GIMME SHELTER | Lisa Fischer, Sasha Allen, Merry Clayton | who is your favorite? | Rolling Stones
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 окт 2024
- The Rolling Stones - Gimme Shelter
Merry Clayton (Let It Bleed - 1989)
Lisa Fischer (Paradiso - 1995)
Sasha Allen (Havana moon - 2016)
The original for me. Sister Merry Clayton. 🎼🎵🎶
I respect all the ladies, but Lisa took it to another level. I have seen her single-handedly tear apart a stage like nobody’s business. This woman’s got a set of pipes on her. ☝🏻🌎🎤🔥
Merry Clayton only
Sasha is really good but Lisa is incomparable.
Tu l'a dit bouffi Miss Lisa est la déesse de la beauté féminine !
Merry Clayton is the one and only Gimme Shelter lady. Lisa Fischer is legendary. Sasha Allen is a worthy successor to these two ladies.
Merry the original version on Let It Bleed. When her voice CRACKS and Mick can be heard “yeah”. Ah just glorious. That album set me on fire at 12🤪
Yes it’s the crack in her voice that has me!
Ever and forever 👉Lisa💥❤️💥
Miss Merry Clayton of coarse. The one and only. The Queen still reigns supreme.
She was the first And suffered for the art
they're all Phenomenal, but Merry Clayton, without a Doubt is the most important, she brought it home, I've seen Lisa, bless her little heart, is great, and Sasha is incredible, But, Merry without a doubt, and thats the truth, jűs sāyīn !😎✌😎!
MERRY CLAYTON her tone is unique and will always be the one for this song.
No one else can sing like LISA 🔥🙏
Merry Clayton All The Way
Lisa Fischer and her back up band😮
Lisa Fisher to me.
Merry Clayton. The original and the best.
Merry Clayton makes the song. She nails it
Lisa Fisher hands down,her voice is unbelievable 🎶
Only Lisa!!🎉
Merry put this song forever on the map studio-wise but Lisa Fischer has no equal live.
Indeed! Would nobody know Lisa's performance on stage, Merry would be the one and only. She deserves huge respect.
But when you hear and see Lisa on stage (e.g. in G.S. "Official Promo" Live version), she kills the game. Mick and her tune 100% and in my view, her thrilling high note at 3'04" has been equaled by no Gimme Shelter female singer before or after.
[PS. Apologies for my poor English, I'm French]
@@ThierryRobert-hs4qo No Worries I understood everything you said and agree completely.
No Doubt Lisa is the Best.🎤❤
Lisa by far. And she was hot in the 80s and 90s.
merry🥰
All are amazing vocalists. Merry did it first and set the bar. But I think Lisa climbed right over it and kept on climbing....
Love Lisa Fisher 😎🤘🎤
Goddamn girl get it!!!
I’ve always loved Lisa Fisher awesome girl
Lisa since I have seen her live so many times. Really enjoy her performances. I respect all the ladies though. Amazing singers.
Merry Clayton
my favorite Lisa Fisher
To be honest I like them all but Lisa has a fantastic singing voice. Thanks Ed
Ed’s got a great new Chanel check it out. ✌🏻☝🏻🌎
@EdBLive ✌🏻
@@naomi8529 hi Naomi. Thanks for letting me know. I was having withdrawals 😂. No live events for over a week
@@Trump-rv4nz me too see you soon ☝🏻🌎🎸💃
All of the ladies are outstanding but Sasha Allen at the Havana Moon concert does it for me. Everything about Gimme Shelter, including Sasha, was amazing.
lisa fischer,... her voice was great
LISA FOR EVER!!!!!
Lisa Lisa Lisa Lisa forever
Mary's part on that song was the single best vocal part ever recorded.
Lisa, Lisa,Lisa and Lisa! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Lisa Fischer
1. Merry,
2. Lisa,
3. Sasha
1. Chanel Haynes
2. Lisa
3. Merry
4. Sasha
Paradiso✌️💯👍🔥🔥🔥🔥🎤🎤🎤🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥.... Amazing show
3 girl masterpice
LISA THE ONE AND ONLY
Merry Clayton ! It's a no brainer
You have an excellent sense of vocal talent and common sense. A time in music history that can’t be replicated
Lisa Fisher! The one and only! It’s not about comparing these ladies. It's about pulling the trigger on me. I saw the Stones in '98 in Düsseldorf/Germany. Jagger dancing around her, she kickin' off one of her 👠! She swung her leg onto one of the monitor’s on stage, and made Mick lick her toe’s! 🔥‼️Rumor is Jerry Hall was not amused……🤣
Lisaaaaaaaa❤
This is Merry’s song, end of discussion
1997 Metrodome concert Lisa Fischer got a standing ovation for her rendition. Glorious AF! But, I'm old school and I have to go with Merry Clayton.
LIIIIIISSSSSSSSAAAAAAAAA
Lisa is the best! I missen her so much
the one and only 🥁📸 Lisa Fischer 🎉🎊 ♂️🔥
*PS: Merry Clayton 💎
These performance choices may have been unfair to Sasha but, based on these, its not even close. Lisa takes it. She is phenomenal. I think Merry Clayton might even envy her performance.
Paradiso Amsterdam best performance 👌
I Love Lisa's voice. Merry Clayton still does it for me. Thanks Ed for all three!
Sasha Allen!
Merry!!!!
Lisa Fisher thé best
How in the world is this even up for question. Merry is the one and only hello!
And throw Carol Kenyon from MJ’s solo tour of Australia in 1988. . Beats nearly every version cept for Merry of course. . Oh while you’re at it, go find ‘Rockwiz’ version with Tim Rogers and Linda Bull. . Absolutely sensational !
LISA
LIsa RULES
Todas ❤
Lisa!
Marry Clayton, sure
Lisa Fischer💐💐💐without a doubt
Love them all!
Saaaaashaaaa. I live for Lisa too❤️
Gotta give it to the original, one and only Merri Clayton.
Merry set the bar. Enough said.
Lisa Fischer 💖💖💖
Lisa Fischer hands down
Merry is Momma, Lisa is the child. Love them both
Lisa mit wunderbarer Stimme...✌👏👌🎶🎼
Total respect given to these ladies … Lord, Merry is The Song ! Lisa absolutely did Merry Great !!!!!! Sasha …. Not There …..
Mick and crew dropped the back up on this one .
Merry set the bar for this. It's great that she inspired these other singers, but they're just trying to copy her. This is all about Merry.
1 Merry 2 Lisa very close 3 Sasha very far
I love it one of the greatest songs of all times thank you brother
merry indubbiamente
❤❤❤❤❤
Mick Taylor's guitar solo in the live show 1972/73
Die Gesamtshow ist hier genial...
Gotta go with the original: sing it Merry!
Chanel Haynes!
She was very good
This is a great hit!!!
Merry Clayton by a mile
Lisa in the 90s, Sasha this days.
Merry Clayton then Lisa Fischer. Merry Clayton did those vocals in one take, eight months pregnant, curlers and a mink coat. None of them had ever met, she killed it!!
Lisa by far.
When Lisa come that not like Rolling stone and band But it like Lisa band❤❤
It's Merry Clayton's song.
On the Steel Wheels tour Cindy Mizelle took turns with Lisa on the Gimme Shelter solo part, I am guessing the 2 chicks on the Urban Jungle portion did the same
Yes I forgot to include Lorelei McBroom, who sang this part during the Urban Jungle Tour
Sophia Jones didn't sing this part eventough she also was the backing vocalist on this tour
@@EdBmusic1 There was also a good singer on Mick's 1988 solo concerts (though Mick sang it poorly at the time).
It should be noted that Sasha is a Soprano and has high notes, too. She and Lisa have sung together (really beautifully, I might add). Sasha chooses not to attempt to copy her. Sasha is more on that Beyonce vibe.
Why chose just one?!?!😋
Lisa on stage, but Merry is the original.
Lisa excelente y Sasha muy bien pero como que no se anima a soltar la voz !
Neither of them‼Give me Mick Taylor‼Full stop‼
Merry Clayton wrote the rule book. Lisa Fischer ripped it up.
Lisa for the win.
The current singer, Chanel Haynes (2024), is respectable but nowhere near Lisa or even Merry.
What utter bullshit, they are all great or they wouldn't have gotten the gig !!
You people voting for Lisa just don’t get it.
todas son excelentes pero la presentación de Lisa es demasiadoooooooo buena
All three ladies are bad mfers. Each one brought something special. Pure fire 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Merry Clayton