It's not a mistake now they are portraying their older government as if they made a mistake but that policy continuous till today and that will continue if India and Pakistan remain in existence for next 1000 years it is going to be the same policy which will drive the southeast so far
Excuse me sir. America DID come to Pakistan's help. They sent their 7th fleet I think. Russians stood by and had us have our own wars. Please stop pretending that you just stood by. You bet against India not once, not twice but a million times. As recent as The Kargil War, America supported Pakistan, even playing the "Big Daddy" trying to intimidate Shri Vajpayee
Presents only half the picture. Pakistan was created by the British as a reward to those who opposed Indian independence. As a result, it was natural that it became part of the West . The claim that US helped India in 1962 is nonsense. Before the war, the US refused to sell defence equipment to India. In the war, US support was limited to speeches, despite Indian request for actually getting involved. The US offer of help came only after China declared a ceasefire. In the 1990s, US continued to pour money into Pakistan despite the Soviet withdrawal from Afghanistan. US supported Pakistani extremism in Kashmir and Punjab. It required 9/11 for YS to become a little neutral. Even now, the US continues to launch propaganda attacks against India in support of drug dealers. To justify this, it calls drug dealers as religious leaders. The US has definitely had an anti India bias in its actions. This is why Indians do not look at US as a trustworthy partner
@@ramachandrankannan274yes. Exactly. They never said a world on pak lead terrorism in india. They were silent on people dying in india,had active role in mumbai attacks,Richard hadlee was a double agent. They support khallistanis, kashmir militants. America was silent on people dying in india for 40 long years. They actually supported Pakistan dictators. They were working close with dictators. Indian democracy never has any appeal to them. They preferred communist China. Bashing indian democracy was always their favorite sport. So people of dont understand US Russia on other hand always understood indias concerns ,problems. People of india have no reason to distrust resent Russia. Growing US friendship means a lot to them but that automatically doesnot make them suddenly hate Russia. India sees Russia as reliable friend.
Americans didn't care a damm on genocide of Kashmiri Hindus,bomb blasts, 26/11 attacks in India ,but their heart goes out for Pakistanis.Down with both these partners
Americans and Europeans even watched over hindu and sikh genocide carried out by Pakistan and Afghanistan and Bangladesh. They also funded islamic and Christian missionaries in India to sabotage Hindus. Americans and Europeans reprimands India to promote islamise and Christianise India freely.
Few corrections: 1. USA did support Pakistan in 1971 war, infact US/UK used their 7th fleet in Bay of Bengal and pointed missiles towards India. 2. USA did not sell weapons to India because it did not want to go against its most favored ally, a military dictatorship, Pakistan. US was totally in bed with Pakistan. Please tell the complete truth
Yes it will be difficult to trust the US on their previous accounts but both countries have to work together for mutual benefits and to keep the common enemies at bay!
@@Somd55 Yes, and I think that is India's intention.. but US is not ready. It wants to keep a control over India by framing this Pannun issue, by not doing the technology transfer as it said.
They also never tell that Russia has always stood with India in UNSC. How many times US has brought resolutions against India but Russia has veto'ed those everytime. US also doesnt want India to get permanent seat in UNSC. Russia and France do.
Bimari kya be humare Indians ko? Yeh lo ji. Indian itne gaa-ndu hai - Ek Anjrez pakiyon ki le raha hai thook laga ke, yeh lage hain usse history ka lesson padhane. If USA and England were serious, USSR could not have stopped them, and USSR did mention that to India that we will posture but we will not fight. But point yeh nahin hai - dhyaan se suno Jeff le raha hai porkiyon ki.
@@induchopra3014 The US has arrested a lot of Khalistanis in recent months. The UK has also cracked down hard on Khalistanis, since they are a threat to the UK. The Canadian government by contrast backs Khalistan. The global left and woke movement is very pro Khalistan. Sadly this extends to part of the US left and woke.
In December 1971, the Nixon administration deployed the U.S. Navy's Seventh Fleet, Task Force 74 (TF 74), to the Bay of Bengal during the Indo-Pakistani War. The fleet's mission was to support Pakistan and intimidate Indian forces. Russians subs sneaked in before and stopped the Americans from interfering.
Pakistan didn't choose islamism in '71. The country was islamist since it's formation. In fact that ideology behind creation of Pakistan started more than a century before
Exactly. The genocide of 95% Hindus and their shrines and 99% of Sikhs and majority nonmuslims took place within months of foundation in 1947.direct action day massacres leading to it targeted nonmuslims.
Exactly. The genocide of 95% Hindus and their shrines and 99% of Sikhs and majority nonmuslims took place within months of foundation in 1947.direct action day massacres leading to it targeted nonmuslims.
Pakistan is lucky to have wise and honest military people. They have safely invested Pakistani money in Papa John's pizza franchise, real estate in Canada, London, Dubai, and an island near Australia. These investments have made sure that Pakistani people don't waste their money on luxury items such as wheat flour, vegetables, electricity, clothing, and education.
what are you paijaans doing on an english language channel..... don't you have some gihadi molvi who will get you 72 hoors to follow.......git git shoo.
The irony here is that the US and the West for the most part chose two utterly non-democratic partners (Pakistan and China) in the region and sidelined a budding democratic state that was ravaged by its colonial past. They still had the gall to ask why India did not stand with the so-called "democratic West". When has the west ever stood for democracy in this part of the world I wonder?
@@zigzoog123They were in a state of shock when India pushed back on the sanctions. Like how dare India not dance to our tunes 😮 it's like they were floating in their own pink dream-bubble until it popped and they landed with a thud. I mean the sound of desperation in their repeated questioning of our FAM Dr. S.Jaishankar on India's stance is just hilarious 😂
Well, decades of Nehru idiocy helped grease the west’s policies. The west couldn’t trust a snowflake 😂 and we’re still reaping the dividends of the congress’s failed foreign policies.
What China is today, because of US policies in 70s,80s,90s,00s. It is just last 15 years US is afraid of china and backtracking. But they created a monster.
India is a Hardcore Conservative Country run by a Centre Liberal Governments, It will be Hard For India to compromise on : Its Civilization, Its Hindu Religion (Sanatan Dharma), India has lost lots of its territory and demography under Islamic And British Colonialism due to religious Conversion and Partition of India. British Colonialism has drained India from its richness its share in Global GDP dropped from 27% to 1% by 1947 at the time of freedom from British. No more interference of external powers in the Indian Subcontinent. Mutual Respect will be appreciated 👍✅
Ethnically Punjabis and Sindhis are North Indians. Secondly many migrants from 1947 live in Pakistan and they identify as Indian migrants or Muhajirs. So learn some history before commenting here.
Indian Hindus believe in Karma. Once someone helps us in critical times, we never forget that. We consider that help as a debt. Unless Russia backstab us in any way, we can't backstab our friend. It's not about Arms & maintenance with Russia. It's about a battle-tested friendship. On the other hand the USA believes in this theory 👇 "There is no permanent friend or enemy in geo-politics; only interest matters"
Bro, ur quoting some Kissinger comment against what some of the masses belief. I share ur sentiment but disagree with ur comment. It'll be nice if you can quote a thing or two about Indian statecraft
The US isn't one thing. The US has many competing lobbies. And what follows in chaos. The US generally does not act in US interests. Which is one of the USA's biggest problems. But the same is often true of India too.
@@GreaterPakistanEngPakistan turn to cry 😅 The pakistani army operates on the orders of a phone call from the USA... Imran Khan jailed... Plus the US and India are happily funding Pashtun independence fighters and Baluchistanis 😅😂
Good presentation. But US holding back GE Fighter Engines after committing to the deal is not playing well in India. American foreign policy is seen as opportunistic, transactional and fickle minded not only in India but now globally especially with Trump's statements on Nato and Taiwan. You guys will soon be left without anyone trusting your words.... A strange position for the world's only super power!
There is a problem. India is part of US partisan politics. With Republicans, independents and moderate Democrats supporting Indo US friendship and the US left and woke being viscerally anti India.
Yup, well put sir!! And especially after our FM S.Jaishankar's razor sharp words exposing American hypocrisy, everybody is starting to see through US's opportunistic intentions.
@@satadaldutta6898 Everyone is not seeing through the anti Indian woke narratives. These narratives are becoming widely held around the world. Defeating these woke narratives (which are inaccurate) means engaging with global conservatives, global liberals and others.
@@ZainUlAbideen804that's your theory, but the whole world thinks otherwise 😅 every nation wants chuslim out 😅😅 they are fed up of you fake Allah and your fake ideologies
You forgot to mention that the USA sent their 7th Fleet,together with the British Navy, against India during the 1971 war and were blocked by the Russian nuclear submarine fleet.
America ABSOLUTELY helped Pakistan in the 1971 war. Read up on the Blood Telegram. The seventh fleet was sent to the Bay of Bengal to intimidate India. America was selling weapons to Pakistan and helping them with military intelligence.
Very well said. Same people , same language, same culture, divided in 1947. How dramatically different is the trajectory. Pakistan is failed state while India is soon to be the 4th Largest economy. What is the difference. Well Muslims demanded Pakistan and got it. India continues to follow Hindu ethos. Europe Beware. You are staring at the same fate, 20 years from now
@@JohnSmith-iq9np True, and it also runs deeper. Greed, anger, lust, illusion, ego, envy, fear. The world's problems may APPEAR political/ economic/ religious / racial, but ARE spiritual problems in the core.
Europe is doomed. Muslims anywhere can’t coexist with others. Since they can’t have pier in this knowledge economy because of their medieval ethos, Their strategy is to produce more babies in western countries once they migrate and take over eventually. Once they are 5%, problems start.
Jeff... As an Indian, I want IND-US to stop playing games with each other. Let's be loud mouths for a change and talk about 1971. Also the US must make public all intelligence they have about the Assassination of Prime Minister Lal Bahadur Shastri in the Soviet Union, links of Nehru Dynasty with the Soviets. Most importantly, USA must say it bluntly, that it was the Brits who drove a wedge between India - USA and pushed India towards Moscow. Vijay Gokhale's book is an eye-opener. I am glad you spoke about Taliban. It was Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto who created the Directorate S of the ISI to intefere in Afghanistan in 1972. Its time to stop playing games amongst our selves.
What! It is public. Please read the book "Conversations with Crow", which is an interview of CIA agent. He has discussed Shastri's and Bhabha's murder and how the CIA did it.
@@sigmaxcc CIA went deep into The Soviet Union in height of the Cold war to murder Shastri without the Russians knowing about it? You people need to learn to grow a brain to start with,
USA in nutshell : We know everything about the world and what best for others without consulting anyone . We will save the world from threat that we decided exist . USA 30 years later : We screw up ! We didn't know better . But we do now . Repeat.
…most of it is correct, BUT the start is not entirely correct. India and Pakistan were not new states that emerged after WW2, India is a 5000+ year civilizational reality and Pakistan ‘was created’ out of nowhere by dismembering India. Pakistan was CREATED by Churchill with the blessing of US to create a buffer state between USSR and India. India after all is a large percentage of world population and historically large % of world GDP. West did not want communists to win over India … ultimately India suffered due to UK/US …and India will NEVER FORGET or FORGIVE!
India in its present form never existed for hundreds of centuries as you’re implying. The most unified empire was of the Mauriyan Empire and even that didn’t include as many regions as there are in India these days. India in its present form is the largest conglomeration of states and sub states as it exists in history and this was created in 1947 not 5000 years before that. 😂
@@mubashir7343 you wish! Of course large and small kingdoms kept forming…but it has been a continuous civilization with a common identify… unlike say Muslims who were different 1400 years ago because there was no Islam before that or Christians … But Bharat has a common unbroken civilizational ethos and identify for a very long time… If that was not the case the European company that did trade with India would not have been called ‘East India Company’ or when Columbus landed in America but thought he had reached ‘India’(that’s what he set out for) and till date the Native Americans are called ‘Indians’. West Indies(Jamaica, Barbados etc etc) wouldn’t be called West INDIES.. So I think you should trace your ancestors and see who exactly you were for thousands of years!
Many important misses like US supporting genocide in bangladesh, US supporting dictators in pakistan against a democracy, formation of pakistan to keep a check on India to name a few.
A correction! During 1971 India-Pak war US sent its navy ships to attack India. USSR govt gave this info to India and urgently sent submarines to help India on the request of PM Indira Gandhi. US navy got the news of the submarines and decided to turn back half way.
Excellent sober analysis. Thanks for explaining (some of) India's position to a Western audience. Western politicians need to stop being naive and PC about Islamism and Pakistan
But didn't follow Gandhi dream of unified the country . Corrupt India government didn't stand up denied Pakistan and Bangladesh independent and recognised by UN as a independent country , so for today's onward that's not internal affairs of India compare with Taiwan which still not recognise as independent country but a province or state of mainland China. So it was internal affairs for China as Taiwan part of China
We are seeing millions of indians immigrating to the UK and USA and every western country. Are u saying same for India and predicting over running of local population by indians.
@@SpoTTd : no, they r Paks taking the name India to save them from deportation, we Indians need h1b visa to go there, not illegal immigrants trying to cross the Mexican border, so Ur lies r baseless even unworthy today for Indians, same despicable, double standard USA talking about !.
@@SpoTTdpakistan - literally pak (pure/holy) + stan (land of). Here holy/pure refers to Muslims (as is clarified by constitution of Pakistan). In the west this idea is known as the Islamic state. It is not a country in the sense there's no bond to a group of people or geography. It just the pure idea of superiority of a religion. Indians in the west cannot create another India (land next to sINDhu river), worst case scenario they can create competition for local population. Islamic state idea on the other hand wants to carve out a new state dominating existing cultures and civilization and ripping the local constitution. These are not quite the same
During Afghan war and rise of Taliban and radical Islam in Pakistan, US was fully in bed with Pakistan. US designed and published radical books in University of Nebraska and those books were distributed in Pakistani madrasas to radicalize Muslims for war in Afghanistan against USSR. So pls tell the truth.
That was done, once Pakistan military agreed to it, sold out itself for military hardware and Hard Dollars…. Period. So STFUWith your victimhood BITCHING.
@@AnAn___ He removed my comment. “The Pakistani Military did not do this for free, they got paid by the US. They volunteered, but now crying victimhood does not count.”
Hay, PORKIPIGBOT you removed my comment. “The Pakistani Military did not do this for free, they got paid by the US. They volunteered, but now crying victimhood does not count.”
It is so refreshing to listen to an American politician talk sense. But I should disagree with the view that the majority of Pakistanis deserve better. The hard fact is that the majority have been systematically brainwashed by their educational system. Whether it's the government run schools or the religious madrassas.
🤣🤣🤣Your ignorance does not make him a scholar . USA did help pak in1971 war , read the comments.USA deep state still endorses Pak against India...This mild admission by Jeff is for ignorant Americans who cannot show Pak on a world map!
Thankyou for speaking about this. Also would like to Add unlike most of American Allies India does not Hate USA. It just does not trust it as much as a friend. A good business partner will be the apt relationship and we appreciate it.
What has Jeff said it's 110% TRUE!! My country,India will NEVER EVER BETRAY YOU.. and that is why WE ARE STILL GOOD FRIENDS WITH RUSSIA... when the US showed us the middle finger Russia supported us.. I am very happy to hear from Jeff that the US has made a big mistake for supporting Pakistan.. Jai Hind.🙏🙏🙏
the irony of 911 is that the Pakistani military sheltered bin laden for years and yet the usa proclaims pakistan to be its closest ally in the SEA region.
Great to see an American willing to articulate a realistic assessment of the history of American involvement in the Indian Subcontinent. The Canadians Brits & Americans provided cover for Pakistan for far too long and have suffered the consequences so hope they have learnt their lessons
Seems like he is trying to justify USA in front of India (of course by hiding a hell lot of facts) par koi matlab nahi hai, kyunki iski sacchai sabko malum hai. Our foreign policy is great not to get to close to anyone more than necessary. Our alienation has led us to become so powerful that we can choose our partners without any fear or begging
I remember this vividly. During 1971 war, there was a restaurant near Bay of Bengal which was very famous for butter chicken. It was so famous that some US generals brought their biggest fleet armed with nuclear weapons to taste that butter chicken. It was so good that they travelled from so far to eat it. Its such an coincidence that there was a war going at that place. USA never came to support pakistan.
@@ishitabhatt2071 only because times they are in. Once they don’t need India, 30 years down the line they will be dishing India on similar platforms. Never trust Americans.
The US relied on British inputs. The Brits partitioned India as a sense of gratitude to the Musalmans who had fought in the British Indian Army in WW2. It took 60 years (with the nuclear deal with India) for the US to start to think independently.
ज्यादा खुश होने की बात नहीं है American are Hypocrites . Don't trust American. They always play games with India. Now they are supporting Saparetist movement in India
It was a time when the US utilized Pakistan to counter the USSR and dubbed the Afghan militants 'freedom fighters.' Photos of those Afghan fighters still adorn the White House walls. However, after the USSR's collapse, the US simply abandoned them, leaving them stranded in a dark alley. Ironically, these were the same liberal countries that had previously supported their cause, but ultimately prioritized their own interests over the welfare of their former allies."
Nope! This guy is very pro India but the US still remains mostly hostile! After sponsoring Pak for 70 yrs, now reviving Khalistanis. US remains an enemy contrary to popular misconceptions.
Mr Know-it-all must get some facts corrected.. 1- Pakistan didn't become Islamist after 1971, it was the basis of its formation in 1947 2- Nor did it feel backstabbed by US in '71 as all its arsenal including best of its time Patton tanks, supplied by the US ,and also send its Navy to directly intimidate India. 3- US did sent its 7th fleet, along with aircraft carrier and also told NATO members like UK and Turkey to send help to Pakistan, which was killing and raping millions of innocent civilians in today's Bangladesh. 4- US kept giving monetary, military, moral and diplomatic support to Pakistan fully knowing it being adictatorship and terrorist state. 5 - US kept pushing India to the wall by acting viciously against it time and again in UN, and denying technology, knowing fully that it was it was the largest and fully functional democracy.. so much for being savior of democracy. 6- Russia/ USSR helped India numerous times in need, without India not being a member of Warsaw pact. India although not believing in communism, likes Russia, because its knows gratitude and friendship 7- US is fooling itself by believing it can buy loyalty by throwing money to Pakistan, as all Islamic countries are inherently anti-west, though their leaders may show otherwise by receiving favours Sadly, US has not learnt its lessons, and still supporting Pakistan and antagonizing India .Because India is not Pakistan.
The west has been run by crooked traitors for quite a while. Politicians and bureaucrats are in rebellion against their own citizens. Somehow they find islam useful, or find it necessary to appease. Because of oil? Money? Perversion? You could help by commenting on leftist/Democrat/Labor channels and teaching some real history.
He actually given US story He never mentioned what happened during 1971 , US funded madrasas in Pakistan, they created mujaheddin Taliban Now they are funding khalistan against India
I think mostly correct analysis, only 1 correction if I may. Pakistan immediately joined the American camp just after independence. Fine India had no problem, India did not go to US camp and remained non aligned. Pakistan can not say thay US not helped Pakistan. In case India had attacked Pakistan then immediately US would have supported Pakistan with full might. But India never had illdesigns against Pakistan as India considered Pakistanis their own ( from same culture , from same region, having same languages) but since then they were dead bent for partition so it was done. Even after partition India gave them the status of most favored nation. But Pakistan thought now US at its side and all the latest military equipments, they initiated all the attacks and democratic US could not help them. In 1971 when US tried to help them then only India in its protection signed defence deals with USSR and USSR helped democratic India.
Henry Kessinger the former US Secretary of State once said ‘To be an enemy of the USA is dangerous but to be a friend is fatal’. As long as US does not realise that the relationship between Pakistan and USA is not of master and slave but of mutual respect and mutual interest, the countries can never come together. Pakistan is proud to have China by it’s side where there is people to people friendship, respect and mutual trust. Long live Pakistan China friendship. 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳
You are doomed in this world and hereafter if you keep unrealistic expectations! Only a foolish can argue that two nation theory applies to hindu muslims but not to Athiest/pgan/budhhist and Muslims. Only a foolish can argue that self respect or mutual respect is begged or bargained.
Ask ughyrs and try finding a true cop of CPEC contracts to understand how much your government has sold out to Chinese,. And do compare the length of queues of visa seekers in front of USA and Chinese embassies to understand contradictions in what you are saying.
Thats a great Speech. Its hard to see honest people still being there in the realm of crowded political correctness, balancing acts and fear of hurting sentiments of a section or groups of the people.
So Navies of US and UK did not come to Indian Ocean in 1971 to threaten India, what history have you learned? Even intellectuals in America are ignorant it seems
As a black american he is humble .. To listen to whire state person is disgusting .. Take eric garshitty Guy is a newsense with that message and tone there is no friendship..
Have the US learnt their lesson from their mistakes? The answer is a clear 'NO'.
It's not a mistake now they are portraying their older government as if they made a mistake but that policy continuous till today and that will continue if India and Pakistan remain in existence for next 1000 years it is going to be the same policy which will drive the southeast so far
Only fools will not realize that USA has not learnt from it.
Unreliable partner
Geopolitics is about "trade-offs."
They are just making a narrative. He doesn't say how Pakistan was west's brainchild, and US funded radcialization in Pakistan to hurt India etc
Excuse me sir. America DID come to Pakistan's help. They sent their 7th fleet I think. Russians stood by and had us have our own wars. Please stop pretending that you just stood by. You bet against India not once, not twice but a million times.
As recent as The Kargil War, America supported Pakistan, even playing the "Big Daddy" trying to intimidate Shri Vajpayee
True
Presents only half the picture. Pakistan was created by the British as a reward to those who opposed Indian independence. As a result, it was natural that it became part of the West .
The claim that US helped India in 1962 is nonsense. Before the war, the US refused to sell defence equipment to India. In the war, US support was limited to speeches, despite Indian request for actually getting involved. The US offer of help came only after China declared a ceasefire.
In the 1990s, US continued to pour money into Pakistan despite the Soviet withdrawal from Afghanistan. US supported Pakistani extremism in Kashmir and Punjab. It required 9/11 for YS to become a little neutral.
Even now, the US continues to launch propaganda attacks against India in support of drug dealers. To justify this, it calls drug dealers as religious leaders.
The US has definitely had an anti India bias in its actions. This is why Indians do not look at US as a trustworthy partner
They have selective memory bro 😂
@@ramachandrankannan274yes. Exactly. They never said a world on pak lead terrorism in india. They were silent on people dying in india,had active role in mumbai attacks,Richard hadlee was a double agent. They support khallistanis, kashmir militants. America was silent on people dying in india for 40 long years. They actually supported Pakistan dictators. They were working close with dictators. Indian democracy never has any appeal to them. They preferred communist China. Bashing indian democracy was always their favorite sport. So people of dont understand US
Russia on other hand always understood indias concerns ,problems. People of india have no reason to distrust resent Russia. Growing US friendship means a lot to them but that automatically doesnot make them suddenly
hate Russia. India sees Russia as reliable friend.
yes, both USA and UK sent their Navy. USSR stood with India and they blocked the western navy. They also stopped China from attacking India
Americans didn't care a damm on genocide of Kashmiri Hindus,bomb blasts, 26/11 attacks in India ,but their heart goes out for Pakistanis.Down with both these partners
इन्होंने कितनी खुबसूरती से बातों को तोड़ मरोड़ कर पेश किया है 😂😂😂😂😂 घटिया लोग
You mean the genocide of the Muslims in Kashmir
and your point is what? Ek American Porkiyon ki le raha hai, India ko support kar raha. Madar-ch-od tu upna hi baaja baja raha hai. saala Tinda!
So true
Americans and Europeans even watched over hindu and sikh genocide carried out by Pakistan and Afghanistan and Bangladesh. They also funded islamic and Christian missionaries in India to sabotage Hindus. Americans and Europeans reprimands India to promote islamise and Christianise India freely.
Few corrections:
1. USA did support Pakistan in 1971 war, infact US/UK used their 7th fleet in Bay of Bengal and pointed missiles towards India.
2. USA did not sell weapons to India because it did not want to go against its most favored ally, a military dictatorship, Pakistan. US was totally in bed with Pakistan.
Please tell the complete truth
Yes it will be difficult to trust the US on their previous accounts but both countries have to work together for mutual benefits and to keep the common enemies at bay!
in 1998, US also scrambled the GPS signals to make it difficult for India to defend Kargil.
@@Somd55 Yes, and I think that is India's intention.. but US is not ready. It wants to keep a control over India by framing this Pannun issue, by not doing the technology transfer as it said.
They also never tell that Russia has always stood with India in UNSC. How many times US has brought resolutions against India but Russia has veto'ed those everytime.
US also doesnt want India to get permanent seat in UNSC. Russia and France do.
Bimari kya be humare Indians ko? Yeh lo ji. Indian itne gaa-ndu hai - Ek Anjrez pakiyon ki le raha hai thook laga ke, yeh lage hain usse history ka lesson padhane. If USA and England were serious, USSR could not have stopped them, and USSR did mention that to India that we will posture but we will not fight. But point yeh nahin hai - dhyaan se suno Jeff le raha hai porkiyon ki.
As long as Pak is a rentier state, USA will never leave Pak. It is the independent mindset of India that USA has low tolerance for.
India is on no one’s side. Period
yea, and who profitted from re-exporting russian crude, who launched S400. there is no transactional pattern here. nato sleeps with a cheap date
@@nudawn110sleeping with pak costs money....its not a date...😂
@@isacr4063 : 😂😂 They don't need to pay, because "haaram ka maal hai wo" !. 😂 look at video (9:00)what the guy is saying !.
Now USA is nurturing khalistani,
Protecting them and painting them as innocent civilians. Double standards of America
@@induchopra3014 The US has arrested a lot of Khalistanis in recent months. The UK has also cracked down hard on Khalistanis, since they are a threat to the UK.
The Canadian government by contrast backs Khalistan.
The global left and woke movement is very pro Khalistan. Sadly this extends to part of the US left and woke.
They should ban the Khalistanis from using Nishan Sahab
@@abhijeetchavhan37 India does not ban this. Why would foreign countries ban this?
@@AnAn___ it's a symbol created by Guru Gobind Singh to protect the people . Not to bomb and separate.
In December 1971, the Nixon administration deployed the U.S. Navy's Seventh Fleet, Task Force 74 (TF 74), to the Bay of Bengal during the Indo-Pakistani War. The fleet's mission was to support Pakistan and intimidate Indian forces. Russians subs sneaked in before and stopped the Americans from interfering.
Yeah
👍
👍👏
100% correct
and USA did not want a direct war with USSR that can become a nuclear war so they stayed out of 1971 war.
👍
Pakistan didn't choose islamism in '71. The country was islamist since it's formation. In fact that ideology behind creation of Pakistan started more than a century before
facts
Exactly. The genocide of 95% Hindus and their shrines and 99% of Sikhs and majority nonmuslims took place within months of foundation in 1947.direct action day massacres leading to it targeted nonmuslims.
Exactly. The genocide of 95% Hindus and their shrines and 99% of Sikhs and majority nonmuslims took place within months of foundation in 1947.direct action day massacres leading to it targeted nonmuslims.
That's a lie at worst and incorrect at best. Pakistan became islamist after the passing of the objectives resolution in 1950 by liaqat Ali khan.
@@JBHACKSAW😂😂 whole was fighting for khilafat in 1920??? And killed thousands of hindus in mopla riots in kerla in1921...
Pakistan is lucky to have wise and honest military people. They have safely invested Pakistani money in Papa John's pizza franchise, real estate in Canada, London, Dubai, and an island near Australia. These investments have made sure that Pakistani people don't waste their money on luxury items such as wheat flour, vegetables, electricity, clothing, and education.
foj zandabad pandabad dhandlibad
😂😂😂Finest comment😂😂😂
Yeah Pizza Generals😂
what are you paijaans doing on an english language channel..... don't you have some gihadi molvi who will get you 72 hoors to follow.......git git shoo.
Sarcastically delivered SATIRE ❤😂😂😂
The irony here is that the US and the West for the most part chose two utterly non-democratic partners (Pakistan and China) in the region and sidelined a budding democratic state that was ravaged by its colonial past. They still had the gall to ask why India did not stand with the so-called "democratic West". When has the west ever stood for democracy in this part of the world I wonder?
they only see their interest - been their foreign policy for decades, and they think others are not aware of this bias 😂😂
@@zigzoog123They were in a state of shock when India pushed back on the sanctions. Like how dare India not dance to our tunes 😮 it's like they were floating in their own pink dream-bubble until it popped and they landed with a thud. I mean the sound of desperation in their repeated questioning of our FAM Dr. S.Jaishankar on India's stance is just hilarious 😂
Well, decades of Nehru idiocy helped grease the west’s policies. The west couldn’t trust a snowflake 😂 and we’re still reaping the dividends of the congress’s failed foreign policies.
Democracy is a myth. USA itself is not a pure democracy, its just a autocratic country with only 2 political powers
What China is today, because of US policies in 70s,80s,90s,00s. It is just last 15 years US is afraid of china and backtracking.
But they created a monster.
India is a Hardcore Conservative Country run by a Centre Liberal Governments,
It will be Hard For India to compromise on :
Its Civilization,
Its Hindu Religion (Sanatan Dharma),
India has lost lots of its territory and demography under Islamic And British Colonialism due to religious Conversion and Partition of India.
British Colonialism has drained India from its richness its share in Global GDP dropped from 27% to 1% by 1947 at the time of freedom from British.
No more interference of external powers in the Indian Subcontinent.
Mutual Respect will be appreciated 👍✅
100 % true.
Well said
Jai Hind Jai ModiJi India may become third largest economy
@@geetgeeta 🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳✅✅👍👍👍
100% true.
Pakistan people in other countries.
We are from India 😂
😂😂😂
they hate and are embarrassed of their own country 😂😂😂
The best way to compliment an Indian, is to say they look like a Pakistani….
Ethnically Punjabis and Sindhis are North Indians. Secondly many migrants from 1947 live in Pakistan and they identify as Indian migrants or Muhajirs. So learn some history before commenting here.
@@kawan5851 we are talking about Pakistanis
We aware how USSR help us India in 1971 war.
India never betrays its friends, and we will always follow this rule, unlike others who are only fair weather friends
Indian Hindus believe in Karma. Once someone helps us in critical times, we never forget that. We consider that help as a debt. Unless Russia backstab us in any way, we can't backstab our friend.
It's not about Arms & maintenance with Russia.
It's about a battle-tested friendship.
On the other hand the USA believes in this theory 👇
"There is no permanent friend or enemy in geo-politics; only interest matters"
Bro, ur quoting some Kissinger comment against what some of the masses belief. I share ur sentiment but disagree with ur comment. It'll be nice if you can quote a thing or two about Indian statecraft
India is still paying debt of 1971 to russia .
Just believe every Indian love Russia and Israel 🙏🇮🇳🙏
India is equally selfish....And Russia serves Indian interests as well..There is no emotion in int diplomacy
The US isn't one thing. The US has many competing lobbies. And what follows in chaos. The US generally does not act in US interests. Which is one of the USA's biggest problems.
But the same is often true of India too.
Crystal clear analysis . Unfortunately CIA is still fast friends with Pakistan military, because of its nuisance value.
and don't forget their newly found friendships with Khalisthanis to arm twist India
CIA wants a pliant Govt in place.
Cry 😂
@@GreaterPakistanEngPakistan turn to cry 😅
The pakistani army operates on the orders of a phone call from the USA... Imran Khan jailed...
Plus the US and India are happily funding Pashtun independence fighters and Baluchistanis
😅😂
@@GreaterPakistanEngsays a paki 🤡 whose govt national game is begging for money and aid 😅😅
Good presentation. But US holding back GE Fighter Engines after committing to the deal is not playing well in India. American foreign policy is seen as opportunistic, transactional and fickle minded not only in India but now globally especially with Trump's statements on Nato and Taiwan. You guys will soon be left without anyone trusting your words.... A strange position for the world's only super power!
Apt
There is a problem. India is part of US partisan politics. With Republicans, independents and moderate Democrats supporting Indo US friendship and the US left and woke being viscerally anti India.
absolute truth, anyone listening and paying attention?
Yup, well put sir!! And especially after our FM S.Jaishankar's razor sharp words exposing American hypocrisy, everybody is starting to see through US's opportunistic intentions.
@@satadaldutta6898 Everyone is not seeing through the anti Indian woke narratives. These narratives are becoming widely held around the world.
Defeating these woke narratives (which are inaccurate) means engaging with global conservatives, global liberals and others.
What a diplomatic way to accept your radicalism towards India
Someone’s hurt looks like 😂
Truly, it's brilliant Wordplay of USA's hypocrisy !
lying subtly 😂😂😂
And what an idio-tic Indian you are.
@@RojaJanemanWait until it happens near your house.
Choosing Pakistan ☪️ Islam over India is basically choosing satin over spirituality.
Satin is not bad especially for bed sheets.
Well don't forget that, above all they r same abrahamic Brotherhood !.
😅😅😅@@VTh-f5x
Choosing Islam over Linduism is always good.
@@ZainUlAbideen804that's your theory, but the whole world thinks otherwise 😅 every nation wants chuslim out 😅😅 they are fed up of you fake Allah and your fake ideologies
You forgot to mention that the USA sent their 7th Fleet,together with the British Navy, against India during the 1971 war and were blocked by the Russian nuclear submarine fleet.
Yup we'd forever be grateful to Russia for cockblocking the allied clowns 🤡
Any bet on a Islamist fundamentalist government is a bad bet.
Ge F414 delivered and still delivering to south korea but not INDIA
and they want India to align with them????
If USA really want to GOOD bet on India, First thing is to kick Pannu out of USA and STOP 🛑 supporting Khalistanis.
LOL.. they gonna do something else, that is their business(main economy of that country) !
*I am an Indian American and i am ashamed of my countries hypocrisy. USA never helped India.* 🇮🇳 ❌️ 🇺🇸
America ABSOLUTELY helped Pakistan in the 1971 war. Read up on the Blood Telegram. The seventh fleet was sent to the Bay of Bengal to intimidate India. America was selling weapons to Pakistan and helping them with military intelligence.
Very well said. Same people , same language, same culture, divided in 1947. How dramatically different is the trajectory. Pakistan is failed state while India is soon to be the 4th Largest economy. What is the difference. Well Muslims demanded Pakistan and got it. India continues to follow Hindu ethos. Europe Beware. You are staring at the same fate, 20 years from now
islam is the real issue
@@JohnSmith-iq9np agreed..!
@@JohnSmith-iq9np True, and it also runs deeper. Greed, anger, lust, illusion, ego, envy, fear.
The world's problems may APPEAR political/ economic/ religious / racial, but ARE spiritual problems in the core.
bigots identified here in comment section
Europe is doomed. Muslims anywhere can’t coexist with others. Since they can’t have pier in this knowledge economy because of their medieval ethos, Their strategy is to produce more babies in western countries once they migrate and take over eventually. Once they are 5%, problems start.
Jeff... As an Indian, I want IND-US to stop playing games with each other. Let's be loud mouths for a change and talk about 1971. Also the US must make public all intelligence they have about the Assassination of Prime Minister Lal Bahadur Shastri in the Soviet Union, links of Nehru Dynasty with the Soviets.
Most importantly, USA must say it bluntly, that it was the Brits who drove a wedge between India - USA and pushed India towards Moscow. Vijay Gokhale's book is an eye-opener.
I am glad you spoke about Taliban. It was Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto who created the Directorate S of the ISI to intefere in Afghanistan in 1972.
Its time to stop playing games amongst our selves.
What! It is public. Please read the book "Conversations with Crow", which is an interview of CIA agent. He has discussed Shastri's and Bhabha's murder and how the CIA did it.
@@sigmaxcc CIA went deep into The Soviet Union in height of the Cold war to murder Shastri without the Russians knowing about it?
You people need to learn to grow a brain to start with,
What ourselves? US is still tactically supporting pappistan and China. Pappi F16s became the basis for Chinese JF17s
🇺🇸 never supports any country.
Everyone supports their own interests. Don't expect much more than that.
@@yidiandianpang : that's what the collective West should learn first !
USA in nutshell :
We know everything about the world and what best for others without consulting anyone . We will save the world from threat that we decided exist .
USA 30 years later :
We screw up ! We didn't know better . But we do now .
Repeat.
…most of it is correct, BUT the start is not entirely correct.
India and Pakistan were not new states that emerged after WW2, India is a 5000+ year civilizational reality and Pakistan ‘was created’ out of nowhere by dismembering India. Pakistan was CREATED by Churchill with the blessing of US to create a buffer state between USSR and India. India after all is a large percentage of world population and historically large % of world GDP. West did not want communists to win over India … ultimately India suffered due to UK/US …and India will NEVER FORGET or FORGIVE!
the british colonizers divided India when they were kicked out. Look at them today they are lost 😂😂😂
India in its present form never existed for hundreds of centuries as you’re implying. The most unified empire was of the Mauriyan Empire and even that didn’t include as many regions as there are in India these days. India in its present form is the largest conglomeration of states and sub states as it exists in history and this was created in 1947 not 5000 years before that. 😂
@@mubashir7343The Cultural and Civilizational state of Bhārata existed and the boundaries were defined since before BCE times. Nice try tho
@@mubashir7343 you wish! Of course large and small kingdoms kept forming…but it has been a continuous civilization with a common identify… unlike say Muslims who were different 1400 years ago because there was no Islam before that or Christians …
But Bharat has a common unbroken civilizational ethos and identify for a very long time…
If that was not the case the European company that did trade with India would not have been called ‘East India Company’ or when Columbus landed in America but thought he had reached ‘India’(that’s what he set out for) and till date the Native Americans are called ‘Indians’.
West Indies(Jamaica, Barbados etc etc) wouldn’t be called West INDIES..
So I think you should trace your ancestors and see who exactly you were for thousands of years!
@@nitinkapoor4752well said 💯💯
Many important misses like US supporting genocide in bangladesh, US supporting dictators in pakistan against a democracy, formation of pakistan to keep a check on India to name a few.
A correction! During 1971 India-Pak war US sent its navy ships to attack India. USSR govt gave this info to India and urgently sent submarines to help India on the request of PM Indira Gandhi. US navy got the news of the submarines and decided to turn back half way.
Excellent sober analysis. Thanks for explaining (some of) India's position to a Western audience. Western politicians need to stop being naive and PC about Islamism and Pakistan
Cry 😂
6 years old Aisha cried in the corner😢@@GreaterPakistanEng
Naive or bought?
@@GreaterPakistanEng u r crying everywhere😂😂 didn't china throw a dirty duster at u to wipe ur tears n lateron wipe something else with it
US was never bothered about India
now it is 😂😂😂
@@zigzoog123 nah..it never does abt anyone
India is strong powerful and capable democratic nation in the world and has independent foreign policy. Jai Hind 🇮🇳 Jai Bharat 🇮🇳
👍👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Don’t boss India, it doesn’t work
But didn't follow Gandhi dream of unified the country . Corrupt India government didn't stand up denied Pakistan and Bangladesh independent and recognised by UN as a independent country , so for today's onward that's not internal affairs of India compare with Taiwan which still not recognise as independent country but a province or state of mainland China.
So it was internal affairs for China as Taiwan part of China
Pakistan is not a country. It is an idea - a sense of entitlement. You will see many Pakistans in Europe if the trend continues.
We are seeing millions of indians immigrating to the UK and USA and every western country. Are u saying same for India and predicting over running of local population by indians.
@@SpoTTd : no, they r Paks taking the name India to save them from deportation, we Indians need h1b visa to go there, not illegal immigrants trying to cross the Mexican border, so Ur lies r baseless even unworthy today for Indians, same despicable, double standard USA talking about !.
@@SpoTTdindians, buddhists always integrate and contribute unlike the community you are from...
@@SpoTTdpakistan - literally pak (pure/holy) + stan (land of). Here holy/pure refers to Muslims (as is clarified by constitution of Pakistan). In the west this idea is known as the Islamic state. It is not a country in the sense there's no bond to a group of people or geography. It just the pure idea of superiority of a religion.
Indians in the west cannot create another India (land next to sINDhu river), worst case scenario they can create competition for local population.
Islamic state idea on the other hand wants to carve out a new state dominating existing cultures and civilization and ripping the local constitution.
These are not quite the same
@@SpoTTd although that is true but it is changing bit by bit.
During Afghan war and rise of Taliban and radical Islam in Pakistan, US was fully in bed with Pakistan. US designed and published radical books in University of Nebraska and those books were distributed in Pakistani madrasas to radicalize Muslims for war in Afghanistan against USSR. So pls tell the truth.
That was done, once Pakistan military agreed to it, sold out itself for military hardware and Hard Dollars…. Period.
So STFUWith your victimhood BITCHING.
You mean in the 1980s under Carter and Reagan, correct? In 1989 George Bush stopped this policy.
@@AnAn___ He removed my comment.
“The Pakistani Military did not do this for free, they got paid by the US. They volunteered, but now crying victimhood does not count.”
Hay, PORKIPIGBOT you removed my comment.
“The Pakistani Military did not do this for free, they got paid by the US. They volunteered, but now crying victimhood does not count.”
I did not know about the books, Thanks.
It is so refreshing to listen to an American politician talk sense. But I should disagree with the view that the majority of Pakistanis deserve better. The hard fact is that the majority have been systematically brainwashed by their educational system. Whether it's the government run schools or the religious madrassas.
True
US and West always triend to help Pakistan even in 1971 and 1999 in every possible way so don't be over smart. 😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Good research and presentation Jeff, glad to see new young scholars rising and making a mark, good luck.
Hey John how you doing?
🤣🤣🤣Your ignorance does not make him a scholar . USA did help pak in1971 war , read the comments.USA deep state still endorses Pak against India...This mild admission by Jeff is for ignorant Americans who cannot show Pak on a world map!
We common Indians knows more and better than American politicians.
അധികാരശക്തി എപ്പോഴും അധികാരശക്തിയെ ബഹുമാനിക്കും.. എപ്പോഴും ! . .. 🇮🇳
Thankyou for speaking about this. Also would like to Add unlike most of American Allies India does not Hate USA. It just does not trust it as much as a friend. A good business partner will be the apt relationship and we appreciate it.
aptly put 👍👏👏
Pakistan GDP was $30-40 billion around that time, a billion was about 3% their GDP and about 0.025% of US GDP, for 12 years
The US has never understood ‘The Indian Subcontinent’ ( South Asia is a joke) and never will.
👍 BHARATHAVARSH - The INDIAN Subcontinent 🇮🇳🙏🏼
Good one now plz don't ask us why we purchase energy from Russia 😂😂
What has Jeff said it's 110% TRUE!! My country,India will NEVER EVER BETRAY YOU.. and that is why WE ARE STILL GOOD FRIENDS WITH RUSSIA... when the US showed us the middle finger Russia supported us.. I am very happy to hear from Jeff that the US has made a big mistake for supporting Pakistan.. Jai Hind.🙏🙏🙏
Well you heard quite few things he never said...!!
the irony of 911 is that the Pakistani military sheltered bin laden for years and yet the usa proclaims pakistan to be its closest ally in the SEA region.
Serves them well!
Never knew India wanted to invade their own country, Kashmir.
Great to see an American willing to articulate a realistic assessment of the history of American involvement in the Indian Subcontinent. The Canadians Brits & Americans provided cover for Pakistan for far too long and have suffered the consequences so hope they have learnt their lessons
not yet, they never learn
Excellent analysis and truth was spoken
except some info to make america seem like a big and fair nation, nothing could be further from the truth
Seems like he is trying to justify USA in front of India (of course by hiding a hell lot of facts) par koi matlab nahi hai, kyunki iski sacchai sabko malum hai. Our foreign policy is great not to get to close to anyone more than necessary. Our alienation has led us to become so powerful that we can choose our partners without any fear or begging
U did supported P0rkis in 1971 war.
Remember u tried to send USS Enterprise to Bay of Bengal. Which is when Soviets blocked you
truth 👍
So you think Americans couldn't come to rescue Pakistan if they wanted ?
US didn't help Pakistan against India in 1971 ?? Read Kissinger's biography and read newspaper articles and US diplomats of those times
Concise, precise and to the point factual analysis I have ever heard w.r.t. Pakistan.
I remember this vividly. During 1971 war, there was a restaurant near Bay of Bengal which was very famous for butter chicken. It was so famous that some US generals brought their biggest fleet armed with nuclear weapons to taste that butter chicken. It was so good that they travelled from so far to eat it. Its such an coincidence that there was a war going at that place. USA never came to support pakistan.
Well analyzed.
USA did tried attack India militarily during 1971 and helped Pakistan in carrying out most horrendous genocide of 20th century.
Waooo.....
Shocked by such true analysis..
Hats off for such bold speech 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
True analysis?? He conveniently made it like they're not against India leaving half of the facts idi
True analysis??
Are you kidding ?
They blame Pakistan for every problem that USA created in the region .
A wise man indeed. I didn't expect such an honest and clear approach to India, Pakistan and USA relations.
@@ishitabhatt2071 only because times they are in. Once they don’t need India, 30 years down the line they will be dishing India on similar platforms. Never trust Americans.
only america,s image projected as fair, not entirely true
The US relied on British inputs. The Brits partitioned India as a sense of gratitude to the Musalmans who had fought in the British Indian Army in WW2.
It took 60 years (with the nuclear deal with India) for the US to start to think independently.
Pakistan and double- game??? Is it even suprising!!!
how can anyone trust them ? 😢
Thank God , Americans are now becoming intelligent.
about time they woke up and started accepting the truth
ज्यादा खुश होने की बात नहीं है
American are Hypocrites . Don't trust American. They always play games with India. Now they are supporting Saparetist movement in India
@@zigzoog123As long as they don't go woke all the way.
really ? 🙄
this man is right, agree as an Indian.. USA did send military (7th fleet) in 1971 but they got stopped by the Soviet Navy and retreated to avoid ww3.
It was a time when the US utilized Pakistan to counter the USSR and dubbed the Afghan militants 'freedom fighters.' Photos of those Afghan fighters still adorn the White House walls. However, after the USSR's collapse, the US simply abandoned them, leaving them stranded in a dark alley. Ironically, these were the same liberal countries that had previously supported their cause, but ultimately prioritized their own interests over the welfare of their former allies."
The most sensible analysis of the American Pakistan relationship.
Brilliant analysis. Sums up US- Pakistan relationship well.
US could never ever hope to make India dance to their tunes, India is far too big & independent minded for that, India is a bloc by itself.
Thank God Americans are realising their mistake and hopefully learn from it.
There establishment will never understand i will bet .
Nope! This guy is very pro India but the US still remains mostly hostile! After sponsoring Pak for 70 yrs, now reviving Khalistanis. US remains an enemy contrary to popular misconceptions.
@@DiptiDangi-zq2wvtrue
No, the US state dept doesn't 😅
@@chillax360 The US State Department is woke as heck, anti Jewish, anti Israeli, anti American, anti Christian and anti Indian.
2 billion dollars 10yrs back is a huge amount of money if you consider ppp. It's basically the entire economic.
Are we still comparing India and Pakistan 🤨 Sorry but we have gone past Pakistan and are competing now with the so called developed countries !!!
Except that you guys are heading down the same path as Ukraine. Pakistan knows what to do.
Yes okay. But so called developed???
Have you seen their cities and our cities.
Compared to them our cities are unlivable hell
@@nyazeeyup Pakistan knows how to stop existing
What wisdom after supporting Pakistan for 50 odd years and being betrayed by them. But a very late wisdom
A very subtle revision of history to make usa look more innocent that it really is😅😅
Never ever heard a more
Truthful story of South Asia.. this guy explained everything in a very Transparent manner😮
he hid many facts ,,
Mr Know-it-all must get some facts corrected..
1- Pakistan didn't become Islamist after 1971, it was the basis of its formation in 1947
2- Nor did it feel backstabbed by US in '71 as all its arsenal including best of its time Patton tanks, supplied by the US ,and also send its Navy to directly intimidate India.
3- US did sent its 7th fleet, along with aircraft carrier and also told NATO members like UK and Turkey to send help to Pakistan, which was killing and raping millions of innocent civilians in today's Bangladesh.
4- US kept giving monetary, military, moral and diplomatic support to Pakistan fully knowing it being adictatorship and terrorist state.
5 - US kept pushing India to the wall by acting viciously against it time and again in UN, and denying technology, knowing fully that it was it was the largest and fully functional democracy.. so much for being savior of democracy.
6- Russia/ USSR helped India numerous times in need, without India not being a member of Warsaw pact. India although not believing in communism, likes Russia, because its knows gratitude and friendship
7- US is fooling itself by believing it can buy loyalty by throwing money to Pakistan, as all Islamic countries are inherently anti-west, though their leaders may show otherwise by receiving favours
Sadly, US has not learnt its lessons, and still supporting Pakistan and antagonizing India .Because India is not Pakistan.
Well analysed 👍
I think America never understand what is jihad 😂
The west has been run by crooked traitors for quite a while. Politicians and bureaucrats are in rebellion against their own citizens. Somehow they find islam useful, or find it necessary to appease. Because of oil? Money? Perversion?
You could help by commenting on leftist/Democrat/Labor channels and teaching some real history.
In short an ally from hell you always wanted and will have it
I dont think anyone can explain better than this.. perfect..
He actually given US story
He never mentioned what happened during 1971 ,
US funded madrasas in Pakistan, they created mujaheddin Taliban
Now they are funding khalistan against India
with some lapses and holes
a more balanced retelling than most! good for natcon!
There is no truth in what he says about 1971 war!!, go read your state dept archives on this war....
Such clarity of thought is rare these days. Very good talk by Jeff
I think mostly correct analysis, only 1 correction if I may. Pakistan immediately joined the American camp just after independence. Fine India had no problem, India did not go to US camp and remained non aligned. Pakistan can not say thay US not helped Pakistan. In case India had attacked Pakistan then immediately US would have supported Pakistan with full might. But India never had illdesigns against Pakistan as India considered Pakistanis their own ( from same culture , from same region, having same languages) but since then they were dead bent for partition so it was done. Even after partition India gave them the status of most favored nation. But Pakistan thought now US at its side and all the latest military equipments, they initiated all the attacks and democratic US could not help them. In 1971 when US tried to help them then only India in its protection signed defence deals with USSR and USSR helped democratic India.
This man has summed up the entire history and the mess brilliantly. No one could could have said better.
Excellent analysis
Finally An American actually stating the truth about Pakistan.
Well called by speaker as "Packistan" nation packed by Army in illusive democracy like Gandhi title of Rahul Vinci Gandhi. 😂😂😂😂
What a amazing clear analysis ❤
Truth, and nothing but the truth. So help me God.
Help ypur self, dont be a weak goat, get up train gear up and be a lion ❤
This was about the best and truthful analysis. 👍👏👏👏
Henry Kessinger the former US Secretary of State once said ‘To be an enemy of the USA is dangerous but to be a friend is fatal’. As long as US does not realise that the relationship between Pakistan and USA is not of master and slave but of mutual respect and mutual interest, the countries can never come together. Pakistan is proud to have China by it’s side where there is people to people friendship, respect and mutual trust. Long live Pakistan China friendship.
🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳
You are doomed in this world and hereafter if you keep unrealistic expectations!
Only a foolish can argue that two nation theory applies to hindu muslims but not to Athiest/pgan/budhhist and Muslims.
Only a foolish can argue that self respect or mutual respect is begged or bargained.
Abey mullo tum Bhikariyon ko koi dost nahi maanta .China ke naukar kehlaane ke laayak bhi nahi ho tum .
Ask ughyrs and try finding a true cop of CPEC contracts to understand how much your government has sold out to Chinese,. And do compare the length of queues of visa seekers in front of USA and Chinese embassies to understand contradictions in what you are saying.
Pakistan's foreign policy = $$
What do you think of China’s 🇨🇳 treatment of Muslims?
Well explained. Thank you
perfect explanation .
made me like the vedio .
I hope usa had learnedits lesson by now .
USA is opprtunist country, can not be trusted
Thats a great Speech. Its hard to see honest people still being there in the realm of crowded political correctness, balancing acts and fear of hurting sentiments of a section or groups of the people.
didn’t say the whole truth
Jammu Kashmir Gilgit Balitastan Pok cok are integral part of India. Can India trust USA? Jai Hind 🇮🇳 Jai Bharat 🇮🇳
does america support us and is on our side ? now we are asking you ?
never trust america, even their european allies are starting to understand that.
Speak the whole truth, the world is not stupid. You've got it.
So Navies of US and UK did not come to Indian Ocean in 1971 to threaten India, what history have you learned? Even intellectuals in America are ignorant it seems
Stopped watching at 25s, what is south asia? you mean the INDIAN subcontinent?
As a black american he is humble ..
To listen to whire state person is disgusting ..
Take eric garshitty
Guy is a newsense with that message and tone there is no friendship..
Garshitty is perfect. Need to popularize it
There will always be a significant issue between US & India- ---Trust
If any muslim says that he is from india either they are from Pakistan india or Bangladesh dont believe they are all Pakistani
Fantastic Truth speaks and crooks were exposed