Spectra vs. Medela: Why Moms Love These Breast Pumps | Which one is right for you?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 авг 2024
- Are you choosing between a Spectra and Medela breast pump? This comprehensive review and comparison dive deep into these two popular brands, uncovering their histories, innovations, and why they've earned the trust of moms worldwide. Get expert advice to help make your decision, whether you're considering factors like portability, sensitivity, or technological advancements.
~~~~~~~~~
READY TO GET HELP? WORKING MOMS // If you want pumping to feel easy and simple by pumping fast and efficiently to protect your milk supply after returning to work, click the link below to schedule a time to speak with us about our long-term support program *Pumping for Working Moms*:
bit.ly/3L6eprC
~~~~~~~~~
ARE YOU AN IBCLC? Come learn from two experts inside the Pumping for Lactation Professionals to help you understand breast pumps and have the resources available to serve your pumping clients!
📋 Start the training: www.pumpingforlactationprofes...
~~~~~~~~~
Don't forget to SUBSCRIBE to the channel!!!
~~~~~~~~~
Videos or products
→ Used Breast Pumps | 🧐 FDA GUIDELINES vs REAL LIFE 😜 • Used Breast Pumps | 🧐 ...
→ How to Get a FREE Breast Pump through ANY insurance • How to Get a FREE Brea...
→ "Hospital Grade" Breast Pumps | What does hospital-grade REALLY mean?? • "Hospital Grade" Breas...
→ Best Breast Pumps for Working Moms Webinar link.newlittlelife.com/widget...
→ Pumping for Working Moms Program 📞 Schedule a call with the New Little Life Team to learn more and join! 📞 www.newlittlelife.com/apply
→ ⚠️ ⚠️⚠️ Discounts and Coupon Codes for breast pumps and accessories are all listed here: www.newlittlelife.com/coupons
NEED MORE HELP CHOOSING A BREAST PUMP?
🌐 Join our next Breast Pumps for Working Moms Webinar! 🌐 www.newlittlelife.com/breast-...
✨ Pick a Breast Pump QUIZ ✨ link.newlittlelife.com/widget...
🌀 Choosing a Breast Pump Facebook group 🌀 / breastpumpsforworkingmoms
0:00 Medela vs Spectra Pumps
0:50 What gives Spectra & Medela an Edge?
6:20 The Current Market for Breast Pumps
8:25 Medela's Response to Spectra's Popularity
9:29 Are These Still the Best Pumps on the Market?
#breastpump #medela #spectra
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
See all the BREAST PUMPING RESOURCES available from New Little Life on the website: www.newlittlelife.com
Click here for the blog post of this video:
www.newlittlelife.com/2023/08...
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
******* More Resources for You 📲 All links here: linktr.ee/newlittlelife
👩💻 _Pumping for Working Moms Program_: www.newlittlelife.com/pumping...
🩸 _Pumping for Lactation Professionals Program_: www.pumpingforlactationprofes...
🌀 Instagram: / newlittlelife_byallison
🥶 Facebook: / newlittlelifellc
🎙 Podcast: www.newlittlelife.com/podcast
🌐 Website: www.newlittlelife.com
📘 Facebook group: / breastpumpsforworkingmoms
Disclaimers: Links in the description are often affiliate links but have no extra cost to you :)
If you want some pumping help from Allison, apply to work with us here! --> bit.ly/462Zd6I
Six months strong and I'm still pleased with the Spectra 2. I'm a teacher and this gets the job done twice a day while at work. I keep my Lansinoh pump in the car as backup just in case I leave a Spectra part at home after rushing in the morning. I love this pump, it's dependable as well.
I’ve been using the medela pump in style maxflow and usually get 1oz each pumping. I wonder if the Spectra could help extracting more. Thank you for any help
Thank you for your work! I’m from Germany and your videos has been very helpful! I‘d love to hear more about the new Medela hands free in general. For example they say „don’t put the assembled cups in the fridge“ in the manual. Do you have an idea why? Greetings
The lactation team at my hospital provided Medela to me and lent it for one week before my Spectra S2 breast pump arrived. So I had experience with both. Both of them work great. Recommended for all. Very easy to use and has great suction. No complain.
I used the freemie closed system plastic cups with the spectra s1 plus. I'm a dispatcher and I exclusively pumped with my first child. I plan on pumping at work for my second and nursing at home. The freemie cups saved me because I can stay at my console without having to stop working. I work in a smaller agency so a flange that sits in the bra is a must.
I’ve been trying to watch all your videos. I can’t choose the correct one. Can you please suggest the which one is best as a first time mom. My insurance covers
Motif Luna
Motif Duo
Spectra s2
Lansinoh SignaturePro
Medela
Spectra 9 plus double
Zomee Z2 Double Electric
This was super helpful, I liked hearing the background on these two companies! I got a Medela pump in style max flow from my insurance and it’s been fine for me, but I only pump one or two days a week 😅
I was so happy someone else is talking about how they broke the motif Luna 😂
I tried looking but is there a full review on the unimom vs unimom minuet?
Pls share video for comparison between Spectra S1 & Spectra Dual compact
Now that I’ve given birth and have used my pumps, I really hate the spectra. The suction is very aggressive, even on a low setting. I always have to mentally prepare myself for the pull. It made me realize how much better breastfeeding is. I ended up getting the Elvie instead of the Willow, and I prefer it now to even the spectra. I get more milk out with it than with the spectra, and it is not painful.
Thank you for sharing your perspective! The spectra has a vibration pattern in its suction style, I wonder if that’s bothersome for you because on the low levels it’s not overly strong. I’m so glad you’ve found success with the elvie! It has such a gentle suction.
I am 30 week s pregnant with my 4th child, but the last time I had a baby was over 10 years ago when the market was just so much simpler. I tis honestly how many breast pumps are avalible, I just don'tknow where to start looking or which one to choose.
I think one of the issues is that most insurance will cover Spectra, Medela, Lansinoh or Motif so they don’t know about options like Pumpables which has 2 great pumps that are covered with some insurance but limited DME providers.
I would love to see the S9 with CaraCups compared to the Medela Freestyle Handsfree.
Me too. With my insurance, I can get the S9 for free. I’m not sure if it’s worth paying the upgrade fee for the Medela hands free.
@@deboraarciniega5141 I have both and prefer the Medela over the Spectra, but I’m curious of the data or if it is just my mind or maybe my S9 needing to be replaced. I had the Freestyle Flex for baby 5 and got the Freestyle Handsfree for baby 6 (I still use the Flex too) the S9 just doesn’t feel like it has a strong suction to it.
Omgosh! I was given the 1996 Medela version after i gave birth in 2018!!! I really disliked that pump, especially since its so loud and took a long time to get any output. Since I had my 2 children back to back, and my insurance only pays for new pumps every 5 years, I had to stick with it yet only pumped for 4 weeks each time.
I got a hand me down spectra s1 so I purchased the medela freestyle hands free through insurance as a more compact option. I did not plan for sharing parts. If I did, I would have bought a different one. Now I have the genie advanced and use the liquid shield kit with the spectra and like it better than using it with the genie advanced even. I like the vibration and the soft kneading feeling similar to baby’s nursing. I feel like medela has some basic issues to resolve with the handsfree-1. Nipple visibility ( I can’t tell if it’s centered) 2. Touch screen lock. 3. More customization with speed and vacuum. I live the simplicity of the cups though for cleaning
Thank you for your feedback! It’s so helpful for other users 💙
Can you do review for the Spectra dual compact pump please
Currently using the symphony that I’m renting from the hospital. I have to return it soon and don’t know what pump to use afterwards. Any suggestions?
Medela Symphony Comparison - Which breast pumps are most similar to the medela symphony?
ruclips.net/video/tAdL_OBSJkc/видео.html
working in a wic clinic, many of our moms only have access to either the cheapest they can find or what their insurance will cover. For me, when it comes to Spectra vs Medela, it's usually the Spectra S1/S2 vs the Medela pump in style with max flow (why such a long name? 🙄 ). Sometiems they can get Zomee Z2, Motif Luna, but usually they are sent a spectra or medela pump in style with max flow.
Many of our moms use the symphony in the hospital or if they're having supply issues. some have the classic medela from the mid 90's.
Do you have the suction pattern and specs for these pumps? I'm trying to better serve our moms by learning as much as I can about the pumps they have access to.
Love your channel! Wish we could have you speak to our group of Peer Counselors and IBCLC's sometime.
Thanks for your feedback and questions! I do have info sheets on these pumps inside our Pumping for Lactation Professionals course and library. www.pumpingforlactationprofessionals.com
I am pretty full on speaking engagements for this year, but you’re always welcome to send over any requests if that’s something helpful for you and your team! Allison@newlittlelife.com
All of my due date groups resoundingly say Spectra. This is my third pregnancy and it’s twins- I called my insurance specifically to ask for a unimom opera and I got one!! I am SO excited to use it!!
That’s awesome!!! Spectra1 or 2 are still such a solid pump, nothing wrong there either. Your opera will be smaller and fun too! I hope you love it.
I love my unimom opera pump the best because it empties me out and relatively quiet. I had the medala in style with my daughter 5 years ago and I hated it because it was loud and only got very little output
Hi Allison Ty ty for your videos
Can you do a video on the topic of wearable breast pumps emitting EMFs? I think that is what is called. That is my only concern when thinking about purchasing a wearable breast pump.
I work in radiology emf is not ionizing radiation. Your phone and everything tv, radio, emits different waves but it's not radiation that you think.
Elizabeth is right, it’s not something to worry much about from what we know about it. To lower any risks, you could go with a wearable pump with no Bluetooth capability, although they’re becoming fewer and fewer!
thank you so so much ladies for taking the time to reply. I really appreciated it. I read it in a blog and I been concern since. ty ty
I’m due soon which should i get through my insurance? Is the zomee ok ? If not these
can you compare the symphony vs supergenie or more videos on pumpables pumps? :)
I love your videos, I was an S2 gal three years ago, crazy the options now. Loving my Baby Buddha but you'd better believe I kept my Spectra just in case, old reliable lol.
“Old reliable” is a great way to put it! Such a classic good pump.
Yes, and the motor can last for multiple kids (I used one for 3!), and being closed system, shouldn't be any concerns. (Know so many moms who reused their old PIS or shared them 🤢🤮)
Can you also do a comparison between Imani with iBox vs Medela? 😊
I oppose those few that said this was too wordy. I loved that you shared history. I used Spectra with second child and I’m now going to use a Medela with this baby (arriving very very soon!).
Not gonna lie, I even thought “what if I manufacture a breast pump?” Ha!
Thank you for the information! Your channel is gold!!
Thank you for this perspective :) not every video is for everyone, but glad you liked this one! I think it’s important to know the whole picture 💙
@@NewLittleLife I actually stopped what I was doing to focus on the history part. Lol! Btw, I meant to say “I’m now” going to use a Medela and not “I’m not”; went back and edited my comment. Spectra was great with my second child to some extent, specially since I exclusively pumped. This time, I am going to try to pump and breastfeed since my husband wants to feed baby as well. I thought Medela will work better for me with this plan.
I'm sad because the only pump through insurance is the new medela and I heard it's not as good as the old one which I loved
What about the zomee Z2? You did a review 1 yr ago after trying it out a couple times. Wuat do you think of it now? All the reviews rave about it and say they like it better than their Spectra. Not sure about longevity though.
I’m wondering the same. In between zomee z2 and spectra 2. Never heard of the brand zomee until recently and I know they also have the hands free option. I’m due soon and have to pick a pump thru my insurance. Which one did you go with??
@@goldies6909 I went with the Zomee. Baby is coming in two weeks. Will see how it goes. My sister got the same one and so far she loves it, especially the hands free cups.
I want a genie advanced, but they don't ship to México. Here only can find Medela or spectra, and the cost it's high when you compare with USA
My first baby (almost 7 years ago) i got the old medela pump in style. Just had a baby 3 months ago, i let my friend use my pump and she gave it away. So anyway.. i needed a new pump. I was going to get the new pump in style because i thought it was like the one i had before.. then i saw the reviews. I didnt even know spectra, ameda, unimom ect. So it was really tempting to just stick to what i knew even though the reviews were kinda awful. I am so glad i didnt. I am so happy i binged a lot of Allison's videos😂 probably saved me a whole lot of money and a lot of headache😁
I have tried Medela am currently renting a Medela symphony but i still need something stronger !!!! Please help
Stronger isn’t always better, could there be something else not quite right in your pumping routine/set up?
Which pumps do you recommend for twins
There's a video on multi-user pumps and I think also on dual-motor pumps. Those might get you in the right ballpark.
which one has strongest suction to the point where it hurts. hospital grade. i had blue medela hospital rented but its huge and bulky. if i cant find same strength ill get it again, but prefer similar or same super strong suction strength.
This video may help
Medela Symphony Comparison - Which breast pumps are most similar to the medela symphony?
ruclips.net/video/tAdL_OBSJkc/видео.html
I'm a soon to be first time mom who has never pumped before and it's hard figuring out which pump to get through my insurance. I can get either the Spectra S1 or the Unimom Opera for similar upgrade fees. I've read mixed reviews on the Unimom Opera with some saying that it's too strong for them and they didn't have good customer service. Since I don't have experience yet, I have no idea if I'll need a pump that's on the stronger side or the more gentle side. I work from home. Which would you recommend getting?
I will do a video comparing these! I get this question a lot. I prefer the unimom opera due to its setting capabilities, size, and weight. They’re both great pumps though 👍🏼 I just filmed a video today actually on pumping tips for work at home moms! If you’re not subscribed, make sure you do because that will be super helpful for you!
@@NewLittleLife Thank you so much! Just subscribed, will check out your new video and can't wait for the S1/Opera comparison video!
@@NewLittleLife I love the Opera even over the Synergy Gold and Synergy Gold Portable because of the available options in a portable pump. If Spectra could put the full S1/S2 options in a battery powered Synergy Gold full size they would be a competitor to the Opera for moms who really love Spectra.
I have the Medela Pump in style that she mentions at 9:00 from my insurance company and it shuts down within the first week, maybe 2 weeks of me having it. The motor shuts off within a couple of SECONDS of turning it on. Medela even mentions the motor not working in the “problems” section of the instruction manual. I don’t recommend it
Yes, similar experience!I just had my baby and now I am engorged and this modela pump hasn’t wanted to start! I have only gotten it to work once or twice!
Interested in setting up a call to talk about what one might be best as I'll need to order one within the next couple months!
We do this often with members inside our coaching program, when are you due?
January 1st
If you need strong suction get Baby Buddha. I was an over-producer with lots of clogged milk duct problems. Spectra S1 was not cutting it… I needed a pump that will empty out my breast completely & it was Baby Buddha. Having a new baby & dealing with clogged duct was a nightmare.
Is baby buddha? This is going to be my 3rd pump i am so frustrated
Also looking for strong suction
The 1996 pump from Medela was my first pump in 2017 and I loved it!! I regret selling it! Thinking I was not going to have anymore kids!
Spectra gold vs the medela sonata.... are they similar? Do they even compare?
These are my top 2 and wondering the SAME!
These are my top 2 and wondering the SAME!
Im looking for an answer too i currently have my spectra gold but not pumping yet since im still pregnant but i also want to try to get the sonata but i want to see if its worth to buy
I just bought the sonata, and I previously had the gold. Both are good, but vastly different. I also haven't seen a good, in depth review of the Sonata anywhere.
Do any DME/vendors give genie advanced through insurance? TYVM
also Unicom opera
Try breastpumps . Com www.breastpumps.com/insurance-provided-pumps/?refersource=Other&referdetails=New+Little+Life
I tried the Spectra and it was NOT working for me. I had to dig out my 5 year old Medela Pump in Style Advanced and finally my mastitis went away and I’m able to unclog my ducts.
I had a Medela Pump in Style pump from 2009. Used it with all my kids and it was the best. I am so sad that I gave that pump away.
Which would you say is more gentle
Kept waiting for helpful info on which pump is better. This video should be called history of pumps.
Both of these companies make several different pumps, which pumps are you looking to compare? I thought the title was clear but perhaps I’ll have another look and adjust! Thanks!
Hi! Have you come across Imani Ibox?
I desperately need help finding a pump that’s more gentle than the spectra
Medala pump in style or Spectra S2 please ??
Which one you bought. ? 😊
can spectra 1 be considered as a main pump?
Definitely!!! It's fantastic.
Pink Spectra vs medela max flow
You are talking much … almost 13 minutes and still you didn’t answer the main question…. Medela or Spectra ?????
Too wordy not straight to the point. Dont need to know the history of all details.
I’m only 2:06 and I totally agree with you. I’m more concerned about which pump is more comfortable, great suction and is covered by insurance
You all are just ridiculous🙄😂 I’m glad to understand these pumps properly..brand longevity is an important factor. In fact ALL of this info is valuable to ANYONE that would prefer to know exactly what we’re/I’m throwing 300-500$ at. Not to mention the fact this info directly correlates to my ability to feed my baby as effectively as possible.
This is certainly one area in which I wouldn’t be so incredibly lazy, for goodness sake. Too lazy even, for 10 mins of simply listening and learning.
Medela sucks!! I know moms get it from there insurance but I really recommend trying other ones
I agree that the new MaxFlow does. I used the PISA with my first 3 and had a lot of success, but nothing with the MaxFlox. I am able to use the Medela Freestyle Flex & Freestyle Handsfree though.
@@charitywooten2135- yep. The Spectra and I were not working out so I dug out my 5 year old PISA and it works great. Sad that they discontinued it.
I absolutely love my spectra s1, I bought the genie advance but have a hard time emptying with it, I usually end up with a massive clog
Try using cycle speed 3, the pumps are pretty comparable so play with the settings until you find what works!
I watched more than half but this video doesn’t really answer the question. Thanks for the history but not what I was looking for…
Long and not straight to the point. Ty anyway
Hands down Medela. Spectra SUCKS
Madela symphony is heaven sent the only pump that emptied my breast