Red Dead Redemption 2 - Arthur Tells Sister He's Dying & Is Afraid (Very Sad Cutscene)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 ноя 2018
- RDR2 2018 The fine art of conversation quest, Arthur Morgan reveals to nun he is dying from TB (Tuberculosis) and tells how he contracted it, for a few $ debt collection, he also talks about his family, life, and that he's afraid, very sad scene
Marvel's Spider-Man 2 Videos: • Marvel's Spider-Man 2 ...
Assassin's Creed Mirage videos: • Assassin's Creed Mirage
Mortal Kombat 1 Videos: • Mortal Kombat 1 2023 (...
God of War videos: • God of War Series (200...
Tekken 8 Videos: • TEKKEN 8
Devil May Cry Series Videos: • Devil May Cry Series (...
Full Game Walkthrough videos: • FULL GAMES Walkthrough...
Full Game Movie / All Cutscenenes videos: • All Game Cutscenes (Fu...
Follow me on Twitter: / chriszanar 
Игры
his eye when he say "I'm afraid"
that an oscar winner performance
First.
@@DarkSharingan21 did anyone fucking ask
@@justanawkwarddude9035 yea I was actually wondering who was first
@@donxponce7729 bro I’m just saying you’re making yourself look a bit dumb by saying “nobody cares” but then typing a whole paragraph. If you didn’t care you would’ve just moved on...be better bro it’s not 2020 anymore
@@justanawkwarddude9035 Woah. Why'd you wake up on the wrong side of the bed, buddy? It's a checkmark user. I just typed first cause I know people like you will swarm to them
Red Dead Depression.
Hiroyuki Matsushima I actually cried at the end of chapter 8
@YGuy1 6 Chapters in regular story and 2 for epilogue. 8 in total
Hiroyuki Matsushima I feel that
I am so sorry really and I hope RDR3 will come ....
LOL!!! that's a good one.
She said goodbye multiple times because she knew that would be the last time they meet.
Well yeah he just said he hd TB and was dying
not the last time
he didnt die in my story
@@ReadThisIfYourGayLolhe dies
If you listen to her tone, you can tell she's close to tears. Sister Calderon really wanted to stretch that conversation for as long as possible for Arthur's sake, but she had a train to catch :(
This Nun is such a great character, some call her a small side character but I call her one of the most important to Arthurs story.
True.
i love her character so much. she reserves judgment and really listens to what arthur has to say.
In a way she was the person Arthur needed to seek redemption
She's one of the if not the final stepping stone for Arthur's redemption. Earthly equivalent of the pearly gates.
500kDISLIKESwhaaa
That feeling when you spend 100 hours with a character and watch him die staring at the sunrise
It's a freaking sunrise.
R A V E N R I D G E I chose the other ending I died when M killed me outside camp after I went back for the money
@@jjkm17 I need to know why would someone chose the money when you know arthur is pretty much dead, please explain why
@@MottoYT_ Only reason I see is arthur goes to get the money to give it to john before he passes
@@MottoYT_ If you have high honor you cut one eye of micah pretty cool
Arthur at beginning of game: We need mo muneh
Arthur at end of game: here’s some muneh
wE jUsT nEeD mOnEh
Huge character arc when you realize, the further you get into the game after Arthur's diagnosis, he gives money away more and more. He knows he's dying and he wants to help people however he can, but still denies being a good man. Everyone thinks Arthur Morgan is a good man except for Arthur Morgan. In the end, he dies fighting to give his friend a chance to start over.
MonEh
It's weird how in every single damn thing the assholes become saints and the saints become assholes🤣
Have some... *GOD DAMN FAITH*
A real bomb shell of a line. You dont often hear this from protagonists, especially someone as strong and manly as Arthur. Makes him so much more human. Excellent writing
@@GrayGaming-uv9md Dont bring that capeshit goyslop into this discussion
@@GrayGaming-uv9md It takes lot of strength to open up to People, many just don't understand that
@@GrayGaming-uv9mdbut a weak person is emotional
@@1stwonder788 Not really
2:10 he sounds like forest gump
3:13 - the voice actor absolutely nails it. The hesitation, then the crack in his voice. It’s all really well done.
It gets better, this was MoCap, so they were acting in most scenes in the game.
Arthur's facial expression too
Roger Clark was absolutely fantastic in this game !
@@BiscuitBoi77 I think the facial expressions are as convincing, if not more than the dialogue. The way his lips pull back and he stares at multiple objects. It's exactly what people look like holding back tears and in a mental spiral.
They're actors, not voice actors. Roger Clark's facial expressions also add to the sadness of this scene.
Arthur to Sister: “I shall try.”
Arthur’s last words: “I tried. In the end, I did.”
Not if you count coughing, wheezing, and heavy breathing
@@crybaby18981 bruh
@@crybaby18981 which aren't words lol smh
@@crybaby18981 "wheeze,cough cough heavy breathing"
-Arthur Morgan
It could be "damn us both!"
“I’m afraid”
That’s like seeing your dad cry
The person you always perceived as strong and unbreakable is showing emotion and it hurts so bad
ŠÄM Damn , I felt that
ŠÄM so true i feel u friend
Morgan is my father
Felt that with my pops. My stepdaddy actually but I am closer with him than my own mother.
Hardcore army man too.
Saw him cry for the first time in my life when he was bedridden due to diabetes . . .
Tore my fucking soul to shreds.
The moment you realize your parents are people just like yourself.
“Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act.”
Words we should all live by.
Sister Calderon is exactly what Arthur needed. She isn't overly preachy and she knows that Arthur needs a more grounded talking to rather than religious jargon. She's even willing to admit her own moments of weakness.
yeah Arthur Said ahh to try and sound happy for her but he just couldn’t hold in that cough
How did you get this cutscene? I got reverend instead
@@silentkbg1393 Having high honour
@@didsthecat1503 gyat damn, I would have preferred this one
I think also you have to complete the mission for the church if I remember right.
He says he is afraid, yet he fights until his last breath to help others start over. What a character!
Hence the "redemption" from a bad life.
@@deepakr.sastry756 total masterpiece!
That's what makes him different from dutch and micah.
Micah always chose the easy way, betraying others and killing others to survive. He had no problem doing these things to anyone anywhere.
Dutch was a manipulative, narcissistic moron who crumbled down when people began questioning him, and when he's watching Arthur die on the mountain, he realises he f*cked up.
But instead of apologising, he lefts Arthur there to die, and it takes him nearly 7-8 years to try and take revenge for what he did.
I love him! 😥
@@lukastojanovic6961 don't we all ?
''Why you keeps doing side missions and avoid the main ones?''
3:17
Damn if this ain't true. I literally spent the rest of the game when I got TB doing everything but the side missions. Plus I didn't want more of my friends to die.
SPOILERS
In the final mission after your horse dies I knew it was the end for Arthur so I turned off the game and didn’t come back for a few days I just didn’t want to see Arthur die at least I had good honor so Arthur died staring at the sunrise
@@vandapanda1324 you were lucky. I wouldnt love the game as I do if I havent died looking the sunshine
sean van der linde your lucky my dumbass got shot by Micah Smelly ass
“Why don’t you do that last debt collecting side mission in chapter two?”
Me: 3:17
The fact that Arthur doesn't know himself is so true. Every time he has the opportunity to help someone, he does it, yet he calls himself a bad man, he calls himself ugly, but if you groom him right, he might be the most handsome man in all the 4 states of the game. He thinks he's simple and dumb but when you look at his journals and his drafting skills, he has an artistic sensibility that no one else in the gang seems to possess.
So very well said, always felt for Arthur when people in the game constantly called him dumb. He’s actually got such an intelligent side to him
He is probably a smart and talented person with a bright future yet its sad with the amount of self deprecation he does to himself it really makes him relatable that the amount of low self esteem you have for yourself will also make you soon realized the amount of credit you could've given to yourself either though its sad most of the time that other people make you realize it better than yourself. Arthur is probably the most realistic human character i ever seen in a video game, I really do hope games will have more characters like him in the future.
He's probably just being humble. I'm very similar. Never give myself credit for anything
@@sib1930 you just gave yourself credit for being humble
Your comment is the best on this video. There are uncontable people around the world that are so brilliant but unfortunately can't perceive that due to bad people that are constantly diminishing them.
1:12 I showed this scene to my grandmother back in 2019, cause it meant so much to me. She loved the message about taking a gamble that love exists. She passed away last month and now every time I come back to this scene, it's like I'm talking to her again.
What happened to her?
Sorry for your loss friend.
What a liar.
@@j-king428take a gamble that this story exists, and make a loving act😢
@@j-king428shut up
“I’m afraid”.
Two words. That’s all it took for me to realize just how much I love Arthur.
@Definitely not the Question no its two
😭😭
When he said that I started to tear up 😭😭😭
Those two words helped me realize he was human, not just a man, not just a killer, but a human being with feelings, (as in his character, I mean this figuratively)
I - am - afraid... In my planet those are three words...
Hearing the baddest outlaw in the west say “I’m afraid” sent chills down my spine
Excellent line for an excellent character. Great way to further humanize him and make him more relatable
For me it felt like seeing my dad cry for the first time. To see this bastion of strength, this steadfast man who never so much as grimaced or winced when he hurt himself, who for my entire life had been a steady, sturdy man, cry for the first time; it changed me. I felt it down to my core how utterly human he was, and how hard he tried to keep it all in. And when that facade finally broke, it felt like I had met him all over again.
@@hunterduncan1078 that is the perfect description of how it felt. he was just a man in the wrong place at the wrong time, and he found redemption at both the best and worst time possible. Rockstar made this one of the best storylines ever created.
@@hunterduncan1078 Yeah when my grandma died and I saw my dad cry it just changed how I looked at him as a person.
"We aint in the west no more."
"But, well- you're right!"
-Arthur and mary-beth
2:20 This face from arthur here is what a lot of guys do when they are about to cry but hold it back. This game has so much detail i swear.
what a lot of humans do*
It's not just a male thing
@@Taima 99% percent of the time, it's a male thing.
@@Taima most woman would just cry, man would try to hold back the tears
@@thefurmidablecatlucky3 it depends. Yes women are more likely than men to just cry, but not every woman is comfortable with straight up crying, and some will try to hold it back in a similar way. I’m not saying it’s some kind of 50/50 thing on men vs women, just that more than a few women do.
@@Taima yeah but men get judged when they cry, women can cry all they want and wont receive anything
I will say it.
Arthur is the best written video game character of all time.
I know people like John, but they wrote Arthur with so much more depth.
The way he says things when random enounters happen like a woman judging Arthur for killing her husband and the way he says sorry is just so hard hitting. I love this character and I will never stop crying at chapter 6. I played it 12 times and I still cry at the end. But nothing was like the first time.
This game is effecting me in rl on a level like nothing else in video games, shows or movies. It actually makes me think how I can be a better human.
Preach
I think there's something to be said about making a protagonist that surpassed John Marston. He's considered one of the best of all time.
i agree so much about adapting the quotes into my real life. The one I use the most is "Revenge is a fools game" ever since i heard that and actually thought about it, I use it in my everyday life. Mainly because revenge will get you nowhere but a deeper hole.
L pfp
Affecting*
"You don't know me." A line Arthur said multiple times to multiple people who viewed him in a good way. You got your redemption in the end, Arthur. Rest in peace.
What does rest in peace mean?
@@ueu3j2nswuwu51 I guess I’m gay now
@@ueu3j2nswuwu51 no u
@@ueu3j2nswuwu51 using emojis like a kid I see
@@ueu3j2nswuwu51 jokes on you I AM GAY. Let me guess, you're 7 huh?
Arthur Morgan is the best fictional character ever created. Fight me.
I agree with you.
@@zilong4133 No way. Not even close.
I agree, but John is close
Guts from Berserk
He is one of the best for sure
God the face of Arthur when he says "I am afraid". A masterpiece.
This was the first video game I ever played fully and it really changed my life. I never felt connected to a character before I was introduced to RDR2.
He was on the verge of tears. This game really makes you feel
I haven’t even played rdr2 yet but it still breaks my heart
This scene helped me get over my depression. Sister is a great gem of a character. Shes an angel
Sister Calderon is too good for us 🥺
Take a gamble that love exists , and do a loving act ♥️
Seriously doubt Rockstar will be able to EVER one up this epic masterpiece. This is the best movie I have ever played.
Agreed, they really out did themselves with the Red Dead games IMO, easily beating their GTA series of games.
@Prestige Gameplays way off buddy. I got into gta back in 2001 (after the first couple of top down GTA games) funny for you to assume that. My point was they (Rockstar games) out did themselves with their Red dead series IMO. Yeah GTA 4 was one of my favorites (VC still stands at the top for me and Vice city stories /gta4 for that series) i do enjoy GTA 5 but RDR and RDR2 have taken my top games by Rockstar. Hope this clears things up for you about myself and my gaming experience.
If there's one who can beat R*, it's R* themselves. They're just unbeatable when it comes to storytelling.
@Prestige Gameplays Alright there’s at the very least some merit to your other points, but story? Are you fucking kidding me? Red Dead’s story is 20x what all of gta’s stories combined could ever dream of being.
It's truly amazing of how hard they worked on this game, true masters of game development. Anyone that thinks game developers shouldn't crunch, they're way wrong. Thank you Rockstar for always making single player the forefront of each game, please try to continue to do so.
The look on his face, in his eyes, when he says “I’m afraid”. That really got me. I felt that.
for real
Thats exactly the face people make when they try to hold in tears
One of the best facial animation in a video game.
I did too
IT HIT ME SO HARD
"I guess... I'm afraid."
This one sentence conveys more emotion than any other in this incredible work of art. The voice actor (whose name I forget) did a fantastic job playing Arthur. Following him on this whole journey, to arrive at this moment, was heartrending. Everything you do after this conversation feels so much more important.
His name is Roger clark
Roger Clark :)
This game has very good writing, if it was a movie it could easily go for the oscars. I just wish other game companies did the same, especially when it's a single player game.
Sadly there ain't too much companies going for making art just like this game, well writted stories and that
This game is so overated love it but Arthur and rdr2 are so overated
@@DeadX2 you are either below the age of 14 or got lobotomy as a child because aint no way
@@DeadX2 says the game's overrated. refuses to elaborate. classic
@@DeadX2 overrated? but how and why? i never heard someone saying that rdr is overrated
One very understated part of this scene I really like is how when Arthur says he has TB, Sister doesn't flinch. She doesn't move away from him, doesn't hold her breath, doesn't even blink or change her expression. From this you can tell she's used to being around the sick and dying. Not only that, she doesn't judge him when he admits to manslaughter. She may be the most truly Christian character I've ever seen in a video game. Like Arthur, I'm not much for belief myself, but I like Sister Calderon. She reminds me of my grandmother.
Dar S// ❤️❤️
Dar S catholic she’s catholic she’s a nun also her church has a cross Christians don’t have neither
@@jjkm17 christians have crosses.
Dimenital Archer Christians who have crosses aren’t Christians they catholic cause Christians believe that Jesus came back from the dead and plus they believe god would hate to look at a cross after it killed Jesus
@@jjkm17 thats literally incorrect my family is Christian. They still have crosses and they believe jesus came back from the dead too. Christians and Catholics are not that much different from one another.
Arthur in heaven:
There you are lenny.
WHY DOES READING THIS HURT ME SO BAD
Oh man this hit me big and needs more likes
And they had music and laughs and booze for eternity
more like
HAAA FOUND YAAA LENNYYYYYYYYYY
"Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act."
This is my favorite line ever, in any entertainment form. Whenever I feel down or in the gutter, I say this line to myself and try to change my perspective.
This line allowed me to meet my wife and become a happily married man. It's amazing how Art can genuinely impact your life in ways you can't fathom. We're all gonna die one day, and the world is a rough place with tough challenges, but don't fall into nihilism. Try and keep your head up, eyes on the beauty, and do your part to move the needle of humanity forward.
I'll never meet you or agree with you on everything, but I love you and wish you the best.
if it is okay can you tell how you met with your wife
@@erentkss7805 I met her on Hinge and the first week together we saw eachother and went on dates/day trips every singe day (we both said "I love you" on the 4th day). Then we spent a week apart (I went to a family thing in a different state.)
That week apart, self doubt creeped in. "Do I really like her?", "Could we really have a future?", "Could I really ask her to marry me?"
When I got back, we talked, I cried, and asked for a break. She was nice about it, but she was sad.
The rest of that day I wrestled with my doubt, spoke to my Grandma, and thought hard about being alone/single again. Then that quote popped into my head. I texted her to meet up the next morning, we did, I apologized, and explained my self doubt and hard time gaking chances. We got back together and got married 3 months later.
That was all a year ago and we're still going strong!
@@My20GUNS oh firstly thank you for telling me this beatiful story. i am having a relationship it already has been 2 years but we barely see each other. we live a distant relationship i can't go to her cause the economic problems of Turkey. i always tell myself do i love her really or i don't. i can't be sure what am i gonna do. she thinks about marriage but how could i get married even i don't know about my feelings what should i do :(
Take a gamble on love, as arthur said. Introspect and then you decide whether you want to spend the rest of your life with her. All the obstacles are worthless in front of love. Trust yourself. Good luck.
I teared up after this scene with Sister. Beautifully said, and it transcends any era
Arthur thinking he’s terrible and irredeemable while everyone who knows him sees a kind, bighearted man in a bad situation.... RT if u slammed that mfing cry button
My crying turned to weeping. Gawd dayum this game is good.
rt?
rachele yea u cant RT on RUclips.
Well depending on how you play.
@@pcgamerz3081 it's a meme, friend
“I had a son...
he passed away.
I had a girl who loved me...
I threw that away.
My momma died when I was a kid...
and my daddy...
well, I watched him die...
and it weren’t soon enough.”
- Arthur Morgan, 1899
I wonder how his father died do u know?played through a lot probably missed it
Damien Vazquez the only things we really know about Arthur’s farther (Lyle Morgan) is that he’s welsh, he was a bad man and obviously Arthur watched him die
BibleThump
@@MitchJenkz thank u i watched every cutscene and thought i missed some detail but either way this game has life like details
@@MitchJenkz aye nigga
This scene, in my opinion, has earned its place among the greatest in gaming history by delivering a raw emotional experience that creates a profound connection to the character and truly brings them to life.
For sure, I can probably name only 10-20 games that have even remotely affected me like this (and sadly most of them are from the 90s and early 00s... I feel like the average narrative depth in games has somehow decreased since then). "Cyberpunk 2077" is probably the only other game from the last few years that's had such an effect. A few other indie titles too, but no other big-budget games.
I got reverend in this scene instead
When author just straight up said, "I'm afraid." that might have been the exact moment that I saw him as not just a character in another game I play, but as a character that will always have a place in my heart in one of my favorite games of all time.
When Arthur says, “I’m afraid.” I don’t see him as an animated character, I see a real man, with a real soul, even though it’s all fiction. That’s what I call art.
Thank god this game isnt from EA
@@silasmerzenich fr
Yeah, this also happens with things like the berserk manga and the last of us 2, especially if you’re open minded enough to understand it’s courageous plot choices, wich are, btw, totally justified, people are just too close minded and aren’t able to understand some character’s emotions
@@bryanvitone6754 some of the best emotional storytelling I’ve ever experienced came from video games, TLOU 1 & 2 are what made me want a ps4 in the first place, Red Dead 2 is what made me proud to own one. So glad to have gotten to play these games.
@@GreatOldOne9866 yeah, honestly people keep calling tlou2 shit even today, apparently people can’t distinguish actual shit from chocolate, is it really all that hard to understand the plot, the characters that aren’t Joel and why the ending was like that ?
Right when he says “I’m afraid.”
I fucking shatter like glass.
Oh, I know...
My poor baby...
@@TheIGITnBLUE
😢
Everytime
Its so heartbreaking seeing Arthur just suffer all throughout chapter 6
How do you see the nun like this though
Seeing Arthur admit to being afraid is like seeing your dad cry.
"take a gamble that love exists and do a loving act" When I was young my father who wasn't always the best Catholic used to say that giving your life for another was the most loving thing a human could do and was convinced that if you did you would be admitted to heaven on the spot . This line always filled me with that sense of love and awe just like when I was a kid.
Sacrificial love is the most beautiful love. Even Jesus' sacrificial love for us is what gets us into Heaven. Believe that He sacrificed for YOU and Heaven is yours to enjoy just like the thief on the cross next to Him.
For all my issues I've had in my life with the Church, the one thing I've heard repeated no matter which Catholic order I've been around is John 15:12-13
This is my commandment, that you love one another as I have loved you. No one has greater love than this, to lay down one’s life for one’s friends.
The amount of expression on Arthur’s face in this scene is so mesmerizing
I playing this game again after final for 4 month ago and just because this scene,i really like the character of arthur morgan
@Jonathan Flood this game was VERY dragged-out, but that conclusion was so worth it. I fell off after Guarma, but came back and the rest of Beaver Hollow made me cry. You really saw the fall of Dutch and it was heartbreaking, as was Arthur’s fate.
Yep. I bet the scene wouldn't be this impactful if the facial animation is not this amazing.
@@paperclip9558 you right,the faces of arthur is make me like seeing my best friend when they dying
Arthur Morgan is really great man i will never forget him
"I got it beating a man to death.. For a few bucks."
Sister: :)
She's happy, because he's being honest with himself.
@@Jamplays592 it's a joke, calm down
@@janalf3760 I don't think the guy said anything, actually, I never looked at it that way.
@@Jamplays592 not even that’s just her neutral fucking face
Im not religious but i see that as proof sister is truly holier than thou. She sits right next to a dying man and takes his confession without judgment or even a frown.
Exploration is a key part of this game, without exploration you can miss this whole scene, the best scene ever written in a video game, the best line ever delivered and probably the most impactful one in the history of the entire medium of gaming, the writing staff at rockstar deserve a big bow of respect. This is what a video game written by Vince Gilligan would look like is, as said by Whitelight.
I’m sitting here in full tears in my eyes, feeling so lost don’t know where my life is headed, failed the second year or university, my life is a total complete mess, no social skill, no good physique, no friends but I use this clip as a refuge of how sad I am and how lost I am and I weep because in some ways I feel him, I’ve never been to full of pride, or showing off I’m just a regular guy just wanting his purpose in life, love you all ❤️
My friend, I'm so sorry you had to go through that! You're not alone, so hang in there. To be honest, my life is a mess as well. I dropped out of college, worked for minimum wage under an abusive boss, have an extreme inferiority complex because I am unattractive, several health issues, no social skills, and no idea where my life is going because I lack talent. But I continue to hope for the best and try to be optimistic in the hope that things will improve someday! When I'm feeling down or sad, I remember the few good times I've had, which makes me happy! It can be more difficult to love ourselves than others at times. We will get through this friend, I assure you. Stay strong!!!
@@karthikmahesh9249 Thank you my friends your words of encouragement mean a lot to me because they lift me up, I shall pray for you and for us to move forward and better our situation ❤️
I know how you feel after failing my first year at university I fell into a dark pit.
@@karthikmahesh9249I hope you’re well I love you my life is still the same but I wish you the best
You can do it friend, whatever happens just keep moving forward and you will find your place in this world, I personally took everything I have now for granted and I may lose it all, but it’s not the end. People make mistakes and bad decisions at times but “ just because someone stumbles or loses their way, it doesn’t mean they’re lost forever, sometimes we all need a little help” and above all…Hope and love
"I'm afraid..."
And this is why both Red Dead Redemption protagonists hold a place in my heart instead of those irredeemable psychopaths in Grand Theft Auto.
@@YoMommaNYaDaddy I do like Niko as well. He seems like the only one trying to be decent.
TheAwesomeDarkNinja yeah he moved to America to get away from the life of crime but is drawn back into it thanks to Roman the story in that game is amazing
still gives me goosebumps when he says that :( im still getting emotional
Nico Bellic wasn't a criminal in his home country, he was a soldier who was betrayed. That's why he came to America. To find the person that double crossed his platoon. And to live with his cousin in the land of opportunity.
That's exactly how I feel, a lot of those charecters in GTA never had a redemption arc and did what they did without remorse (especially 5 more so)
You just can't go evil after this cutscene.
You only get this cutscene if you play on high honor so... wouldn't get why would someone want to suddenly go evil
@@thegili8460 for me my honor was constantly shifting from high to low and after i saw this scene I never let it go back down again
@@sexymm3379 makes sense. consider yourself lucky that you were on high honor while playing this mission😅
@@thegili8460 bro i was on almost max honor for the whole game and didnt get this cutscene
@@g3s0 probably because you didn't do enough side missions... the sister is a character from a side mission
I love it when Arthur help the Sister carry her luggage and help her get to the train after she told him to take the gamble, at that moment he already take the gamble and do a loving act.
A friend of mine died of a terminal illness about half a year ago, and my uncle was diagnosed with stage four cancer the year this game came out. Like many people, I've lost several loved ones since the game launched in October 2018. I'm playing through the story once more, and Arthur's reconciliation with his fate is much more impactful to witness this time around.
I had a friend that absolutely loved this game that unfortunately passed away 2019. His name was Mason Roland. Mason was born with a rare kidney disease called cystonosis and he didn’t have much time to live around the time this game came out. He loved the game though and he grew to love Arthur as we all did. Unfortunately he died before finishing the game. Before he died he actually got into the story mode like really deep, I think he was around the part where hosea and Lenny die in the bank robbery. But anyways, I always wanted him to get to this part so he could understand that even a video game character shares his pain deeply, because I think my best friends biggest problem was knowing he was gonna die. Idk I just wanted him to not feel alone in his situation. And I know that there’s a huge difference there between reality and video games but the message is R* sent just hit me different every time I see this scene. I love you Mason I know you watching over me at all times.
I can relate you done great you're not in this alone may mason ride up above across the skies
Sorry for your loss brother..
I’m very sorry for your loss life is cruel
Life is the cruellest thing to exist, but just know that your friend is in a much, much better place now. I'm so, so sorry for your loss, I couldn't imagine losing a friend, leave alone the way that you did.
Hes in heaven now with virtual arthur morgan with hes back watching over you
This scene means so much to me since I contracted TB this year. Only thing is, I'm going to be fine. Arthur wasnt.
Kristopher Lawson good luck with that
How did you contracted it ?
Thank god TB isn't a death sentence now like it was back then.
Kristopher Lawson i know
I wish you good luck brother, you will be fine
Unpopular opinion: Arthur Morgan is not only the greatest protagonist in video games, but he is the greatest protagonist in any type of entertainment
How a small sentence can have such an emotional weight... brilliant
What's s name of this mission
“I’m afraid. I still don’t believe in nothing..”
“There is nothing to be afraid of..
Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act”.
Arthur saves John.
This is such a beautiful moment in the game.
Helped John, Abigail, and Jack escape.
He gave the entirety of his share from the train heist to Tilly so she could live a good life
Despite being tired of fighting he goes to help Sadie end the last of the O'Driscoll's so that she could avenge her husband
He did everything he could to redeem himself for what he's done to Mrs. Downs and her son
His relationship with Rain's Fall and doing everything he could to help him and his people
The act of constantly gave money out to those in need, he took a gamble with so many people.
Well I went for the money 😐😥
Opxxi _ is whyyyyyyyy
Jack M ikr
@@opxxi_2197 bruhhhh
3:17, the most human a video game character has ever felt.
And you can tell they put a lot of detail into his face. The curl of his lips, the tears in his eyes, the swelling of his cheeks. He was genuinely afraid.
I think he was the greatest most human character in the history of games
@@georgecant-stand-yeh5451 Mhm. Even though they portray him as a cold outlaw, they still manage to humanize him along the whole story.
Ok..?
Not a single toxic Witcher fanboy bragging about Geralt?? Strange
Arthur is such a relatable character. We’ve all done bad things, lived bad lives. Some of us have committed worse sins than others, but there’s always hope with life. Even when you’re at the end of your rope you have the opportunity to do some good. Even if, like Arthur, you feel like a fraud and have no idea why you’re doing what you’re doing
every single time I see this scene, I always cry. Arthur is the first character that has ever made me cry just with two words. "im afraid."
I love how Arthur just starts giving out money to everybody he's saying goodbye to. He knows he isn't going to need it, and just a little cash can get a person off to a good start.
such an underrated observation
@@shubhamkarbarman6028 Did you also make this observation?
Ironic since you start the game by robbing a lot of unfortunate people
@DILF Asriel games not called red dead REDEMPTION for nothing.
@@dilfasriel6354that’s what I thought when I read this comment, seems like a good way to end things off considering he knows he is dying and make up
That “I’m afraid” is the closest I’ve come to crying during a cutscene. You can literally hear the tears he’s holding back. Great performance
Not sure if this is triggered by an optional side mission or I missed it, I didn't get this cutscene after sending captain Monroe. But for me I literally cried when Arthur tries to console his dying horse at the end.. "There, there, easy..Whoah.. Thank you 🙏" The most emotional moment in a videogame so far for me
@@mohanhegde I believe it is good honor only
@@qeeps3991 Yeah I had my honor maxed, but looks like it requires the optional Brothers and Sisters side mission completed for the sister cutscene
@@mohanhegde you need your honor maxed and you need to do all the sisters side missions.
@@ponyboy9557 yeah, I figured it out later👍
Arthur Morgan easily is one of the best written video game characters ever
But we should give Roger Clark, his voice and mocap actor, just as much love and recognition for helping give so much life to such a wonderful character
This has to be the most important and beautiful scene in the whole game.
If it makes anybody feel better: reading his journal after this encounter, he writes that he's pretty much at peace.
Christopher Mac i remember reading that and it made me feel much better. That talk with the nun apparently helps ease his mind and then he says his mental goodbyes to everyone in the gang that he cares about
lol many YT videos are becoming therapy sessions to overcome the death of a game character. What an achievement...
Dude it's about the message of the scene and the meaning behind it not about Arthur itself he doesn't exists XD
What did it say I missed it?
thanks, I needed this.
Arthur has became the best main character of all time...
Daniela Viegas The emotion in this story and it's characters rivals The Last Of Us
Daniela Viegas yes even better than movie characters
Mavoric 7895 it’s way better than the last of us
@@Dronom- they both equal IMO
His character development was so good; outlaw and right hand man to a gang leader, turned into a caring, hopeful guardian to his extended family.
Hands down, one of my top 3 favourite vid game characters.
After finishing Arthur's arc I felt like I really lost someone really close to me, I spent hours crying about all the things that Arthur did
After the game ended I literally was lost in my thoughts I was like,wow.Arthur Morgan is by far the greatest video game character of all time,this game gave me an insight about life
Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act.
Years later she meets John Marston in Mexico.
John Marston.. the man that could live on with his family because Arthur did his loving act.
It's makes me cry
Bro stop
y stop?
@@level100wizard unfortunately John copped the harsh side of life and the law.
But it was still 11-12 years that he wouldn't of got if Arthur didn't give his life for him.
Those years contained what we saw in the epilogue and during the credits.
@HidanVenom yes good point I forgot to add that as well. Despite Johns tragic ending, Jack lives on.
Who knows what would be of Jack and Abigail if Arthur had not saved John, could they of lived without John? Who knows, but Arthurs bravery ensured that John lived on to keep his family safe.
The way the actor and the animators deliver that "I'm afraid" line is incredible, proof that once more videogames are one of the best way to experiences good storytelling.
Juan Amaya the actors name is Roger Clark I case you where wondering
Performance and facial capture was utilised also, by the way. So it's not just his voice and perhaps why it matches it up so well.
*the best
I agree. Books and video games seem like the best storytelling media we have right now. One puts you into the mind of the protagonist and hits all your senses through your imagination, while the other allows you to actively interact and make decisions during your adventures. Damn, we're so lucky.
Hell yeah.
People say it all the time, but still - this game is a masterpiece. A transcendent work of art, and one of the best games ever made.
Arthur’s words reveal deep regret, sadness, and fear about the life he has led, his past actions, and the consequences of those actions.
Regret and guilt: Arthur admits to living a bad life, marked by violence and poor decisions. He feels guilt for the consequences of his actions, such as contracting TB and losing the people he loved. His remorse is evident in the way he recounts these events.
Loss and loneliness: Arthur has experienced significant loss, including the death of his mother, father, son, and the end of a loving relationship. These losses contribute to his feelings of isolation and despair, as he has no one left to turn to for support.
Fear of the unknown: Arthur admits that he still doesn't believe in anything, suggesting a lack of faith or spiritual grounding. This lack of belief leaves him uncertain about what comes next, especially in the face of his own mortality. His fear likely stems from the unknown nature of what awaits him after death and the potential consequences of the life he has led.
Desire for redemption: Arthur’s words imply a desire for redemption, even though he may not explicitly express it. By acknowledging his past mistakes and admitting his fear, he's showing a willingness to confront the truth about his life. This vulnerability may be a first step toward seeking forgiveness, redemption
The fact that Sister, a person Arthur has met only a few times, cares more about Arthur dying than Dutch, essentially his father whom he has known for 20 years says a lot about him and how he never really cared about Arthur.
I disagree I think it had something to do with the stress put on Dutch and the head injury he sustained in chapter 4.
@@hyperfire1134 Those didn't make Dutch crazy, they just made him show his true colors more by how wreckless and insane his plans got from that point. I don't think he ever truly cared about Arthur, because once Arthur starts to realize Dutch's insanity and questions Dutch even a little bit, he straight up calls Arthur a traitor and that he isn't believing in Dutch and his ideals anymore. It's obvious he only liked Arthur because of his blind loyalty. Dutch doesn't want loyalty, he wants blind loyalty, which is why as soon as Arthur began doubting and questioning Dutch on Guarma, he replaced him with Micah in the snap of a finger, even though Arthur has been in the gang the longest out of everyone, and Micah has only been with them a few months and is very clearly untrustworthy and dangerous. If he really cared about Arthur, he would've been checking up on him about his sickness and mental well being, but he never even acknowledges it, and when he does for one time near the end of the game, he doesn't give Arthur an emotional speech about life like Sister did, and instead focuses on his own needs and desires, which is to be admired like God.
@@billyhenerson2871 in Red Dead 1 John describes Javier as a cynic who convinced himself he was a romantic. I think that also describes Dutch perfectly.
There's a random camp event where Uncle of all people points out that Dutch just wants to rule over his own little fiefdom of bandits and not actually change the world.
Dutch was a narcissistic user and an awful person.. especially by the end. Sister doesn’t know him as well but is a good person. It goes to show calling someone son doesn’t mean you love them. Dutch made his choices at the end.
Because Dutch is dic*head hand in hand with micah, freakin annoyin voth of them
I really love how, she never mentions God. She doesn't preach. She just is warm and kind. She affirms Arthur. She gives him strength when he needed it. To push him. It's such a bitter sweet moment.
Thats cus the creators of the game didnt want to deal with whining and backlash from intolerant hate groups from both sides. Despite it being a fictional game, it's very interesting that he opens up to person who has a strong relationship with Christ about his fear. Game does not have to state it, the way she expresses her love for others and does not judge Arthur shows how strong her commitment is.
@@imarvg8285 the game dealt with backlash regardless. Everyone has something to say. You ever think that the plot, lines, and characters aren't written in a certain way to avoid "backlash", but to-you know, establish a character, put forth a theme or two, tell a story, or make you feel?
@Google User 2000 They didn't do it cause of backlash they did it to show that not everything has to do with God, even from religious folk. To show that people can help others without preaching to show what human kindness and love is. She flat out states she doesn't believe in anything until she sees humans like Aurthur. A deeply flawed man, who also Is a beacon of love and kindness.
@@LunaS043 believe in anything this world has to offer that is....
@Google User 2000 This world is real, it's the life we have. Humans have incredible potentials, like Aurthur Morgan. The potential of good or bad.
I played this game at some bad point of my life, watching this for first time was like the deepest feeling i've ever felt playing a game. I'm still afraid
Im in tears watching this again years later. Like i watched it for the first time. This game is gem.
I really like John Marston and I appreciate him even more after RDR2 but Arthur Morgan is on another level. To me is the best character Rockstar has ever created. And this scene alone proves it. It's really emotional and deep.
Gustavo Albornoz not just the best character created by rockstar. best video game character of all time imo 😭
@@jackatkins7725 He definitely had the best character development in a game to date, i just hope the rest of the industry is taking notes from this
And not just that,also one of the best voiced characters of all time.roger clarkes voice fits perfectly
John's character in RDR1 was infinitely better. So much more of a person and they left more of the thinking to the audience
@@liambutler9427 Leaving an audience with doubt isn't the best way to make them love a character. In RD2, by the end of the game, you see who Arthur truly is and that he would've been everything but an Outlaw had he never met Dutch
Nobody talks about how good of a job the Sister did at voice acting.
*performance capture. Also Roger Clark is the star of this scene. The sister is amazing too
Yeah her voice acting is amazing in this game.
@@AdityaSathya You don't have to correct it. Performance capture does not encapsulate voice acting, they're separate things. That being said I think she did fine with both.
Ghost De Razgriz She never ever did voice acting
All of the actors did a great job
In all honesty, i’ll come back and watch this video every other week or so to remind myself that we need to feel pain to appreciate beauty.
Arthur might be dying but he still got the freshest cut
"Take a gamble that love exists and do a loving act."
ngl, that line changed the way i look at life.
It was for me as well. Maybe theirs still hope me after all.
Rip Mr. Morgan
Now, I want to ask my crush out lol
@@silentbigsteve3429 If it's meant to be than it'll be, if not then there's always someone else :)
JazzyJaiden ga
This whole game made me feel like that. 😢😢
"Take a gamble love exists, and do a loving act."
Words to live by
It's not a gamble.
@@cosmic_order for some people it is, after many hardships and encounters with bad ppl you sometimes doubt if love really exists
@@carlangaz007 Without a standard of love, how can we know that hurting people is unloving in the first place?
Sister was telling it in a religious way
@@cosmic_order Which makes sense in Arthur's case. All he knew was killing and stealing, there's no love in that. Sure he had some romantic relationships in the past but love here means showing compassion for others who he didn't necessarily care for romantically, bystanders and whatnot, and those relationships often didn't go anywhere for Arthur which might plant seeds of doubt in him regarding the concept. In the end he went with his conscience and delivered love to those he either did wrong or those who he saw had more opportunity to be better than him
I come back and watch this every so often. Reminds me to, as the sister says, take a gamble on and do a loving act. Reminds me to be human, even if it hurts. Best game ever.
Still makes me cry every time. RIP Dad.
“ *I guess I... I'm afraid.* ”
Red dead redemption taught me a lot..."The fear, make us more humans"
true
If you know what you’re afraid of then you know what’s important
Omg that's true when I was afraid dying I was a whole different person
“Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act”
I feel like that’s a quote that the world needs to hear.
I think it was partly inspired by a quote from St. Maximilian Kolbe, "A Single act of Love makes the soul return to life".
'Take a gamble that love exists'
What does that mean???
@@munehboi Make yourself believe that love exists, even if you don't have a proof. Act according to what you believe and live like that. (Meaning you can't really know or learn that love exists or not, so you have to take a gamble and make a choice.)
Arthur Morgan is really great man i will never forget him
@@alexjr977 he has taught me more than my dad has
“Often neither do I but then I meet someone like you and everything makes sense” that shit struck a chord with me.
This secret actually hurts a lot, you can see how deep that is 😔
"Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act."
These words have stuck with me since the day I've heard it. In the darkest of moments, one step in the right direction is often more than enough.
i wanted to comment exactly this before reading this, i feel exactly the same way
Yes same. It’s the closest the game gets to talking about God and I’m glad they didn’t make it explicit. Love is something everyone understands
@@tbw980371 They actually talk about God a lot and there are tons of mission titles that are references to events in the Bible. But it is nice that they don't outright force it on everyone, as a Christain I wouldn't mind but I can see how that could get annoying for someone who thinks differently.
The problem with the scene is that what the nun did, from a christian and biblical perspective is the same as you seeing a drowning man and istead of tossing him a rope, you let him drown with a smile.
While I understand why people like it, it is highly deseptive. What she should have done was give the example of the criminal that was crusified with Jesus. Despite his crimes, he chose to believe and was saved at the last moment.
The message this scene teaches is that you can save yourself with a good deed, which is not true and any christian can tell you this. If she was any other person I would be ok with what she said, but a nun not mentioning Jesus's name, not even once, to a dying man that is clearly repentant. The message is deeply deceptive, it's 99% truth and 1% lie, the best kind of lie.
@@thickac7579 this game isn’t about religion, that would water down the message they’re trying to deliver. this is about facing your inevitable end and choosing to do your best to leave this world a better place than when you found it. it’s much a bigger picture than one man’s battle with faith, which isn’t even really a theme in the games narrative. also arthur had already expressed to the sister that he isn’t a man of strong belief, so to have her harp on about jesus would be a huge waste of this character moment
It's so sad seeing and hearing him say "I'm afraid, sister", he's on the verge of crying.
Whose more tragic Arthur or john.
@@MrMovielover17 Arthur, by far. With John it just happened quickly, I'm not saying it wasn't sad or anything but it just happened. With Arthur though it was slow and painful, and the way he speaks to Dutch in the end and the way the whole game ended just made it more tragic in my opinion.
@@Ghaffar_KH i agree. But I also think Dutch was another great example of a tragic character. Knowing what happens to him in redemption and seeing him slowly become unhinged thought redemption 2, hes my favorite besides arthur
@@MrMovielover17
Probably the most complex villian rockstar has created.
@@MrMovielover17 Exactly! I really wish if they were ever to make another Red Dead Redemption it'd be about Dutch and Hosea recruiting Arthur and John back in the days and setting up the gang. Dutch throughout chapters 1 till 4 was so incredible, he was a true leader. Then Micah came along and ruined it all. Hosea's death and him realizing in the end that Arthur was right and how he died in front of him were the leading factors in his destruction.
Arthur reminds me of my dad when he first cried in front of me. suddenly a man i considered a untouchable hero was as vulnerable as me… it made me appreciate him more and understand myself as an extension of him.
I remember when I played this for the first time, as soon as he said “I’m afraid,” it struck a completely different chord within me I’ve never felt in any other videogame. It’s awesome to know that it did the same for everyone else
Imagine being so terrified of your own father, that watching him die actually brings you peace. Having a son you love, only for him to pass away. Arthur as a character is a straight up masterpiece. I’m 22 and it still brings a tear to my eye watching him say his afraid. Rockstar really went bullfrog with this game.
One of, if not, the greatest game ever made in terms of story telling. May I ask what "went bullfrog" means?
.
RD2 is a master piece
@@isakyhadz You may not
That one dude: *Bruh grow up its just a game get over yourself, god people are so weak anymore*
Imagine a nun telling you that your presence reinstates her faith. That’s when there’s no doubt God is in your corner.
Absolutely ❤️ praise the Lord
Omfg really pushing religion on a red dead video?
@@MonkeyDBatman fam chill, leave it be
@@thgduels4519 Why? They're pushing their shit.
@@MonkeyDBatman And? Don't acknowledge it then and go about your day
Me when my dentist tells me to open up
real
This clip helped me a lot when i was diagnosed with cancer. 6 months in remission and it still makes me tear up everytime I hear it.
"But then I meet someone like you... and everything makes sense."
Some of the most uplifting words you can hear from someone.
True
You plan but God's plan encompass far more beauty than your plan
@@thelaymenmuslim4603 gods not real
@@thatonefruitthatistasty708 and how the universe began then? Pop out from nothingness?
@@thatonefruitthatistasty708 you're one of THOSE people, and im not talking about atheists🙄
"Life is full of pain but there is also love and beauty"
-Sister Calderon
These words help people understand life Clear
Fits TLOU 2, even though it is a disappointment
@@jeongminkim4409 Nope it's great
@@alimhm7341 after thinking about it, it’s decent now. I respect ur opinion tho
@@jeongminkim4409 me too
This scene hits me because my dads cancer started acting up really bad around this time. It was all I could think about was how my dad felt just like Arthur.
The greatest cutscene of any game ever. Still makes me feel emotional after all these years. Arthur will always be my favorite character of any story.
After playing RDR and RDR2, I´m going to sue Rockstar Games for emotional abuse.
Awww 😂💔
BETA!!
@@12227UserName emotionless empathy lacking psycho!!
How dare you
😂😂😂
Dying is something we will all face some day. Do your best everyone.
Have a good day, boah. Live your best life :)
Remember "dont worry about the future youll get anxious dont remininsce about the past youll get depressed focus on the here and now the present moment
-Some dude i found in a comment
@@rockatoxx1605 live your best life by doing good deeds like helping the poor etc not going to bars and nightclubs
Live your life. Dont let the weight weigh you down for it will blind you from the things you love most.
By reconciling and treating yourself from despair, you will truly know peace when the day comes
Yeah you too boah
I love the complete lack of judgement on her part. He flat out tells her that he beat a man to death for a few bucks and that he's a lived his life as a very bad man. Still, she does nothing but try to be as uplifting as possible. She showed him that even if darkness surrounds him there is always a glimmer of light to show him the right path. All he has to do is keep moving toward it and eventually he'll free himself.
This game needs an Oscar
Thaddous virger If this game was somehow compressed into a film or maybe a film trilogy. You bet your fucking ass that there wouldn’t be many movies that rival the brilliant writing and themes that this game displays. It’d be a best picture winner no doubt. It rivals the best out there, Shawshank Redemption, no country for old men, etc. It’ll never happen but this game would sure deserve it.
Thaddous virger I’m pretty sure the first one got an Oscar
if it was a high budget movie with the same plot and really really good characters acting it would beat endgame
@@warden6682 To be honest, no it wouldn't. It'd do somewhat good but nowhere near as good as Endgame
This game would win
Best Animated Feature
Best Sound
Best Original Score
Best Actor