Dear Mr Huber... I am neither a musician nor a music critic... just an old lady who happens to appreciate classical piano, and who favors this piece so much she returns to it regularly. If there are "flaws" I don't know about them and don't care. As for your expression, I feel it is totally appropriate and the smile at the conclusion is very well earned. Please post more videos! (Can I put in a plea for some Chopin?)
You are so kind Dear Lady Sheryl. I only wanted to you thank you for your humble comment. It's nice to know that there are still good people in the world. And I’m so sorry about my broken English. 🌸 Goodbye.🌸
I think that the very consistent tempo may have been felt as 'unemotional' by some people, but to me made it feel more powerful and forceful, without sounding overly deliberate.
It depends on what piece you are playing. If it has a "march" feel, like this piece then consistent tempo would be good. But if it very slow and emotional piece, like Barber - Adagio for strings, then it will sound shallow and robotic, like a midi player.
This song to most may be fit for the end of the world, where the villains won and all hope is lost. But I think it represents beauty. This beautiful piece represents beauty... and knowledge... seeing the world evolve in front of our eyes and flowers blooming in the sun...
@@PaulGruendlerBeau to me it conveys the feeling of doing something morally questionable for the benefit of everyone, and in front of those close to you. they know that what you did was right and inevitable, but your relationship with them may never recover.
What a stunning, honest and unaffected performance. Found it by accident, what fortune? Totally generous and devoid of ego on the part of the pianist who only shows any sign of self indulgence with his understated smile at the end. Beautiful, thank you.
What a touching performance. This is my favorite Beethoven piece - I’ve only heard it in an orchestra - never heard it strictly on piano before. You beautifully brought it life. Thank you that. Look forward to hearing your next work. Keep going! You got this 🤜💥 +1 sub
Dude... that Liszt with his brilliant transcription. Can you imagine Liszt listening to the orchestral piece and thinking... "I'm gonna transcribe that for piano and it's gonna be just as powerful as an acoustic single-instrument piece" ? That's why this video is so special. It highlights two powerhouses: Beethoven and Liszt. I think that Balu der Bär knows this as he plays... with his little smile at the end of the performance.
You playing is just perfect, and the steady tempo isn't really a problem. But when it comes to the part somewhere around 3:26, it's written "Marcatissimo", which means it should not be as soft as you play it. Nice job at playing it though!
Uma das peças de Beethoven que mais amo! Brilhantemente ensinada, já que é uma peça das mais difíceis. Todas as vezes que a ouço lágrimas me vêem aos olhos. Parabéns! Muito obrigada pelo vídeo. (portuguese)
I love that put the score at the bottom of the video and that we can see your hands playing the keys. Thanks for making the video and well done for learning that piece
I’m learning this for me first sheet music piece, this is a great reference. I don’t know if I intend to do all the pages but I will try until I want to play something else.
Thank you I have been looking for a beautifull played on piano version of this. I am in love with this piece of music. One day I will get there if it takes me years.
Thanks for the uploader. Beethovens inmense talent... wow! He is speaking about his life, about his feelings, about his thoughts, his beliefs, his victories, his failures. We all have thoughts, beliefs but most men are not gifted with musical prowes like beethoven.
Bereft of status but brimming with purpose, Gabriel gave the angels amassed at the gate of the auditorium one last message before leaving Heaven for the very last time. His arm outstretched, without a word, the people saw. In the silence the message rang out to the far ends of the cosmos.
Very nicely played, with a convincing sense of the overall shape of the piece. Really hard to do. It is a pity that you decided to use sustaining pedal in places where Liszt has deliberately left it out, to imitate the sound of staccato bowings (for instance in the chords in the second bar) and in some places where he marks one melody note tenuto, against the staccato tread, when you pedal through, it loses the contrast between wind and strings.
Great performance. It's been a while since I've been able to sit through and entire youtube vid performance. you captured my attention. Curious is it just me or does that Yamaha sound just like a Steinway? Very close in timbre.
Interesting use of the sustain pedal. The loudness of the marcatissimo section at measure 75 can be a bit distracting with an upright piano, but it seems to me that it is supposed to be very forceful.
Haha I'm in the same situation now. There is a simplified version ( ruclips.net/video/v_olmKUxVw4/видео.html ), which I think I'll learn first. It is not very well played, though. But the video is good for learning. I still think it's a good idea to start off there, but then move to the next level here. Especially for such a beginner piano player as I am.
![Megan Thee Stallion - Neva Play (feat. RM) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TpYTyAaTRts/mqdefault.jpg)
Dear Mr Huber... I am neither a musician nor a music critic... just an old lady who happens to appreciate classical piano, and who favors this piece so much she returns to it regularly. If there are "flaws" I don't know about them and don't care. As for your expression, I feel it is totally appropriate and the smile at the conclusion is very well earned. Please post more videos! (Can I put in a plea for some Chopin?)
You are so kind Dear Lady Sheryl. I only wanted to you thank you for your humble comment. It's nice to know that there are still good people in the world. And I’m so sorry about my broken English. 🌸 Goodbye.🌸
Yeah...that "smile" was 'kick-ass'-as I found myself smiling, too!
Your newest Subscriber-for-life thanks you for your channel!
Bien sûr... pas du tous de la merde pour likes.
I think that the very consistent tempo may have been felt as 'unemotional' by some people, but to me made it feel more powerful and forceful, without sounding overly deliberate.
It depends on what piece you are playing. If it has a "march" feel, like this piece then consistent tempo would be good. But if it very slow and emotional piece, like Barber - Adagio for strings, then it will sound shallow and robotic, like a midi player.
it isn't even that slow. Gould's version is actually slower.... :)
@@Bigblackpiano Gould never played this piece, sadly.
@@AwibaeGibbon You can hear it here: ruclips.net/video/AnS1i9bVGHU/видео.html
@@JeanDavidMoisan this has been confirmed as not him...
My favorite symphonic work of Beethoven. The melody is transcendent and timeless.
Love seeing and hearing my fav Beethoven…..thought the piano duet in the movie Bonfire of the Destiny playing this piece was great!,
the gradual progression up to the climax just feels extremely epic.
Where you from?
This song to most may be fit for the end of the world, where the villains won and all hope is lost. But I think it represents beauty. This beautiful piece represents beauty... and knowledge... seeing the world evolve in front of our eyes and flowers blooming in the sun...
Amen ... Ludwig Van Apocalypse
@@PaulGruendlerBeau to me it conveys the feeling of doing something morally questionable for the benefit of everyone, and in front of those close to you. they know that what you did was right and inevitable, but your relationship with them may never recover.
Great job. I like the editing and the score being visible is a great touch.
Absolutely loved the editing
What a stunning, honest and unaffected performance. Found it by accident, what fortune? Totally generous and devoid of ego on the part of the pianist who only shows any sign of self indulgence with his understated smile at the end. Beautiful, thank you.
Oh, this performance is divine. Right to the end with your smile and relaxation afterwards. What a salute to this work of Beethoven. Many thanks!
I thought it was beautiful and honest playing. I really enjoyed it and noticed your smile at getting through it. Very well played.
Wow, this is now one of my favourites interpretations of this movement.
It is one of best I've heard. The amount of work is obvious. Thank you
I love how you use the sustain pedal on the 1st section. Most pianists don't, and it always sounds a little abrupt to me. Nice!
totally agree
Yes, intentionally ignoring what's written in the score. Very innovative...
@@tonihanemaayer9387 its a piano transcription of a piece composed for violin, so he is being innovative
What a touching performance. This is my favorite Beethoven piece - I’ve only heard it in an orchestra - never heard it strictly on piano before. You beautifully brought it life. Thank you that. Look forward to hearing your next work. Keep going! You got this 🤜💥 +1 sub
Dude... that Liszt with his brilliant transcription. Can you imagine Liszt listening to the orchestral piece and thinking... "I'm gonna transcribe that for piano and it's gonna be just as powerful as an acoustic single-instrument piece" ? That's why this video is so special. It highlights two powerhouses: Beethoven and Liszt. I think that Balu der Bär knows this as he plays... with his little smile at the end of the performance.
You playing is just perfect, and the steady tempo isn't really a problem. But when it comes to the part somewhere around 3:26, it's written "Marcatissimo", which means it should not be as soft as you play it. Nice job at playing it though!
Uma das peças de Beethoven que mais amo! Brilhantemente ensinada, já que é uma peça das mais difíceis. Todas as vezes que a ouço lágrimas me vêem aos olhos. Parabéns! Muito obrigada pelo vídeo. (portuguese)
É tão esperançoso encontrar brasileiros em vídeos como esse.
Amo esse movimento.
Veja pela interpretação da filarmônica de Viena,pelo maestros Cristian Thieleman
Smile at the end says it all. Amazing job, thank you for this!
The smile at the end is for great musician Ludwig van Beethoven... I can feel it :)
I love that put the score at the bottom of the video and that we can see your hands playing the keys. Thanks for making the video and well done for learning that piece
Thank you! I am speechless. What an emotional journey!
Absolutely fantastic piece of music, and I love how you play it on the piano! Sounds absolutely incredible.
POV: you got beaten by a sentient gopro 2 times
Death stains the auditorium.
@@possiblyabear451 POV: your dad didn't read you bible stories tonight and you went edgy
...to be this consistent in tempo throughout this piece is a feat in itself....
What a beautiful performance. I really, really liked the beginning!
A magnificent piece played magnificently by a magnificent pianist. It's definitely harder than my level, but I will still try it...
@The X -files Ναι, αλλά δεν ξέρω αν θα το βγάλω με το τωρινό μου επίπεδο.
@The X -files Η αλήθεια είναι ότι είχα και πανελλήνιες, αλλά ο Liszt είναι πάντα δύσκολος...
I was really touched. It was a great performance.
I’m learning this for me first sheet music piece, this is a great reference. I don’t know if I intend to do all the pages but I will try until I want to play something else.
here before the ultrakill comments start
Thank you I have been looking for a beautifull played on piano version of this. I am in love with this piece of music. One day I will get there if it takes me years.
Thanks for the uploader. Beethovens inmense talent... wow! He is speaking about his life, about his feelings, about his thoughts, his beliefs, his victories, his failures. We all have thoughts, beliefs but most men are not gifted with musical prowes like beethoven.
The pieces never fit together to begin with.
Face it brother, God is dead. The fire is gone. You're chasing phantoms.
Bereft of status but brimming with purpose, Gabriel gave the angels amassed at the gate of the auditorium one last message before leaving Heaven for the very last time.
His arm outstretched, without a word, the people saw. In the silence the message rang out to the far ends of the cosmos.
What?!
Great playing, great sounding piano, great everything!
For some reason, I love this song
Amazing 😍. That was flawless. Great job.
Wonderful performance. Bravo!
You played this beautifully!! Thank you for sharing!
Beautiful, soulful playing. Thank you.
me when i chase phantoms
Very beautiful
Good playing and good video production.
Wonderful performance. I would love to play it as well.
Death stains the auditorium.
"You will never be able to receive the Father's Light! You'll be dead within hours!"
@@lytatroan
"..."
"I know."
TO BE CONCLUDED IN
ACT III GODFIST SUICIDE
Thank you, dear sir. Maestro himself would be happy hearing you play.
Maestro would be happy hearing anything.
@@RodrigoFernandez-td9uk lol
beautiful. played with such expression
Sehr schöne rendition! Danke für's hochladen.
**ultrakilling**
Gabriel is havin a fun time
very lovely playing, im surprised ,my 1st time hearing this transcription
Es lo mas Beethoven que escuché en mi vida.
Uma obra prima
Hi! Ich habe gerade abonniert und will fragen, ob vielleicht nochmal neue Videos kommen? :)
Very well played.
It's not easy to play this Allegretto, beleive me.
I know. It’s difficult 😒
The 3rd moviment has one of the hardest passages ever wrutten
this is an awesome video, excellent editing and remarkable playing, thank you!
this is beautiful
So beautiful
Great editing and perfect sound! This is a recipe for an entertaining and wonderful video. Thank you for making this!
Excellent rendition ~ Thank You for your effort and for uploading!
Beautiful, just fucking beautiful. Thanks for uploading this. 😊
Fantastic
Não sabia que o Peter do Ei Nerd tocava piano. Parabéns!!!
😆
Wunderschoen gespielt. Vielen Dank.
Beautiful execution
Very good job ... ! Thank you for sharing
Beautiful music and very nice audio recording. I wish I had this Yamaha grand instead of my U3...
Very nicely played, with a convincing sense of the overall shape of the piece. Really hard to do. It is a pity that you decided to use sustaining pedal in places where Liszt has deliberately left it out, to imitate the sound of staccato bowings (for instance in the chords in the second bar) and in some places where he marks one melody note tenuto, against the staccato tread, when you pedal through, it loses the contrast between wind and strings.
Very, very well played. Wonderful.
This is an excellent job ! I am impressed !
Very nicely played
When the EMPs go off, people like this Gentleman will be the saving grace.
Great playing! You should check out Glenn Gould's interpretation of this piece as well, it's one of my favourites
Nice
Omg...that was good
wow amazing piano that notes in piano
This piece is so powerful, I can imagine some Rachmaninoff variations coming out of it as well
U r awesome dude! Sublime! Hace muchos años tocas? Yo empecé este año 😊
Me when i tell my brother that he has to accept that god is dead, the fire is gone and he is chasing phantoms
Great performance. It's been a while since I've been able to sit through and entire youtube vid performance. you captured my attention. Curious is it just me or does that Yamaha sound just like a Steinway? Very close in timbre.
11:15 ☺
😅
?
look at him face ☺
Awww 😊
I still waiting for the page-turn moment that never happened..
LOL
Nice stuff
very well played. you have accomplished something special.keep up the good work.
Beautifully played!!
Interesting use of the sustain pedal. The loudness of the marcatissimo section at measure 75 can be a bit distracting with an upright piano, but it seems to me that it is supposed to be very forceful.
Please submit this to Apple Music (Classical) I’d have it on repeat along with other favorites
Beautiful. ❤
Incredible.
A masterpiece! thank you.
Sie können sehr stolz und zufrieden sein.
Beautiful, Thank You
Why does ik take almost a minute before the music starts? What is the use of the silent intro?
Те, кто ставит дизлайки, попробуйте сами сыграть такое многоголосие!!!
Great!
Beautiful!
Thank you for this.
Thanks Dude! I like to much your piano version!
that was beautiful.
Well done!! this one gives me shivers. Don't pay attention to comments like Michaels. Don't need comments like that.
How difficult is this piece? I'd love to play it, but I think I might be punching way above my weight class if I tried learning it now.
Haha I'm in the same situation now. There is a simplified version ( ruclips.net/video/v_olmKUxVw4/видео.html ), which I think I'll learn first.
It is not very well played, though. But the video is good for learning.
I still think it's a good idea to start off there, but then move to the next level here. Especially for such a beginner piano player as I am.
beautiful
when you have to face it that god is dead
Death stains the auditorium.
I love it!
Incredible! Love the slow tempo you play with, really helps capture the feeling of the symphony. Out of curiosity where did you find the music sheet?
IMSLP
Amazing