@RAATCC36 Yes the ladies behind her sing the words of the quando m'en vo', it was staged that way.. she is kind of a celebrity in that staging so I think it was intended that way!
Sorry I posted my comment before the end of the video... Puccini is my favorite composer (I'd sell my parents for Tosca performed at la Scala) and Musetta one of my favorites roles and arias... For some reasons as lovely as she is, I didn't find Natalie great in that role, even the interpretation was a bit (in my humble opinion) trop travaillee... I saw musetta being plus legere, moins drole, plus sarcastique.... What did u think? and her about her voice in the role too?
qui est le directeur en ce momet car ce n est plus Gerard Mortier ?et le directeur technique est ce toujours Gilles Modolo ou est ce Jurgen Hoffer ? merci en tous ca c'est tres beau et tres interessant merci M
C'est vrai ca? Et puis je me demande si vous meme vous l avez deja rencontree! Je vis a NYC et regarde souvent vos videos d'elle sur youtube. Meme si je suis pas forcement ok avec votre pseudo, lol, J'espere qu'elle vous a au moins envoyee des chocolats!!! Regards, M
Not than I am a big fan of Callas (at least not in everything and certainly not in musetta), but you should check on youtube the Juilliard Master Class Callas give about the role! She just understood the libretto, the score, the role perfectly. And since Dessay is such a fan she should have checked it out too. LOOOL. You could still change your nickname you know.... Take off "best". Thanks for the link to Esti's blog btw...
Wow, that's totallya shame about the lady behind her mouthing the words. I wonder if it was staged that way for some reason. Weird. Anyway it toally detracts from Natalie. Anyways, Dessay sounds great as usual : )
Mi, preciosa, chica, Natalie Dessay, este, montaje experimental, oscuro, mata, la magia, del final, del segundo Atto, Es, el, carnaval, la, locura, los, celos, de Marcelo, con, muerta, esta, ópera, se desarrolla, en, el, barrio, latino, en, París, Natalie, maravillosa, giancarlo del Mónaco al, igual, que maríe Terese kaufmann - yo -, opinamos, igual, y el teizier, un, impresentable, ebrio, drogado, y sin ganas de trabajar!!!
Mimi-type of voice? You must be joking I hope. She has no middle notes, no low notes ... One of the reasons why she has totally destroyed her voice. However here, although the voice is certainly not for her either, she is marvellous. And she's such a splendid actress.
this was totally magical indeed and nothing is more appropriate than Esti's words : the very second she gets into the scene, everything becomes real.
Wish I could see the whole performance !!! Natalie !!! The best !!!!
too bad shes retired shes great!
beautiful
mai piu!!!!!!♥0♥
@RAATCC36 Yes the ladies behind her sing the words of the quando m'en vo', it was staged that way.. she is kind of a celebrity in that staging so I think it was intended that way!
Bravo Madame
What is with the ladies in the back mouthing the words?
Sorry I posted my comment before the end of the video... Puccini is my favorite composer (I'd sell my parents for Tosca performed at la Scala) and Musetta one of my favorites roles and arias... For some reasons as lovely as she is, I didn't find Natalie great in that role, even the interpretation was a bit (in my humble opinion) trop travaillee... I saw musetta being plus legere, moins drole, plus sarcastique.... What did u think? and her about her voice in the role too?
qui est le directeur en ce momet car ce n est plus Gerard Mortier ?et le directeur technique est ce toujours Gilles Modolo ou est ce Jurgen Hoffer ?
merci en tous ca c'est tres beau et tres interessant merci
M
C'est vrai ca? Et puis je me demande si vous meme vous l avez deja rencontree! Je vis a NYC et regarde souvent vos videos d'elle sur youtube. Meme si je suis pas forcement ok avec votre pseudo, lol, J'espere qu'elle vous a au moins envoyee des chocolats!!! Regards, M
Not than I am a big fan of Callas (at least not in everything and certainly not in musetta), but you should check on youtube the Juilliard Master Class Callas give about the role! She just understood the libretto, the score, the role perfectly. And since Dessay is such a fan she should have checked it out too. LOOOL. You could still change your nickname you know.... Take off "best". Thanks for the link to Esti's blog btw...
나탈리 드세가 성대 수술 이후 높은 고음을 요하는 배역을 절제했더라면 리릭 레제로 소프라노로서 푸치니나 베르디의 작품도 개성 있게 소화해냈을텐데, 아쉬움이 남습니다.
Wow, that's totallya shame about the lady behind her mouthing the words. I wonder if it was staged that way for some reason. Weird. Anyway it toally detracts from Natalie. Anyways, Dessay sounds great as usual : )
Rachel Stewart Singing I thought so too. So weird.
Mi, preciosa, chica, Natalie Dessay, este, montaje experimental, oscuro, mata, la magia, del final, del segundo Atto, Es, el, carnaval, la, locura, los, celos, de Marcelo, con, muerta, esta, ópera, se desarrolla, en, el, barrio, latino, en, París, Natalie, maravillosa, giancarlo del Mónaco al, igual, que maríe Terese kaufmann - yo -, opinamos, igual, y el teizier, un, impresentable, ebrio, drogado, y sin ganas de trabajar!!!
N. Dessay as Musette? Interesting casting choice.
I thought she (is) was more of a Mimi~type.
TB Franci Dessay doesnt have the voice for that.. hell, she is barely a Musetta
Mimi-type of voice? You must be joking I hope. She has no middle notes, no low notes ... One of the reasons why she has totally destroyed her voice. However here, although the voice is certainly not for her either, she is marvellous. And she's such a splendid actress.
Her voice is not suited for Verdi or Puccini