Thank you for doing all this research and making this video! It was very needed. You're right - these things are not cheap. Us Mama's need reviews like this. ♡ God bless you.
Thank you for bringing up the point about not emptying enough can reduce supply. Our team of IBCLCs often get asked if we have wearable pumps. In truth we have prototypes but have yet to mass produce because of this concern. We like to say the 'traditional' pumps are considered primary and wearables can be considered 'secondary.' Hopefully after more perfecting, we will feel safe to deliver a wearable version to the market soon. We work so hard to make milk for our babies! Understandably everyone's lifestyle should be considered when choosing what's best for their bodies.
Currently pregnant with my second. I was not able to breastfeed my first. I really want to breastfeed this time around. I saw that Elvie now has a hospital grade pump. As an IBLC, what would your thoughts be on a pump like that? Does hospital grade mean better suction for emptying the breast?
I'm expecting my first in March and researching the best way to pump as a high school math teacher, so I don't have to take a "time out" from teaching every day especially if I'm not lucky enough to have a co-teacher. I have yet to finish watching your review but imagine my surprise at discovering one of my high school classmates is now teaching me about breast pumps on RUclips. Glad to see small-town people doing great things!
Loved the video. Thank you for your honest review. I’ve been using my Elvie for 6 months already and I LOVE IT. It’s so easy to pump at work and when on the go.
I am currently sitting in the NICU watching this. Thanks for helping me make my decision. I hope it works well for me also. There is nothing like these hospital pumps (Ameda). I wish the manufacturer of these would make wearable😂. Great review. Thanks again. 😅
Both breast pumps are fsa, hsa and insurance compatible for anyone that wants one. And they actually don’t run $500 for both the elvie actually is only $400 coming for both, but you have the option to get only one as well which is $200 something. Again both you can get through insurance or hsa and fsa
I know you are a Dr. but I couldn't help but notice your neck, have you got your thyroid checked? when looking at the video its on the left that seemed enlarged. My husband had thyroid cancer so this concern comes from the heart- and maybe you are already aware of this.
Thank you for this video! I love my Elvie pump. I find it so great to pump in the car, for traveling or when I have people over in my house. I also found that they charge very quickly.
I am very thankful I invested in the elvie because I could not be an outpatient physical therapist assistant without it. It is just not possible to take 20mins away from my patient's 60min appt. I do have to be careful not to lean too far forward with it. Very excited to hear the comparison of the 2 from someone else in thw medical field. It will help with baby number 2
@@kaylaperkins8309 I try not to drop my chest to parallel to the floor. I can still change out equipment at work and pick up the baby. I just make sure to squat not lean, as we should anyway. I am not one of those people that can sit still well.
Yess! Okay you are the perfect review and comment for me. I’m also a OP PTA and trying to figure out what’s going to be best. How was the suction? Was it strong enough for you at least to get you by during the day.
Ugh, I wish I had that experience lol, mine CONSTANTLY leaked, no matter what position I was in. I lost sooooo much milk. So sad. They were even put together correctly.
@@brianavachal2900 the WORST feeling 😭 I’ve lost so much milk because I didn’t put them together right and didn’t notice until after and I was soaked 💔
@@brianavachal2900 and that’s why I am choosing to save a little more and buy one of these more expensive models. I need something that won’t spill. I’ve heard consistently that the willow does not spill.
I’ve read several comparison articles between these two brands, and this is the best breakdown I’ve seen. It was so helpful to hear them and to see you actually wear them. And you brought up points that none of the sources I’ve read even mentioned, like how the willow does constant suction vs traditional intermittent suction on the Elvie. Thank you! Very helpful information.
Tbh I did a lot of research between the Willow 3 and the Willow Go and tbh the Willow Go is the way easier, more affordable option. It’s still louder but it feels more akin to my spectra when it comes to emptying my breasts when I crank it up. Anyway, the Willow Go model is a game changer as far as pumping goes, the new model seems really good for if you need sanitary bags but honestly it’s a money grab. I exclusively have to pump for my nicu baby and the Go has really saved my breastfeeding journey. One big negative though is you can’t stick your pump parts in the fridge if you’re a lazy bum like me who used to only wash my parts like three times a day. So I do a couple good hand washes and sanitize/dry the pump parts in my little sanitizer machine now.
I ended up buying the zomee fit, works for me as it was the cheapest with insurence i paid $50 so i could try it without spending $150 or $200 for willow or elvie so it was less of a paperweight if it didnt work. Definately larger than elvie and holds more, so yes dolly parton boob for me but it had features that others lacked that made it worth it like nipple correction and 2 modes. Cons are size, and the full sensor sometimes fogs up so i have to swish the milk around to wipe the view of the sensor to clean it to get it pumping again. Thankfully it doesnt happen too often. Holds charge for about 4 pumps. Parts are a pain to buy as they are sold out often...... So there is that and you have to use upright, but it works well on me and i can pump exclusively enough on it so im a happy camper. My son has tounge tie partially and struggles to feed on me so i dont mind pumping. Nights are hard but at least i can pump while he sleeps a little longer than every hour feeding that he desires. I cannot be an all you can eat buffet milk maid for his constant snaker style feeding.
Awesome video! 👌🏼 everything i needed to know exactly, second time around easy to understand which ur talking about thank you! I am interested if its possible for the massage, when clogged in elvie , u said cant in willow but still so great
Can you as well review the new Elvie Stride wearable pump please!? Lots of people love it and it’s cheaper than the original Elvie and said it’s “hospital grade” pump! Thank you!
This comparison was SO helpful!! I’ve been researching wearables and thought I was going to get the Willow Go. After watching your video I will definitely be purchasing the Elvie. Thank you Dr!!
Kortney-the Willow I reviewed in this video is the Willow 3.0! I think the GO has more traditional suction but I don’t know (haven’t tried it yet). I’m definitely going to try the GOs with baby #2 and will make a video-but don’t know much about them yet. Best of luck to you on your pumping journey!!!
Thank you so much for the thoughtful review, I already had the Elvie on my registry, and am glad I went that way after the video. Also getting the Spectra S1 from my insurance.
Glad I seen this… sound is definitely important to me and glad you demonstrated that feature for both. If I decided to buy a wearable it would definitely be elvie.
Watching your videos again for my second pregnancy! I am contemplating getting one of these this time. I was so sick and tired of being “strapped” in with a closed door at work for a year with my Spectra. It was also hard to coordinate events, regular dinners with family and friends, without having to retire early to pump alone. ETA: omg the Willow sounds like a constant spray bottle. 😂.
Love the channel. I had twins 5 months ago and have the Elvie. I love that I don't have to have cords everywhere while working at my desk. I still have to pump using my regular pump 2-3x per day though.
-I really appreciate your review. I had the Willow 3 for exclusive pumping in 2020 (my 2nd baby was in NICU and refused to BF from me once she realized she didn't have to work for it from a bottle, lol). I am a psych nurse in clinic and sometimes hospital. I had a Medela Symphony that I would use (usually at home for comfort). The Willow was great for work as hands free but because of constant suction, I think I just got to the point I was tired of it and uncomfortable (I quit pumping at 3 months, sadly). I also had issues with reusable containers after 2 months not working and the company sent me tips, those didn't help, I bought new containers and it would eventually not read that I was pumping and not get out of stimulation mode. The added costs of the Willow just make me think that I'm not going that route thus time and will try Elvie instead. My BCBS insurance covered Willow in full. My nips are elastic per lactation consultant and stretch very easily which may have contributed to my discomfort. I will try the Elvie this time and hope for the best given its more natural suction. I feel the constant suck on the Willow really didn't help with my let down and I was never fully emptied which I desperately needed to avoid mastitis which I had twice. I liked that the Willow had the bag option too but it got pricey. My 3rd baby should be here in 2 months or less, so i hope to breastfeed but will be ready for back to work with a hands free pump. Thank you again for the review!
I bought the willow and it's also my greatest regret. I think I'm going to stop pumping because it doesn't work. Heavy on chest, reusable containers never work and I had them replaced rwicd
@@christamyers8647 I have blue shield of california and they cover half of the wearable ones for me. Another thing you can do is only get a half pump, so just one of them, and it will be half price.
Hi! I’m currently 12 weeks pregnant with my second child. I used and LOVED my spectra s1 3 years ago when I would pump for my first. For this pregnancy I’ve been looking into hands free options to go along with my spectra and was so torn because breastfeeding is so personal and those pumps are not cheap. Thank you SO SO much for breaking down the pros and cons of each pump in such a realistic way that answered all of my concerns, especially the suction style. I have so much more to consider now but it will definitely help me to decide which pump to pick. Since you said you would do more videos on pumps I will hold off on making my final choice until you have gone through more! Thanks again!!
Thank you so much for taking the time out of your day to do this! It was so well put together!!! Do you have or plan on having one on the Elvie Stride? It's a bit more affordable.
Hi! Could you guys possibly due a video on baby crib mattresses? I am overwhelmed by the options. We think a spring mattress is best compared to foam, but curious what you guys have or recommend. So many options and so many opinions on what is "best" or "safest" so wondering if you have any recommendations for navigating this.
I wish I would have watched this before buying willow! Literally some of the worst pumps I’ve ever used and the most expensive… I had no sleep and bought these on a whim thinking they would be great, was very wrong. Thanks for sharing your experience.
Wonderful, I’m due in a month and a half and already got the Elvie. I was hoping to use it in the car or occasionally, as I hope to primarily breast feed. This information came at a great time for me. It was hard to choose between the two with just looking at basic reviews.
Yes, I noticed this as well. I have a family history of thyroid disease, so I wasn’t sure if I’m just hyper sensitive at noticing those kinds of things, or if other people noticed as well.
Someone else asked the same thing and she responded and said she has a nodule in her thyroid that is benign. She gets it drained and is planning to have it removed completely 👍🏾
Agreed!! Doesn’t hold a great charge I only use it 2 times at work and I have to charge it for next day. But love the Elvie overall! Worth the investment especially if you plan on having a few little ones
I just want to put this out there… call your insurance company and check! I have blue cross blue shield through team care and they cover any pump 100% no cap on price. It even said wearables like willow and elvie. I was just about to buy one but I called and checked first thank goodness
Wow, that’s great. My insurance only covers certain models (re: cheap models). But also, I would want to use that benefit to purchase my main pump. I do want to get one of these pumps too for when I go to work, but I still want to use my main one.
Elvie now has a hospital grade pump, so the suction is supposed to be much better, and you're supposed to be able to fully empty the breast. I would be curious about what your thoughts would be on that one?
Have you tired the Elvie Stride!? I was trying to see which Elvie one to get through insurance and they have both. I use spectra S2 but for me it honestly doesn’t have a strong pull I find myself hand expressing still after🥺
@@destinyshoopman3452 I'm finding out that even though the elvie says hospital grade suction, I'm still having to go in with a manual pump or hand express after. Was only getting 2 oz out when using the pump. And that was total from both breasts. Meanwhile when using a manual pump I was able to get 4 oz out. And that was just from my left side
I am 5 weeks PP and exclusively pumping. My primary pump is the Spectra Synergy Gold, which I love and I recently purchased the Imani 2 from Legendairy Milk. I love my spectra as it really empties me, but the Imani is hit or miss. Some sessions it seems to empty me and others I find an hour later I need to go back to my spectra and pump for relief. I am a teacher and will be going back to work in a few more weeks. I am still considering the Elvie or Willow as the Imani is very bulky and I’m just not thrilled with the performance of it.
Thanks for sharing! I love my spectra and how well it does at emptying too. Finding the right wearable was tricky, but hopefully my journey helps you a bit on yours
Can you PLEASE make a video on what your baby is eating? My baby is 9 months and just got his first tooth. I’m going to start him on more “advanced” foods and need some ideas/tips. Thank you!
Have you tried pasta or french fries? Everything that's soft enough (apart from the usual suspects: raw milk cheese, honey, raw meat, etc.) should be fine. Just try some different foods and see how it goes! 😉 We had great success with soft french fries, pretzels and pasta in the beginning. If your baby isn't interested yet or doesn't like it, pause for a week and then try again.
Thank you for this video! I love my spectra too but it’s hard to get tied down to a pump every 3 hours of the day. I can’t afford to buy the “wrong one” so this is very helpful :) 👏🏼👏🏼
Thank you, Great video! Do you still plan to make the other videos showing how to set them up? If you so can you also show how you care for them as well please
Thanks for sharing! My husband and I have been TTC for a few months now so I'm doing any and ALL research, while I have the time! Hahah Hope you had a wonderful holiday!
I did the same and have to rewatch everything because pregnancy brain haha I recommend making a baby playlist of the videos you like so you can rewatch if you need to. Baby dust to you guys!
Hi! I had a spectra from my previous pregnancy. The last time I used it was 2 years ago. Do you think I can continue to use it alternating with a new Elvie? So I don’t have to buy 2 new pumps. Or does a spectra go bad by time ? I’m talking about the motor only but I’m definitely gonna buy new supplies( tubing, bottles, flanges.. etc)
Hi! I got a spectra 2 3 yrs ago and just had a baby and it works like it’s brand new. I got the caracups now and use them with my spectra. Hope this helps!
I felt the same way ... I love my spectra as well when I was breastfeeding I felt the willow pump was a waste of money I had to keep calling & even had to replace mine
Hi ! You made my morning with the Willow and Elvie. I’m a new mommy to be 16 weeks today and I’m doing my research about breast pumping because I want to breast bump as long as I can. I’m freaking out with the shortage of formula and scared that I might not produce breast milk. What are suggestions or guide you have on producing/keeping breast milk to keep follow coming ? and my second question/concern which spectra pump do you use or recommend ?
Oh hun, don’t stress. I breastfed my son for 19 months without ever needing to supplement with formula. Drinking enough water is major! I drank 4 litres a day. I also continued taking my prenatal vitamins with dha for baby’s brain development. In the beginning I would pump for 15 minutes after I nursed my little guy so my milk came in in an abundance! Nutritional eating is a major factor as well. Sleep also impacts milk production, we co-slept and my breasts were readily available so I would barely even have to wake up to nurse (I’m a light sleeper). You got this hun, your body will know what to do
Thank you for being so supportive within your family dynamic!!! This is my first time seeing that a man actually watched a video like this in the name of his wife!!!!
Great review! Idk why anyone would buy the willow in general, but especially after watching this! If you’re gonna pay $500 for a pump, it may as well be the Elvie and not all the cons that Willow has.
I loved my willow! I was literally able to demo a deck with a crowbar while I pumped. She also ignores that it’s really easy to reuse the bags, so you don’t actually need new bags for each pumping session. The Willow isn’t perfect, but it’s the best option for people who need a truly closed system
I'm in my first trimester and after seeing everything is going well at my first ultrasound I'm letting myself start to plan. I'm big on making lists, even lists of lists I need to make haha. I work from home, get 3 months of paid leave, and really am motivated to breastfeed. I like the idea of a hands free option but at $500 I think I'd like to know breastfeeding will work for me and understand my supply before making that kind of investment. Do you think it's necessary to have a pump ready for when you get home from the hospital?
Speaking from my recent experience, having some type of pump helps because it lets you see if your milk has come and how much you can get. I wish someone told me to get a pump because for 4 days, my poor baby was starving as I thought I was “nursing” without realizing my milk hadn’t come. I’d nurse for good 40 minutes and would put the baby down thinking the baby had enough milk when in fact, I barely had any. I so wish someone mentioned to pump so I could see how much I’m giving the baby. Even a hand held manual pump works if your intending on using it just for few days for measuring purposes.
@@tanazakbar831 thank you for the advice, that's really helpful. I was looking at the haakaa to start with. I hope all ended up working out for you and baby.
Honestly I would try to get my milk to come in by pumping around the time of my due date. If you're ready it helps labor begin and also it'll allow you to start developing colostrum before the baby arrives.
I had the opposite problem and my milk can in really heavy making me too full and it hard for my baby to latch. So having a pump available to release some of the pressure was really helpful
@@tanazakbar831 although it's important to note thty your baby usually will get more from you than the pump can from you because the baby is more efficient. If you are following a feeding with a pump it just makes sure you were empty and you can see how much was left, but if you're replacing a feeding it's not a great measure. Also one way to tell if baby is getting anything while they are nursing is to listen for swallows, but the only way to know for sure how much they were able to get from you is to go to an IBCLC and do a weighted feed.
Hello Doctors 🌷🌷🌷I’d like to ask you more professional opinions: How to return body shape and tone after pregnancy . When it’s better to start , what exactly work well what is dangerous to do . About food etc ) Thank you)!
Correction: You can change the suction level from the Willow 3.0 app so you don't have to go under your shirt to adjust it. Another con of the Willow is that the bags are just awkward. The weird round shape is hard to store, the label's writing area is very small, and they are difficult to pour milk out of.
Hello Doctor. Thank you for your videos. Quick question I am all about being as natural as possible. Pregnant with baby number two and been thinking about using a wearable breast pump. However, someone brought up on a blog I was reading the danger of possible being exposed to EMFs. What are your thoughts on that? ty in advanced
Hello! Thanks so much for your super helpful videos! I am an outpatient pediatrician, and I was wondering if you find that the Elvie is leak free when actually moving around to examine a patient or is it more for typing notes at a desk? How about when wrangling a toddler for a COVID swab? 😂 Thanks!!
How long does the battery life last for the Elvie and the Willow? I plan on using one of these for 3-3.5 hour time intervals in between my breaks at my 12 hour work shifts
It’s a personal item. It’s like asking someone to donate you their toothbrush. I would personally not accept such a gift. But to each their own, I guess…
Hi! Thank you for taking the time to create these videos! I have learned so much. Quick question about the booster vaccine and first trimester. I am 6 weeks pregnant and worried about the potential for high fever if I get the booster vaccine during my first trimester. Is there any evidence indicating that waiting (and quarintining😎) until 2nd trimester to get the booster (or any vaccine) shot could mitigate against potential harm from vaccine immune response fever? Thank you! (And as always, I plan to consult my OB😊)
Hi, I’m 20 weeks now, but I got my booster at 16 weeks. I spoke with my midwife because I had a high fever with the second shot. We decided to wait till the second trimester and I was fine. The side effects were a lot less severe with the booster thankfully Speak with your OB or midwife and get their advice!
I’m not a dr but from what my midwife told me and from what I’ve seen recommended in their videos there’s no reason to wait IF you have a chance of being exposed to covid. Otherwise waiting till your second trimester is fine. I didn’t have any reaction to my first two shots (only a little sore where the shot was given) so it could depend on your body too. If you felt very ill or had a high fever with the first two shots that’s when I would wait personally. But remember too people get sick and have fevers all the time and still have healthy babies. I think it goes off of your risk of exposure and comfort level. I didn’t want to do anything for the first trimester but sleep haha. Good luck!
There’s no increased risk that’s been seen from these vaccines to babies at any time during pregnancy. If it makes you feel better to isolate and wait until later in pregnancy, you can do that, but we would recommend to our loved ones not to wait given the increased risks of COVID to women who are pregnant. - the best way to keep baby healthy is to keep mom healthy.
@@TheDoctorsBjorkman I hated when our OBGYN told us this as if there have been years of the proper studies done. NOBODY TRULY KNOWS. So to tell all these mothers there aren’t any possible side effects and you should just take it should be a crime. Get back to me when all of these babies turn 10>15>18, when these mothers have 2 more babies after their boosters, when there aren’t literally drastic side affects in the beginning stages of the vaccine. Irresponsible….
Have you been checked for goiter? Your neck looks so swollen. Not trying to be rude maybe it’s just a shadow but it’s the concerned nurse in me with a family history of thyroid issues😬
You all have a great eye!! I totally have a thyroid nodule!! I’ve had it drained a couple times (it’s benign) but the dumb thing keeps re-accumulating so I’m probably gonna end up having it removed here eventually. Thank you so much for saying something-it’s so nice to have our RUclips fam lookin out for us too!!❤️
Thanks for this video. I have tried one wearable breast pump and I hated it. It made my boobs bleed, but it was one I got off Amazon for around $60. But I more than anything wanted to be able to pump without taking off my shirt.
Soap and hot water is more than adequate as long as you have clean water where you live. Everything else isn’t necessary, just maybe givens people piece of mind.
imagine if men where to breastfeed..then maybe the breast-pump industri would have realistic pricing for wearable breast pumps. Would love to try one, but the price puts me off. Great video btw, I really enjoyed it.
My sister in law used the Elvie (I don’t know which model) and it didn’t work for her. She was larger chested when her milk came in and they wouldn’t stay on or she just wouldn’t get hardly anything out. She has an amazing supply and hasn’t had any issues with other pumps.
This is a great (and challenging) topic. We found TakingCaraBabies to be incredibly helpful for us. It maybe a bit until we get around to make a video ourselves on this, so please check out her stuff. It’s great!
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you for doing all this research and making this video! It was very needed. You're right - these things are not cheap. Us Mama's need reviews like this. ♡ God bless you.
Would love a 2023 update with the other pumps you mentioned at the end of the video.
I would love a video on what you two did for sleep training or sleep support for your little one after the newborn stage.
Lies again? Bull's Penis Bio Perine
Thank you for bringing up the point about not emptying enough can reduce supply. Our team of IBCLCs often get asked if we have wearable pumps. In truth we have prototypes but have yet to mass produce because of this concern. We like to say the 'traditional' pumps are considered primary and wearables can be considered 'secondary.' Hopefully after more perfecting, we will feel safe to deliver a wearable version to the market soon. We work so hard to make milk for our babies! Understandably everyone's lifestyle should be considered when choosing what's best for their bodies.
Currently pregnant with my second. I was not able to breastfeed my first. I really want to breastfeed this time around. I saw that Elvie now has a hospital grade pump. As an IBLC, what would your thoughts be on a pump like that? Does hospital grade mean better suction for emptying the breast?
I'm expecting my first in March and researching the best way to pump as a high school math teacher, so I don't have to take a "time out" from teaching every day especially if I'm not lucky enough to have a co-teacher. I have yet to finish watching your review but imagine my surprise at discovering one of my high school classmates is now teaching me about breast pumps on RUclips. Glad to see small-town people doing great things!
Loved the video. Thank you for your honest review. I’ve been using my Elvie for 6 months already and I LOVE IT. It’s so easy to pump at work and when on the go.
Do you exclusively pump??
@@cristalzuniga6004 I only pump at work.
I am currently sitting in the NICU watching this. Thanks for helping me make my decision. I hope it works well for me also. There is nothing like these hospital pumps (Ameda). I wish the manufacturer of these would make wearable😂. Great review. Thanks again. 😅
Both breast pumps are fsa, hsa and insurance compatible for anyone that wants one. And they actually don’t run $500 for both the elvie actually is only $400 coming for both, but you have the option to get only one as well which is $200 something. Again both you can get through insurance or hsa and fsa
Thank you, you hit all the points that I wanted to know when shopping for a wearable pump. Thank you for all your content I love it!
I know you are a Dr. but I couldn't help but notice your neck, have you got your thyroid checked? when looking at the video its on the left that seemed enlarged. My husband had thyroid cancer so this concern comes from the heart- and maybe you are already aware of this.
What were his symptoms
As some one who had thyroid cancer there where no symptoms just a large mass growing near my facial nerve and saliva glands
I think it’s a shadow from the curl in her hair. I saw that too when the video started but as I kept staring I noticed the shadow
Wow I am noticing it now… I usually don’t pay attention to the person talking
I was thinking the same thing!
Thank you for this video! I love my Elvie pump. I find it so great to pump in the car, for traveling or when I have people over in my house. I also found that they charge very quickly.
The Elvie is definitely my favorite too
I am very thankful I invested in the elvie because I could not be an outpatient physical therapist assistant without it. It is just not possible to take 20mins away from my patient's 60min appt. I do have to be careful not to lean too far forward with it. Very excited to hear the comparison of the 2 from someone else in thw medical field. It will help with baby number 2
How far forward?
@@kaylaperkins8309 I try not to drop my chest to parallel to the floor. I can still change out equipment at work and pick up the baby. I just make sure to squat not lean, as we should anyway. I am not one of those people that can sit still well.
Yess! Okay you are the perfect review and comment for me. I’m also a OP PTA and trying to figure out what’s going to be best. How was the suction? Was it strong enough for you at least to get you by during the day.
I currently use the Momcozy S9 wearable pump and the flanges are silicon super comfortable, and more affordable. $100 and gets the job done!
Ugh, I wish I had that experience lol, mine CONSTANTLY leaked, no matter what position I was in. I lost sooooo much milk. So sad. They were even put together correctly.
@@brianavachal2900 the WORST feeling 😭 I’ve lost so much milk because I didn’t put them together right and didn’t notice until after and I was soaked 💔
@@brianavachal2900 and that’s why I am choosing to save a little more and buy one of these more expensive models. I need something that won’t spill. I’ve heard consistently that the willow does not spill.
Thank you so much for buying these and reviewing them. It's very helpful! Take care and hope your family is well. 😊
We’re so glad to know this was helpful for you. You’re most welcome!
I’ve read several comparison articles between these two brands, and this is the best breakdown I’ve seen. It was so helpful to hear them and to see you actually wear them. And you brought up points that none of the sources I’ve read even mentioned, like how the willow does constant suction vs traditional intermittent suction on the Elvie.
Thank you! Very helpful information.
Tbh I did a lot of research between the Willow 3 and the Willow Go and tbh the Willow Go is the way easier, more affordable option. It’s still louder but it feels more akin to my spectra when it comes to emptying my breasts when I crank it up. Anyway, the Willow Go model is a game changer as far as pumping goes, the new model seems really good for if you need sanitary bags but honestly it’s a money grab. I exclusively have to pump for my nicu baby and the Go has really saved my breastfeeding journey. One big negative though is you can’t stick your pump parts in the fridge if you’re a lazy bum like me who used to only wash my parts like three times a day. So I do a couple good hand washes and sanitize/dry the pump parts in my little sanitizer machine now.
What sanitizer machine do you use?
Thank you for your review! I got Elvie pumps and it’s great! Thank you!
I ended up buying the zomee fit, works for me as it was the cheapest with insurence i paid $50 so i could try it without spending $150 or $200 for willow or elvie so it was less of a paperweight if it didnt work. Definately larger than elvie and holds more, so yes dolly parton boob for me but it had features that others lacked that made it worth it like nipple correction and 2 modes. Cons are size, and the full sensor sometimes fogs up so i have to swish the milk around to wipe the view of the sensor to clean it to get it pumping again. Thankfully it doesnt happen too often. Holds charge for about 4 pumps. Parts are a pain to buy as they are sold out often...... So there is that and you have to use upright, but it works well on me and i can pump exclusively enough on it so im a happy camper. My son has tounge tie partially and struggles to feed on me so i dont mind pumping. Nights are hard but at least i can pump while he sleeps a little longer than every hour feeding that he desires. I cannot be an all you can eat buffet milk maid for his constant snaker style feeding.
Dolly Parton boob 😂
Which version of the Spectra do you use? Thank you for such a helpful video!
If it’s the same as an earlier video it’s the spectra s1 which is the blue one. I love mine so much!
Thanks for this! I was sold on the Willow until this video, but I think I’ll be switching to Elvie, now. 😊
Awesome video! 👌🏼 everything i needed to know exactly, second time around easy to understand which ur talking about thank you! I am interested if its possible for the massage, when clogged in elvie , u said cant in willow but still so great
Can you as well review the new Elvie Stride wearable pump please!? Lots of people love it and it’s cheaper than the original Elvie and said it’s “hospital grade” pump! Thank you!
This comparison was SO helpful!! I’ve been researching wearables and thought I was going to get the Willow Go. After watching your video I will definitely be purchasing the Elvie. Thank you Dr!!
Kortney-the Willow I reviewed in this video is the Willow 3.0! I think the GO has more traditional suction but I don’t know (haven’t tried it yet). I’m definitely going to try the GOs with baby #2 and will make a video-but don’t know much about them yet. Best of luck to you on your pumping journey!!!
@TheDoctorsBjorkman Have you since tried the Willow go? I'd love to know if you prefer it to the elvie or not. Thanks!
Thank you so much for the thoughtful review, I already had the Elvie on my registry, and am glad I went that way after the video. Also getting the Spectra S1 from my insurance.
Glad I seen this… sound is definitely important to me and glad you demonstrated that feature for both. If I decided to buy a wearable it would definitely be elvie.
Watching your videos again for my second pregnancy!
I am contemplating getting one of these this time. I was so sick and tired of being “strapped” in with a closed door at work for a year with my Spectra. It was also hard to coordinate events, regular dinners with family and friends, without having to retire early to pump alone.
ETA: omg the Willow sounds like a constant spray bottle. 😂.
Love the channel. I had twins 5 months ago and have the Elvie. I love that I don't have to have cords everywhere while working at my desk. I still have to pump using my regular pump 2-3x per day though.
What do you mean by regular pump? So you use the Elvis and another?
@@destinyshoopman3452 yes I was using a Motif Luna pump that plugs into the wall and the Elvie when I didn't have time to be stationary.
-I really appreciate your review. I had the Willow 3 for exclusive pumping in 2020 (my 2nd baby was in NICU and refused to BF from me once she realized she didn't have to work for it from a bottle, lol). I am a psych nurse in clinic and sometimes hospital. I had a Medela Symphony that I would use (usually at home for comfort). The Willow was great for work as hands free but because of constant suction, I think I just got to the point I was tired of it and uncomfortable (I quit pumping at 3 months, sadly). I also had issues with reusable containers after 2 months not working and the company sent me tips, those didn't help, I bought new containers and it would eventually not read that I was pumping and not get out of stimulation mode. The added costs of the Willow just make me think that I'm not going that route thus time and will try Elvie instead. My BCBS insurance covered Willow in full. My nips are elastic per lactation consultant and stretch very easily which may have contributed to my discomfort. I will try the Elvie this time and hope for the best given its more natural suction. I feel the constant suck on the Willow really didn't help with my let down and I was never fully emptied which I desperately needed to avoid mastitis which I had twice. I liked that the Willow had the bag option too but it got pricey. My 3rd baby should be here in 2 months or less, so i hope to breastfeed but will be ready for back to work with a hands free pump. Thank you again for the review!
I bought the willow and it's also my greatest regret. I think I'm going to stop pumping because it doesn't work. Heavy on chest, reusable containers never work and I had them replaced rwicd
1) how did you get them to cover willow? I have BCBS but they said they don't cover any of the wireless pumps?
2) did they cover elvie?
hi may I ask how the Elvie is working for you?
thinking of getting it
@@christamyers8647 I have blue shield of california and they cover half of the wearable ones for me. Another thing you can do is only get a half pump, so just one of them, and it will be half price.
Hi! I’m currently 12 weeks pregnant with my second child. I used and LOVED my spectra s1 3 years ago when I would pump for my first. For this pregnancy I’ve been looking into hands free options to go along with my spectra and was so torn because breastfeeding is so personal and those pumps are not cheap. Thank you SO SO much for breaking down the pros and cons of each pump in such a realistic way that answered all of my concerns, especially the suction style. I have so much more to consider now but it will definitely help me to decide which pump to pick. Since you said you would do more videos on pumps I will hold off on making my final choice until you have gone through more! Thanks again!!
If you’re in the states try to see if insurance will cover some of the cost.
Good luck mama!
I absolutely loved my Baby Bhudda pump. There customer service is great. Highly recommend them over Spectra.
I’d like to hear your review on the mom cozy!
Thank you so much for taking the time out of your day to do this! It was so well put together!!! Do you have or plan on having one on the Elvie Stride? It's a bit more affordable.
Hi! Could you guys possibly due a video on baby crib mattresses? I am overwhelmed by the options. We think a spring mattress is best compared to foam, but curious what you guys have or recommend. So many options and so many opinions on what is "best" or "safest" so wondering if you have any recommendations for navigating this.
Most recommended ive heard is the Newton if you can afford it.
@@AznBeachGirl I’ve heard that as well.
Our girl is due in May and that’s what we plan to purchase but no first hand experience yet.
Newton. My baby started sleeping on his stomach at 4 months and I had peace of mind knowing it was breathable.
I’ve exclusively pumped for over a year and both Elvie and Willow are a gamble. You either hate it or love it, there’s no in between.
What do you love?? I am planning on exclusivity pumping.
@@cristalzuniga6004 I haven't tried the willow, but I personally really love the elvie
Hi! Love your page. Would love for you to do a video on safe birth control methods while breastfeeding 🤱🏽. Which one would be more beneficial
I would love to see a comparison with Elvie Stride too.
I wish I would have watched this before buying willow! Literally some of the worst pumps I’ve ever used and the most expensive… I had no sleep and bought these on a whim thinking they would be great, was very wrong. Thanks for sharing your experience.
This review is SO helpful - thank you!
Thank you for the review. I also love my Spectra but I can't use it while on the move. I'll get the Elvie. It is smaller and quieter.
Wonderful, I’m due in a month and a half and already got the Elvie. I was hoping to use it in the car or occasionally, as I hope to primarily breast feed. This information came at a great time for me. It was hard to choose between the two with just looking at basic reviews.
Hi! Has anybody mention anything about your thyroid? They’re not symmetrical and slightly enlarged. I hope you get them checked. Take care
I was also distracted by it while watching this video. 🤔
Yes, I noticed this as well. I have a family history of thyroid disease, so I wasn’t sure if I’m just hyper sensitive at noticing those kinds of things, or if other people noticed as well.
Was just about to comment the same thing!
Yes, I noticed as well. Hope Dr. Bjorkman gets a chance to have it checked out
Someone else asked the same thing and she responded and said she has a nodule in her thyroid that is benign. She gets it drained and is planning to have it removed completely 👍🏾
Great video! I appreciate testimonials and comparisons!
Agreed!! Doesn’t hold a great charge I only use it 2 times at work and I have to charge it for next day. But love the Elvie overall! Worth the investment especially if you plan on having a few little ones
I just want to put this out there… call your insurance company and check! I have blue cross blue shield through team care and they cover any pump 100% no cap on price. It even said wearables like willow and elvie. I was just about to buy one but I called and checked first thank goodness
I had bcbs and they said they only covered 3 types?
Wow, that’s great. My insurance only covers certain models (re: cheap models). But also, I would want to use that benefit to purchase my main pump. I do want to get one of these pumps too for when I go to work, but I still want to use my main one.
Elvie now has a hospital grade pump, so the suction is supposed to be much better, and you're supposed to be able to fully empty the breast. I would be curious about what your thoughts would be on that one?
What pump is that?
@@quatarious-quay-anderson8194 it's called the Elvie Stride
@@amidthephantomsrose cool, thank you! I was looking at that one today and wondered if that's what you were talking about
Have you tired the Elvie Stride!? I was trying to see which Elvie one to get through insurance and they have both. I use spectra S2 but for me it honestly doesn’t have a strong pull I find myself hand expressing still after🥺
@@destinyshoopman3452 I'm finding out that even though the elvie says hospital grade suction, I'm still having to go in with a manual pump or hand express after. Was only getting 2 oz out when using the pump. And that was total from both breasts. Meanwhile when using a manual pump I was able to get 4 oz out. And that was just from my left side
Thank you so much for making this video!
Another great video! Thank you so much for making it.
Thank you so much for your videos. They are so helpful!
I am 5 weeks PP and exclusively pumping. My primary pump is the Spectra Synergy Gold, which I love and I recently purchased the Imani 2 from Legendairy Milk. I love my spectra as it really empties me, but the Imani is hit or miss. Some sessions it seems to empty me and others I find an hour later I need to go back to my spectra and pump for relief. I am a teacher and will be going back to work in a few more weeks. I am still considering the Elvie or Willow as the Imani is very bulky and I’m just not thrilled with the performance of it.
Thanks for sharing! I love my spectra and how well it does at emptying too. Finding the right wearable was tricky, but hopefully my journey helps you a bit on yours
Can you PLEASE make a video on what your baby is eating? My baby is 9 months and just got his first tooth. I’m going to start him on more “advanced” foods and need some ideas/tips. Thank you!
Have you tried pasta or french fries?
Everything that's soft enough (apart from the usual suspects: raw milk cheese, honey, raw meat, etc.) should be fine. Just try some different foods and see how it goes! 😉
We had great success with soft french fries, pretzels and pasta in the beginning. If your baby isn't interested yet or doesn't like it, pause for a week and then try again.
This is very helpful, thank you!
Thank you for this video! I love my spectra too but it’s hard to get tied down to a pump every 3 hours of the day. I can’t afford to buy the “wrong one” so this is very helpful :) 👏🏼👏🏼
Thank you, Great video! Do you still plan to make the other videos showing how to set them up? If you so can you also show how you care for them as well please
Which spectra do you like the most?
S2
Thanks for sharing! My husband and I have been TTC for a few months now so I'm doing any and ALL research, while I have the time! Hahah Hope you had a wonderful holiday!
I did the same and have to rewatch everything because pregnancy brain haha
I recommend making a baby playlist of the videos you like so you can rewatch if you need to. Baby dust to you guys!
Sounds like our brains work the same way. Best of luck and all the baby dust to you!
Have you conceived yet? I would try and focus on that first. One day at a time…blessings and good luck 🍀
Thank you for making this video
Hi! I had a spectra from my previous pregnancy. The last time I used it was 2 years ago. Do you think I can continue to use it alternating with a new Elvie? So I don’t have to buy 2 new pumps. Or does a spectra go bad by time ? I’m talking about the motor only but I’m definitely gonna buy new supplies( tubing, bottles, flanges.. etc)
Sure you can! Where I live there is a service provided by pharmacies to rent an electric breast pump. If that's safe, you should be fine. 😉👍
@@saschamayer4050 thank you so much for your response
Hi! I got a spectra 2 3 yrs ago and just had a baby and it works like it’s brand new. I got the caracups now and use them with my spectra. Hope this helps!
I felt the same way ... I love my spectra as well when I was breastfeeding I felt the willow pump was a waste of money I had to keep calling & even had to replace mine
Hi ! You made my morning with the Willow and Elvie. I’m a new mommy to be 16 weeks today and I’m doing my research about breast pumping because I want to breast bump as long as I can. I’m freaking out with the shortage of formula and scared that I might not produce breast milk. What are suggestions or guide you have on producing/keeping breast milk to keep follow coming ? and my second question/concern which spectra pump do you use or recommend ?
Oh hun, don’t stress. I breastfed my son for 19 months without ever needing to supplement with formula. Drinking enough water is major! I drank 4 litres a day. I also continued taking my prenatal vitamins with dha for baby’s brain development. In the beginning I would pump for 15 minutes after I nursed my little guy so my milk came in in an abundance! Nutritional eating is a major factor as well. Sleep also impacts milk production, we co-slept and my breasts were readily available so I would barely even have to wake up to nurse (I’m a light sleeper). You got this hun, your body will know what to do
What were the pump model specific names? I'm considering the Elvie Stride but I'm wondering what these two models were.
Its 4am and my wife wants this to make her life easier lol
Good luck everyone
Thank you for being so supportive within your family dynamic!!! This is my first time seeing that a man actually watched a video like this in the name of his wife!!!!
What did you do regarding the Elvie flange sizes ?
I love watching y’all. Sarah you’re so down to earth and beautiful! Thank you for doing this for us! I so trust your opinion!
Super helpful. Thanks so much !!
Very helpful! I give this advice to be helpful, try to replace the word "um" with silence.
Great review! Idk why anyone would buy the willow in general, but especially after watching this! If you’re gonna pay $500 for a pump, it may as well be the Elvie and not all the cons that Willow has.
I loved my willow! I was literally able to demo a deck with a crowbar while I pumped. She also ignores that it’s really easy to reuse the bags, so you don’t actually need new bags for each pumping session. The Willow isn’t perfect, but it’s the best option for people who need a truly closed system
Yaaaaay! I found your September 2020 TTC video. I just had to search for most recent. Woohoooo! Congratulations 🎉🎈🎊
I'm in my first trimester and after seeing everything is going well at my first ultrasound I'm letting myself start to plan. I'm big on making lists, even lists of lists I need to make haha. I work from home, get 3 months of paid leave, and really am motivated to breastfeed. I like the idea of a hands free option but at $500 I think I'd like to know breastfeeding will work for me and understand my supply before making that kind of investment. Do you think it's necessary to have a pump ready for when you get home from the hospital?
Speaking from my recent experience, having some type of pump helps because it lets you see if your milk has come and how much you can get. I wish someone told me to get a pump because for 4 days, my poor baby was starving as I thought I was “nursing” without realizing my milk hadn’t come. I’d nurse for good 40 minutes and would put the baby down thinking the baby had enough milk when in fact, I barely had any. I so wish someone mentioned to pump so I could see how much I’m giving the baby. Even a hand held manual pump works if your intending on using it just for few days for measuring purposes.
@@tanazakbar831 thank you for the advice, that's really helpful. I was looking at the haakaa to start with. I hope all ended up working out for you and baby.
Honestly I would try to get my milk to come in by pumping around the time of my due date. If you're ready it helps labor begin and also it'll allow you to start developing colostrum before the baby arrives.
I had the opposite problem and my milk can in really heavy making me too full and it hard for my baby to latch. So having a pump available to release some of the pressure was really helpful
@@tanazakbar831 although it's important to note thty your baby usually will get more from you than the pump can from you because the baby is more efficient. If you are following a feeding with a pump it just makes sure you were empty and you can see how much was left, but if you're replacing a feeding it's not a great measure. Also one way to tell if baby is getting anything while they are nursing is to listen for swallows, but the only way to know for sure how much they were able to get from you is to go to an IBCLC and do a weighted feed.
Thank you for the informative video! Watching this back, it looks like there’s a bump/lump in her neck or thyroid area?
What are your thoughts on the new Elvie pump which is covered under insurance?
It's called the stride
Hello Doctors 🌷🌷🌷I’d like to ask you more professional opinions: How to return body shape and tone after pregnancy .
When it’s better to start , what exactly work well what is dangerous to do . About food etc )
Thank you)!
Correction: You can change the suction level from the Willow 3.0 app so you don't have to go under your shirt to adjust it.
Another con of the Willow is that the bags are just awkward. The weird round shape is hard to store, the label's writing area is very small, and they are difficult to pour milk out of.
Hello
Doctor. Thank you for your videos. Quick question I am all about being as natural as possible. Pregnant with baby number two and been thinking about using a wearable
breast pump. However, someone brought up on a blog I was reading the danger of possible being exposed to EMFs. What are your thoughts on that? ty in advanced
How do you know if you’re emptying completely?
Hello! Thanks so much for your super helpful videos! I am an outpatient pediatrician, and I was wondering if you find that the Elvie is leak free when actually moving around to examine a patient or is it more for typing notes at a desk? How about when wrangling a toddler for a COVID swab? 😂 Thanks!!
Very helpful!
The pump that I like useing is lashionh breast pump and I tryed medela but didn't like it
Great video !
How long does the battery life last for the Elvie and the Willow? I plan on using one of these for 3-3.5 hour time intervals in between my breaks at my 12 hour work shifts
Hi Dr., are you open to donating your Willow, seeing that you don't use them anymore? I'll pay for shipping :)
It’s a personal item. It’s like asking someone to donate you their toothbrush. I would personally not accept such a gift. But to each their own, I guess…
Question:is it safe to buy a breast pump used.
Hey Dr Sarah... how old is your baby now and are you still pumping? If not when did you stop? I have 3 month old and just got back to work...
Very useful
Is there an emf radiation from the Bluetooth?
What are some Facebook support groups can I join ? I am in my second trimester
can I use my Elvie and then a manual breast pump to empty all the milk from breasts? I cant afford a traditional pump and a portable one
Is it painful ? And is it pumps good?
Is this good for girls who are double DD?
Hi! Thank you for taking the time to create these videos! I have learned so much. Quick question about the booster vaccine and first trimester. I am 6 weeks pregnant and worried about the potential for high fever if I get the booster vaccine during my first trimester. Is there any evidence indicating that waiting (and quarintining😎) until 2nd trimester to get the booster (or any vaccine) shot could mitigate against potential harm from vaccine immune response fever? Thank you! (And as always, I plan to consult my OB😊)
Hi, I’m 20 weeks now, but I got my booster at 16 weeks. I spoke with my midwife because I had a high fever with the second shot. We decided to wait till the second trimester and I was fine. The side effects were a lot less severe with the booster thankfully Speak with your OB or midwife and get their advice!
I’m not a dr but from what my midwife told me and from what I’ve seen recommended in their videos there’s no reason to wait IF you have a chance of being exposed to covid. Otherwise waiting till your second trimester is fine.
I didn’t have any reaction to my first two shots (only a little sore where the shot was given) so it could depend on your body too.
If you felt very ill or had a high fever with the first two shots that’s when I would wait personally. But remember too people get sick and have fevers all the time and still have healthy babies. I think it goes off of your risk of exposure and comfort level. I didn’t want to do anything for the first trimester but sleep haha.
Good luck!
There’s no increased risk that’s been seen from these vaccines to babies at any time during pregnancy.
If it makes you feel better to isolate and wait until later in pregnancy, you can do that, but we would recommend to our loved ones not to wait given the increased risks of COVID to women who are pregnant. - the best way to keep baby healthy is to keep mom healthy.
@@TheDoctorsBjorkman I hated when our OBGYN told us this as if there have been years of the proper studies done. NOBODY TRULY KNOWS. So to tell all these mothers there aren’t any possible side effects and you should just take it should be a crime. Get back to me when all of these babies turn 10>15>18, when these mothers have 2 more babies after their boosters, when there aren’t literally drastic side affects in the beginning stages of the vaccine.
Irresponsible….
Have you been checked for goiter? Your neck looks so swollen. Not trying to be rude maybe it’s just a shadow but it’s the concerned nurse in me with a family history of thyroid issues😬
I noticed that too..
I also noticed this. Hoping someone at her work can take a look for her!
You all have a great eye!! I totally have a thyroid nodule!! I’ve had it drained a couple times (it’s benign) but the dumb thing keeps re-accumulating so I’m probably gonna end up having it removed here eventually. Thank you so much for saying something-it’s so nice to have our RUclips fam lookin out for us too!!❤️
@@TheDoctorsBjorkman hope all goes well 🙏🏻💛
How do you check to see if you’re empty??
Thanks for this video. I have tried one wearable breast pump and I hated it. It made my boobs bleed, but it was one I got off Amazon for around $60. But I more than anything wanted to be able to pump without taking off my shirt.
Any thoughts on the WillowGo?
A lactation specialist told me the motor only really lasts during the warranty and there are issues after the warranty.
Could you guys do a video on sterilization for newborns? My nephew was just born and man is there a lot of different info out there
Soap and hot water is more than adequate as long as you have clean water where you live.
Everything else isn’t necessary, just maybe givens people piece of mind.
imagine if men where to breastfeed..then maybe the breast-pump industri would have realistic pricing for wearable breast pumps. Would love to try one, but the price puts me off. Great video btw, I really enjoyed it.
They would be able to play contact sports with them I’m sure 🙄😂
I’m a little late here telling you, but you can usually qualify for a free one through your insurance.
Do you think these work if you’re a bigger chested mama?
My sister in law used the Elvie (I don’t know which model) and it didn’t work for her. She was larger chested when her milk came in and they wouldn’t stay on or she just wouldn’t get hardly anything out. She has an amazing supply and hasn’t had any issues with other pumps.
Curious about most recent data on co-sleeping and what the science says
I’ve got the Elvie breast pump and can’t wait to use them once my baby is here xxx
Doing a c section while wearing a pump is not a issue with sterility?
Can you use the ellie without apps?
yes😊
Love your content! Could you do a video on sleep training?
This is a great (and challenging) topic. We found TakingCaraBabies to be incredibly helpful for us. It maybe a bit until we get around to make a video ourselves on this, so please check out her stuff. It’s great!