The sad thing about RTD and these activists is on one hand they say things like “haters only exist in small corners of the internet not the real world” and then also say things like “we need to create safe spaces in a world that is intolerant” which is it? You cannot have both.
This whole woke movment is nothing but hypocrisy, how in the same breath one can say toxic masculinity is hurting women while simultaneously defending a man's right to obliterate women in the world of sports and invade their only safe spaces like bathrooms and locker rooms blows my ever loving mind lol
I take exception to the statement Moffat isn't stupid. Whenever he's been posed a perfectly reasonable question about the immense logical holes in his writing he responds with insulting sarcasm, deflection and immense condescension.... but never an answer. He always comes across as insufferably arrogant and pompous.
Being arrogant and pompous isn't the same as being stupid though. Davies and Moffat know what they're doing and it's just that they are targeting an audience that simply isn't there, no matter how desperately they want to pretend that it is, that makes them look stupid. There is a logic behind the madness, even if you can argue that the logic is incredibly flawed.
"They were born, raised, and controlled by the State" And the unintended message they didn't think about... they got left behind the moment it wasn't profitable.
@@zarrothfalse: it was profitable, that’s why Biden sold it to China. One of the very first bills he passed was a semiconductor deal, guess who makes those? Guess who had the material needed to make those? Also something something something the missing Malaysia flight had two of three of the share holders for an Asian company making semiconductors with the last share holder beings Rothschild or maybe it was a Rockerfeller? It was one of those and now we’re forcing electric cars on everyone even though they barely have a 10 shelf life, because replacing the battery cost as much as the car itself.
Another thing that I find interesting is, this is not the first time the doctor has encountered the Anglicans. He called on them in a devil’s run. He worked with them against the weeping angels. He’s encountered and respected them on multiple occasions, and now when he finds that they are literally being manipulated by a third-party, he attacks them. I mean, this is almost not recognizable as the same individual from the doctors daughter.
@@AKUJIVALDOI remember when I was eight, when the show first aired, thinking “babies aren’t stupid enough for this.” Even as a child it was obvious that the bar had been lowered.
Forget watching stuff like that with them…show them better quality stuff to begin with. Like Hilda. Or Bluey. Or Studio Ghibli. Or old Disney. Hey Arnold. As Told by Ginger. My Little Pony: FiM. Avatar. All written, all aesthetically pleasing, all good for media literacy skills. Just saying “cartoons are for kids” is the reason so many adults have crap taste now. Start’em early. If you think the plot or other storytelling elements are poor quality, then it’s not for your child even if it’s harmless in other areas. The only exception would be movies that everyone is currently watching. As long as it’s not wildly inappropriate that’s a great time to watch it with them and…TALK ABOUT IT AFTER. Not enough parents do that and that’s why people can’t understand nuance. Lack of media education is why we have such shallow movies and backlash whenever something intellectually challenging is made.
@@Window4503Sorry to tell you, but later seasons of Bluey have been subverted. Disney used it as a vehicle because they knew it would more likely slip in unnoticed by the parents because they liked earlier seasons.
So basically Reddit. Just questioning why someone felt the need to add an anti-Christian statement where it’s irrelevant to the topic causes them to double down while claiming to have critical thinking or just ignore the callout.
These revelations show two things: Never ever ever let your kids watch something you haven't seen, and Disparu needs to keep making these videos so we can see their values.
Of course, if you are going to pick a religion that demands absolute faith, is rigidly stuck in a medieval past and whose adherants, more than any other's are willing to kill and die for that Faith today, it's not Christians, or Jews, or Hindus or Buddists or Taoists or witches. It's the Faith that must not be named. But these stunning and brave writers would never dare to criticize THAT Faith (even a little), because they don't want to be stabbed in the eye.
Just commented similarly yet slightly less vaguely myself😂swap "thoughts and prayers" for "Allah hu Akbar, Allah hu Akbar, Allah hu Akbar, Allah hu Akbar" - I dare the writers to do that. Can you imagine it? We would soon find out what the phrase 'Religion of Peace' means,
@@nigelbrayshaw2709 I wonder why being Muslim is perfectly fine but Christianity is criticized so heavily I mean I guess because it more embedded in American culture so they feel better about criticizing it?
@@Riseofziggy Because they view Muslims as the oppressed and the Christians as the oppressors. Which is pretty ridiculous, because if you go ANYWHERE in the 56 countries that are officially Muslim, I don't think the Christians will get away with much oppression there... I mean... Quite the contrary the Christians who live in the Middle East or North Africa don't fear oppression... they fear the Allah Hu Akbar treatment that can happen at any moment. ... But yeah seriously, anyone who claims they are fleeing Islam should not be allowed to continue being a Muslim I mean. "I am fleeing Islam, also it is my human right to keep following the Islamic fate in my new country." .... Huh? ... Something smells fishy here, I dunno. Maybe people who wish to invade tend to lie, I dunno.
You are more of a journalist than any journalist around these days. Your ability to just find the crazy things that these people say and put in power point presentations is next level. You deserve a medal for having the patience to read through that stuff.
Children were always a fertile ground for new ideologies. They can be easily brainwashed. Nazi Germany did that. Soviet Union did that. BBC/Disney is doing it right now. Different methods, the same goal (more people following their ideology).
The whole "Activist" meaning atleast the modern evolution of term is strongly linked to narcissism. It's people who dont have any qualities or abilities that they can take pride in so they have manifest something and call them selves activist. The same way "Brave" used to mean selfness and courage and potential sacrifice now its means accepting yourself and telling ppl to accept you.
@@dking1836 and let's not forget his companion throwing her preferences in everyone's face every episode, even though it didn't have anything to do with anything. Yah, great stuff there! Capaldi is a great actor, but he got hoodwinked when he took that role.
I'm half Scottish. A Rwandan in a kilt is cultural appropriation and I'm going to whine to the Beeb about it worse than than the whiniest blue-haired whiner.
My Mum was Scottish and a Dr Who fan from the Hartnell era onwards. I was named after Jamie McCrimmin. She loved that there was a traditional Scotsman in the show. Surely under these new "rules" they're playing by anyone but a Scotsman in a kilt is cultural appropriation.
Fun fact: when doctor who started in 1963 it was originally intended to be educational about history. But the audience preferred the sci-fi aspect of the show, so they reworked the show. If only they still listen to the people today
I doubt too many people were requesting the emperor to come back. Or for him to die as he did....but I do know many people who shipped the Reylo thing.@@videogamesworld01
It’s an empty virtue much like faith or empathy or unity. They all only matter depending on their object, not in and of themselves. Progress only matters in terms of the object it progresses toward, faith only depending on who you believe in, etc.
C.S. Lewis: "We all want progress, but if you're on the wrong road, progress means doing an about-turn and walking back to the right road; in that case, the man who turns back soonest is the most progressive."
“Power is in tearing human minds to pieces and putting them together again in new shapes of your own choosing.” ― George Orwell, 1984 1984 is a cautionary tale, BBC its not an instruction manual!
RTD thinks sending "thoughts and prayers" is pointless and you should send money and shut up if you're poor? Russell I'm not religious but if someone who is prays for me , that's BEAUTIFUL. Is there anything inside this guy? Other than Ncuti obviously .
@@JohnKobaRuddyExactly. It would be different if people just offered up a prayer on the spot but anyone can say the phrase. Some people also think prayer is just sending out feelings to that person or the universe, not actually petitioning God. More like wishes than prayers.
@@JohnKobaRuddy I can't speak for everyone obviously, but when I say that I'll pray for someone, I mean it. I have a friend who is going through some very difficult times, things that I can't help her with no matter how much I'd like to. We don't live close to each other. So the best I can do is let her tell me about her troubles and pray for her to get through them.
Being as one of the first lines uttered by this travesty of the character was "I've just been snowflaked" I think it's far more likely that RTD has been inside Ncuti Gatwa!
As time passes, I'm increasingly of the belief I was utterly wrong to dismiss concerns raised by the religious right 10-20 years back. I simply didn't believe this is where we'd end up.
I’ve never been religious at all and I’m 29 now, but after seeing the devil in literally everything in our world I’ve started to pray to god, especially for my daughter. And am trying to shake off the way I grew up and approach ’god’ with a more mature mindset. If I have a choice between the devil and god, I know which path I’m choosing. And if it somehow helps us as a people, then I’m all for it 😂👌
Exactly. People of faith give their own money to help others. Activist want the government to forcefully take money from people and redistribute it. They rarely ever voluntarily give their own money to help others.
Religious people far more frequently supply both funds and physical help to those in need, such as victims of crimes or natural disasters, than any other demographic. Churches will house displaced populations or those in need of temporary shelter, churches and religious neighborhoods will band together to help a neighbor or congregation member for free, these same groups regularly hold potlucks and other related events for entire communities. This rhetoric that traditional religious people don’t help others is just a bald faced, mean spirited lie. Even historically, _all charities used to be religious enterprises._ That only changed once Western governments chose to take control-and they’ve been doing a far worse job.
Reminds me of the sight that made realise this as a kid. Saw a woman pestering her teenage son for some change. He forked it over and she then took a selfie of herself mock giving it to an annoyed homeless man. I don't who that bint was but years later just thinking about her still boils my blood.
Doctor Who Review of Season 1 Episode 3 "Boom" confused me. Between the BBC, Disney and Russel T Davies how did Stephen Moffat come out with an episode that made so little sense? It had directly contradictory messages, but only from my point of view. When you're attacking faith while also saying it's necessary, it seemed strange to me, so it was time to try and work out what they meant by it. Was it that some types of faith are good, while religious faith is bad? Is it just that previous beliefs are bad but new modern ever changing beliefs are great? Do these ideas tie into the rest of the series? What do you think? Let me know your thoughts down below and as always, thanks for watching :)
Super ironic that the people who do nothing but parrot buzzwords they've heard other people say, refer to faith as "the magic word that keeps you never having to think for yourself." Doubly so when you realize just how many words keep them from thinking at all, which is to say most of them 🤣
What I'm understanding from this is more about not placing your "faith" in religion and only have faith in themselves and people they can look up to. The fact that Moffat is trying to tell children "hey kids don't believe in religion as it never does anything to help you believe in yourself and your role models" only proves to me that there's going to a mass exodus/persecution against anyone and everyone who doesn't agree with his set of ideals. Heck this is happening in the video gaming sphere already.
Faith doesn't keep you from thinking though! People have had faith that the sun will rise everyday when it sets. That hasn't changed since it was found that the world is round, we orbit around a sun and it could be day on one part of the world and night in the other. Anyone telling people with faith not to believe in is trying to sell you something.
@Disparu I don’t mean to sound like I’m blowing smoke up your trousers but I genuinely think that this is the best and most insightful video you’ve ever done and I’ve been a viewer since ROP. Thank you for shining a spotlight and explaining just how insidious this ‘kids’ show really is. I’m so relieved that my two sons checked out of Doctor Who after the atrocious specials. Thanks again. From a parent and from a long-term Doctor Who fan 👏
Once they finally kill the BBC license fee, I hope that tv will get better. If the only way TV companies can make money is by getting views, they will be forced to make tv shows people actually want to watch.
Strongly disagree, it deserves a cast and crew that care about the characters, history, lore, continuity…they need to come across the VR machine keeping someone alive playing the “I’m the Doctor” game that we’ve seen the last several years…wake them, let them become the new companion and learn who & what the Doctor really is.
@@jimmyfrench4722 Or it’s like that episode with “the dream master” and Capaldi is just in a coma on the floor of the tardis? Also they could fix Star Trek by having the time police go back and kill Burnham’s mother, immediately restoring the timeline.
They should change the Tardis to a public toilet and put a disco ball in it. What's next weeks episode ( The Glory Hole Of Doom ) I have no idea who's watching this to be honest.
The biggest donors to disaster relief and charity funds are religious households. Charity disaster relief organizations are often out rebuilding houses after disasters long before any government organization has started moving resources toward it. I'm not religious and have other issues with how institutional religions are run, but they are consistently good at doing charitable work.
The point is having the Dr be sceptical of religious faith makes sense, but having him target it childishly and having a completely different view a moment later is bizarre. I am a religious person but I take no exception to the fact that people disagree with me (As long as they don't try to actively hurt me financially or physically). The idea that you can decide what you believe based on your experiences and influences should be just basic. I have found some people who absolutely think I am completely wrong, religiously and politically but are still my allies in other areas like moral questions or on the idea of hard work or national pride. It seems so odd that there are those who have very liberal ideas in many areas do not want to be along side those who do not have all the same values but do in some areas. Indeed they would help engage and change minds more if they were more tolerant to those they consider in need of reform.
@@Trisjack20 I was responding more to Moffat's point about thoughts and prayers than the episode itself, but yeah there's certainly something to be criticized about replacing critical thinking with faith. The idea of capitalists preying on the faithful could be done well, in real life that's what megachurches are doing. However that's a completely different message than just "religion bad," which seems to have been the message of the episode.
As a lifelong Christian, I have been actively encouraged to question why I believe what I believe by my religious teachers, because they had faith that their teachings would both hold up under scrutiny and be all the stronger for it. C. S. Lewis was famously converted when he aggressively studied Christianity in an attempt to debunk it. We are not called to blind faith, but a trusting faith. The kind of faith that takes the hero's hand as he leads you through certain doom safely. He knows what he's doing, even if it looks scary and hopeless.
Right? I've always been told, my whole life as a Christian, to seek out answers for myself. Discover for myself the truths of the Gospel. I've never been told to follow just to follow. I think a lot of people don't understand that about religious folks. Some go with the flow sure, but maybe, JUST MAYBE, some of us believe in it BECAUSE we've studied it.
That's because our faith is true. No faith other than ours encourages thinking. First scribes were Christians, science is based on the foundation of the intelligent design (for if it were only chaos, then there would be no rules to discover). The development that we've seen occurred under Christian culture. Now, by contrast? Science smacked against a wall and our society has regressed as well.
You know there's a book series in relation to this that always highly amuses me. Phillip Pullman's "His Dark Materials." also known as "The Golden Compass." Which is an excellent book series that COMPLETELY fails their stated mission. According to Pullman himself, what he wished to do was criticize the works of C.S. Lewis and tear down Christianity but... All his books ever do, is tearing at the power institution that is the church, not Christianity itself. While C.S. Lewis never talked about any churches in his books anyway, but only the core principles of Christianity that Pullman obviously couldn't debunk. I mean heck, even within his own book, the big anti C.S. Lewis anti-Christian book... He STILL acknowledges souls, an afterlife and even a higher being... In a very roundabout way he ends up affirming Christianity and the only thing he tears down at is the human created Church. And well... Even Jesus criticized the Church! He had a fit of rage in there because they turned a house of prayer into a den of gambling. And the big message, in the bible itself, is that the church is still run by humans, and humans are very flawed so the church can absolutely become corrupted. What can't become corrupted is the word of god spoken by Jesus. So yeah... Pullman... You acknowledged the church when turned into an institution of power can become extremely corrupt... Good job... I don't think C.S. Lewis ever disagreed with you on that... Which is why he wasn't a Christian at first, but as he consumed the true word of god and found the true meaning of it, THAT is what he put into his books that you can't debunk.
@@Wendeta-hq2cp literally nothing you said is true or even true if you don't think about it. What do you mean your faith encourages thinking? It's literally "Read the book, pray exactly this many times at this time, don't do x, y and z, go to church every Sunday. It's a book full of rules, no free thinking. Believing there's another god is sinful, not praying is sinful. You and the other idiot who believes In god literally said "We are Christians because we thought about it" are you assuming atheists never thought about it? You are aware of the ol' contradiction of your god literally made me, knew what I am going to do and why I think the way I think and therefore has directly forced me into a hell of his own creation? Like jesus Christ are you going to tell me I deserve pain and suffering for the rest of my existence because I like to pleasure myself? Or not talk to a man who has literally killed the earth a few times, who has created fallible beings and yet lacks the knowledge or willingness to correct us? He's a fucking idiot, would be fired at any job and divorced by any woman. He raped an innocent woman to give birth to his son, which is him, to then kill himself, of which is his own design, by people who hate his religion, the only religious that should be spread and yet we have never had him spread it more than once, who then should have forgiven the sins of our fathers, aka the fallible people he created but continues to punish people regardless. Like my brain is going to explode with the amount of crap that no self respecting person should believe but yet do. Spread your peace and love, but not in that egotistical assholes name. Science isn't based off of religion or his design, science is a way of finding something out, nothing more than a tool to find answers, not a belief or a worldview. Dunno where you got the first scribes are Christians bs from, there has been literal gods before yours that you just don't believe in. Civilisation that we occupy is barely influenced by religion other than cathedral placement, and wasn't even the beginning of society, the Romans and Greeks did it whilst believing in other gods that you would laugh at, which is exactly what I would do to you if it wasn't so sad. Society could be seen as regression, or maybe we just hit our peak? Or focus on things that aren't there to advance our society. We are currently in a golden age of wealth, health and prosperity, none of which is because of god, especially with the rising number of atheists. You'll find that a lot of poor people or those without skills love god because they need him to be real to keep their lives together, whilst the happiest of us just simply ignore him and make our lives, our only lives bette.r
I never comment on RUclips videos but I needed to say how good this video is. I really hope that it gets seen by a lot of people. You have articulately and brilliantly explained how Doctor Who has become something nasty and how they have our children in their sights. As a Christian myself, maybe I’m feeling this more on a personal level but your video has shown me that I’m having a perfectly valid reaction to it all. Thank you for a great video and keep up the good work!
I cannot believe these people are so delusional. The show runner really said “for every viewer we lose because of our trans/gay messaging we will gain 2-3 more viewers from those who agree with us”. Uhhh is someone gonna tell them???
They live in delusional bubble, where they have affirmations of other wokies...and they think all world is like their bubble...despite scores of fails in entertainment industry.
Well, that just makes no sense, everyone at their dinner parties agrees with them. The idea that more than 90% of the population wouldn't agree? Simply absurd dahling! Goldfish cannot conceive of a world beyond their fishtank.
Anyone remember.. I think it was called "The Curse of Fenric" or something like that, with Sylvester McCoy's Doctor, where The Doctor extolled the virtues of faith in driving away evil?
I remember The Curse of Fenric and that Sylvester McCoy's Doctor defeated the evil by extolling the virtues of faith however I kinda remember the story mainly due to the Haemovores because how creepy they were as well as that they looked like something out of an Lovecraft story.
You totally nailed it. This should be required viewing, because you identified the underlying strategy of all that's going on in the entertainment, gaming, and comics industry, as well as education and politics.
Disparu, I love your videos. I really enjoy the format of your videos, your voice is not annoying, your takes on things going on in the world. Just thanks for making these videos. I hope you actually make a profit from this. Have a good day man.
Consider the problem is that while Moffat may have been a somewhat decent writer in the past, he's not anymore and his fall off has been recorded in the abysmal things he did before handing over the series to Chibnall, so yeah this is bad writing on its own - evil bad writing but still bad writing.
The more activist-minded he got the worse he became. I mean seriously look at his early works, his great works. With Blink and Silence of the Library... no activism. I personally really liked "Jekyll." as well, and it's just a thriller. If anything it has a message about love and family at the end. The one thing Hyde ends up caring about is his family, people who make him feel loved. And he'll die to protect them even when he really feared death before because he had the mind of a child. Then we arrive at Dracula where he wanted a woman hellsing to be a strong independent wahmen who is the ultimate foil of Dracula cause she's so much better and smarter than him, Also Christianity dumb, also Jonathan Harker is my bride because breaking gender stereotypes... siiigh, it's all so tiresome isn't it?
@@Jackson-ub1uv No I'm more pointing out things like Bill, the entire Clara plot they're redoing next season btw and the destruction of the First Doctor
@@UncensoredScion Bill and Clara were fine, and the First Doctor wasn't "destroyed". The First Doctor was portrayed like that because he was purposefully trying to embarrass Twelve. There was nothing wrong with Bill, and Clara was _very_ good at being the Doctor's equal in terms of stubbornness, cunning, manipulation, and recklessness. We also have no confirmation that the next companion is going to be another Clara; you _do_ realise that it could just be another Donna situation, right? The Doctor has already stated that he'll be checking in on Mundy, so it's more than likely that _that_ will be how she becomes the next companion.
@@Jackson-ub1uv Yes they were And he was portrayed as a misogynist, thus destroying his legacy. I'll never get tired of saying this to stupid people Bill was only there for representation purposes she was a poor-quality Rose photocopy. THE COMPANION SHOULD NOT BE EQUAL TO THE DOCTOR AT ANY POINT THE COMPANION IS THE AUDIENCE POV AND MAKING A COMPANION EQUAL TO THE DOCTOR MAKES THAT IMPOSSIBLE. I hope that me having to allcaps that section to get across the level of stupid you are for saying that about Clara helps. We can't have a POV if a character is equal to the hero character you freaking idiot. Yes we do, last week the Priest woman was said BY MOFFAT that she was the next companion and that they're doing the Clara story again. You want to suck off Moffatt, you go right ahead and do it but don't lie. You make yourself look less like a hore and more like a blind idiot when doing that when you lie.
@@JohnKobaRuddyIt's fascinating how western leftists love Muslims and Palestine despite the fact that they are viewed as degenerate decadent heathens by most of them. Read Quran. Everything is there.
Gatwa's acting in doctor who is the exact same as in Sex Education.He didnt even bother bringing Something new to the table.If you pretend doctor who is Sex Education presents :Eric Effiong bizzare adventures than the actual show would make more sense 😂😂😂😂
Compared to Matt Smith who was younger than Ncuti Gatwa when he joined Doctor Who, but managed to pull off the most mature Doctor yet! I miss his version of the Doctor. 😢
One of your best breakdowns. As a parent, it pains me that we now live in a world wherein corporations seem like they are hellbent on going after kids and pulling them away from family values.
I haven’t heard a single person ask why Christianity was chosen to be ‘the faith’ in this episode, rather than Islam. Peaceful, harmless and a forgiving target I guess? If Muslims were the soldiers, the show would have been instantly cancelled and a Fatwa pinned to RTD and Moffat’s heads.
As a Christian, it's always been that way. I had a bunch of classmates once gather around me and chant "get out of our school" at me because I admitted to being Christian, and that was more than 10 years ago. The teacher when he came back in the room was suitably horrified, but nothing ever came of it. ANY OTHER RELIGION ON EARTH and it would have resulted in legal problems, expulsions, etc. Not with Christianity. Weird, huh?
@@deadworld953 there are studies that claim Christianity is the most persecuted religion on Earth today. I mentioned this some months ago on a thread and by God, regretted it after the hatred that was spewed my way! Seems the general consensus is ‘they deserve to be”.
When I was a teenager I thought the whole "thoughts and prayers" thing was so stuuupid... then I grew up and I realized that a lot of people who say this kind of thing comes from a place of "I want to do something but I'm not in a position where I can personally" and I think that's beautiful. Belief in God or not, the sentiment is deeply human and kind. Assuming that all who say this are using it as an excuse to dismiss people in need, is such a negative interpretation and really shows how many believe that human beings are evil by nature...
As if giving money would ease the pain of having lost someone... These MF's are entirely mental. It actually reminds me of a scene from The IT Crowd (Season 2 Episode 2, around the 12 minute mark), at the funeral of Denholm Reynholm (of Reynhom Industries), where Jen tells Roy to just say "sorry for your loss, and then move on", as in: say that and then walk away. In this scene both Roy and (Maurice) Moss offer condolences to the widow: Roy: Sorry for your loss Roy: move on Widow: ... ... Moss: Sorry for your loss Moss: It's not like you lost a pen, is it? It's so much worse. Moss & Widow: ... Moss: Would you like a pen? [takes out a pen and offers it to the widow] Widow: ... Widow: ... Moss: please take the pen... Widow: half in shock over the absurdness of it, reluctantly accepts the pen
Holy hell, this is one of the best analysis videos you’ve done in a long time. I like your work usually, but this just absolutely knocked it out of the park.
@@NoPowerintheVerse google thinks he was saying something in Kinyarwanda. I can't say if the translation itself is accurate but the individual words do seem to give a similar meaning to little friend
Great Mate, succinctly put in such a humourous way. Forget everyone that tries to dis you, they are just envious of your brains....it must be so difficult coming up with theses videos. Keep doing what you're doing it's so good
"When I finish a book on kindle the algorithm recommends another" Relying on an algorithm to tell what to read. Thats the very definition of not thinking for yourself.
100% agree with children accepting what ppl of importance say as the truth and not questioning it. When I was 30, I was sat watching Return of the Jedi and noticed yoda died. I was shocked. I had seen the film hundreds of times and had always thought yoda hibernated for 900 hundred years and was going to come back at some point. My father pissed himself laughing. He had told this story of "hibernation" to stop me crying as a small child when I first watched it. Believed it for years.
Never had a problem with the Yoda scene, but my Parents would never take us to see Bambi because they didn't want to deal with the potential crying so they just skipped it everytime it was out in theaters. The good thing is my parents didn't lie about death, but they did try to limit our exposure to it if possible.
Children are taught from young that vaccines are safe and effective. They are also taught that the earth is a spinning globe that supposedly revolves around the sun.
He cast an 18 year old Charlie Hunnam as a 15 year old in the first season of QaF because he didn't want a teenage actor's parents objecting to what he had that character do.
Look at episode 1 of Queer ad Folk. He is literally a child sex advocate. He portrays men having sex with boys as normal, fun, and actually wanted and beneficial by the 15 yo boy. A normal part of gay culture. rtd is a pedo like many gay rights activists of his era, including peter tatchell
It's not 2+ million viewers, it's 2+ million people who watched for 30 seconds. Like a RUclips view. You leave the TV on, goes to the next program, you start looking for something else but leave it in the background for a minute or 2. Now you're a viewer!
Hmm another wrong un from a copration of wrong uns. Funnily enough I think I have a idea for a show the BBC could produce its called "whats on my laptop" where we pick 3 random bbc employees and search there computers/ laptops for illegal and compromising material then see who will get the most jail time if exposed. It could be a big success the public would love it and the wealth of talent available at the BBC is almost limitless.
So, it's a kind of good old, family friendly tale of inculcation/gr00ming? Get to them while they're still young and malleable. You'd think the BBC would have learnt their lesson about this stuff. -This is by far the best breakdown of this episide I've watched, and Ive watched a few. You nailed their ideology perfectly.
Faith cannot exist without doubt. Faith is belief in the face of doubt and questioning. If there was no doubt, it would be a fact. Idiots can't, don't want to, understand Faith.
@@Alexander_Kale I wasn't arguing the positive or negative, just describing what faith involves. Anything taken to an extreme can be bad. But it depends what you have faith in, if you put your faith in something worthy, then I doubt you will have a problem with "evidence".
@@Sadovari Faith is always something worthy, that is the problem. Why would anyone put their faith in anything they consider unworthy? And of course, anyone who does not share your faith is necessarily doing it wrong. That's why vegans tend to be militant. That's why different religions tend to hate one another. That's why wars between brothers are the bloodiest and nastiest you can imagine.
@@Alexander_KaleA man more intelligent than me once said: "Faith needs the intellect to stay grounded, but the intellect needs faith to keep it humble." You're not wrong in your criticisms of Faith, but that does not mean it doesn't have it's place. It is difficult to find the right balance, though, like most things
@@Stormmblade I fail to see how this is reflective of reality. One aspect of intelligence is critical thinking. Faith, rather implicitely, is the believe in a thing in the absencee of evidence and sometimes in the presence of evidence to the contrary. Thus, if you apply critical thinking to your religion, it will inevitably start falling apart. On the other hand, being humble does not require religion either, because there are multiple other sources for that.
I think I’ve figured out what the problem is. Or at least what the difference is in the old episodes the doctor had faith (no pun intended) in humanity and when in a problem he would help guide them to a solution helping them learn along the way. The new doctor has a disdain for “some humans” (we all know which ones) and he yells at them like its a lecture
You're forgetting episodes like Midnight and The Beast Below where the Doctor completely lost faith in humanity. As with this Doctor, the loss in faith of humanity is and was only temporary. You're making up a non-existent difference, in my opinion.
4:29 This is true, but I think to a degree "thoughts and prayers" has been overused to the point where people just dismiss it out of hand. They don't see it as an admission of compassion. They want immediate solutions (which they can't have) so they just dismiss it as cynical.
There was a debate in my country some years back with some people taking offence to "my condolences" because they said it had been overused and lost its meaning. I personally think it's a good phrase to have when you don't know what else to say but you want to express sympathy to someone in a sad situation. I understand people in the US get fed up with constant "thoughts and prayers" from politicians after something like a shooting instead of them *actually* trying to fix the issue, but surely that's more on those politicians than the phrase?
Don't know why my comment keeps getting removed. I'm not even saying anything bad. Guess you can just do whatever you want when you have a monopoly on the internet.
Remember when Matt Smith met the Anglican Marines that were using his wife to help them and he lectured them on their beliefs? No, he didn't. When Moffat was the showrunner. And algorithims could use a bit of work. Like someone said "I hate that the Amazon algorithim thinks my purchase of 1 air purifier meant I wanted to build a vast, air purifying, empire!".😁
It’s fine to be in the show, because trans people do actually exist. But ideally it would be statistically accurate, and trans characters would be 1% of the characters at the most. Gay characters would only be 5% at the most. Representation that is accurate to the time period and location is fine. Shoehorning modern diversity into every time and place is fucking stupid though.
I think its more the forceful push on representation. I'm all for whoever doing whatever, but don't destroy the culture around specific franchises with -"agree or you're a bigot"- overtones. Surely this just ends up hurting the reputation of those you're trying to represent and the beloved franchises in the process. I thought that umbrella academy did it well. The change didn't affect the overall story or franchise, allowing the viewer to just go with it and still have a good experience watching.
I don't think it's a case of it doesn't belong but it needs to be done by someone who doesn't unquestionably believe anyone about anything they say. I feel a more doctor who like story would be a planet where it's at its logical extreme where all residents are paired up by a system and have their gender changed to make the best offspring with the message being at the end that while some were feeling better in their new gender for some they were regretful and wanted to go back but could not anymore. Im not a writer but I feel that is a better starting point for a story that can tackle an issue about trans people in a way that isn't like a scale being weighted to guarantee one side the preference
@@glawenclattuc3127There are many - including me- who do not believe transgenderism exists. Transgenderism is based on the idea of ‘gender’ and of ‘gender identities’ which everybody is apparently born with that can’t be measured or detected and constantly give the person an expectation of which pronouns they need to hear. Gender identity was made by John Money who oversaw the raising of a castrated boy as a girl. He believed it was a six sea but both twins later killed themselves. I don’t believe there are gender identities that demand each person wears pants or skirts . There is only biological sex.
Scientology is a proven cult and has contributed nothing to human welfare much less moral morality. Abuse is built into its system by putting all spiritual ability onto the believer. That actually does deserve contempt and mockery.
Disparu you really do exceptional work getting to the roots of a lot of the vapid commentary that modern “writers” think they’re sneaking in to these properties. Fantastic analysis as always.
It's like setting fire to the house you are living in, telling the Fire Department to F-Off and then complaining that nobody is putting out the fire! If nobody watches your show, there will be no money to make the next one, and in this case, that's a good thing!
These episodes of doctor who are the left's parables. The Bible has the parable of the mustard seed, RTD has the parable of the space babies. The Bible has the parable of the lost coin, RTD has the parable of the Devil's chord. The Bible has the parable of the unforgiving servant, RTD has the parable of Boom. Each episode isn't simply a simple episode of TV and shouldn’t be treated like one. They should be treated like what they are: religious propaganda of the left. Space babies is a parable about abortion, how children are the future, but also (since they never grow up btu run the ship) a subtle slash at the future, saying that the future, while competent, will be childish and create their own problems which they will be unable to solve without a multiple box-checking immigrant to solve. It’s essentially the crystallisation of the left’s views on immigration: only they can solve us squabbling children who made our catastrophic problems due to our state and our own childish ignorance. The Devil’s Chord is a parable about not only music, but about how loss of control over that music will result in destruction of the future. However, music int this episode refers to power. Music is, in a way, propaganda. I admit the messaging here is a little muddled, seeing as how it implies that giving power to trans people will destroy the future… I’m not quite sure how to reconcile that with RTD’s bias and I think I’m missing something, though I admit I haven’t watched this dreck so I might have missed or simply be unaware of something. Boom is a parable about how faith in the PAST (religion) which bonded and formed society (and, when taken with Space Babies, will create a destroyed world of infants who cause their own deadly problems they can’t solve) is evil and foolish to believe. Btu that doesn’t mean that Boom is implying that faith itself is bad. Indeed, as a religious text, boom is very much in favour of faith, just THE RIGHT KIND of faith. Faith in their beliefs. That’s why the doctor says that faith is bad but necessary. This is a very bastardised (and warped in an attempt to hide the true meaning) version of ‘faith in the past is bad but faith in general binds us and is necessary. Therefore, you need to have the right belief; the one WE tell you to have, the one which will steer us away from Space Babies’ future, where ‘the future is knackered’. The reason most (other than Disparu) missed this is because it is simply foreign to them: those like Nerdrotic (no shame no shame to him; I’ve been a sub to him for years) simply don’t think to look for messages in this way. Everyone’s been primed to look for overt messages like Endgame’s girlpower moment, but few are trained to look for covert messaging and parables. It’s understandable, because their channels are about entertainment and not religion or English Analysis, and that’s how they get you. Fortunately, noone’s watching this. Imagine of this covert messaging was actually popular. The flaw with RTD’s plan is twofold: firstly, he lives in an echo chamber so doesn’t realise that the people he sees as sheep are actually very, very primed against any messaging and secondly, his work simply isn’t entertaining. He’s writing from money, as opposed to entertainment. A lot of his other episodes have messaging. Midnight is about groupthink and the effects of stress on groups and how social bonds can become strained in stressful scenarios. The doctor’s daughter is about a fake war. It’s very similar to the base plot of boom, except more well thought out. Amy’s choice is about love vs friendship. The End of the world is about what makes us human and about cosmetic surgery and the fear of our legacy dying (earth is destroyed and no one watches). One could argue aliens in london is about illegal immigrants deliberately destroying the country (though that’s a stretch). Dalek is about capital punishment, a conversation that is conveniently sidestepped by RTD’s desire to have the Dalek commit suicide. The Long game is about the effects of the media in controlling our lives. Father’s day is about guilt and loss. The Doctor dances is about single motherhood and the importance of reconciling with your past indiscretions. Practically every episode of RTD’s doctor who has messaging. The difference is that he had talent back then. He knew how to rein in his desires, his messaging. He knew he wasn’t in an echo chamber and so he had to hide his true messaging within entertainment. That’s what he’s missing. Living in an echo chamber is effectively isolation. It prevents you from seeing others’ opinions and so you can’t see how others think. You can’t see just how alone you are in your beliefs. But RTD’s delusion is our boon. His isolation acts as a signal to others to ignore his work. It destroys his legacy and, more importantly, convinces everyone not to watch the insidious dreck he creates.
Disparu, my deer friend, you have outdone yourself. This was a master piece!
5 месяцев назад+6
"Painting people who believe to be a bunch of sheep blindly following their belief." is the message this show wanted to send.... A message that describes the woke perfectly. They self owned.
The first episode had a preteen boy in a school uniform saying "thats my daddy" to a grown man dressed like a Brazilian carnival. Knowing the people that made this and what their agenda is, this might be the most disgusting thing I've seen for a long time.
Stupid the kid called them his daddy cause he was created from that character. Like like the character call the toymaker, their father and daddy cause they are the toymaker child. Wtf is wrong with u? The fact u saw that seen and think about it in a sexual way, shows that u are the issue and a pedo
5 месяцев назад
Don't forget later that same freak sucks off a violin bow while moaning.
I really don't think so, they are relying on Disney money for this, and well... Disney itself is flailing so Disney cannot afford expensive shows that has no viewers and... how many are watching on Disney+ ??? That's the big question, do they get enough new subscribers to justify the cost? Doubtful! People are STILL cancelling their Disney+ subscriptions because... A: Nothing good on there. B: people are penny pinching, we're all in the same recession!
@@Rendell001 Season 2 is already filmed. Potential cancellation will happend after Season 2 or 3 (RTD is already writing S3 but Disney is silent about paying for it again).
"A man who doesn't have any kids showing too much interest in them." That's why Disney hired him.
umm.
You nailed it!
Thank God Davies has no kids....
Pdf files all around the place
Disney also hired Brian Peck but let him go after fans complained.
When I first found Disparu reviewing RoP, I never thought he'd turn out to be one of the most insightful reviewers on RUclips.
I found him looking for WoT reviews and have been engaged even since. Agree with you!
He didn't turn out that way.
@jasonthewatchmansson8873
why are you here?
@@jasonthewatchmansson8873 Always was, eh?
You are spot on!
The sad thing about RTD and these activists is on one hand they say things like “haters only exist in small corners of the internet not the real world” and then also say things like “we need to create safe spaces in a world that is intolerant” which is it? You cannot have both.
They have no objective morality, yes they will have it both ways. The Cause is everything, the communist end justifies the hypocritical means.
But they _want it_ to be both. They're both the new norm _and_ the brave pioneers (whichever looks more fabulosa at the time).
Sadly happening with so many groups/types of activists at this point too. LGBT+, feminist, various stripes of racial activists, list goes on.
This whole woke movment is nothing but hypocrisy, how in the same breath one can say toxic masculinity is hurting women while simultaneously defending a man's right to obliterate women in the world of sports and invade their only safe spaces like bathrooms and locker rooms blows my ever loving mind lol
@@harbl99victim and victorious at the same time, forever.
I take exception to the statement Moffat isn't stupid. Whenever he's been posed a perfectly reasonable question about the immense logical holes in his writing he responds with insulting sarcasm, deflection and immense condescension.... but never an answer. He always comes across as insufferably arrogant and pompous.
He’s why I stopped watching during Matt Smith’s run. Matt Smith did a fine job imo given what he was handed but Moffat’s writing was abysmal.
@@surlyunicorn9461 Same. I initially thought Matt Smith was poor, but quickly realised he was given lousy material to work with.
Sounds like the average politician, most of the notable CEOs, and activist types in general at this point tbh.
He's an elitist. He's now teaching the "little people" the right way to live.
Being arrogant and pompous isn't the same as being stupid though. Davies and Moffat know what they're doing and it's just that they are targeting an audience that simply isn't there, no matter how desperately they want to pretend that it is, that makes them look stupid. There is a logic behind the madness, even if you can argue that the logic is incredibly flawed.
"They were born, raised, and controlled by the State"
And the unintended message they didn't think about... they got left behind the moment it wasn't profitable.
The state has no loyalty.
Corporations have no loyalty.
sorta like Afghanistan.
These shows are made by COMMUNISTS. Think about this!
@@zarrothfalse: it was profitable, that’s why Biden sold it to China. One of the very first bills he passed was a semiconductor deal, guess who makes those? Guess who had the material needed to make those? Also something something something the missing Malaysia flight had two of three of the share holders for an Asian company making semiconductors with the last share holder beings Rothschild or maybe it was a Rockerfeller? It was one of those and now we’re forcing electric cars on everyone even though they barely have a 10 shelf life, because replacing the battery cost as much as the car itself.
And the profit has peaked it's just the descent now step back and let it happen
Another thing that I find interesting is, this is not the first time the doctor has encountered the Anglicans. He called on them in a devil’s run. He worked with them against the weeping angels. He’s encountered and respected them on multiple occasions, and now when he finds that they are literally being manipulated by a third-party, he attacks them.
I mean, this is almost not recognizable as the same individual from the doctors daughter.
The truth is we can no longer leave the kids alone with Disney or the BBC
You couldn't do that when Teletubies or whatever that shite was called started...
You never could.
@@AKUJIVALDOI remember when I was eight, when the show first aired, thinking “babies aren’t stupid enough for this.” Even as a child it was obvious that the bar had been lowered.
Forget watching stuff like that with them…show them better quality stuff to begin with. Like Hilda. Or Bluey. Or Studio Ghibli. Or old Disney. Hey Arnold. As Told by Ginger. My Little Pony: FiM. Avatar. All written, all aesthetically pleasing, all good for media literacy skills. Just saying “cartoons are for kids” is the reason so many adults have crap taste now. Start’em early. If you think the plot or other storytelling elements are poor quality, then it’s not for your child even if it’s harmless in other areas. The only exception would be movies that everyone is currently watching. As long as it’s not wildly inappropriate that’s a great time to watch it with them and…TALK ABOUT IT AFTER. Not enough parents do that and that’s why people can’t understand nuance. Lack of media education is why we have such shallow movies and backlash whenever something intellectually challenging is made.
@@Window4503Sorry to tell you, but later seasons of Bluey have been subverted. Disney used it as a vehicle because they knew it would more likely slip in unnoticed by the parents because they liked earlier seasons.
"Destroy the past. Kill it if you have to" a quote in the last jedi that sums all this up/
I can only assume at this point that iconoclasm is a mortal sin.
Moffat talking about how reinforcing prejudices is bad while actively making an episode prejudiced against religious people.
He is just reinforcing his point😂
A bit like saying how bad it is to associate disability with evil and then has a person of queer culture as a villain moaning about their pronouns.
I’d dare him to make an episode like this geared more towards the “religion of peace” if I didn’t know that he’s a coward already
only christians and catholics though, he won't dare criticize those other guys
So basically Reddit. Just questioning why someone felt the need to add an anti-Christian statement where it’s irrelevant to the topic causes them to double down while claiming to have critical thinking or just ignore the callout.
"Blindly follow the values of THIS authority figure, but not THAT one. The one with the purple hair."
This theme seems familiar. 🤔
It should. Its the basis of every religious squabble ever.
It's creepy how they're targeting our kids.
It’s beyond creepy. Its demonic
It's been happening for decades 😢
Creepy and absolutely intentional
You don't have kids
@@videogamesworld01 I think you're talking about yourself.
These revelations show two things:
Never ever ever let your kids watch something you haven't seen,
and Disparu needs to keep making these videos so we can see their values.
This is even MORE true for the internet. The amount of children who have their own smart phones is alarming
Of course, if you are going to pick a religion that demands absolute faith, is rigidly stuck in a medieval past and whose adherants, more than any other's are willing to kill and die for that Faith today, it's not Christians, or Jews, or Hindus or Buddists or Taoists or witches. It's the Faith that must not be named.
But these stunning and brave writers would never dare to criticize THAT Faith (even a little), because they don't want to be stabbed in the eye.
Especially strange considering the C of E is painfully woke itself now
thats EXACTLY what i was thinking. theres a certain faith that the BBC would never dare to criticize
Just commented similarly yet slightly less vaguely myself😂swap "thoughts and prayers" for "Allah hu Akbar, Allah hu Akbar, Allah hu Akbar, Allah hu Akbar" - I dare the writers to do that. Can you imagine it? We would soon find out what the phrase 'Religion of Peace' means,
@@nigelbrayshaw2709 I wonder why being Muslim is perfectly fine but Christianity is criticized so heavily I mean I guess because it more embedded in American culture so they feel better about criticizing it?
@@Riseofziggy Because they view Muslims as the oppressed and the Christians as the oppressors.
Which is pretty ridiculous, because if you go ANYWHERE in the 56 countries that are officially Muslim, I don't think the Christians will get away with much oppression there... I mean... Quite the contrary the Christians who live in the Middle East or North Africa don't fear oppression... they fear the Allah Hu Akbar treatment that can happen at any moment.
... But yeah seriously, anyone who claims they are fleeing Islam should not be allowed to continue being a Muslim I mean.
"I am fleeing Islam, also it is my human right to keep following the Islamic fate in my new country."
.... Huh? ... Something smells fishy here, I dunno. Maybe people who wish to invade tend to lie, I dunno.
You are more of a journalist than any journalist around these days. Your ability to just find the crazy things that these people say and put in power point presentations is next level. You deserve a medal for having the patience to read through that stuff.
Indoctrination Who
Indoctrinate, Indoctrinate.....New daleks probably 😂
@@ScottishRoyal1 that's a good shout and you ain't far wrong
Get these on a t-shirt
That is a very keen observation: they are actively driving away the adults so they can get to the children without supervision.
Children were always a fertile ground for new ideologies. They can be easily brainwashed. Nazi Germany did that. Soviet Union did that. BBC/Disney is doing it right now. Different methods, the same goal (more people following their ideology).
It hasn’t been Doctor Who for a long time. This is the continued adventures of the Timeless Child and theys journeys through times up and safe space.
😂😂
Innit bro
Dr. Theym.
When Capaldi arrived in black victorian London was when I realised we were in an alternative universe
@@bradleysmith2021Doctor Zir
The whole "Activist" meaning atleast the modern evolution of term is strongly linked to narcissism. It's people who dont have any qualities or abilities that they can take pride in so they have manifest something and call them selves activist. The same way "Brave" used to mean selfness and courage and potential sacrifice now its means accepting yourself and telling ppl to accept you.
Let's start calling this what it truly is Russel T Davies Folly.
Doctor Who died when Capaldi was replaced.
RIP Who
"Doctor, I let you go"
Capaldi was NOT a great Doctor either, way too much "am I a good man"? No, neither a good man nor a good doctor...
@@dking1836 and let's not forget his companion throwing her preferences in everyone's face every episode, even though it didn't have anything to do with anything. Yah, great stuff there! Capaldi is a great actor, but he got hoodwinked when he took that role.
Dr Who died when he became Dr B*tch...
Let's call this what it is, *HERESY.*
It's no longer Doctor Who, it's officially Nurse What. I learned this from AZ, Gary and MauLer on The Real BBC.
Scottish men in kilts: Yes
Ancient romans: hell yes
Whatever this flamboyant mockery is: F NO !! 🤡
And special shout out to Jamie McCrimmin, wore a kilt the whole time and kicked some serious arse!
Which is why I wanted Capaldi to deliver his lines using kilts, but never happened
difference is 2 of these made skirt things look manly, the other did not.
I'm half Scottish. A Rwandan in a kilt is cultural appropriation and I'm going to whine to the Beeb about it worse than than the whiniest blue-haired whiner.
My Mum was Scottish and a Dr Who fan from the Hartnell era onwards. I was named after Jamie McCrimmin. She loved that there was a traditional Scotsman in the show. Surely under these new "rules" they're playing by anyone but a Scotsman in a kilt is cultural appropriation.
As "non-religious" person, you make a great case for religion and a great argument against Doctor Who's dialectic material activism.
Fun fact: when doctor who started in 1963 it was originally intended to be educational about history. But the audience preferred the sci-fi aspect of the show, so they reworked the show.
If only they still listen to the people today
Fun fact when they listened to people star wars ep 9 became one of the worst blockbusters ever made.
I think you meant episodev8@videogamesworld01
@@viktorvondoom5950 no, I didn't
I doubt too many people were requesting the emperor to come back. Or for him to die as he did....but I do know many people who shipped the Reylo thing.@@videogamesworld01
@@videogamesworld01 My bad, then 😀
Probably the best review of what is happening in the "Free World," using a television show as a metaphor.
"progression is always good. Like progressing right off the ledge and falling to your death"
That depends doesn't it? Did you want to jump off? If yes, then you made progress in your endeavor, that is what progress is.
Or like progressing to a world where a certain type of people no longer exist. I wonder if they want that kind of progression...
It’s an empty virtue much like faith or empathy or unity. They all only matter depending on their object, not in and of themselves. Progress only matters in terms of the object it progresses toward, faith only depending on who you believe in, etc.
C.S. Lewis: "We all want progress, but if you're on the wrong road, progress means doing an about-turn and walking back to the right road; in that case, the man who turns back soonest is the most progressive."
“Power is in tearing human minds to pieces and putting them together again in new shapes of your own choosing.”
― George Orwell, 1984
1984 is a cautionary tale, BBC its not an instruction manual!
Remember when Dr Who was a family friendly, light entertainment, sci-if show?
Actually no, it's been so long I forgot what that was like.
Yeah,but then again gay used to mean happy. 😏
From family show to "being snowmanned..."
@@Shineinpoverty I’m not sure what that means, and I’m scared to look it up! 🤣
@@Shineinpoverty And drag queen fellating a violin bow, groaning as they do it too.
RTD thinks sending "thoughts and prayers" is pointless and you should send money and shut up if you're poor? Russell I'm not religious but if someone who is prays for me , that's BEAUTIFUL. Is there anything inside this guy? Other than Ncuti obviously .
Do be honest with yourself do you genuinely think they actually pray for you when they get home?
@@JohnKobaRuddyExactly. It would be different if people just offered up a prayer on the spot but anyone can say the phrase. Some people also think prayer is just sending out feelings to that person or the universe, not actually petitioning God. More like wishes than prayers.
@@JohnKobaRuddy I can't speak for everyone obviously, but when I say that I'll pray for someone, I mean it. I have a friend who is going through some very difficult times, things that I can't help her with no matter how much I'd like to. We don't live close to each other. So the best I can do is let her tell me about her troubles and pray for her to get through them.
Being as one of the first lines uttered by this travesty of the character was "I've just been snowflaked" I think it's far more likely that RTD has been inside Ncuti Gatwa!
"You should think for yourself, and by that I mean; You should only think what I tell you to."
As time passes, I'm increasingly of the belief I was utterly wrong to dismiss concerns raised by the religious right 10-20 years back. I simply didn't believe this is where we'd end up.
I’ve never been religious at all and I’m 29 now, but after seeing the devil in literally everything in our world I’ve started to pray to god, especially for my daughter. And am trying to shake off the way I grew up and approach ’god’ with a more mature mindset.
If I have a choice between the devil and god, I know which path I’m choosing.
And if it somehow helps us as a people, then I’m all for it 😂👌
Moffit’s complaint doesn’t even make sense. It’s shown that people of faith are ones giving the money. ‘Activists’ WANT your money for themselves.
Exactly. People of faith give their own money to help others. Activist want the government to forcefully take money from people and redistribute it. They rarely ever voluntarily give their own money to help others.
Religious people far more frequently supply both funds and physical help to those in need, such as victims of crimes or natural disasters, than any other demographic. Churches will house displaced populations or those in need of temporary shelter, churches and religious neighborhoods will band together to help a neighbor or congregation member for free, these same groups regularly hold potlucks and other related events for entire communities. This rhetoric that traditional religious people don’t help others is just a bald faced, mean spirited lie. Even historically, _all charities used to be religious enterprises._ That only changed once Western governments chose to take control-and they’ve been doing a far worse job.
Reminds me of the sight that made realise this as a kid. Saw a woman pestering her teenage son for some change. He forked it over and she then took a selfie of herself mock giving it to an annoyed homeless man. I don't who that bint was but years later just thinking about her still boils my blood.
I love the disparu still manages to work defenestrate into his videos.
I think it's too bad he's stopped saying "yeet". Something about the way he said it. He always seemed almost joyful in using the word.
Doctor Who Review of Season 1 Episode 3 "Boom" confused me. Between the BBC, Disney and Russel T Davies how did Stephen Moffat come out with an episode that made so little sense? It had directly contradictory messages, but only from my point of view. When you're attacking faith while also saying it's necessary, it seemed strange to me, so it was time to try and work out what they meant by it. Was it that some types of faith are good, while religious faith is bad? Is it just that previous beliefs are bad but new modern ever changing beliefs are great? Do these ideas tie into the rest of the series? What do you think? Let me know your thoughts down below and as always, thanks for watching :)
Thank you for your sacrifice.
Did you forget to pin this comment?
This video by the way, is masterful & needs to go viral.
Super ironic that the people who do nothing but parrot buzzwords they've heard other people say, refer to faith as "the magic word that keeps you never having to think for yourself."
Doubly so when you realize just how many words keep them from thinking at all, which is to say most of them 🤣
Their statement about faith is also parroted from other people. I don't know how many layers of irony we're at, but it's a lot.
What I'm understanding from this is more about not placing your "faith" in religion and only have faith in themselves and people they can look up to. The fact that Moffat is trying to tell children "hey kids don't believe in religion as it never does anything to help you believe in yourself and your role models" only proves to me that there's going to a mass exodus/persecution against anyone and everyone who doesn't agree with his set of ideals. Heck this is happening in the video gaming sphere already.
The dogma of the American extreme left is of a religious nature, so it's not that surprising.
Faith doesn't keep you from thinking though! People have had faith that the sun will rise everyday when it sets. That hasn't changed since it was found that the world is round, we orbit around a sun and it could be day on one part of the world and night in the other. Anyone telling people with faith not to believe in is trying to sell you something.
@Disparu I don’t mean to sound like I’m blowing smoke up your trousers but I genuinely think that this is the best and most insightful video you’ve ever done and I’ve been a viewer since ROP. Thank you for shining a spotlight and explaining just how insidious this ‘kids’ show really is. I’m so relieved that my two sons checked out of Doctor Who after the atrocious specials. Thanks again. From a parent and from a long-term Doctor Who fan 👏
It deserves to be cancelled.
Once they finally kill the BBC license fee, I hope that tv will get better.
If the only way TV companies can make money is by getting views, they will be forced to make tv shows people actually want to watch.
Which means it’ll be signed on for 5 seasons of Propwash.
Strongly disagree, it deserves a cast and crew that care about the characters, history, lore, continuity…they need to come across the VR machine keeping someone alive playing the “I’m the Doctor” game that we’ve seen the last several years…wake them, let them become the new companion and learn who & what the Doctor really is.
@@shannondavis3686 I would love for the BBC costume and prop department to be auctioned off and all the money put back into the UK budget.
@@jimmyfrench4722 Or it’s like that episode with “the dream master” and Capaldi is just in a coma on the floor of the tardis?
Also they could fix Star Trek by having the time police go back and kill Burnham’s mother, immediately restoring the timeline.
They should change the Tardis to a public toilet and put a disco ball in it. What's next weeks episode ( The Glory Hole Of Doom ) I have no idea who's watching this to be honest.
The biggest donors to disaster relief and charity funds are religious households. Charity disaster relief organizations are often out rebuilding houses after disasters long before any government organization has started moving resources toward it. I'm not religious and have other issues with how institutional religions are run, but they are consistently good at doing charitable work.
The point is having the Dr be sceptical of religious faith makes sense, but having him target it childishly and having a completely different view a moment later is bizarre. I am a religious person but I take no exception to the fact that people disagree with me (As long as they don't try to actively hurt me financially or physically). The idea that you can decide what you believe based on your experiences and influences should be just basic.
I have found some people who absolutely think I am completely wrong, religiously and politically but are still my allies in other areas like moral questions or on the idea of hard work or national pride. It seems so odd that there are those who have very liberal ideas in many areas do not want to be along side those who do not have all the same values but do in some areas. Indeed they would help engage and change minds more if they were more tolerant to those they consider in need of reform.
@@Trisjack20 I was responding more to Moffat's point about thoughts and prayers than the episode itself, but yeah there's certainly something to be criticized about replacing critical thinking with faith. The idea of capitalists preying on the faithful could be done well, in real life that's what megachurches are doing. However that's a completely different message than just "religion bad," which seems to have been the message of the episode.
@@Vaelosh466 I absolutely agree
"We know everything, thanks."
"The trouble with our liberal friends isn't that they're ignorant. It's that they know so much that isn't so."
As a lifelong Christian, I have been actively encouraged to question why I believe what I believe by my religious teachers, because they had faith that their teachings would both hold up under scrutiny and be all the stronger for it. C. S. Lewis was famously converted when he aggressively studied Christianity in an attempt to debunk it.
We are not called to blind faith, but a trusting faith. The kind of faith that takes the hero's hand as he leads you through certain doom safely. He knows what he's doing, even if it looks scary and hopeless.
Right? I've always been told, my whole life as a Christian, to seek out answers for myself. Discover for myself the truths of the Gospel. I've never been told to follow just to follow. I think a lot of people don't understand that about religious folks. Some go with the flow sure, but maybe, JUST MAYBE, some of us believe in it BECAUSE we've studied it.
Well said!
That's because our faith is true. No faith other than ours encourages thinking. First scribes were Christians, science is based on the foundation of the intelligent design (for if it were only chaos, then there would be no rules to discover). The development that we've seen occurred under Christian culture.
Now, by contrast? Science smacked against a wall and our society has regressed as well.
You know there's a book series in relation to this that always highly amuses me.
Phillip Pullman's "His Dark Materials." also known as "The Golden Compass."
Which is an excellent book series that COMPLETELY fails their stated mission.
According to Pullman himself, what he wished to do was criticize the works of C.S. Lewis and tear down Christianity but...
All his books ever do, is tearing at the power institution that is the church, not Christianity itself.
While C.S. Lewis never talked about any churches in his books anyway, but only the core principles of Christianity that Pullman obviously couldn't debunk.
I mean heck, even within his own book, the big anti C.S. Lewis anti-Christian book... He STILL acknowledges souls, an afterlife and even a higher being... In a very roundabout way he ends up affirming Christianity and the only thing he tears down at is the human created Church.
And well... Even Jesus criticized the Church! He had a fit of rage in there because they turned a house of prayer into a den of gambling. And the big message, in the bible itself, is that the church is still run by humans, and humans are very flawed so the church can absolutely become corrupted. What can't become corrupted is the word of god spoken by Jesus.
So yeah... Pullman... You acknowledged the church when turned into an institution of power can become extremely corrupt... Good job... I don't think C.S. Lewis ever disagreed with you on that... Which is why he wasn't a Christian at first, but as he consumed the true word of god and found the true meaning of it, THAT is what he put into his books that you can't debunk.
@@Wendeta-hq2cp literally nothing you said is true or even true if you don't think about it.
What do you mean your faith encourages thinking? It's literally "Read the book, pray exactly this many times at this time, don't do x, y and z, go to church every Sunday. It's a book full of rules, no free thinking. Believing there's another god is sinful, not praying is sinful. You and the other idiot who believes In god literally said "We are Christians because we thought about it" are you assuming atheists never thought about it? You are aware of the ol' contradiction of your god literally made me, knew what I am going to do and why I think the way I think and therefore has directly forced me into a hell of his own creation? Like jesus Christ are you going to tell me I deserve pain and suffering for the rest of my existence because I like to pleasure myself? Or not talk to a man who has literally killed the earth a few times, who has created fallible beings and yet lacks the knowledge or willingness to correct us? He's a fucking idiot, would be fired at any job and divorced by any woman. He raped an innocent woman to give birth to his son, which is him, to then kill himself, of which is his own design, by people who hate his religion, the only religious that should be spread and yet we have never had him spread it more than once, who then should have forgiven the sins of our fathers, aka the fallible people he created but continues to punish people regardless. Like my brain is going to explode with the amount of crap that no self respecting person should believe but yet do. Spread your peace and love, but not in that egotistical assholes name.
Science isn't based off of religion or his design, science is a way of finding something out, nothing more than a tool to find answers, not a belief or a worldview.
Dunno where you got the first scribes are Christians bs from, there has been literal gods before yours that you just don't believe in.
Civilisation that we occupy is barely influenced by religion other than cathedral placement, and wasn't even the beginning of society, the Romans and Greeks did it whilst believing in other gods that you would laugh at, which is exactly what I would do to you if it wasn't so sad.
Society could be seen as regression, or maybe we just hit our peak? Or focus on things that aren't there to advance our society. We are currently in a golden age of wealth, health and prosperity, none of which is because of god, especially with the rising number of atheists. You'll find that a lot of poor people or those without skills love god because they need him to be real to keep their lives together, whilst the happiest of us just simply ignore him and make our lives, our only lives bette.r
I never comment on RUclips videos but I needed to say how good this video is. I really hope that it gets seen by a lot of people. You have articulately and brilliantly explained how Doctor Who has become something nasty and how they have our children in their sights.
As a Christian myself, maybe I’m feeling this more on a personal level but your video has shown me that I’m having a perfectly valid reaction to it all.
Thank you for a great video and keep up the good work!
I cannot believe these people are so delusional. The show runner really said “for every viewer we lose because of our trans/gay messaging we will gain 2-3 more viewers from those who agree with us”. Uhhh is someone gonna tell them???
It was the drag queen that said that, not the showrunner. Davies said plenty of other stupid things.
They live in delusional bubble, where they have affirmations of other wokies...and they think all world is like their bubble...despite scores of fails in entertainment industry.
Well, that just makes no sense, everyone at their dinner parties agrees with them. The idea that more than 90% of the population wouldn't agree? Simply absurd dahling!
Goldfish cannot conceive of a world beyond their fishtank.
The Showrunner didn't say that though
That wasn't him. It was the demented fat man in the ginger wig
Anyone remember.. I think it was called "The Curse of Fenric" or something like that, with Sylvester McCoy's Doctor, where The Doctor extolled the virtues of faith in driving away evil?
I remember The Curse of Fenric and that Sylvester McCoy's Doctor defeated the evil by extolling the virtues of faith however I kinda remember the story mainly due to the Haemovores because how creepy they were as well as that they looked like something out of an Lovecraft story.
You totally nailed it. This should be required viewing, because you identified the underlying strategy of all that's going on in the entertainment, gaming, and comics industry, as well as education and politics.
Disparu, I love your videos. I really enjoy the format of your videos, your voice is not annoying, your takes on things going on in the world. Just thanks for making these videos. I hope you actually make a profit from this. Have a good day man.
Consider the problem is that while Moffat may have been a somewhat decent writer in the past, he's not anymore and his fall off has been recorded in the abysmal things he did before handing over the series to Chibnall, so yeah this is bad writing on its own - evil bad writing but still bad writing.
The more activist-minded he got the worse he became.
I mean seriously look at his early works, his great works. With Blink and Silence of the Library... no activism.
I personally really liked "Jekyll." as well, and it's just a thriller. If anything it has a message about love and family at the end. The one thing Hyde ends up caring about is his family, people who make him feel loved. And he'll die to protect them even when he really feared death before because he had the mind of a child.
Then we arrive at Dracula where he wanted a woman hellsing to be a strong independent wahmen who is the ultimate foil of Dracula cause she's so much better and smarter than him, Also Christianity dumb, also Jonathan Harker is my bride because breaking gender stereotypes... siiigh, it's all so tiresome isn't it?
Abysmal things such as World Enough and Time, The Doctor Falls, Twice Upon A Time, etc?
@@Jackson-ub1uv No I'm more pointing out things like Bill, the entire Clara plot they're redoing next season btw and the destruction of the First Doctor
@@UncensoredScion Bill and Clara were fine, and the First Doctor wasn't "destroyed". The First Doctor was portrayed like that because he was purposefully trying to embarrass Twelve.
There was nothing wrong with Bill, and Clara was _very_ good at being the Doctor's equal in terms of stubbornness, cunning, manipulation, and recklessness.
We also have no confirmation that the next companion is going to be another Clara; you _do_ realise that it could just be another Donna situation, right? The Doctor has already stated that he'll be checking in on Mundy, so it's more than likely that _that_ will be how she becomes the next companion.
@@Jackson-ub1uv Yes they were
And he was portrayed as a misogynist, thus destroying his legacy.
I'll never get tired of saying this to stupid people
Bill was only there for representation purposes she was a poor-quality Rose photocopy.
THE COMPANION SHOULD NOT BE EQUAL TO THE DOCTOR AT ANY POINT THE COMPANION IS THE AUDIENCE POV AND MAKING A COMPANION EQUAL TO THE DOCTOR MAKES THAT IMPOSSIBLE.
I hope that me having to allcaps that section to get across the level of stupid you are for saying that about Clara helps. We can't have a POV if a character is equal to the hero character you freaking idiot.
Yes we do, last week the Priest woman was said BY MOFFAT that she was the next companion and that they're doing the Clara story again.
You want to suck off Moffatt, you go right ahead and do it but don't lie. You make yourself look less like a hore and more like a blind idiot when doing that when you lie.
"It's such a big jump from former Doctors" says the guy claiming we're imagining things 😢
Very good analysis of the very thinly veiled intent to ‘pied piper’ children.
Next week the "Doctor" will be wearing a Hamas scarf.
What's a hamas scarf? Did Gaza only exist for you when your TV told you to? The same TV you don't like?
@@JohnKobaRuddy Duh. x
It's hilarious you think Disney or the BBC would ever allow that, especially on a show promoting zionist ideology.
@@JohnKobaRuddyIt's fascinating how western leftists love Muslims and Palestine despite the fact that they are viewed as degenerate decadent heathens by most of them. Read Quran. Everything is there.
Palestinians are a fictional group which go with doctor who fictions.
Gatwa's acting in doctor who is the exact same as in Sex Education.He didnt even bother bringing Something new to the table.If you pretend doctor who is Sex Education presents :Eric Effiong bizzare adventures than the actual show would make more sense 😂😂😂😂
Yeah I expected a lot more from him.
hes a shit actor and his role in dr who just feels like hes playing himself
hes a sh!t actor and his role in dr who just feels like hes playing himself
@@catbhoy why. Its not obvious that he is just an angry homo with no talent?
Compared to Matt Smith who was younger than Ncuti Gatwa when he joined Doctor Who, but managed to pull off the most mature Doctor yet!
I miss his version of the Doctor. 😢
One of your best breakdowns. As a parent, it pains me that we now live in a world wherein corporations seem like they are hellbent on going after kids and pulling them away from family values.
I haven’t heard a single person ask why Christianity was chosen to be ‘the faith’ in this episode, rather than Islam. Peaceful, harmless and a forgiving target I guess?
If Muslims were the soldiers, the show would have been instantly cancelled and a Fatwa pinned to RTD and Moffat’s heads.
As a Christian, it's always been that way. I had a bunch of classmates once gather around me and chant "get out of our school" at me because I admitted to being Christian, and that was more than 10 years ago. The teacher when he came back in the room was suitably horrified, but nothing ever came of it. ANY OTHER RELIGION ON EARTH and it would have resulted in legal problems, expulsions, etc. Not with Christianity. Weird, huh?
@@deadworld953 there are studies that claim Christianity is the most persecuted religion on Earth today. I mentioned this some months ago on a thread and by God, regretted it after the hatred that was spewed my way!
Seems the general consensus is ‘they deserve to be”.
You know why. Ones real ones a fake religion of a false prophet Mohammad.
Devil does not need to spite false gods.
Because Islam is a false religion and thus the devil does not need to stop it.
Because Islam is a false religion.
When I was a teenager I thought the whole "thoughts and prayers" thing was so stuuupid... then I grew up and I realized that a lot of people who say this kind of thing comes from a place of "I want to do something but I'm not in a position where I can personally" and I think that's beautiful. Belief in God or not, the sentiment is deeply human and kind.
Assuming that all who say this are using it as an excuse to dismiss people in need, is such a negative interpretation and really shows how many believe that human beings are evil by nature...
Sentiment is actually useless. Isn't the 'God' that made us 'in His image' evil by nature?
"Sorry for your loss. Here, here's 20 bucks"
Reminds me of the robot chicken sketch with the tooth fairy
It's either that or necromancy I guess.
@@multitimmytiger2 or a subway coupon. Pay 10 get one free
@@Riseofziggy "Congratulations! This is the darkest sketch in TV History! Darkest Sketch! Darkest Sketch!"
As if giving money would ease the pain of having lost someone... These MF's are entirely mental.
It actually reminds me of a scene from The IT Crowd (Season 2 Episode 2, around the 12 minute mark), at the funeral of Denholm Reynholm (of Reynhom Industries), where Jen tells Roy to just say "sorry for your loss, and then move on", as in: say that and then walk away. In this scene both Roy and (Maurice) Moss offer condolences to the widow:
Roy: Sorry for your loss
Roy: move on
Widow: ... ...
Moss: Sorry for your loss
Moss: It's not like you lost a pen, is it? It's so much worse.
Moss & Widow: ...
Moss: Would you like a pen? [takes out a pen and offers it to the widow]
Widow: ...
Widow: ...
Moss: please take the pen...
Widow: half in shock over the absurdness of it, reluctantly accepts the pen
Holy hell, this is one of the best analysis videos you’ve done in a long time. I like your work usually, but this just absolutely knocked it out of the park.
2025 HEADLINE:
"Disney's Dr. Who, Ncuti Gatwa - convicted of Pedophilia."
Did you do something to his name to translate it to Little Friend? Or does his name actually mean that? 😂
@@NoPowerintheVerse google thinks he was saying something in Kinyarwanda. I can't say if the translation itself is accurate but the individual words do seem to give a similar meaning to little friend
Spotted that too. @@NoPowerintheVerse
You know what, given how the entertainment industry and Disney in particular have gone the past 15 years, this would not surprise me in the slightest.
Not sure about him but Jinkx will definitely be arrested after someone sees his hard drives.
Wow. Amazingly accurate (and terrifying) analysis, Disparu.
Not even being funny that red hair would scare the absolute shit out of me
Great Mate, succinctly put in such a humourous way. Forget everyone that tries to dis you, they are just envious of your brains....it must be so difficult coming up with theses videos. Keep doing what you're doing it's so good
"When I finish a book on kindle the algorithm recommends another"
Relying on an algorithm to tell what to read. Thats the very definition of not thinking for yourself.
Relying on it solely can be problematic, but using algorithms is not inherently bad.
100% agree with children accepting what ppl of importance say as the truth and not questioning it. When I was 30, I was sat watching Return of the Jedi and noticed yoda died. I was shocked. I had seen the film hundreds of times and had always thought yoda hibernated for 900 hundred years and was going to come back at some point. My father pissed himself laughing. He had told this story of "hibernation" to stop me crying as a small child when I first watched it. Believed it for years.
Never had a problem with the Yoda scene, but my Parents would never take us to see Bambi because they didn't want to deal with the potential crying so they just skipped it everytime it was out in theaters. The good thing is my parents didn't lie about death, but they did try to limit our exposure to it if possible.
Children are taught from young that vaccines are safe and effective. They are also taught that the earth is a spinning globe that supposedly revolves around the sun.
I keep saying that someone needs to look at RTD's hard drive?
Look at episode 1 of queer as folk. Rtd is literally a child sex advocate.
I’ve been thinking about that for the last few weeks.
He cast an 18 year old Charlie Hunnam as a 15 year old in the first season of QaF because he didn't want a teenage actor's parents objecting to what he had that character do.
RTD definitely looks like one of them.
Look at episode 1 of Queer ad Folk. He is literally a child sex advocate. He portrays men having sex with boys as normal, fun, and actually wanted and beneficial by the 15 yo boy. A normal part of gay culture. rtd is a pedo like many gay rights activists of his era, including peter tatchell
It's not 2+ million viewers, it's 2+ million people who watched for 30 seconds. Like a RUclips view. You leave the TV on, goes to the next program, you start looking for something else but leave it in the background for a minute or 2. Now you're a viewer!
I think Willm. Blake wrote, if I'm in my sick bed and I hear someone's coming to help, I crawl out my bedroom window and run away.
Hmm another wrong un from a copration of wrong uns.
Funnily enough I think I have a idea for a show the BBC could produce its called "whats on my laptop" where we pick 3 random bbc employees and search there computers/ laptops for illegal and compromising material then see who will get the most jail time if exposed.
It could be a big success the public would love it and the wealth of talent available at the BBC is almost limitless.
So, it's a kind of good old, family friendly tale of inculcation/gr00ming?
Get to them while they're still young and malleable.
You'd think the BBC would have learnt their lesson about this stuff.
-This is by far the best breakdown of this episide I've watched, and Ive watched a few. You nailed their ideology perfectly.
Faith cannot exist without doubt. Faith is belief in the face of doubt and questioning.
If there was no doubt, it would be a fact. Idiots can't, don't want to, understand Faith.
Problem with faith is, it tends to keep people invested in an idea, even when there is overwhelming evidence to the contrary.
@@Alexander_Kale I wasn't arguing the positive or negative, just describing what faith involves.
Anything taken to an extreme can be bad. But it depends what you have faith in, if you put your faith in something worthy, then I doubt you will have a problem with "evidence".
@@Sadovari Faith is always something worthy, that is the problem. Why would anyone put their faith in anything they consider unworthy?
And of course, anyone who does not share your faith is necessarily doing it wrong. That's why vegans tend to be militant. That's why different religions tend to hate one another. That's why wars between brothers are the bloodiest and nastiest you can imagine.
@@Alexander_KaleA man more intelligent than me once said: "Faith needs the intellect to stay grounded, but the intellect needs faith to keep it humble."
You're not wrong in your criticisms of Faith, but that does not mean it doesn't have it's place. It is difficult to find the right balance, though, like most things
@@Stormmblade I fail to see how this is reflective of reality. One aspect of intelligence is critical thinking.
Faith, rather implicitely, is the believe in a thing in the absencee of evidence and sometimes in the presence of evidence to the contrary.
Thus, if you apply critical thinking to your religion, it will inevitably start falling apart.
On the other hand, being humble does not require religion either, because there are multiple other sources for that.
PDF files target kids to help make more of them. They are a cancer.
@AnoneemusNoename I see all child actors same way. Parents either naivé or in on it and don’t care.
This is one of the most significant points of criticism I’ve seen in years. Bravo. This video felt important.
Bro, your videos are gold
It always baffled me why they were telling old fans to leave. Thats a great analysis on "why?" by you. Good work
Seriously good vid Disparu fantastic analysis. So switched on.
Damn man, you are cooking in this one. It really puts this show in a sinister light that I strongly doubt I will be able to unsee.
I think I’ve figured out what the problem is. Or at least what the difference is in the old episodes the doctor had faith (no pun intended) in humanity and when in a problem he would help guide them to a solution helping them learn along the way. The new doctor has a disdain for “some humans” (we all know which ones) and he yells at them like its a lecture
You're forgetting episodes like Midnight and The Beast Below where the Doctor completely lost faith in humanity. As with this Doctor, the loss in faith of humanity is and was only temporary.
You're making up a non-existent difference, in my opinion.
I watched several of your stuff. This was deep. Bravo.
4:29 This is true, but I think to a degree "thoughts and prayers" has been overused to the point where people just dismiss it out of hand. They don't see it as an admission of compassion. They want immediate solutions (which they can't have) so they just dismiss it as cynical.
Ok well these weirdos are clearly Satanic so...
I think it's more likely that people who are triggered by the phrase have no conscience and see all forms of kindness as virtue signaling or weakness.
Ok well these "people" are Satanic anyway so...
There was a debate in my country some years back with some people taking offence to "my condolences" because they said it had been overused and lost its meaning. I personally think it's a good phrase to have when you don't know what else to say but you want to express sympathy to someone in a sad situation. I understand people in the US get fed up with constant "thoughts and prayers" from politicians after something like a shooting instead of them *actually* trying to fix the issue, but surely that's more on those politicians than the phrase?
Don't know why my comment keeps getting removed. I'm not even saying anything bad. Guess you can just do whatever you want when you have a monopoly on the internet.
A new generation of Mao's little generals.
The issue is never the issue. The Revolution is always the issue.
"Don't fight the evil corporation, just surrender to it" - Dr Who of the alphabet cult
Remember when Matt Smith met the Anglican Marines that were using his wife to help them and he lectured them on their beliefs? No, he didn't. When Moffat was the showrunner.
And algorithims could use a bit of work. Like someone said "I hate that the Amazon algorithim thinks my purchase of 1 air purifier meant I wanted to build a vast, air purifying, empire!".😁
How many believe that transgenderism does not belong in Doctor who???
It’s fine to be in the show, because trans people do actually exist.
But ideally it would be statistically accurate, and trans characters would be 1% of the characters at the most. Gay characters would only be 5% at the most.
Representation that is accurate to the time period and location is fine.
Shoehorning modern diversity into every time and place is fucking stupid though.
It doesn’t belong anywhere except in the private lives of trans people.
I think its more the forceful push on representation. I'm all for whoever doing whatever, but don't destroy the culture around specific franchises with -"agree or you're a bigot"- overtones. Surely this just ends up hurting the reputation of those you're trying to represent and the beloved franchises in the process. I thought that umbrella academy did it well. The change didn't affect the overall story or franchise, allowing the viewer to just go with it and still have a good experience watching.
I don't think it's a case of it doesn't belong but it needs to be done by someone who doesn't unquestionably believe anyone about anything they say. I feel a more doctor who like story would be a planet where it's at its logical extreme where all residents are paired up by a system and have their gender changed to make the best offspring with the message being at the end that while some were feeling better in their new gender for some they were regretful and wanted to go back but could not anymore.
Im not a writer but I feel that is a better starting point for a story that can tackle an issue about trans people in a way that isn't like a scale being weighted to guarantee one side the preference
@@glawenclattuc3127There are many - including me- who do not believe transgenderism exists. Transgenderism is based on the idea of ‘gender’ and of ‘gender identities’ which everybody is apparently born with that can’t be measured or detected and constantly give the person an expectation of which pronouns they need to hear. Gender identity was made by John Money who oversaw the raising of a castrated boy as a girl. He believed it was a six sea but both twins later killed themselves. I don’t believe there are gender identities that demand each person wears pants or skirts . There is only biological sex.
The moral is, vet your kids TV.
how tf we all just sitting here waiting for a new disparu drop
A masterclass critique. Well done.
I’m atheist so my belief system is obvious. But why is it that only Christianity and Scientology are able to be made fun of.
Scientology is a proven cult and has contributed nothing to human welfare much less moral morality. Abuse is built into its system by putting all spiritual ability onto the believer. That actually does deserve contempt and mockery.
oh atheists are easy to make fun of... can't do basic math and have no understanding of science
I would go out in my back garden to "Touch grass." But it's been raining here.
No smell quite like grass after the rain. Certainly smells better than (glances at Nu Who), well, you know.
@harbl99
Definitely 😁 smells fresh 🌱🍃
Disparu you really do exceptional work getting to the roots of a lot of the vapid commentary that modern “writers” think they’re sneaking in to these properties. Fantastic analysis as always.
notice there's a video going viral of the conscious baby, and in doctor Who has the "space babies" episode have the intelligent baby people.
Great video Disparu, you really put that together well. Keep it up Lad!
Your commentary is *SO* much more thoughtful and articulate than the people you consider your peers.
It's like setting fire to the house you are living in, telling the Fire Department to F-Off and then complaining that nobody is putting out the fire! If nobody watches your show, there will be no money to make the next one, and in this case, that's a good thing!
Wow! Spot on. Well done! You explained so much. Thank you.
Massive critique. Thanks, Disparu.
I thought the 800 pound gorilla in RTD's room was his boyfriend, Clarence?
Ah, so that is how monk-pox jumped species...
These episodes of doctor who are the left's parables. The Bible has the parable of the mustard seed, RTD has the parable of the space babies. The Bible has the parable of the lost coin, RTD has the parable of the Devil's chord. The Bible has the parable of the unforgiving servant, RTD has the parable of Boom.
Each episode isn't simply a simple episode of TV and shouldn’t be treated like one. They should be treated like what they are: religious propaganda of the left.
Space babies is a parable about abortion, how children are the future, but also (since they never grow up btu run the ship) a subtle slash at the future, saying that the future, while competent, will be childish and create their own problems which they will be unable to solve without a multiple box-checking immigrant to solve. It’s essentially the crystallisation of the left’s views on immigration: only they can solve us squabbling children who made our catastrophic problems due to our state and our own childish ignorance.
The Devil’s Chord is a parable about not only music, but about how loss of control over that music will result in destruction of the future. However, music int this episode refers to power. Music is, in a way, propaganda. I admit the messaging here is a little muddled, seeing as how it implies that giving power to trans people will destroy the future… I’m not quite sure how to reconcile that with RTD’s bias and I think I’m missing something, though I admit I haven’t watched this dreck so I might have missed or simply be unaware of something.
Boom is a parable about how faith in the PAST (religion) which bonded and formed society (and, when taken with Space Babies, will create a destroyed world of infants who cause their own deadly problems they can’t solve) is evil and foolish to believe.
Btu that doesn’t mean that Boom is implying that faith itself is bad. Indeed, as a religious text, boom is very much in favour of faith, just THE RIGHT KIND of faith. Faith in their beliefs. That’s why the doctor says that faith is bad but necessary. This is a very bastardised (and warped in an attempt to hide the true meaning) version of ‘faith in the past is bad but faith in general binds us and is necessary. Therefore, you need to have the right belief; the one WE tell you to have, the one which will steer us away from Space Babies’ future, where ‘the future is knackered’.
The reason most (other than Disparu) missed this is because it is simply foreign to them: those like Nerdrotic (no shame no shame to him; I’ve been a sub to him for years) simply don’t think to look for messages in this way. Everyone’s been primed to look for overt messages like Endgame’s girlpower moment, but few are trained to look for covert messaging and parables. It’s understandable, because their channels are about entertainment and not religion or English Analysis, and that’s how they get you.
Fortunately, noone’s watching this. Imagine of this covert messaging was actually popular.
The flaw with RTD’s plan is twofold: firstly, he lives in an echo chamber so doesn’t realise that the people he sees as sheep are actually very, very primed against any messaging and secondly, his work simply isn’t entertaining.
He’s writing from money, as opposed to entertainment. A lot of his other episodes have messaging. Midnight is about groupthink and the effects of stress on groups and how social bonds can become strained in stressful scenarios. The doctor’s daughter is about a fake war. It’s very similar to the base plot of boom, except more well thought out. Amy’s choice is about love vs friendship. The End of the world is about what makes us human and about cosmetic surgery and the fear of our legacy dying (earth is destroyed and no one watches). One could argue aliens in london is about illegal immigrants deliberately destroying the country (though that’s a stretch). Dalek is about capital punishment, a conversation that is conveniently sidestepped by RTD’s desire to have the Dalek commit suicide. The Long game is about the effects of the media in controlling our lives. Father’s day is about guilt and loss. The Doctor dances is about single motherhood and the importance of reconciling with your past indiscretions.
Practically every episode of RTD’s doctor who has messaging. The difference is that he had talent back then. He knew how to rein in his desires, his messaging. He knew he wasn’t in an echo chamber and so he had to hide his true messaging within entertainment.
That’s what he’s missing. Living in an echo chamber is effectively isolation. It prevents you from seeing others’ opinions and so you can’t see how others think. You can’t see just how alone you are in your beliefs.
But RTD’s delusion is our boon. His isolation acts as a signal to others to ignore his work. It destroys his legacy and, more importantly, convinces everyone not to watch the insidious dreck he creates.
Fantastic video, one of your best, Great Job!
Disparu, my deer friend, you have outdone yourself. This was a master piece!
"Painting people who believe to be a bunch of sheep blindly following their belief." is the message this show wanted to send....
A message that describes the woke perfectly. They self owned.
The first episode had a preteen boy in a school uniform saying "thats my daddy" to a grown man dressed like a Brazilian carnival. Knowing the people that made this and what their agenda is, this might be the most disgusting thing I've seen for a long time.
Cause the character was literally the kids father u idiot.
Stupid the kid called them his daddy cause he was created from that character. Like like the character call the toymaker, their father and daddy cause they are the toymaker child.
Wtf is wrong with u?
The fact u saw that seen and think about it in a sexual way, shows that u are the issue and a pedo
Don't forget later that same freak sucks off a violin bow while moaning.
I can see Doctor Who having another Doctor after Gatwa and then going on a 20 year hiatus...
I really don't think so, they are relying on Disney money for this, and well... Disney itself is flailing so Disney cannot afford expensive shows that has no viewers and... how many are watching on Disney+ ???
That's the big question, do they get enough new subscribers to justify the cost? Doubtful! People are STILL cancelling their Disney+ subscriptions because... A: Nothing good on there. B: people are penny pinching, we're all in the same recession!
At which point, everything after Capaldi is, by consensus, declared heretical and expunged from the canon timeline.
@@Xbalanque84 That may in fact be the right answer... still think DW will go on indefinate hiatus after this series finishes.
@@Rendell001 Season 2 is already filmed. Potential cancellation will happend after Season 2 or 3 (RTD is already writing S3 but Disney is silent about paying for it again).