As a Muslim, I am happy to see different Jewish voices. This gives me tears and hope💐. A lot of us do not support terrorism and would do anything to stop violence on both sides.
Good to hear from you. Please know that I am another citizen of the US who am welcoming of Muslims, Palestinians, Iraqis, Lebanese and others in this country. I work with Muslims (and Jews and others) to support the Palestinians. I’m sorry, my country is ultimately responsible for this horrible tragedy.
Remember, as Mr. Maté has said, he does not blame himself because he has been fighting these atrocities practically all his life. He is doing his best. You are also doing your best and it’s not a small thing to make people feel welcome. 🍁
I have a quarter Jewish ancestry which is enough to at least make me eligible to apply for citizenship in Israel, not that I would ever do it and not that they would ever accept me now, this is ridiculous and terrible what Israel is doing, it's abominable
"O Prophet! Strive against the disbelievers and the hypocrites! Be harsh with them. Their ultimate abode is hell, a hapless journey's end." These religions promote violence. The cognitive dissonance among the religious is wild.
Gabor's last statement gave me full body chills and tears welled up in my eyes. He laments that they cannot do anything practically to end the genocide but at least "we are saying to Palestinians, we see you and you're not alone, and I think that's important". I can't express how much that means. Thank you for seeing us. We feel less alone with you by our side. Much love from the Palestinian diaspora ♥️♥️
Yeah I cried alone on my bed after hearing his last statement. As a buddhist who believe karma, I felt Mr. Gabor's every word very strongly. Thank you very much sir for talk the truth 💐🫡 I wish peace 🕊 Love from Sri Lanka 🇱🇰❤️🌍
My heart has been broken for a year, and I feel an indescribable sense of rage and despair. Hearing you tonight both upset and soothed me, because you put the right words to what is inside me. I feel less alone in this nightmare. THANK YOU
What is upsetting me is how Americans, of whom I am surrounded by, feel about this, if they even know. I am in a state of shock how people don’t get it. That makes me more than sad and enraged. today’s work - can you even believe it can get worse. My heart is with every single Palestinian Shaheed. And to be very honest, I feel those who turn their backs on this pain have something coming their way.
I am an Irish Canadian. I am a sixty-eight-year-old peace and nonviolence advocate. I love, love, love Dr. Gabor Maté, his son Daniel and all the wonderful people who study and teach all of us about all forms of Trauma. I support all those who teach us how to calm our emotional storms. I send love to all creatives, ecologists, educators, environmentalists, humanitarians, healers, and advocates for nonviolence, peace, truth and reconciliation. I bless all of you.
As Irish people, it is easy to empathise with Gaza & we are horrified by what's happening. There's a movement now to stop American arms being shipped through Shannon.
Here we go again with little, deranged Gabby......I knew him as a teenager. Every group of people have their psychopaths and he is ours. Like a capo or judenrat, he hates his own people. He ingratiates himself with Israel's enemies so that he will be seen as a "good Jew". He has, sadly, passed his sickness on to his sons. Pitiful.
@@aliajellu Here we go again with little, deranged Gabby......I knew him as a teenager. Every group of people have their psychopaths and he is ours. Like a capo or judenrat, he hates his own people. He ingratiates himself with Israel's enemies so that he will be seen as a "good Jew". He has, sadly, passed his sickness on to his sons. Pitiful.
He means what he teachers, a true expert on trauma.How could he claim to understand trauma and human pain if he had ignore the biggest example of it in our time.Him drawing parallels with the holocaust and acknowledging his Jewish identity and calling out those in his community who support this whilst claiming to be mortified by the holocaust also demonstrates a courage and honesty that just wins even more respect.
I am appalled by U.S. support of these tragedies and atrocities. I share your Rage Gabor'e I Pray Constantly these atrocities are Stopped some how some Way !
Thank you so much Frank for the work you do , for having Gabor Mate on today .We need each other in this dark time.Gabor Mate has been a light in the dark.Your work is so important...More then you can immagine.Thank you Frank
Here we go again with little, deranged Gabby......I knew him as a teenager. Every group of people have their psychopaths and he is ours. Like a capo or judenrat, he hates his own people. He ingratiates himself with Israel's enemies so that he will be seen as a "good Jew". He has, sadly, passed his sickness on to his sons. Pitiful.
Do the Palestinians have high suicide rates due to the mental illnesses inflicted upon them? I know they are very strong supportive people and community.
I watched the entire interview with tears in my eyes. Dr Mate and his sons Aaron and Daniel are hugely important voices during these dark times. Love from a Lebanese expat ❤️🇵🇸🇱🇧❤
@AntoinetteTurkie - Re your comment - "I watched the entire interview with tears in my eyes.! - You are not alone - deep sigh ! - Clearly Netanyahu is both a psychopath & a war criminal !
My grandparents lived in Lebanon as employees of USAID, helping Lebanon cope with Palestinian refugees of the Naqbah. All my life, I’ve been so appalled and sad at the active obfuscation practiced by Israel and the United States regarding the treatment of Palestine and its’ people. I’m overjoyed to see so many Israelis, and Jews living in other countries, starting to speak up for Palestine and her people. My thanks is so deep and so overwhelming… please keep moving forward and speaking out. Together, you are a force to be reckoned with….
I’m now 77 and for a long time now, perhaps from the time Yasser Arafat was a prominent voice I’ve taken an interest in Palestine’s fight for survival. I have to say this is the worse time of my life and I see no end to the terrible genocide and terror being perpetrated on the Gazan people. I said to my husband only today that the difference between the holocaust and what is happening now is that we’re seeing the crimes daily on alternative media whereas during the Second World War it was mainly hidden and the majority of people knew nothing of the horrors. I can’t understand how the rest of the world looks on and does nothing to help the innocents being slaughtered. It’s diabolical. Thank you for this conversation between two good men.
In America, all we can do is pester and beg our leaders to stop. And they won't listen. It doesn't matter how loud, how big, how disruptive. They have their own agendas, greed driven agendas. What can we do? How do we make them stop when they hold all the power and American citizens have so little...
By Yassar Arafat you mean the billioner who stole 3 billion dollars of aid maoney from his own people and that is why he was called by his own people 'hanzeran' i.e. pig? This is the benevolent 'freedom fighter' you refer?
Respect to these kind of Germans that are not supporting Germany Respect to these kind of Poles that are not supporting Poland Respect to these kind of Egyptians that are not supporting Egypt
I am so grateful for Professors such as Gabor Mate for consistently speaking up and raising awareness on this matter. I dont think he realises how many people's view points he has changed over the last year. I commend him for educating us all on this matter. ❤
What a pleasure to have the opportunity to hear Gabor Maté, even if horror is again and again unfolded in front of the eyes of Western countries and their leaders who are unable to do more than to condemn. Thanks Frank...
@@bazs7669 Here we go again with little, deranged Gabby......I knew him as a teenager. Every group of people have their psychopaths and he is ours. Like a capo or judenrat, he hates his own people. He ingratiates himself with Israel's enemies so that he will be seen as a "good Jew". He has, sadly, passed his sickness on to his sons. Pitiful.
Here we go again with little, deranged Gabby......I knew him as a teenager. Every group of people have their psychopaths and he is ours. Like a capo or judenrat, he hates his own people. He ingratiates himself with Israel's enemies so that he will be seen as a "good Jew". He has, sadly, passed his sickness on to his sons. Pitiful.
Even though it seems like there's no hope, the people's of the world can not stop highlighting the plight of the Palestinians. Western governments have failed the Palestinians. The citizens of the world CANNOT fail them as well. Thank you gentlemen for lending your voice loudly to the Palestinian cause.
Very important conversation. Thank you Dr. Maté for your points on the cult-like sadism and brainwashing around supremacy, fear, and loathing of the other coupled with historical trauma passed on for generations provides overview for self-compassionate bearing of witness rather than the normalized distancing from reality. "Let our hearts be broken together, and feel what we feel." "Empires don't love anybody." May divine truth, and strong-hearted courage, prevail. 🌿❤🔥 🌿
@@mhdivito Here we go again with little, deranged Gabby......I knew him as a teenager. Every group of people have their psychopaths and he is ours. Like a capo or judenrat, he hates his own people. He ingratiates himself with Israel's enemies so that he will be seen as a "good Jew". He has, sadly, passed his sickness on to his sons. Pitiful.
Thank you a lot. I am from Iran and I felt very sympathized watching you two good European men with golden hearts. Our hearts with people of Palestine and any human being in the world
All rational people understand what is going on in your region and are in horror of what is happening. Unfortunately, it seems that all our power in our so called Democracies, if one can still call them that, has been taken from us and we have slowly slipped into a dystopian and rather fascist system that neither has any respect for the people that has put their representatives in charge, nor are even willing to listen to the rule of law and decency. All they are interested in is money and power. In short, they are completely corrupt. I wished that those people with said rational minds would all come together and finally topple such shameless outlaws from their seats of power, replacing them with more open minded and wise people, but alas, until now I don't see anything like this happening and I really wonder why. What are we afraid of? We, living in the Western world have fought for centuries to get rid of despots, tyrants and dictators to earn the right to be in charge and decide our own destinies freely. Why are we stopping right now? It is beyond me. I simply do not understand this. Was the blood shed by our forefathers not enough to appease the thirst for blood of further monsters? Perhaps it is also our own fault, believing that freedom is just granted by others, instead of constantly fighting for it day by day. We, as a people have become weak and victims of our misguided belief that our system would continue to work by inertia. It did not, and now we see the results. But be reassured, the wheel of time always continues to turn, and as the sun shines and sets everyday, things will eventually change anyway. I only hope it won't be too late for us, decent people of the world, to see yet another shining dawn on the horizon, filled with wisdom and decency for all.
Thank you so much, Frank and Gabor, for this beautiful conversation with so much depth, compassion and courage by both of you! The depth of it chased away considerable loneliness and even some despair, so now I'm in a better place to greet each morning's dawn wholeheartedly and work for honest, loving peace for Palestinians, all people, all creatures great and small, earth and sky.
@@yabitsle pire c’est qu’on nous donne pas de vote pour arrêter se massacre ni la parole… c’est complètement dingue, j’ai encore du mal à comprendre que l’argent peut-être au dessus de la vies des enfants 😞
Thank you gentlemen for a most insightful conversation,listening from South Africa with tears in my eyes for the atrocities that man is capable of without a single thought of humanity is so saddenung,but this conversation gives one hope knowing there are people like yourselves ,with greatest respect ❤❤❤I Thank you,
my sympathies are there in South Africa with you... the things the Boers and Afrikaners are suffering through is, in a way, *worse* than what's happening in Gaza. it's far more insidious, because it's not done by the military. it's free-roaming Africans that have been brainwashed by Jewish-controlled Communist agitators that are doing it. and in their minds they absolve the guilt of it because they're doing it by proxy.
This interview with Gabor Mate moved me immensely as he addressed the helplessness one feels watching the horror of what Israel is doing to the Palestinian people while so many in the mainstream media cheer it on or make excuses for it. Just listening to him and feeling that I was not alone was heartening. Thank you both.
Máté Gábor Always touches my soul. He speaks from a well spring the majority of people can never hope to find in themselves. Kivánok sok évet hogy a bölcsessége érinthessen embereket világ szerte. . Öszinte szeretettel, Sarolta, andalucia
I needed this today. This really connected with how I'm feeling, powerless, depressed and I have no words. I guess I just need to let myself feel this grief and pain.
It’s unimaginable to me that Israelis can support these horrors in Gaza - especially given its history of oppression & genocide during WW2. It is beyond comprehension as Gabor so vehemently states. I bought his book on trauma… excellent read & excellent human being ❤❤❤
When I see the atrocities and videos circulating online, I feel so incredibly helpless, heart-broken, and shocked into a state of low mood. It’s talks like these that are able to bring me some small level of comfort and hope, and pull me out of that enraged and dejected stupor that I find myself in. We live in a dystopian nightmare, I used to go onto tiktok to see funny videos, now I just see victims of a holocaust, trying their hardest to charge their phones by any means because a charged phone is so integral to their daily life- to ask people online for help. We are seeing the holocaust from the perspective of the victims. Little babies learning English to tell us in the west what they are going through. Whether a family eats is determined by how many shares they get on the internet. This along with the callousness of the very people that these victims look to for help. Their ability to make jokes, laugh, display their complete apathy to these people. It’s a new kind of sadism. This is really up there as one of the greatest crimes against humanity and there are so many parallels as well as differences with the Nazi holocaust.
hello from palestine west bank , i appreciate your work and your attempts. often times it makes me bitter to see people talk about their pain or trauma when they are sitting in their comfortable areas. although i understand what kind of trauma you both are talking about with my brain, deep in my heart i feel mocked for calling what you are going through "trauma" but then i look at gaza, and i look inwards into my own soul. and as i walk the streets of the west bank i often start seeing buildings fall down on people, it's all in my imagination but i knwo it's just my voice deep inside telling me that we are next. but when i connect my trauma of what the future would look like to me and compare it to the trauma that gaza is going through i start to understand and connect with people like you both. i start to understand that there is a certain line of which once you cross, any trauma is untolerable. in that sense i appreciate you both, and i thank you for every word. practically nothing will ever stop this new norm except when people stand up against taxes, in this world and age, money talks and as long as the average person is paying his/her/there taxes the few ruling class people will find it justified to continue killing.
Gabor Maté is a Holocaust survivor from Hungary. Please don't minimize his ability to know trauma when he sees it or feels it. Empathy is the only thing that will lead to peace.
@@Historian212 HA! Dr. Mat'e was an infant during the Holocaust. My parents and grandparents were Holocaust survivors who actually REMEMBER what happened. And, wonders of wonders, they thought that maybe, just maybe, Jews should have some mechanism that allows persecuted Jews to have a refuge and to defend themselves. They were unabashed Zionists, card-carrying Zionists. Mat'e badmouths me, my parents and grandparents of blessed memory. Now I KNOW he means well, I really do. But, I won't give him a pass for the harm he does. If we Zionists are so horrible, then I guess whatever violence happens to us, we had it coming, didn't we? Well F*** that.
@@Historian212 HA! Dr. Mat'e was an infant during the Holocaust. My parents and grandparents were Holocaust survivors who actually REMEMBER what happened. And, wonders of wonders, they thought that maybe, just maybe, Jews should have some mechanism that allows persecuted Jews to have a refuge and to defend themselves. They were unabashed Zionists, card-carrying Zionists. Mat'e badmouths me, my parents and grandparents of blessed memory. Now I KNOW he means well, I really do. But, I won't give him a pass for the harm he does. If we Zionists are so horrible, then I guess whatever violence happens to us, we had it coming, didn't we? Well F*** that.
@@Historian212 Dr Mat'e was an infant when it happened. My parents and grandparents actually went through the Hol0caust in Poland, where the real horrors happened, and remembered what happened. And, wonder of wonders, they decided that a Jewish State was the best bet we got so that we don't get F***ed up again. So they were unabashed, card-carrying Zionists. And now Mat'e comes along and badmouths me, my parents and grandparents of blessed memory. I know he means well, but he's causing harm. If Z1onists are so horrible, then it's easy to conclude that whatever terrible things happen to them (like 0ct.7.23) they had it coming, didn't they?
God bless you guys and especially Gabor Mate for bringing this genocide to the light of day This horror mortifies me with every single day that goes by
Same here- so and many of us Christians here in the USA. We are not all Zionists:/. We are against the horrible genocide and are praying for it to end .
He said, “it’s like we’re watching Auschwitz on TickTock Toc” YES! It’s sickening and horrifying! And that my country is complicit and supplying the arms is beyond forgivable! And no one listens:( So many have been duped by the media .
We've got to stop thinking war is strong and good. We have to teach our children that killing is unintelligent and that strength comes from sharing space for each other ❤ thanks guys. This was really needed
In Africa we call it Ubuntu. Buntu in Zulu means man. Ubuntu translates loosly into humanity. South Africa's democratic elected ruling party in 1994 avoided a blood bath by offering the olive branch of forgiveness and an insistance that never again will one nation be oppressed by another. That should be a shining light for humanity.
What an extremely kind, caring, well-spoken & intelligent human being. Wow! We love the Maté family... keep on doing what you do! & Yes, all our hearts are broken, we are with you. Too tragic for words.
Thankyou Frank Barat & Gabor Mate for this profound and humane conversation: it offers a timely reminder of how such hate-filled brainwashing can lead to demonic states of mind and sadistic behaviour. We will never stop calling this out - our very humanity is at stake.
I am in Australia and look on in absolute horror and often times paralysis and with despairing emotions over what is happening. It is encouraging to know I’m not alone. My heart is broken.
Sadly, Australia openly oppresses their own indigenous peoples like it’s normal. Their system serves the crown and neocon imperialism! Indigenous peoples need to join BRICS and leave King Charles subjects to his wef system!
Hypocrisy. You genocide the indigenous peoples there. Israel wants to become Australia and have no accountability for genocide just like Australia. You're oblivious to your own involvement in genocide.
@@passyourielts indigenous peoples in the country been fighting government oppression for generations and generations, now you will see that even YOU don’t matter anymore, they got your votes for materialism year in year out!
Thankyou for this video. I feel rage, heartbreak and utter powerless. Endless letters to MPs, marching on the streets…….doesn’t seem to make an iota of difference. I want to shout and scream but I’ve come up against a taboo. Many people don’t want to talk , but turn away and get on with their lives. What terrifies me is the loss of humanity in the Israeli soldiers and in this we all lose a bit of our humanity. The tragedy of the ethnic murder ( cleansing is too benign a word) of the Palestinians is part of a bigger tragedy. Thank you Gabor for your insight into “uselessness” and “broken heartedness”. I have been a therapist for nearly forty years of my life and I know how long healing takes. This fills me with despair.
It sounds like what we're facing in 🇨🇦. It is absolutely unbelievable that so many people, including close family, refuse to even engage in any discussion about the murderous genocide of the Palestinian people and now Lebanon. I live in a perpetual state of rage.
@@India-go6heSo true, fellow Canadian. They continue to use the line, “ the Israelis have to defend themselves “ without trying to understand there is a bigger issue at play. Should Canada call an election, I will not waist my vote on anyone that supports Israel. 🍁
I truly appreciate this episode I have been dealing with rage and anger because of watching the documented genocide in Palestine and on the other hand watching the silence of our leaders
We must grieve, grieve together. And reflect on the atrocities that human beings are capable of. Thank you Mr Frank Barat and Dr Gabor Mate for sharing a moment of sanity.
Having an own nation state is a very natural desire for any ethnic group and I don't see why Jews wanting their own nation state is worse than Hungarians, Croatians, Lithuanians, Ukrainians or Poles wanting this. Living in eternal diaspora is not the natural way of existence for any people.
@@ledpupBeing Jewish is belonging to a People. Anyways, the Muslims have more than enough lands. If they really wanted to help the Palestinians, and I'm not talking militarily, they could have a long time ago. But they hate the Jews more than they care about the Palestinians. That's why they maintain them for 76 years in refugee camps, instead of helping them integrate in their societies.
Much love ❤️ and respect to Gabor Mate and his family. They are amazing human beings who speak the truth and are standing up on the right side of history.
I agree regarding the darkest time of my life. I have never felt so lonely and so sad. I am frustrated by the failure of our society to understand what is going on. All the things you talk about. I appreciate this discussion. I don't feel so alone. I do know there are many others out there who feel the way I feel. I wish I could do more.
@@jackklugman107that just means you are human. If everyone were like you, there wouldn't be this slaughter. You probably raised chikdren that share your moral compass, and that too is something. I too have cried and raised and wrote all the politicians using our tax money to fund this genocide, donated and tried to volunteer to go to Gaza, boycotted since 1976, and knew it was all not enough. But I do know in the midst of the devastation the people of Palestine say they gain strength from knowing that we support them, that for once their suffering is not in vain. So you are giving hope.
@@hunger4jsutice "…for once…" Yes, for once. FINALLY. After over 75 years. Because Hamas broke through the prison fence one October day in 2023. For once their suffering is not in vain.
It is also the darķest time of my life.i am 74 years old.i always thought i am crazy i am always seing what is going on in Gaza and Westank oh my god help them this is the hell for them In love for this people❤
Trauma begets more trauma, from the victimizer and victim, and gets replicated since they are not addressing the core issue of their sense of insecurity. You cannot imprison a people and expect them to act like normal people at all times, and this doese not condone acts of terror or crimes for those actions on both sides. Love that you have Mr. Mate on, he is so clear-sighted. I admire him.
If you believe the Zionist Project carries the trauma of the Holocaust you are fundamentally mistaken. The weaponization of what most Jews (by "Jews" I do not mean those residing in or fighting alongside the "Only Democracy in the Middle East") know as Shoah has only started quite late, after the trial of Eichmann (in 1961) and gradually, accelerating after 1973, and was and remains calculated and cynical.
This trauma is now so so bad that it is seriously affecting people who are not even victims ... living thousands of miles away and who have beds to sleep in ... and food to eat. Now, I am not even beginning to compare myself to what the victims are going through ... however, my heart is broken ... truly broken ... and it hurts severely to see people treated in this way ...
In the last week, I have listened to Dr Gabor Mate, Yanis Varoufakis, and Norman Finkelstein, and it would seem all are at the same point, of not being able to see a stop to the genocide based on protest, or the sudden morality of governments that never comes. Personally, I want to say that through the heartbreak, rage, confusion and anger, I now feel I want to do something, take some action for the long term. This will not help Palestine today, but if more of us make changes, we can stop another 'Palestine' tomorrow. The warning is already here, and none of us are useless. If the aggressors don't care about life, they'll care about money, and we still have choice about how we use what we earn, for now.
Best way to do this is to buy local. Buy small business and small brands. Everything. Toothpaste, shampoo, etc. Keep all electronics as long as you possibly can. Shop Palestinian owned brands (i love Palestine soap cooperative for soap!) Our money is our power.
Rita, I am sincerely hoping we can still do something today. I’m not certain yet what I will do. I know that I want to donate some money to , Doctors Without Boarders and UNRWA (? ). 🍁
I'm absolutely heartbroken I hate to imagine what those poor people are feeling. Anguish horror terror fear sadness everything all at the same time. All jews of the world should be ashamed and shoukd come out the billions of them to condemn israel and the state it is. It should go back to the original palestine. End this serial killing madness. Thankyou to both of you humble humans ❤❤
Just excellent. Thank you from a heart broken Irish woman. May we continue to shine a light on the darkness, not be afraid to tell the truth and to pray for peace
@@pepperminttea1 Here we go again with little, deranged Gabby......I knew him as a teenager. Every group of people have their psychopaths and he is ours. Like a capo or judenrat, he hates his own people. He ingratiates himself with Israel's enemies so that he will be seen as a "good Jew". He has, sadly, passed his sickness on to his sons. Pitiful.
@@AS-jh2gv A kapo was a person in a concentration camp that survived by betraying his fellow prisoners. Are you accusing Gabor Mate of being a kapo? How is that lovable?
I was born in Australia at the end of 1945. My father was in the RAAF. When I was a young teenager, my dad told me the outlne of the Holocaust. It was horrifying to me of course but I am thankful that he did. It has made me aware and sensitive to the Colonial brutalisation of Indigenous peoples. The horror of the ADF ongong attacks in Gaza and Palestinians does, as Gabor says, does make many of us feel helpless. When we in Australia learnt about the killing of Australian Aid Workers attempting to deliver food and other aid to Gazan people by ADF airstrikes brought this tragedy even more close to home. In the last years, I have been becomng more and more grief stricken and depressed. Listening to Gabor Mate and other spokespeople who are telling the truth about this horror helps I think.
Grateful to be able listen to wise curious souls talking about everything that happens. We are in troubled times, but many are waking up to truth on many levels. There is a lot to take in everywhere we look ! We must overcome these old ways, share and forgive to move on with intelligence and understanding. Nothing will be solved without the heart of compassion for others seen as part of ourselfes. When I see and listen to it all that last many years, I feel the suffering there is because of lack of understanding and wisdom. Gabor is here to help us grow in deeper perspective. We go through much taking it all in,while learning and understanding better, but we must stand strong and become wiser for there to be a more peaceful place for all to live together. So many labels, fear and ideas comes from the past mind, dividing all, instead of being open and sharing.
Exactly Mary! I thought, guilt? No, wrong emotion! It’s rage and deep disgust. If I describe what I want to say my comment will be deleted. Thank you Gabor.
@@AmonAnon-vw3hr How brave of you to announce to the public that you don’t care about the suffering of people. But that makes sense coming from a person who supports a nation the is committing gen o cide on an occupied people, mur der ing women and children in the name of defending themselves. They mistakenly think they are Gods people, but He rejected them and would never sanctify the hei nous acts they are presently perpetrating on the true victims of this w ar. The world is disgusted.
@@AmonAnon-vw3hr That makes total sense because how else are the people you support able to commit such heinous acts of vio le ce on innocent women and children. The world is disgusted with your dark hearts.
Our hearts are broken, too. We are saddened by the pain and suffering of one side and the utter hypocrisy of the masses. Thank you for covering this and let's be sad together rather than indulging in superficial things like sports and entertainment. Lets have conscious and at least call it wrong collectively so we can stand in front of our Creator and say we didn't have the capacity to bring about change but we did what we could and we cried over these horrible atrocities.
Gracias por este espacio compartido. Que la impotencia que experimentamos ante el Horror mayúsculo no se convierta en culpa paralizante, sino en ira e indignación activas. No podemos rendirnos, hemos de seguir exigiendo a nuestros gobiernos el fin de su complicidad en el genocidio. Que más y más gente a nuestro alrededor despierte. Aunque cada día nuestro corazón vuelva a romperse... GRACIAS
Gabor’s words and insights in these bloody , horrific atrocities and genocide sheds a bit of hope and light during these desperate times , I remember the impacts , when I first read Gabor & Daniels book “Myth of normal , and how profound that has been so far,on my views of world , listening to him now gives more clarity to those impacts. Thanks to both of you for this conversation and sharing your insights
I'm sorry that the West is so Tyrannical and Controlling and it's come to this level of evil. There's a reason for Holloween and Christmas that we were never educated about.
Yes, how can they blatantly ignore their own neocon systems and their own oppressive actions towards the indigenous peoples of the western world- namely USA Canada, Australia and New Zealand.
@@noviaparker5839 but colonised countries like usa, Canada, Australia and NZealand think they wrapped in democracy when they oppressing their own peoples!
I can think of a few others. For example, Rabbi Arik Ascherman who puts himself physically between settlers / police and Palestinians in the West Bank. And has done for many years.
Thank you Frank, for bringing us Gabor, who tells the truth, and says what all the leaders and politicians are afraid to say. Love, from a proud Canadian.
It's Horror upon Horror ! Just as horrific the first time I heard about Nazi Germany . Unspeakable Tragedy. I have No words. Only aggrieved muted tears.
This is the best explanation of the cruelty that’s going on in the Middle East especially when it is explained by an Israeli man , thank you Frank for having him on and thank you Gabour for your calm explanation, anyone seeing this please share because the mainstream media will not , bless you both Martin from Ireland 🙏🙏👏👏👏👏
❤️ This was the most touching interview I have seen in years. There is an incredible depth in your words and facial expressions. I can feel your hearts crying out... Thank you for sharing this. For being and staying human, for cultivating an open heart and mind, and for making a difference. Peace to the world... ❤️
Gabriel Mate. This man's humanity. His sincerity. The heartfelt empathy he feels for his cousins the Palestinians, resonates even just through the timbre of his voice. What a beautiful soul. What a pure heart. He often moves me to tears over this massacre, just in the manner he tries to make sense of it. Keep talking Gabriel. We will listen. And change the world. One soul at a time. Don't ever give up on us. And thank you for this great interview, and the wonderful and thought provoking questions ...
@@calicocat8213 I know. But he is often called Gabriel by non-Hungarians. As you will note in the multitude of interviews he has done with Western interviewers.
Also mir gehen die Palästinenser mehr und mehr auf die Nerven. Zuerst laufen sie einem linken Nationalismus hinterher, dann werfen sie sich alle den Islamisten um den Hals, nerven die Welt mit ihren Terroranschlägen, leben von unseren Steuergeldern (UNRWA), wollen nichts arbeiten und kriegen alle 6 bis 10 Kinder und wundern sich dann, dass es eng wird im Gazastreifen. Kulturell sind uns die Juden viel näher, besonders die deutschstämmigen. Also liegt meine Sympathie eher dort.
Greetings from a fellow German who lives in the UK... I despair of our governments. Free Palestine and the middle East from the evils of Zionism in the world and Israel 🇵🇸🕊️🇱🇧🕊️❤️🙏🏻
@@MichiZaus GERMAN!! AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!👿👿👿👿 Di F@hne h.o.ch! Di R3ihen f3st ge$chlo$.sen! $.A. mars.hiert mit ruh1g fe$tem S.c.hritt K@m'r@.den, di R0tfr0nt und Reaktion er$cho.ssen, Mar$chier'n im Gei$.t in un$er'n R3ihen m!t.☠☠☠☠
Thank you both so much. Such knowledge and compassion!! I truly appreciate being reminded we may be physically alone, yet there are many, many, many beautiful souls bearing witness, speechlessly breaking/opening our hearts more every day. I am being forced to "weed my garden" and it (I) will be healthier and much more beautiful next year, God willing/Inshallah Shalom 🕊 and... Love to the like-minded trauma survivors out there
![[#2024MAMA] BIGBANG (빅뱅) - 뱅뱅뱅 (BANG BANG BANG) + FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EQsYfiPR9uM/mqdefault.jpg)
Would love a like, a share and for you to subscribe to my channel, thanks !
Thanks for everything you do.
Look for plum village
Tich Nhat Hanh knows *how* to be with things, listen to what he says
Done
20 years of watching utube -i never saw a more sick comlitly sick antisemite podcast
even not muslim ----un belivable
so are you anti semite or you are just on putin payrol?
As a Muslim, I am happy to see different Jewish voices. This gives me tears and hope💐. A lot of us do not support terrorism and would do anything to stop violence on both sides.
Absolutely.
Good to hear from you. Please know that I am another citizen of the US who am welcoming of Muslims, Palestinians, Iraqis, Lebanese and others in this country. I work with Muslims (and Jews and others) to support the Palestinians. I’m sorry, my country is ultimately responsible for this horrible tragedy.
Remember, as Mr. Maté has said, he does not blame himself because he has been fighting these atrocities practically all his life. He is doing his best. You are also doing your best and it’s not a small thing to make people feel welcome. 🍁
I have a quarter Jewish ancestry which is enough to at least make me eligible to apply for citizenship in Israel, not that I would ever do it and not that they would ever accept me now, this is ridiculous and terrible what Israel is doing, it's abominable
"O Prophet! Strive against the disbelievers and the hypocrites! Be harsh with them. Their ultimate abode is hell, a hapless journey's end."
These religions promote violence. The cognitive dissonance among the religious is wild.
Gabor's last statement gave me full body chills and tears welled up in my eyes. He laments that they cannot do anything practically to end the genocide but at least "we are saying to Palestinians, we see you and you're not alone, and I think that's important". I can't express how much that means. Thank you for seeing us. We feel less alone with you by our side. Much love from the Palestinian diaspora ♥️♥️
🤗🤗♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️🇨🇦😁🙏🏽💪🏽
❤ Deep respect and solidarity ❤
Yeah I cried alone on my bed after hearing his last statement. As a buddhist who believe karma, I felt Mr. Gabor's every word very strongly. Thank you very much sir for talk the truth 💐🫡 I wish peace 🕊
Love from Sri Lanka 🇱🇰❤️🌍
@@Hellomyfrndss ...👌🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗♥️♥️♥️🇨🇦🐾🐾🐻
❤❤😢
My heart has been broken for a year, and I feel an indescribable sense of rage and despair. Hearing you tonight both upset and soothed me, because you put the right words to what is inside me. I feel less alone in this nightmare. THANK YOU
Exactly Exactly. And thank you as well for describing what i am feeling
You definitely are not alone in this nightmare!
Me too ❤
Feeling the same..🙏
What is upsetting me is how Americans, of whom I am surrounded by, feel about this, if they even know. I am in a state of shock how people don’t get it. That makes me more than sad and enraged. today’s work - can you even believe it can get worse. My heart is with every single Palestinian Shaheed. And to be very honest, I feel those who turn their backs on this pain have something coming their way.
I am an Irish Canadian. I am a sixty-eight-year-old peace and nonviolence advocate. I love, love, love Dr. Gabor Maté, his son Daniel and all the wonderful people who study and teach all of us about all forms of Trauma. I support all those who teach us how to calm our emotional storms. I send love to all creatives, ecologists, educators, environmentalists, humanitarians, healers, and advocates for nonviolence, peace, truth and reconciliation. I bless all of you.
Beautifully said. Thank you.
As Irish people, it is easy to empathise with Gaza & we are horrified by what's happening. There's a movement now to stop American arms being shipped through Shannon.
don't forget his son aaron, a tireless and powerful voice against all injustice.
Gabor Maté is one of the greatest minds of our age.
He's a decent human being but not the greatest mind of our age.
@@Marius_vanderLubbe -- I am going to count what is called "emotional intelligence." Truly one of the greatest along that parameter.
Los PALESTINOS deben saber que aunque no podamos hacer mucho por ellos, los vemos, los sentimos y nuestros corazones y plegarias les acompañan.
Agreed.
Terrible doctor though
Gabor and his two sons, Aaron and Daniel, are heros of the first order. How were we blessed with their existence and their courage? Thank you
I think of this so often.
Here we go again with little, deranged Gabby......I knew him as a teenager. Every group of people have their psychopaths and he is ours. Like a capo or judenrat, he hates his own people. He ingratiates himself with Israel's enemies so that he will be seen as a "good Jew". He has, sadly, passed his sickness on to his sons. Pitiful.
They are clowns of the progressive nutcase order.
Such courage. They live in f*cking Canada and don't give a sh*t about anything but their fame and the fawning over them. HA!
@@aliajellu Here we go again with little, deranged Gabby......I knew him as a teenager. Every group of people have their psychopaths and he is ours. Like a capo or judenrat, he hates his own people. He ingratiates himself with Israel's enemies so that he will be seen as a "good Jew". He has, sadly, passed his sickness on to his sons. Pitiful.
Gabor Maté is a one of the most humane people on the planet. Thank you so much for hosting him.
Gabor Mate is wrong about Israel twice
He’s a great human being no doubt We could use more people like him in this insane world God bless Gabor Mate
Comparing Israel/Gaza and what the Nazis did in Auschwitz is shocking. Not much of an Intellectual.
He means what he teachers, a true expert on trauma.How could he claim to understand trauma and human pain if he had ignore the biggest example of it in our time.Him drawing parallels with the holocaust and acknowledging his Jewish identity and calling out those in his community who support this whilst claiming to be mortified by the holocaust also demonstrates a courage and honesty that just wins even more respect.
@@MrJREllmanrather YOU’RE wrong for infinity if you think that what’s happening is justified you need genuine help
I am appalled by U.S. support of these tragedies and atrocities. I share your Rage Gabor'e I Pray Constantly these atrocities are Stopped some how some Way !
Thank you so much Frank for the work you do , for having Gabor Mate on today .We need each other in this dark time.Gabor Mate has been a light in the dark.Your work is so important...More then you can immagine.Thank you Frank
Here we go again with little, deranged Gabby......I knew him as a teenager. Every group of people have their psychopaths and he is ours. Like a capo or judenrat, he hates his own people. He ingratiates himself with Israel's enemies so that he will be seen as a "good Jew". He has, sadly, passed his sickness on to his sons. Pitiful.
OCT 7TH FAFO
Do the Palestinians have high suicide rates due to the mental illnesses inflicted upon them? I know they are very strong supportive people and community.
Telling the truth in times of universal deceit is a revolutionary act. Salute to both the host and the guest for standing with humanity.
I watched the entire interview with tears in my eyes. Dr Mate and his sons Aaron and Daniel are hugely important voices during these dark times. Love from a Lebanese expat ❤️🇵🇸🇱🇧❤
@AntoinetteTurkie - Re your comment - "I watched the entire interview with tears in my eyes.! - You are not alone - deep sigh ! - Clearly Netanyahu is both a psychopath & a war criminal !
My grandparents lived in Lebanon as employees of USAID, helping Lebanon cope with Palestinian refugees of the Naqbah. All my life, I’ve been so appalled and sad at the active obfuscation practiced by Israel and the United States regarding the treatment of Palestine and its’ people. I’m overjoyed to see so many Israelis, and Jews living in other countries, starting to speak up for Palestine and her people. My thanks is so deep and so overwhelming… please keep moving forward and speaking out. Together, you are a force to be reckoned with….
I’m now 77 and for a long time now, perhaps from the time Yasser Arafat was a prominent voice I’ve taken an interest in Palestine’s fight for survival. I have to say this is the worse time of my life and I see no end to the terrible genocide and terror being perpetrated on the Gazan people. I said to my husband only today that the difference between the holocaust and what is happening now is that we’re seeing the crimes daily on alternative media whereas during the Second World War it was mainly hidden and the majority of people knew nothing of the horrors. I can’t understand how the rest of the world looks on and does nothing to help the innocents being slaughtered. It’s diabolical. Thank you for this conversation between two good men.
In America, all we can do is pester and beg our leaders to stop. And they won't listen. It doesn't matter how loud, how big, how disruptive. They have their own agendas, greed driven agendas. What can we do? How do we make them stop when they hold all the power and American citizens have so little...
It's indeed diabolical, like Devil has possessed zionists.
Yes, it's diabolical....
These things were happening just as bad then. The thing now is cameras have gotten alot better!
By Yassar Arafat you mean the billioner who stole 3 billion dollars of aid maoney from his own people and that is why he was called by his own people 'hanzeran' i.e. pig? This is the benevolent 'freedom fighter' you refer?
Respect to these kind of Jews that are not supporting Zionism
Too few, far too few... Almost a rounding error.
Respect to these kind of Germans that are not supporting Germany
Respect to these kind of Poles that are not supporting Poland
Respect to these kind of Egyptians that are not supporting Egypt
@@LongDefiant Agreed. My Jewish friends are glaringly silent.
qui ne dit mot , consent@@desmondjames9312
The Kapo self haters
I love this man a man of honor as you Frank❤ humanity never dies.
Very moved by Gabor's simple and direct words: 'Just be with them.'
Yes indeed BUT WE MUST STOP THEM. ACTION IS NEEDED. COMPASSION IS HONOURABLE BUT WE must see an end 😢😢😢😢😢
I am so grateful for Professors such as Gabor Mate for consistently speaking up and raising awareness on this matter. I dont think he realises how many people's view points he has changed over the last year. I commend him for educating us all on this matter. ❤
What a pleasure to have the opportunity to hear Gabor Maté, even if horror is again and again unfolded in front of the eyes of Western countries and their leaders who are unable to do more than to condemn. Thanks Frank...
Gabor ... A beautiful man with the softest and most compassionate heart ... ❤️🖤🤍💚🤲
@@jylyhughes5085 bleeding heart with no answer to the plans of radical Islam to genocide the people of Israel.
Search for: Gabor Mate is wrong about Israel twice
@@MrJREllman Wrong from the zayo pov.
@@nestorbamboo You didn't search for it and you didn't watch it. Try. Then tell me what is wrong with it.
@@MrJREllman How could you know what I have or haven't watched?
Gabor Mate is a blessing, may God bless his heart!
Gabor Mate, one of the shining lights of humanity
@@bazs7669 Here we go again with little, deranged Gabby......I knew him as a teenager. Every group of people have their psychopaths and he is ours. Like a capo or judenrat, he hates his own people. He ingratiates himself with Israel's enemies so that he will be seen as a "good Jew". He has, sadly, passed his sickness on to his sons. Pitiful.
then why does he lie about ww2?
@@Mario42033what did he lie about? You gotta be more specific
He said their goals bring the cruelty that must happen, it didn't have to happen , their goals are wrong.
Thank you for putting words on our pain, Dr Maté. Please continue speaking up!
Here we go again with little, deranged Gabby......I knew him as a teenager. Every group of people have their psychopaths and he is ours. Like a capo or judenrat, he hates his own people. He ingratiates himself with Israel's enemies so that he will be seen as a "good Jew". He has, sadly, passed his sickness on to his sons. Pitiful.
Ja, Doktor Mat'e ist den guten Jude! Er ist UNSERN Jude! 🙋🙋♀🙋♂
Even though it seems like there's no hope, the people's of the world can not stop highlighting the plight of the Palestinians. Western governments have failed the Palestinians. The citizens of the world CANNOT fail them as well. Thank you gentlemen for lending your voice loudly to the Palestinian cause.
Very important conversation. Thank you Dr. Maté for your points on the cult-like sadism and brainwashing around supremacy, fear, and loathing of the other coupled with historical trauma passed on for generations provides overview for self-compassionate bearing of witness rather than the normalized distancing from reality. "Let our hearts be broken together, and feel what we feel." "Empires don't love anybody."
May divine truth, and strong-hearted courage, prevail.
🌿❤🔥 🌿
I’m so grateful for Gabor Mate, his wisdom and insights are truly a gift.
Thanks for another great interview, Frank. 💚
❤
@@mhdivito Here we go again with little, deranged Gabby......I knew him as a teenager. Every group of people have their psychopaths and he is ours. Like a capo or judenrat, he hates his own people. He ingratiates himself with Israel's enemies so that he will be seen as a "good Jew". He has, sadly, passed his sickness on to his sons. Pitiful.
Thank you a lot. I am from Iran and I felt very sympathized watching you two good European men with golden hearts. Our hearts with people of Palestine and any human being in the world
Gabor Mate is Jewish. ❤
@@samanthav3141and?
All rational people understand what is going on in your region and are in horror of what is happening. Unfortunately, it seems that all our power in our so called Democracies, if one can still call them that, has been taken from us and we have slowly slipped into a dystopian and rather fascist system that neither has any respect for the people that has put their representatives in charge, nor are even willing to listen to the rule of law and decency.
All they are interested in is money and power. In short, they are completely corrupt.
I wished that those people with said rational minds would all come together and finally topple such shameless outlaws from their seats of power, replacing them with more open minded and wise people, but alas, until now I don't see anything like this happening and I really wonder why.
What are we afraid of? We, living in the Western world have fought for centuries to get rid of despots, tyrants and dictators to earn the right to be in charge and decide our own destinies freely. Why are we stopping right now? It is beyond me. I simply do not understand this. Was the blood shed by our forefathers not enough to appease the thirst for blood of further monsters? Perhaps it is also our own fault, believing that freedom is just granted by others, instead of constantly fighting for it day by day.
We, as a people have become weak and victims of our misguided belief that our system would continue to work by inertia. It did not, and now we see the results.
But be reassured, the wheel of time always continues to turn, and as the sun shines and sets everyday, things will eventually change anyway.
I only hope it won't be too late for us, decent people of the world, to see yet another shining dawn on the horizon, filled with wisdom and decency for all.
@@samanthav3141 Yes. A European Jewish! I feel big respect for him 💙
@@samanthav3141 Hungarian/Canadian Jew.
Thank you so much, Frank and Gabor, for this beautiful conversation with so much depth, compassion and courage by both of you! The depth of it chased away considerable loneliness and even some despair, so now I'm in a better place to greet each morning's dawn wholeheartedly and work for honest, loving peace for Palestinians, all people, all creatures great and small, earth and sky.
I have been feeling completely disconsolate. Within the first two minutes I felt I was in the company of those who truly understand. Thank you.
As an American, I feel horrendous at my nation's complicity in all of this. Rage and disgust.
Feel the same..crying helpless hopeless angry
@@yabitsle pire c’est qu’on nous donne pas de vote pour arrêter se massacre ni la parole… c’est complètement dingue, j’ai encore du mal à comprendre que l’argent peut-être au dessus de la vies des enfants 😞
@@yabits 🎯👍👍👍👍
@@yabitsI feel the same about Britain.😊
Thank you gentlemen for a most insightful conversation,listening from South Africa with tears in my eyes for the atrocities that man is capable of without a single thought of humanity is so saddenung,but this conversation gives one hope knowing there are people like yourselves ,with greatest respect ❤❤❤I Thank you,
I am absolutely horrified and disgusted. The worst.
@@fatimaguled969 Impossible to believe it is real.
my sympathies are there in South Africa with you... the things the Boers and Afrikaners are suffering through is, in a way, *worse* than what's happening in Gaza. it's far more insidious, because it's not done by the military. it's free-roaming Africans that have been brainwashed by Jewish-controlled Communist agitators that are doing it. and in their minds they absolve the guilt of it because they're doing it by proxy.
Idiot
South Africa is a failed state
This interview with Gabor Mate moved me immensely as he addressed the helplessness one feels watching the horror of what Israel is doing to the Palestinian people while so many in the mainstream media cheer it on or make excuses for it. Just listening to him and feeling that I was not alone was heartening. Thank you both.
Donate to palestenian children relief fund
www.pcrf.net
Máté Gábor Always touches my soul. He speaks from a well spring the majority of people can never hope to find in themselves. Kivánok sok évet hogy a bölcsessége érinthessen embereket világ szerte. . Öszinte szeretettel, Sarolta, andalucia
Always eager to listen to the profound words of wisdom coming out the mouth of Dr Gabor Mate.
I needed this today. This really connected with how I'm feeling, powerless, depressed and I have no words. I guess I just need to let myself feel this grief and pain.
You are not alone. I’m even having nightmares about the atrocities.❤
Two beautiful souls! Two humanitarians … God bless you both… ❤
❤❤❤
It’s unimaginable to me that Israelis can support these horrors in Gaza - especially given its history of oppression & genocide during WW2. It is beyond comprehension as Gabor so vehemently states. I bought his book on trauma… excellent read & excellent human being ❤❤❤
Study the Bolsheviks
@@Evettecord I have and I'm struggling to see a connection between them and the current genocide in Gaza. Could you elaborate on what you mean?
When I see the atrocities and videos circulating online, I feel so incredibly helpless, heart-broken, and shocked into a state of low mood. It’s talks like these that are able to bring me some small level of comfort and hope, and pull me out of that enraged and dejected stupor that I find myself in.
We live in a dystopian nightmare, I used to go onto tiktok to see funny videos, now I just see victims of a holocaust, trying their hardest to charge their phones by any means because a charged phone is so integral to their daily life- to ask people online for help. We are seeing the holocaust from the perspective of the victims. Little babies learning English to tell us in the west what they are going through. Whether a family eats is determined by how many shares they get on the internet. This along with the callousness of the very people that these victims look to for help. Their ability to make jokes, laugh, display their complete apathy to these people. It’s a new kind of sadism. This is really up there as one of the greatest crimes against humanity and there are so many parallels as well as differences with the Nazi holocaust.
@@WeldorLife there is nothing Godly about supporting Israel. It’s a complete inversion of righteousness, it would be like supporting the antichrist.
hello from palestine west bank , i appreciate your work and your attempts. often times it makes me bitter to see people talk about their pain or trauma when they are sitting in their comfortable areas. although i understand what kind of trauma you both are talking about with my brain, deep in my heart i feel mocked for calling what you are going through "trauma"
but then i look at gaza, and i look inwards into my own soul. and as i walk the streets of the west bank i often start seeing buildings fall down on people, it's all in my imagination but i knwo it's just my voice deep inside telling me that we are next. but when i connect my trauma of what the future would look like to me and compare it to the trauma that gaza is going through i start to understand and connect with people like you both. i start to understand that there is a certain line of which once you cross, any trauma is untolerable.
in that sense i appreciate you both, and i thank you for every word.
practically nothing will ever stop this new norm except when people stand up against taxes, in this world and age, money talks and as long as the average person is paying his/her/there taxes the few ruling class people will find it justified to continue killing.
"it's all in my imagination" Thanks for being honest.
*WHERE'S KFIR BIBAS????????*
Gabor Maté is a Holocaust survivor from Hungary. Please don't minimize his ability to know trauma when he sees it or feels it. Empathy is the only thing that will lead to peace.
@@Historian212 HA! Dr. Mat'e was an infant during the Holocaust. My parents and grandparents were Holocaust survivors who actually REMEMBER what happened. And, wonders of wonders, they thought that maybe, just maybe, Jews should have some mechanism that allows persecuted Jews to have a refuge and to defend themselves. They were unabashed Zionists, card-carrying Zionists.
Mat'e badmouths me, my parents and grandparents of blessed memory. Now I KNOW he means well, I really do. But, I won't give him a pass for the harm he does. If we Zionists are so horrible, then I guess whatever violence happens to us, we had it coming, didn't we? Well F*** that.
@@Historian212 HA! Dr. Mat'e was an infant during the Holocaust. My parents and grandparents were Holocaust survivors who actually REMEMBER what happened. And, wonders of wonders, they thought that maybe, just maybe, Jews should have some mechanism that allows persecuted Jews to have a refuge and to defend themselves. They were unabashed Zionists, card-carrying Zionists.
Mat'e badmouths me, my parents and grandparents of blessed memory. Now I KNOW he means well, I really do. But, I won't give him a pass for the harm he does. If we Zionists are so horrible, then I guess whatever violence happens to us, we had it coming, didn't we? Well F*** that.
@@Historian212 Dr Mat'e was an infant when it happened. My parents and grandparents actually went through the Hol0caust in Poland, where the real horrors happened, and remembered what happened. And, wonder of wonders, they decided that a Jewish State was the best bet we got so that we don't get F***ed up again. So they were unabashed, card-carrying Zionists.
And now Mat'e comes along and badmouths me, my parents and grandparents of blessed memory. I know he means well, but he's causing harm. If Z1onists are so horrible, then it's easy to conclude that whatever terrible things happen to them (like 0ct.7.23) they had it coming, didn't they?
We will not distance ourselves and not be silenced. Truth must prevail.
Truth will prevail you will not like the result
Why?? @@JacobRothman
@@JacobRothmanisrahell will not like the result of truth
God bless you guys and especially Gabor Mate for bringing this genocide to the light of day This horror mortifies me with every single day that goes by
Same here- so and many of us Christians here in the USA. We are not all Zionists:/. We are against the horrible genocide and are praying for it to end .
@@dianemautone2862 God bless Diane
He said, “it’s like we’re watching Auschwitz on TickTock Toc”
YES! It’s sickening and horrifying! And that my country is complicit and supplying the arms is beyond forgivable! And no one listens:(
So many have been duped by the media .
You can call it wahtever you want, but there is no genocide.
We've got to stop thinking war is strong and good. We have to teach our children that killing is unintelligent and that strength comes from sharing space for each other ❤ thanks guys. This was really needed
Congrats
EXACTLY what Trump meant when he said it just has to stop. It's NOT about winning, it should be stopping death.
In Africa we call it Ubuntu. Buntu in Zulu means man. Ubuntu translates loosly into humanity. South Africa's democratic elected ruling party in 1994 avoided a blood bath by offering the olive branch of forgiveness and an insistance that never again will one nation be oppressed by another. That should be a shining light for humanity.
What an extremely kind, caring, well-spoken & intelligent human being. Wow!
We love the Maté family... keep on doing what you do!
& Yes, all our hearts are broken, we are with you. Too tragic for words.
I like before even listening. Thank you Frank and thank you Dr Gabor for your humanity 🙏
Dr Mate is a genuis, been following his work for many years.
Thankyou Frank Barat & Gabor Mate for this profound and humane conversation: it offers a timely reminder of how such hate-filled brainwashing can lead to demonic states of mind and sadistic behaviour.
We will never stop calling this out - our very humanity is at stake.
I am in Australia and look on in absolute horror and often times paralysis and with despairing emotions over what is happening.
It is encouraging to know I’m not alone. My heart is broken.
Sadly, Australia openly oppresses their own indigenous peoples like it’s normal.
Their system serves the crown and neocon imperialism!
Indigenous peoples need to join BRICS and leave King Charles subjects to his wef system!
Sadly Australia publicly and proudly serve the crown and at the expense of the oppressed indigenous peoples of the lands!
Hypocrisy. You genocide the indigenous peoples there. Israel wants to become Australia and have no accountability for genocide just like Australia. You're oblivious to your own involvement in genocide.
I just wrote Penny my second strongly worded letter. Don't know what else to do tbh.
@@passyourielts indigenous peoples in the country been fighting government oppression for generations and generations, now you will see that even YOU don’t matter anymore, they got your votes for materialism year in year out!
Thankyou for this video. I feel rage, heartbreak and utter powerless. Endless letters to MPs, marching on the streets…….doesn’t seem to make an iota of difference.
I want to shout and scream but I’ve come up against a taboo. Many people don’t want to talk , but turn away and get on with their lives. What terrifies me is the loss of humanity in the Israeli soldiers and in this we all lose a bit of our humanity. The tragedy of the ethnic murder ( cleansing is too benign a word) of the Palestinians is part of a bigger tragedy.
Thank you Gabor for your insight into “uselessness” and “broken heartedness”.
I have been a therapist for nearly forty years of my life and I know how long healing takes. This fills me with despair.
It sounds like what we're facing in 🇨🇦. It is absolutely unbelievable that so many people, including close family, refuse to even engage in any discussion about the murderous genocide of the Palestinian people and now Lebanon. I live in a perpetual state of rage.
@@India-go6heSo true, fellow Canadian. They continue to use the line, “ the Israelis have to defend themselves “ without trying to understand there is a bigger issue at play. Should Canada call an election, I will not waist my vote on anyone that supports Israel. 🍁
Marching for Ukraine too?
And how long is required to recover from those ravages? Because for me that's for life ...
I truly appreciate this episode I have been dealing with rage and anger because of watching the documented genocide in Palestine and on the other hand watching the silence of our leaders
We must grieve, grieve together. And reflect on the atrocities that human beings are capable of.
Thank you Mr Frank Barat and Dr Gabor Mate for sharing a moment of sanity.
Exactly: An escalation of madness and insanity beyond words.
a psychopathy beyond comprehension!!!!
@@desireedebellis6766 Yes. Expressed in other words. ❤
Having an own nation state is a very natural desire for any ethnic group and I don't see why Jews wanting their own nation state is worse than Hungarians, Croatians, Lithuanians, Ukrainians or Poles wanting this. Living in eternal diaspora is not the natural way of existence for any people.
@@ekesandras1481Judaism is a religion, not an ethnic group. Nevertheless, some nation-states commit horrendous atrocities.
@@ledpupBeing Jewish is belonging to a People.
Anyways, the Muslims have more than enough lands.
If they really wanted to help the Palestinians, and I'm not talking militarily, they could have a long time ago. But they hate the Jews more than they care about the Palestinians. That's why they maintain them for 76 years in refugee camps, instead of helping them integrate in their societies.
Frank Barat and Gabor Mate, two of the best and most compassionate human beings on the planet!
And also the most ignorant
Where is the compassion for the Israelis that were murdered and taken hostage
Thank you both for your intelligence, compassion and wisdom 🙏🏻
Much love ❤️ and respect to Gabor Mate and his family. They are amazing human beings who speak the truth and are standing up on the right side of history.
I agree regarding the darkest time of my life. I have never felt so lonely and so sad. I am frustrated by the failure of our society to understand what is going on. All the things you talk about. I appreciate this discussion. I don't feel so alone. I do know there are many others out there who feel the way I feel. I wish I could do more.
You 100% describe my feelings- I cried more in this 12 momths than I was REALLY HAPPY in 40 years combined.
@@DonElFernandosame .. this NYC born Chicago a hole has shed more tears in a year than my entire life
@@jackklugman107that just means you are human. If everyone were like you, there wouldn't be this slaughter. You probably raised chikdren that share your moral compass, and that too is something. I too have cried and raised and wrote all the politicians using our tax money to fund this genocide, donated and tried to volunteer to go to Gaza, boycotted since 1976, and knew it was all not enough. But I do know in the midst of the devastation the people of Palestine say they gain strength from knowing that we support them, that for once their suffering is not in vain. So you are giving hope.
@@hunger4jsutice "…for once…" Yes, for once. FINALLY. After over 75 years. Because Hamas broke through the prison fence one October day in 2023. For once their suffering is not in vain.
It is also the darķest time of my life.i am 74 years old.i always thought i am crazy i am always seing what is going on in Gaza and Westank oh my god help them this is the hell for them
In love for this people❤
Trauma begets more trauma, from the victimizer and victim, and gets replicated since they are not addressing the core issue of their sense of insecurity. You cannot imprison a people and expect them to act like normal people at all times, and this doese not condone acts of terror or crimes for those actions on both sides. Love that you have Mr. Mate on, he is so clear-sighted. I admire him.
If you believe the Zionist Project carries the trauma of the Holocaust you are fundamentally mistaken.
The weaponization of what most Jews (by "Jews" I do not mean those residing in or fighting alongside the "Only Democracy in the Middle East") know as Shoah has only started quite late, after the trial of Eichmann (in 1961) and gradually, accelerating after 1973, and was and remains calculated and cynical.
This trauma is now so so bad that it is seriously affecting people who are not even victims ... living thousands of miles away and who have beds to sleep in ... and food to eat.
Now, I am not even beginning to compare myself to what the victims are going through ... however, my heart is broken ... truly broken ... and it hurts severely to see people treated in this way ...
In the last week, I have listened to Dr Gabor Mate, Yanis Varoufakis, and Norman Finkelstein, and it would seem all are at the same point, of not being able to see a stop to the genocide based on protest, or the sudden morality of governments that never comes. Personally, I want to say that through the heartbreak, rage, confusion and anger, I now feel I want to do something, take some action for the long term. This will not help Palestine today, but if more of us make changes, we can stop another 'Palestine' tomorrow. The warning is already here, and none of us are useless.
If the aggressors don't care about life, they'll care about money, and we still have choice about how we use what we earn, for now.
Best way to do this is to buy local. Buy small business and small brands. Everything. Toothpaste, shampoo, etc. Keep all electronics as long as you possibly can. Shop Palestinian owned brands (i love Palestine soap cooperative for soap!) Our money is our power.
Rita, I am sincerely hoping we can still do something today. I’m not certain yet what I will do. I know that I want to donate some money to , Doctors Without Boarders and UNRWA (? ). 🍁
Exactly
Listen to Douglas Murray and get the truth!
@@cassylane120 😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣
I'm absolutely heartbroken I hate to imagine what those poor people are feeling. Anguish horror terror fear sadness everything all at the same time. All jews of the world should be ashamed and shoukd come out the billions of them to condemn israel and the state it is. It should go back to the original palestine. End this serial killing madness. Thankyou to both of you humble humans ❤❤
Just excellent. Thank you from a heart broken Irish woman. May we continue to shine a light on the darkness, not be afraid to tell the truth and to pray for peace
Palestine has broken the heart of many. I have never cry so much in my life.
Simply a great human being- in dark times.... Had to watch this video once it popped up. Thanks Frank for this interview with Mate.
@@pepperminttea1 Here we go again with little, deranged Gabby......I knew him as a teenager. Every group of people have their psychopaths and he is ours. Like a capo or judenrat, he hates his own people. He ingratiates himself with Israel's enemies so that he will be seen as a "good Jew". He has, sadly, passed his sickness on to his sons. Pitiful.
Thank you Frank and Gabor. We Must All Rise! Tipping Point!
Just like Gabor said, “You are not useless”. Actively holding the candle of hope in the darkness, means you are useful.
This man is an angel proud of Jewish people because of Jew like him will never allowed myself to dislike Jewish people.
I don't think the Palestinians or Lebanese hate Jews, they hate Zionists. Jews have a history of living peacefully with Muslims in the Arab world.
yes a lovable kapo
@@AS-jh2gv A kapo was a person in a concentration camp that survived by betraying his fellow prisoners. Are you accusing Gabor Mate of being a kapo? How is that lovable?
@@LouisasPrivatePlaylists It's never too late to speak up. Yeh You!! Inspired. If not now, when? Exactly. Thank you.
I was born in Australia at the end of 1945. My father was in the RAAF. When I was a young teenager, my dad told me the outlne of the Holocaust. It was horrifying to me of course but I am thankful that he did. It has made me aware and sensitive to the Colonial brutalisation of Indigenous peoples. The horror of the ADF ongong attacks in Gaza and Palestinians does, as Gabor says, does make many of us feel helpless. When we in Australia learnt about the killing of Australian Aid Workers attempting to deliver food and other aid to Gazan people by ADF airstrikes brought this tragedy even more close to home. In the last years, I have been becomng more and more grief stricken and depressed. Listening to Gabor Mate and other spokespeople who are telling the truth about this horror helps I think.
I love you, Gabor! You are so heartfelt and caring, courageous and wise!
Mate’ one of shinning light of our times❤️
Grateful to be able listen to wise curious souls talking about everything that happens. We are in troubled times, but many are waking up to truth on many levels. There is a lot to take in everywhere we look !
We must overcome these old ways, share and forgive to move on with intelligence and understanding.
Nothing will be solved without the heart of compassion for others seen as part of ourselfes.
When I see and listen to it all that last many years, I feel the suffering there is because of lack of understanding and wisdom. Gabor is here to help us grow in deeper perspective.
We go through much taking it all in,while learning and understanding better, but we must stand strong and become wiser for there to be a more peaceful place for all to live together.
So many labels, fear and ideas comes from the past mind,
dividing all, instead of being open
and sharing.
Please keep on talking! Thank you Frank for being the voice of the oppressed and for allowing all voices like yours to be heard!
Dr. Gabor Mate is a genius. God has blessed him well. Great interview!
I do not feel guilt, I feel anger and injustice and sorrow.
Exactly Mary! I thought, guilt? No, wrong emotion! It’s rage and deep disgust. If I describe what I want to say my comment will be deleted. Thank you Gabor.
I feel indifference.
@@AmonAnon-vw3hr How brave of you to announce to the public that you don’t care about the suffering of people. But that makes sense coming from a person who supports a nation the is committing gen o cide on an occupied people, mur der ing women and children in the name of defending themselves. They mistakenly think they are Gods people, but He rejected them and would never sanctify the hei nous acts they are presently perpetrating on the true victims of this w ar. The world is disgusted.
@@AmonAnon-vw3hr That makes total sense because how else are the people you support able to commit such heinous acts of vio le ce on innocent women and children. The world is disgusted with your dark hearts.
@@AmonAnon-vw3hr Yes the world sees the results of that indifference and is disgusted by it.
This was great to watch. Thank you Frank and thank you Dr. Mate.
Our hearts are broken, too. We are saddened by the pain and suffering of one side and the utter hypocrisy of the masses. Thank you for covering this and let's be sad together rather than indulging in superficial things like sports and entertainment. Lets have conscious and at least call it wrong collectively so we can stand in front of our Creator and say we didn't have the capacity to bring about change but we did what we could and we cried over these horrible atrocities.
Gracias por este espacio compartido. Que la impotencia que experimentamos ante el Horror mayúsculo no se convierta en culpa paralizante, sino en ira e indignación activas. No podemos rendirnos, hemos de seguir exigiendo a nuestros gobiernos el fin de su complicidad en el genocidio. Que más y más gente a nuestro alrededor despierte. Aunque cada día nuestro corazón vuelva a romperse... GRACIAS
Yes, to stop Palestinians genocide against Israel. Why Americans will support Israel. You challenged Israel, and you will arouse a jew. JESUS.
All my respect and admiration to Dr Gabor, for all his honesty, integrity, courage and for the kindness of his beautiful heart.
A true and honest human with in-depth analysis of the colonial powers and their atrocities to the world.
Two beautiful souls......thank you. ❤
❤❤❤
Thank you Dr Gabor ✌🏼
Thank you both. Spotlighting the horrors in this meaningful way is the first step. People around the world are watching.
Thank you, Gábor Mate for words of Truth. The end of conversation was really sad. I feel the samé pain every day.
Gabor’s words and insights in these bloody , horrific atrocities and genocide sheds a bit of hope and light during these desperate times , I remember the impacts , when I first read Gabor & Daniels book “Myth of normal , and how profound that has been so far,on my views of world , listening to him now gives more clarity to those impacts. Thanks to both of you for this conversation and sharing your insights
I'm sorry we have failed Palestine. 💔🖤🤍💚
Radiohead has been making ALBUMS about this behavior becoming the norm since the Bends.
Feeling so powerless.
I'm sorry that the West is so Tyrannical and Controlling and it's come to this level of evil. There's a reason for Holloween and Christmas that we were never educated about.
What can we do? The US clearly backs Israel. No one can challenge or hold the US accountable.
@@cmathews5909 Radiohead (Thom and Jonny at least) are Zionists and refuse to boycott Israel. Jonny is married to an Israeli.
Gabor Maté is a beautiful and wise person. Thank you to both of you.
The two gentlemen are very intellectual and to top it all they are such great humans. All the respect to you from a Palestinian ❤
Such a crucially important interview. Thank you. I hope everyone sees it.
"If people don't look at their own history, why would they look at horrors elsewhere?"
Yes, how can they blatantly ignore their own neocon systems and their own oppressive actions towards the indigenous peoples of the western world- namely USA Canada, Australia and New Zealand.
Very apt .
@@noviaparker5839 but colonised countries like usa, Canada, Australia and NZealand think they wrapped in democracy when they oppressing their own peoples!
Dr. Gabor Mate is hands down, the most amazing human being on the planet!
A Great Healer!
Apart from all the Palestinuans who've never given up the hope of freedom and justice
I can think of a few others. For example, Rabbi Arik Ascherman who puts himself physically between settlers / police and Palestinians in the West Bank. And has done for many years.
PARALYZING
I have made myself sick because of the pain of helplessness, it’s as if I am personally under attack. 😳🇿🇦
Imagine how the Palestinians must feel then…
I thought I was the only one. My heart is on fire 😭 🇬🇧
It's an attack on humanity ! We have to stand against it or humanity is lost
Gabor is so incredibly insightful.
This man express a sense of huge humanity.
Thank you Frank, for bringing us Gabor, who tells the truth, and says what all the leaders and politicians are afraid to say. Love, from a proud Canadian.
I deeply respect Dr. Gabor Maté, and his sons. The World needs more people like them. With love from Southern California.
❤🤍💙
It's Horror upon Horror ! Just as horrific the first time I heard about Nazi Germany . Unspeakable Tragedy. I have No words. Only aggrieved muted tears.
Thank you so much Frank, I feel like you, helpless and without words. Thank you Gabor Maté!!
Let our hearts be broken together ❣️💔 22:05
I love the truth and logic I always hear from the great Gabor Mate. Keep up the truth not many have the balls to say what you are saying
This is the best explanation of the cruelty that’s going on in the Middle East especially when it is explained by an Israeli man , thank you Frank for having him on and thank you Gabour for your calm explanation, anyone seeing this please share because the mainstream media will not , bless you both Martin from Ireland 🙏🙏👏👏👏👏
MERCI pour cette remarquable interview Franck !
Un immense merci à Gabor Mate "Juste" parmi les "Justes" .
Les Francais sont bons amis des Juifs 😈😈😈😈
Merci Beaucoup, Marshall Petain et Monsieur Laval!!!!
-Drancy
Petain
Laval
Drancy
Petain
Laval
Drancy
❤️ This was the most touching interview I have seen in years. There is an incredible depth in your words and facial expressions. I can feel your hearts crying out... Thank you for sharing this. For being and staying human, for cultivating an open heart and mind, and for making a difference.
Peace to the world... ❤️
Thanks Gabor and Frank for giving oxygen to justice
Gabriel Mate.
This man's humanity.
His sincerity.
The heartfelt empathy he feels for his cousins the Palestinians, resonates even just through the timbre of his voice.
What a beautiful soul.
What a pure heart.
He often moves me to tears over this massacre, just in the manner he tries to make sense of it.
Keep talking Gabriel.
We will listen.
And change the world.
One soul at a time.
Don't ever give up on us.
And thank you for this great interview, and the wonderful and thought provoking questions ...
His is a Hungarian name, Gabor.
@@calicocat8213
I know. But he is often called Gabriel by non-Hungarians.
As you will note in the multitude of interviews he has done with Western interviewers.
@@Tanakatricks Really? Thanks, didn't know.
You're from Japan BTW?
@@calicocat8213
Correct. Konnichiwa !
@@calicocat8213 Gábor is Hungarian for Gabriel.
Thank you both🙏
Greeting from Germany.Free PALESTINE.Stop Genocide in GAZA
Germany is the land of the Germans. Are you for the Germans having a nation state?
Also mir gehen die Palästinenser mehr und mehr auf die Nerven. Zuerst laufen sie einem linken Nationalismus hinterher, dann werfen sie sich alle den Islamisten um den Hals, nerven die Welt mit ihren Terroranschlägen, leben von unseren Steuergeldern (UNRWA), wollen nichts arbeiten und kriegen alle 6 bis 10 Kinder und wundern sich dann, dass es eng wird im Gazastreifen.
Kulturell sind uns die Juden viel näher, besonders die deutschstämmigen. Also liegt meine Sympathie eher dort.
Greetings from a fellow German who lives in the UK... I despair of our governments. Free Palestine and the middle East from the evils of Zionism in the world and Israel 🇵🇸🕊️🇱🇧🕊️❤️🙏🏻
@@MichiZaus GERMAN!! AHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!👿👿👿👿
Di F@hne h.o.ch! Di R3ihen f3st ge$chlo$.sen!
$.A. mars.hiert mit ruh1g fe$tem S.c.hritt
K@m'r@.den, di R0tfr0nt und Reaktion er$cho.ssen,
Mar$chier'n im Gei$.t in un$er'n R3ihen m!t.☠☠☠☠
@@MichiZaus GERMAN! AHAHAHAHAHA! 😈👿👿👿👿👿👿
You guys gonna try again, huh? ("Free... from the evils of..." yeah, heard that before)
Thank you both so much. Such knowledge and compassion!!
I truly appreciate being reminded we may be physically alone,
yet there are many, many, many beautiful souls bearing witness,
speechlessly breaking/opening our hearts more every day.
I am being forced to "weed my garden" and it (I) will be healthier and much more beautiful next year, God willing/Inshallah Shalom 🕊 and...
Love to the like-minded trauma survivors out there