Hi friends! This is a 7-minute preview clip of a 45-minute episode with Dean Kishore. As per all 7-minute clips, we cannot explain every qualifier, solve the world's problems, or include all the caveats. We hope this clip will pique your intellectual interest. For longer-form interviews, we recommend Pak Gita's Endgame podcast with Dean Kishore here: ruclips.net/video/jn7Q9ZvXRcI/видео.html and ours, which will be coming up later this week. I also recommend the following videos that you may enjoy: - Dean Kishore’s TED Talk : ruclips.net/video/dsJWs6Z6eNs/видео.htmlsi=uaxjKvFmWKE7GUr- - Rise of the Asian Century with James Crabtree : ruclips.net/video/N5T0vpl8Jrg/видео.htmlsi=DxbuM9FNGuOrDh-4 - Asia Society Discussion : ruclips.net/video/PIfb7BUiqHY/видео.htmlsi=zu0HKmUBwjvtI0kh
Unable or unwilling? Kishor Mahbubani is just being diplomatic. War is America's bread and butter. It is not that it was unable to prevent the war in Ukraine and Gaza, it was unwilling to do so. It is in America's strategic interest that these and other wars be fought. The war theatre is now moving to Asia. This has been a top agenda for a long while now.
@Goodnightandgoodluck. My 2 posts agreeing with your sentiments were promptly deleted by empire censors. Why should an uprisimg by an oppressed people be condemned? Also, note that the very large number of Israeli troops and security personnel killed (550) is proof that it was a military operation.
They didn't want it, but did little to avoid it from being escalated. There is more downside than upside n history has proven it. Britain lost control coz it was involved in WW. Sure, America has major advantages, but major cracks have developed n it's prudent to have alternatives.
yes for the Neocons who believe in the American Century sheet. the empire is a sea power. the wars started under Bush, Afghanistan to control Central Asia, then Iraq in West Asia. things always look simple and doable on paper. LOL
To condemn Hamas by completely ignoring the past 75 years of history is bone-headed. I have always found Mahbubani to be fair minded. But not this time. I am disappointed at him. Losing it in his old age. What a pity.
Ikr😂. Should the Vietnamese demilitarize themselves too after the American Vietnam war because America may have been concerned for its security? Or take your pick of any number of conflicts. This man does not understand the basis of this conflict. It's so simple. It's probably one of the most simplest of conflicts I have ever researched
Interestingly there's no word about condemning Israel actions against the Middle East while there's no invading, provocation and yet this small island condemned Russia while being provoked by Ukraine as a pawn for Nato and the West. This Man has the gut to speak out what's thinking as the onus of happening.
Mr. M must toe the line carefully. He can’t criticise Netanyahu in keeping with s’pore’s alignment with the west. He’ll criticise Russia for “invading” Ukraine, but never Israel for ravaging Gaza. A bit of a hypocrite.
Would Singapore much smaller than Gaza would agree to live as a demilitarised state under Malaysia? Mahbubani is respected by us. So he should not step in an issue close to billions of Muslim.
@@VM-is8by not really. But due to racial demography. If singapore stay in Malaysia, both sides will experience instability due to numbers of Malay and chinese almost same. Actually this is now happening in Malaysia. Singapore able to avoid this thanks to 75% are chinese.
I used to look up to him as someone who's able to intelligently navigate around difficult and controversial topics, and a beacon of wisdom, but when he openly condemned Hamas for the Oct 7 attack and choose not to condemn IDF for the atrocities in Gaza, this is where we have to part ways. This conversation is no different from how the west sees the Israel Gaza conflict. We need strong leaders to do the right things rather than the easy ones.
@@alexpkeaton4471I was just about to comment the same thing. US says one thing and does another. It's not about their leaders are strong or not. It is the unofficial foreign policy and it really doesn't matter whether it's a Democrat or Conservative govt. The stirring of trouble around the globe has continued and will continue. Kishore is a name dropper. He probably thinks that would bolster his statements.
I don't agree that the wars in Ukraine and Middle East is a result of weak leaders in the West. The reason is Middle East problem has been going for 75 years and has gone through many changes in Western leaders. Similarly, Ukraine problem started years ago and again over mant changes in Western leadership. The problem is the imperialist nature of the Western cultures which have been going on since centuries ago invading and taking over others like the colonial periods. And this continued cos the West got strong and build military n financial structures to keep them in power n any challenges even by their own kinds are put down. e.g. when Germany got economically and technically strong US see it as a challenge, France faced the same, so is Japan. So it is not the weaknesses of the Western leadership it is the nature of Western civilisation that see the rest of the world as phariah😂
pepsi or coke, GOP DNC are the same heads on the serpent, Trump is somewhat of a anomaly but I believe he knows if he goes against the deep state too much he too will be eliminated.
😂😂😂 I disagree that Merkel was for peace. She herself said the Minsk Agreement with Russia was to allow Ukraine build up it's arm force with NATO help to fight Russia. That's is not resist Ukraine to join NATO but to give Ukraine time. 😂😂 All her credibility n trust is lost by just that fact.
Please search for the videos online. Hamas went into Israel to take hostages to be used as bargains against the thousands in Israeli prisons. Then, Israeli defence forces intervened per helicopter and other means, lengthy shootings followed and many civilians were killed in this crossfire. Hamas never went in to kill civilians.
I think Kishore has mischaracterized Gaza stuff. Everyone aside from Iran/Hezbollah/Houthi all voted in favor or abstain for whatever Israel is doing with their action. Most countries pay lip service, some countries can't even do that, and then there is US which is actively bolstering Israel. Look, 99% of government want to pass an actual genocide killing 2 millions under people's eyes and there is nothing could be done (whatever civilians do amount to 2% of decision making), in 21st century. Two things that is keeping 2 million people alive, Israel incompetence and Houthi/Hezbollah. It's the same thing with Ukraine, perpetuators on one side, other nuclear state on the other. Russia/China can stop Gaza but it's very dangerous to escalate with US. US can stop Ukraine but same reason. Gridlock and people dies.
Kishore mentioned the deterioration OF WESTERN LEADERS led to disastrous consequences. I also heard in Taiwan media (and my own observation) that American leadership also showed trend of leadership deteriorations since Kennedy. The question is WHY? My quess is "liberal democracy' is the cause as such system always push leaders into "populism politics'.
@@wnklee6878 This is the world of nationalism. In every country in the world, people feel strongly about not being ruled by foreigners. Of course it is hard. This is the information age, people everywhere know what happens on the other side of the world. They have multiple channels of information. They are also much better educated. Even in the poorest countries, literacy is far below 50 years ago. Of course it is hard. I actually argue that ruling the world is impossible. You are much better off making friends and business partners.
@waichui2988 I agree! I only wanted to say that the US will never give up trying to continue ruling the world. The US act according to the law of the jungle.
On the question of the killing of civilians, Western or Western influenced academics which Kishore clearly is, always follow the narrative that terrorist organization like HAMAS must be condemned even as they condemned Israeli 'retaliation'. I think this is an ingenuous way by Western intellectuals to continue the narrative to justify Israel's claim of self-defence. I see this blurring of the righteous Human Rights of the Palestinians to armed self-defence against an occupying force as provided by the UN as utterly unacceptable. I think the rest of the non-Western world is waking up to the immorality of this Western narrative.
Throughout 12,000 years since the advent of Human Civilizations, War Conflicts have had been always unavoidable ... and will continue to be unavoidable ..as humanity looks forward to more War Conflicts, as there would always be some profits and gains to engage in more Wars and even to prolong the War. The motivations are always these: Money, Power Fame and Immortality !.
Francis Fukuyama did a good job on behalf of Asia. His book put the West and especially the US State Dept into sleep for two decades. Now that Asia and especially China has progressed so far the West can't do anything.
I completely do not share his view. How could one person, some more with Asian name say one sentence and followed by one billion western people. Such exaggeration doesn't make any logical sense. It was the unilateral power that west could dictate the entire world make the people feeling the entitlement.
2024 Oct 23 now BRICS MEMBERSHIP additional 13 partner countries: Algeria, Belarus, Bolivia, Cuba, Indonesia, Kazakhstan, Malaysia, Nigeria, Thailand, Türkiye, Uganda, Uzbekistan, and Vietnam. How Kishore Mahbubani think of ASEAN deal with Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand & Vietnam being part of BRICS now. How S'pore think of Malaysia part of BRICS & they not.
I think the British colonization of India was a strategic mistake too. Do you need to be reminded of that. This reminds of Ann Coulter calling out Vivek for being Indian.
Kishore Mahbubani is a wise man. All the Western warmongers have forgotten the Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan etc, as well as, WWII. Now only see the quarterly ROI of the military-industrial complex.
@@Jadichoo thanks for the comment. My father survived Stalingrad he never spoke about it, during the Vietnam war we protected a USA drafted conscript in Sweden and the story goes on.
I think that Kishore is right here about a lot of things, though I do think he underestimates the influence of the Israel lobby and the fact that no American President wants to spend the political capital to defy that very powerful group for the sake of the Palestinians or long-term peace. So, they kept kicking the can down the road, assuming that Palestinians could be set aside. Everything else, Kishore is right about.
Run🎉🎉❤❤Faker Gangyang Like Bollywood movies 🎉🎉🎉 Yesterday was eventful gambit🎉 historical past ❤ Masy'Allah Alhamdulillah syukur rezeki kita seluas hamparan langit biru aamiin
Why should there be an opinion like regretting western leaders incompetence. Aren't they so called chosen leaders by their proud people? There is no deserving nation on earth, all are equal. While Europe contributed to plenty of good to the world, they contributed even more opposite to the world. The world colonisation started from where? And of three very big pieces of land, owned by Aborigines, Indians in Australia, Canada, and North America, whose descendants take the full ownership and privilege today? Were the land being purchased at fair price from original owners? And seeing major museums in Europe major cities, most of the artefacts are coming from where? Were all those items purchased with fair price?
Appreciate & Respect your expertise. Please don't forget to mention the innocence killings of Palestinians ( it's though they are target practicing on them ) for the last 7 decades or more
It's too big a chunk to chew, bro.Let talk about ourselves, The Brics,the so called logistics US base,The Lees treatment of Chinese during the 60s,The lees sanctions on Russia, etc.
He is right about Ukraine. He is wrong on his arguments on gaza. Israel can never be authorised on palestine. There cannot be a 2 state solution. Both don't want it
1000 trillions dollars US CDS funds is too big to be controled... like a maddened horse that has broken loose from its chains and is rushing into the abyss.
With Ukraine you are missing the point...America wanted to push russia to the edge...it wanted to be on its boarders...and I don't condem hamas...its clear others followed hasas out of prison and went not professional like hamas who intended a military op with its limited resources after the Palestinians had exhausted all other options as it was dealing with an enermy that was unreasonable...and its support the empire doesn't negotiate
Professor Mahbunani I used to listen to your lecturing of global affairs but today when you're talking about Hamas and Palestine you sound an apologistick.
A Russian guy here. I have a feeling the West is doing what China did at some point - decided to become closed/isolated. "China before 1840 was completely closed, isolated from the rest of the world, except for the limited foreign trade in the city of Canton"
There is NO reason to blame HARMAS , they had been under besieged for decades. Their land Golan height had been occupied. Don't they have the right to fight back.
Also kishore doesnt know, THOUSANDS of babies and children are still under the rubble in GAZA. And kishore needs to tell us the origins of the palestinian people,from where did they come from?
Our dear kishore, this is what you never knew or isn't in your knowledge . Israel doesn't get to decide whether or not the palestinians have a right to self-determination, this is something that is enshrined in the united nations charter, it is something that is enshrined into international law, it is also a founding principle of the united nations decision to found Israel! So,you know it is absolutely necessary that Israel accepts that it cannot exist without the existence of a palestinian state!. So please pass this message to Mr benzion mileikowsky .(satanyahu) also talk of what has been happening since 1948, also please talk about the massacre of "sabra and shatila " refugees camps, in just a period of just 4 hours Sharon butchered 3850 women and children.
Jadichoo >if you have a better analysis of these events, please write a book or even better let us know by arranging to get interviewed for your opinion. Or we will think you are full of it.
@@sword7872 there are many books written contrary to the snake oil book. Go read the book written by the 3 researchers that recently won the Nobel prize for economics. Then you will finally understand why the snake oil salesman is just full of it.
You know exactly what's up. However, you are holding back and being super diplomatic!!! Why don't you talk about 75 years of atrocities by the artificial entity! You are a ZIO Lover!!!!!!!!
Hi friends!
This is a 7-minute preview clip of a 45-minute episode with Dean Kishore.
As per all 7-minute clips, we cannot explain every qualifier, solve the world's problems, or include all the caveats.
We hope this clip will pique your intellectual interest.
For longer-form interviews, we recommend Pak Gita's Endgame podcast with Dean Kishore here: ruclips.net/video/jn7Q9ZvXRcI/видео.html and ours, which will be coming up later this week.
I also recommend the following videos that you may enjoy:
- Dean Kishore’s TED Talk : ruclips.net/video/dsJWs6Z6eNs/видео.htmlsi=uaxjKvFmWKE7GUr-
- Rise of the Asian Century with James Crabtree : ruclips.net/video/N5T0vpl8Jrg/видео.htmlsi=DxbuM9FNGuOrDh-4
- Asia Society Discussion : ruclips.net/video/PIfb7BUiqHY/видео.htmlsi=zu0HKmUBwjvtI0kh
Unable or unwilling? Kishor Mahbubani is just being diplomatic. War is America's bread and butter. It is not that it was unable to prevent the war in Ukraine and Gaza, it was unwilling to do so. It is in America's strategic interest that these and other wars be fought. The war theatre is now moving to Asia. This has been a top agenda for a long while now.
Hamas should be condemned? what about the atrocities israel has committed since 1948?
❤exactly
@@petergreen5337 yes
@Goodnightandgoodluck. My 2 posts agreeing with your sentiments were promptly deleted by empire censors. Why should an uprisimg by an oppressed people be condemned? Also, note that the very large number of Israeli troops and security personnel killed (550) is proof that it was a military operation.
My 3 posts agreeing with your semtiments were immediately deleted by empire censors. No one should condemn an uprising by an oppressed people.
Don’t you think the Americans actually wanted this war?
Yes, Israel does nothing on its own without approval.
They didn't want it, but did little to avoid it from being escalated.
There is more downside than upside n history has proven it. Britain lost control coz it was involved in WW. Sure, America has major advantages, but major cracks have developed n it's prudent to have alternatives.
@@karatsurba4791 I disagree, I believe they wanted it in Ukraine but not directly via them. The Gaza war caught them by surprise though.
Yes, that’s their war economy
yes for the Neocons who believe in the American Century sheet. the empire is a sea power. the wars started under Bush, Afghanistan to control Central Asia, then Iraq in West Asia.
things always look simple and doable on paper. LOL
Jai Hind. The Rules based One World Order using UN, ICC, ICJ and Western NGOs had died in the Gaza genocide.
I mean not really
@@TacticalMayo Yes really, cope
Yes agree🎉
To condemn Hamas by completely ignoring the past 75 years of history is bone-headed. I have always found Mahbubani to be fair minded. But not this time. I am disappointed at him. Losing it in his old age. What a pity.
Yes he has to carry the Americunts balls lah.
If not cannot go the UAssA again to plough his wealth lah😅
Money talks
everyne lowers theır level when ıt comes to West's Israel project
"Israel is concerned about its security" . But Palestine's security takes less importance amirite ?
Ikr😂. Should the Vietnamese demilitarize themselves too after the American Vietnam war because America may have been concerned for its security? Or take your pick of any number of conflicts. This man does not understand the basis of this conflict. It's so simple. It's probably one of the most simplest of conflicts I have ever researched
Interestingly there's no word about condemning Israel actions against the Middle East while there's no invading, provocation and yet this small island condemned Russia while being provoked by Ukraine as a pawn for Nato and the West. This Man has the gut to speak out what's thinking as the onus of happening.
Exactly my thought, singapore is another puppy
Mr. M must toe the line carefully. He can’t criticise Netanyahu in keeping with s’pore’s alignment with the west. He’ll criticise Russia for “invading” Ukraine, but never Israel for ravaging Gaza. A bit of a hypocrite.
@@TakeThis-z7v a great hypocrite!
Would Singapore much smaller than Gaza would agree to live as a demilitarised state under Malaysia? Mahbubani is respected by us. So he should not step in an issue close to billions of Muslim.
I do not really understand the logic, why israel security is a concern, is Palestine security not a concern at all?
Singapore becomes as a separate nation is due to Islam...read history😂😂😂😂
@ By using your knowledge and logic ‘Due to Islam Palestine will become a separate nation, not a demilitarised one’.
@@VM-is8by not really. But due to racial demography. If singapore stay in Malaysia, both sides will experience instability due to numbers of Malay and chinese almost same.
Actually this is now happening in Malaysia. Singapore able to avoid this thanks to 75% are chinese.
I used to look up to him as someone who's able to intelligently navigate around difficult and controversial topics, and a beacon of wisdom, but when he openly condemned Hamas for the Oct 7 attack and choose not to condemn IDF for the atrocities in Gaza, this is where we have to part ways. This conversation is no different from how the west sees the Israel Gaza conflict. We need strong leaders to do the right things rather than the easy ones.
Singapore supports Israel 🇮🇱.
I don't understand an Indian origin intellectual mentioning Churchill as an exemplary leader...
That’s another issue .
Naive. Has zewro class consciousness. No understanding of Israel's role as attack dog for the US Empire.
It's pretty wild that he seems to believe that the US ever actually wanted the two state solution.
@@alexpkeaton4471I was just about to comment the same thing. US says one thing and does another. It's not about their leaders are strong or not. It is the unofficial foreign policy and it really doesn't matter whether it's a Democrat or Conservative govt. The stirring of trouble around the globe has continued and will continue.
Kishore is a name dropper. He probably thinks that would bolster his statements.
I don't agree that the wars in Ukraine and Middle East is a result of weak leaders in the West. The reason is Middle East problem has been going for 75 years and has gone through many changes in Western leaders. Similarly, Ukraine problem started years ago and again over mant changes in Western leadership. The problem is the imperialist nature of the Western cultures which have been going on since centuries ago invading and taking over others like the colonial periods. And this continued cos the West got strong and build military n financial structures to keep them in power n any challenges even by their own kinds are put down. e.g. when Germany got economically and technically strong US see it as a challenge, France faced the same, so is Japan. So it is not the weaknesses of the Western leadership it is the nature of Western civilisation that see the rest of the world as phariah😂
The good news is that in 2 months' time, Blinken will no longer be the Sec of State
Did u c how Trump becomes pliable to Bibi in their press conference when trump was in power.
Anyways, one can always hope.
They don't pick good men for secretary of states anyway. Wasn't pompeo just as terrible? All they want is war.
pepsi or coke, GOP DNC are the same heads on the serpent, Trump is somewhat of a anomaly but I believe he knows if he goes against the deep state too much he too will be eliminated.
if u think little Marco is better blinkin ur really delusional
@calioumarx4289 We know little Marco hates China and he is not hiding it. Blinken on the other hand is two-faced and he lied all the time.
Merkel did. She did caution and resisted Ukraine joining NATO.
😂😂😂 I disagree that Merkel was for peace. She herself said the Minsk Agreement with Russia was to allow Ukraine build up it's arm force with NATO help to fight Russia. That's is not resist Ukraine to join NATO but to give Ukraine time. 😂😂 All her credibility n trust is lost by just that fact.
Merkel was the best Germany chansollor ever. She was liked by the whole free world.
Please search for the videos online. Hamas went into Israel to take hostages to be used as bargains against the thousands in Israeli prisons. Then, Israeli defence forces intervened per helicopter and other means, lengthy shootings followed and many civilians were killed in this crossfire. Hamas never went in to kill civilians.
Such a disappointment professor, your assessment about the Palestine and middle east is totally bias and unbalance, you are not a smart man after all
What an ignorant person who doesn’t condemn Israeli atrocities over 75 years😢😢😢😢
I think Kishore has mischaracterized Gaza stuff. Everyone aside from Iran/Hezbollah/Houthi all voted in favor or abstain for whatever Israel is doing with their action. Most countries pay lip service, some countries can't even do that, and then there is US which is actively bolstering Israel. Look, 99% of government want to pass an actual genocide killing 2 millions under people's eyes and there is nothing could be done (whatever civilians do amount to 2% of decision making), in 21st century. Two things that is keeping 2 million people alive, Israel incompetence and Houthi/Hezbollah. It's the same thing with Ukraine, perpetuators on one side, other nuclear state on the other. Russia/China can stop Gaza but it's very dangerous to escalate with US. US can stop Ukraine but same reason. Gridlock and people dies.
The concept of an Asian century was unthinkable for the West in 1990s because at that time Asia equated Japan and Japan already started the decline.
Churchill, as a strategic thinker, is overstated. Eisenhower is acceptable and praiseworthy.
Gazans were incarcerated for decades. What about this outrage ? Aren't you forgetting this ?
Kishore mentioned the deterioration OF WESTERN LEADERS led to disastrous consequences. I also heard in Taiwan media (and my own observation) that American leadership also showed trend of leadership deteriorations since Kennedy. The question is WHY? My quess is "liberal democracy' is the cause as such system always push leaders into "populism politics'.
Probably Deep State loves puppets who can’t string a sentence together?
Nice studio, kishore looks at home here.
Ruling the world is not as easy as it used to be.
Boy are we ever going to have a bunch of problems in this planet now.
@@wnklee6878 This is the world of nationalism. In every country in the world, people feel strongly about not being ruled by foreigners. Of course it is hard.
This is the information age, people everywhere know what happens on the other side of the world. They have multiple channels of information. They are also much better educated. Even in the poorest countries, literacy is far below 50 years ago. Of course it is hard.
I actually argue that ruling the world is impossible. You are much better off making friends and business partners.
@waichui2988 I agree! I only wanted to say that the US will never give up trying to continue ruling the world. The US act according to the law of the jungle.
On the question of the killing of civilians, Western or Western influenced academics which Kishore clearly is, always follow the narrative that terrorist organization like HAMAS must be condemned even as they condemned Israeli 'retaliation'. I think this is an ingenuous way by Western intellectuals to continue the narrative to justify Israel's claim of self-defence.
I see this blurring of the righteous Human Rights of the Palestinians to armed self-defence against an occupying force as provided by the UN as utterly unacceptable. I think the rest of the non-Western world is waking up to the immorality of this Western narrative.
Wow, Keith. This is a job well done! Thank you!
I'm glad the west listened to Fukuyama
Throughout 12,000 years since the advent of Human Civilizations, War Conflicts have had been always unavoidable ... and will continue to be unavoidable ..as humanity looks forward to more War Conflicts, as there would always be some profits and gains to engage in more Wars and even to prolong the War. The motivations are always these: Money, Power Fame and Immortality !.
The US, Israel, and some European countries they have opened a can of worms - what do you think is going to happen when the Gaza orphans grow up?
West really didn't think Russia could win the war in Ukraine. Given all the technology and training we poured into Ukraine.
Haha
I find it interesting that he always adds "one on one" whenever he mentions his last conversation with HK.
A weak, biased and short sighted analysis by Kishore. What a pity!
Francis Fukuyama did a good job on behalf of Asia. His book put the West and especially the US State Dept into sleep for two decades. Now that Asia and especially China has progressed so far the West can't do anything.
I completely do not share his view. How could one person, some more with Asian name say one sentence and followed by one billion western people. Such exaggeration doesn't make any logical sense.
It was the unilateral power that west could dictate the entire world make the people feeling the entitlement.
Gordon Chang is better. I suspect Gordon Chang is a CCP agent.
That shirt is a violation of international law
2024 Oct 23 now BRICS MEMBERSHIP additional 13 partner countries: Algeria, Belarus, Bolivia, Cuba, Indonesia, Kazakhstan, Malaysia, Nigeria, Thailand, Türkiye, Uganda, Uzbekistan, and Vietnam. How Kishore Mahbubani think of ASEAN deal with Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand & Vietnam being part of BRICS now.
How S'pore think of Malaysia part of BRICS & they not.
Excellent summary! Thank you!👌
Incredibly enlightening!!
I think the British colonization of India was a strategic mistake too. Do you need to be reminded of that. This reminds of Ann Coulter calling out Vivek for being Indian.
Israel has a right to defend itself
invaders & occupiers have rights?
@henryyip1 Ignorance is bliss. It is Jewish land since day one. Quit spewing the terrorist narrative
Kishore Mahbubani is a wise man.
All the Western warmongers have forgotten the Korea, Vietnam, Afghanistan etc, as well as, WWII.
Now only see the quarterly ROI of the military-industrial complex.
He’s an Attention Seeking Fox … he’s trying very Hard not saying that WAR is BIG Business to some Countries … Always follow the Money 😊
@@AlexanderKopriwa do you really know anything about those wars? You don't sound like you do all
@@Jadichoo thanks for the comment. My father survived Stalingrad he never spoke about it, during the Vietnam war we protected a USA drafted conscript in Sweden and the story goes on.
@@Hs5687 correct follow the money trail
I think that Kishore is right here about a lot of things, though I do think he underestimates the influence of the Israel lobby and the fact that no American President wants to spend the political capital to defy that very powerful group for the sake of the Palestinians or long-term peace. So, they kept kicking the can down the road, assuming that Palestinians could be set aside. Everything else, Kishore is right about.
Hi Keith, would there be a podcast on Mr Mahbubani?
❤An accurate analysis. Thank you very Professor
Why can't the West produce quality quality leaders?
Run🎉🎉❤❤Faker Gangyang Like Bollywood movies 🎉🎉🎉 Yesterday was eventful gambit🎉 historical past ❤ Masy'Allah Alhamdulillah syukur rezeki kita seluas hamparan langit biru aamiin
Ukraine did not keep sending rockets into Russia nor take Russian hostages, while claiming to want peace.
Amb. Mahbubani's comments are right on target. Where are these voices in the collective West??
When has the West ever not been Unwise?
I think when the US govt talk about the 2 state solution, they mean the 2 swing states of Michigan and Pennsylvania
The current US administration is duplictious as often when a leadership is weak, ineffective, continues on this trajectory of disingenuity.
Why should there be an opinion like regretting western leaders incompetence. Aren't they so called chosen leaders by their proud people? There is no deserving nation on earth, all are equal.
While Europe contributed to plenty of good to the world, they contributed even more opposite to the world. The world colonisation started from where? And of three very big pieces of land, owned by Aborigines, Indians in Australia, Canada, and North America, whose descendants take the full ownership and privilege today? Were the land being purchased at fair price from original owners?
And seeing major museums in Europe major cities, most of the artefacts are coming from where? Were all those items purchased with fair price?
Demilitarized state?!
So your superior political intellect told you the Palestinians will accept this humiliating solution?!
Appreciate & Respect your expertise. Please don't forget to mention the innocence killings of Palestinians ( it's though they are target practicing on them ) for the last 7 decades or more
Good analysis.
Lovely shirt Mr Mahbubani! 😍🧡🏵️ x
North America will continue to dominate, and Asia will become even poorer. This dude doesn't know what he is talking about.
Yankee is famous for speaking with a forked tongue.
Talks one thing and does another.
It's too big a chunk to chew, bro.Let talk about ourselves, The Brics,the so called logistics US base,The Lees treatment of Chinese during the 60s,The lees sanctions on Russia, etc.
He is right about Ukraine. He is wrong on his arguments on gaza. Israel can never be authorised on palestine. There cannot be a 2 state solution. Both don't want it
Why does EVERYBODY skirt around Putin's Russia?
Kissinger was not an exemplary person
If somebody push some slaves or marionete to butchering childrens...how cruel that regime most be in deep soul
1000 trillions dollars US CDS funds is too big to be controled... like a maddened horse that has broken loose from its chains and is rushing into the abyss.
What do you make of USA doxa against russia.strategie
With Ukraine you are missing the point...America wanted to push russia to the edge...it wanted to be on its boarders...and I don't condem hamas...its clear others followed hasas out of prison and went not professional like hamas who intended a military op with its limited resources after the Palestinians had exhausted all other options as it was dealing with an enermy that was unreasonable...and its support the empire doesn't negotiate
Meritocracy is the future.
Israel First, Not America
Look up the "HANNIBAL DIRECTIVE" AND THE "DOHIYA DOCTRINE" to those who bring up Hamas and october 7th don't bring up the Hannibal Directive enoguh
Wars are profitable.
Professor Mahbunani I used to listen to your lecturing of global affairs but today when you're talking about Hamas and Palestine you sound an apologistick.
minute 1:48 condemn hamas… yet he does not dare to say condemn Israel for killing 40,000 Palestinians….
A Russian guy here. I have a feeling the West is doing what China did at some point - decided to become closed/isolated.
"China before 1840 was completely closed, isolated from the rest of the world, except for the limited foreign trade in the city of Canton"
Ukraine is separate county before Lenin revaluation -gorbachov gov eduwad seeanadzay is speech and request I am freedom country/
Hamas condemned fool you are you forced to speak !!
Sausages say it all, so does a rolex under the table, a Merkle lie and a German capitulation to a dolt.
Demilitarised why there being occupied it’s the country their right to govern themselves what a waste of life and study
There is NO reason to blame HARMAS , they had been under besieged for decades.
Their land Golan height had been occupied.
Don't they have the right to fight back.
You now have aging incompetent career politicians helming the most important job in the world.😂
Nonsense. My boy
Eu n nato leadership voted for wars ..lol !!
That is wrong yr thinking, Putin is not strategy thinking is worst, I asked me yr one side supporter/
Also kishore doesnt know, THOUSANDS of babies and children are still under the rubble in GAZA. And kishore needs to tell us the origins of the palestinian people,from where did they come from?
!
Our dear kishore, this is what you never knew or isn't in your knowledge . Israel doesn't get to decide whether or not the palestinians have a right to self-determination, this is something that is enshrined in the united nations charter, it is something that is enshrined into international law, it is also a founding principle of the united nations decision to found Israel! So,you know it is absolutely necessary that Israel accepts that it cannot exist without the existence of a palestinian state!. So please pass this message to Mr benzion mileikowsky .(satanyahu) also talk of what has been happening since 1948, also please talk about the massacre of "sabra and shatila " refugees camps, in just a period of just 4 hours Sharon butchered 3850 women and children.
So full of it, this supreme snake oil salesman
Salesman yes, but not selling snake oil
@@wuzhai2009：Pls say something objectively not emotionally nor racially.
@@wuzhai2009 definitely selling his snake oil. And worse his book where his prediction is way off.
Jadichoo >if you have a better analysis of these events, please write a book or even better let us know by arranging to get interviewed for your opinion. Or we will think you are full of it.
@@sword7872 there are many books written contrary to the snake oil book. Go read the book written by the 3 researchers that recently won the Nobel prize for economics. Then you will finally understand why the snake oil salesman is just full of it.
Too bad , they didn't ask your opinion. Anyway take care of Singapore and don't talk too much.
Just wasting time.
You know exactly what's up. However, you are holding back and being super diplomatic!!! Why don't you talk about 75 years of atrocities by the artificial entity! You are a ZIO Lover!!!!!!!!
In 50 years u couldnt learn that its the wars that USA lives for.....😂
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_End_of_History_and_the_Last_Man