New or Used: 2021 Perodua Ativa vs 2015 Honda HR-V Comparison Review in Malaysia | WapCar
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 июл 2024
- For the price of a brand new 2021 Perodua Ativa (RM 72,000), you can fetch yourself a good used car like the 2015 Honda HR-V pre-facelift.
A HR-V has much more practical appeal to the family man. It’s spacious, comfortable and refined. The Ativa on the other hand offers an arsenal of technologies such as turbo engine, full suite of ADAS and a new platform.
How would you pick? Let Jason break it down for you.
Download WapCar’s official app on Google Playstore now: wapcar.onelink.me/spIk?pid=yo...
_____________________________________________
Quick Specs:
2021 Perodua Ativa
Engine: 1KR-VET 1.0-litre 3-cylinder turbo petrol
Power: 98 PS & 140 Nm
Transmission: CVT automatic
0 - 100 km/h: 13.2 seconds (as tested)
Fuel Consumption: 7.9L/100 km (as tested)
Price: RM 72,000 (OTR without insurance & SST)
Read More: www.wapcar.my/long-term-test-...
Quick Specs:
2015 Honda HR-V 1.8 V
Engine: R18Z9 1.8L 4-cylinder i-VTEC
Power: 142 PS & 172 Nm
Transmission: CVT automatic
0 - 100 km/h: 10.9 seconds (claimed)
Top Speed: N/A
Price: RM 60,000 - 80,000 (used price)
Read More: www.wapcar.my/cars/honda/hr-v
Read More: www.wapcar.my/cars/honda/hr-v
_____________________________________________
Intro: 00:00
Ativa Exterior Design: 00:40
HR-V Exterior Design: 01:55
Ativa Boot Space: 02:39
HR-V Boot Space: 03:20
Ativa Interior Design: 03:59
Ativa Rear Legroom: 04:35
HR-V Interior Design: 05:07
HR-V Rear Legroom: 05:50
HR-V Ultra Seats: 06:36
Ativa Engine Performance: 07:02
Ativa Ride Comfort: 08:16
HR-V Driving Performance: 10:08
Conclusion: 10:4
----------------------------Follow Us----------------------------
Website www.wapcar.my/
Facebook: / wapcar.my
Instagram: / wapcar.my
Shot by: Furqan Nazhif
Edited by: Furqan Nazhif ( / uhhhfinnnnn )
Host: Jason Ngion ( / jpngion )
#PeroduaAtiva #HondaHRV 
Авто/Мото
Don't know why people are laughing about the comparison, this is exactly what i was thinking actually, whether to get new Ativa or 2nd hand HRV. Thanks for the comparison, very clear pros and cons. The HRV is still a value proposition, especially if you get at least one year warranty left, so you can get everything checked and covered before it's over.
Another thing to note: this gen HRV price might drop more when the new Vezel comes into the market. Might be a good bargain for a 2017-18 HRV in 2022 if the timing works out for someone out there.
@@ndt2046 Hope you found it helpful! Yes when the new-generation replacement model comes in, used car prices may dip
i agree. hrv still very compelling simply due to its packaging especially in its usage of space. the ultra seats is just too good and its 2nd row deceivingly spacious. Boot space iinm is still class leading.
Ativa vs Hrv? Im more impress with his vocabulary range, he is really wise with his words. Thanks for the review.
finally there's a comparison video that I would thought up sometimes, thumbs up
Hi Jason. An excelent piece. A friend actually used yr video to decide on purchase. Best wishes for more value output. Hey .. your lingo is class man.
This is a fresh view on car purchase, I like it, instead of the usual which new car to get
LOL alot of comment says this is joke comparison not fair lah different segment lah that why Wapcar use "2nd hand HRV" instead of new one that cost RM105K price tag ...btw this is good comparison between lower segment NEW car (Ativa) vs upper segment but "USED"... HRV is more refined due to 4 cylinder 1.8 N/a engine & more practical. used market around RM70K + if u really don't mind used car and active safety feature yeah HRV is worth to considered
Very good comparison. I happen to be considering the exact car models. I'm more likely to get the hrv after this video. My sons are kinda tall so the taller head space and leg space will come in handy.
Very Good Comparison , Thanks a lot 👍✌️
nice review jason :) good comparison to a secondhand car!
He comparing New ativa with used HRv. Not comparing based on pricing but so we see an option on the same price range. I actually looking for this kind of video.
Hope you found it helpful!
how about the height of these 2 cars? Ativa is a more fun to drive especially the fully adaptive headlight. really love it. it makes my night driving experience really comfortable and relaxing. also DNGA really help rear passenger prevent wobbling feel which i experienced severely in my friend's hrv. my ativa driving experience reminded me the feel of my old camry.
I did the exact comparison last two months. ended up with ativa. One of the main reason, is the interest rate. much2 higher for a 6 years old car, at 3.5-3.8 PA compared to new ones at 2.34 PA. And, i havent got any luck with proper maintaned specimen of HRV. I aint going that TLC journey yet once again like my e39, coz i dont love HRV that much. :P
Very good comparison review that i was looking for :) I was driving HRV for 6years now, when Ativa came out, I had a crazy idea to get the Ativa, but seriously the space killing me, it can't fit in my 2-meter long working equipment, my HRV when full load it looks like a pasar malam stall and ready to go, but the maintenance fee is the bigger challenge for an older car
Hi Sir, if u mind.. How's the maintenance and quality of the HRV?
I saw a lot of complaints regarding this car
@@SyhaDan Actually, I had lots of bad experiences with their service
1. I remember once my hrv can't start and stuck at Jalan tun Razak in the midnight, the car was 2 years old, so I make a few calls to the honda 1800 helpline but the line looks like under maintenance can't get through, this makes me super mad on them, lucky the parking jockey help me to jumpstart. after the event, I write an email to them this will be the last honda I brought with them. I think maybe now they have improved their service? haha
2. When i get the car, got a funny "beezee" sound at the speaker area, after switching 4 service centres, final they found is the petrol cap open handle loosen cause the "beezee" sound while driving :)
3. the boot actually getting loosen after a few years, I had to buy a screwdriver to tighten the hock, lucky someone accidentally hit my car boot, now I got a new one :)
I brought a low spec HRV, the car itself is actually a very good car, you got a space that can fit 2 durian baskets side by side while the chair flat, still got space at the boot, a magical chair can fold up to fit in 1.2meter tripod, full load long journey no problem, super fuel-efficient, very robust, quality car brake and stability control saving me a lot of time.
I am quite heavy use, reaching 10k every 3 months, maintenance with honda service a bit expensive, i went outside workshop after finish the warranty, now i feel that condition still good.
The car was good but the after-sale cause you headache :) haha
@@Caskep03275 Thank You Sir, In terms of practical it is definitely the car to buy
I'm aiming at 2nd hand Hrv myb 2015 or 2017 since 2016 n 2018 models have recall... I will take your advice
My worry is only the reliability regarding this car, If bought 2nd hand... I was hoping that I can get 10 years, kinda worry on that part
I read some guy has problem with cvt transmission ngam2 after warranty finish
This is good comparison, im from Jakarta and daihatsu rocky VS 2nd hand hrv are in the same price
When talk about a family with two kids, it would be good if you can show two child seats are installed and compare the rear seats spaces.
Ya, since is about family with kids. I presume they will make an effort to see how easy to install the car seats and if two child seats are fitted on each side, can a adult sit in the middlem row. I I thought WAP car is all about the details?
In the process of adding to our reviews!
My mom has HRV, my aunt have BMW 3 series E90 and I have Ativa. Of course the older BMW has best driving experience, HRV second, and Ativa third. But I am really happy with Ativa for its new affordable price (same price as stupid Nissan Almari years ago) and good driving experience, safety features and practical space. But oh how I wish Ativa has magic seats like HRV which is really practical!
How's the HRV bro? I'm thinking of getting 2nd... I like the Ativa but space wise not so much
Could you comments their NVH for both cars?
Safety-wise Ativa win, since we're talking as family man..
Family man drive in safety mode....no depend on ADAS
Yeap, but practicality and comfort are also big consideration
Great comparison and this is what it miss on most of the other vehicle media platform. For me at least from the consumer standpoint, most of the time is not about what is the class of the car or maybe which segment of the car or whether it is a SUV or sedan car or even the car is new or not. It is more about what can I get for this budget. Brilliant Video. Thanks Jason!
Glad you found it helpful!
Well, if i have the money/budget, surely i'll think of the new ativa & the used hrv as options if i want to buy a new car.. maintenance wise, maybe i choose the ativa..
Yeap, 5 years warranty and no need to replace major parts in the first few years
As long as they fixed the infamous suspension problems, HRV with the ULTRA seat is far more practical
It is really worth the second hand car trouble or just get a new car?
Those who are a big fan of boxy, manly car like the Jimny, will definitely go for the Ativa :)
it’s not manly it’s cute
Pre facelift HRV V Spec seat's are far more comfortable than the Facelift V and RS specs seats in my opinion. The seat's have more support, cushion and the half leather half cloth vs full PU leather adds to the general comfort. The only up for the face lift V and RS is the electric adjustable driver's seat.
Clearly people who dont get this comparison is not in the market for it... if someone really contemplating between this 2, i believe this video helps them in choosing the right one... to be honest how many time we look for segment when buying a car as a real world user? All we care is the price and is it worth it...
"Real-world user" is the keyword here, we like that. Glad you found this video helpful!
Nice and wise ideas comparison..
Probably the only channel to compare used Japanese car vs new Perodua? This channel understands consumers. Love this new guy Jason.
Thank you for the recognition!
from these 2 comparisons, i chose ativa
As a new car- i go 4 ativa. Atleast for next 5years i lm free frm nonsense hassle frm a 2nd car.
Just wanna know… is llumar tinted perform well? 😃
So far, no complaints haha. Does it's job perfectly 😄
@Jason Ngion Eh not cooling enough la 😂 -Adrian
Go for honda, although it’s a used car, you will get honda quality.
If you’re a family man who love yours family, how can you forego safety features found in the Ativa that aren’t in the HRV. Surely your family’s safety rates higher than selfish driving pleasure
Becouse he is smart driver...not depend on ADAS system...family man always drive as family man....
While we agree that safety features and ADAS are great to have. But family space and comfort are also top considerations for buyers.
any car that has electric stability control will be good enough already actually, your perception about safety feature is shaped by the commercial and advertisement, so that they can upsell their cars above their competitor brands
I was considering exactly this option several months ago. I've owned 2 Hondas before, 1 had a cvt failure and had to be scrapped. In the end I chose the Ativa, I've never bought a second hand car before and maybe that's why lol. In comparison, the Ativa has more fancy gadgets and displays too. The HRV is still an older gen car with analog dials and barely any equipment.
What should I get between the new Ativa and current Honda HRV? Which one is worth in term of value. Please assist.
If I had more money it is ok to go for hrv. But i will choose ativa as it is affordable for the budget.
HRV seems good though. But.. Of course.. It's used car, 5-6 years.. There's lot of risks need to reassess for maintenance.
after 6 year got sound sana sini...im hrv user too just let go it...before price going down too low
@@fuyongkit932 what car u pick next? And the reason for picking that car?
I'm not sure am I the only one disturbed with those "right" word in almost every single sentence.. nonetheless, it is a good video indeed..
As a family man, with 2 kids also, between the HRV and Ativa, I'll choose the Toyota 86.
😂
please do something to your app
Apologies! Our development team is working on the updates & fixes!
Here's the think....Honda is smart at not giving tons of features like ADAS , blind spot monitoring and many more like the Ativa so that Consumers won't have any issue on the long run....this is why Honda's are rated the best car brand ever....no doubt about it
The HR-V came out in 2015 where ADAS is still not mainstream yet
Hrv engine is more refine and smooth compare to Activa...even it is used car
Well "if" you found the problem-free hrv. There's a reason why people selling car, most of the reason is there's a problem.
Agreed, the engine is very refined
4 year old HRV with 1 year warranty is far better than new ativa. Its in the name bro, HRV (high resale value)
More like High rubbish vague ride.
Ops ativa also same rubbish ride
LOL first time we've seen this acronym 😂
@@hdbsg3.5At RM 72,000, nothing else rides better than the Ativa. The HR-V has softer damping for family buyers.
RIGHT RIGHT RIGHT 😁
Of course buy a new car. Go for Ativa.
Of course hrv la, king of compact crossover in the country...feeling wise, all aspects ticked without any struggle or drama...the ativa is so bad, until it makes the mediocre hrv looks good btw..can search n study by urself for honest comparison~ I didn't own any but have test driven them several times, so i m just stating fact of my personal experience n preference~ cheers...
i dont think it is a relevant comparison... i will tell you why:
1) comparison of the build quality for RM70K cars vs RM100K car totally out of league. regardless its is new or used. eg: bmw year 1999 build quality still better than proton saga..
2) you just played with the car prices but you forgotten to mention that the interest for new & used car have very huge gaps, not to mention that there is a tax holiday for new car.
Need to improve on your presentation sir. Stop saying 'right' at the end of each sentence. Sounds like you keep asking the viewers to agree with u the whole video. Anyway, the comparison is quite good n not irrelevant as other comments here may suggest.
Agree Wei
After he sold his 2015 HR-V he will get another SUV 2021. But definitely not Ativa because both 2 different segment. For this segment HR-V segment and price above Rm100k+ got so many choice la.
2015 hrv poor resale value, bank market value Rm40k-Rm50k, used car dealers is taking less that it
Really? I can't hardly find one below 50k
@@ndt2046 bank and dealers took that car below rm50K then sell it back for 60-70K
Review bring ppl to Holland
Im 2015 hrv owner for me pick ativa for the almost same price new car....👍
Please give us a feedback for 2015 Hrv, lately Honda Malaysia CKD has QC issue, so I'm bit worried
Good review, right?
Family car of course buy Exora😆
haha
Honda HRV just way too old to compare with newest car nowadays..
but still it is causing dilema already in choosing vs brand new Activa hahaha
2015 model is only 6 years old, shorter than most loan tenures in Malaysia
Ativa better
First lol
U sound bias😂😂
You sound bias
Ativa is bandwagon... literally bandwagon... SUV bandwagon...
Joker making joke comparison , Adrian know ativa more well than this guy