Judy’s voice is always exceptional. Have you seen A STAR IS BORN ? Also the duet with Mel torme the trolley song. Listen to her sustain the last note. UNBELIEVABLE!!!!!!
This classic musical number is pure movie magic! I can't fathom why MGM deleted any part of this! I own this on videotape, DVD and Blue Ray. The legendary, adorable, beautiful, very intelligent and extremely talented Judy Garland does is perfect! Actor George Murphy is excellent! Everyone does an excellent job in this classic number! Thank you for posting and sharing this!
Incrível que todo vídeo que eu clico que Judy está no meio, se torna um dos meus preferidos. Ela arrasou nesse trabalho e cantou lindamente como sempre, Judy nunca nos decepcionou.
It’s too bad that more of these commentators were not born in the 40’s. So many of them cannot begin to appreciate Judy Garland’s music and her wonderful films. I don’t think anything produced today comes close to the magic of Judy Garland and by extension, anything MGM put out in the 40’s. I didn’t appreciate them until the 60’s but then I wasn’t born until 42. No one will ever compare with Judy Garland in my book.
When I saw that this was the "extended version" I was hoping the hula doll footage would be included. No such luck, but at least I can hear the soundtrack. It's obvious that it was there originally since George's rejection of it is present in the lyrics that remain: "Those yacka-hicki hula dolls are really much too faddy..."
Not to mention this is the LITERAL objectification of women as dolls that can be purchased and used as the man likes. I do like the song in spite of this but its still pretty gross lol
Another INCREDIBLE job Mark! And quite a lengthy clip too at almost 5 WHOLE minutes to synchronize! But as always, expertly done. I only wish Warner Home Video would do the same with "For Me And My Gal". Thanks so much for your hard work. Did this one take long to do? And did you encounter any problems? What ALWAYS astounds me is just HOW MUCH material Metro Goldwyn Mayer used to cut out! The whole bit with the Hawaiian girl is edited out, but we seem to see a quick flash of her seated on the soundstage floor at 04:30 into the video. Oh wow I WISH you would do the whole of the "Atchison Topeka" number [but I realize that is a tall order LOL]. Cheers David.
This was tough, as some parts of it were alternate takes (e.g. Lucille's entire opening). Also, always hard to add the taps! All that work for a meh number. You've seen my clip of "For Me and My Gal", right? I've done Atchison, but haven't uploaded it. It's also available in stereo as an extra on the DVD!
You're all MF's that program Still Borns. That's all I can say. Guess what, here is the notice that you asked for. I'll type it twice. "There's a new world commin' " That's all you get. HA HA! -THE NEST
It's funny, I had never noticed the hawaiian girl hahaha also, in the classic theatrical trailer, we get a glimpse of the French can-can "doll", quite interesting!
Danny Chavez , I totally agree. I'm sure that it was taken differently in the 1940s. ....... Also, in my opinion, whomever designed this costume for Garland obviously wanted to show off her small waist , but forgot that the.costume should flatter her in total.
As a woman - seems like the only one in this thread - that really this whole depiction of women is sexist. And let's be clear: Garland's roll as the Doll here is steeped in the heteropatriarchal tradition in America. That being said, women in hollywood have to be the utter image of perfection and if they aren't, well they get cast out. Garland certainly was the epitome of that as she had to have fake teeth early in her career and was put on drugs to get thinner. So, tell me again how that isn't rooted in sexism and the heteropatriarchal tradition of hollywood?
Well, I'm a woman too, so I guess I'll leave my two cents. Calling him Daddy and Papa, with clear sexual overtones, is what bothers me the most. CREEPY AS FK!!! And no, they didn't see it differently in the 40s. Sex abuse, molestation, and incest was alive and well back then. This was around the same time the Kinsey report was published. The level of sexual and physical abuse against women and children in Hollywood was unreal. What bothers me second is the equating of living female human beings to mechanically animated objects.
June Allyson once said that Judy couldn't do anything differently in her life just because her talent was so overwhelming and she didn't know it. That is why Judy didn't care about financial management and the state of her bank account at all... the rest is history.
I don’t really understand this .. could you explain it to me. (I already know Judy was unequivocally talented & that her $ situation was poorly handled, I just don’t get Allyson’s statement).
She was too busy working just to make enough money to eat for her and her children. She thought she had reliable people taking care of her finances. Put yourself in her place. You didn’t begin to understand Miss Allyson’s meaning. Not only that, she was a child and by the time she was a woman, she was ill. She had to work all the time. She couldn’t take the time needed to get well. Doctors begged MGM to give her the time but she was a very important and lucrative piece of property. Her talent was overwhelming for her and greedy grabbing money making leeches who surrounded her including a certain husband were spending her money faster than she could make it including the IRS because some one of those people paid to over look her affairs were not doing their job and I’m sure pocketing whatever they could get their grubby little paws on.
Desert Rehab PT Oh I agree with that 100%. Everyone around Judy took advantage of her and left her alone to dry. I just didn’t understand the wording of the first comment. I love Judy so much myself, would never place the blame on her for the terrible circumstances that befell her.
certain days of the week given even a hardcore feminist would miss the good ol' days when being a woman was basically won on your looking good and being cute especially when Judy Garland does it so well - Not that looking good is infinitely easy it is infinitely easier than kicking it for yourself mind you only certain days lol.
Eu acho que as mulheres sofriam muito com o machismo, mas os homens sabiam a forma certa de conquistar a gente naquela época… hoje em dia é só mostrar o corpo que já ganha dinheiro e o “”””amor””””” dos homens, é deprimente como veem a gente nesse tempo! Evoluímos para trás.
Who cares whether or not it was in stereo. Just goes to show you how magnificently her talent was and cane over the RKO microphones. She didn’t need stereo!
@@mikeos1 God, I love "Internet Experts"! Stereo experiments began in the early 1930s. Beginning in the mid-30s, all MGM pre-recordings were done in multichannel sound. These "stems" were later mixed down to mono for the film's release. Fortunately, many of these original stems survived, and literally hundreds of them have been released in true stereo since the 1990s. You might consider not pontificating on things of which you have zero knowledge.
Judy's voice was exceptional here.
Judy Garland voice was awesome, she had raw raw talent and she was one of the Best singers in that time back then.
Judy’s voice is always exceptional. Have you seen A STAR IS BORN ? Also the duet with Mel torme the trolley song. Listen to her sustain the last note. UNBELIEVABLE!!!!!!
@@desertrehabpt211 Like the kids say, OMG. That last note was what's known as a "loop."
Yes, he really got the most beautiful doll!
Judy is perfect
Ahhh.. The incomparably without a doubt.. Quite the doll herself‼️ Judy Garland... Sing it you "great big beautiful doll "💚
One of the greatest old films ever! Beautiful, classy, romantic, tragic, it has everything
This classic musical number is pure movie magic! I can't fathom why MGM deleted any part of this! I own this on videotape, DVD and Blue Ray. The legendary, adorable, beautiful, very intelligent and extremely talented Judy Garland does is perfect! Actor George Murphy is excellent! Everyone does an excellent job in this classic number! Thank you for posting and sharing this!
Judy's voice is in top form here.
Incrível que todo vídeo que eu clico que Judy está no meio, se torna um dos meus preferidos. Ela arrasou nesse trabalho e cantou lindamente como sempre, Judy nunca nos decepcionou.
Filme maravilhoso… Judy Garland sem dúvida a DIVA da “Era de Ouro de Hollywood “
Oh George Murphy you beautiful doll!
Every time I see George Murphy my heart goes "Oh oh oh oh oh you beautiful doll!!!"
Good. He is getting some recognition.
Thank you for sharing this.
no, thank you.
George Murphy was a fabulous dancer. He danced all the way to the U.S. Senate.
Fantastic Musical Number!
I Love this perfomance! ❤
George Murphy was adorable
love it thanx for shareing!!!!
It’s too bad that more of these commentators were not born in the 40’s. So many of them cannot begin to appreciate Judy Garland’s music and her wonderful films. I don’t think anything produced today comes close to the magic of Judy Garland and by extension, anything MGM put out in the 40’s. I didn’t appreciate them until the 60’s but then I wasn’t born until 42. No one will ever compare with Judy Garland in my book.
Perfeitos!!! Td maravilhoso!!! Vejo e revejo, nao me canso! Q obra prima!!!😍😍😍
Eu também não canso de assistir. Sou fã da Judy Garland. Tenho este filme em DVD.
When I saw that this was the "extended version" I was hoping the hula doll footage would be included. No such luck, but at least I can hear the soundtrack. It's obvious that it was there originally since George's rejection of it is present in the lyrics that remain: "Those yacka-hicki hula dolls are really much too faddy..."
in todays society, this performance and that "daddy" will creep the hell out of us. but on the side note, this song so good >
i cant imagine this not being creepy though.. he wants a doll to romance, and ends up with a dall that calls him daddy? 😂
Speak for yourself. That "daddy" Judy sung gave me goosebumps......I loved it 💯😍😍😍😍😍
Not to mention this is the LITERAL objectification of women as dolls that can be purchased and used as the man likes. I do like the song in spite of this but its still pretty gross lol
@@beccamcdonald9846 it makes me laugh because If I ever purchased a doll and she sang like this, oh we going on the road, American idol etc lol
@@TrangPakbaby Hahaha true
Maravilhoso! Nao me canso de ver!
Filme com a grande “Judy Garland” foi a maior dançarina de filmes musicais da Era de Ouro de Hollywood... lovely
Concordo contigo. Ela era simplesmente maravilhosa.
@@juliamariaf.queiroz2682 sim…
Maravilhosos! Adoro!!!
Amooo!!!😍😍😍
The Can Can Doll and the Hula Doll should have been used in the final movie!
Apaixonante❤
This Musical Number should have been left uncut in the final cut!
Another INCREDIBLE job Mark! And quite a lengthy clip too at almost 5 WHOLE minutes to synchronize! But as always, expertly done. I only wish Warner Home Video would do the same with "For Me And My Gal". Thanks so much for your hard work. Did this one take long to do? And did you encounter any problems? What ALWAYS astounds me is just HOW MUCH material Metro Goldwyn Mayer used to cut out! The whole bit with the Hawaiian girl is edited out, but we seem to see a quick flash of her seated on the soundstage floor at 04:30 into the video. Oh wow I WISH you would do the whole of the "Atchison Topeka" number [but I realize that is a tall order LOL]. Cheers David.
This was tough, as some parts of it were alternate takes (e.g. Lucille's entire opening). Also, always hard to add the taps! All that work for a meh number.
You've seen my clip of "For Me and My Gal", right? I've done Atchison, but haven't uploaded it. It's also available in stereo as an extra on the DVD!
You're all MF's that program Still Borns. That's all I can say. Guess what, here is the notice that you asked for. I'll type it twice. "There's a new world commin' " That's all you get. HA HA! -THE NEST
It's funny, I had never noticed the hawaiian girl hahaha also, in the classic theatrical trailer, we get a glimpse of the French can-can "doll", quite interesting!
The Daddy part is creepy.
Danny Chavez , I totally agree. I'm sure that it was taken differently in the 1940s. ....... Also, in my opinion, whomever designed this costume for Garland obviously wanted to show off her small waist , but forgot that the.costume should flatter her in total.
@Sacred Atheist I didn't say Judy wasn't sexy in this. I said singing to her daddy like that was creepy. If she was singing that to me it would be on.
As a woman - seems like the only one in this thread - that really this whole depiction of women is sexist. And let's be clear: Garland's roll as the Doll here is steeped in the heteropatriarchal tradition in America. That being said, women in hollywood have to be the utter image of perfection and if they aren't, well they get cast out. Garland certainly was the epitome of that as she had to have fake teeth early in her career and was put on drugs to get thinner. So, tell me again how that isn't rooted in sexism and the heteropatriarchal tradition of hollywood?
Well, I'm a woman too, so I guess I'll leave my two cents. Calling him Daddy and Papa, with clear sexual overtones, is what bothers me the most. CREEPY AS FK!!! And no, they didn't see it differently in the 40s. Sex abuse, molestation, and incest was alive and well back then. This was around the same time the Kinsey report was published. The level of sexual and physical abuse against women and children in Hollywood was unreal.
What bothers me second is the equating of living female human beings to mechanically animated objects.
@@dannychavez7876 you think that dressing a young woman up as little girl Bo Peep is sexy? 😐
Omgggg 😍
😂😂😂
Her waist snatched
yes i agree chris
Is that Gene Kelly at 3:57?
Yep - he's her co-star in the film.
Eu nem o reconheci 😨 conseguiram deixar ele, um ator tão bonito, com uma fantasia tão bizarra e feia! 😅
What does "unused" mean?
Unused in the film.
I love Judy, and her voice is perfect, but... this song makes me very, very uncomfortable. 😝 Anyone else feeling weird about it? Crikey.
I didn't like the line, "I don't care how mean you are to me." But I'm with you about Judy--she's a peach.
hell naaaw why they got her in a box like that
😭😭sis
@@MiaWallace85 what bbg
... f-111 v rocket ... right up yours ...
June Allyson once said that Judy couldn't do anything differently in her life just because her talent was so overwhelming and she didn't know it. That is why Judy didn't care about financial management and the state of her bank account at all... the rest is history.
Witold Banasik But with June A. that Depends...
I don’t really understand this .. could you explain it to me. (I already know Judy was unequivocally talented & that her $ situation was poorly handled, I just don’t get Allyson’s statement).
She was too busy working just to make enough money to eat for her and her children. She thought she had reliable people taking care of her finances. Put yourself in her place. You didn’t begin to understand Miss Allyson’s meaning. Not only that, she was a child and by the time she was a woman, she was ill. She had to work all the time. She couldn’t take the time needed to get well. Doctors begged MGM to give her the time but she was a very important and lucrative piece of property. Her talent was overwhelming for her and greedy grabbing money making leeches who surrounded her including a certain husband were spending her money faster than she could make it including the IRS because some one of those people paid to over look her affairs were not doing their job and I’m sure pocketing whatever they could get their grubby little paws on.
Desert Rehab PT Oh I agree with that 100%. Everyone around Judy took advantage of her and left her alone to dry. I just didn’t understand the wording of the first comment. I love Judy so much myself, would never place the blame on her for the terrible circumstances that befell her.
certain days of the week given even a hardcore feminist would miss the good ol' days when being a woman was basically won on your looking good and being cute especially when Judy Garland does it so well - Not that looking good is infinitely easy it is infinitely easier than kicking it for yourself mind you only certain days lol.
Eu acho que as mulheres sofriam muito com o machismo, mas os homens sabiam a forma certa de conquistar a gente naquela época… hoje em dia é só mostrar o corpo que já ganha dinheiro e o “”””amor””””” dos homens, é deprimente como veem a gente nesse tempo! Evoluímos para trás.
obviously not in stereo.
Obviously in real stereo - why would I say it was if it’s not?
Who cares whether or not it was in stereo. Just goes to show you how magnificently her talent was and cane over the RKO microphones. She didn’t need stereo!
@@boinx1234 Stereo recording did not exist in 1942, that's why.
@@mikeos1 God, I love "Internet Experts"! Stereo experiments began in the early 1930s. Beginning in the mid-30s, all MGM pre-recordings were done in multichannel sound. These "stems" were later mixed down to mono for the film's release.
Fortunately, many of these original stems survived, and literally hundreds of them have been released in true stereo since the 1990s. You might consider not pontificating on things of which you have zero knowledge.
@@boinx1234 point taken. Just re-listened to it over good hi-fi. Sounds great. Incidentally I adore Judy Garland.