This was brilliant. Geri singing “if you want my future, forget my past” takes on a different meaning in the context of your creative narrative. It’s almost like she’s apologizing and asking forgiveness for (publicly) breaking up the group.
Happy New Year Lipehall!! Here's to a Spicey 2024!!! I always say to the doubters that there were never any wars when the spice girls ruled world!! Xxx
Amigo, acabei de ver o vídeo e tipo, não paro de chorar. Eu tinha 12/13 anos quando soube da notícia. Lembrei de tudo na época e tô chorando agora. 😭😭😭😭
Gente, eu chorei tanto aqui. Lembrei de tudo na época que a Ginger saiu. Lembrei da Mel B dizendo que chorou na gravação da música. Obrigado por tocar no coração dos fãs com esse vídeo. As Spice Girls deveriam assitir esse vídeo
This was perfectly created! From Geri intro, to incorporating her before Victorias verse! I literally shed a tear towards the end, where Victoria was on the screen on SpiceWorld 2019! This was excellent 😢❤
Amazing video. Thank you so much for making this. I wish the official Spice Girl team made this much effort. Amazing memories and perfect video of an era
Geri, you & Melanie B were my heroes in the Spice Girls. I was so heartbroken when you left the Spice Girls in 1998. In a way, I believe that your departure was a blessing in disguise for the Spice Girls. I know, after sacking Simon Fuller, you girls were all tired. Forgive us, for being angry when you left the four remaining Spice Girls. We (as fans) didn't know all the shit that you went through, because you & the other four girls sold us the image of strong individual women through Girl Power. And we bought it. You and the other four were strong women. You girls managed to hide whatever problems you were dealing with at that time. Only after you left, we found out that Melanie C had some demons too that she had to deal with (😊 depression, eating disorder etc) & Victoria too was rumoured to have some issues about eating disorder etc (But I don't know if they were all true, I don't wanna know). We blamed you for being responsible of the spitting up of the Spice Girls. No one understand that the Spice Girls needed a break after your (Spice Girls) success in 1996 to 2000. We didn't understand that you & the girls were only human. I still believe after your departure, the other four remaining Spice Girls finally had the chance to sit down & decided to have a break & did the decisions to focus on their individual priorities, you girls only needed to have your own individual time after the phenomenal success that you've achieved. And THANK YOU for reuniting for us in 2007 & 2019. I love you Geri. I love Melanie B & I love the other three (Emma, Melanie C & Victoria) too. Wishing you all the girls. And please consider to do another reunion for us again, at least once. I still need to introduce you girls to my own children. I want them to get to know you lot & they need to listen to your music. You girls have shaped me into the woman I am today, love, Crazy Spice xxx✌️🇬🇧 xxx
I really really love your comment so much The 4 girls used to be very angry when Geri suddenly left, but actually the band was exhausted and tired after their glory, and they really wanted to be free on their own path (like Geri).
@@damdaung8369 Thank you 💋I have to say I noticed that name of yours in mostly every video that involves the Spice Girls here (in the pasts) in RUclips. I think I know that name of yours, been seeing that particular name here & there before. We might've argued once or twice before about the information about the Spice Girls before. May I ask, if you're a Vietnamese? Sorry, if my question offend you, I didn't mean any harm. I'm Malaysian btw, my mother's from Leeds, England, she's biracial, just like Melanie B. So in my younger days, I could totally relate to Scary Spice, although I'm only half a quarter black woman. And I remember during an interview with Morgan Piers (I maybe got the wrong person, or spelt his name wrongly), Geri did say that, she had never apologize to any of the Spice Girl when she left because they were just young, they were nothing to be sorry for. And I remember reading some nasty comments in RUclips on how Geri was selfish for never apologizing. But in Spiceworld Tour 2019, that Geri did apologize to the Melanies & Emma for leaving them in 1998. But we all know now, the reason Geri walked out on them. Geri deserve an apology from the Spice Girls fans who were so mean to her. They all praise Melanie C, but dissing the others. As a fan, it hurts to see that behavior. The Spice Girls were about a team. Just one Spice Girl is not enough to make her the Spice Girls. They're all about a vibe. Every 5 girl completes each other. They're like 5 different warriors with 5 different specialities in a war field 🇬🇧✌️
@@crazyspice3951 hello, nice to see you again, Crazyspice Sorry for a long time I didn't talk to you because of my own busy business You're right about my country, I'm Vietnamese and I'm 33 years old now, maybe you and me has the same age, 😀😀
@@crazyspice3951 and you're right about your last opnion, that "Geri deserve an apology from the Spice Girls fans" Many fans were so disapointed and angry when Geri left in 1998, But whether Geri left or not, sooner or later Spice Girls would break up , because all members have planned to act in the band in a short time and then separate to go their own way (Mel B confirm that in interview with Larry King in 2014) So that Geri was NOT the reason why the band break up and nowaday, Geri always be the most important members of all the reunions of the band (in 2007-2008, 2016, 2019). Although she was the first one leaving the band, but she has been the last one to persuade the girls to come back to keep Spice girls alive until now So truly that Ginger was the best leader of spice girls, as the girls couldn't reunite without her. Do you think so?
Omg that was such a beautiful video. Love that you put geri in the video as well. Cried the whole time. Thank you again for doing these amazing videos for us 🤗🤗🤗❤️❤️❤️
Those drums are just amazing right? That’s always been my fav version of goodbye. Followed very closely by the reunion I’m 07/08 version. The outro of that is bloody amazing. Great version here. Loved the effort put into it with the story winding throughout. Well done. 👍🏻
Você toca em um lugar onde só que é fã consegue sentir. Muito obrigado por esse lindo trabalho. Se as próprias pudessem ter esse privilégio de assistir aos seus trabalhos, os últimos “lançamentos” seriam muito mais humanos do que robóticos. Muito obrigado por existir Lipe ❤️ Que todas as boas energias do Universo abençoe seu talento.
@@LipeHall Also, I have to tell you, I debuted my first solo comedy show the other night and I used your Olympics ‘Spice Up Your Life’ as the exit music for myself and the audience. They loved!
a parte mais sensacional ter colocado a VB no telao em Wembley logo depois da parte dela no final da musica! IRADO demais, me fez voltar aos shows da tour TROTSG and SW2019
hi im angelee in october 2023 i had 2 grandmas that died it was sad for me when i think of my 2 grandmas i start to cry i miss my 2 grandmas they where in my life so i feel sad its not easy but im trying to stay strong when i cry i love both my grandmas it was hard for me to say good bye to my 2 grandmas
This was brilliant.
Geri singing “if you want my future, forget my past” takes on a different meaning in the context of your creative narrative. It’s almost like she’s apologizing and asking forgiveness for (publicly) breaking up the group.
that's it! you got it 🤍
OMG the intro when Ginger left, that's epic
😢🤍🕊️
Happy New Year Lipehall!! Here's to a Spicey 2024!!! I always say to the doubters that there were never any wars when the spice girls ruled world!! Xxx
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
❤
@@LipeHall I just don't understand why you don't share the whole Victoria Union Libre performance? PLease
One of the best vocal moments for Emma. She really shined in this song
simplesmente SENSACIONAL, quem foi fan e viveu e sofreu a saída da Geri, certeza q chorou vendo essa versão do Lipehall. Incrível!
😢🫶🏻
Amigo, acabei de ver o vídeo e tipo, não paro de chorar. Eu tinha 12/13 anos quando soube da notícia. Lembrei de tudo na época e tô chorando agora. 😭😭😭😭
Saddest anniversary, but it’s a goodbye to our pain and about being stronger and moving on.
Gente, eu chorei tanto aqui. Lembrei de tudo na época que a Ginger saiu. Lembrei da Mel B dizendo que chorou na gravação da música. Obrigado por tocar no coração dos fãs com esse vídeo. As Spice Girls deveriam assitir esse vídeo
This is a masterpiece, they need to see this tribute it’s beautiful
thank you! 🤍🕊️
Goosebumps 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
😢🫶🏻
Watching with a teary eye!! Amazing!! Thanks for sharing!! ❤
Glad you enjoyed it!
Wow❤
This was an emotional roller coaster of a masterpiece!!! 😢 😭 🤧
Mel C*) always the best*) absolutely beautiful voice*>
Wonderful, so touching and nostalgic. Thank you once again, fantastic job 👏🏼 ❤
thank you so much! 🫶🏻🤍
Emocionado aqui! Você sempre arrasa. Dessa vez tocou fundo! ❤❤❤❤❤
Mel C and Emma owns this song 💙💖💖💙
GIRL POWER!!!! ✌️✌️✌️✌️✌️
hermosa version del goodbye amo esta canción
emocionante! lindo! ❤
😍😍
❤❤❤ Minun Rakkaat Naiset The Best Music T.Finland ❤❤❤
OMG what a beautiful version of Goodbye ❤👍
🤍🕊️
Nossa amigo, me arrepiei todo
You are an artist.
♥️
Estou Apaixonado 🥰
😍
❤So So Amazingly Beautiful ❤
I cried
Que vídeo mais lindo. Parabéns pelo trabalho!! E essa música consegue me fazer chorar mesmo depois de 25 anos. Impressionante!
Amores❤❤❤Bella ❤❤❤Besos ❤❤❤❤
This was perfectly created! From Geri intro, to incorporating her before Victorias verse! I literally shed a tear towards the end, where Victoria was on the screen on SpiceWorld 2019! This was excellent 😢❤
thank you so much!!
I agree❤❤❤
thank you for keep the girls ALIVE!!
Thanks for sharing us this gift.
Beautiful. Just beautiful. THANK YOU, Lipe Hall!
so glad you like it! 🫶🏻🕊️
"Goodbye" is emotional for every Spice Girls' fan. The edits you made and the intro for Geri - perfection. Thank you. Crying. I love this!
Absolutelly amazing
This is amazing. Loved all the details.
Thanks so much! Love your videos!
😍😍
Spice girl 😊❤
You made me get very emotional with this video!!!
🫶🏻🕊️
Amazing 😍 The Geri references literally gave me goosebumps!
😍😍
Meine jugendliche Zeit ❤
Amazing video. Thank you so much for making this. I wish the official Spice Girl team made this much effort. Amazing memories and perfect video of an era
とても素敵な編集であの時のライウ゛行ったな、等も思い出しました。日本ではSPICEGIRLSの
来日公演はありませんでしたので遠征でロンドンやアメリカへライウ゛を体感しに行きました。彼女達の曲はいつまで色褪せない次世代にも愛される曲達ですね。
Siempre maravilloso. Una belleza de video. Como todos.
Gracias! 😊
Geri, you & Melanie B were my heroes in the Spice Girls. I was so heartbroken when you left the Spice Girls in 1998.
In a way, I believe that your departure was a blessing in disguise for the Spice Girls. I know, after sacking Simon Fuller, you girls were all tired.
Forgive us, for being angry when you left the four remaining Spice Girls. We (as fans) didn't know all the shit that you went through, because you & the other four girls sold us the image of strong individual women through Girl Power. And we bought it.
You and the other four were strong women. You girls managed to hide whatever problems you were dealing with at that time.
Only after you left, we found out that Melanie C had some demons too that she had to deal with (😊 depression, eating disorder etc) & Victoria too was rumoured to have some issues about eating disorder etc (But I don't know if they were all true, I don't wanna know). We blamed you for being responsible of the spitting up of the Spice Girls.
No one understand that the Spice Girls needed a break after your (Spice Girls) success in 1996 to 2000. We didn't understand that you & the girls were only human. I still believe after your departure, the other four remaining Spice Girls finally had the chance to sit down & decided to have a break & did the decisions to focus on their individual priorities, you girls only needed to have your own individual time after the phenomenal success that you've achieved. And THANK YOU for reuniting for us in 2007 & 2019. I love you Geri. I love Melanie B & I love the other three (Emma, Melanie C & Victoria) too. Wishing you all the girls. And please consider to do another reunion for us again, at least once. I still need to introduce you girls to my own children. I want them to get to know you lot & they need to listen to your music. You girls have shaped me into the woman I am today, love, Crazy Spice xxx✌️🇬🇧 xxx
I really really love your comment so much
The 4 girls used to be very angry when Geri suddenly left, but actually the band was exhausted and tired after their glory, and they really wanted to be free on their own path (like Geri).
@@damdaung8369 Thank you 💋I have to say I noticed that name of yours in mostly every video that involves the Spice Girls here (in the pasts) in RUclips. I think I know that name of yours, been seeing that particular name here & there before. We might've argued once or twice before about the information about the Spice Girls before.
May I ask, if you're a Vietnamese? Sorry, if my question offend you, I didn't mean any harm. I'm Malaysian btw, my mother's from Leeds, England, she's biracial, just like Melanie B. So in my younger days, I could totally relate to Scary Spice, although I'm only half a quarter black woman.
And I remember during an interview with Morgan Piers (I maybe got the wrong person, or spelt his name wrongly), Geri did say that, she had never apologize to any of the Spice Girl when she left because they were just young, they were nothing to be sorry for.
And I remember reading some nasty comments in RUclips on how Geri was selfish for never apologizing.
But in Spiceworld Tour 2019, that Geri did apologize to the Melanies & Emma for leaving them in 1998.
But we all know now, the reason Geri walked out on them.
Geri deserve an apology from the Spice Girls fans who were so mean to her. They all praise Melanie C, but dissing the others. As a fan, it hurts to see that behavior. The Spice Girls were about a team. Just one Spice Girl is not enough to make her the Spice Girls. They're all about a vibe. Every 5 girl completes each other. They're like 5 different warriors with 5 different specialities in a war field 🇬🇧✌️
@@crazyspice3951 hello, nice to see you again, Crazyspice
Sorry for a long time I didn't talk to you because of my own busy business
You're right about my country, I'm Vietnamese and I'm 33 years old now, maybe you and me has the same age, 😀😀
@@crazyspice3951 and you're right about your last opnion, that "Geri deserve an apology from the Spice Girls fans"
Many fans were so disapointed and angry when Geri left in 1998, But whether Geri left or not, sooner or later Spice Girls would break up , because all members have planned to act in the band in a short time and then separate to go their own way (Mel B confirm that in interview with Larry King in 2014)
So that Geri was NOT the reason why the band break up
and nowaday, Geri always be the most important members of all the reunions of the band (in 2007-2008, 2016, 2019). Although she was the first one leaving the band, but she has been the last one to persuade the girls to come back to keep Spice girls alive until now
So truly that Ginger was the best leader of spice girls, as the girls couldn't reunite without her. Do you think so?
Parabéns LipeHall! Seus videos são verdadeiras homenagens. Esse ficou emocionante demais ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
😍🫶🏻🤍
Epic
🫶🏻
Omg that was such a beautiful video. Love that you put geri in the video as well. Cried the whole time. Thank you again for doing these amazing videos for us 🤗🤗🤗❤️❤️❤️
You are so welcome!
Geri, you destroyed so many childhoods, I know is a Leo thing.
amazing job, i like see posh in the screen on sw2019
❤❤❤❤❤
Those drums are just amazing right? That’s always been my fav version of goodbye. Followed very closely by the reunion I’m 07/08 version. The outro of that is bloody amazing. Great version here. Loved the effort put into it with the story winding throughout. Well done. 👍🏻
Ohhhh 😢 me emocioné demasiado! Spice Girls Forever ❤
Você toca em um lugar onde só que é fã consegue sentir.
Muito obrigado por esse lindo trabalho. Se as próprias pudessem ter esse privilégio de assistir aos seus trabalhos, os últimos “lançamentos” seriam muito mais humanos do que robóticos.
Muito obrigado por existir Lipe ❤️
Que todas as boas energias do Universo abençoe seu talento.
muito obrigado pelas suas palavras e pelo carinho!!
Incrível! Disse tudo! 👏👏
Ya vieron su comparación de holler, las mel dance battle
Simplesmente PERFEITO
🫶🏻✨🤍
Lindo demais.❤❤❤
Lipe, vc se supera 💛
😍🫶🏻 obrigado!
Bellissimo ❤
!!!!!!! W🦋W !!!!!!!!!!!
😢 emotional
This is so fabulous. Another work of art from you!
Thank you very much!
@@LipeHall Also, I have to tell you, I debuted my first solo comedy show the other night and I used your Olympics ‘Spice Up Your Life’ as the exit music for myself and the audience. They loved!
@@ciaransammon😍😍 that’s great!!
Nostalgia ❤️ 1998 Navidad ✌️🌎🥂🇦🇷
a parte mais sensacional ter colocado a VB no telao em Wembley logo depois da parte dela no final da musica! IRADO demais, me fez voltar aos shows da tour TROTSG and SW2019
ahh que legal que gostou!!
This Is so gorgeous and sad at the same time🥺 the intro Is like a Geri death😭
Another masterpiece, the intro gave me the chills! 🫶🏻🥹
❤
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
😍
👏🏻👏🏻♥️♥️👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Gracias por compartir tu talento con otros fanáticos...
🫶🏻✨
I'm Crying
Sempre na expectativa!!! Ele arrasa, forever! ❤
😍😍🫶🏻
Hi from Mexico ❤ 🇲🇽🇲🇽🇲🇽
Thank you for all your wonderful videos, Lipehall.❤
😍😍
wonderful video
Many thanks
Sooooooo good, sooo goood. Thank you so much
You're so welcome! 🤍
wow really nice work
😍😍
Stupenda
🫶🏻✨
MEU DEUS, CHOREI HORRORES! Só faltou ela pedindo perdão no final... DEMAAAAAISSS!!!
Soooo nice
Wow super great work❤ Thank You very much 😊
Thank you! Cheers!
OMG IM BROKEN IN 4:00 BEAUTIFUL 😭❤️
🫶🏻🤍
@@LipeHall❤q😂😊
Hi from italy ❤
Amazing ❤❤❤
😍😍
Amazing!!!! Thanks for sharing with us! :D
🤍🕊️
when this song first came out it really felt like the ending of the spice girls as we knew it.
Hi from Israel ❤
This is the best version of Goodbye I’ve seen so far, this is truly wonderful ❤
Love this
❤
hi im angelee in october 2023 i had 2 grandmas that died it was sad for me when i think of my 2 grandmas i start to cry i miss my 2 grandmas they where in my life so i feel sad its not easy but im trying to stay strong when i cry i love both my grandmas it was hard for me to say good bye to my 2 grandmas
This is really cool! Thank you for this! And you added in all the good parts from like to the alternate versions very well done
Glad you like it! 😍
I love it!! ❤️
Congrats!
😍 thank you!
Love it!!
So glad!
Great job as usual!
Q perfeição. Foi de emocionar e relembrar a adolescência com a saída da Vanish. Foi de arrepiar locais não depilados
I love this video. Great edit. 🖤
Thank you so much!!
Só tem no RUclips pra ouvir? Não tem nenhuma outra plataforma ? SoundCloud por exemplo?
RUclips Music: music.ruclips.net/video/ioCXtTbe3vk/видео.html&si=cD_LbkyJoA_Hgjdm
Ginger Died in 1998 I absolutely love the start of this video
Sporty spice always in my dream.
Emma огонь❤❤❤
very nice! do u offer ur services to work on other artists material?
@@sahithidalgo3165 sure, contact me on instagram
hey LipeHall, when will you do the next video of SGirls?
Miss you so much, we haven't seen you for a long time,