The Alternate Histories of Mars

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 сен 2024
  • Have you ever looked up at Mars and asked...what if? Well some alternate historians have and I'm going to talk about a few of the alternate red planets they've created.
    Email: ahwupdate at gmail dot com
    Facebook: / the-alternate-historia...
    Twitter: @alt_historian, @mattmitrovich
    Blog: alternatehistor...
    Patreon: / mattmitrovich
    SOURCES AND PHOTO CREDITS
    www.uchronia.ne...
    www.thespacere...
    www.uchronia.ne...
    www.uchronia.ne...
    www.tor.com/20...
    www.alternateh...
    • Video
    www.alternateh...
    tvtropes.org/p...
    tvtropes.org/p...
    www.space.com/...
    www.uchronia.ne...
    www.uchronia.ne...
    turtledove.fan...
    / 1521189316491415556
    en.wikipedia.o...
    / 427437169382743
    • Elon Musk Cameo Scene ...
    them0vieblog.c...
    shop.2000ad.co...
    • War of the Worlds Goli...
    • THE GREAT MARTIAN WAR:...
    / 164072277096849
    • Battlezone (1998) - Of...
    www.hipcomic.c...
    www.muddycolor...
    us.macmillan.c...
    www.alternateh...
    www.indiebound...
    Goodreads.com
    Wikipedia.org

Комментарии • 46

  • @nickalexander3107
    @nickalexander3107 2 года назад +22

    Thanks for the kind words about my work, Proxima: A Human Exploration of Mars, I'm really really happy to bring it to folks every monday!

  • @giladpellaeon1691
    @giladpellaeon1691 2 года назад +10

    The Long Earth series by Pratchett and Baxter is an excellent series to read and dealing with a lot of possible issues in finding easy-ish access to many more Earths through "Stepping". Highly recommend it and remember your potato.

  • @Grant_Scarboro
    @Grant_Scarboro 2 года назад +8

    Can't wait for the video covering the alternate histories based on speculative evolution!😏

    • @TheAlternateHistorian
      @TheAlternateHistorian  2 года назад +4

      Honestly there are some pretty good ones out there. Like the recent Sidewise winner The Doors of Eden by Adrian Tchaikovsky.

  • @TheAlternateHistorian
    @TheAlternateHistorian  2 года назад +5

    So I was wrong to say Mars was our closest planetary neighbor. Surprisingly its Mercury: www.popularmechanics.com/space/solar-system/a26839314/closest-planet-to-earth-on-average/. Sorry about that misinformation.
    Also people keep asking why I didn't mention Kim Stanley Robinson's Mars trilogy. The answer is simple: it isn't alternate history. They are both set in the future of when they are written. As far as I know no past historical events were changed/altered to create the setting. So they aren't relevant to a video about alternate history works regarding Mars.

    • @Arakhor
      @Arakhor 2 года назад

      That is a great trivia point. Thanks!

  • @vallond1973
    @vallond1973 2 года назад +3

    Hi, Hello and Greetings from the twin island Republic of Trinidad and Tobago in the Southern Caribbean. I really enjoyed this episode on Alternate Mars. Especially your including War of The Worlds, War of The Worlds Goliath and Scarlet Traces.
    There is another War of the Worlds type spinoff by John Rust and Mark Gardner, " War of The Worlds: Retribution." This story centers around an allied expediationary force of ships, troops and walkers from The British Empire, France, Imperial Germany, The Soviet Union, the United States of America etc. Launching an invasion of Mars, featuring famous military officers such as Patton, De Gaule, Rommel and Zhukov faceing off against Martin forces. It's most definately worth a read.
    Keep up the great work.

    • @DinoRicky
      @DinoRicky Год назад

      Hey I’m from Puerto Rico 🇵🇷 cool that there’s another Caribbean watching this :)

  • @ccib00
    @ccib00 2 года назад +3

    Human always has colorful imagination on mars. Also, Voyage, Eye turned skyward, and proxima got mentioned!? Damn. Those are some of my favorite.

    • @nickalexander3107
      @nickalexander3107 2 года назад +2

      Always happy to hear proxima is on the favorites list :)

  • @HebaruSan
    @HebaruSan 2 года назад +2

    It's neat that Lee Smolin blurbed one of these, kind of amusing to imagine him reading sci fi

  • @piplupsingularity
    @piplupsingularity Год назад

    Love the shoutouts to Voyage, Eyes Turned Skyward, Proxima, and For All Mankind. Spaceflight alternate histories are the best.

  • @francissreckofabian01
    @francissreckofabian01 2 года назад +1

    Baxter also did a sequel to the Time Machine which was odd but I found to be a lot of fun.

  • @SomasAcademy
    @SomasAcademy 2 года назад +2

    Mars isn't our closest planetary neighbor; Venus comes the closest to us of any planet at the closest part of our orbits, and is closer to us than Mars at both the closest and farthest parts of its orbit, and Mercury is technically closest to us on average (because it orbits much faster and is closer to the sun, meaning it passes close to us more regularly and is less far away when it's on the opposite side of the sun than Venus is). Unless you mean closest in terms of how similar it is to us, in which case... also Venus, which is MUCH closer to us in size (the gravity is only about 10% lower, while on Mars it's closer to 60% lower) and while its atmospheric makeup and density and the resulting heat would make it impossible for humans to reach its surface (even making it difficult to land rovers on the surface for more than a brief window of time), Mars has an extremely thin atmosphere made up almost entirely of Co2, and as a result has a frigid surface, so it's equally distinct from ours in the opposite direction.

  • @jordanmagpiebullet7978
    @jordanmagpiebullet7978 2 года назад

    New subscriber and amazing video keep it up and you’ll go far on RUclips and can I ask you something as will

  • @Arakhor
    @Arakhor 2 года назад +2

    I'm surprised you didn't mention Kim Stanley Robinson's Red, Green & Blue Mars trilogy from the 90s. Also of note is the short story anthology "Medieval Mars" about a partially terraformed Mars whose human settlers regress to mediaeval technology after an unspecified disaster on Earth.

    • @TheAlternateHistorian
      @TheAlternateHistorian  2 года назад

      Robinson's series isn't an alternate history. As far as I understand he didn't change past historical events to create what is basically a straightforward SF story set in the future. As for Medieval Mars, I never heard of it and it didn't come up in any of my research, but I will try to check it out later.

    • @ParasaurolophusEwan
      @ParasaurolophusEwan Год назад +1

      Aw, I knew that post-apocalyptic rennaissnce Mars idea I had was familiar.

    • @Arakhor
      @Arakhor Год назад

      @@ParasaurolophusEwan Well, there's no copyright on ideas, merely on their execution.

  • @vadarman9906
    @vadarman9906 2 года назад +3

    Yeah, Harry Turtledove doesn't have a good understanding of Marxism. Historically, governments that operated under Marxist assumptions were, themselves, formerly feudal states that instantly jumped to a socialist state.
    I think Turtledove looked at a basic timeliness of how Marxists view history and saw that "Feudalism leads to Capitalism which leads to Socialism" as well as some Marxist explanation of the benefits of Capitalism when compared to Feudalism. Then Turtledove just left it there without going further.

    • @creatoruser736
      @creatoruser736 2 года назад

      Marxists don't have a good understanding of Marxism.

  • @kronosbach5263
    @kronosbach5263 11 месяцев назад

    I kinda want you to do a similar vidoe on moon althists just because of how baffling The Moon is a Harsh Mistress is

  • @cristophermartinez6707
    @cristophermartinez6707 2 года назад

    great video, just subscribed from your sliders videos and just in general interested of "what if"

  • @terencewong-lane4309
    @terencewong-lane4309 2 года назад

    Voyage by Stephen Baxter is one of my VERY FAVOURITE books!

  • @joshuawells835
    @joshuawells835 2 года назад

    For Anime fans, a good Mars alternate history I enjoyed was Aldnoah.Zero. The basic storyline goes that in 1972, the Apollo 17 Mission discovered ancient alien technology on the moon called the Hypergate, which was used to jumpstart the colonization of Mars. Upon the discovery of more alien technology called Aldnoah, the colonists found the Vers Empire. The Vers Empire is technologically superior to Earth, but covets the resources of Earth. This leads to the First Earth-Mars War, which ends in 1999 after Heaven's Fall, where the Hypergate goes out of control and destroys the moon. The series takes place in 2014 with the start of the Second Earth-Mars War.

  • @CraftsmanOfAwsomenes
    @CraftsmanOfAwsomenes 2 года назад

    The sandwich story is a myth. There's a Smithsonian article that addresses it. The route was known and whether or not Princip had food is in no contemporary source.

  • @eduardwiebe3737
    @eduardwiebe3737 2 года назад

    I liked Goliath too :D

  • @readingking1421
    @readingking1421 2 года назад

    Nice! Haven't seen War of the World: Goliath get enough love so this is automatically a good video. Shame they took it off Netflix.

  • @Maximara
    @Maximara 2 года назад

    I guess that because they were short stories and set in the future Stanley G. Weinbaum's "A Martian Odyssey" and "Valley of Dream" didn't qualify as alternate history. On a side note the GURPS RPG has a Mars supplement (GURPS Mars) which generalizes many of the various versions of Mars.

  • @kingkuroneko7253
    @kingkuroneko7253 2 года назад +1

    Yo

  • @Mangoonistgamer12344
    @Mangoonistgamer12344 2 года назад

    I want You do stephen baxters voyage

  • @francissreckofabian01
    @francissreckofabian01 2 года назад

    I'm a little bit stunned that you missed 2 of the 3 most important Mars series in SF. ie Kim Stanley Robinson and Ray Bradbury. Lucky you are young and you have time to catch up.

    • @TheAlternateHistorian
      @TheAlternateHistorian  2 года назад +1

      I've read Bradbury, but never got past Red Mars with Robinson (just didn't enjoy it). As for "stunned", why did you think I would mention them in a video covering alternate history works of Mars? Neither are alternate histories since they do not change past events and are rather set in the future of when they were written.

  • @cristophermartinez6707
    @cristophermartinez6707 2 года назад

    would you do a video about alternative histories or worlds of technological advancements or declines (basically Cyberpunk)

  • @realhorrorshow8547
    @realhorrorshow8547 2 года назад

    "Mars, the Red Planet, our closest planetary neighbour." Our closest planetary neighbour is Venus. Report to the Agony Booth citizen.

    • @TheAlternateHistorian
      @TheAlternateHistorian  2 года назад +1

      Yes yes yes. You are not the first person to correct me. See the pinned comment. Also apparently Mercury is our closest neighbor by certain measurements.

    • @realhorrorshow8547
      @realhorrorshow8547 2 года назад

      @@TheAlternateHistorian It's Mercury occasionally, when Venus is in opposition and Mercury is in conjunction. But on average it's Venus. Sorry I didn't see the pinned comment, for some reason it's not at the top.

  • @springboipruductions8806
    @springboipruductions8806 2 года назад

    Wait what Venus is our closest planetary Nabighor not mars he literally says this 3 seconds into the video

  • @steel12fire8
    @steel12fire8 2 года назад

    How are you injoying For All Mankind

  • @jonathan-rm4sk
    @jonathan-rm4sk 10 месяцев назад

    Don't pay for streaming services when you can commit piracy like me