The way he said it along with Arthurs facial expression really killed me a little inside. Thats sort of when I realized he was going to meet his fate soon and when it did happen it was just as heartbreaking as with Johns ending. Rockstar truly makes some incredible stories and Roger is an incredible actor.
The Bit Gamer 2 Rockstar is, by heart, a great gaming company. Take two (the company that produces their games) just forces them to do bad things when it comes to the online portions.
Mary tells Arthur to run away with her and not look back, similar to how Arthur tells to run away and not look back. It’s almost like Arthur is telling John to leave the life as an outlaw and live out Arthur’s dream. 😭
@@reichdertotenisonthemoon9906 Ah, there you go. By that I meant that it doesn't matter when you TEXT someone. Clearly, people can understand what he wants to say.
Rockstar has the best script writers in the industry. It truly feels like a really good TV show script within a game. I feel like most other games try to cater to younger people too much. It’s nice to experience a mature, intricate story.
“All them bullets shot at me, all them horses threw me, all them fights and it was the beating of that pathetic little fella Downes that killed me. I reckon,” Arthur Morgan
Man, the acting at 17:52 is seriously top notch. The way Arthur looks away from sister, eyes welling with tears doing his best to hold them back. Masterclass.
When his eyes start darting around when the Sister starts replying back, I like to think that he's thinking of John and how he's gonna get his brother out of the gang, and save his family before he can no longer stand for him self, let alone others. Also, not sure, but isn't this shortly before you kick Strauss out?
Reverend just wants to leave because of the situation and tries to increase the animo for him to be a real man. Meanwhile she just tries to help Arthur with what is going to happen calming him and to not be afraid
Arthur's story is so great because of how human, how relatable it is. Arthur Morgan has done bad things, and he knows that. And we know that, but we also see that he's a caring, kind-hearted person. He and we aren't really sure where to put him on our "morality scale," if you will. His life, like our own, is not so clear. Was he good? Was he bad? He was both and riddled with regrets. In this way, Arthur really I think carried a lot of the fears we have of our lives, our future. He was mislead and foolish in his pass, and maybe the bad things he did were more than just foolishness. But in the end, Arthur tries to do good, to show love to some people and help them escape the life he's fallen into. He does one last loving act. And whether or not we know where he is on that morality scale that we all carry, I think we all agree that he got redemption. He became a better man with courage and honesty. And that's a future we all want, redemption for what we regret. RIP Arthur.
I don't totally agree. I mean, he's definitely bad. He made some good actions in the end of his life but he never actually stopped making bad things (murdering, for example) The interesting thing is what you said, he's human, full of contradictions and paradoxes. He definitely earned the Redemption in the end though. It makes you think that if he survived and wasn't sick he would lived a peaceful life
"I wish things were different, but it weren't us who changed". Is one of my favorites. This is where you know Arthur is basically saying "fuck dutch" in the coolest way possible
boubou665 then Dutch's reaction. "I..." the first time Dutch is speechless and realizes what he's done. Watching his most loyal follower die, at that moment he realized that he fucked up.
I always played Arthur as a high honor outlaw, and the high honor ending felt the most fitting for him. The man fought so hard against the hand he had been dealt and he died the way he would've wanted to go. Protecting those he saw as family. I wasn't a fan of GTAV's story, but Red Dead Redemption 2 certainly became one of my personal favorite singleplayer stories
Mary to Arthur: "Run away with me Arthur. Run away and don't look back." Arthur to John : "When the time comes, you gotta run and don't look back" When he learned his time was counted, he didn't run. He stayed, for his family, for his friends, for his ideas. He could have ran to Mary, forget everything. But he stayed. No one in that camp deserved Arthur. No one. Especially Dutch.
@@andrewwilliams5546 The whole "get some fresh air" thing doesn't actually work. Sanatoriums were more meant to isolate sick people to prevent them from infecting others. Tuberculosis was and still is lethal most of the time, and difficult to recover from even after antibiotic treatments.
Kicking Strauss out pissed me off. Even with high honour, yet when I watched the cutscenes on yt when you have low honour I felt terrible for the old man.
Gary I kinda agree. Strauss was doing just what he was told. He was snake, but he needed protection and was brought on to do just that. Us as Arthur didn’t have to do any of it. Minus the one that is essential to the story. It’s more on Arthur than it is Strauss.
00:00 10- Keep her in black 01:29 9- We are theives 02:27 8- We are more ghosts than people 04:20 7- It weren't us who changed 07:07 6- I am afraid I have to insist 09:59 5- People I need to take care 11:48 4- A fighter a killer 14:06 3- Keep pushin arthur 15:19 2- I guess I am afraid ( my fav 😭) 18:26 1- It turns out I have won
@@keithgreen69 TB is very contagious. In fact: most doctors in hospitals have to wear these special hazmat suits and isolate the entire room the patient is in just to contain the disease
@@keithgreen69 sorry for joining in on the discussion, but first, it's spread, not inherited. Secondly, my best friends grandpa is dying of TB after he caught it off a co-worker
Damn, the sisters words to Arthur were truly powerful. Arthur’s words as well explaining how despite everything, he still believes in nothing and is truly afraid of death. It’s just so relatable, to fully believe in nothing but still be afraid of the end of everything. “Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act.” Something that I think everyone can take away from and apply to their lives from this absolutely stellar game.
scrolling thru the comments and saw yours and wow either i forgot or i never knew she visited his grave. i was literally wondering about that lol insane game man
This just dawned on me but does Anyone else feel robbed we didn’t get to see John reunite with Abigail before the epilogue since she thinks he’s dead it would have been pretty emotional to see them reunite especially right after Arthur dying
18:58 when Dutch stared at Micah he finally understood he was wrong for the first time, he saw that Micah was a traitor, but Dutch was never strong enough to admit he was wrong
“I’m afraid.” Is the most human and amazing line in the whole game besides “You’re my brother.” The whole game had culminated into those two words and it hurts so much to hear such a good man say that he’s afraid.
And to hammer home how much 40 grand was in 1899 that's like telling your gang we got 1.3 million in the stash but we need more money. If the Gang knew how big of a piece of shit dutch was they'd of bounce right at the first. Uncle hit the nail on the head Dutch wanted to be an American King and have blindly loyal knights follow him.
I was suspicious the moment he never let anyone see or know where the box was. It was like Dutch wanted to money to himself as much as he was wanting everyone to escapen
I really wonder where those gold bars came from. In the whole game, almost all Dutch's plans have failed. They only get a few thousands from the Cornwall train, and another few thousands from the oil factory. Dutch must have enough money for Tahiti plan even before the game started.
The fact Arthur gives up his happiness to be with Mary because he'd rather John get out and be with his family is literally the most selfless act in the whole game, amazing stuff!!
I love how Dutch’s character works. He’s a strong leader, forsure. But if you take a look at his character from a windows eye in, you can see how his mental instability combined with his leadership skills leads the gang into more and more turmoil and chaos. But In his mind, it’s what’s right. But Arthur sees how he changes and he uses every ounce of power with the time he has left to try clean up Dutch’s war path. He recognized how his blind following has been apart of the problem just as much as Dutch and Micah is.
Every time I hear Arthur say ‘I’m afraid’ I tear up a little. Seeing this character that we’ve seen as strong the whole game appear weak for the first time, it breaks my heart a little.
17:55 when he says that hes afriad, the look in his eyes is unforgettable, you can see him forcing his mouth shut and frowning to stop himself from choking and crying. the detail in this game, im going to cry
"We're more ghosts that people" always feels like so much loss with a few words. The idea of what could've been made of both Arthur and Sadie had life not steered them in the direction it did
@@anxiousearth680 he meant that if he tried vengeance for his father (killing Arthur) that he will kill him. Then his mother will stay in mourning (in black) on his behalf (for her son).
The "we're more ghosts than people" conversation went different in my playthrough. He asked Sadie to help John, Jack, and Abigail get out instead of getting out with money.
When he said that "I'm afraid" I realized his time was getting closer and I felt it in my chest! I got so attached to Arthur and his growth as a character that it hurt me knowing he would inevitably die! 😢 Rockstar really made it with this one! My favorite game ever!!
The way his VA did his voice, it just matches so well with the situation every time, its minute adjustments like these that bring games closer and closer to real life
I want rockstar to do another prequel with Arthur in his younger years so I can cling on to Arthur just a little longer but I know this will cancel out the impact from his sacrifice 😭😭
SpaceDawg007 a prequel where you play as another character but when they die you play as Arthur for the prologue just like in this one and the first one
It’s insane how so much backstory into really understanding Arthur and why he is how he is at the beginning and end of the game at least on high honor is in one optional conversation with Rain falls
I love the subtle touch during the train station scene. After Arthus says "My path is coming to an end", you notice Reverend subtly scoot away from Arthur. He tries to do it in the nicest way ever while still trying to protect himself.
Seeing this made me realise a lot of the dialogue changes from having high honor and low honor. In the final mission Arthur says “it’s of no use to me anymore” to John when he gives his hat, high honor it’s “it would mean a lot to me”. Phenomenal detail
Arthur Morgan is my favourite fictional character of all time. It genuinely pains me that his life didn't turn out quite how he wanted, despite him being able to set others up. Red Dead 2 is an amazing piece, I've never been so invested and emotional about something that isn't real in my life.
Mine is: "BOAH" -Arthur Morgan "PLAN" -Dutch PLAN Der Linde "LUMBAGO" -Uncle WOW! 20 likes? I never got that much likes but thanks people *BONUS* !YNNEL -Arthur Morgan 116 LIKES!? WOW THANKS ALOT! btw I tried antagonize to people and this is what i got. Arthur - "Thats some animal u got there" Stranger - "Thanks" Arthur - "Im not talking to u, im talking to the horse" Stranger - "What th-" XDXDXD
Underrated but when he’s talking to John On the bridge and John says what about loyalty, the line “be loyal to what matters” that one hits me close to home
At 13:00 when Reverend was saying "I know" about Arthur being sick, it was such a nice detail that he was scooting a bit farther back so he didn't catch it.
I love the mood with the mrs downes collection at #10. The music in the ride, Arthur’s bluntness and detached coldness, the dialogue and sound quality. It’s the peak of Arthur as the ‘villain’ in the story, regardless of which type of honor play through you’re going for. It’s great
The elk's call at 6:59 is extremely symbolic imo. Elks used to signify endurance, which that's exactly what John and Arthur did. The constant antics from Dutch made their loyalty be tested and in the end, it endured. Could be the call was random, or it was an actual thing in the real scene. Either way, the way it sounds after Arthur reminds John that they endured and never changed is incredible
"There's always another goddamn train" It's all serious, but I love how the line is delivered. Roger Clark really makes it sound like Arthur has done a lot more train jobs than we've seen.
Y’know, I actually kind of liked reverend Swanson’s speech and what he was trying to say. Even though you get his dialogue if your dishonorable, I really liked his message. He was trying to tell Arthur that, maybe it’s ok if things don’t change; maybe it’s okay to die a bad, crazy person.
I know it's year old but you don't get Swanson speech if you dishonorable, only if you don't help brother Dorkins (or something like that) and sister Calderon, you can have high honor and talk with Swanson
@@Kalorak111 Yeah, I had forgotten to do that side-mission early on and wouldn't you know it; I got to the mission where you have to run away from the army and send the captain on his way and I found Swanson there. I felt like I made a mistake, but seeing as it was new content to me at the time I enjoyed seeing him. And it felt a lot more fitting for the closing of the story as he spoke directly about the gang. While I enjoy Sister's speech better considering Arthur's character, I feel like you need to speak with Swanson at some point. It's not something you can really brush off.
I still get emotional when Arthur says to Sister Calderon "Im afraid", and that genuinely honest and sad face holds for just a few moments, it just hits me like a ton of bricks every time.
0:00 *Keep Her In Black* (Sodom? Back to Gomorrah) 1:29 *We Are Thieves...* (The New South) 2:27 *More Ghosts Than People* (Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow I) 4:20 *It Weren't Us Who Changed* (The Bridge To Nowhere) 7:07 *I'm Afraid I Have To Insist* (Our Best Selves) 9:59 *People I Need To Take Care* (Fatherhood And Other Dreams II) 11:48 *A Fighter, A Killer* (The Fine Art Of Conversation) 14:06 *Keep Pushin', Arthur* (Red Dead Redemption) 15:19 *I'm Afraid* (The Fine Art Of Conversation, but only if you have High Honor and you completed all the Sister Calderòn and Father Dorkins secondary missions) 18:27 *It Turns Out I've Won* (Red Dead Redemption)
Rockstar: maybe when the players finish mourning john marston...ill keep em in black on our behalf you think on that boah.
*Boah
😂😂😂😂😂Timed perfectly
Maybe you shall... And maybe other events shall transpire
@suprcrzy rockstar: "You better stick to them video games because complaining is a idiots game"
@@round105 lmao
The emotion that Roger Clark put into that one line...”I’m afraid.” He deserved to win performance of the year based on that alone. That’s powerful.
Meagan W. He did win
The way he said it along with Arthurs facial expression really killed me a little inside. Thats sort of when I realized he was going to meet his fate soon and when it did happen it was just as heartbreaking as with Johns ending. Rockstar truly makes some incredible stories and Roger is an incredible actor.
he won The best performance
@@satisfrying5497 what time in video
DChief94 and? What does that have to do with anything? He didn't say all he did was use his voice, that's just the only thing he got his award for.
Javier Escualla: “That could’ve gone smoother.”
Arthur Morgan: “That’ll be on my gravestone.”
😂😂
BrushedTrout007 XD I remember that
Arthur is one of the best characters ever created.
That will be on MY gravestone
If i ever would find myself on death row even though i won't go there those would be my last words haha.
Gabby GamerGirl amen to that
Without a single doubt Arthur morgan is the greatest protagonist rockstar ever created
greatest protagonist EVER created
Minus the word rockstar
captain price don’t push it
Say another name that has stronger character. Not just rockstar.
Arthur, Niko, Michael, Trevor, CJ, Tommy, Claude, Toni, Jimmy Hopkins, John, Max Payne
His delivery on, "and there's always a goddamn train" always gets me. Arthur was really tired of the bullshit. I really felt it in that line.
"All we had to do was rob the damn train, Arthur!!"
Jesus Loves You
“Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act.”
Guys this is from rockstar.
ROCKSTAR
That's one of the signs that armaghedon is coming
The Bit Gamer 2 I really wish that they’d take the same approach to the next GTA
Thinking about getting that tatted on me
The Bit Gamer 2 Rockstar is, by heart, a great gaming company. Take two (the company that produces their games) just forces them to do bad things when it comes to the online portions.
DChief94 Yeah, I got the terminology mixed up with movies.
Mary tells Arthur to run away with her and not look back, similar to how Arthur tells to run away and not look back. It’s almost like Arthur is telling John to leave the life as an outlaw and live out Arthur’s dream. 😭
He would of ran away if there was ice cream
The story is more complete with those side quests & stranger missions.
Dont forget, this is what John tells Abigail and Jack right before he sends them off, and gets shot to pieces
He gave up halfway through when he was diagnosed and he lived long enough to see John Become like him into the man Arthur wanted to be
I think that’s exactly why he said that to John
"Despite my best efforts to the contrary, it turns out I've won."
Arthur Morgan
The best sentens in videogame
@@anonymousfreedom1253 sentens?
@@reichdertotenisonthemoon9906 You get what he meant, it doesn't matter as long as people understand what they say.
@@thefunnyhasbeendetected295 Ok, so I could right that on a resumé and it wouldn't matter?
@@reichdertotenisonthemoon9906 Ah, there you go. By that I meant that it doesn't matter when you TEXT someone. Clearly, people can understand what he wants to say.
honestly this game has some of the best writing of the last decade.
That "i'm afraid" is like a kick to the stomach
Ouch
Rockstar has the best script writers in the industry. It truly feels like a really good TV show script within a game. I feel like most other games try to cater to younger people too much. It’s nice to experience a mature, intricate story.
“Vengeance is an idiots game” forever will love that by Arthur.
BatManBen 1:08
@@BatManBen 😂
@@BatManBen he says “revenge is a fools game” in a couple other cutscenes but “vengeance is an idiots game” in the cutscene with the Downes boy
I tried to comment this but it said vegan eggs is an idiots game
@@BatManBen Apologize, fool.
“You sir, are a fish” -Arthur Morgan
Alejandro Hernández first comment in a while that made me laugh after the emptional journey reliving arthurs story. Thank you
Ahahah
"Good ta meet'cha!" *hacks up left lung*
"HELLO, BOAH!" - Arthur Morgan
Ho said that?
Arthur tells John to run and don't look back. It's sad because John says the same thing to Abigail and Jack before his death.
Brandon Marshall damn I never noticed that. 😭
It was Mary to Arthur, Arthur to John, and John to Abigail
And jack takes revenge too
Mary Linton to Arthur
Arthur to John
John to Abigail and Jack
Run and don't look back
He told Jack to take his horse to the dirt road and ride till he cant no more.
When he said thank you to his horse I legit cried. That was my favorite moment.
jmangell I know dude I had that horse since chapter 2 😭
I had buell 😢
It was worse that I had my Arabian :( she was best girl :(
My handsome El Diablo... R.I.P. D,:
I had the black horse from the bear mission.
“All them bullets shot at me,
all them horses threw me,
all them fights and it was the beating
of that pathetic little fella Downes that killed me. I reckon,”
Arthur Morgan
When does he says that
@@navax1468 exactly I have 100% in the story and I've never heard this line in my life
@@navax1468 If I had to guess, in his journal.
@@shoreZ yeah me too
@@NaruSanavai probably
Man, the acting at 17:52 is seriously top notch. The way Arthur looks away from sister, eyes welling with tears doing his best to hold them back. Masterclass.
When his eyes start darting around when the Sister starts replying back, I like to think that he's thinking of John and how he's gonna get his brother out of the gang, and save his family before he can no longer stand for him self, let alone others. Also, not sure, but isn't this shortly before you kick Strauss out?
@@Wildlink123 After I think the cutscene with Arthur meeting Sister at the train station is one of the final missions in chapter 6
Jesus Loves You
They post poned this game for years. And it was worth it to get a character like Arthur Morgan.
hell yeah rockstar took time to make an awesome game
They will do same with GTA 6. Rockstar are only capable of making the best now nothing less
@@JazF30 I wouldn't be so certain...
@@xaviertsun5004 matter of opinion bro. Fair enough if you dont agree
@@JazF30 the online aspects taint this game.
lets all be honest, the talk with the nun is better than with swanson
I agree but they both have their highlights
Rhys Wyatt is that a side mission cuz I don’t remember it
You dont get the "I am afraid" line though.
Swanson tries to move away from Arthur on the bench as though hes scared of being infected. The nun does not do that. Anyone noticed?
Reverend just wants to leave because of the situation and tries to increase the animo for him to be a real man. Meanwhile she just tries to help Arthur with what is going to happen calming him and to not be afraid
“I hate you Uncle Arthur!”
-Jack
I HATE YOU UNCLE ARTHUR
Jack Marston I HATE YOU UNCLE JACK
Shitboi41 I HATE YOU UNCLE BOI
@@slippinjimmybean LANGUAGE
LasJohn Griffin SORRY DAD
Arthur's story is so great because of how human, how relatable it is. Arthur Morgan has done bad things, and he knows that. And we know that, but we also see that he's a caring, kind-hearted person. He and we aren't really sure where to put him on our "morality scale," if you will. His life, like our own, is not so clear. Was he good? Was he bad? He was both and riddled with regrets. In this way, Arthur really I think carried a lot of the fears we have of our lives, our future. He was mislead and foolish in his pass, and maybe the bad things he did were more than just foolishness. But in the end, Arthur tries to do good, to show love to some people and help them escape the life he's fallen into. He does one last loving act. And whether or not we know where he is on that morality scale that we all carry, I think we all agree that he got redemption. He became a better man with courage and honesty. And that's a future we all want, redemption for what we regret. RIP Arthur.
Amen 🙏
@@carltonisaweenie1859 actual agreeable comment
Well said!
Bro, you tryin to publish a book?
I don't totally agree. I mean, he's definitely bad. He made some good actions in the end of his life but he never actually stopped making bad things (murdering, for example)
The interesting thing is what you said, he's human, full of contradictions and paradoxes. He definitely earned the Redemption in the end though. It makes you think that if he survived and wasn't sick he would lived a peaceful life
17:53 you can clearly see Arthur holding back tears after saying "Im afraid"
Yeah I know 😞
No shit, that's exactly why it's so emotional
"Jack, come here. You're a good kid. Now be brave, son. I'm gonna go get your Momma."
This scene was so sad I almost cried on my second playthrough
"Mrs. Adler. Ride with me!"
"I wish things were different, but it weren't us who changed". Is one of my favorites. This is where you know Arthur is basically saying "fuck dutch" in the coolest way possible
It also taps on the whole 'The world doesn't want people like us no more' mantra that is brought up throughout the games story.
"I gave you all i had" is also one of the most memorable line
boubou665 then Dutch's reaction. "I..." the first time Dutch is speechless and realizes what he's done. Watching his most loyal follower die, at that moment he realized that he fucked up.
No lenneh ma boah is
I always played Arthur as a high honor outlaw, and the high honor ending felt the most fitting for him. The man fought so hard against the hand he had been dealt and he died the way he would've wanted to go. Protecting those he saw as family.
I wasn't a fan of GTAV's story, but Red Dead Redemption 2 certainly became one of my personal favorite singleplayer stories
I tried playing as low honor Arthur after my first play through, but I simply couldn’t do it. Making Arthur low honor just feels so dirty to me
Mary to Arthur: "Run away with me Arthur. Run away and don't look back."
Arthur to John : "When the time comes, you gotta run and don't look back"
When he learned his time was counted, he didn't run. He stayed, for his family, for his friends, for his ideas. He could have ran to Mary, forget everything. But he stayed.
No one in that camp deserved Arthur. No one. Especially Dutch.
Mary Beth, Tilly, Charles, hosea and the Marstons are the only people that deserved him
Egenix52 he would of died eventually due to tuberculosis
HenRYbenRY he probably could have lived if he relaxed in a warm area
@@andrewwilliams5546 The whole "get some fresh air" thing doesn't actually work.
Sanatoriums were more meant to isolate sick people to prevent them from infecting others.
Tuberculosis was and still is lethal most of the time, and difficult to recover from even after antibiotic treatments.
John repeated that line to Abigail and Jack in the first game too.
Can I sue Rockstar for killing Arthur? Is that an option?
Thats the way it is
El Stink yep he got his redemption but sadly
Yeah, for the emotional distress
Lol we do it for that reason and rockstar can't continue to give the same quality content
Sadly no :( also who got the honorable ending so micah wouldn't get the last laugh???
I like when Arthur kicks out Strauss with high honor. "You and me, we ain't decent..."
Kicking Strauss out pissed me off. Even with high honour, yet when I watched the cutscenes on yt when you have low honour I felt terrible for the old man.
But those folks, they was.
Gary I kinda agree. Strauss was doing just what he was told. He was snake, but he needed protection and was brought on to do just that. Us as Arthur didn’t have to do any of it. Minus the one that is essential to the story. It’s more on Arthur than it is Strauss.
TMac53 Yes it was so goddamn awesome
Strauss shouldnt have been kicked out with high honor imo. Itd have been cool if it makes a big argument to juxtapose high honor in the game.
"Listen to me.... When The time comes, you gotta run and don't look back.... This is over "
I'll start to use when my friends have Love problems.
Me too
"Be loyal to what matters"
Words I live by to this day.
May they stand unshaken
Friend: me and so so are getting engaged!! Wanna be my best man
You: when the time comes...your run and don't look back...this is over
Wehn your 13 and your mom doesn't want to buy a ps4 pro
Me: im afraid i have to insist
00:00 10- Keep her in black
01:29 9- We are theives
02:27 8- We are more ghosts than people
04:20 7- It weren't us who changed
07:07 6- I am afraid I have to insist
09:59 5- People I need to take care
11:48 4- A fighter a killer
14:06 3- Keep pushin arthur
15:19 2- I guess I am afraid ( my fav 😭)
18:26 1- It turns out I have won
Thanks mister
U are cool
@@bobphigglebottom2839 no, you're cool
@@Røbby91939 anytime partner 🤠
I guess i am afraid almost had me cry bro
"I wish things where different but it weren't us who changed."
One of the greatest protagonist quotes Rockstar has ever written
Agent Milton: "That's quite a cough you got there."
Arthur: "Sure..Tuberculosis."
He shouldve been spitting on Milton and Micah in their fights
Guys TB can't be inherited
@@keithgreen69 TB is very contagious. In fact: most doctors in hospitals have to wear these special hazmat suits and isolate the entire room the patient is in just to contain the disease
@@keithgreen69 Uhm... are you an idiot?
@@keithgreen69 sorry for joining in on the discussion, but first, it's spread, not inherited. Secondly, my best friends grandpa is dying of TB after he caught it off a co-worker
"You're too smart for me sister. I guess I...I'm afraid."
“You speak as if killing was something I cared about.”
now that’s a line I’ll remember
A classy, intellectual killer in the making
Or LENNEH MA BOAH
Damn, the sisters words to Arthur were truly powerful. Arthur’s words as well explaining how despite everything, he still believes in nothing and is truly afraid of death. It’s just so relatable, to fully believe in nothing but still be afraid of the end of everything. “Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act.” Something that I think everyone can take away from and apply to their lives from this absolutely stellar game.
The final conversation between Arthur and Mary, along with the scene in the credits where she visits Arthur's grave never fail to make me tear up
scrolling thru the comments and saw yours and wow either i forgot or i never knew she visited his grave. i was literally wondering about that lol insane game man
I cried when Arthur said “I’m afraid” it just hit me like a train, the look on his face and knowing how he’s feeling...wow...
He said it himself ”I think im a fool, and i suffer from my foolishness”
Arthurs life in one sentence.
This just dawned on me but does Anyone else feel robbed we didn’t get to see John reunite with Abigail before the epilogue since she thinks he’s dead it would have been pretty emotional to see them reunite especially right after Arthur dying
Waterman217 70 true
I totally agree, it would’ve been like the first game where you ride back to the ranch to find johns corpse before the epilogue
fuck this john, dont see him an interesting person
It dawned on think about how Arthur gave John his satchel filled with all of his money and lose of it making me think what the he’ll happened but yeah
Mad Jack play the first game
18:58 when Dutch stared at Micah he finally understood he was wrong for the first time, he saw that Micah was a traitor, but Dutch was never strong enough to admit he was wrong
“I’m afraid.” Is the most human and amazing line in the whole game besides “You’re my brother.”
The whole game had culminated into those two words and it hurts so much to hear such a good man say that he’s afraid.
Sadie: *my husband died...*
Arthur: Ok IlL cAtCh YoU lAtEr ThEn
Lmaoooooo
He needed to find lenneh first
Dutch is always talking about money when he has a lock box with 40 odd grand
He was a snake since the start of the game
And to hammer home how much 40 grand was in 1899 that's like telling your gang we got 1.3 million in the stash but we need more money. If the Gang knew how big of a piece of shit dutch was they'd of bounce right at the first. Uncle hit the nail on the head Dutch wanted to be an American King and have blindly loyal knights follow him.
I was suspicious the moment he never let anyone see or know where the box was. It was like Dutch wanted to money to himself as much as he was wanting everyone to escapen
I really wonder where those gold bars came from. In the whole game, almost all Dutch's plans have failed. They only get a few thousands from the Cornwall train, and another few thousands from the oil factory. Dutch must have enough money for Tahiti plan even before the game started.
@@huanglong08
Imagine how much he would have had from the Saint Denis bank
@@hopoutattheafterparty6245 but those are sunk into the sea
I insist rockstar to bring Arthur back
Insist?
Yeah...INSIST
@@jasongamekiller7455 He insists upon it. Insists!
Bunch of people are signing so that you can play as him after the game
Hopefully they go single player dlc and make under nightmare 2
19:18 the moment where dutch died inside, realizing he was too blind to see reason and costing his son’s life for that
The fact Arthur gives up his happiness to be with Mary because he'd rather John get out and be with his family is literally the most selfless act in the whole game, amazing stuff!!
I guess you could say he redeemed himself
I love how Dutch’s character works. He’s a strong leader, forsure. But if you take a look at his character from a windows eye in, you can see how his mental instability combined with his leadership skills leads the gang into more and more turmoil and chaos. But In his mind, it’s what’s right. But Arthur sees how he changes and he uses every ounce of power with the time he has left to try clean up Dutch’s war path. He recognized how his blind following has been apart of the problem just as much as Dutch and Micah is.
17:40 that sister was so kind , my heart overwelmed watching her talking so sweetly to Arthur
Every time I hear Arthur say ‘I’m afraid’ I tear up a little. Seeing this character that we’ve seen as strong the whole game appear weak for the first time, it breaks my heart a little.
Perhaps, in that moment .... he was the strongest he’s ever been.
“You know the only thing that mattered to me was loyalty, it was all I knew”
- Arthur Morgan
17:55 when he says that hes afriad, the look in his eyes is unforgettable, you can see him forcing his mouth shut and frowning to stop himself from choking and crying. the detail in this game, im going to cry
17:53*
@@DieHardRedemption thanks brah :)
@@dort9288your welcome, brah
How I miss Arthur Morgan...the best video game character ever
Arthur Morgan... definitely one of my top 5 anti-heroes of all time.
And that song...
"May I....stand unshaken...
Every time I see Arthur put his hat on John and put his hand on his shoulder... It's too much. :(
"We're more ghosts that people" always feels like so much loss with a few words. The idea of what could've been made of both Arthur and Sadie had life not steered them in the direction it did
I love that the sister took away almost all of Arthurs fear!
He even writes it in his diary
Huge character developement there!
I want Arthur to narrate my life.
"We can't change what's done.We can only move on."
"Maybe I'll keep in her black on your behalf" .....Man thats cold lol
He knew what the boy had in mind
He’s a real savage tho
Love that part 👌🏻
What does that mean?
@@anxiousearth680 he meant that if he tried vengeance for his father (killing Arthur) that he will kill him. Then his mother will stay in mourning (in black) on his behalf (for her son).
The "I'm afraid" line gets me choked up every time. The facial expression is beyond magnificent for displaying the pain and emotion Arthur is feeling.
The "we're more ghosts than people" conversation went different in my playthrough. He asked Sadie to help John, Jack, and Abigail get out instead of getting out with money.
Because he had low honour
Best like from marston rdr1: bonnie im married
Best line from Arthur rdr2: okay ill catch you later then
20:49 the first and only time i've cried at an in-game characters death
Me too, im usually pretty stoic when it comes to characters too
@@friccle_ I almost cried in TLOU 2 but I was actually in tears in my RD2 playthrough
Red Dead Depression. Once again...
When he said that "I'm afraid" I realized his time was getting closer and I felt it in my chest! I got so attached to Arthur and his growth as a character that it hurt me knowing he would inevitably die! 😢
Rockstar really made it with this one!
My favorite game ever!!
The way his VA did his voice, it just matches so well with the situation every time, its minute adjustments like these that bring games closer and closer to real life
I want rockstar to do another prequel with Arthur in his younger years so I can cling on to Arthur just a little longer but I know this will cancel out the impact from his sacrifice 😭😭
SpaceDawg007 a prequel where you play as another character but when they die you play as Arthur for the prologue just like in this one and the first one
@@williambradley2084 what about Jack
Uncle With lumbago have u never played the first game
i wanna play as young hosea
SpaceDawg007 maybe you’ll play as Dutch in a prequel game
PRETTY BOAH? YOU KIDDING ME, PRETTY BOAH?
It’s insane how so much backstory into really understanding Arthur and why he is how he is at the beginning and end of the game at least on high honor is in one optional conversation with Rain falls
What about?
"$5000 dollars? For me? Can I turn myself in?"
I love the subtle touch during the train station scene. After Arthus says "My path is coming to an end", you notice Reverend subtly scoot away from Arthur. He tries to do it in the nicest way ever while still trying to protect himself.
"I'll keep her in black" is such an amazing threat, one of the best I've heard in a game.
19:06 That really hits you in the soul.
Tbh you can see the regret and fear in dutch he knows he messed up thats why he shoots Michah lster he planned it all from that very moment
“Despite my best efforts to the contrary, it turns out I’ve won”
Arthur Morgan 1899
Seeing this made me realise a lot of the dialogue changes from having high honor and low honor. In the final mission Arthur says “it’s of no use to me anymore” to John when he gives his hat, high honor it’s “it would mean a lot to me”. Phenomenal detail
Arthur Morgan is my favourite fictional character of all time. It genuinely pains me that his life didn't turn out quite how he wanted, despite him being able to set others up. Red Dead 2 is an amazing piece, I've never been so invested and emotional about something that isn't real in my life.
Mine is:
"BOAH" -Arthur Morgan
"PLAN" -Dutch PLAN Der Linde
"LUMBAGO" -Uncle
WOW! 20 likes? I never got that much likes but thanks people
*BONUS*
!YNNEL -Arthur Morgan
116 LIKES!? WOW THANKS ALOT! btw I tried antagonize to people and this is what i got.
Arthur - "Thats some animal u got there"
Stranger - "Thanks"
Arthur - "Im not talking to u, im talking to the horse"
Stranger - "What th-"
XDXDXD
"IMPLORE" -John Marston
Wow you are soooo original
Huh
'' We just need more money'' - Dutch Van Der Linde
Arthur/Dutch - "INSISTS"
Wait this doesn’t have all of his lines in the game I think they made a mistake here
Its different dialogue. It depends on your honour and what side Missions you have done
This is low honor lines. Some arent different regardless of honor, but many of them here are low honor
@Fluxeild Gaming they all lost lol
I like how no one got the joke
@@lukeharman7054 he’s saying everything authors says is iconic and memorable
My favorite quote was when Arthur stated "this gang, the bond we share, is the realest thing to me, I would kill for it, I'd gladly die for it
"-and I still would have left you here if Charles hadn't stopped me."
Underrated but when he’s talking to John On the bridge and John says what about loyalty, the line “be loyal to what matters” that one hits me close to home
8:53 i LOVE how arthur stands his point
How can you forget
LEEEEEENNY!
Ha ha found ya Lenny
Its lennny not leeeeny cus he aint leany
I know
Ynnel?
Don't you mean YNNEL?
At 13:00 when Reverend was saying "I know" about Arthur being sick, it was such a nice detail that he was scooting a bit farther back so he didn't catch it.
I love the mood with the mrs downes collection at #10. The music in the ride, Arthur’s bluntness and detached coldness, the dialogue and sound quality. It’s the peak of Arthur as the ‘villain’ in the story, regardless of which type of honor play through you’re going for. It’s great
The elk's call at 6:59 is extremely symbolic imo. Elks used to signify endurance, which that's exactly what John and Arthur did. The constant antics from Dutch made their loyalty be tested and in the end, it endured. Could be the call was random, or it was an actual thing in the real scene. Either way, the way it sounds after Arthur reminds John that they endured and never changed is incredible
"There's always another goddamn train"
It's all serious, but I love how the line is delivered. Roger Clark really makes it sound like Arthur has done a lot more train jobs than we've seen.
“But... I tried in the end I did”
Arthur Morgan- 1899
Greatest game of all time
My Favorite Arthur line was when I tackled someone to stop them from snitching
Victim: NO! NOO!
Arthur: I ASSUME THAT MEANS YES!
Me: :o
Lmaoooooo
"I gave you all I had"
Is more emotional than
"I'm afraid"
"We are theives,In a world that dont want us no more." One of Arthur's most iconic lines ever.
"Be loyal too what matters'' great advice right there 💯
Y’know, I actually kind of liked reverend Swanson’s speech and what he was trying to say. Even though you get his dialogue if your dishonorable, I really liked his message. He was trying to tell Arthur that, maybe it’s ok if things don’t change; maybe it’s okay to die a bad, crazy person.
It really isn't and that's a poor and lazy excuse to not even try to improve oneself.
I know it's year old but you don't get Swanson speech if you dishonorable, only if you don't help brother Dorkins (or something like that) and sister Calderon, you can have high honor and talk with Swanson
@@Kalorak111 Yeah, I had forgotten to do that side-mission early on and wouldn't you know it; I got to the mission where you have to run away from the army and send the captain on his way and I found Swanson there.
I felt like I made a mistake, but seeing as it was new content to me at the time I enjoyed seeing him. And it felt a lot more fitting for the closing of the story as he spoke directly about the gang. While I enjoy Sister's speech better considering Arthur's character, I feel like you need to speak with Swanson at some point. It's not something you can really brush off.
I still get emotional when Arthur says to Sister Calderon "Im afraid", and that genuinely honest and sad face holds for just a few moments, it just hits me like a ton of bricks every time.
"I need a vacation" is much deeper than it sounds
“I tried...in the end...I did” that still hits me
Outlaws for life
Unpopular opinion: I like johns outfits from the main story better than the prologue
it’s looks stupid in this game, he was more buff in the first game, even if you get max weight it still looks wrong
That gray coat outfit is so slick.
@@addyznxanyzz3179 no he wasnt go back and play the first one again hes actually kind of a skinny boi
Retrogamer what i meant was it looked like he fit the outfit better 😂
@@addyznxanyzz3179 I agree, something about the Red Dead 2 version was just off
The most beautiful, action-packed, funny, sad and amazing game. The story line was amazingly done. Bravo Rockstar
0:00 *Keep Her In Black* (Sodom? Back to Gomorrah)
1:29 *We Are Thieves...* (The New South)
2:27 *More Ghosts Than People* (Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow I)
4:20 *It Weren't Us Who Changed* (The Bridge To Nowhere)
7:07 *I'm Afraid I Have To Insist* (Our Best Selves)
9:59 *People I Need To Take Care* (Fatherhood And Other Dreams II)
11:48 *A Fighter, A Killer* (The Fine Art Of Conversation)
14:06 *Keep Pushin', Arthur* (Red Dead Redemption)
15:19 *I'm Afraid* (The Fine Art Of Conversation, but only if you have High Honor and you completed all the Sister Calderòn and Father Dorkins secondary missions)
18:27 *It Turns Out I've Won* (Red Dead Redemption)
"And we'll find out just who and what we should be loyal to." Love that line.