Kia e-Niro Long Term Test Results: Is It Worth the Hype? - Ability after 3.5 years and 39,000 miles

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 6 янв 2025

Комментарии • 89

  • @BobKirk50
    @BobKirk50 4 месяца назад +11

    I have been following you and I have just collected my 2021 Kia e Niel 4+ with 11,600 miles, It is my first time driving an automatic / Electric car and I drove it from where I collected it 4.5 hours to my home. It is a dream to drive looking and very very happy forward to many happy miles.😊

    • @JonathanPorterfield
      @JonathanPorterfield  4 месяца назад +1

      Thats great news Bob , its a great EV , and a great car 😊

    • @contra_plano
      @contra_plano 4 месяца назад

      @@BobKirk50 the Driver SEAT is confortable and the most specially is the cooler ... I have 40°C in Portugal, some days in summer... To worst for us in Portugal is that our KIA importer do not have that Trim... I had to import the car... In this case from France. It is almost a 4+

    • @bdeithrick
      @bdeithrick 3 месяца назад

      It’s not automatic. Just drive

  • @MrEV
    @MrEV 4 месяца назад +8

    What a car. I'm a bit envious of your 4+ as those ventilated seats would have been welcome for our Italian trip!

    • @graham5649
      @graham5649 4 месяца назад +1

      They are great Mr. T

    • @JonathanPorterfield
      @JonathanPorterfield  4 месяца назад

      ...and the 11kW ac on board charger 👌, 2 position memory drivers seat stops any 'discussions' on who left the seat like this ? 'chats' 😀

    • @kinross24
      @kinross24 4 месяца назад +1

      That’s why swapping from my Ioniq Premium SE which has the heated and ventilated seats, I think I’d definitely miss that in summers.

    • @MrEV
      @MrEV 4 месяца назад +1

      @@JonathanPorterfield I forgot about the 11kW AC as well! Doh!

    • @cheatinlumax
      @cheatinlumax Месяц назад +1

      ​@@JonathanPorterfield
      What trim does the 11kw recharger start at? Is it 4 or 4+?

  • @rorywebb8906
    @rorywebb8906 22 дня назад +1

    Thanks for this inspiring update Jonathon on the Kia E Niro 4+ yatch blue 2021. We have exactly the same car colour and year but although we have Octopus they do not recognise the new RAC installed Hive chargers we have so we cannot get the 8p rate. Even so charging in the day with panels helps. Even though we spent £375 on rapid chargers this year and charged at home for 10,000 miles using home at around 24p per Kwh it has still worked out as 0.67 per mile. Only problem we have is with annoying quiet clicking noise when one accelerates and de-accelerates although my wife can't hear it. Garage did tighten the drive shafts abut then still there and they are look into in the new year when we have time. Love the car. 30,000 miles of quality motoring.

    • @JonathanPorterfield
      @JonathanPorterfield  22 дня назад +1

      Hi Rory , I on Octopus Go tarriff, doesnt matter what charger you have , plus you can use the 8p rate for anything from 00.30 till 05.30 😉
      The ticking noise may well be the motor , all covered under Kias brilliant 7 year warranty , a batch of motors seem to be wearing the motor bearings early !

  • @thindo
    @thindo 4 месяца назад +3

    Great video exploring all angles and everything answered... nothing left to imagination

  • @devonbikefilms
    @devonbikefilms 2 месяца назад +1

    Had my 4+ for three years although I’ve only covered 16,000 miles (I also have a motorcycle) and it’s been superb. We did the sums in September this year and the running costs are 2/3 of my wife’s Picanto 1.0 over the same mileage. Won’t be changing it for years. Overall very happy with it.

  • @mikesmith666
    @mikesmith666 4 месяца назад +2

    Bought my 4+ in June, so 1 month after you. I have to agree it's a fantastic car. Decided to keep it beyond 3yrs as does everything I need a car to do brilliantly.
    Not had any issues in the 3+ years, just three alloys changed under warranty due to the dreaded white worm which I've found is a Kia / Hyundai known issue.
    Never had an issue with the 12v. Saying that, my Leaf is 4 1/2yrs old and never had an issue with that 12v either.

  • @johnbolton7894
    @johnbolton7894 4 месяца назад +4

    Jonathan, Brilliant, I have one and and amazing machine. Thank you for the great amount of detail.

  • @dianecox185
    @dianecox185 4 месяца назад +5

    Great video Jonathan. I bought a 2021 Soul First Edition last week which I think is based on the same tech? Only 4k miles on it. Hope my experience matches yours going forward. Your videos have given me confidence to make the switch, thank you!!

  • @rappermusician
    @rappermusician 4 месяца назад +3

    Fabulous proof - if anyone still needs it! You must be nuts to but a new diesel or petrol car now

  • @Bawdale
    @Bawdale 7 дней назад

    I have an eNiro4+ I took delivery in Dec 20. I would recommend the Goodyear
    EfficientGrip Performance 2 tyre, I find it quieter. Over the four years I have done 65k miles and love the car. My only complaint is the slow charging on long road trips. I plan to replace it with the EV3 late next year.

  • @johniooi3954
    @johniooi3954 4 месяца назад

    Interesting stats in spreadsheet. As a fellow Blue 2021 E-Niro owner. Just mine has a mere 16K on the clock. Worst range 290 miles, best 324 on the GOM. Which is pretty much spot on for me.

  • @FalkinerTim
    @FalkinerTim 2 месяца назад

    In Australia, 2020 MG ZS EV Mk1s with less than 40,000 km sell for around A$23,000 to A$25,000.

  • @timoliver8940
    @timoliver8940 4 месяца назад +1

    The MPGE of EVs is something very few of the anti-EV’ers take into account when decrying EVs, Even my AWD new Mini Countryman S E can easily exceed 150mpgE and mostly it’s been getting 180mpgE this summer. I like watching channels like Out of Spec and love it when they show huge American pickups that in ICE form might see 15mpg on a good day but in EV form see 80mpgE regularly and even on a bad day 1mile/kWh is still 40mpgE!

  • @UpsideDownFork
    @UpsideDownFork 4 месяца назад

    Very fair with your figures!
    Winter tyres are all noisy compared to summer tyres.

  • @tsp52
    @tsp52 3 месяца назад +1

    Hi Jonathan thankyou so much for all the videos you make on the e-Niro, by brother in law has a 4+ and loves it and i am about to get one seconds hand. Did the 4's have heat pumps or was it just the 4+. I have found your videos so helpful.

    • @JonathanPorterfield
      @JonathanPorterfield  3 месяца назад

      Yes the 4s have heat pumps , watch this video too see where it is under the bonnet
      ruclips.net/video/fiHl90y-1Qg/видео.htmlsi=M1iZS8TiTBwTylDA
      and this one ....
      ruclips.net/video/DfpeEq5VGY8/видео.htmlsi=lKbiInr_ByVasYp1
      And thanks for watching and its great you've found the videos useful 😀

  • @thelaserhive3368
    @thelaserhive3368 4 месяца назад +1

    Nice one JP. You certainly get better miles per kWh than we get on our new shape Motability Niro 4. Having said that it’s still a nice car and things like the HUD and the feature of being able to remotely reverse or drive forward the car using the key fob are great. The latter feature is especially good for me as a wheelchair user to help me access tricky chargers like the older Tesla ones.

    • @stevemulroy1417
      @stevemulroy1417 4 месяца назад

      The range will go up. When we got our new shape back in may, we only got 425+430km on a full charge. Now it’s between 465-495km at 100%. Our dealer even said to us, “give it 4-5000km and you’ll see it increase and top out.” I guess it’s to do with the chemistry and charge / discharge cycles. But really I have no clue…

    • @kinross24
      @kinross24 4 месяца назад

      The new Niro EV is less efficient than the old ENiro. Less power, slower and heavier. Why??

  • @graham5649
    @graham5649 4 месяца назад

    Hi, these really are great cars. In my first year of ownership July 23 - Jul 24 the cars long term trip says 7900 miles at 4.7m/Kw which I think is fantastic. Like you during the summer 300 miles of range is easily achievable. I'm ashamed to say I had missed your video on the tyre noise as I recently took mine in to Kia thinking I had a wheel bearing problem as I was getting a noise. Kia don't seem to be aware of this issue as they said everything was fine including the tyres. I took it to a tyre specialist and they said the wear was ok but and the tyres were safe but slightly distorted and they had seen a lot of ev's especially tesla's with this problem they believe due to their weight. My tyres are still at 5mm so I don't want to change them and only 2 months ago at its service I had the tracking checked which was also ok. I know these aren't the best looking ev's on the road but with the features in the cars and the range from only a 64Kwh battery I don't understand why they aren't more popular.

  • @stephenclay6852
    @stephenclay6852 4 месяца назад +1

    Great video having had the E NIRO myself I agree with your thoughts. It would be interesting to know the state of health of the battery at that 40,000 mile stage. The best range I managed out of mine in the summertime was 329 miles. Photographed to prove it.

    • @JonathanPorterfield
      @JonathanPorterfield  4 месяца назад +2

      Next fridays video will be about the SOH of the battery 🔋 😀

  • @martinpickard100
    @martinpickard100 4 месяца назад +4

    Great Video Johnathon. My 2019 has just passed 102000 miles. Faults. Sticky charge flap changed under warranty at 45000. Original Battery lasted until 90000. Average has been 4.4.mkwh.

    • @karmanline2005
      @karmanline2005 4 месяца назад +2

      Do you mean the original 12V or the HV 64kWh?

    • @martinpickard100
      @martinpickard100 4 месяца назад +3

      @@karmanline2005 original 12v.🙂

  • @OraEtLabora0
    @OraEtLabora0 4 месяца назад +2

    7:25 where did you get that "most expensive electricity" claim from?
    3rd party rapids are over 60p/kWh. only Tesla & Ionity, on subscriptions are in 40s...

    • @pauleast4372
      @pauleast4372 4 месяца назад

      @@OraEtLabora0 Membership of tesla for charging meant, on recent Cornwall trip, 32p on way there and 37p on way back. If you pay the Fossil Giant's rate you are either a company car driver that doesn't care or in need of therapy

  • @pauleast4372
    @pauleast4372 4 месяца назад +3

    Thanks Jonathan. I do volunteer driving in my 4 year old e-Niro with payment of running the car of 45 pence per mile (tax threshold since 2011). I have Octopus Go and there is no way that I could afford to do it with a fossil-fuel car (even the extra insurance cost is a myth). I have just booked the 70,000 mile service at the same time as I had to have the 12v battery replaced. As for re-sale value? Why would I sell it inside the 7 year warranty period? You didn't mention wear on the brake system!

  • @Tim_Small
    @Tim_Small 4 месяца назад +2

    Quite a few have suffered reduction gearbox bearing failures. Mine had a complete new gearbox and motor fitted under warranty just before I bought it last month. Several other models such as the Hyundai Kona have the same gearbox and issue. I believe the 12 volt battery issue was partly addressed by a firmware update a year or two ago (changed when 12v is charged from the HV system). I'd be interested to see what battery state of health Jonathan's car has. Fortunately mine is still reporting 100% after 90k miles!

    • @peterrhodes9121
      @peterrhodes9121 4 месяца назад

      Just bought my used 2021 eNiro and sure enough, it needs the gearbox and/or motor replacing under warranty. Got a date at the KIA garage coming up

    • @joethered1
      @joethered1 3 месяца назад

      ​@peterrhodes9121 what are the symptoms of this?

    • @Tim_Small
      @Tim_Small 3 месяца назад

      @@joethered1 Initially bearing noise (somtimes a ticking sound proportional to speed) - usually louder under either acceleration or regen. Getting gradually worse, until total failure.

  • @GordonHudson
    @GordonHudson 4 месяца назад +1

    My wife gets 35 mpg out of her petrol Qashqai. That's 16p per mile. My Leaf costs 3p per mile for electricity using Octopus Go plus a bit of peak rate electricity. Interestingly the Qashqai is only 50kg lighter than my Leaf E+, but that's with no petrol in it. With a full tank they are about the same weight.

  • @Banyan314
    @Banyan314 2 месяца назад +1

    My ENiro 4+ has made a proposed purchase of an EV3 a very trick decision. The Niro still does what I need it to do and the EV3 is just not a compelling buy as it doesn’t do much more than my existing car and is so expensive. With an extra cost for a heat pump and no V2G/H capability ( which is available on EU spec cars) the EV3 just didn’t have appeal to me as an energy store on wheels for my home. Hence the EV3 sale didn’t happen.
    The E Niro is just a great car.

  • @robtaylor7772
    @robtaylor7772 4 месяца назад +1

    Hi Jonathan. We’re EV converts and have the new Niro EV 4 and an older Ioniq 38kwh. You mentioned that almost all of your solar goes to the car. Is it not more cost effective to charge the car overnight using cheap rates and export the solar at (15p kWh in our case)?

    • @JonathanPorterfield
      @JonathanPorterfield  4 месяца назад

      To many renewables here so i cant officially export to the grid and get paid !

    • @robtaylor7772
      @robtaylor7772 4 месяца назад +1

      Thanks. Very interesting!

  • @richardtrundle2758
    @richardtrundle2758 4 месяца назад +2

    Hi Jonathan, I noticed you mentioned purchasing outright after your lease ? Do you feel the pricing was based on what the vehicle was worth at the time or what it owed the finance company ? I’m thinking those two pricing methods could give different results in a volatile market.
    Was it easy to buy after the lease ended? Reason being we’ve just taken delivery of an EV lease car and like it so far.thank you 😊

    • @JonathanPorterfield
      @JonathanPorterfield  4 месяца назад +1

      With Arval ( the funder) they based the sale price on trade value 👌 not what it owed them.

    • @richardtrundle2758
      @richardtrundle2758 4 месяца назад

      @@JonathanPorterfield thank you .. that’s promising 👍

    • @JonathanPorterfield
      @JonathanPorterfield  4 месяца назад +1

      @richardtrundle2758 it depends on your funder , i know Lex wont sell direct !

    • @JonathanPorterfield
      @JonathanPorterfield  4 месяца назад +1

      Check out the procees i went through with Arval
      ruclips.net/video/go2DDRLc0lM/видео.htmlsi=9a0zUHCWPoxR7UFS

    • @richardtrundle2758
      @richardtrundle2758 4 месяца назад +1

      Ours is Leassys. But no worries will ask the question if I’m up for it at end of lease. 🙏 thanks again.

  • @wobby1516
    @wobby1516 2 месяца назад +1

    Don’t go for Michelin tires they were on my new Niro and I got very poor mileage from them less than 20000 miles. The guy who services our car drives an MG electric and he get way over 40000 miles from his EVs “Cleevely EV mobile” they specialise in servicing EVs and travel all over the country they also repair / replace EV batteries, a brilliant company

  • @garysmith5025
    @garysmith5025 4 месяца назад +2

    A lot of people can't get an EV tariff, me included, because our "smart" meters will not communicate due to a weak WAN signal, I'm not even in a particularly remote part of Caithness. I still pay less to charge two cars (one is my son's Ioniq Classic, he was quite smug when you said you've averaged 4miles/kWhr!) power and heat the house and swimming pool than I did just to put petrol in my last ICE, but an EV tariff would save me £1500/year and it's really p*****g me off!

    • @Tim_Small
      @Tim_Small 4 месяца назад +2

      You can still go to traditional economy 7 type tariff in this situation. Might not be right for you but at least it is an option.

  • @bdeithrick
    @bdeithrick 3 месяца назад +1

    Like 👍🏽. True

  • @CliffReece
    @CliffReece 4 месяца назад +1

    Hi Jonathan. I believe from a previous conversation that my eNiro was an ex Orkney Reflex car I purchased from Arval as an ex lease car. I have found a geotab unit in my car but have no idea how to retrieve the data from it. Geotab website is not much help as I have no log in details. Did email Arval but no response as yet. Would like to retrieve this info if possible - any help would be appreciated and please keep up with the videos. Thanks.
    👍

    • @JonathanPorterfield
      @JonathanPorterfield  4 месяца назад

      Hi cliff.
      Arval will not be aware of these geo tabs , you can try this e mail i used.
      Tommy@levltelematics.com
      State the VIN and see what happens , they may ask ReFLEX for permission, this is out of my control , but ask anyway !

  • @kinross24
    @kinross24 4 месяца назад +1

    Great video and stats. I’m so definitely swapping out my 48000 mile 2020 Ioniq electric premium se for a 4+ E Niro and same blue as yours. Can you still buy at auction for us or have to go to Eco Cars?

    • @JonathanPorterfield
      @JonathanPorterfield  4 месяца назад +1

      Has to go through eco cars , as this was the agreement when i sold the business, that i won't compete against them !

  • @mrdsn189
    @mrdsn189 4 месяца назад

    Thank you

  • @wobby1516
    @wobby1516 2 месяца назад +1

    The government in your case has lost out by £4000 if we all go electric the the government is going to have to change the tax rules. Oh and like you I drive a Kia Nero 4plus too.

  • @gohumberto
    @gohumberto 3 месяца назад +1

    If you can charge at home, ideally using some Solar input (as I do) then you stop even monitoring the costs of "fuel". It's too cheap to be bothered counting.
    I pay more in fuel for my Lawn Mower than my car. NOTE. I "virtually store" my surplus Solar (via my energy deal here in France) and I "store" about 4,000 kw/hrs a year.
    That's 16,000 free, Solar, miles for an E-Niro, or £2,700 saved in petrol using your calculations. Even better than that though .... I never need to do that petrol filling thing, stood in a rainy cold petrol station, handing over a hundred quid for a few days worth of smelly "dinosaur juice".

  • @dayoadeosun1520
    @dayoadeosun1520 4 месяца назад

    Hi Jonathan, Great video, lots of useful information. I drive a Toyota Prius Excel 2020 PHEV, a very efficient vehicle, whether charged or not, with 110 mpg over 33 months/ 42, 000 miles I have owned the car. I would like to know your thoughts, what if you had the Kia Niro PHEV, do you think the cost of owning the vehicle over the same 3.5yr/39,000 miles would be the same or more than the EV? Thanks. I'm Dayo.

  • @antoniopalmero4063
    @antoniopalmero4063 4 месяца назад

    Hey John, does the 4+ have cooled seats too ?.

  • @no-oneman.4140
    @no-oneman.4140 4 месяца назад +2

    Would love to know what traction battery degradation, servicing costs, any fault fixes under warranty or not. I'm looking at buying a Kona EV , 2020 reg, around the £15k mark, just worried that the warranty has only one more year so it's a gamble, also means when I come to sell it won't have any warranty so will depreciate badly. I'd love the Niro 4+, it has everything except a heads up display. Where best to get one, Kia dealers are dearer or go to a supermarket, cheaper, yes. Still under warranty though. If anyone knows of a fair priced one in dark blue or white, let me know.

    • @JonathanPorterfield
      @JonathanPorterfield  4 месяца назад +2

      Hi , tune in next friday 6pm for battery state of health 😀 😊

    • @garysmith5025
      @garysmith5025 4 месяца назад

      The main thing to check with the Kona is that it doesn't have any outstanding recalls, they should have had a battery coolant change done as a recall but some of the leased ones didn't get it done, although it can still be done for free which is actually very handy as it's quite expensive to have done at the 40k service! There have also been some cases of wear in the reduction gearbox, it's rare but has been known, quite simply there should be no transmission sounds at all under acceleration just the very slight whine of the inverter/motor. Regarding battery degradation, our Kona at 3 years and 40k miles, will happily do the return trip down to Inverness without a charge on route. That's 242miles and we tend to arrive home with somewhere between 10% and 20% SOC, no measurable drop in range as far as I can tell.
      Quite a few Premium SE round about 40k miles on Autotrader at the moment for under £15k.

    • @no-oneman.4140
      @no-oneman.4140 4 месяца назад

      Thank you for such a comprehensive reply. I'd prefer the Kona at say £15k but my head says I should spend another £3k on a Niro4+ to get that piece of mind warranty, ah decisions ...

    • @garysmith5025
      @garysmith5025 4 месяца назад

      @@no-oneman.4140 I know what you mean, our Kona is going back to Motability soon at the end of the lease. We tried the new Kona but to be brutally honest it felt like a step backwards, so I'll be after either 2021 Kona or e-Niro to buy outright to replace it; both cars have their plus points with very few negatives. I'm not actually bothered about the warranty side of things, the battery just isn't a problem, motor/inverter/gearbox a minimal risk; suspension and brakes are just the same as any car.

    • @timothybloomer8287
      @timothybloomer8287 4 месяца назад

      I suggest starting with car gurus. There's over 50 e niros under 20k on there currently.

  • @contra_plano
    @contra_plano 4 месяца назад

    Could you put comzuption in kW/h

  • @dewarmc
    @dewarmc 4 месяца назад

    Johnathon, do you think it would be worthwhile leaving the 'geo-tab' in place for as long as you have the car, or is the 'geo-tab' no longer supported, because there wouldn't be many people out there and able to collect the information you are doing, which would be invaluable over the coming years, don't you think. Personally, I'd hook it up again, great review :-)

  • @radiotowers1159
    @radiotowers1159 4 месяца назад

    Yes My Nero EV camera gets fogged up and its not quite central so relying on it to reverse you end up slightly squinty !

  • @David-jt8eq
    @David-jt8eq 4 месяца назад +1

    J P As we are all aware the Labour want to tax EVS due to lost fuel tax hope they don’t see this or we will be crying as they will want the £4K you have saved,
    They have set up car tax for next year.
    Me think EVS are going to be taxed by pay per mile to make up for lost fuel tax.
    Cars are only going to be for the rich moving in to 2030.

    • @leskennedy
      @leskennedy 3 месяца назад

      Any government will need to do something to get revenue in now people are switching from fossil fuels.
      I'm sure motoring will get more expensive in the future so it really pays to have an EV now to maximise the saving potential.