I love her smile after she delivers that first line...the way her hand trembles near the end of those more intense lines...the seriousness of her look while she waits to deliver the next. Absolutely the most magical version of this song, EVER! Soar with the angels, Sinead!
@@sdr-deluxe2426 they’re performing good, they just have bad tones, a product of this being such a large production in 1990. For what it was, this is very good.
For me, this is the version that gives me the most chills. It's a symbolic concert, 8 months after the fall of the wall, in a symbolic place in Berlin Potsdamer Platz, first destroyed during the Second World War then separated in two by the wall during the Cold War. This is the concert I would have wanted to do if I had to do just one (And David Gilmour's 2016 Live in Pompei). So many great artists, great musicians and Sinead O'Connor who gives me goosebumps when she pushes a little... Thank you Sinead, gone too soon, may you now rest in peace. 🌿
Interestingly enough, I came here from an article where Roger Waters was saying he didn't enjoy working with her. But he was all smiles on stage. Maybe aside from that he still appreciated her talent though. I enjoyed her singing this beautiful song. Her voice really was beautiful.
@@Dorisasaurus1133 They were members of The Band. Helm was American but Rick and the rest of the band were Canadian. The bearded man on accordian is Garth Hudson. He was the keyboardist (and every other instrument you can think of) in The Band
The looks on everyone's faces.. they know they have become part of a genuinely poignant moment, recognizing that Sinéad's heart is completely in it, and she is killing it.
Thanks for this Big, Loud and Transparent song...... Made in The Wall!!! Thanks for the beautiful voice and the Heart of Sinead O'Connor make It! She's a pretty soul kind! Cheers from Argentina........
Today June 2nd 2024 this song stands as an anthem for all in Mexico that wanted a change but we got the continuity of a horrible government. Thanks Sinéad for giving the best performance of this song ever and Roger Waters for writing this masterpiece
Jesus said, "I tell you the truth no one will see the kingdom of God unless he is born again. I am the way the truth and the life, no one comes to the Father except through me." For God so loved the world that He give His only Son that whoever believes in Him will not perish but will have eternal life. For God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world but to save the World through Him. For all have sinned and come short of the Glory of God. For the wages of sin is death but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord, and All who call upon the name of the Lord will be saved. " If you want to be sure of Heaven and avoid the other place below say the following prayer sincerely from your heart." Lord Jesus I repent and am sorry for my sins forgive me. I forgive all who have offended me. Come into my heart and save me. I accept you as my Lord and Saviour. Fill me with your Holy Spirit and baptise me with your Holy Spirit. Fulfill your plan and purpose in my life. "I recommend you read John's Gospel especially chapter 3.Gbu.John 3v3v22,John 14v6.
I was there, it was a shambles to be honest. But I was there to see The Band 😊The sound went so it was quite a fraught atmosphere. She did take some persuading to come on, and I’ve heard this recording is from a rehearsal. All that aside, it’s a sad day today ❤️
Sit back & listen to the genius of Sinead with Roger and know there’s not many better live versions of this ever. Even by the amazing Floyd. RIP Sinead. You done your best.
Frankly Speaking i was at Rehab,, Many i stay n listening with are not anymore... I was so blessed... I have a beautiful Family,, Grand children....God Bless me so much... Now,, Its 2024 , July Sunday 21 .. Still listening .... 😢😢😢😢
It is obvious to me that Sinead digs her most intimate depths to achieve a rendering elevated by the proof she can find what is pertinent in this song, beyond the fact it's originally about a relationship boy Vs castrating mother. I hear a girl in dialogue with her smothering covert narcissist mother, it's exactly what I picture, and it is all due to her inexplicable transcendant, and so often displayed, ability to express truthfull innocent-like charisma in her singing voice.
Its a shame Roger hated her so much saying she was an ego manic that had disappeared up her own bum. At least he knows the feelings of other musicians that have had to work with him.
After seeing this I'm surprised Roger Waters had to publicly slag Sinead off in an interview, calling her unprofessional, big headed, self involved and "up her own bum" among other things. You'd think after she smashed it out of the park with her live performance he'd have forgiven her any diva behaviour, but not old Super Grouch. Can you imagine Dave Gilmour treating a fellow artist like that? Or indeed anyone?? Nope, just good old Roger "I'm smarter than everyone else on the planet ever so I can behave like a complete arse!" Waters!
I see you came here from the same article I just read. I thought that was a bit of a bummer to read as well. Yet in the video hes all smiles. I was thinking maybe despite that he still could appreciate her talent in the moment. Regardless of how difficult he felt it was to work with her . 🤷♀️
One of the most beautiful women in the whole world, the most talented and amazing singer. I sing her songs All the time. On my karaoke machine. I listened to her on the way to work and at work and on the way home from work and when I'm at home. And beautiful, amazing natural, beautiful, amazing singer. I wish I could assault her in concert. But she's with the Lord now. God bless her and her family. And everyone in the world, thank you, seinead O'Connor.❤ I love you.❤
Ruhe in Frieden Sinead. ❤ Ich bin immer noch geschockt über deinen Tod. Kein Promi war so bescheiden, echt, ehrlich und hat trotz schlimmster Verzweiflung an das Gute im Menschen geglaubt. Du fehlst so unglaublich. Ich wär gerne mit dir einen Nachmittag am Meer in Bray gesessen. 😢😢😢
I love this performance by Sinead. I come back to it from time to time and it never ever gets old. I used to listen to it and so many of her songs over and over and over. There was no one like her and never will be. I deeply miss you Sinead and I am eternally grateful for your beautiful voice and soul.
R.I.P. - this live Performance is perfection - No one sing this better than you beautiful flower- unbelievable Feelings, voice ❤ thx all 4 this great Performance. Pink Floyd is my Religion
Sadly Garth is the only one left from The Band. I get chills when I hear Helm and Danko sing in Harmony on this video. Great Rock and Roll is hard to come by now a days, all my Rock heroes are dying off!
I love my mother!!! ❤❤❤😂!!! Overwehlming und Wunderschön und Wunderbar!!! I am Michael Matthias Frohn Mühlstroh und Jesus Christus!!! ❤❤❤😂 Very nice version!!! Sin'ead O'Connor for President!!!
J'ai vu plusieurs fois cette vidéo merci pour celle-ci qui est de très bonne qualité. Sinéad est merveilleuse comme toujours, je t'aime infiniment ❤❤😢❤ S'il vous plaît restaurez les autres vidéos de ma belle irlandaise dans cette qualité, cela serait génial.
After Sinéad's passing I stumbled upon this performance and I was so blown away by her and The Band's vocals here (however brief it all may be) that I just had to get this concert and get it to play on a decent set-up. I can tell you that I got even more blown away hearing this bit on Dolby Surround. Played Live in Berlin years before and I don't remember it making such an impact then. Things have changed. Rest easy, Sinéad.
Give Damien Dempsey some creds. He’s underrated! Sinead I always loved you! See you soon! She smiled there because she thought she was gonna get booed off stage.
Özellikle son hamlen çok iyiydi. Allah a teslim oldun ve müslüman olarak can verdin. Yusuf İslam, Muhammed Ali ve niceleri gibi. Rabbim bizleri cennetleri de buluştursun. Ben de 56 yaşındayım, gençlik yıllarımda dinlerdim.
This version of the song was made on DVD , HENCE,THE BUILDING OF THE WALL, DIFFERENT MUSITIONS SUNG THE WALL songs, that's why no ROGER W. EXCELLENT. DVD by the way ❤😮😊😂
One of the best live versions of this incredible song, thanks to Sineads voice. You will be missed, Sinead.
This is the studio version. The live version had electrical problem but they recorded this a day before.
It's not studio, It's from an earlier dress rehersal that they recorded like recording a live match and watching it later.
don't talk nonsense.
A complete tragedy this Wonderful person is gone so young , we will listen to You forever and forever Sinead
Rip sweet lady. Another beautiful voice falls silent. ❤️
Its so not silent in my gaff,love our original Irish rebel ❤Sinead❤and cant 4get her mini me sweetheart ❤❤Shane❤❤❤❤
I love her smile after she delivers that first line...the way her hand trembles near the end of those more intense lines...the seriousness of her look while she waits to deliver the next. Absolutely the most magical version of this song, EVER! Soar with the angels, Sinead!
playback
Not playback
No comment......just enjoying ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
It's incredibly rare to achieve perfection in music, especially when recorded live, but when it does happen, you get this.
Stunning little Lady! the world lost one of the greatest voices of our time. R.I.P Sinead.
RIP Sinead and Dolores--two Irish queens we lost too soon. My heart breaks.
amen to that
They will live on forever. With love from South Africa ❤
Definitely the best live performance of this song of all time, period.
Sinead
🤓well akkkktually this version is taken from the rehearsal because the actual performance had the power go out for the band
You didn't hear the original version. The Band sounds terrible.
@@sdr-deluxe2426 they’re performing good, they just have bad tones, a product of this being such a large production in 1990. For what it was, this is very good.
@@sdr-deluxe2426 I think this is live.
Great version of a great song. From Garth's haunting accordion to Sinead's angelic vocals. Rest in Power Sinead❤
For me, this is the version that gives me the most chills. It's a symbolic concert, 8 months after the fall of the wall, in a symbolic place in Berlin Potsdamer Platz, first destroyed during the Second World War then separated in two by the wall during the Cold War. This is the concert I would have wanted to do if I had to do just one (And David Gilmour's 2016 Live in Pompei). So many great artists, great musicians and Sinead O'Connor who gives me goosebumps when she pushes a little... Thank you Sinead, gone too soon, may you now rest in peace. 🌿
RIP Sinead ..be at peace now This is a testament to Sinead as Roger and Pink Floyd don't just allow just anyone to sing their songs
Interestingly enough, I came here from an article where Roger Waters was saying he didn't enjoy working with her. But he was all smiles on stage. Maybe aside from that he still appreciated her talent though. I enjoyed her singing this beautiful song. Her voice really was beautiful.
I'm obsessed with this video. Sinead was great.
Each time I watch this, It's hard to believe it's 7 minutes long. I wish it could go on and on and on...
Voice of an angel. May she rest now.
Descansa en paz Sinead, aunque este mundo tal vez no era para ti, ahora cantas con los ángeles.
Oh man. Levon Helm, Rick Danko and Sinead, three wonderful singers, all gone now
Thank you I was wondering who the men were singing with Roger and Sinade are they American country music singers?
They were members of The Band. Helm was American but Danko and the rest of the band were from Canada@@Dorisasaurus1133
@@Dorisasaurus1133 They were members of The Band. Helm was American but Rick and the rest of the band were Canadian. The bearded man on accordian is Garth Hudson. He was the keyboardist (and every other instrument you can think of) in The Band
@@Dorisasaurus1133the band (some members)
@@sunshinedaydream70 Thank you for clarifying that for me
The looks on everyone's faces.. they know they have become part of a genuinely poignant moment, recognizing that Sinéad's heart is completely in it, and she is killing it.
Thanks for this Big, Loud and Transparent song...... Made in The Wall!!!
Thanks for the beautiful voice and the Heart of Sinead O'Connor make It! She's a pretty soul kind!
Cheers from Argentina........
Today June 2nd 2024 this song stands as an anthem for all in Mexico that wanted a change but we got the continuity of a horrible government. Thanks Sinéad for giving the best performance of this song ever and Roger Waters for writing this masterpiece
Say what you will about SOC, she nails this one. Plus Levon in a Red Sox hat. :)
Yes I agree!! I love listening this song and love to sing with her ♥️
Yes, love the guy in the Red Sox hat..gave it a different sound
Jesus said, "I tell you the truth no one will see the kingdom of God unless he is born again. I am the way the truth and the life, no one comes to the Father except through me." For God so loved the world that He give His only Son that whoever believes in Him will not perish but will have eternal life. For God did not send His Son into the world to condemn the world but to save the World through Him. For all have sinned and come short of the Glory of God. For the wages of sin is death but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord, and All who call upon the name of the Lord will be saved. " If you want to be sure of Heaven and avoid the other place below say the following prayer sincerely from your heart." Lord Jesus I repent and am sorry for my sins forgive me. I forgive all who have offended me. Come into my heart and save me. I accept you as my Lord and Saviour. Fill me with your Holy Spirit and baptise me with your Holy Spirit. Fulfill your plan and purpose in my life. "I recommend you read John's Gospel especially chapter 3.Gbu.John 3v3v22,John 14v6.
No
Look at her fingers trembling when she sings "they'll try to break my balls"... God... Sinead is feeling every second of her performance...!
I was there, it was a shambles to be honest. But I was there to see The Band 😊The sound went so it was quite a fraught atmosphere. She did take some persuading to come on, and I’ve heard this recording is from a rehearsal. All that aside, it’s a sad day today ❤️
wow . . . i saw the "back up male vocalists" & sat up and now you answered ny question. The Band . . .
Rick Danko and Levon Helm is it?
@@devilsforkdigital1490 Yes and Garth Hudson on the accordion
RIP Ireland's rose: singing from the best album ever written. Thank you for sharing this beauty 🙏❤️
Sit back & listen to the genius of Sinead with Roger and know there’s not many better live versions of this ever. Even by the amazing Floyd.
RIP Sinead. You done your best.
Sinead was a beautiful soul.
Sinead makes everything better ❤
She's a clown and has been for 3 decades. Also Roger Waters fucking hated her after this because she, surprise, acted like a clown
Frankly Speaking i was at Rehab,, Many i stay n listening with are not anymore... I was so blessed... I have a beautiful Family,, Grand children....God Bless me so much... Now,, Its 2024 , July Sunday 21 .. Still listening .... 😢😢😢😢
Am sitting here wondering why the hell Rodger Waters didn't sing the song at the time..? Was he having vocal cord issues or something...?
Think about that?
Why would he when he had the great Sinead O Connor available to him.
It is obvious to me that Sinead digs her most intimate depths to achieve a rendering elevated by the proof she can find what is pertinent in this song, beyond the fact it's originally about a relationship boy Vs castrating mother. I hear a girl in dialogue with her smothering covert narcissist mother, it's exactly what I picture, and it is all due to her inexplicable transcendant, and so often displayed, ability to express truthfull innocent-like charisma in her singing voice.
Huh?
Nah i feel this.
Its a shame Roger hated her so much saying she was an ego manic that had disappeared up her own bum. At least he knows the feelings of other musicians that have had to work with him.
I can’t put into words the magic of this version - thanks especially to Sinead; and yeah that smile!
Fly Sinead looking the bright side of the moon 🦋
After seeing this I'm surprised Roger Waters had to publicly slag Sinead off in an interview, calling her unprofessional, big headed, self involved and "up her own bum" among other things. You'd think after she smashed it out of the park with her live performance he'd have forgiven her any diva behaviour, but not old Super Grouch. Can you imagine Dave Gilmour treating a fellow artist like that? Or indeed anyone?? Nope, just good old Roger "I'm smarter than everyone else on the planet ever so I can behave like a complete arse!" Waters!
I see you came here from the same article I just read. I thought that was a bit of a bummer to read as well. Yet in the video hes all smiles. I was thinking maybe despite that he still could appreciate her talent in the moment. Regardless of how difficult he felt it was to work with her . 🤷♀️
Roger was a huge fan of Sinead but felt a little insulted when Sinead flew back home and didn't stay on for a retake later on for the video.
Join the human race, leave the human race, nothing compares. RIP
One of the most beautiful women in the whole world, the most talented and amazing singer. I sing her songs All the time. On my karaoke machine. I listened to her on the way to work and at work and on the way home from work and when I'm at home. And beautiful, amazing natural, beautiful, amazing singer. I wish I could assault her in concert. But she's with the Lord now. God bless her and her family. And everyone in the world, thank you, seinead O'Connor.❤ I love you.❤
My phone messes up and text talking I wish I could have seen her in concert.
Google needs to correct that 1 mess up in my text talking. It was to see her in concert, not the other word.
😂
😮
😅
Thank Sinéad for this fly ,R.I.P 🖤
I'd forgotten all about this version. Now I'm crying. What a voice. May you rest in peace ❤🩹
Magnifica interpretazione . Simead, un angelo che ci hanno prestato un po’ su questa terra e che è tornata al suo posto . Un posto migliore
A singer with soul... sadly missing in today's corporate music world 🥺❤️
❤
Ruhe in Frieden Sinead. ❤
Ich bin immer noch geschockt über deinen Tod.
Kein Promi war so bescheiden, echt, ehrlich und hat trotz schlimmster Verzweiflung an das Gute im Menschen geglaubt.
Du fehlst so unglaublich.
Ich wär gerne mit dir einen Nachmittag am Meer in Bray gesessen.
😢😢😢
I love this performance by Sinead. I come back to it from time to time and it never ever gets old. I used to listen to it and so many of her songs over and over and over. There was no one like her and never will be. I deeply miss you Sinead and I am eternally grateful for your beautiful voice and soul.
R.I.P. - this live Performance is perfection - No one sing this better than you beautiful flower- unbelievable Feelings, voice ❤ thx all 4 this great Performance. Pink Floyd is my Religion
Shine head oconnor sang good songs.
Wow. How we miss her voice. And powerful words. She would have much to say now….💔🎶💔
Mother Fucking Garth Hudson on Accordion❤️.. Rick Danko Levon Helm
This was easily the best set of the night. Sinead stole the show here.
😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍 indescribably beautiful - Tears in my eyes
I send a Gifa Like from Argentina.
Sionism......Set free the World!!!
yes, the best live version. Amazing!
Garth Hudson.....what a class act......he was The Band...him and a few others.
Sadly Garth is the only one left from The Band. I get chills when I hear Helm and Danko sing in Harmony on this video. Great Rock and Roll is hard to come by now a days, all my Rock heroes are dying off!
Amazing performance Sinead broken heart in heaven RIP.
brasil 2024, years 27, bigfan sinnead feat pink floyd.
I love my mother!!! ❤❤❤😂!!! Overwehlming und Wunderschön und Wunderbar!!! I am Michael Matthias Frohn Mühlstroh und Jesus Christus!!! ❤❤❤😂 Very nice version!!! Sin'ead O'Connor for President!!!
Fly free forever, Sinead! 🎶💙🎶
she was gorgeous
Que espetáculo não sabia que ela gravou Mother do pik Floyd ❤❤
the band the band the band...
Nice Version!!! Michael Matthias Frohn Mühlstroh und Jesus Christus!!! ❤❤❤😂
RIP Sinhead.
I paid tribute to sinead and randy tonight. Two beautiful voices. Rest in peace. Thanks for the great music.
Rocked that accordion!
R.I.P Sweet Hurt Lady ❤❤❤
Irish Rebels always Rock
Is it Garth Hudson on the back ?
Yes
Very sad ! This song is amazing but watching this is just so sad such a beautiful and talented singer but now sadly gone ? 🥹 R.I.P 🙏
Wow, what a treat! Adds to it with Roger in accompaniment!
Marvelous Sinead . RIP.
Heaven gained an angel.❤Love you Sinéad
Eine der schönsten Fassungen dieses, meiner Meinung nach, besten Liedes von "The Wall"! Und Leider aktueller als in der Phase der Entstehung! 😭
Ya descansa en paz pues debe estar con su hijo. ¡Hasta siempre, Sinead!
R.I.P. dolce Sinead troppo sensibile per questa terra angelo 😢
Why this Is the First time I see ?
Absolutely wonderful.
Cuimhne i gco'nai
álainn ❤
The sad shame is she died broke and heart broken and now "They" trying to break Roger Watters
J'ai vu plusieurs fois cette vidéo merci pour celle-ci qui est de très bonne qualité.
Sinéad est merveilleuse comme toujours, je t'aime infiniment ❤❤😢❤
S'il vous plaît restaurez les autres vidéos de ma belle irlandaise dans cette qualité, cela serait génial.
After Sinéad's passing I stumbled upon this performance and I was so blown away by her and The Band's vocals here (however brief it all may be) that I just had to get this concert and get it to play on a decent set-up. I can tell you that I got even more blown away hearing this bit on Dolby Surround. Played Live in Berlin years before and I don't remember it making such an impact then. Things have changed. Rest easy, Sinéad.
I too will have to give this a listen on a good setup. It’s a great performance.
This was a huge Concert as commemoration of the fall of the Berlin Wall.. Its a masterpiece with incredible guests and stage work.
This for me is her Best Song Ever - like it more than Nothing Compares❤
This one, and Molly Malone. She was not just a singer, she told story's with her hart.
I love u girl!! Rest in peace ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Give Damien Dempsey some creds. He’s underrated! Sinead I always loved you! See you soon! She smiled there because she thought she was gonna get booed off stage.
Özellikle son hamlen çok iyiydi. Allah a teslim oldun ve müslüman olarak can verdin. Yusuf İslam, Muhammed Ali ve niceleri gibi. Rabbim bizleri cennetleri de buluştursun. Ben de 56 yaşındayım, gençlik yıllarımda dinlerdim.
Amazing!
Man, but I love the accordion in rock and blues!
That smile of Roger!
The best version hands down
RIP Sinead. Thanks for sharing this amazing piece.
I wonder if that is Rob Hyman of Philadelphia's own "HOOTERS" on the "hooter" instrument at 5:48 ? 🎹
yes
❤
It looks like I need to buy one more version of The Wall!
Her voice is crystal clear
This version of the song was made on DVD , HENCE,THE BUILDING OF THE WALL, DIFFERENT MUSITIONS SUNG THE WALL songs, that's why no ROGER W. EXCELLENT. DVD by the way ❤😮😊😂
The very first line she sang gave me chills!
Rest In Peace Sinéad.
This is why Pink Floyd will always be Watters and Barret because that’s where the genius lies. Sid fell and Roger picked up the baton and kept running
Fly Sinead!!
Espetacular!
Isn't that Loretta Lynn's Daddy up there. What an eclectic group
RIP beautiful woman
I was kind if a fan for her for like two weeks when she first came out. Then this other character emerged that i never liked.
All women are like that
She's a nutcase liberal, but awesome voice and excellent at conveying emotion. Even Roger Waters thought she was a handful, and that's saying alot😊
Incredible version. Great Sinead. Great the Pink Floyd...
The Band?
OMG. I’m sobbing and wondering why I outlived that beautiful woman. 😢❤