@@DropoutJerome Yes one game every object has a mass and density where you can manipulate the world physics to play around and the other is a mostly scripted game.
@@farhan007 they're both open-world RPG sandbox titles that share a huge amount of mechanics and details. Tell me you're a nintendrone without actually telling me you're a nintendrone
@@oddgbmo3036 ok then, what do you think is better, the flavor of apples or living in a yacht? the answer is obvious, no? guess what, its because the comparison is stupid.
To be fair, both games nail it on their on ways. Zelda TOK has a beautiful cartoonish stile and RDR2 has a beautiful photo realistically style and that's it
Bro rdr2 is more realistic but it doesn't take away the fact that Zelda Tok is an incredible game like rdr2 and the Last of us these 3 are the best games of all
No... theyre both open-world RPG sandbox titles. They're totally comparable and Nintendo should be held up to the standard of other triple a devs because they're charging triple a dev prices while also lacking in hardware and quality. Stop allowing Nintendo to have their own little category where it's acceptable to be outdated and charge current gen prices.
@@bigwizard914 bruh nintendo fans are different species and will suck up everything nintendo poops out pokemon violet, botw and now totk selling insanely well on switch while looking worse than ps2 games and running below 20 fps.
@@nanamimusic the only exclusively Nintendo games I own are Mario Odyssey, BOTW, and TOTK. And for the record, RDR2 is one of my top 3 games easily. I’m just saying comparing something that was designed for PC and beefier consoles can’t really fairly be compared to a game designed for a handheld console. That’s literally my only point here.
@@alaa341g bro i love rdr2, its one of my favorite game, all that mechanics is incredible, but lets see the possibilities, cause i just playing totk and that is my first zelda game, and i was amaze with lots of mechanics, what im thinking will possible in that game, but im still amaze when i flying in sky to the depth on underground without loading screen :". but rdr2 is still best game all time for me.
Being non biased,I have over 300 hours in tears I always thought rdr2 is bad until my brother let me play it,and when I got 2 chapter 2 I was having a blast now that I look at it , both games are amazing games but tears is not in the same level.U can ask me any questions about Both games and I’m happy to answer it
Me too maybe I don't know I mean they are different , red dead redemption is about history And Zelda liberty anf gameplay For feelings red dead redemption 2 And for fun Zelda But red dead redemption bored me in some history Zelda never , always manteinme happy But the final of red dead redemption. Was 10 and Zelda like 8 or 9
@@den-den3229 I have to say, I loved RDR, but RDR2 was just a mediocre game to me. The gameplay is just not fun, the story is not that interesting and the world is not well designed. It just a series of scripted encounters found in the map. The one redeeming quality are the breathtaking graphics and the crazy numbers of handcrafted details. I don’t believe rdr2 will stand the test of time because what makes a game great is the depth of his gameplay. In comparison BotW was the first time in almost 25 years since I got my first genesis that I fought - this might actually be the best game ever made.
@@DropoutJerome what? no development for totk started early 2019 as botw dlc but quickly turned into a sequel not basically dlc (i can tell you haven't played it)
Zelda botw and RDR 2 for me was amazing master pieces when they came out I both had almost 150-200hr Totk just wasn’t same I just left some cabes and wells It start get boring do shitty grind for gear set that I can’t wear on most places because of wetter so I why even bother Feeling so unrewarded after u complete mission
I agree that you cant compare these games. Yes, they are both open world games. But the developers of Zelda didn't even TRY to go for a realistic style, they went for a cartoon cell shade style (like windwaker). The developers of Red Dead Redemption tried to make the game as realistic as possible, and the developers of Zelda had other goals in mind. You can't fault them for not making a photorealistic game when they were not trying to do that in the first place. That's like saying that Cuphead or Journey aren't realistic. If you really prefer photorealistic games, then choose playstation or PC for gaming; everyone knows that, no one is trying to say that the Switch can compete in terms of graphics. But people who love Zelda believe that there is much more to games than just photorealistic graphics. Zelda is better than a lot of games with much better graphics because its game design (not graphic design) is so much better. It has real character, and it is fun. Graphics isnt everything. But if you disagree, that's perfectly fine; just keep playing playstation or PC. Not all people have to like the same things.
@@zembla8957 that's zelda story, not gameplay. rdr2 is just basic mid repititive gameplay over extremely good graphics totk is clearly miles better unless you care more about graphics than gameplay
@@prc1410 everytime someone says that the missions are ''point A to point B'', i already know they played the game for 5 minutes and dropped it off because of their ADHD brain.
@@aaxel_dz it's not an opinion, but a fact that rdr2 has the same "point A to point B shooting missions" mostly where you follow a companion for like 2 mins, shoot a bunch of guys, and then return to camp, rinse and repeat throughout whole game and what you get is rdr2, another typical rockstar repetitive mission game.
@@prc1410 Every game that has quest or missions can be summarized that way if we retrieve the context or the meaning of why we do it (the story). Your logic doesn’t even stand since even games like the Witcher 3 or Skyrim with non linear stories can also be summarized the same way if we only take account of what you need to do to complete their quests/missions.
Doesn't make sense AT ALL. You can compare any game and it truly is fascinating. This isn't a comparison on which game is better. It's just a comparison.
That's what I'm thinking, then I thought about it more and was like Red Dead 1 might be comparable to breath of the wild. Then again breath of the wild seems to be slightly more detailed a tad but the physics on Red Dead 1 are elite. I compare Red Dead 2 and tears of the Kingdom like they just did so in a way you're right and wrong.
@@oddgbmo3036there’s many complaints about the game being just not fun at all, tedious and slow. my brother got bored with it(he loved breath of the wild for example)
Realism doesn't mean a better game, TOTK or even elden ring destroys red dead 2 for sure and i played them, the only lack of red dead 2 is having good gameplay and freedom
if we follow logic , the better game would be the most sold one ; cuz every other opinion is subjectif , so the only objectf value that we have is statistique , a game that appeal to most the majority is the better game , so basically rdr2 almost smashes both zelda and elden ring combined ( and don't tell me sales don't mean shit , cuz if they were better , ppl will most likely buy them more and they would sell more copies , end of the story )
I went back to rdr2, because of Tears of the kingdom Zelda I came to realised and appreciate and love the open world environment much more. I just have to say rdr2 felt like jt could've had a lot more to it
@@pauldel7509ik rdr2 is one of the best story games to date but Zelda has a solid story incredible lore fantastic gameplay and good abilities rdr2 doesn’t have lore and the gameplay gets boring really fast (only reason I completed 6 play throughs was because of the story and post game stuff)
Zelda totk es en mi opinión mas bonito y divertido mientras que rdr2 es mas realista e inmersivo pero si me dieran a elegir seria el zelda aunque rdr2 también me fascina
Nintendo games are made for kids 10 and under. This is why they do not have the best graphics, because they do not target adults, abd kids don't know any better.
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
*WHICH GAME IS BEST?*
The Legend of Zelda Tears of the Kingdom
Red Dead Redemption 2
Not a fair comparison at all
@@Halcyth how
Get bent. You know damn well which one is better you sh!t kicker.
Zelda’s graphic style is beautiful
it is when i use fsr and AA on pc to play it in 4k, on switch it looks like muddy washed out dog shit
They are very flat, the beautiful thing is the filter that they put on it
Tbh red dead redemption looks like youre playing with a Max steel doll over a realístic world, It feels weird
@@TwoDimensionalBro que te hizo el juego pa que lo trates así
They're both amazing for their own reasons, and aren't comparable because of the different genres
Dude, what? They're both open world RPG sandbox titles. Yes, they're completely comparable.
@@DropoutJerome Yes one game every object has a mass and density where you can manipulate the world physics to play around and the other is a mostly scripted game.
@@farhan007 they're both open-world RPG sandbox titles that share a huge amount of mechanics and details. Tell me you're a nintendrone without actually telling me you're a nintendrone
And different studios.
@@DropoutJeromeI really don't care about Nintendo. I'm just saying BOTW is an immersive sim and Red Dead isn't.
Bro you can’t compare these games together they are both amazing in different ways 😭
You can compare almost ANYTHING. But suddenly it's too far?
@@oddgbmo3036 what are you talking about? 😂😂😂
@@MrAtheking0 if you have trouble reading basic English id recommend some classes. Maybe try online courses? 🤣🤚
@@oddgbmo3036 you keep telling people “you can compare almost anything” 🤓
@@oddgbmo3036 ok then, what do you think is better, the flavor of apples or living in a yacht? the answer is obvious, no? guess what, its because the comparison is stupid.
everyone's like this is an unfair comparison when THEY LITTERLY SEARCHED FOR THIS VIDEO!!!
FUCKING TRUE
To be fair, both games nail it on their on ways. Zelda TOK has a beautiful cartoonish stile and RDR2 has a beautiful photo realistically style and that's it
@@buttcube6085 you don't need so much hate just because you didn't like the NPCs
@@buttcube6085 I like them 😁
Bro rdr2 is more realistic but it doesn't take away the fact that Zelda Tok is an incredible game like rdr2 and the Last of us these 3 are the best games of all
@@allison6368 why did i read that as tlou 3
This is like apples and oranges man. Two amazing and beautiful games, just for different reasons.
No... theyre both open-world RPG sandbox titles. They're totally comparable and Nintendo should be held up to the standard of other triple a devs because they're charging triple a dev prices while also lacking in hardware and quality. Stop allowing Nintendo to have their own little category where it's acceptable to be outdated and charge current gen prices.
@@DropoutJerome nah I’ll keep letting them have the category. Especially considering the limitations of the Switch.
@@bigwizard914 bruh nintendo fans are different species and will suck up everything nintendo poops out pokemon violet, botw and now totk selling insanely well on switch while looking worse than ps2 games and running below 20 fps.
@@nanamimusic the only exclusively Nintendo games I own are Mario Odyssey, BOTW, and TOTK. And for the record, RDR2 is one of my top 3 games easily. I’m just saying comparing something that was designed for PC and beefier consoles can’t really fairly be compared to a game designed for a handheld console. That’s literally my only point here.
@DropoutJerome neither are rpgs what are you smoking?
really depends on what mood you're in. Zelda got cartoony, fantasy vibe while red dead is more realistic and gritty.
dont forget about the skill. Fuse, Ultrahand, Ascend, Recall, Autobuild and more
Fr if we’re gonna do a fair comparison let’s see those RDR2 mech suits
@@brycedecker7142that’s all fluff added to the game.it’s not even Zelda anymore
@@brycedecker7142 yeah let arthur the man living in 1870 , in a normal world fuse 2 building and make light saber , and going throw the walls
@@alaa341g bro i love rdr2, its one of my favorite game, all that mechanics is incredible, but lets see the possibilities, cause i just playing totk and that is my first zelda game, and i was amaze with lots of mechanics, what im thinking will possible in that game, but im still amaze when i flying in sky to the depth on underground without loading screen :". but rdr2 is still best game all time for me.
Being non biased,I have over 300 hours in tears I always thought rdr2 is bad until my brother let me play it,and when I got 2 chapter 2 I was having a blast now that I look at it , both games are amazing games but tears is not in the same level.U can ask me any questions about Both games and I’m happy to answer it
You can’t compare both games 😭😭 they are two entirely different things
They both are RPG open world for sure, same category is comparable but different animation and story styles
You can compare almost anything
@@beaconing7689 yes but they are not really comparable with each other, they are both detailed but in very different ways
@@oddgbmo3036 yeah almost anything but not everything
@@MrAtheking0 great! You agree. You can compare red dead to this game.
I own and love both of these games but I prefer Rdr2 because it look so realistic and much detailed.
Me too maybe I don't know I mean they are different , red dead redemption is about history
And Zelda liberty anf gameplay
For feelings red dead redemption 2
And for fun Zelda
But red dead redemption bored me in some history
Zelda never , always manteinme happy
But the final of red dead redemption. Was 10 and Zelda like 8 or 9
I agree. Even tho Zelda is a really good game, i feel like its slightly overrated
i love both games but i prefer more rdr 2
@@den-den3229 I have to say, I loved RDR, but RDR2 was just a mediocre game to me. The gameplay is just not fun, the story is not that interesting and the world is not well designed. It just a series of scripted encounters found in the map.
The one redeeming quality are the breathtaking graphics and the crazy numbers of handcrafted details.
I don’t believe rdr2 will stand the test of time because what makes a game great is the depth of his gameplay.
In comparison BotW was the first time in almost 25 years since I got my first genesis that I fought - this might actually be the best game ever made.
Crazy how RDR2 released almost 5 years ago and is still better than most games
It was under development for 8 years, and by the biggest game company in the industry
it also cost 540 million to make.
Technically ToTK has been in development for 8 years as well since its basically a BoTW DLC.
@@DropoutJerome what? no development for totk started early 2019 as botw dlc but quickly turned into a sequel not basically dlc (i can tell you haven't played it)
@@DropoutJerome tell me you haven't played totk without telling me your haven't played totk
To me zelda feels like a very good game, but Red Dead Redemtion 2 feels like a real experience
Red Dead Redemption was made with the thought of becoming a master piece.
Only thing I don’t like about red dead’s physics is its water. The water looks and acts like Liquid Metal, it’s just off for me…
Zelda botw and RDR 2 for me was amazing master pieces when they came out I both had almost 150-200hr
Totk just wasn’t same I just left some cabes and wells It start get boring do shitty grind for gear set that I can’t wear on most places because of wetter so I why even bother
Feeling so unrewarded after u complete mission
I agree that you cant compare these games. Yes, they are both open world games. But the developers of Zelda didn't even TRY to go for a realistic style, they went for a cartoon cell shade style (like windwaker). The developers of Red Dead Redemption tried to make the game as realistic as possible, and the developers of Zelda had other goals in mind. You can't fault them for not making a photorealistic game when they were not trying to do that in the first place. That's like saying that Cuphead or Journey aren't realistic. If you really prefer photorealistic games, then choose playstation or PC for gaming; everyone knows that, no one is trying to say that the Switch can compete in terms of graphics. But people who love Zelda believe that there is much more to games than just photorealistic graphics. Zelda is better than a lot of games with much better graphics because its game design (not graphic design) is so much better. It has real character, and it is fun. Graphics isnt everything. But if you disagree, that's perfectly fine; just keep playing playstation or PC. Not all people have to like the same things.
Dont judge by graphics if they were to be actualky compared it will be a tie
comparing 160GB game to a 15GB one on a Nintendo console is crazyyy, ppl also be saying totk is better is even crazier to me💀
totk is better than that repetitive rockstar game
@@prc1410 Zelda is the same save the princess shit over n over again and you talking repetitive??? Y’all are getting mad with the d*riding
dude what totk is great and is honestly very close to rdr2 even if only 18gb
@@zembla8957 that's zelda story, not gameplay.
rdr2 is just basic mid repititive gameplay over extremely good graphics
totk is clearly miles better unless you care more about graphics than gameplay
@@prc1410 link pfp is definitely not biased
You can't compare them they're both masterpiece
I love both of these games so much!
They are both in my top 5 of all time
Zelda is obviously the better game. If you mean which has better graphical fidelity, I would assume the PC game over the handheld game
Love how most the comments are "both are good!"
Very little war here
Rdr2 is only better in graphics
Totk completely demolishes rdr2 and pretty much whole rockstar in creativity & gameplay
And story. combat, immersion. AI, NPCs interaction, world detail, and a BIG etc.
@@mrcactuar8515 and yet is filled with very repetitive and boring missions point A to point B shooting missions.
Also rdr2 combat sucks.
@@prc1410 everytime someone says that the missions are ''point A to point B'', i already know they played the game for 5 minutes and dropped it off because of their ADHD brain.
@@aaxel_dz it's not an opinion, but a fact that rdr2 has the same "point A to point B shooting missions" mostly where you follow a companion for like 2 mins, shoot a bunch of guys, and then return to camp, rinse and repeat throughout whole game and what you get is rdr2, another typical rockstar repetitive mission game.
@@prc1410 Every game that has quest or missions can be summarized that way if we retrieve the context or the meaning of why we do it (the story).
Your logic doesn’t even stand since even games like the Witcher 3 or Skyrim with non linear stories can also be summarized the same way if we only take account of what you need to do to complete their quests/missions.
Is this red dead on pc?
this isn't why i've been playing games since 1982, sorry.
tbh i would compare red dead 1 more to zelda because of system specs, the switch isnt even stronger than an xbox one
Doesn't make sense AT ALL. You can compare any game and it truly is fascinating. This isn't a comparison on which game is better. It's just a comparison.
That's what I'm thinking, then I thought about it more and was like Red Dead 1 might be comparable to breath of the wild. Then again breath of the wild seems to be slightly more detailed a tad but the physics on Red Dead 1 are elite. I compare Red Dead 2 and tears of the Kingdom like they just did so in a way you're right and wrong.
Two wildly different games, hard to compare. However, even though it is good, I do think Rdr2 is overrated
Wouldn't say overrated. It's overrated to you but to others who played the game they severely enjoyed the experience. It's a matter of opinion.
@@oddgbmo3036there’s many complaints about the game being just not fun at all, tedious and slow. my brother got bored with it(he loved breath of the wild for example)
@@natanhaelalvarado6137 matter of opinion, thank you
Realism doesn't mean a better game, TOTK or even elden ring destroys red dead 2 for sure and i played them, the only lack of red dead 2 is having good gameplay and freedom
Why so insecure? This isn't a comparison on the better game.
if we follow logic , the better game would be the most sold one ; cuz every other opinion is subjectif , so the only objectf value that we have is statistique , a game that appeal to most the majority is the better game , so basically rdr2 almost smashes both zelda and elden ring combined ( and don't tell me sales don't mean shit , cuz if they were better , ppl will most likely buy them more and they would sell more copies , end of the story )
@@alaa341g huh?
Such a bad take.
@@alaa341g so by your logic minecraft, tetris, pubg, gta 5 are far far far better than rdr 2. and elden ring and botw won got but rdr 2 didn't
I went back to rdr2, because of Tears of the kingdom Zelda I came to realised and appreciate and love the open world environment much more.
I just have to say rdr2 felt like jt could've had a lot more to it
nice vid
Horse riding in Zelda is actually really good
Rdr2 blows it out of the water
Rockstar games >>>>>>>
Facts. Rockstar >>>>> kkds games
In gameplay Zelda is better...
@@JoseCarlos-lo6pg if the only positive point of your game is the gameplay it's very sad
@@pauldel7509 gameplay is the most important part of the game
@@pauldel7509ik rdr2 is one of the best story games to date but Zelda has a solid story incredible lore fantastic gameplay and good abilities rdr2 doesn’t have lore and the gameplay gets boring really fast (only reason I completed 6 play throughs was because of the story and post game stuff)
In terms of GAME, totk is better so far.
rdr 2 is a movie, totk is a game
Zelda totk es en mi opinión mas bonito y divertido mientras que rdr2 es mas realista e inmersivo pero si me dieran a elegir seria el zelda aunque rdr2 también me fascina
can you make a mecha in red dead 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
zelda it a great game thats very cartoonish and read dead redemption 2 got more realistic style
Why would you compare red dead with Zelda . It’s like trying to race and beat up old car against a hellcat like what smh
Red dead is the best game ever
🤣
@@ZR02012it is
red dead looks gloomy
skyrim
W
Hidrogen Bomb vs Coughing Baby
20gb vs 100gb
that doesn’t mean anything 😂
Rdr2 2018. Zelda 2022🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@anthonybastos1040 Zelda is better in gameplay
@@JoseCarlos-lo6pg gameplay? Ok.
Rdr2:
Grapichs
Story
Protagonist
Characters
Details
Imersive
LMAO rdr2>> zelfa
@@anthonybastos1040
Zelda:
Gameplay
Exploration
Level Design
Art direction
Creativity
Emparejamientos de Clash royale
Best video ever
Reaching
Comparing a big 150 GB game and a small 16.3 GB game. 🤣🤣🤣🤣 🤣
GOAT GAME VS TRASH ZELDA GAME 😅😅😅😅😅😅
@@anthonybastos1040gow 4 mandou lembranças 😂😂😂😂😂😂
rdr better
RD2. zelda is just a cheap genshin carbon copy 🙃
Retard alert. Botw which TOTK is based on was released 2017, therefore before Genshin.
💀
Dumbass 😂 I don't know which planet are you from genshin is the carbon copy of Zelda botw which is prequel of totk you people are so dumb.
Genshin Copy 💀
This is a f4cking kid saying shit💀
Skyrim better than Zelda
Nintendo games are made for kids 10 and under. This is why they do not have the best graphics, because they do not target adults, abd kids don't know any better.
You're joking. Zelda is played by adults all over the world.
The Zelda series is older than you are
Funny thing is red dead 2 game design treats you like a kindergarten, zelda TOTK game design treats you like an adult that allows you to be creative
@@hare75 bro watched NakeyJakey and could not make an opinion by himself.
Totk is way better than RED dead redemption 2
Nah
only a bit
KID?
@Pfplays Nope only fax stfu kid. Zelda won goty and RED dead redemption 2 did not LMAOOOO
At least 1 game has a main character with actual expressions