Being a union member I can tell you that there was a period where the unions were overreaching in their demands. I can also tell you that is no longer the case. We want to make a living and to be able to support our families. Somehow conservatives have painted union as wanting too much and making the US anti-competitive in the world; that average worker salaries should not be based on a minimum amount, but the lowest amount a manufacturer can get away with paying - while still giving bailouts and low interest loans to corporations and the wealthy that far exceed that of all those workers combined. We need to change people's minds about what unions are and what they actually do for the common worker.
You're spot on. Unions are the reason my parents could put me through college. It's sad that Gen Z has no clue about the source of legacy wealth they enjoy from their middle class grandparents.
I'm not anti union by any stretch of the imagination, but I find your first sentence and fourth sentence to be kind of weirdly out of touch with your points. Unions went too far but conservatives painted them in his light somehow? Sounds like unions did that on their own, or at least gave conservatives the ammunition necessary to make the argument. To be fair to your argument, I am sure conservatives didn't provide a nice nuanced and balanced approach to this and didn't overexaggerate anything at all, surely not, but unions kind of did this to themselves and if they are getting back to more real "for the worker" negotiations then great, but like Tim Ryan pointed out, perception changes slowly. It is going to take time to rebuild that reputation after decades of corruption and focuses on politician lobbying by union leaders and heads.
Polyamory doesn't work. Especially in America where some dominatrix surrounds herself with two or three simps with some queerness thrown in. But good old Bill, who can't keep a cat, is right there talking about nothing.
Polyamory actually works for some people, even a taxi driver in Egypt has 3 wifes. People in Utah do as well.. 😅 It just doesn't work for most people but there are exceptions 😊
@@pietrojenkins6901 maybe you didn't realize that fake is the way to go for most middle east countries... Why do you think they demand women to cover their hair?? So they can have multiple partners...
Honestly there are some places feelings should not be. Like when running giant superpower nations. You end up letting in enemies of our country and gangsters.
@@jenniferjeransky1352 Phil assumes the data that backs his good old boy GOP Christian schemata. But his view doesn't take into account the number of abusive or adulterous or disagreeable "monogamous" relationships that end in divorce, kids with parents living apart, or those who stay together but daily life is miserable.
MAGA math on full display. Pondering why she wanted to characterize 2018 as four years ago. Repeatable part of her standard stump babble? Some Maga yahoos will undoubtedly be spewing identical erred assertions now. Dumb asses!
I was a supervisor for several years at a major hospital system. You literally are forced to take anti-union training. Whatever you want to call it. How to report organization, what to say and not to say. They made it abundantly clear they will not be negotiating with any union. Edit: Which by the way should be a huge red flag to regular employees. A corporation doesn’t go to lengths to try to bust something before it even happens if they don’t fear it for some reason. If they don’t want it and are afraid it, it’s probably in your best interest to want it.
@@einundsiebenziger5488 It's called speech to text. Maher vs Mahar, both are European surnames easily confused by Google. Meanwhile, you must be a blast at parties 😉
I don't think that was comedy. I've seen the esteemed "Dr." get pretty pissed anytime he's challenged. He does not like being challenged. Bill was pushing his buttons, and good for Bill. He didn't back down. Phil is a bully.
I am a member of the union. And at least in my industry, some of these unions aren’t interested in the benefits of the workers they supposedly support, rather they provide the company with workers. Unions are good in theory but they come with a host of issues themselves.
Batya missed the main reason why unions are less popular now. That is due to Ronald Reagan’s union busting, specifically of PATCO. I wish someone mentioned this in the show.
Reagan committed so many crimes against America-great foreign policy, despicable domestically. And every republican since has been worse, both domestically and on foreign policy
@@ibuydigital1574Union wages and benefits drive non union wages as well. I am not a union member but have union clients and a lot of the trades are desperately seeking workers in today's world. It's not as exclusive as you seem to think. But it is hard work.
3rd year apprentice union plumber . Happy I joined; wish I did it right out of high school. I have free medical/dental/vision insurance plus an HRA card for related expenses, pension and way better wages than non union - we are always looking for more members. 5 years of school while also working 40-60 hours is a lot but my schooling costs me less than 200$ a year. If you are able bodied and like real life legos check out a trade. I've worked plenty of dead end jobs before finding my profession and career. Good luck and stay safe!
Phil ignores facts that don't fit his agenda. If three people like to be together and do the wild thing, good for them. 95% of my relationships "didn't work" by his standard since we never married or reproduced. But it was great at the time and I regret none of it. As long as they aren't harming anyone or breaking legit laws, what does it matter what people are doing behind closed doors?
But he's NOT talking about facts, as he doesn't produce any source for these facts, he talks out of his ass. He doesn't agree with something and so he condemns it without looking at the whole picture. Probably because he heard someone say something bad about it 15 years ago.
I’m a Union member and as a member I find it so unfair that an immigrant becomes a Union member just by buying their way in, while the us citizen has to be built through apprenticeship and go through the ruff times while the unskilled migrants get the top benefits
Unfair? They shouldn't even be allowed to hold a job let alone get a union card. Vote like your job depends on it because it does. Absolutely no D's and no RINO's. Only America first candidates please.
They band together to take over plot act against your interests to take over it is planned and You need to help stand against them. They say all the service jobs in NY were taken over this way and construction crews bragged about this to my brother in Colorado, Dirty tricks by them against non hispanics is on the plan.
@@816928 Written like a true nazi, the originators of the America First slogan. The GOP is an atrocious, hateful, self-centered bunch. Immigrants are doing work that US citizens have refused to do.
With regard to workers and unions, Tim and Batya are BOTH right. Tim is correct that Republicans have been working to diminish and undermine worker rights and unions for DECADES. But Batya is also correct that Democrats have all but abandoned them -- not just over immigration but because they've switched their focus from economics to demographics. They've become obsessed with "minorities" and "diversity" and have almost entirely forgotten courting WORKING CLASS people (their former base), REGARDLESS of color or demographic category.
Not correct on that second part, because unlike republicans, the Democratic party has actually proven it can walk and chew gum at the same time to be able to try to help ALL of the demographics you've just listed (minorities. diversity, working class, etc). Just because the republican party wants to make everything an either/or "win" scenario in SUPPOSED favor of their voting base over their opposition doesn't mean it's automatically a "both sides are just as bad" situation that means Democrats do the same thing. But understanding this reality requires the capability to compare what republicans SAY to what they actually DO when proposing/passing legislation.
I think it's more about taking voters for granted. They figured that the working class would automatically choose to vote for policies that align with their best interests. This assumption was wrong and Democrats need to make the case for every single vote.
Regarding the Unions, they're both right . Republicans have been waging war on them for decades, and Unions took a immigration policy stance that directly hurts their members
My first job was a retail job at a big national retail chain, and I remember expecting the onboarding training videos to be about the history of the company and about the company's distinctive culture; instead they were about the danger of unions, how unions would be bad for the employees, and about employees' responsibilities to report and stop any potential union-organizing activities they hear about or encounter, or risk losing their job
You should talk about RETAIL JOBS, as if these companies are any better. Have you seen how they price gouge us and now reduce the size of everything 16oz packages are now between 11 and 14 oz and cost more?
According to the American Psychological Association, approximately 40-50% of first marriages end in divorce. The divorce rate for second marriages is even higher, with approximately 60-67% of second marriages ending in divorce.
Here are some weird stats about divorce: Divorce rates are actually dropping in the US and have been for 20 years. 6% of divorces will result in remarriage to each other. Religious people are less likely to divorce as they view marriage a lot more seriously. Knowing divorced people increases your odds of getting divorced by 33-75%. And lastly older couples that marry tend to divorce less. So being an older, religious, never been married person who knows no divorcees is the best combo for success.
Right to work means you come in and work and take all the benefits that the Union has fought to get and don’t think you should pay dues to support it, but you still get all the benefits. I would think that if you didn’t want to work somewhere that has higher wages, better benefits, and pay union dues then go work somewhere with lower wages where you don’t have to pay dues. Right to work makes that decision for people so it’s easier to say no to paying union dues without people understanding why that’s not good.
Unions don't guarantee higher wages, auto makers in southern states are paid a higher wage when scaled to cost of living differences. What law gives a union the right dictate how an employer hires? It's all about intimidation. Of course there's the political contribution aspect.@@brentcoleman9075
Regarding Bills point about the SCOTUS delay of the Trump immunity case, I was disappointed that the elephant in the room wasn’t addressed. That being why did Jack Smith and Merrick Garland wait until 2023 to indict Trump. Truth is they delayed it way too long and this could have been settled by now.
The lady is 100% correct and spot on. It happened to a lot of us in Georgia & TN because of migrants. I will be voting for Trump, the borders need to be closed. It pisses me & other Americans off! We are fed up with it too! It shows in our votes on super Tuesday!
I was a union supporter since I was a child, coming from generations of blue collar union members. I was a union member until I discovered that my union had fixed a union election, called my union rep about it, and he screamed at me about all that the union had done for me, and hung up. Then, when I needed help, they were useless. I left the union and have not joined another.
I was never a union member but found out ALL non union jobs are fixed... come back and comment when you are over 50 when non union companies lay you off and you can't find a job other than pulling in shopping carts at supermarkets and department stores. Ain' that America home of the free? LOL.
When things like that happen members should be getting involved and fighting to make change vs leaving to go somewhere else. It is discouraging when those things happen but won’t change until members make their elected representatives more accountable for how they represent. At some point it was bad enough in the shop for people to come together and vote to become union, pretty much the same way they can vote to become non-union. Unfortunately when people start feeling like it isn’t worth being union is because they forgot what they fought to improve or weren’t there to fight for it in the first place.
@@jamescaldwell2357 I stand corrected sir! interesting though that law enforcement has a strong union, but union membership as Rep. Ryan said has been discredited over time since the 50's and 60's. Back then a CEO might make 7 times the av. worker's salary, now it is 70+ times and more.
@@timapple9157 In regards to CEO's growing salaries (etc)... we've been developing our own home-grown oligarchy fro decades. As for unions... union LEADERS absolutely are a part of that oligarchy. They *are* politicians... they work for "a" government, if not "the" government... and they are ELECTED. Union leaders are your "corporate government"... your *second* one. Think about this... Cali just passed a law to raise fast food workers' minimum wage to 20$/hr... but it's "only" 15$/hr for other workers. As a result, hundreds, if not 1000's... are going to get laid off... permanently. The ones who are left, are going to have to work harder as a result. So, if they "care" so much... why didn't they talk Newsome out of this, so that their members could keep their jobs? Aside from that, raising the minimum wage *causes* inflation. No, it's not the only cause, but it's one of them.
I hated how bill cut off Tim to ask that stupid question to Dr phil at the end, which he didn't even try to answer.. Tim was saying something important
Tim Ryan was in the process of taking that woman and her BS talking points about Unions apart and Maher cut him off. Kind of a dick move and irresponsible to let that BS stand without the pointed rebuttal that was about to come from Ryan. He's done this a few times lately, letting BS talking points go by without comment. It's sad.
Bill knows that his audience doesn't want to hear liberal talking points; Maher's primary audience seems to actually be more libertarian than liberal, like Bill Maher himself
Bill- this is what bothers me about when people make these pronouncements about the way another person lives their life- Dr. Phil- YOU ASKED ME! it took me out 😂
Unions were fine when they performed a positive service, but a lot of large unions nowadays are merely supplementing their necessity by bringing strike actions for more pay and benefits, instead of realizing that the high prices of labor is the main reason that large corporations have LEFT the US for cheaper labor. It's a fact that companies are in business to make a profit and if they don't, then why be in business. That doesn't mean they can run amuck over workers, but there are plenty of non-unionized companies that pay a good to great wage. I regretted seeing the union come in to the company I was working for because I took a $1.60 an hour pay CUT, not an increase!
Yes, except schools, and other civil services. But record millions and billions in bonuses to the top 3 or 4 executives in a company while people are having two incomes and barely making it is wrong. Insurance racket, housing and lending practices, and price gouging are tearing up our country so even two income families are flailing.
@@lisab9541 Well, since schools and civil services are NOT 'for profit' entities, I believe this is a non-starter. Also, many people who are having the two income families are also caused by the need to 'keep up' with the Jones and the toys. Granted, that is not ALL people, but many fit this bill.
I worked at Kaiser in Cali 1986 when our union advised striking. I was out 6 weeks received 1 check.for $60. Someone in the union had stole ALL monies from our dues. After that 6 weeks the union recommended the same contract they had advised to not accept.
The car manufacturers were making money hands over fist. They chose not to share any of it with their employees . I'm sure the unions members have a different opinion than you!!
Under Biden, the auto workers got one of the best deals ever, increased wages and working conditions. Unemployment is down, wages are up. Thanks Biden!
Congrats he forced those auto manufacturers to be even less competitive with Toyota and Tesla, Brilliant! Glad ford is catching on and building new facilities in non union states.
Unemployment is down naturally after the blue states opened up after shutting down during COVID. Wages are going up slowly but not really enough to counter inflation and the increased cost of living. Biden isn't doing good enough.
I saw Dr Phil on Rogan talking about people living high on the hog when they're on foodstamps and unemployment. The way he misrepresented and flat out lied was remarkable.
Dr. Phil's claim is entirely accurate though. It has been demonstrated by numerous socioeconomic census surveys that people taking out welfare benefits are far less fiscally responsible (hence their need to take out those benefits). One needs to look no further than the stats about poor folks who suddenly became lottery winners, then became broke in a matter of years and often months because of frivolous spending habits. It's grim, but you can't fault the data for being inaccurate here.
@@jacobwatson3781 If you are asking about the number on welfare that spend frivolously as a percentage of those on welfare, economist Thomas Sowell has excellent literature about the subject. Precise figures can vary depending on the study and methodology.
Yeah, she had them flustered a couple of times. Apparently she didn't have all of her facts right (according to the commenters here), but i definitely agree on the class issue, because that is clearly what is happening, also here in Holland. My colleagues come from diverse backgrounds, but we share our 'social status'. And it has been more than obvious that the higher educated are preferred, their mindset is what chased comedians like Seinfeld and Maher away from college and uni gigs in the first place. I'm sure Bill has connected these dots at some point, but yeah, he fails to fight for it, which is why he never gave Bernie his full support among other things.
I saw the episode where he read out the quote by the Jack Posobiec quote - "We're here to overthrow democracy completely, we almost got it done on J6, but we will endeavor to get rid of it and replace it with this right here (holds up a cross)" to the applause and "amens" of the crowd and co speakers. Batya Ungar-Sargon tried to dismiss this quote during the discussion as though Jack were joking, but it really does not seem at all that he, or the crowd is joking in the video.
I'm not a fan of Dr, Phil's position on vaccines or the pandemic and he clearly has Republican leanings but putting him in the same universe as Dr. Oz is crazier than Dr. Oz himself.
@@Luciphers_Workshop In the same way that hydroelectric and nuclear energy destroyed coal jobs. We can't keep clinging to the internal combustion engine as our sole mode of transportation.
@@SWLinPHX Yeah, what part? Was it when Dr. Phil told him in a respectful way that he's not there to make a political statement during the one on one, or was it when Dr. Phil cited actual statistics after Bill said some shit that wasn't true? Go to 1:40. Dr. Phil puts everyone in their place becasue you can't bullshit Dr. Phil. But go ahead, please, tell me where Dr. Phill got schooled.
She has the facts wrong about the Teamsters-they haven’t given the RNC $45K. I’m a Teamster and we just had a meeting the other day. The $45K is still sitting on the Teamsters desk. They explained that it’s just put aside so the Teamsters can attend and have a presence at the RNC convention. They feel it’s important that we attend and have a presence of members at both the DNC & RNC conventions this year. $45K is just the amount put aside to make that happen at the RNC convention. There’s another amount put aside for the DNC convention too.
Godamit Bill, when she asks are we better off in 2018...the answer is YES. Record low unemployment, record high stock market, inflation getting better...just have the balls to answer her.
Bill has been corrupted by his wealth and success. He has no idea what middle America is going through, or what raising a family entails because he is anti-family. Japan is collapsing for the same reason. They are not getting married and having families and they are cultural snobs who have been historically against immigration so their economy will collapse if they don't open their borders.
Trickle down economics never made it down to the workers, another stance that sounded good and the track record since shows who the real winners become. Have the workers wages and benefits increased as much as profits since then?? I think the data shows everyone the answer. Unfortunately that’s still not enough. The voice and reach of those with money will always silence those with less. The voices of those with less when collectively sticking together will always be louder.
One of my friend's is a union worker at tva ( a plant that provides power/electricity.) He worked at the plant for 47 years. An undocumented immigrant was hired. My friend's hours got cut down to part-time. The migrant got 40 hrs plus over-time hours making less wages than my friend. My friend was loyal to the company for 47 solid years, a very hard worker, never missed work, and was laid off. He had to just retire early, be cause the union and tva screwed my friend. Also, the migrant hit my friend several times. Bosses did nothing about it! The truth! The lady on this show is spot on correct to what happens to union and loyal American workers! The average American blue collar worker. Close the borders! Americans lose our jobs, get lower wages, and get screwed over by migrants, & our companies/employers hiring the migrants for less wages to save the company money! Open borders and migrants kill our jobs & wages! Truth! We are fed up with it too! I will be voting for Trump, because he completely understands this problem!
Your friend's company doesn't care about its workers... it has nothing to do with immigrants. Your friend's company would hire twelve-year olds to save a buck if it could. 😒
One thing I hate about bill is he does zero actual research nowadays. If writers don’t tell him he doesn’t know but he keeps talking like no one else knows either.
I bet you think cnn and msnbc and democrats are geniuses? The lady was the smartest on the panel but she needs to learn how to keep talking when tim ryan talked over her, rudely.
Because Unions support Immigrants is the problem? Unions have been relentlessly attacked by the GOP since Reagan because they are the most powerful "get out the vote" juggernaut that the Democrats have, and they are the largest donors to the Democratic Party. That women is a Trump/GOP sycophant, and too vapid to hold the job that she has.
She was brilliant, fair, incisive and clear. She clearly understands all of politics, not just the pro-establishment dogslop folks like you virtue-signal with. Honestly, get out of the way.
If a business is taking good care of their employees they should never have to worry about fighting off unions because it takes majority support to organize. If a majority of the workforce are not happy, is it always the workers? Or is it the employer?
The cost of living is the problem not wages. Who controls the costs of living? Wall Street. Once Wall Street drives up prices, that gives a greenlight to privately held companies to do the same until it saturates the whole economy.
Just last week a bunch of Google contractors made a union in Texas and demanded better conditions from Google. Google just laid off the entire team… Ironically while they were speaking publicly about how great they all did for forming a union to “speak truth to power”. … Well you spoke to power and power spoke back… Don’t get mad when it says something you don’t like. Everyone in the west has a consensual relationship with their employers, they don’t owe you a job and you don’t owe them your value. If you don’t like it, market your value somewhere else. I guess this is what happens when education changes focus from value to emotion.
4 millionaires thinking they know what's best for common Americans. I need a show where 4 people making 50-100k are treated as experts on what's best for rich people.
I like how the chick with the star of David chain brushed off the Michigan's Gaza vote as about immigrants as if immigration does not affect the rest of the country.
Phillip Calvin McGraw the ultimate opportunist, if Opera Winfrey had not been called down to Texas to court for slamming the meat industry no one would ever know who Philip Mcgraw was or is
I think it’s easy to extrapolate that couples have less emotional variables that threaten the relationship like a poly relationship would have. Threesomes are fun experiences but they are not sustainable relationships no matter what anyone’s denial tells them
In Germany we have a thing called "workers council" that is mandatory to be formed for every bigger company. It is like an incompany mini union. The lawmaker tells the companies how that council is elected and what rights and say it got. It is not a full union and it doesnt block unionmembership for the workers.
Being a union member I can tell you that there was a period where the unions were overreaching in their demands. I can also tell you that is no longer the case. We want to make a living and to be able to support our families. Somehow conservatives have painted union as wanting too much and making the US anti-competitive in the world; that average worker salaries should not be based on a minimum amount, but the lowest amount a manufacturer can get away with paying - while still giving bailouts and low interest loans to corporations and the wealthy that far exceed that of all those workers combined. We need to change people's minds about what unions are and what they actually do for the common worker.
Good comment.
You're spot on. Unions are the reason my parents could put me through college. It's sad that Gen Z has no clue about the source of legacy wealth they enjoy from their middle class grandparents.
There are good cops and bad cops. there are good unions and bad unions. The bad unions do make whole industries uncompetitive
@@oliversissonphone6143 To use your analogy, we don't do away with all the cops because there are some bad ones, do we?
I'm not anti union by any stretch of the imagination, but I find your first sentence and fourth sentence to be kind of weirdly out of touch with your points. Unions went too far but conservatives painted them in his light somehow? Sounds like unions did that on their own, or at least gave conservatives the ammunition necessary to make the argument. To be fair to your argument, I am sure conservatives didn't provide a nice nuanced and balanced approach to this and didn't overexaggerate anything at all, surely not, but unions kind of did this to themselves and if they are getting back to more real "for the worker" negotiations then great, but like Tim Ryan pointed out, perception changes slowly. It is going to take time to rebuild that reputation after decades of corruption and focuses on politician lobbying by union leaders and heads.
Polyamory. I don't want two people being permanently angry at me.
Polyamory doesn't work. Especially in America where some dominatrix surrounds herself with two or three simps with some queerness thrown in. But good old Bill, who can't keep a cat, is right there talking about nothing.
Polyamory actually works for some people, even a taxi driver in Egypt has 3 wifes. People in Utah do as well.. 😅 It just doesn't work for most people but there are exceptions 😊
@@Rasarel nooo, what kind of people get 3 wives ? Single is the way to go, you don't have to wake up to fake person/people next to you.
@@pietrojenkins6901 maybe you didn't realize that fake is the way to go for most middle east countries... Why do you think they demand women to cover their hair?? So they can have multiple partners...
@Rasarel if the women are submissive it can work. In the west it doesn't work.
Dr Phil admitting that he’s part of the “eff your feelings” gang…
“I barely care about my own feelings.” 🙌
It’s not “eff your feelings”. It’s facts and statistics don’t care about feelings. Too much logic for you?
Honestly there are some places feelings should not be. Like when running giant superpower nations. You end up letting in enemies of our country and gangsters.
That is the expression, however. Too much for you to understand?@@jenniferjeransky1352
He's always been a laughing stock
@@jenniferjeransky1352 Phil assumes the data that backs his good old boy GOP Christian schemata. But his view doesn't take into account the number of abusive or adulterous or disagreeable "monogamous" relationships that end in divorce, kids with parents living apart, or those who stay together but daily life is miserable.
I wish the audience stoped applauding, gets in the way all the time of the discussion etc.. frustrating
I agree!
Starting to wish I didn't choose "working class" as the phrase for my drinking game today
Well played.
You win the internet for today, my friend!
Ohhhh 💩 buddy.
Hang in there. 🙏🏽🤪
Cheers 🍻 from Cancún México. 🍹🤘🏽🇲🇽
I used "Racist " I'm Shit Faced all the Time ....
Lady, that's how you keep Union membership high, offering jobs. I wish the emigración problem began with work Visas.
😂
Whoever this Batya woman is kept asking if we were better off four years ago in 2018. Four years ago was 2020
It would have been better if she had never realized the mistake.
MAGA math on full display. Pondering why she wanted to characterize 2018 as four years ago. Repeatable part of her standard stump babble? Some Maga yahoos will undoubtedly be spewing identical erred assertions now. Dumb asses!
In fairness, I've blocked the COVID years out of my mind too lol
Batya is so use to Cherry Picking... and that's why she thinks to hate on, The Migrants. 😳🤭
Another Ann Coulter wannabe. Yawn.
Dr Phil dodging a red hot bullet at the end. 😂
I was a supervisor for several years at a major hospital system. You literally are forced to take anti-union training. Whatever you want to call it. How to report organization, what to say and not to say. They made it abundantly clear they will not be negotiating with any union.
Edit: Which by the way should be a huge red flag to regular employees. A corporation doesn’t go to lengths to try to bust something before it even happens if they don’t fear it for some reason. If they don’t want it and are afraid it, it’s probably in your best interest to want it.
Would never have imagined it, but Dr Phil and Bill Mahar should get a show. The way they combine and antagonize the other on issues is hilarious 😂
Only in the sense that Fredo antagonized Michael Corleone.
@@HansDelbruck53 well then Maher is Fredo for sure 🤣
Watching this show, God help anyone who actually got help from Dr Phil. I been to shrink and dr.phil does not talk like Dr or shrink but sooo judgy
Bill Maher* - what is it with this five-letter last name that so many can't even properly copy it from the title?!
@@einundsiebenziger5488 It's called speech to text. Maher vs Mahar, both are European surnames easily confused by Google. Meanwhile, you must be a blast at parties 😉
Best ending of overtime ever 😂
wow. cutting off someone making a real point, to talk about psycho women. overtime can be dumb but this was one of the dumbest EVER.
Wtf was he supposed to answer, then?@@hi-octanecomics404
Maher and Dr. Phil make a first-class comedy duo.
I don't think that was comedy. I've seen the esteemed "Dr." get pretty pissed anytime he's challenged. He does not like being challenged. Bill was pushing his buttons, and good for Bill. He didn't back down. Phil is a bully.
I would watch every episode of Bill & Phil
I am a member of the union. And at least in my industry, some of these unions aren’t interested in the benefits of the workers they supposedly support, rather they provide the company with workers.
Unions are good in theory but they come with a host of issues themselves.
Batya missed the main reason why unions are less popular now. That is due to Ronald Reagan’s union busting, specifically of PATCO. I wish someone mentioned this in the show.
How long ago was that? 40 plus years ago?
Only 6% of American workers are in unions, but more Americans would join if they had the opportunity.
@@Trumpetjoe40yeah I guess it was kind of mentioned then if that’s what he meant lol. But if he was more specific that would’ve been nice
Reagan committed so many crimes against America-great foreign policy, despicable domestically. And every republican since has been worse, both domestically and on foreign policy
Well, she's able to turn a blind eye to an awful lot.
Been a union member over 40 years, good wages, medical, and a pension.
Jon Stewart Explains Trickle Down: ruclips.net/video/u1U7k7yNyog/видео.html
There isn't enough unions for everyone, not a consistent solution. Congrats, you got into a exclusive club. Lots of unions are absolutely useless
@@ibuydigital1574Union wages and benefits drive non union wages as well. I am not a union member but have union clients and a lot of the trades are desperately seeking workers in today's world. It's not as exclusive as you seem to think. But it is hard work.
...and nothing wrong with that. Look at the benefits European blue collar workers get
3rd year apprentice union plumber . Happy I joined; wish I did it right out of high school. I have free medical/dental/vision insurance plus an HRA card for related expenses, pension and way better wages than non union - we are always looking for more members. 5 years of school while also working 40-60 hours is a lot but my schooling costs me less than 200$ a year. If you are able bodied and like real life legos check out a trade. I've worked plenty of dead end jobs before finding my profession and career. Good luck and stay safe!
"I don't care how you feel, I barely care how I feel. I'm talking about the facts." Well said.
In general yes, but I want to know where the hell Dr Phil gets these facts. What thruple stats does he know off the top of his head?
Phil ignores facts that don't fit his agenda. If three people like to be together and do the wild thing, good for them. 95% of my relationships "didn't work" by his standard since we never married or reproduced. But it was great at the time and I regret none of it. As long as they aren't harming anyone or breaking legit laws, what does it matter what people are doing behind closed doors?
But he's NOT talking about facts, as he doesn't produce any source for these facts, he talks out of his ass. He doesn't agree with something and so he condemns it without looking at the whole picture. Probably because he heard someone say something bad about it 15 years ago.
Watching Dr. Phil dunk on Maher has made my day
Tim, button up your shirt, you look like a budget version of Tony Soprano.
LOL!!!
dang dr phil doesnt look like he can even move his face anymore
I was noticing something was up.
Yeah he's looking a bit rough; I leaned over to my wife and said "either he's drunk or he's dying". 🤷♂️😂
Can't use his brain either
He looks high as Fk to me.
@@mofishin2648what did he say that makes you say that? Be specific
Go Dr. Phil . Smart guy and takes no BS.
I’m a Union member and as a member I find it so unfair that an immigrant becomes a Union member just by buying their way in, while the us citizen has to be built through apprenticeship and go through the ruff times while the unskilled migrants get the top benefits
Chump
Explain how that works.
Unfair? They shouldn't even be allowed to hold a job let alone get a union card. Vote like your job depends on it because it does. Absolutely no D's and no RINO's. Only America first candidates please.
They band together to take over plot act against your interests to take over it is planned and You need to help stand against them. They say all the service jobs in NY were taken over this way and construction crews bragged about this to my brother in Colorado, Dirty tricks by them against non hispanics is on the plan.
@@816928 Written like a true nazi, the originators of the America First slogan. The GOP is an atrocious, hateful, self-centered bunch. Immigrants are doing work that US citizens have refused to do.
With regard to workers and unions, Tim and Batya are BOTH right. Tim is correct that Republicans have been working to diminish and undermine worker rights and unions for DECADES.
But Batya is also correct that Democrats have all but abandoned them -- not just over immigration but because they've switched their focus from economics to demographics. They've become obsessed with "minorities" and "diversity" and have almost entirely forgotten courting WORKING CLASS people (their former base), REGARDLESS of color or demographic category.
Now why couldn’t she express it like that?
@@TreatzTMA I'm not sure, but she seems to be fixated on the immigration issue.
Not correct on that second part, because unlike republicans, the Democratic party has actually proven it can walk and chew gum at the same time to be able to try to help ALL of the demographics you've just listed (minorities. diversity, working class, etc).
Just because the republican party wants to make everything an either/or "win" scenario in SUPPOSED favor of their voting base over their opposition doesn't mean it's automatically a "both sides are just as bad" situation that means Democrats do the same thing.
But understanding this reality requires the capability to compare what republicans SAY to what they actually DO when proposing/passing legislation.
I think it's more about taking voters for granted. They figured that the working class would automatically choose to vote for policies that align with their best interests. This assumption was wrong and Democrats need to make the case for every single vote.
What did Drumpf do for the working class? How did those Billionaire tax cuts help the working class? Hell, he doesn't even like our military!
Dr. Phil is so much cooler when he's not walking on eggshells.
LOL, Dr. Phil is NEVER cool...he's an arrogant RINO who is way over
Dr Phil got it right. Some questions are just too stupid to answer.
Bill and Phil - new duo! Great together. 😊 Bravi, great show!
Regarding the Unions, they're both right . Republicans have been waging war on them for decades, and Unions took a immigration policy stance that directly hurts their members
And it was the Democrats led by Clinton in the '90s who moved to the right and offshored millions of jobs!
Republicans keep corruption out of the unions.
My first job was a retail job at a big national retail chain, and I remember expecting the onboarding training videos to be about the history of the company and about the company's distinctive culture; instead they were about the danger of unions, how unions would be bad for the employees, and about employees' responsibilities to report and stop any potential union-organizing activities they hear about or encounter, or risk losing their job
You should talk about RETAIL JOBS, as if these companies are any better. Have you seen how they price gouge us and now reduce the size of everything 16oz packages are now between 11 and 14 oz and cost more?
Batya Ungar-Sargon, my new hero!
We need more legal immigration and less illegal immigration.
Reform the system
According to the American Psychological Association, approximately 40-50% of first marriages end in divorce. The divorce rate for second marriages is even higher, with approximately 60-67% of second marriages ending in divorce.
Open relationships fail at a higher number.
Don’t think polyamory is going to improve the situation
@@meganturner1456It may help the divorce rate, as they won't be getting married in the first place.
Here are some weird stats about divorce: Divorce rates are actually dropping in the US and have been for 20 years. 6% of divorces will result in remarriage to each other. Religious people are less likely to divorce as they view marriage a lot more seriously. Knowing divorced people increases your odds of getting divorced by 33-75%. And lastly older couples that marry tend to divorce less. So being an older, religious, never been married person who knows no divorcees is the best combo for success.
Open relationships are not the solution.
So obvious Dr Phil has been on tv for years. Definitely better than most guests
100% right on Batya!
First time I've ever seen or heard of this lady, but I'd be fine never hearing her try to yell every point she has ever again.
Right to work doesn't ban unions, it just means you can't be forced to join a union just to work somewhere that has a union.
Unfortunately they get the benefit of working in a Union shop, leeches.
Right to work means you come in and work and take all the benefits that the Union has fought to get and don’t think you should pay dues to support it, but you still get all the benefits. I would think that if you didn’t want to work somewhere that has higher wages, better benefits, and pay union dues then go work somewhere with lower wages where you don’t have to pay dues. Right to work makes that decision for people so it’s easier to say no to paying union dues without people understanding why that’s not good.
There's a lot more to it than that
Unions don't guarantee higher wages, auto makers in southern states are paid a higher wage when scaled to cost of living differences.
What law gives a union the right dictate how an employer hires? It's all about intimidation.
Of course there's the political contribution aspect.@@brentcoleman9075
Regarding Bills point about the SCOTUS delay of the Trump immunity case, I was disappointed that the elephant in the room wasn’t addressed. That being why did Jack Smith and Merrick Garland wait until 2023 to indict Trump. Truth is they delayed it way too long and this could have been settled by now.
because they waited till the election year. It's called politics and political persecution.
They didn't want it settled by now, they want it in the news while he's campaigning.
The lady is 100% correct and spot on. It happened to a lot of us in Georgia & TN because of migrants. I will be voting for Trump, the borders need to be closed. It pisses me & other Americans off! We are fed up with it too! It shows in our votes on super Tuesday!
The public in this show applauds anything...
I was a union supporter since I was a child, coming from generations of blue collar union members. I was a union member until I discovered that my union had fixed a union election, called my union rep about it, and he screamed at me about all that the union had done for me, and hung up. Then, when I needed help, they were useless. I left the union and have not joined another.
Once you see it, its difficult to unsee it
I was never a union member but found out ALL non union jobs are fixed... come back and comment when you are over 50 when non union companies lay you off and you can't find a job other than pulling in shopping carts at supermarkets and department stores. Ain' that America home of the free? LOL.
When things like that happen members should be getting involved and fighting to make change vs leaving to go somewhere else. It is discouraging when those things happen but won’t change until members make their elected representatives more accountable for how they represent.
At some point it was bad enough in the shop for people to come together and vote to become union, pretty much the same way they can vote to become non-union.
Unfortunately when people start feeling like it isn’t worth being union is because they forgot what they fought to improve or weren’t there to fight for it in the first place.
Fact check from Wikipedia.on the lady in red, 12% of the US workforce are union members, not 6%. mostly in govt. or law enforcement
She said private sector. Those are not private sector jobs.
@@jamescaldwell2357 I stand corrected sir! interesting though that law enforcement has a strong union, but union membership as Rep. Ryan said has been discredited over time since the 50's and 60's. Back then a CEO might make 7 times the av. worker's salary, now it is 70+ times and more.
@@timapple9157 In regards to CEO's growing salaries (etc)... we've been developing our own home-grown oligarchy fro decades.
As for unions... union LEADERS absolutely are a part of that oligarchy. They *are* politicians... they work for "a" government, if not "the" government... and they are ELECTED. Union leaders are your "corporate government"... your *second* one.
Think about this...
Cali just passed a law to raise fast food workers' minimum wage to 20$/hr... but it's "only" 15$/hr for other workers.
As a result, hundreds, if not 1000's... are going to get laid off... permanently.
The ones who are left, are going to have to work harder as a result.
So, if they "care" so much... why didn't they talk Newsome out of this, so that their members could keep their jobs?
Aside from that, raising the minimum wage *causes* inflation. No, it's not the only cause, but it's one of them.
@@jamescaldwell2357 But why would she only include private sector jobs? Seems she did that just so she had an excuse to tout a lower number.
She was talking about non government union jobs
Phil hasn't been a doctor for years, that's never stopped him from bloviating!
America first! 🇺🇸
Dr phil is launching his own tv station in April so he's looking for viewers on all sides. So now he is taking out of both sides of his mouth
No he’s not talking out of both sides of his mouth give me a break
The minimum wage should be at least $20. Since 2009 CEOs salaries have increased by 400%. This is shameful.
SPREAD THE WEALTH! 8:24
Bill Maher and Phil McCraw are fucking hilarious together.
Put them on a show
Like the last question when everyone looked at Batya 😂
I hated how bill cut off Tim to ask that stupid question to Dr phil at the end, which he didn't even try to answer.. Tim was saying something important
Tim Ryan was in the process of taking that woman and her BS talking points about Unions apart and Maher cut him off. Kind of a dick move and irresponsible to let that BS stand without the pointed rebuttal that was about to come from Ryan. He's done this a few times lately, letting BS talking points go by without comment. It's sad.
which is why he cut him off.
Bill knows that his audience doesn't want to hear liberal talking points; Maher's primary audience seems to actually be more libertarian than liberal, like Bill Maher himself
Bill is so insecure about losing power on his show so he always makes smartass remarks,interrupts.
@@icantollieLOL
Bill- this is what bothers me about when people make these pronouncements about the way another person lives their life-
Dr. Phil- YOU ASKED ME! it took me out 😂
Unions were fine when they performed a positive service, but a lot of large unions nowadays are merely supplementing their necessity by bringing strike actions for more pay and benefits, instead of realizing that the high prices of labor is the main reason that large corporations have LEFT the US for cheaper labor. It's a fact that companies are in business to make a profit and if they don't, then why be in business. That doesn't mean they can run amuck over workers, but there are plenty of non-unionized companies that pay a good to great wage. I regretted seeing the union come in to the company I was working for because I took a $1.60 an hour pay CUT, not an increase!
Yes, except schools, and other civil services. But record millions and billions in bonuses to the top 3 or 4 executives in a company while people are having two incomes and barely making it is wrong. Insurance racket, housing and lending practices, and price gouging are tearing up our country so even two income families are flailing.
@@lisab9541 Well, since schools and civil services are NOT 'for profit' entities, I believe this is a non-starter. Also, many people who are having the two income families are also caused by the need to 'keep up' with the Jones and the toys. Granted, that is not ALL people, but many fit this bill.
Interesting. I suspect that’s the truth. Bringing in illegals gives them a slave class who can’t complain or demand more.
I worked at Kaiser in Cali 1986 when our union advised striking. I was out 6 weeks received 1 check.for $60. Someone in the union had stole ALL monies from our dues. After that 6 weeks the union recommended the same contract they had advised to not accept.
The car manufacturers were making money hands over fist. They chose not to share any of it with their employees . I'm sure the unions members have a different opinion than you!!
Under Biden, the auto workers got one of the best deals ever, increased wages and working conditions. Unemployment is down, wages are up. Thanks Biden!
That’s why cars are so expensive now right🙄🙄🙄
And what exactly did Biden do to help any of it? What policy or legislation did he enact?
@@dwaynecoy1871he stopped by the picket line for a 10 minute photo op. cause Trump said he was going to lol
Congrats he forced those auto manufacturers to be even less competitive with Toyota and Tesla, Brilliant! Glad ford is catching on and building new facilities in non union states.
Unemployment is down naturally after the blue states opened up after shutting down during COVID. Wages are going up slowly but not really enough to counter inflation and the increased cost of living. Biden isn't doing good enough.
I saw Dr Phil on Rogan talking about people living high on the hog when they're on foodstamps and unemployment. The way he misrepresented and flat out lied was remarkable.
Dr. Phil's claim is entirely accurate though. It has been demonstrated by numerous socioeconomic census surveys that people taking out welfare benefits are far less fiscally responsible (hence their need to take out those benefits).
One needs to look no further than the stats about poor folks who suddenly became lottery winners, then became broke in a matter of years and often months because of frivolous spending habits. It's grim, but you can't fault the data for being inaccurate here.
@g_4784 How many people are in the situation that Dr Phill talked about
@@jacobwatson3781 If you are asking about the number on welfare that spend frivolously as a percentage of those on welfare, economist Thomas Sowell has excellent literature about the subject. Precise figures can vary depending on the study and methodology.
I hope Dr. Phil flossed after that Bill M snack .
i actually loved dr phil's answer
Geez.. the clapping is unbearable..
Thanks God we had Bantya in the panel, a light of knowledge and truth. Telling Bill all the show that he was wrong in so many issues was priceless.
Yeah, she had them flustered a couple of times.
Apparently she didn't have all of her facts right (according to the commenters here), but i definitely agree on the class issue, because that is clearly what is happening, also here in Holland.
My colleagues come from diverse backgrounds, but we share our 'social status'.
And it has been more than obvious that the higher educated are preferred, their mindset is what chased comedians like Seinfeld and Maher away from college and uni gigs in the first place.
I'm sure Bill has connected these dots at some point, but yeah, he fails to fight for it, which is why he never gave Bernie his full support among other things.
Batya absolutely dominated🔥🔥
Natural gas is being replaced by lower cost solar and wind power
I saw the episode where he read out the quote by the Jack Posobiec quote - "We're here to overthrow democracy completely, we almost got it done on J6, but we will endeavor to get rid of it and replace it with this right here (holds up a cross)" to the applause and "amens" of the crowd and co speakers.
Batya Ungar-Sargon tried to dismiss this quote during the discussion as though Jack were joking, but it really does not seem at all that he, or the crowd is joking in the video.
WTH that was not the joke she claims that statement was
Really? You think he really said that out loud so everyone could hear it and he was serious? 🙄
@@vanessalore9942 Watch the vid yourself, but judging by his delivery and the response of the audience, yes.
Maher and Dr Phil should have a show together. As they are so different. Their pre show interview was funny.
Dr Phil got RIGHT under Bill's skin... That was entertaining
She just can't stop losing her s***.
How so?
You don’t take a cognitive test unless their is a concern. Dr. Phil and Dr. Oz have become a joke.
There’s not a concern?! 💀
There or their? Learn to spell before calling others a joke.
I'm not a fan of Dr, Phil's position on vaccines or the pandemic and he clearly has Republican leanings but putting him in the same universe as Dr. Oz is crazier than Dr. Oz himself.
Biden and to be fair Trump also have clearly declined from yesteryears. Biden is just no where near the same person he even was in 2012.
@@pepesilvia3776Not according to Kevin McCarthy and other Republicans who admit that behind the scenes Biden is sharp and well prepared at meetings.
Dr Phil and Bill Maher need their own show together. Hilarious.
I wish my politicians sounded like Batya
This is the perfect moment to ditch the duopoly. Support 3rd parties and independents. Stop being held hostage by corrupt liars.
Batya is not known by me but her rant against Biden is full of misinformation.
Batya... Mission Accomplished. 💃
Batya was on a mission with a shitty agenda. 😒 The truth had nothing to do with her plan on tonight's show.
Shes right though, ev has destroyed many jobs. Even FORD has shut down their ev truck line because of no demand
She’s a total rank hypocrite.
@@Luciphers_Workshop In the same way that hydroelectric and nuclear energy destroyed coal jobs. We can't keep clinging to the internal combustion engine as our sole mode of transportation.
She lied so much, it wasn't funny.
I love watching Dr. Phil put Bill in his place.
There was a lot of Bill putting Phil in his place in the one-on-one guest spot at the top of the show.
I think you missed it,.pal....it was the other way around
@@marialewis6432 Yes, exactly as I saw it and responded to him in my comment above.
@@SWLinPHX Yeah, what part? Was it when Dr. Phil told him in a respectful way that he's not there to make a political statement during the one on one, or was it when Dr. Phil cited actual statistics after Bill said some shit that wasn't true? Go to 1:40.
Dr. Phil puts everyone in their place becasue you can't bullshit Dr. Phil. But go ahead, please, tell me where Dr. Phill got schooled.
@@SWLinPHX Yeah, Phil cops out a lot.
I stil like hearing from him, but i cannot take much of what he says seriously.
She has the facts wrong about the Teamsters-they haven’t given the RNC $45K. I’m a Teamster and we just had a meeting the other day. The $45K is still sitting on the Teamsters desk. They explained that it’s just put aside so the Teamsters can attend and have a presence at the RNC convention. They feel it’s important that we attend and have a presence of members at both the DNC & RNC conventions this year. $45K is just the amount put aside to make that happen at the RNC convention. There’s another amount put aside for the DNC convention too.
Godamit Bill, when she asks are we better off in 2018...the answer is YES. Record low unemployment, record high stock market, inflation getting better...just have the balls to answer her.
Bill has been corrupted by his wealth and success. He has no idea what middle America is going through, or what raising a family entails
because he is anti-family. Japan is collapsing for the same reason. They are not getting married and having families and they are cultural
snobs who have been historically against immigration so their economy will collapse if they don't open their borders.
The people of ohio made a big mistake not electing ryan to the senate. JD Vance, are you kidding me
Batya Ungar-Sargon is head-and-shoulders smarter and more articulate than anyone else sitting at the table.
Was a good appearance once again from her.
Thank goodness Batya is here
Tim Ryan got it right about the right to work states. Union busting started under Ronald Reagan.
Trickle down economics never made it down to the workers, another stance that sounded good and the track record since shows who the real winners become.
Have the workers wages and benefits increased as much as profits since then?? I think the data shows everyone the answer. Unfortunately that’s still not enough.
The voice and reach of those with money will always silence those with less. The voices of those with less when collectively sticking together will always be louder.
It started flourishing under Reagan, but Tricky Dick got the ball rolling.
One of my friend's is a union worker at tva ( a plant that provides power/electricity.) He worked at the plant for 47 years. An undocumented immigrant was hired. My friend's hours got cut down to part-time. The migrant got 40 hrs plus over-time hours making less wages than my friend. My friend was loyal to the company for 47 solid years, a very hard worker, never missed work, and was laid off. He had to just retire early, be cause the union and tva screwed my friend. Also, the migrant hit my friend several times. Bosses did nothing about it! The truth! The lady on this show is spot on correct to what happens to union and loyal American workers! The average American blue collar worker. Close the borders! Americans lose our jobs, get lower wages, and get screwed over by migrants, & our companies/employers hiring the migrants for less wages to save the company money! Open borders and migrants kill our jobs & wages! Truth! We are fed up with it too! I will be voting for Trump, because he completely understands this problem!
TRUMP WILL WIN
Your friend's company doesn't care about its workers... it has nothing to do with immigrants.
Your friend's company would hire twelve-year olds to save a buck if it could. 😒
this is most pro republican show claiming to be balanced FYI UNIONS DON'T HIRE ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS AND CAR MAKERS ARE MOSTLY UNION IN THE NORTH
One thing I hate about bill is he does zero actual research nowadays. If writers don’t tell him he doesn’t know but he keeps talking like no one else knows either.
She's just regurgitating crap she read instead of actually going to the Unions and seeing for herself.
Oh BOY!! This Woman is CLUELESS!! WOW!! Stupid talking points...
If she is stupid then what do you call Biden policies?
What SPECIFICALLY is “clueless”, “talking points”?
She's awful, I doubt he'll have her back
I bet you think cnn and msnbc and democrats are geniuses? The lady was the smartest on the panel but she needs to learn how to keep talking when tim ryan talked over her, rudely.
Bill’s audiebce is awful clapping and laughing at everything and bill is awful. She was great! Smarter than her haters and the panel.
That woman was just so horrible in every way. Newsweek was once a credible news source.
Because Unions support Immigrants is the problem?
Unions have been relentlessly attacked by the GOP since Reagan because they are the most powerful "get out the vote" juggernaut that the Democrats have, and they are the largest donors to the Democratic Party.
That women is a Trump/GOP sycophant, and too vapid to hold the job that she has.
She was brilliant, fair, incisive and clear. She clearly understands all of politics, not just the pro-establishment dogslop folks like you virtue-signal with. Honestly, get out of the way.
@@jonathanbrown4237 I think she did great, and i wish Bill would pick up on the point of the class divide more.
Lol you sound really unintelligent John
Whoa!!! Batya Unyar-Sargon👍🏻
Anyone who owns a business knows how horrible unions are.
Cause they are fucking afraid of treating their employees like humans.
If a business is taking good care of their employees they should never have to worry about fighting off unions because it takes majority support to organize. If a majority of the workforce are not happy, is it always the workers? Or is it the employer?
free palestine
God bless Israel.
he doesn't exist anyway
The cost of living is the problem not wages. Who controls the costs of living? Wall Street. Once Wall Street drives up prices, that gives a greenlight to privately held companies to do the same until it saturates the whole economy.
Credit to Bill for bringing on three reasonable people
Just last week a bunch of Google contractors made a union in Texas and demanded better conditions from Google. Google just laid off the entire team… Ironically while they were speaking publicly about how great they all did for forming a union to “speak truth to power”. … Well you spoke to power and power spoke back… Don’t get mad when it says something you don’t like. Everyone in the west has a consensual relationship with their employers, they don’t owe you a job and you don’t owe them your value. If you don’t like it, market your value somewhere else. I guess this is what happens when education changes focus from value to emotion.
Don’t you love when your denied a job because you don’t speak a foreign language in America?
I guess it's just the beginning since now they are running commercials on TV and RUclips in Spanish.
Dr. Phil is the f’ing GOAT lol
4 millionaires thinking they know what's best for common Americans. I need a show where 4 people making 50-100k are treated as experts on what's best for rich people.
Fair play to Tim Ryan for standing his ground on unions.
Ryan, were YOU on that picket line?😮
I like how the chick with the star of David chain brushed off the Michigan's Gaza vote as about immigrants as if immigration does not affect the rest of the country.
Every single answer she gave was wrong. 🤠
Bravo. Truth is beautiful
I’m convinced dr Phil is an alien
The degree to which Maher is uninformed is astonishing!
Phillip Calvin McGraw the ultimate opportunist, if Opera Winfrey had not been called down to Texas to court for slamming the meat industry no one would ever know who Philip Mcgraw was or is
I don't think Bill likes Dr.Phil. LOL.
Also, the UAW supports Biden, so there's that BATYA. Sheesh.
Statistics show also, Mr. Phil, that couples don't work either. Humans gonna human.
I think it’s easy to extrapolate that couples have less emotional variables that threaten the relationship like a poly relationship would have. Threesomes are fun experiences but they are not sustainable relationships no matter what anyone’s denial tells them
Dr. Phillip, you ask him a question he doesn’t answer why did he get on the show just to advertise his show…
In Germany we have a thing called "workers council" that is mandatory to be formed for every bigger company. It is like an incompany mini union. The lawmaker tells the companies how that council is elected and what rights and say it got. It is not a full union and it doesnt block unionmembership for the workers.
Auto workers will vote against Joe cuz of NAFTA?
HUH! This woman is not on.
Jesus, they let the wacky lady dominate the talking time.