Half in the Bag Episode 132: mother!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 янв 2025

Комментарии • 2,2 тыс.

  • @EinSophistry
    @EinSophistry 6 лет назад +844

    Goddamnit, Mike, how am I supposed to know what to think about this movie if I don't know which episode of Star Trek it reminded you of?

  • @vallytine
    @vallytine 7 лет назад +2234

    Mother! Is basically a Neil Breen film. The leading man plays god, the plot centers around a magic rock, and the leading lady spends most of the movie without a bra. 10/10

    • @TheBenjaman
      @TheBenjaman 7 лет назад +54

      Yes the nipple action in this movie was of the charts lmao

    • @metalmugen
      @metalmugen 6 лет назад +23

      It REALLY is tho

    • @antediluvianspy5371
      @antediluvianspy5371 6 лет назад +48

      3 breen salad

    • @mistertagomago7974
      @mistertagomago7974 6 лет назад +44

      Neil Breen films are entertaining though.

    • @mcrettable
      @mcrettable 6 лет назад +13

      Valerie Aust j law without a bra is ok with me 🙏

  • @pepepoopsonthefarright7531
    @pepepoopsonthefarright7531 4 года назад +552

    "...jennifer lawrence is like mother earth or some shit..."
    this should have been the tagline for the movie

    • @bjrnvindabildtrup9337
      @bjrnvindabildtrup9337 3 года назад +8

      Yay, poop on those right wingers, pepe!

    • @Wonkess_Chonkess
      @Wonkess_Chonkess Год назад +4

      I like to make jokes and be the clown at my work but Mike always humbles me with his killer humor...

  • @thegameneededme5
    @thegameneededme5 7 лет назад +567

    "mother! is the art-house version of Independence Day"
    - Jay Bauman, 2017

  • @MetropolisPictures
    @MetropolisPictures 7 лет назад +464

    Saw it with an elderly couple who walked out with a WTF look on their faces once it was over, I remember the woman saying "I thought this was supposed to be a romance movie?".

    • @LeMissT
      @LeMissT 4 года назад +33

      laughed so hard at this omg.

  • @contravariant_functor
    @contravariant_functor 7 лет назад +724

    "I shouldn't have that reaction to a baby being slaughtered and eaten"
    -Jay Bauman 2017

    • @MrLaggan
      @MrLaggan 7 лет назад +27

      God bless Jay Bauman

    • @randomfools808
      @randomfools808 7 лет назад +1

      I had the same reaction....

    • @VashdaCrash
      @VashdaCrash 7 лет назад +21

      That's too much B movies for you, you can't be shocked by disgust anymore.

    • @FredCracklin
      @FredCracklin 7 лет назад +6

      I bet Jay's Anthropophagus vhs has a certain part worn out.

    • @VashdaCrash
      @VashdaCrash 7 лет назад +7

      Cliff Trainor
      Maybe you can be cured by stop watching movies. Though it could take years.

  • @Solstng
    @Solstng 7 лет назад +395

    Can we get a commentary track for this that's just Jay saying "do you get it!?" for every allegory

  • @mikeobarr8589
    @mikeobarr8589 7 лет назад +2844

    This is how the universe balances itself, the shittier a movie is the better it's "Half in the bag" episode will be.

    • @NoTodoEsArte1
      @NoTodoEsArte1 7 лет назад +29

      its**. I'm just pointing it out because the first time I read your comment I didn't understand it. I don't mean to play smartass or anything, I'm not even a native speaker

    • @NoTodoEsArte1
      @NoTodoEsArte1 7 лет назад +52

      Ok, fixed. Fuck you

    • @mikeobarr8589
      @mikeobarr8589 7 лет назад +29

      NoTodoEsArte - seriously? My phone added an apostrophe to its and that caused you enough distress to warrant a reply? Sorry, I'll have a talk with someone in the apostrophe department at LG first thing tomorrow. Obviously I'm just poking fun. Sorry about confusion bud.

    • @mikeobarr8589
      @mikeobarr8589 7 лет назад +11

      Gage Bauer thanks for clarifying what travesty my phone had perpetrated. Auto-correction claims another one.

    • @signifidelica2819
      @signifidelica2819 7 лет назад +3

      This is one of the best comments I've had the privilege to witness, no joke.

  • @Akasazh
    @Akasazh 7 лет назад +2428

    If it's an allegory concerning climate change woudn't that make it an algorey ?

  • @Rudofaux
    @Rudofaux 7 лет назад +586

    Do you get it?
    Do you get it?
    Do you get it?
    Do you get it?

    • @pulkmees
      @pulkmees 6 лет назад +7

      I didn't get it, because I went into this movie without reading anything about it and I'm not religious(even though most of the stories were the really known ones). Zero reason to think someone would make a movie about just retelling bible stories. Like wtf is the point ? I mean I know the director, I liked most of his previous work, but I thought this was going to be a straight psychological thriller based on the beginning.

    • @lettylunasical4766
      @lettylunasical4766 5 лет назад +5

      @@pulkmees I grew up religious and so got some of the religious allegory... buuuuut... it wasn't well done and still didn't really make sense, even looking at it that way. I think the director just did what he wanted and didn't really think any of it through. Like the randomness of her drinking that yellow mixture, and then stopping, and it's never bought up again.

    • @psychospherean
      @psychospherean 4 года назад

      no!

  • @aaronfitzsimons
    @aaronfitzsimons 7 лет назад +630

    I am fully invested in this Jay/Plinkett marriage love story.

    • @hornyhornyhippos4091
      @hornyhornyhippos4091 7 лет назад +25

      Aaron FitzSimons as long as there is a Jay/Plinkett porn, I'm in.

    • @DirtyBoySingToGod
      @DirtyBoySingToGod 7 лет назад +13

      But which celebrity news outlet will spill the juicy gossip on the honeymoon night ?!

    • @SpiritSoulRecords
      @SpiritSoulRecords 7 лет назад +11

      It's so dense

    • @KevlarGorilla
      @KevlarGorilla 7 лет назад +12

      Mr. Plinkett is a lucky man.

    • @fatsamurai007
      @fatsamurai007 7 лет назад +1

      I wish Mike and Jay weren't.

  • @Drinkabeerandplayagameofficial
    @Drinkabeerandplayagameofficial 7 лет назад +1105

    I've been binging RLM for the last month and this is my first new episode. It's like Christmas morning

    • @blakejohnson3965
      @blakejohnson3965 7 лет назад +27

      Lol literally same here. I saw the Plinkett Ghostbusters 2016 Review and now i legit can't stop watching.

    • @NeuronalAxon
      @NeuronalAxon 7 лет назад +24

      You mean you guys never caught the Plinkett Star Wars Prequel reviews back in the day?

    • @KodiakCaptures
      @KodiakCaptures 7 лет назад +6

      +NeuronalAxon I started watching RLM around the time Rogue One came out, so no plinkett reviews for me. I'm a Star Wars fan and heard about the controversy surrounding their Rogue One review and decided to check it out. After watching the review, I wasn't able understand the big fuss some people were having. Maybe it's just me.

    • @fistfulofgroovy9746
      @fistfulofgroovy9746 7 лет назад +11

      Make sure you watch the Plinkett reviews that started it all...

    • @PeterBondeVillain
      @PeterBondeVillain 7 лет назад +9

      Welcome to the family!
      ... the disgusting, horrible family ...

  • @taqu
    @taqu 7 лет назад +119

    "(you will never answer the door again.)" - From the trailer
    Yes, if you're a living biblical allegory, you will be scared shitless!

  • @margaesperanza
    @margaesperanza 7 лет назад +856

    Interesting enough my friend thought the movie was a metaphor for celebrity culture and how people (celebs and social media stars) have a huge disregard for privacy and always have the need to share everything with everyone because of their egos. It shows how we tend to treat celebs like gods and not normal people. The child being passed around and killed was a metaphor for when these very people share every single aspect of their children that they have basically doomed them to a fate in the spotlight that could eventually kill them (also a metaphor for child actors who went off the deep end). JLaw being called a slut, stripped and getting beaten for it harkens back to her photo scandal and how certain people treated and see her differently for it. I truly bought this interpretation from my friend until I watched the director's interview and we FUCKING WASTED OUR TIME THINKING TOO HARD OVER A SHALLOW ASS MOVIE.

    • @troin3925
      @troin3925 5 лет назад +106

      I love mother! but this interpretation sounds much more interesting.

    • @MiotaLee
      @MiotaLee 5 лет назад +125

      See, better to leave the movie up for interpretation. It's better that way.

    • @claudiafahey1353
      @claudiafahey1353 5 лет назад +5

      Yeah i was starting to think that too lol

    • @sjk7467
      @sjk7467 5 лет назад +44

      But I mean death of the author right? I can totally see that interpretation which in a way means it’s true. Does it really matter what the director thinks when you can draw that totally valid interpretation?

    • @cheesypoohalo
      @cheesypoohalo 5 лет назад +31

      Exactly like you said. I loved the movie and thought it was really clever... but I'm a UK citizen who's been raised atheist and knows jack all about the Bible. I thought the movie was about a controlling spouse, he never takes her side, lets random people into the house without even explaining who they are, he cared about himself while she cared about themselves.
      Reading all the references to the Bible online afterwards was actually quite fun, although all of this is somewhat of a flaw for me. If the movie was supposed to be about something so specific, it probably shouldn't have flown so far over my head lol

  • @ryanhodge9342
    @ryanhodge9342 6 лет назад +86

    "There's a billion of us; should we just kill ourselves or what?" Mike had me laughing way too hard at that one.

  • @EbblingMis
    @EbblingMis 7 лет назад +181

    I would absolutely LOVE a re:View episode of Possession. That movie is an all time favorite for me and more people need to know about it!

  • @Bwaarghz
    @Bwaarghz 7 лет назад +137

    mother exclamation point

    • @Bwaarghz
      @Bwaarghz 7 лет назад +13

      Mother ! 2: mother?!

  • @tactiCole_
    @tactiCole_ 7 лет назад +644

    "the most expensive student film ever made"
    damn

    • @hatefulgaming1800
      @hatefulgaming1800 5 лет назад +16

      Drog .NDTrax Listen just because a film has some message doesn't mean it's good.

    • @madcourier6217
      @madcourier6217 5 лет назад +8

      @Drog .NDTrax I'm sorry not paying attention to the amazing and not at all heavy handed message this movie presents makes you a peasant.

    • @PedroGomes-cx7ku
      @PedroGomes-cx7ku 5 лет назад +3

      @Drog .NDTrax ooh we got a brooklyn cab driver here.

    • @LuisAngel-mu4zv
      @LuisAngel-mu4zv 4 года назад +4

      @Drog .NDTrax thats such a pretentious statement, it doesnt matter if a movie has methapors or not what matters will always be the story, lawrance does nothing shes just being a victim in this movie shes not a charecter shes just a victim its no different from any home invasion film but somehow its a masterpiece because of the methapors? So movies that suck can be great if they get inside an editing room and add in some methapors? I tought it was good writing ,good story and narrative but okey i guess methapors is the only thing that matters now, We dont dislike this movie because we dont understand it im pretty sure everyone understood its messege but if your just gonna use methapors for 2 hours without compelling charecters then thats just lazy writing , you can have methapors and charecters that feel like charecters but somehow every film student now just thinks about the occult messege instead of making a good story or narrative , events are not story

    • @DarkAngelEU
      @DarkAngelEU 4 года назад

      It defies any convention of critique AND cinéma, so I'd give that student film an A++

  • @brettpgh3312
    @brettpgh3312 7 лет назад +606

    I watch so many movie review shows on RUclips. RLM really is just completely above all the competition. Across the board.

    • @kostajovanovic3711
      @kostajovanovic3711 7 лет назад +20

      Oh don't be like that, yms is near, and some movie essay channels are also great

    • @salaciouspancakes
      @salaciouspancakes 7 лет назад +12

      Brett PGH Love Double Toasted as well.

    • @brettpgh3312
      @brettpgh3312 7 лет назад +2

      Me too!

    • @giovannimoise1473
      @giovannimoise1473 7 лет назад +3

      Yes more Double Toasted shoutouts

    • @angespice
      @angespice 7 лет назад +16

      Kosta Jovanovic yeah, I love these channels, but red letter media is above all of them

  • @Bobashasaurus
    @Bobashasaurus 2 года назад +74

    This movie reminded me of a couple apartments I had in my mid 20s. My roommates had people over day and night, often people would just show up uninvited. They ate and drank the groceries I bought, made a big fucking mess, broke stuff. I knew if I objected or tried to kick people out I would be treated as the crazy person, so I didn't bother. I also have a social anxiety disorder that was crippling at that point in my life, so confrontation wasn't something that I had the capacity to handle then. I took this movie as a literal, surrealistic interpretation of the type of living situation I was trapped in, and in that regard it absolutely nails the anxiety, frustration and feeling of madness that I felt in those apartments.

  • @FEfan56
    @FEfan56 7 лет назад +959

    "Humanity is bad and the earth was better off without it"...did you like my point? That'll be $8.95 in humanity money that i need to survive as a human.

    • @helsinkirenaissance
      @helsinkirenaissance 7 лет назад +20

      For real... Once I saw a matinee ticket costing $15 suddenly the whole experience of attending sank to the level of going to a yodling concert. I'm not talking about going to this Aronofsky movie. I wouldn't go even if somebody gave me a ticket and paid me to watch this, but just in general this is what the downfall of cinema looks like. Quality goes down and the prices go up, a winning equation.

    • @SilverShade1008
      @SilverShade1008 7 лет назад +15

      If that’s the only message you took from the movie you should have been paying more attention.

    • @Mariodash23
      @Mariodash23 7 лет назад +55

      SilverShade1008 T O B E F A I R Y O U N E E D T O H A VE A V E R Y H I G H I Q T O U N D E R S T A N D M O T H E R

    • @georgeptolemy7260
      @georgeptolemy7260 5 лет назад +2

      @Yul Brynner at this point kinda

    • @bajscast
      @bajscast 10 месяцев назад

      That's not what the movie is about

  • @ButtonMasherReal
    @ButtonMasherReal 7 лет назад +276

    They were gonna make a sequel called 'Father!', but the script ran away.

    • @sir0nion
      @sir0nion 2 года назад +4

      If someone spilt milk on the script it wouldn't have to leave to go to the store.

  • @Hey-Its-Sara
    @Hey-Its-Sara 7 лет назад +59

    I saw Possession recently and I am fascinated with it! It's such a harrowing experience, watching it for the first time, not quite knowing what to expect. You're just overwhelmed by the performances watching it. And the sad part is, barely anyone knows or talks about that movie. Jay should DEFINITELY host a Re:view episode about it!

  • @tastyloaf5487
    @tastyloaf5487 7 лет назад +451

    Aronofvsky should have called the movie...
    "Recognise my obvious artistic talent... you plebs."

    • @Mariodash23
      @Mariodash23 7 лет назад +64

      I would call it “Darren Aronofsky tipping his fedora for 2-3 hours”

    • @nunnayobiznis
      @nunnayobiznis 6 лет назад +12

      Tasty Loaf Which is a shame, because Arronofsky is a great director, so I can only hope he learns from this fuck-up and goes back to being good.

  • @HamSupZhai
    @HamSupZhai 7 лет назад +581

    "It reminds me of one of my favourite movies" - Jay
    "It reminds me of one of my favourite movies" - Jay
    "It reminds me of one of my favourite movies" - Jay
    "It reminds me of one of my favourite movies" - Jay
    "It reminds me of one of my favourite movies" - Jay

    • @francissantos3634
      @francissantos3634 7 лет назад +219

      Jay's version of Mike's "there's an episode of Star Trek where....."

    • @KaiUno
      @KaiUno 7 лет назад +7

      That's when I open my nzb indexer and get them all.

    • @antediluvianspy5371
      @antediluvianspy5371 6 лет назад +3

      Your point?

    • @DarkAngelEU
      @DarkAngelEU 6 лет назад +5

      DO YOU GET IT?

    • @the2penguins
      @the2penguins 6 лет назад

      not really but k

  • @delsin1126
    @delsin1126 7 лет назад +62

    The sarcasm is so real in the beginning

  • @PhoenixWakeStudios
    @PhoenixWakeStudios 7 лет назад +141

    'mother!'?
    more like 'oh brother!'
    [cue disappointed trumpet interlude]

    • @RestingJudge
      @RestingJudge 7 лет назад +1

      Ian Phoenix oh brother where art thou was great though!

    • @arsarma1808
      @arsarma1808 7 лет назад

      You can write this shit

    • @thewhatness
      @thewhatness 7 лет назад +8

      *slidewhistle*

  • @TheRealMcFlames
    @TheRealMcFlames 7 лет назад +118

    The whole rant from mike about the Brooklyn cab driver aronovsky is fucking gold.

  • @ACD95
    @ACD95 3 года назад +29

    Funny thing is, I actually did see this in theaters with my grandmother. We just wanted to watch a new release movie after our enjoyable lunch at Cheddars. She was not a fan to say the least and did not speak to me on the ride home.

  • @nicholasewertz8770
    @nicholasewertz8770 7 лет назад +307

    This is a strange retelling of the NES game.

    • @oscardighton8580
      @oscardighton8580 5 лет назад +22

      Earthbound deserves a movie or at least a cartoon

    • @obmarte3803
      @obmarte3803 2 года назад

      Ness' Dad got murdered pretty hard in the 3rd act.

    • @sgyoung86
      @sgyoung86 2 года назад

      This is the gritty, realistic Nolan style "reimagining"

  • @kingkerwick
    @kingkerwick 7 лет назад +221

    Rich Evans never knew his own mother, which begs the question of who the obese elderly lady buried under his floor boards is.

    • @NeuronalAxon
      @NeuronalAxon 7 лет назад +13

      That's 'Good Rich'...

    • @brain_apostrophe_t
      @brain_apostrophe_t 7 лет назад +14

      ...or why she looks as though she was crushed between a tree and a 1981 Century Green Cadillac and cut up in a bathtub...

    • @steamedrice97
      @steamedrice97 7 лет назад +21

      The twist is that she's not actually dead and there's an OLD LADY IN THE WALLS!

    • @MisanthropicMarxist
      @MisanthropicMarxist 7 лет назад +2

      Funnily enough, that actually *is* his mother, but he doesn't know

    • @KingNothing710
      @KingNothing710 7 лет назад +1

      hahahahaha

  • @markbisone6169
    @markbisone6169 7 лет назад +359

    Wait... Are you suggesting that Darren "Ass to Ass" Aronofsky doesn't do subtlety well?

    • @NeedsContent
      @NeedsContent 7 лет назад +16

      Jennifer Connely tho... das ass

    • @markbisone6169
      @markbisone6169 7 лет назад +36

      Yes. It's Called "Wrecked Colon for a Cream"

    • @AirahsELL
      @AirahsELL 7 лет назад +7

      That scene was in the book, though.

    • @markbisone6169
      @markbisone6169 7 лет назад +34

      And an underage gangbang was in Stephen King's "It". Doesn't mean you have to film it.

    • @CaptTerrific
      @CaptTerrific 7 лет назад +2

      jack bran i object to that statement! Jude Law is equally attractive!!

  • @HasturCarcosaYT
    @HasturCarcosaYT 7 лет назад +243

    I clapped because I remember the Bible!

    • @madcourier6217
      @madcourier6217 5 лет назад +7

      @@jimjam7928 Welcome to the Redlettermedia comment section. As the crew once said in one of the wheel of the worst episodes "That's the same shit they've been saying for 5 years!"

    • @madcourier6217
      @madcourier6217 5 лет назад

      @@jimjam7928 That they are.

    • @acidset
      @acidset 3 года назад

      Do ya though?

  • @StuntmanMikeL
    @StuntmanMikeL 4 года назад +16

    23:46 I love how Mike let that Reefer Madness reference sink in and then just silently cracked up after processing it in his mind while Jay kept talking.

  • @SuperSethstone
    @SuperSethstone 7 лет назад +374

    Mother Earth being portrayed as innocent, good and forgiving is ridiculous in of itself. Because nature is extremely violent. Animals having to kill each other for survival and natural disasters are not something that man created. Jennifer Lawrence should have been portrayed as having split personalities or something. Nice and calm one minute, and raging and screaming with a knife the next minute.

    • @boobysr
      @boobysr 6 лет назад +146

      Wouldn't that require her to act

    • @StrifeRixa
      @StrifeRixa 6 лет назад +7

      @@boobysr Not if you cast a politician as her spouse (ALLEGEDLY)

    • @boobysr
      @boobysr 5 лет назад +11

      @@adamw116 I've seen a lot of her movies and have never gotten a sense of her playing different characters. She can do sad face, scared face. She just plays herself. A lot of the time, not even that well.

    • @boobysr
      @boobysr 5 лет назад

      @@adamw116 She was good in Winter's Bone though

    • @cleobinx
      @cleobinx 5 лет назад +21

      Visitormassacre that’s the dumbest shit I have ever heard . Trees don’t come back when you have destroyed the environment, when you have put so many chemicals into the atmosphere that the earths natural barrier and protection from the sun , you know the thing called the Ozone layer , that little thing that makes it possible for life to flourish on this planet ! Yah , dinosaurs didn’t destroy the Ozone layer , yes they ate trees BUT they didn’t bulldoze down millions of acres of forest , they didn’t destroy the coral reefs that bring the ocean to life or dump Chemiclas into our oceans . You know that other little thing called water that makes it Possible for life to flourish on this planet . Yes there has always been climate change , the continents have changed and shifted and the life on earth adapted . This is very very different when you destroy far more then you can ever replace to keep the natural balance the earth needs to retain life . Yes Dino’s , cows , ancient people , released gassed into the atmosphere but no where near the amount we do now and what we do now is NOT natural . We have destroyed the oceans and much of the life in it , wrecking the natural order of things and the ocean slowly dies . We have ripped holes in the atmosphere so bad the polar ice caps that have been there for thousands and sometimes millions of years are freaking melting at alarming rates AND is leading to lakes and rivers drying up everywhere , crops dying because of that . The hurricanes the storms , the colder winters and hotter summers , it’s all because of the holes we created in the atmosphere. It’s because of the ignorance of people like you this planet is dying. Of course over thousands /millions of years the earth goes through changes , that’s natural . We however have significantly speed up global warming . When you bulldozer rainforest and so much land that the earth can’t possible replenish itself and destroy and pollute the oceans what do you think is going to happen

  • @johncfalk
    @johncfalk 7 лет назад +100

    The neck snap was upsetting. The eating didn’t work because it was extreme for the sake of extreme.

    • @everylaurenislemons
      @everylaurenislemons 4 года назад +7

      Everyone was freaking out about the cannibalism and then I saw it and was like, "that's it?"

    • @LeMissT
      @LeMissT 4 года назад

      The eating sort of worked for me.. I've always wondered why that custom exists, as it sounds awful. he depicted what i think of when i hear people mention it.

  • @kleptooohhyena
    @kleptooohhyena 7 лет назад +66

    You guys are the fucking realest movie YT channel ever. Skip over most shit like American Assassin, Emoji Movie etc and just talk about the movies that deserve discussion. Props for that.

    • @salaciouspancakes
      @salaciouspancakes 7 лет назад +7

      kleptooohhyena Would have loved to see them talk about "The Emoji Movie" to be honest. They genuinely hate product placement and tackling a movie that was basically all product placement would have been somewhat cathartic.

    • @giovannimoise1473
      @giovannimoise1473 7 лет назад +4

      Oh you mean like every other RUclips movie critic

    • @elchucabagra
      @elchucabagra 7 лет назад

      they did do a HITB of emoji movie... it is hilarious

  • @RoKModder
    @RoKModder 7 лет назад +18

    I love how straightforward you tell the plot xD. All other reviews I've seen are trying to keep the plot spoiler free like, "Hey, I'm gonna try and tell you about this movie, but I can't cause the whole movie is a spoiler." type of attitude xD.

  • @t.c.bramblett617
    @t.c.bramblett617 7 лет назад +27

    I agree with them, the most shocking thing about this film is that it is playing in mega malls around the country instead of art houses

  • @marymitchell6257
    @marymitchell6257 7 лет назад +20

    Jay, thank you very much for introducing me to Possession. I had never heard of it before, and I just watched it and it's pretty much the best thing ever. Please do a Re:View on it at some point.

  • @ens0246
    @ens0246 7 лет назад +62

    I remember when I saw Javier Bardem in No Country For Old men and thought how great he was and looked forward to seeing what he did next. Then he made bad decision after bad decision for the next 10 years.

  • @lfgavalas
    @lfgavalas 7 лет назад +32

    "Take chances with weirdo stuff, sometimes you 'll find great things!" Words to live by!

  • @PeterStellenberg
    @PeterStellenberg 7 лет назад +10

    Thank you for bringing up Possession, such a great underrated film.

  • @cheyennenash6774
    @cheyennenash6774 4 года назад +13

    When I first watched this movie I was convinced it was an experimental exercise to induce panic attacks or as extreme a reaction from the viewer as possible, but the more I think about it the more I realize the directors and writers probably aren’t that clever.

  • @miffedmax6775
    @miffedmax6775 3 года назад +8

    it's so funny to me that even in film school Jay Bauman was savagely critiquing his classmates films

  • @DaiBenduMonk
    @DaiBenduMonk 7 лет назад +230

    Who ever said we wanted the Bible to be rebooted as well!!!?...

    • @robertkarnick1286
      @robertkarnick1286 5 лет назад +20

      Get ready for the JCCU (Jesus Christ Cinematic Universe)

    • @AltoStratusX1
      @AltoStratusX1 5 лет назад +2

      It would've worked too if they gave it to JJ Abrams or Michael Bay

    • @theheebs100
      @theheebs100 5 лет назад +5

      the bible 2: Jesus reloaded

    • @DarkAngelEU
      @DarkAngelEU 4 года назад

      You obviously haven't heard of Fist of Jesus smh

  • @SimonClark
    @SimonClark 7 лет назад +1234

    Well that's the next half hour sorted then

    • @matthewlapierre9032
      @matthewlapierre9032 7 лет назад +17

      But what are you doing now, 30 minutes later?

    • @Thebossstage1
      @Thebossstage1 7 лет назад +4

      Correction
      Half an hour and 1 second

    • @strobbedelutz
      @strobbedelutz 7 лет назад +10

      How can you last that long? I came at 2m25s

    • @SimonClark
      @SimonClark 7 лет назад +2

      Johnny Threefour actually I'm about to finish my PhD and get my RUclips 100k subs plaque but same difference

    • @1981Mog
      @1981Mog 7 лет назад

      Well, that crushing sense of ennui isn't going to defer itself...

  • @iAmTheSquidThing
    @iAmTheSquidThing 7 лет назад +17

    Fun fact: _The Turn Down for What_ video was directed by the guys who did _Swiss Army Man._

  • @spethmanjones2997
    @spethmanjones2997 4 года назад +14

    All of the nuance and subtlety of a WWE wrestler wielding a jackhammer from the hood of a monster truck

  • @ChristianMulkey
    @ChristianMulkey 4 года назад +9

    "I'm really excited about the Mother! Cinematic Universe that's going to spawn..."
    I'm dead.

  • @theresastarmanwaitinginthe5149
    @theresastarmanwaitinginthe5149 7 лет назад +776

    This Mike dude sounds like Mr Plinkett. But it can't be because he doesn't have a wheelchair and pizza rolls.

  • @zguy95135
    @zguy95135 7 лет назад +146

    I literally just finished watching this. The symbolism is right on the nose BUT I really enjoyed it. It's worth it just to watch it go completely off the rails. You know exactly where it's going but I enjoyed the ride. Worth a rental

    • @madcourier6217
      @madcourier6217 5 лет назад +10

      @@jimjam7928 When Jennifer Lawrence turned around and they were eating the baby I just fucking lost it and started laughing at the absurdity.

    • @bronzeager1298
      @bronzeager1298 5 лет назад +20

      Yeah it's definitely worth watching. I don't know if I liked it or not, but it was entertaining, especially the bat shit second half. I wish it flowed together better though...the obvious Genesis metaphors from the first half were kind of at odds with the second half. If it were a tight 90 minute movie that flowed a little better, I think it'd be a legitimate cult classic. I also laughed at the baby scene...not in a bad way though, I thought it was just blackly comic how quickly it escalated and how absurd the Christian metaphor is when literalized like that. I wish there had been more of that black absurdism in the rest of the movie.

    • @DarkAngelEU
      @DarkAngelEU 4 года назад +5

      I'm so glad I sa it in theatres, because the impact of this movie is just gigantic during the war scenes, with the house coming down and everything. I felt sick afterwards, but in a good way.

  • @preemptive74
    @preemptive74 4 года назад +37

    Mother is a Danzig song, let's keep it that way

    • @a_zawodny
      @a_zawodny 4 года назад +3

      I like the way you think!

    • @apothecurio
      @apothecurio 3 года назад +3

      I honestly found the music equivalent to Mother! being “To Be Kind” by Swans.

  • @MadfellaDuke
    @MadfellaDuke 5 лет назад +22

    9:40 I was just watching this video and I swear to god I could hear some one whispering in my ear. I was fucking creeped out. So I went back to 9:40 and I realised it was Rich Evans in the background saying "what are you doing, what are you doing"

  • @coosoorlog
    @coosoorlog 6 лет назад +47

    “Never trust the teller, trust the tale. The proper function of a critic is to save the tale from the artist who created it.”

    • @frankmerker630
      @frankmerker630 3 года назад +5

      That’s how I feel about Shark Exorcist and Honorable Men. Those directors should not be held accountable for their intents in any way

  • @BezoRazo
    @BezoRazo 7 лет назад +602

    Sooo... they basically took the "An Unexpected Party" chapter of _The Hobbit,_ padded it out to two hours, and threw in some assault and infanticide to up the edge factor...?

    • @XxBunnytailxX
      @XxBunnytailxX 7 лет назад +61

      Red Daikini Ha! That's what I was thinking when I saw the preview! I was like "this is a horror movie for hobbits."

    • @ROUGEBLOCK
      @ROUGEBLOCK 7 лет назад +4

      I love it!

    • @music79075
      @music79075 7 лет назад +5

      Red Daikini lmao.

    • @RyanHall42
      @RyanHall42 7 лет назад +18

      there are zero trees ejaculating on Hugh Jackman in this movie whats even the point

    • @marikotrue3488
      @marikotrue3488 7 лет назад +6

      @RedDaikini---you should write for IMDb they need more energy and precision analysis plus this description is spot on.

  • @studiojournal9436
    @studiojournal9436 6 лет назад +7

    the fact that the whole scenario repeats at the end and we are told that this is just a cycle basically makes "Mother's" ordeal pointless. Totally undercuts the emotional consequences of what we had just witnessed over the previous two hours.

  • @Well_Meaning
    @Well_Meaning 7 лет назад +57

    So Aronofsky really can't do shit unless he's stealing from Satoshi Kon, huh?

    • @roelin360
      @roelin360 6 лет назад +1

      youranimesucks requiem for a dream is waaayy overrated. Life of pi was alright, I guess.

    • @roelin360
      @roelin360 6 лет назад

      @Pale Shadow sorry

    • @roelin360
      @roelin360 3 года назад

      @@lucasmossman3820 I never said he did. Whatever comment I responded to is gone now, so the actual context is lost.
      It has been many years since I've seen requiem for a dream, but I remember my problem with it being a distinct lack of attachment or care for the characters because of how they were written. I felt nothing for the suffering they went through because of it, and without that, there's little value in the film for me. The technical qualities of the film should serve to bolster the experience of the story and characters, but since I cared for neither, it failed to impress me. It boredered on pretentious for me, which I define as focusing on technical features or grander themes without enough care for actually making an engaging experience. I didn't understand why everyone cried at it when I was bored instead. I can't give details because it has been so long ago though.

    • @robertyeah2259
      @robertyeah2259 Год назад

      ​@@roelin360 you have your definition of pretentious

    • @roelin360
      @roelin360 Год назад

      @@robertyeah2259 how so?

  • @ClosetoHumanMusic
    @ClosetoHumanMusic 6 лет назад +227

    Wow, it's so crazy how different people interpret different things. I watched this with no prior knowledge of what it was supposed to be about. I had no idea about the director's intended religious overtones nor his attempt to create a metaphor about man's relationship with earth. To me, this was just a story about abusive relationships. The insanity in the house and JLaw's attempts to justify it and keep it all together felt like a metaphor for the way people rationalize their own toxic relationships. In my mind, the house signified the relationship itself, that's why JLaw was trapped there while everyone else could come and go as they pleased. The husband was your typical artist, more in love with his work than his own family, hence his willingness to sacrifice his child in order to get the praise he craves. "You didn't love me, you only loved how much I loved you." That was the whole story in a nutshell for me. Everything Mike and Jay are saying here totally makes sense, especially when you see it in the context of Arronofsky's own words. However, the way this film resonated with ME was something else entirely. I loved the shit out of it.

    • @calvinlee8103
      @calvinlee8103 6 лет назад +69

      This is why I don't like when people explain their art. You watched the movie and got something interesting and different out of it. But since the director has flat out said, "this is what the movie means..." It turns your unique interpretation of the movie (and all other interpretations of it) into nothing but an incorrect explanation. IMO, that kinda sucks.

    • @franciscoastorga8299
      @franciscoastorga8299 6 лет назад +12

      Same here. I really liked Mother, more for how it made me feel that for what it tried to say. I love when movies try to challenge the viewer by making it unconfortable, pushing the envelope to what pictures can convey. Not since early Lynch have I felt so uneasy watching a film.
      Then I watched some Aronofsky interviews and I said to myself "oh, no...this guy loves to eat his own shit..."

    • @calvinlee8103
      @calvinlee8103 6 лет назад +3

      Chimutrufio Gumercindo Ibañez del Campo - Have you ever seen the movie Pi? It's by the same director as Mother, but it's a little reminiscent of early Lynch stuff. Not in a huge way; it just has that famous uncomfortable Lynch-style atmosphere, a bit like Eraserhead but with the weirdness toned way down. It's definitely worth a watch if you haven't seen it already; you seem like the type that would also enjoy it.

    • @franciscoastorga8299
      @franciscoastorga8299 6 лет назад

      Calvin Lee Yeah man, great movie.

    • @Bumble_gum
      @Bumble_gum 6 лет назад +2

      I feel like metaphors and symbolism like this were intended despite what he's said about the movie. I really enjoyed it because I felt that it spoke about a lot of different topics and ideas within one story. Their relationship definitely was a large part of it, and I feel the toxicity of it was intended. The biblical references and comparisons to our earth only add to the film.

  • @dead123456789
    @dead123456789 7 лет назад +5

    For weeks I had a "Mother!" ad before every single RUclips video I watched. Finally finding out what it's all about. XD

  • @oniponi
    @oniponi 7 лет назад +10

    Possession is such an awesome and underated movie, nice to hear it being mentioned

  • @anverhelm
    @anverhelm 7 лет назад +44

    Mother!
    Tell your children not to walk my way

  • @beanfiend5118
    @beanfiend5118 7 лет назад +18

    "the baby-eating scene"
    never heard that before

  • @natalieshark
    @natalieshark 7 лет назад +10

    "The guy with the vibrating eyes." I'm so glad I'm not the only one who thought about that.

    • @cratonorogen9208
      @cratonorogen9208 3 года назад

      Oh no you’re not! He was in constantine with keanu reeves and they used his eyes IN the movie!

  • @calebpeacock3304
    @calebpeacock3304 7 лет назад +17

    I loved everyone’s acting in it. Like yeah it’s over the top and obvious film but I appreciate the craftsmanship of it all. It’s not better than his other movies but I’m still thinking about it a week after.

  • @beatrixwickson8477
    @beatrixwickson8477 7 лет назад +40

    Great, biblical allegory... because it's has brand recognition!

    • @boheyo
      @boheyo 7 лет назад +4

      You jest but the Jesus Cinematic Universe is nothing to sneeze at.

    • @beatrixwickson8477
      @beatrixwickson8477 7 лет назад +2

      Gargenville My favourite JCU film is The Lawnmower Man. It broke new ground.

  • @GreenDayFanMT
    @GreenDayFanMT 7 лет назад +99

    But Jesus was a space alien engineer!

    • @foxybingo1112
      @foxybingo1112 6 лет назад +2

      GreenDayFanMT There's a film I'd pay money to see

    • @Beyersdorff
      @Beyersdorff 4 года назад +4

      @@foxybingo1112 it's called Prometheus, look it up

  • @paulswietek3665
    @paulswietek3665 2 года назад +10

    "You don't look at a science fiction film to see our reality..."- Jay Baumann
    I guess Jay has never seen a science fiction film, which highlight current social issues ALL THE TIME.

  • @DarrenSemotiuk
    @DarrenSemotiuk 7 лет назад +8

    OMG! This opening 2 minutes actually reminded me of how the RLM guys "reviewed" that steaming pile known as "Movie 43". Just as... accurate.

  • @carleden8156
    @carleden8156 7 лет назад +13

    lol did anyone else see the trailer for this in theatres and it had one of those 2000s era dramatic male voice overs that more or less said "THIS WILL MESS YOU UP"

  • @MattDemers
    @MattDemers 7 лет назад +19

    I feel like "Do you get it?" should be added to "I clapped, I clapped when I saw it!" as essential lines for media criticism.

  • @buzzardbeatniks
    @buzzardbeatniks 4 года назад +3

    I love it when I discover a channel that's been around for years, so much to catch up on.

  • @vegan4theanimals
    @vegan4theanimals 7 лет назад +318

    "Don't take chances with weirdo stuff"

    • @TheK3vin
      @TheK3vin 7 лет назад +22

      "No, take chances with weirdo things" is what he's saying

  • @ravissary79
    @ravissary79 7 лет назад +54

    " I wanted to make a story about our connection with the earth"... looks at a film in which the humans have no connection with the earth.
    The humans literally come from nowhere and mother earth hates them from the first second.
    fascinating.

    • @DarkAngelEU
      @DarkAngelEU 4 года назад +2

      Earth rejects humanity. Isn't that an accurate depiction of our contemporary experience?

    • @ravissary79
      @ravissary79 4 года назад +8

      @@DarkAngelEU not in the least. Nature is a constant fight for survival for all life. We're better at it than most organisms due to our ability to accumulate knowledge, structures, culture, technology.
      Humans are part of nature.
      Like ants, Termites, Meercats, we alter the environment to increase our effective survival. Unlike those other species, we can sit around and talk about how unfortunate the side effects are when we're too good at it yet careless and we lose the balance and asthetics of the glories of nature.
      We can eve make pretentious movies that sort of express a misguided form of this sentiment.

    • @DarkAngelEU
      @DarkAngelEU 4 года назад +3

      @@ravissary79 Are you denying climate change? Cos that's happening pretty much everywhere right now.

    • @ravissary79
      @ravissary79 4 года назад +4

      @@DarkAngelEU it's virtually impossible to deny such vague claims with any meaningful intelligence.
      Obviously the climate is changing.
      The question is how much, are projections accurate, what's the expected outcome, are the proposed causes proportionate to what's popularly believed and what, if that's true, can be done about it.
      My previous reply in no sense takes any of this lightly.
      Do you think humans are aliens of spirits and aren't part of nature?
      DO you think nature is some pagan personified force that makes decisions and is trying to get even with people or is it a biological complex habitat that has trends but no supernatural will?
      Because the idea that "humanity isn't part of nature, and the earth is trying to wipe us out" is Captain Planet fairy tale nonsense.
      It isn't even self aware honest nonsense since ALL of the cautionary tales that say how bad people are and how ignorant we are and how we deserve to pay are.... all invented by HUMANS, not "nature" as a personified mind or a goddess, but PEOPLE who want to see other PEOPLE pay.
      My advice is, if you're an anti-natalist, stop it with the hypocrisy, start with yourself.

    • @DarkAngelEU
      @DarkAngelEU 4 года назад +2

      @@ravissary79 Lol I'm not anti-natalist, and it's not hypocritical to say that we should have less babies whilst still being alive. You're exposing some of your own ideology here.
      Let's first make clear that we are modern human beings. We have separated ourselves from nature, we have plenty of means to shelter ourselves from natural forces, even circumvent them, we no longer rely on the seasons or other natural phenomena to survive, so in a way we have become independent from nature to thrive. This is the modern condition of man.
      However, and this is what can be called the postmodern condition, there are still parts of nature we can't change and because we are thriving independently from nature, we are railing against the "edges" of how much human activity our planet can tolerate before its ecosystem starts to collapse. This is what we are witnessing today.
      In this way, you could say the movie isn't so much an allegory for Christianity, but it is an allegory for nature vs nurture (culture) and how those two seem to fight for control over the human condition. The movie makes a statement that culture always wins, exactly because for your reasons that all these ((linguistic)) expressions are manmade constructions: as long as there's man, there is God. However, you can't deny that climate change is real, that it is happening, and in a sense you could argue that this is like an autoimmune response of the Earth when it is being tipped out of balance, like a body fighting an infection. Even if Earth isn't trying to consciously get rid of us, it is reacting to our industrial activities, so we should be more conscientious of our behavior and moderate it in a way that doesn't disturb the planet in favor of our survival as a species and in an effort to conserve our precious ecosystems.

  • @RobTunes
    @RobTunes 7 лет назад +4

    4:43 - That description is incredible. Also, Mike, no one can say "What the fuck?!" quite like you. You mean that sentiment so deeply. I appreciate that.

  • @screentyper
    @screentyper 7 лет назад +654

    WOW 2 reviews in less than 3 weeks? Go easy on the hard work hack frauds!!!!11!!1

    • @naomi-nada
      @naomi-nada 7 лет назад +5

      lololol

    • @DangerLevel10
      @DangerLevel10 7 лет назад +5

      Lucas Rossi I find it hard to believe there's two movies worth watching in 3 weeks of time.

    • @mightymelee
      @mightymelee 7 лет назад +1

      Lucas Rossi blame hollywood

    • @MrFirstkid
      @MrFirstkid 7 лет назад +1

      mightymelee and they blame rotten tomatoes

    • @keiskay
      @keiskay 7 лет назад +1

      S James when you have a 12 k a month Patreon you can do a lot.

  • @ryanfrantz8994
    @ryanfrantz8994 7 лет назад +4

    Watching RLM at 8 in the morning is like drinking before noon: awesome.

  • @user-bw2ye2ce3h
    @user-bw2ye2ce3h 7 лет назад +13

    I think we are honestly at a point now where movie criticism is more interesting than the movies themselves - sort of like how RUclips personalities critiquing the news media is more interesting now than the actual news media.

  • @SilkyFetus
    @SilkyFetus 7 лет назад +45

    I saw this at a Regal Theater and it was basically a full house. Theb about 20 minutes in I think 90% of the audience checked out. Lots of talking and laughing and phone usage. Though there were 2 middle aged women sitting behind me that may have come to see it just to riff on it, because that's what they did almost from the start.

    • @paulpsycho78
      @paulpsycho78 6 лет назад +6

      Do the world a favor and loudly tell these people to shut the fuck up.

  • @AbbaForensis
    @AbbaForensis 3 года назад +5

    quite literally the first time i saw this movie i was super high and i just remember loving it and telling everyone it was like insane and they all looked at ME like i was insane and then i made my sister watch it with me while i was sober and i slowly pieced together that everything i thought was weird and interesting was actually some weird biblical metaphor or some shit i was so pissed.

  • @nwoking666
    @nwoking666 7 лет назад +23

    Not interested in this film. Tons of people screaming at each other. If I want to see that, I can just go to Wal-Mart

    • @milominderbinder9639
      @milominderbinder9639 7 лет назад +7

      And if you want to see a baby ripped to shreds, you can also go to Wal-Mart.

    • @nwoking666
      @nwoking666 7 лет назад

      It sure sounds like it in there LOL

  • @brianreck5971
    @brianreck5971 5 лет назад +11

    This sounds like Clue meets Lord of the Flies

  • @curtishammer748
    @curtishammer748 7 лет назад +4

    Thank you, RLM, for dismantling this movie whose ads i remember flooding my media consumption a while ago. I love it when an artificially over-hyped feature turns out to be dissapointing or worse, especially if i actively chose not to spend money on it.

  • @Melody_Raventress
    @Melody_Raventress Год назад +1

    "which is pretty fucking horrific" says Jay in the most bored voice ever.

  • @batfreeze56
    @batfreeze56 7 лет назад +2

    "You'll be getting $5 in your birthday card this year as opposed to $10!"
    I fucking died.

  • @KodiakCaptures
    @KodiakCaptures 7 лет назад +271

    I clapped when I saw RLM's new video!

  • @kitpalmer1583
    @kitpalmer1583 3 года назад +34

    the symbolism gets incredibly heavy-handed but as an experience it's incredible. can't think of many films that made me so anxious.

  • @joandarcy9796
    @joandarcy9796 3 года назад +6

    "Did they trick people into thinking this was a horror movie?" "That would be the worst thing they could've done."
    .....They tricked me into thinking this was a horror movie 😑

  • @upStomp
    @upStomp 5 месяцев назад +1

    "You just have to ignore the intentions of the filmmaker."
    Best lukewarm recommendation of all time.

  • @darkhymnsfromthecoldnorth
    @darkhymnsfromthecoldnorth 2 года назад +3

    I forgot how much Jay loves the Wrestler. Man, as someone who grew up watching wrestling in the 80s, and then was horrified as an adult watching where a lot of those guys lives went in the 90s and 2000s...such a heavy movie.

  • @tinyturnip7676
    @tinyturnip7676 7 лет назад +4

    Contemporary Reefer Madness 9000/9000

  • @JacobHillSBD
    @JacobHillSBD 7 лет назад +9

    I always thought Arinofsky was French. Who knew he was just from BROOKLYN?

  • @johnc6497
    @johnc6497 7 лет назад +239

    Whenever I hear the director say something like, "Starts like X, then shifts," I feel like that's code for: jumbled. fucking. mess

    • @kelvinwilliams5581
      @kelvinwilliams5581 7 лет назад +22

      John Cummings Not necessarily tho. From Dusk til Dawn. Fight Club. etc.

    • @kelvinwilliams5581
      @kelvinwilliams5581 7 лет назад +11

      It's all the other shit Aranosfky says that lets you know it's going to be clusterfuck

    • @Stand_By_For_Mind_Control
      @Stand_By_For_Mind_Control 7 лет назад +15

      Apocalypse Now, Lost Highway, Melancholia, Old Boy, No Country for Old Men.
      Lots of movies shift gears. You might be able to make a case that SOME of those were jumbled messes, not all of them.

    • @milominderbinder9639
      @milominderbinder9639 7 лет назад +1

      Kelvin Williams Those are really bad examples, though I'm a pretty huge defender of movies with tonal shifts.

    • @pizzaman11
      @pizzaman11 7 лет назад +1

      From Dusk till Dawn I would not rank next to it cause the literal appeal of that movie is how much a disconnect the two parts of the movie have. If u were to try to take the movie seriously it would just be bad as mother! but mother! doesnt have the humor factor as much as From Dusk till Dawn.

  • @lacristina85
    @lacristina85 5 лет назад +25

    I went to see this film with my partner in theaters, after being thoroughly intrigued when watching the trailer. No joke, there was a couple in the row before ours, and the man was so furious at one point when watching the movie (the baby part), he stomped his way out of the theater through the emergency exit, leaving his poor, girlfriend awkwardly sitting there. It's nothing I've ever seen in my 28 years of movie watching...

  • @vinicapiotti
    @vinicapiotti 7 лет назад +1

    I watched this on theaters knowing nothing about it beforehand, and it was probably my favorite experience watching a film, although I also completely get what you guys are coming from.
    I guess it goes to show how much context and expectations matter. Watching one trailer or review would have probably put me in that cynical "did you get it?" mode too, but instead I was completely involved on multiple levels: the shifts in intensity, the surreal/abstract presentation, the biblical allegory (it actually gave me some insight on something I'm not that familiar with), the execution, and people's reaction in the theater.

  • @ps238principal
    @ps238principal 7 лет назад +5

    9:38 Someone can be "dewy-eyed" or "doe-eyed," but no on outside of a 3 Stooges pie fight is "doughy-eyed."

  • @mwellnow5016
    @mwellnow5016 7 лет назад +408

    God does Jennifer Lawrence only have 1 facial expression?

  • @skrink1981
    @skrink1981 7 лет назад +11

    Ed Harris is in Westworld on HBO and hes amazing

  • @teslacoilsmusic
    @teslacoilsmusic 6 лет назад +5

    Just finished watching Mother! It's 11PM. I'm so nauseous and disturbed. Thank god that I can come here, and with that familiar sound of the stock music piano intro, I know that Mike and Jay will deconstruct it to the point of calming me down and allowing me to sleep. Thankyou for being here Mike and Jay

  • @CertifydBadAss
    @CertifydBadAss 7 лет назад +37

    lol The Ringer just published an article on "Films More Frightening and Bizarre than Mother!" and included a relatively lengthy discussion about that subway scene in Zulawski's Possession, linking to the scene.
    How much you wanna bet the writer (Adam Nayman) saw this vid last night and copped Jay's point for his own article?