This is why I have no time for Americans that have no education at all...they know nothing but pretend to know everything...Ai makes it worse and GPT4...it's a script... Waste of time
"At 78, David Gilmour FINALLY Confirms WHY Roger Waters DESTROYED Pink Floyd" Err, well no he does not - this just a lenghty diatribe that does not tell you anything people do not already know. Total rubbish.
Just another attempt to write Roger out, he was the genius, he wrote most of the stuff when Gilpour could not even read or write music, no Roger is not perfect by any means, it was his band
This video tells of nothing - just the stuff every Pink Floyd fan already knows- RUclips should ban these types of videos from people who are after an income through misleading the viewer!
So, according to your own statement, this video is informative to those who are not Pink Floyd fan club members. What is the size of that audience compared to the size of the Pink Floyd fan club?
I am 65. David Gilmour has always been my rock ‘n’ roll hero a wonderful human humanitarian, a brilliant musician. I can’t imagine living life without his music can you?
Just like The Beatles went on without John Lennon ... and then without George Harrison. The reality is that as soon as Roger and David went their own separate ways, Pink Floyd ceased to exist. Roger knew it. It's sad that David didn't. He basically wanted to capitalise on the Pink Floyd name which he has continued to do because much of the audience have no clue about the true history and spirit of the band. Back in the 1990s, I saw David, Rick and Nick perform together as "Pink Floyd". But with no Roger, the band lacked "soul". And has continued to do so except for one bright unexpected moment at the Live 8 concert.
I'm glad I watched that. One of my favorite bands of all time. Lyrics to the songs are brilliant. And the music compliments it so well. The way David Gilmore makes the guitar talk is lyrics in itself
without Waters' conceptualism, the band would be "next" and ordinary, without the musical talents of Gilmour and Wright, the band would be boring and little-known. It was only an accidental combination of these creative principles that led to what it led to. But people connect and diverge, they don't have to meet the expectations of others. So... there is less pathos.
Your post remembers me of Van Halen, which was never the same after Dave's departure, lacking his showmanship. In the other hand, Dave's lounge and superficial solo act, had nothing to do with what VH was about
Now Gilmore is my favorite of the band. But we already know all this. If I wanted to see another documentary video about David Gilmour there’s hundreds of other videos better than this one out there. What about their break up? I didn’t see really anything about that than the stuff we already know about it. You kind of wasted all of our times.
Hi all - is there any way to block this BS clickbait page? I’ve already reported it and hid it from my channel but I really want to completely block them. What a waste of time and space Top Rewind is. A coma patient could do better.
Without Waters there would not have been a Floyd . Not of the caliber they achieved. I.e. - forgotten . They were all millionaires when they broke up with big egos . They're human , it happens. Let's just be grateful for their collaboration , which was better than all later individual or group efforts .
Obviously click bait that provides no new information regarding Pink Floyd. Simply an AI narrative summary of the great Pink Floyd. Watch ONLY if you never heard of PINK FLOYD., else total waste of time!
So, will you tell us now what's the answer of Roger Waters to this Gilmour's statement, so that we 'll be able to know the TRUTH? Otherwise we 'll know thw HALF of the truth , and that's aLIE , as everyone knoww...
The answer is: Clickbait. I saw a video awhile back or Waters walking through a large field of tall grass. You could see Crickets jumping around him. All he was doing was walking around aimlessly. Then as the sound got louder, what you thought was the Crickets, was actually "Clickbait! Clickbait! Clickbait!" I almost fell out of my chair...
"During the recording of the album Wall Waters insisted that keyboardist R.Wright leave the band". Oh, really? Wasn't it during recording of the album Animals? ...
Totally misleading title for this content. Don't bother. How do I prevent "Total Rewind" from appearing in my feed? (along with other obvious spammers.)
Bit hypocritical, don't you think? Fire a guy from his own band then change the band name to prevent him receiving royalties then dedicate a song to him.
Every time I hear that I ask what songs are their favorite. 9 out of 10 times they start naming David's songs. Wish you were here top of the list, comfortably numb...etc...
A disappointing video. As just noted by @elp5000 there isn't anything really new here. And most disappointing the very titling of the video suggests that we'd hear a more 1st person account of this from David Gilmour himself rather than a 3rd account from an anonymous narrator--who I worry may not even be a real person in the first place.
He wasnt told to go, Roger decided not to pick Syd up on way to recording studio. They drove straight past his flat and never had any contact afterwards. And continued to alter the band's name so as to cut Syd out off future Royalties. So bas😢ically, fired and ripped off.
u know, the "flower power" is still existing in its deadliest form - the one that took away Jimi, Kurt, Janis, Jim, Syd, Whitney, MJ, 2pac, Kelly, Elvis, Belushi, etc.. Imagine that they stayed in this, "our reality" just a little bit more... "You can check out any time you like, but you can never leave..." Young people, don't take it, don't fall under its spells! THE DRUGS ARE THE DEVILS FISHING BAIT. DON'T GET HOOKED, BE YOURSELF DESPITE ALL TIPES OF "HIGH", CAUSE (they say this in my home, the banana state) THE HIGHER YOU FLY, YOUR GUARANTEED FALL WILL BE HARDER, YOU CAN’T DO ANYTHING BUT SCREAM, LOOSE YOUR MIND AND SURELY DIE, KNOWN AS "ONCE-A-MAN, NOW A FADING MEMORY, TOMORROW ONLY AN UNKNOWN, FOREIGN "MEMORY ERROR", THE BALLON IN YOUR MORNING CUP OF COFFEE... 20:51
When it started I was pro Gilmore and assumed Waters was a Narc. But by 20:20 realized it was more likely Gilmore had the problems. Pity, as Pink Floyd made such great music.
for decades, i have felt in the minority cos i never hitched my wagon to the mindless Waters-bashing that was the conventional wisdom amongst (younger) Floyd fandom. besides, we really only ever get Gilmour's post-script, incidental perspectives on what was - like all enduring collaborations in life - a sprawling, complex and nuanced saga of chemistry, conflict and bursting creativity.. and this AI clickbait doesn't even handle that competently.
PLEASE do not be influenced in any way by this pack of lies!!!! Shows a photo of Rick Wright and calls him Syd Barrett - so that tells you all you need to know about the rest of it. AI at it's very worst, compiled by an idiot!
Listen to these Post PF split up "Roger Water" solo albums if you haven't already they are brilliant - same structure as PF albums not songs, entire albums to be listened to with a decent stereo or amazing headphones with no distractions 1. Pro's and Cons of Hitchhiking - 1984 - was intended to be the last album of PF but was replaced by the "Final Cut" album - Eric Clapton on Guitar and Dave Sanbourne on sax - brilliant album 2. Amused to Death - 1992 -- Jeff beck on lead guitar - absolutely amazing 3. Is this the life we really want - 2017 - makes a mockery of a certain ex President who was president at the time - less guitar on this album but still a great album 4. Radio Chaos - 1987 - great concept and story but little guitar so an ok album but not my favourite 5. Music from the body and Ca Ira I cannot comment on
I always preferred Waters because he was the one who made Floyd great, and his solo career was also great, but to hear he may be antisemitic... well that just makes me like him even more.
WATERS é o mais DIGNO artista da Europa, o Único com caráter e coragem para se pronunciar constantemente nas redes sociais, sua indignação pelo genocídio em GAZA, e sobre a guerra da OTAN contra a Rússia, na Ucrânia ! Tem o RESPEITO do mundo soberano e livre !
Roger Waters is Antisemitic by definition. There is no genocide in GAZA in contrary Hamas try to make genocide in Israel. Just learn the facts before writing nonsense.
Clickbait with nothing to say, especially not what it claims in the title. And that robotic delivery, wow! Devoid of substance and a snooze fest even at 2x speed. Please stop.
@@jsullivan2112 I disagree sir! Roger was heavily involved in creation the best PF albums. DSOM, the Wall, wish you were here and Animal. Granted, he was difficult to work with but how could you dismiss his role in PF!
@@Quantum-XF I hate Animals and the Wall, can't listen to them, so I guess there's that. They're so negative and cynical. Roger just needed therapy instead. Final Cut I still haven't bothered with, waste of my time. I can't stand Roger's voice and he started singing more on top of hijacking the band. I'll take the Division Bell any day. You mistake me, I'm not dismissing his role, when they were A BAND, not a solo artist with a backing band.
@@jsullivan2112 I appreciate your reply and respect your opinion. But somehow I see a huge disconnect between our musical tastes. I’m not a mono Pink Floyd freak. Mu range in rock is pretty vast, I loved grunge, the Rush and alike . Somehow though, I find it bizarre when a seemingly rock fan. Says he hates the Wall album or the Animals! Peace
@@Quantum-XF That's fine, I know a veiled insult when I see it. Sorry I hurt your feelings lol. The fact you can't comprehend liking Rush and hating those two records says more about you than me. Stumped are we?
Newsflash, You start this out by stating that Roger Waters nearly brought Pink Floyd to it's knees, but Roger was the one who put Pink Floyd on the map as awesome as Gilmour is at guitar and can write songs he can't write the load of work Waters can and did so without Waters there would be no Pink Floyd after Syd got kicked out, now the guitar in those songs are simply great due to Gilmour but you have to have a great song to frame those solos in and Waters wrote 75% of their catalog so he did the complete opposite of bringing Pink Floyd to it's knees although Roger made questionable decisions along the way like kicking Richard Wright out was plain stupid but who knows what arguments they had behind the scenes, and then you say Gilmour is the vocalist for Pink Floyd which was not true pre 1985 as he was co-vocalist with Roger but not sole vocalist until Roger left in 1985
Gilmour is great and one of the greatest guitarist but the reason why actually in MSM : Gilmour = good and Waters = Bad Its because of their political view about war. Waters is pro-peace whatever the war while Gilmour took same position MSM did (meaning same position as western government).
Nothing to feel sorry about. Pink Floyd opened our eyes in so many ways (and still do), that for sure all members are excused for their almost sad ending.
Dont forget WHY he had to go? Dont forget the other band members encouraged Syd to take drugs in the beginning to help bring out the artiste within and suggested using him like a lab rat by having him locked away from the outside world and continue writing the songs for them to sing until he was out of reach
clickbait... and btw. ROGER WATERS IS PINK FLOYD. it is their lyrics and songwriting that makes them so special. Unless you just like the "beat"... in which case i reccomend Jaz Z....
Waters may have wrote the bulk of the material, but you can't underestimate (or disregard like you are doing) the life that Gilmour breathed into the songs, vocally or musically. Wright was also a big contributor musically as well.
@@nicke.3782 i suppose you could say that about any band. from the doors to the jimi hendrix experience.. yea without robby krieger so much of the sound would be so very different. but when i listen to bands and think about what makes them so unique and potent, it is the artistic characteristic which is often designed by a single or just a couple of the main members. the lyrics especially, which is the most significant with floyd or bob dylan or jethro tull... etc...
@@sleepingtiger4436 You could say that about a lot of bands... but certainly not "any band." The lyrics are only the tip of the iceberg so to speak. Songs need life musically as well, and Waters did not show Gilmour or Wright their parts. That was a team effort in Pink Floyd... with Waters leading the way.
Roger went off and wrote an album, had no time for including anyone elses songs, then wanted the introduction "Roger Waters and Pink Floyd" like the rest of the guys were just some backing band he picked up somewhere. Based on the way he has since totally failed to express himself on what are probably admirable positions, I think he needed someone to tell him to just shut up and play, like forty years ago.
Exceptional artists and gifted musicians can become blinded and indecisive after fame & fortune.....Think VERY HARD before you decide to be in the Rock & Roll circus because it's a long way to the top if you can handle it.Most cannot
I wonder why Gilmour did not do an album for half century long Israeli invasion of Palestine, just like the one he did for Russian invasion of Ukraine. I guess the answer sums him up…
Sounds more like "Why David Gilmore destroyed Pink Floyd". Personally, I prefer Roger Waters and his touch. Sadly, they both complimented each other when co-operating, but obviously egos got in the way. The fact that Gilmore had to get his family involved and then supported them in publicly sh!t-canning Waters is nothing short of disappointing.
They're both ok with each other when talking and making music. When politics come in, shit flies every which way. It doesn't help when one of their wives gets involved too.
This, Ladies and Gentlemen, is what happens when you let kids with AI loose on the web. The script was written by AI as evidenced by the sheer nonsense of parts of it. The narrator is the common AI voice used in almost all AI videos like this and also makes blunders that are often rather humorous. Just say no to AI. Give this a thumbs down and do not subscribe.
Yes Gilmour is a great guitarist and all that ... BUT Waters WAS and always will be Pink! As the early part of the piece states, he controlled the creation of the best of their music! Just because he was the one with vision doesn't mean he destroyed the band ... they just couldn't keep up with his vision!
I have to admit that I did Love the direction that Waters took the band but it pains me because Waters is a Total A.H. I think that Wright, Mason, and Gilmore were the core of the band and you can just See their 'connection' to each other when you watch them play. Gilmore, of course, has a talent that Far Exceeds just regular guitar playing. Some of his solo's can bring on so much emotion that eyes will begin to leak. Now, as far as this video goes.....Total Waste Of Time!
There is NO NEWS here..
Thanks
think so?
thanks for saving my time
No news is GOOD NEWS!!!!
Thank you 🙏
The Title is ClickBait.....DO NOT WATCH THIS VIDEO.
report the account "as misinformation" and AI generated as I just have
This is why I have no time for Americans that have no education at all...they know nothing but pretend to know everything...Ai makes it worse and GPT4...it's a script...
Waste of time
@@ABStudioProductions69 done
Yeeeep Gilmour didn’t confirm anything
Thank you 👍
"At 78, David Gilmour FINALLY Confirms WHY Roger Waters DESTROYED Pink Floyd" Err, well no he does not - this just a lenghty diatribe that does not tell you anything people do not already know. Total rubbish.
report the account "as misinformation" and AI generated as I just have
Thank you, I just saw a few seconds and after that went directly to comments section, when I noted your proper observation.
Thank you. I stopped after 8 mins to read the comments because it seemed to be heading there. I will forget the rest of it...
Thanks for posting that ...... I don't have to watch it now.
Just another attempt to write Roger out, he was the genius, he wrote most of the stuff when Gilpour could not even read or write music, no Roger is not perfect by any means, it was his band
Clickbait
And you and i clicked HOOK LINE and SINKER 🤣lol
Thanks
report the account "as misinformation" and AI generated as I just have
@@ABStudioProductions69 No need for all that. Just hit the dislike button and move on. 🤪
This video tells of nothing - just the stuff every Pink Floyd fan already knows- RUclips should ban these types of videos from people who are after an income through misleading the viewer!
report the account "as misinformation" and AI generated as I just have.
I didn’t think it was too bad. I’ve seen worse especially with the clickbait
So, according to your own statement, this video is informative to those who are not Pink Floyd fan club members. What is the size of that audience compared to the size of the Pink Floyd fan club?
another BS story.
report the account "as misinformation" and AI generated as I just have
What utter tripe😤🥱
THAT IS NOT A PHOTO OF BARRETT IT IS RICK WRIGHT?... SHAME SLOPPY NARRATIVE....INSULTING TO GREAT MUSICIANS.
Totally agree.
Clearly the "AI" narrator is not "I" enough to realise the mistake?
The whole twenty wasted minutes is an insult to the viewers!
Gave up after 7 mins, just seemingly endless rambling by an AI narrator (hint: real people don't say one nine eight six for the year...)
Gave up when the AI pronounced the "lead singer" as "led singer", like Led Zeppelin.
@@Nemozoli I somehow hear "The Division Bells" in my head. I will vote against AI.
@@Nemozoli that was a warning! Got as far as the one-nine-eight-six and gave up!
report the account "as misinformation" and AI generated as I just have
@@ABStudioProductions69 But it's not misinformation according to the Google AI generated algorithm.
"At 78, David Gilmour FINALLY Confirms WHY Roger Waters DESTROYED Pink Floyd" Not in this video he doesn't
Ffs rubbish .Headline a bag of crap
Nice one mate
report the account "as misinformation" and AI generated as I just have
I am 65. David Gilmour has always been my rock ‘n’ roll hero a wonderful human humanitarian, a brilliant musician. I can’t imagine living life without his music can you?
Sad for the break up between the two, but the fans benefited of great music between the two and they do have a difference of style that I do enjoy
Pink Floyd was never destroyed. It just went on without Roger Waters.
Just like The Beatles went on without John Lennon ... and then without George Harrison.
The reality is that as soon as Roger and David went their own separate ways, Pink Floyd ceased to exist. Roger knew it. It's sad that David didn't. He basically wanted to capitalise on the Pink Floyd name which he has continued to do because much of the audience have no clue about the true history and spirit of the band.
Back in the 1990s, I saw David, Rick and Nick perform together as "Pink Floyd". But with no Roger, the band lacked "soul". And has continued to do so except for one bright unexpected moment at the Live 8 concert.
I'm glad I watched that. One of my favorite bands of all time. Lyrics to the songs are brilliant. And the music compliments it so well. The way David Gilmore makes the guitar talk is lyrics in itself
without Waters' conceptualism, the band would be "next" and ordinary, without the musical talents of Gilmour and Wright, the band would be boring and little-known. It was only an accidental combination of these creative principles that led to what it led to. But people connect and diverge, they don't have to meet the expectations of others. So... there is less pathos.
Your post remembers me of Van Halen, which was never the same after Dave's departure, lacking his showmanship. In the other hand, Dave's lounge and superficial solo act, had nothing to do with what VH was about
not many people explain this correctly. But you did.
Now Gilmore is my favorite of the band. But we already know all this. If I wanted to see another documentary video about David Gilmour there’s hundreds of other videos better than this one out there. What about their break up? I didn’t see really anything about that than the stuff we already know about it. You kind of wasted all of our times.
Gilmour would not be Gilmour without Waters
Absolutely rubbish referring to "why did Waters destroy Pink Floyd". Zero information.
Hi all - is there any way to block this BS clickbait page? I’ve already reported it and hid it from my channel but I really want to completely block them. What a waste of time and space Top Rewind is. A coma patient could do better.
Without Gilmour, Pink Floyd would have been forgotten
Sorry John
Without Waters there would not have been a Floyd . Not of the caliber they achieved. I.e. - forgotten . They were all millionaires when they broke up with big egos . They're human , it happens.
Let's just be grateful for their collaboration , which was better than all later individual or group efforts .
Obviously click bait that provides no new information regarding Pink Floyd. Simply an AI narrative summary of the great Pink Floyd. Watch ONLY if you never heard of PINK FLOYD., else total waste of time!
Total waste of time ESPECIALLY if you have never heard of Pink Floyd.
Full of nonsense and factual errors (lies!)
So, will you tell us now what's the answer of Roger Waters to this Gilmour's statement, so that we 'll be able to know the TRUTH? Otherwise we 'll know thw HALF of the truth , and that's aLIE , as everyone knoww...
Roger Walters leaving Floyd was the best thing to happen imo. Love you David thanks for supplying the soundtrack to my life.
Don't be fucking silly.
So ummm…why? Did I blink and miss tte AI answer? 😁
The answer is: Clickbait.
I saw a video awhile back or Waters walking through a large field of tall grass. You could see Crickets jumping around him. All he was doing was walking around aimlessly. Then as the sound got louder, what you thought was the Crickets, was actually "Clickbait! Clickbait! Clickbait!"
I almost fell out of my chair...
@@Bigfoot-px9gj 😂🤣
Thanks for saving me the agony of another youtube click bait time waster - sorry you got roped in.
@@bruceh92 glad I could help 😀
This is click bait,nothing more.
"During the recording of the album Wall Waters insisted that keyboardist R.Wright leave the band".
Oh, really? Wasn't it during recording of the album Animals? ...
He is reading straight from Wikipedia.
HE is AI - but not very "I" !!
thank you for saving 20.51 minutes of my life. Much appreciated!
Totally misleading title for this content. Don't bother. How do I prevent "Total Rewind" from appearing in my feed? (along with other obvious spammers.)
Bit hypocritical, don't you think? Fire a guy from his own band then change the band name to prevent him receiving royalties then dedicate a song to him.
Roger did NOT destroy Pink Floyd, as Floyds most popular, and requested, music was during his time with the band.
I’m knew as soon as I heard the narrators voice that this would be garbage, I managed 20 seconds before stopping it
David is a King
The more I hear about Waters, the more I would never like to meet him.
You don't even said how and by what means Roger Waters destroyed Pink Floyd?
This film merely show, continues show
Just a shame that creative differences had to finish PINK FLOYD. RIP SYD BARRETT. 😪💔🎸🎶
roger is the heart and soul of PF,david can't nerver replace him,peroid.
Every time I hear that I ask what songs are their favorite. 9 out of 10 times they start naming David's songs. Wish you were here top of the list, comfortably numb...etc...
I came for answers and got a documentary
Roger Waters is Pink Floyd
Your ass
You should not … Led Zeppelin Didn’t!
David Gilmour wanted his wife to be a member of Pink FLoyd - Waters recognised this was ridiculous.
Ridiculous. Roger had left the band a few years before David even MET Polly.
Nothing we didn’t already know. Could tell that the editor of this knows little about Gilmour or Pink Floyd.
A disappointing video. As just noted by @elp5000 there isn't anything really new here. And most disappointing the very titling of the video suggests that we'd hear a more 1st person account of this from David Gilmour himself rather than a 3rd account from an anonymous narrator--who I worry may not even be a real person in the first place.
He wasnt told to go, Roger decided not to pick Syd up on way to recording studio. They drove straight past his flat and never had any contact afterwards. And continued to alter the band's name so as to cut Syd out off future Royalties. So bas😢ically, fired and ripped off.
u know, the "flower power" is still existing in its deadliest form - the one that took away Jimi, Kurt, Janis, Jim, Syd, Whitney, MJ, 2pac, Kelly, Elvis, Belushi, etc.. Imagine that they stayed in this, "our reality" just a little bit more... "You can check out any time you like, but you can never leave..." Young people, don't take it, don't fall under its spells! THE DRUGS ARE THE DEVILS FISHING BAIT. DON'T GET HOOKED, BE YOURSELF DESPITE ALL TIPES OF "HIGH", CAUSE (they say this in my home, the banana state) THE HIGHER YOU FLY, YOUR GUARANTEED FALL WILL BE HARDER, YOU CAN’T DO ANYTHING BUT SCREAM, LOOSE YOUR MIND AND SURELY DIE, KNOWN AS
"ONCE-A-MAN, NOW A FADING MEMORY, TOMORROW ONLY AN UNKNOWN, FOREIGN "MEMORY ERROR", THE BALLON IN YOUR MORNING CUP OF COFFEE...
20:51
@ erm, right ok
@ ok
And he's got the right to talk of pink floyd
It's weird how Waters seems to have aged better than Gilmour, who was such a pretty boy back then.
Click bait
Never got to the point👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻
Waters thought he was Pink Floyd. He wanted to leave and take his ball, but it wasn't his to take.
I mean his last albums were written by his women Mrs. Gillmour
When it started I was pro Gilmore and assumed Waters was a Narc. But by 20:20 realized it was more likely Gilmore had the problems. Pity, as Pink Floyd made such great music.
for decades, i have felt in the minority cos i never hitched my wagon to the mindless Waters-bashing that was the conventional wisdom amongst (younger) Floyd fandom.
besides, we really only ever get Gilmour's post-script, incidental perspectives on what was - like all enduring collaborations in life - a sprawling, complex and nuanced saga of chemistry, conflict and bursting creativity..
and this AI clickbait doesn't even handle that competently.
PLEASE do not be influenced in any way by this pack of lies!!!!
Shows a photo of Rick Wright and calls him Syd Barrett - so that tells you all you need to know about the rest of it.
AI at it's very worst, compiled by an idiot!
Listen to these Post PF split up "Roger Water" solo albums if you haven't already they are brilliant - same structure as PF albums not songs, entire albums to be listened to with a decent stereo or amazing headphones with no distractions
1. Pro's and Cons of Hitchhiking - 1984 - was intended to be the last album of PF but was replaced by the "Final Cut" album - Eric Clapton on Guitar and Dave Sanbourne on sax - brilliant album
2. Amused to Death - 1992 -- Jeff beck on lead guitar - absolutely amazing
3. Is this the life we really want - 2017 - makes a mockery of a certain ex President who was president at the time - less guitar on this album but still a great album
4. Radio Chaos - 1987 - great concept and story but little guitar so an ok album but not my favourite
5. Music from the body and Ca Ira I cannot comment on
You only ever seem to hear Gilmour's side of the argument / story, Waters is very creative and deserves equal recognition IMHO
@@smitbar11 2,000% agree
I always preferred Waters because he was the one who made Floyd great, and his solo career was also great, but to hear he may be antisemitic... well that just makes me like him even more.
How much of Floyds music did Gilmore write Not much Waters wrote it all mostly
I don't take anyone seriously at the AA meeting until they put on a Boston Third Stage shirt.
Don’t get me wrong I love PinkFloydBut I could never stomach Roger Waters and his solo efforts like RadioKaos
WATERS é o mais DIGNO artista da Europa, o Único com caráter e coragem para se pronunciar constantemente nas redes sociais, sua indignação pelo genocídio em GAZA, e sobre a guerra da OTAN contra a Rússia, na Ucrânia ! Tem o RESPEITO do mundo soberano e livre !
Roger Waters is Antisemitic by definition. There is no genocide in GAZA in contrary Hamas try to make genocide in Israel. Just learn the facts before writing nonsense.
@@yf6mt
Since when is standing up for peace anti-Semitic?
100%
Clickbait with nothing to say, especially not what it claims in the title. And that robotic delivery, wow! Devoid of substance and a snooze fest even at 2x speed. Please stop.
And after Roger left, the band was never the same!
After Roger left the band righted itself.
@@jsullivan2112 I disagree sir! Roger was heavily involved in creation the best PF albums. DSOM, the Wall, wish you were here and Animal. Granted, he was difficult to work with but how could you dismiss his role in PF!
@@Quantum-XF I hate Animals and the Wall, can't listen to them, so I guess there's that. They're so negative and cynical. Roger just needed therapy instead. Final Cut I still haven't bothered with, waste of my time. I can't stand Roger's voice and he started singing more on top of hijacking the band. I'll take the Division Bell any day.
You mistake me, I'm not dismissing his role, when they were A BAND, not a solo artist with a backing band.
@@jsullivan2112 I appreciate your reply and respect your opinion. But somehow I see a huge disconnect between our musical tastes. I’m not a mono Pink Floyd freak. Mu range in rock is pretty vast, I loved grunge, the Rush and alike . Somehow though, I find it bizarre when a seemingly rock fan. Says he hates the Wall album or the Animals! Peace
@@Quantum-XF That's fine, I know a veiled insult when I see it. Sorry I hurt your feelings lol. The fact you can't comprehend liking Rush and hating those two records says more about you than me. Stumped are we?
Newsflash, You start this out by stating that Roger Waters nearly brought Pink Floyd to it's knees, but Roger was the one who put Pink Floyd on the map as awesome as Gilmour is at guitar and can write songs he can't write the load of work Waters can and did so without Waters there would be no Pink Floyd after Syd got kicked out, now the guitar in those songs are simply great due to Gilmour but you have to have a great song to frame those solos in and Waters wrote 75% of their catalog so he did the complete opposite of bringing Pink Floyd to it's knees although Roger made questionable decisions along the way like kicking Richard Wright out was plain stupid but who knows what arguments they had behind the scenes, and then you say Gilmour is the vocalist for Pink Floyd which was not true pre 1985 as he was co-vocalist with Roger but not sole vocalist until Roger left in 1985
Gilmour is great and one of the greatest guitarist but the reason why actually in MSM : Gilmour = good and Waters = Bad Its because of their political view about war. Waters is pro-peace whatever the war while Gilmour took same position MSM did (meaning same position as western government).
Gilmour,..., Gilmour..., Gilmour... bla, bla, bla. Why is AI so dumb?
Ultimate argument in our house hold was either pro Waters or pro Gilmour....in the end (and it's near/ is Gilmore.
What do you mean finally. You’ve told us nothing we didn’t already know.
"Top Rewind" "Golden Rewind" how many other clones do you have?
What's your point? You mentioned no new news on how RW destroyed Pink Floyd? This "cut" is a biography of Gilmore's life and music history.
Absolutely right - Roger Waters is THE INTELLECT and PINK FLOYD
The TRUTH is that it was David who broke PF up NOT Rogers.
The dates are way off, Rattle that lock was not out until 2013 or so not in the 1970s this is total misinformation .
21 minutes you'll never get back
David Gilmor dosn't speak a word during this clip. It is completely narrated. No interviews here.
Barrett left the band?? Barrett was fired. insulting for the band to dedicate Shine On to him
Yes, well, he did turn up at the studio when they were recording Shine On, so I guess that's why they made the dedication.
Yes Syd fan - but don't forget WHY he was told to go!
What do you mean finally? He’s made it clear for years.
It's time that owners of these clickbait channels were charged with fraud.
Nothing to feel sorry about. Pink Floyd opened our eyes in so many ways (and still do), that for sure all members are excused for their almost sad ending.
Dont forget WHY he had to go? Dont forget the other band members encouraged Syd to take drugs in the beginning to help bring out the artiste within and suggested using him like a lab rat by having him locked away from the outside world and continue writing the songs for them to sing until he was out of reach
Love you Roger....go man !
clickbait... and btw. ROGER WATERS IS PINK FLOYD. it is their lyrics and songwriting that makes them so special. Unless you just like the "beat"... in which case i reccomend Jaz Z....
Waters may have wrote the bulk of the material, but you can't underestimate (or disregard like you are doing) the life that Gilmour breathed into the songs, vocally or musically. Wright was also a big contributor musically as well.
@@nicke.3782 i suppose you could say that about any band. from the doors to the jimi hendrix experience.. yea without robby krieger so much of the sound would be so very different. but when i listen to bands and think about what makes them so unique and potent, it is the artistic characteristic which is often designed by a single or just a couple of the main members. the lyrics especially, which is the most significant with floyd or bob dylan or jethro tull... etc...
@@sleepingtiger4436 You could say that about a lot of bands... but certainly not "any band." The lyrics are only the tip of the iceberg so to speak. Songs need life musically as well, and Waters did not show Gilmour or Wright their parts. That was a team effort in Pink Floyd... with Waters leading the way.
The narrator is not a Pink Floyd expert by any means
No NEWS. Only an advertisement of Devid Gilmour, where it did have bad effect on my openion towards Gilmour.
Roger went off and wrote an album, had no time for including anyone elses songs, then wanted the introduction "Roger Waters and Pink Floyd" like the rest of the guys were just some backing band he picked up somewhere. Based on the way he has since totally failed to express himself on what are probably admirable positions, I think he needed someone to tell him to just shut up and play, like forty years ago.
All of division bell was written by his Mrs. Gilmour
Exceptional artists and gifted musicians can become blinded and indecisive after fame & fortune.....Think VERY HARD before you decide to be in the Rock & Roll circus
because it's a long way to the top if you can handle it.Most cannot
Stopped watching when he said that Syd agreed tp leave the group. He dind't, he left behind.
I wonder why Gilmour did not do an album for half century long Israeli invasion of Palestine, just like the one he did for Russian invasion of Ukraine. I guess the answer sums him up…
i agree with gilmour's wife. waters is a nut. some people are just out of their minds, he's one of them.
He was an early mentor and supporter of Kate Bush!
Gilmour is the 14th guitarist of all time? :))))
Great history of Gilmour but nothing new to see here. We all know the reason: Money.
I’ve not watched this but I know it’s going to be one of those videos that don’t tell you shit you didn’t already know.
Rodger waters was always the problem….youre welcome
Sounds more like "Why David Gilmore destroyed Pink Floyd".
Personally, I prefer Roger Waters and his touch.
Sadly, they both complimented each other when co-operating, but obviously egos got in the way.
The fact that Gilmore had to get his family involved and then supported them in publicly sh!t-canning Waters is nothing short of disappointing.
They're both ok with each other when talking and making music.
When politics come in, shit flies every which way. It doesn't help when one of their wives gets involved too.
so??? where is WHY roger destroyed pink??????? 😑
3d wooden night light looks nice
This, Ladies and Gentlemen, is what happens when you let kids with AI loose on the web. The script was written by AI as evidenced by the sheer nonsense of parts of it. The narrator is the common AI voice used in almost all AI videos like this and also makes blunders that are often rather humorous. Just say no to AI. Give this a thumbs down and do not subscribe.
Yes Gilmour is a great guitarist and all that ... BUT Waters WAS and always will be Pink! As the early part of the piece states, he controlled the creation of the best of their music! Just because he was the one with vision doesn't mean he destroyed the band ... they just couldn't keep up with his vision!
Hey guys give this video a break. It's a good biography of david Gilmour if nothing else.
Click bait. Hit pause. Thumb down. Move on.
NO PERDER TIEMPO!!!
Gilmour NO habla en este video.
He did not agreed to leave the band! He was fired !!!😂😂😂
I have to admit that I did Love the direction that Waters took the band but it pains me because Waters is a Total A.H.
I think that Wright, Mason, and Gilmore were the core of the band and you can just See their 'connection' to each other when you watch them play.
Gilmore, of course, has a talent that Far Exceeds just regular guitar playing. Some of his solo's can bring on so much emotion that eyes will begin to leak.
Now, as far as this video goes.....Total Waste Of Time!