No, please look closely. It's an image of multiple books layered on top of one another. The top one is Shaykh Akram Nadwi's "Madkhal Al Raai' Ila Sahih Al Bukhari"
@unkn0wnserv3r it would be great had they done that in their video and you asked them this question but you rather ask the comments lol. Obviously can't have a whole analysis here but comparing bukhari authenticity to the moon made of cheese? Also falsely reporting the argument of those who are in the not so authentic camp for starters. Anyway just my .02
@@ImranKhan-rt2gi the analogy was on ridiculous points. But what books and scholars are on the 'no so authentic camp' that they should have responded to?
@@ImranKhan-rt2gi From my listening on the podcast, they referred to a book questions the ascription of Bukhari. And then mentioned books which have responded to those claims. Summarising the responses and referring to further reading. You seem to claim there are parts missing and not actually mentioning what is missing 😂
Sahih bukhari has an error. Thats in hadith number 7517. Where it says "before the Divine Inspiration was revealed to Him." So we know the book has errors...
we don't backbite other Muslims, especially scholars. He may have differences to the mainstream hanafis or muqallids but that does not mean we speak ill of him, wassalam.
There are some audio issues in this episode, The volume may need to be adjusted at some points in the first 40 minutes.
Great watch mashallah
MashaAllah
Fascinating discussion. I’m learning much. Please keep it up جزاك الله خيراً
Allamah Zeeshan MashaAllah
ليتكما تكلمتما بالعربية ليستفيد منكم العرب والذين لا يعرفون الإنجليزية. خاصة بما أن الموضوع موضوع علمي والكتب عربية... بارك الله فيكما
I definitely think an Arabic podcast would be very juicy❤
You already have more Arabic content on the book by many esteemed sheikhs in Arabic 😢
MashaAllah 👌
Can someone timestamp dr. akram nadwi part
Is there English translations of any of these books?
Where is the beginning nasheed from
ruclips.net/video/vFF9Pjq70sw/видео.htmlsi=CIzDwE1KIffNaEH8
What is the name (English transliteration and arabic) of the first book
❤❤❤
You posted an image of madkhal to sahih ibn hibban instead of sahih bukhari
No, please look closely. It's an image of multiple books layered on top of one another. The top one is Shaykh Akram Nadwi's "Madkhal Al Raai' Ila Sahih Al Bukhari"
@97MrOmar I think he's talking about in the video around the 4th minute mark
A lot of half information (put mildly) and false analogies in the textual integrity of bulhari bit.
Can you please provide actual points, rather than a massive claim with zero evidence
@unkn0wnserv3r it would be great had they done that in their video and you asked them this question but you rather ask the comments lol. Obviously can't have a whole analysis here but comparing bukhari authenticity to the moon made of cheese? Also falsely reporting the argument of those who are in the not so authentic camp for starters. Anyway just my .02
@@ImranKhan-rt2gi the analogy was on ridiculous points.
But what books and scholars are on the 'no so authentic camp' that they should have responded to?
@@ImranKhan-rt2gi From my listening on the podcast, they referred to a book questions the ascription of Bukhari. And then mentioned books which have responded to those claims. Summarising the responses and referring to further reading.
You seem to claim there are parts missing and not actually mentioning what is missing 😂
Sahih bukhari has an error. Thats in hadith number 7517. Where it says "before the Divine Inspiration was revealed to Him." So we know the book has errors...
I don't think anyone claimed it has no errors
are you talking about the english translation?
Hadith has fabircations!
Who said it doesnt😂?
Who is Akram nadwi
Is he that mad man?
we don't backbite other Muslims, especially scholars. He may have differences to the mainstream hanafis or muqallids but that does not mean we speak ill of him, wassalam.