Honestly this is the most unresolved disappointing love story I've ever seen. I love stargate and the will they won't they between these characters over the years but the writers refused to give us a proper ending with them! I think there must've been disputes between the writers where some wanted to have them finally be a couple and some that did not and they ended up with the weird compromise we got which ultimately left it up to our imaginations. I always feel empty over the years when I've rewatched the series.
There was supposed to be a movie where it would be confirmed they got together, but the movie got dropped. But we have a new hope now, when Amazon bought MGM and the creator of Stargate SG-1 was working on a new story for some time
I've always felt the last scene should have been Harriman coming up and saying to Carter something to the effect "Colonel, phone call line 3. It's Jack." And leave the audience saying "O'neill?"
Omg, why didn't they ever just let her say that! Always attempting, but always interrupted or cut. I know it's obvious how they feel about each other, but I wanted to hear the actual "I love you" from both Sam and Jack
Yes and jack was later frozen in a stasis pod similar to Han being frozen in carbonite. And the battle over Antarctica was an homage to empire strikes back and the battle of Hoth. They should’ve named this episode the Goa’uld Strikes Back.
Genau das hab ich auch gedacht... Als ich die szene das erstemal gesehen habe, fing ich voll an zu fluchen. Schon, dass er es weiß aber könnte sie es vllt auch sagen, damit wir anderen das auch alle ganz offiziell wissen...grrrrrrrrrrrrr...das machen die mit Absicht
The way he dismissed her confession with an "i know" & silence then back to whatever he was doing like it was nothing.. was SUCH A BAD WRITING of this scene.. like it wasn't him in season 4 who said he cares about her more than he's supposed to, or that he'd rather die than lose her.. Now she's about to say out loud she loves him, yet he's dismissing like it's a banal thing then goes about his day without mentioning it again.
I always liked stargate SG1 but recently ordered the box set and will have next week so I have a binge session coming up . I thought Atlantis and universe were good in their own right.
They got together in other timelines/universes. Jack boinked her when him and teal'c had the day repeat thing going. They boinked in the jumper that one time when they got the zpm. They had tok'ra lie detectors prove they loved each other. I'm happy with all those. :)
I love how the comments are added here eleven years ago and a few months ago. This proves that the Stargate fandom is still not dead.
Help bring Stargate back savethegate.org
never :)
One a fan, always a fan
yeppp
We will never falter.
The audio commentary for this scene is awesome! Amanda Tapping says something like
"See, he resigned, I should have kissed him!!"
teehee
😂
Honestly this is the most unresolved disappointing love story I've ever seen. I love stargate and the will they won't they between these characters over the years but the writers refused to give us a proper ending with them! I think there must've been disputes between the writers where some wanted to have them finally be a couple and some that did not and they ended up with the weird compromise we got which ultimately left it up to our imaginations. I always feel empty over the years when I've rewatched the series.
There was supposed to be a movie where it would be confirmed they got together, but the movie got dropped. But we have a new hope now, when Amazon bought MGM and the creator of Stargate SG-1 was working on a new story for some time
I've always felt the last scene should have been Harriman coming up and saying to Carter something to the effect "Colonel, phone call line 3. It's Jack." And leave the audience saying "O'neill?"
there are probably thousands of people thinking in the back of their minds, "bastard scriptwriters"
Wasn't it obvious already ? The time loop when O'Neill kisses Carter...
@@tomf3150 everyone's favorite time loop.
"Sir... last time at your house what I was going to say was... I LOVE YOU I DON'T WANNA LOOSE YOU!"
Ahhh! What is it with all my fandoms?? "I know" "Does it need saying?" YES. Sometimes the audience wants to hear the words!
IKR! It is so annoyinggg
"As you wish" 😂
I don't understand how Pete even happened after this!
bad writers
Out of all of Sam's guys I really didn't like Pete the most.
Peter DeLuise was one of the show's producers/directors. He had it written in I think.And yes, he's Dom DeLuise(Urgo)'s son.
@@paulmichaelfreedman8334 of course it's literally because if the writers, but the whole storyline makes no sense after that scene.
@@momogoes3329 what about her ex-fiance who decided to play god?
well back to writing fanfics to mend my broken shippers heart!
:D
no! i dont know what she was gonna say! tell him you love him and just kiss marry have kids already!!
Omg, why didn't they ever just let her say that! Always attempting, but always interrupted or cut. I know it's obvious how they feel about each other, but I wanted to hear the actual "I love you" from both Sam and Jack
Was Jack’s “I know” an homage to Han Solo’s reply to Princess Leia just before he was frozen?
Yes and jack was later frozen in a stasis pod similar to Han being frozen in carbonite. And the battle over Antarctica was an homage to empire strikes back and the battle of Hoth. They should’ve named this episode the Goa’uld Strikes Back.
More of a rip-off 😂but okay
he resigned for gods sake kiss!!!
Resigned as a head of SGC, not as a general altogether.
@@Domihork the point was : by resigning he's not in her direct chain of command (which was the main blocking point for them being together)
@@Seagull_J.Livingston ooooh! I thought the problem was them both being in active duty in the Air Force. Thanks for clearing that up :)
He just resigned so why doesn't he let her talk???? "I know" is crap!
We were so close to a Sam and jack kiss. So close.
They definitely should have in this scene!
Genau das hab ich auch gedacht...
Als ich die szene das erstemal gesehen habe, fing ich voll an zu fluchen. Schon, dass er es weiß aber könnte sie es vllt auch sagen, damit wir anderen das auch alle ganz offiziell wissen...grrrrrrrrrrrrr...das machen die mit Absicht
MGM just get on and make the 'REVOLUTION' movie already!!!!
I’m rdy for it
Instead they went with Stargate Origins...bad call.
Dammit why wont he let her say it!
The way he dismissed her confession with an "i know" & silence then back to whatever he was doing like it was nothing.. was SUCH A BAD WRITING of this scene.. like it wasn't him in season 4 who said he cares about her more than he's supposed to, or that he'd rather die than lose her..
Now she's about to say out loud she loves him, yet he's dismissing like it's a banal thing then goes about his day without mentioning it again.
WTH where was i when this aired.....can't believe important seeing this for the first time major facepalm -___-
Stargate Lives!
I always liked stargate SG1 but recently ordered the box set and will have next week so I have a binge session coming up . I thought Atlantis and universe were good in their own right.
How’d you like it?
can we find the scene somewhere?????
Ja das hat mich auch voll angekotzt, wiedermal so kurz davor und dann das...
They got together in other timelines/universes. Jack boinked her when him and teal'c had the day repeat thing going. They boinked in the jumper that one time when they got the zpm. They had tok'ra lie detectors prove they loved each other. I'm happy with all those. :)
I think in the Groundhog Day episode he kissed her right before the reset. So no boink then.
I've always loved that kiss
I think it's the Lost City part 1
Warum konnte Jack sie nicht ausreden lassen? :(
@44hilla44 I like that whole idea!!!!!!!!!!
Nope. Did not do the or say. Foot hold!!!!!!
Thanks I will definitely look for it! >
@spacexbutterfly Hell YES!!!
Well who wouldn't like to LOL
agreed
What episode is that
It tells you in the first couple seconds. The Lost City 2. Season 7 episode 22
Was the scene shot?
yes :) in the episode number mentioned at the beginning of the video....