Buying GSA CC Morgan Dollars on ebay • Open Box • Should I Send These in for Grading?

Buying GSA Carson City Morgan Dollars on ebay, Open Box, Should I Send These in for Grading? Photo comparisons and grade discussion.

[@Crypt0fin]

The Ebay photo on the first toner looks like a 63 to me might grade 64 but the Ebayer made it look like you got a 65. The second one looks more like a 64 but those marks might make it a 63. The third one looks like 63 or worst case 62. the last one looks like a 63 maybe a 64. The first one had the most eye appeal but the second one looks like it would grade the highest. I might be wrong post what you get for grades.

[@JoshuaAndersonLife]

Thank you for your input! I agree completely with your assessment! 👍👍

[@shawn951951]

Just curious why you choose NGC over PCGS? Is it so they can fit back into the OGP boxes?

[@JoshuaAndersonLife]

Yes, it's so they still fit in the boxes. Otherwise I use PCGS for all my grading.

[@davidbell9130]

the ones you want will be labeled uncirculated on the gsa dollar, you got the cheaper much cheaper version

[@JoshuaAndersonLife]

If they have any toning on them at all they do not get the uncirculated designation from GSA. If they also have a lot of heavy bag marks on them They will also not get the uncirculated designation. I like toning so I will often buy them without having the uncirculated label on them. So not having the "uncirculated" does not always mean that they are going to be a cheaper version. I have some that are graded MS65 by NGC that do not have the uncirculated.