND PAKISTAN .
1. As regards Maldives, India should ensure that free access to its people into India should be curtailed and ensure that our tourists are taxed if they visit Maldives. No free lunches to Maldives until it improves it behavior. We innocently believe that Muizzu is a temporary phenomenon. We are wrong, to say the least!! 2. As regards China, Xi has been making big mistakes since Dokhlam days. His initiatives made India wake up and get ready to tackle China. And Modi is neither Nehru nor even Indira! In next 5-10 years, China will find it has lost all its leads in strategic and military domain.
My worry at this point of timeis this. The opposition is trying to oust this govt at some way or ither by giving false assurances,levelling false accusations etc.and keeping the people confused to acieve their gol. If it happens the tempo of India may slow down. Hope The Almighty will take care of the welfare of Indiaandcalso pray for that
Do not worry
While the indians are discussing what is rattling the china, they should also discuss and admit what china developments are rattling the indians.
Recently i read china is building roads at Shaksham valley near siachen glacier.
Is it rattling the indians? 😂
Very active todaY!
@@gunnersshot 😂
What are implications if we dereciignize tibet as part of China and take USA, UK, EUROPE WITH US.
Ask in a live show
Sir what is the use of discussing these all after both of you are retired?
hmm
leaving this comment for our Chinese Brothers/Bots
Waiting for Chinese trolls :P
Why do you all wasting your time on China when India needs plenty of your attention just to move along?
Hmm
From aircraft to self propelled artillery to air tp ground missiles , one can't help being ashamed of the disaster that the Indian defense ministry ,the Army's procurement bodies and to some extent the air force have turned out to be .
Talking about defeating China or having rattled China is so easy . It however stands in strong contrast to the humiliation this same army brought to the country .
Even the mockery invited from all corners of the world after the humiliation of the IAF by Pakistan seems not to have bothered our great Generals who find in dialectics a fine alternative for physical reality .
Just try to compare the huge disaster that the Indian military is with the South Korean armed services and you'd start to understand what a monumental failure the Indian army is .
Indigenous development in India has been made impossible by this colonial body .
75 yrs since 47 .... And one still keeps running across news items warning Indian military to hurry up or risk being left behind by the Pakistani army . That's the army of a bankrupt country .
Says much about both the armies .Only Indians can but be ashamed of this shameless colonial carcass that their money pays for .
Your only saving grace is numbers .
Shame on this abject exemplar of inefficiency.
It's no surprise that Indian military is obsessed with Pakistan . While qualitatively much inferior , your numbers still favour you .
The worst part is that the Army , the most inept of all services Swallows up the major chunk of the budget whereas the Navy , the saving grace is forced to make do with the pittance it gets .
Imagine ... This third rate army not allowing the Navy to develop .
It's like communism .
The Army would not rest till it has brought the navy to lows that so far only it knows .
Shame on you .
Not that you'd understand what that emotion means
quite a fool from across!
@@gunnersshot
You're bloody right.
MODE IS NOT MORE THAN ME HE CAN NOT TALK TO ME.MAP WICH YOU HAVE FOR NO INDIA ON THIS GLOBE AS KE MA KE OS.
DO NOT TALK ABOUTE AGNEE WE DO HAVE TOO. EVEN BATTER THAN YOU. WHAT IS IMPORTANT IS TO SOLVE BORDER ISSUE AS YOU ARE ILLEGALLY OCCUPING KASHMER AND JONAGHAR.
Hmm
With due respect, you are respectable figures. However, when a person, politician or a group of people promises apple and delivers berry, the 2nd person in this bargain feels lemoned and although he may not speak, given delivery of berry. We the people have been promised recoup of PoJK, CAA, NRC, UCC, PCC, etc etc etc and been delivered net 3~4% vikaas. Without army delivery of valour to inflict disproportionate damage on enemy, these talks sounds like masterstroke of jhumlatantra.
Hmm
Try to get your housing society bldgs repaired with a certain time in mind & then reply after you finish.
China is basically jingoistic nation otherwise what they wanted to achieve could have been achieved by good relations with India and may be more. But their madness of capturing new territories does not allow them. Had they returned axai chin and dropped claim on NEFA, they would have reaped much more benefit at much less cost.
❤