Analysis: Somali Government Rejects Somaliland Deal with Ethiopia
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 янв 2024
- Somalia on Tuesday rejected a pact its breakaway region of Somaliland signed with Ethiopia allowing it to use a major port with access to the Red Sea in return for recognition as an independent state, saying the agreement had no legal force. On Wednesday, protests broke out in the Somali capital, Mogadishu, in agreement in support of the government’s rejection. For more, VOA’s Esther Githui-Ewart spoke to David Onserio Monda, professor at City University of New York.
I believe it is a wake up call for the Somali politicians and Somali people put a side of their differences and think the future of this country. Ethiopia has flagrantly violated the sovereignty and the territorial integrity of Somalia. The Somali government and Somali people should not take this issue lightly.
Somalia needs another siad barre
They should definitely be united but they won’t make much difference
@@BringbackImperialEthiopiaWhat do you mean by that? Be more direct?
@@GuledAar We are all for unity of our neighbors but they don’t stand a chance with any of the ethnic groups in Ethiopia
@@BringbackImperialEthiopia You gotta be kidding stink!ng d!rty habesh you are piece of sh*t. Somalis have the heart and courage to destroy all of ethiopia. When we take guns we barbecue Ethiopians despite our population difference when the lions of Africa take guns you have run for your life you don't have another choice somalis are not one small tribe like the Amhara savages and galla peasents we are the true masters of africa we are the most famous tribe in africa with the largest land controlled by single tribe from NFD to Djibouti with longest coastline in africa mainland. with so much history and pride. Try us and see what happens to your d!rty st!nking countrymen.
as Somali this is a sign of war, Ethopia is an aggressive state, they have problem with every state in East Africa and Egypt, and we don't want Ethiopia in our land, Threatening to invade one country and violating the integrity of another are hostile acts in the part of Ethiopia that very much show why East African countries aren't too keen in making deals with Ethiopia. we will fight for our land.
Come on now... its too late to recognize Somaliland as ur own country.
So basically you make no negations with Ethiopia. But your willing to fight to the death to deny port access to not even be leased. But also not share a port to a landlocked country, but then you wonder why Ethiopia is aggressive?
@@fitsumbulti7577it's not
the african union said somaliland wouldnt open a pandoras box among africans as somalilands case is unique and justified its also a colonial boundry the somaliland protectorate they are restoring the previous soverignty they once had like how egypt and syria merged and split and senegal and gambia same thing somalland is older than somalia but they became one with the south italian colony now they want out after genocide by the dictator they defeated holding them back for 30 plus years its wrong somalia must let go and stop being a parasite
@@cushitic173 somaliland is older than somalia😅😅 were dis u get thus in information 🤣
Never celebrate to early, Somalia for Somalis forever 🇸🇴👏🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴💪💪💪💪💪
I don't know this flag
@@timowayne6993beenta aduunka
@@timowayne6993aqoon kaaga ma baahna cawaale xabashiyohow marnaba haku fakirin inad bad ilawadagtid bada somali baa leh weyna laheyd wayna lahan doonta
@@timowayne6993who cares
@AyanSaed Sweetheart, you should focus on your failed country. I don't know where to begin but honestly I don't care. Why not invite more African countries to babysitting you guys? I heard Ethiopia is gonna visit you again next week 🤣 But seriously you people are so well behaved in Kenya and Uganda why not let them run Somalia?
As Somali🇸🇴We have right to reject because, it was Unconstitutional Act with International law and Ethiopia 🇪🇹 is the aggression over this. So, it should Respect Our Sovereignty of Somalia🇸🇴, No One Can’t tach it 💯👌🏾Iam so proud of Somali🇸🇴Community Around the World, including Me period.
❤❤
Very well said
stop being delusional!
What constitution are you talking about? somalia-italia DOES NOT HAVE CONSTITUTION!
Secondly REPUBLIC OF SOMALILAND has its own constitution and sovereignty and theres NOTHING SOMALIA-ITALIA CAN DO ABOUT IT
people of the REPUBLIC OF SOMALILAND has the moral, legal right to make whats good for the UMADA SOMALILAND
TIME TO LET GO WAKANDA DREAM AND EXPANSIONIST FALLACY
the african union said somaliland wouldnt open a pandoras box among africans as somalilands case is unique and justified its also a colonial boundry the somaliland protectorate they are restoring the previous soverignty they once had like how egypt and syria merged and split and senegal and gambia same thing somalland is older than somalia but they became one with the south italian colony now they want out after genocide by the dictator they defeated holding them back for 30 plus years its wrong somalia must let go and stop being a parasite
You must be in America
Remember Ethiopia is 120mln strong people but one should keep in mind that Somalia alongside Eritrea 🇪🇷 is a member of the East African community 301.8 mln even STRONGER PEOPLE 🌍⚖️⚔️🇸🇴🇩🇯🏴☠️🦅🦁🫡
💚🤍❤️🇪🇹🇪🇹👊🏾👊🏾👊🏾 failed state 😂
Why don't you show us ur strength?😂
Who said Ethiopia is 120 million it's lies. Is propaganda they're adding every year 10 million it's fake reality no one done real count. I reckon not more than 70 million. And just remember QUANTITY doesn't count what counts is QUALITY
@@user-wq4xi1so2u Tell me ur quality 😂
So what who cares this Is our home land even if u guys are 500 000m we are ready,
PS No More Ethiopia ask Tigray and Amhara
Ethiopia wants to grab a coastal line from Somali territory to satisfy its lack of ports and access to sea, but this will not happen, If they try to grab by force then they know that Somalis can stop that and it will be suicidal for them to try any stupid thing. Ethiopia is already struggling with an internal strive and Abiy is trying to deflect his inability to stop internal conflicts to something like this but it will not work.
Kkkkkkkkkkk hé eat your kaht plis
try if you can
@@bajajetube4131 Galla regime will fall
@@mohamedhussein4124 African maind alwoys thé samme
Stop ur lenses! Idiot!
Somalia is Strong and Can Defense. It’s national Borders.🇸🇴💪
DEFEND FROM WHO?????.IM SOMALI AND DO NOT WANT TO HAVE ANYTHING TO DO WITH YOU!!!!!!.PERIOD!!!!.GET LOST!!!!!
Strong 😂😂😂😂
@@mustafahassan2555 your not Somali
@@Cabdi_Maxamuud_Cabdi yes strong
@@Eplhighlights1600 TYPICAL!!!!!.IF IM NOT SOMALI WHY WOULD I WAIST A SECOND OF MY TIME WITH THIS NONSENSICAL ISSUE!!!!!!.BELEIVE ME, SOMALIS ARE THE ONLY RACE THAT SPEAKS THE SAME LANGUAGE YET CAN NEVER UNDERSTAND EACH OTHER!!!!!.THEY ARE THE ONLY RACE THAT ONE SIDE SAYS THIS IS A WALL, AND THE OTHER SAYS IT IS NOT A WALL!!!!!.THE MOST BESIRE RACE ON EARTH!!!!!!.
The international Community and AU have to respect Somalis Sovereignty and its Rights.
Many Governments and Organizations believe Somalia is a weak Country, but Somalia is much stronger than expected.
The Ethiopian ideas divide and rule will never work as easily as expected.
Hopefully, this is the time Somali people Will be United better than before.
Viva for Somalia
It's difficult re_union again, becuase somali southern still not to admit two independent states were unified 1960
Keep dreaming.
Somalia has been a broken country since 1991. It has no power to enforce its will even in the areas it claims to control. lol
@@user-tf5hi7yn8b it doesn't need to admit the unified states, because it is already in the Constitution.
@@user-tf5hi7yn8b Actually Somaliland 1st President Abdirahman Ahmed wanted to remain as Somaliland state of Somalia even after the civil war to avoid separatism. Muse Bihi obviously had other plans 🤦🏾♂️he seen the land as a business opportunity like other corrupt African Presidents. Absolute sellout.
@@user-tf5hi7yn8bthe flag that somaliland took in 26th june 1990 is the same blue flag of somalia so to ask question can you show us the flag of somaliland in 1960 if it was astate ???
As I am a Eritreans , I support my Somali brothers.
Of course because you guys are jealous
No one cares, Yo can support them 100000 times ,but it doesn't bring anything to the table😂
you are stupped man
@@Ethiopia_the_great1977 will be A tip of the ice Berg
@hakeemahmed2874 ohh bro😂,u stucked in 1977, today every thing is changed today’s Somali can't even control over it self, And I know in 1997, your bombastic leader tried to invade the great Ethiopia and his dream was to make Somalia Africa's Singapore now only singers and poor are left because of his mistaken actions😂😂
To respect african border colony is main factor of African Union, so therefore Somaliland was British colony, Somaliland got back its union from somalia ,not independent from somalia already Somaliland got its independent from British colony on June 1960
The failure of Abiy Ahmed's government to make a US$33 million coupon payment on its only international government bond in late December confirmed Ethiopia's status as the third African state to default in as many years.
Ethiopia pays one billion dollars past year search it that's 1/4 of somalis GDP
the african union said somaliland wouldnt open a pandoras box among africans as somalilands case is unique and justified its also a colonial boundry the somaliland protectorate they are restoring the previous soverignty they once had like how egypt and syria merged and split and senegal and gambia same thing somalland is older than somalia but they became one with the south italian colony now they want out after genocide by the dictator they defeated holding them back for 30 plus years its wrong somalia must let go and stop being a parasite
Ohh bro don't make me laugh 😂, Ethiopian Air line by itself can cover that interest as it makes 6.1 billion$s ,but it's not necessary expenditure 😊
Ethiopian airlines revenue itself is over 6 billion USD while the entire GDP of Somalia is about 1 billion USD.
If God almighty did not give a sea to Ethiopia who are we to honour them with our own God given right ? Let Ethiopia try the Nigeria sea port and explain their deadlock problem well😂😂
As a Somali I believe 🇪🇹 have no right whatsoever
Ethiopia must respect the territorial integrity of Somalia 🇸🇴
😂😂😂😂 this is a redundant statement....what does it mean??? Where is somalia? Does the government control Hargeisa Barbara burco borame and Many more....what plan do u have for the north?? What plan do u have for urself?
But, in fact Somaliland is not among Somalia territorial integrity! What are talking about??????????? Get back to primary school & study history again baby.
Somaliland isn't somali wakeup your fake daream faqash
The meaning of SOMALILAND is the territory of Greater Somalia 🇸🇴. And Now What so called Self declared Somaliland is a Part of Somalia 🇸🇴
So, Go back to School all of you and learn history of the Greater Somalia 🇸🇴”the ones urge the name🙏🏾”
@@canabcabdulle6500 that's according to u walalo....this thing is gone.... Somalia has one option now, be the second country to recognise Somaliland....ooh the other option is cambaarees...waxaan cambaareyneenaa😂😂😂 federal republic of cambaareys....can it take any action??? I don't think so.
Why did AU recognized South Sudan?
Because sudan conceded it... big difference. Somalia vowed to never allow it
Sudan agreed to it that is why
Cause sudan and south sudan also have major diffrences like cultural, religous and tribes and looks. So it makes more sense but somalis and landers are the same😊
Why don't you ask them.
Tigray Amhara and Oromo also want to, soon Ethiopia will be like Yoguslavia
We know the culture of Ethiopia, they made a false agreement with Eritrea and it took Eritreans more than seventy years to liberate themselves from Ethiopia and we don't want that to happen to us. One inch of Somali land is not for sale or lease.Historically, every ethnic group in Ethiopia has been conquered and there are wars that these ethnicity want to separate from Ethiopia.
The only thing that is true in ur comment is ur hate for Ethiopia. U guys can solve ur own problem then we can resign the agreement with you too.
@@lafforie6823What he said is true, why deny it?!
@@lafforie6823let’s just say we did hate Ethiopia, why are you acting like that’s such a crazy idea. We don’t hate all Ethiopians just the ones that continuously cross our boundaries.
Amm Somalia and it won't happen that we rather die
Are you somalia the country itself or somali guy
@khaledali5093😂😂😂😂😂😂
Dr do you know that Somaliland Has a International border like An other afrcan countries
Do you know the Republic Of Somaliland had gained it's Independence before Soomalia?
If so; you have to know
Nothing like that man
The international Community and AU have to respect Somalis Sovereignty and its Rights Of Somalia. Somalia people will fight hard and unity even if rest of Africa supports Ethiopia.
Kenya will fight Ethopia if Somalia land is taken
@@tiktokafrica370😂😂
Wonderful Ethiopia already took our land in Ogadenia region we didn't forget that and now want again to take our sea , you will know what somali people will do it.
😂 they take anything about somali somalia is not somaliland get your facts straight
To be a country or to declare sovereignty you have to meet the criteria. What can you guys bring to the table ?
Somaliland is older than Eritrea and south sudan
Somaliland and the Italian Somalis lived together only 31 years in their history, they united and became independent Somalia 🇸🇴 in 1960,and then they fight and separated in 1991, this is the only period they were one country
Tribal enclave isaaqland is not a nation.
Somaliland never existed it's only somali
Your so delusional and naive!
Well, Isaaq enclave moving with a whole lot of autonomy. Maybe the rest of Somalia is finally paying for their past sins. Surely they’d be able to do something…..but they can’t do diddly squat.
How crazy just tell us this terratory was not somalia before colonial and after colonial abd inhabitants are not somalis, Unless you want devide on tribal line which is sad.
Not an inch of Somalia can or will be signed away by anybody. Somalia belongs to the Somali people. This is final.
Somaliland should get recognition
Keeping dreaming 😂😂
To Ethiopians,
As a Somali, we hold no personal grievances against you as INDIVIDUALS.However, when there are attempts to infringe upon our sovereignty and territorial integrity, there will be a response. While some of you express respect for Somalis, it's crucial to direct that respect towards your government and address the issues through protest. Somali people do not interfere in others' affairs; it has always been YOUR leaders involved our internal affairs for the past 50 years. Despite past actions like the Ogadenia war and the 2006 invasion attempt, we remained quiet. Considering the actions of leaders like Meles Zenawi and now Abiy, YOU expecting Somalis to be quiet ? This is unrealistic. We won't stay silent; if your leaders aren't restrained, we will take action and speak out. During the TPLF war last year, Somalia avoided unnecessary conflict to get involved in your internal affairs. We've had enough of your leaders, and unless they are held in check, we will not remain silent. It's essential to emphasize that our sovereignty, territorial integrity, and internal issues are not Ethiopian matters. Be a respectful neighbour, not one breaking international laws and consistently causing trouble and seeking expansion.
Somaliland is a part of Somalia and our territorial and maritime sovereignty cannot be violated 🇸🇴
Somaliland is not apart of Somalia and hasn't been apart of the Somali republic for 30 years.
Simple if Somaliland is part of Somalia, come to hargeisa and bring the Somalia flag. We will welcome you without any harm 😂. You guys actually think this is game huh?
@@titantrades-se8ifwhat a naïve comment!
Somaliland is a prank and not a country.. Somaliland are a part of Somalia 🇸🇴
@@cabdiraxmanmaxamud2164 It is for this type of thing that others have taken advantage of the Somalis, Somaliland is not a joke, it exists in spite of you.
Even if I don't agree with many things with Somaliland, we must respect each other.
If war start somalia win
Somalia win,you must be joking, when did somalia ever won ,who,alshabab still there all those years,
Prime Minister Abiy made a call to all the neighbors in his speech to Parliament about port. This is Ethiopia's call to work in peace, realizing that nothing can be achieved by fighting. It was Somaliland that responded to the call. Others, however, said that Somalia did not respond positively, except that we should protect the Red Sea together. In any case, if Somaliland did not make an agreement with Ethiopia, would it not have been independent? If it is a Samalia state, why has it not returned for the past 30 years. The thing is, if another white citizen were to accesses and make this deal, no one would care. It is because we are enmeshed with each other. We have only one option to grow together
The biggest antiblack antiAfrican US international poltical mistake of 20th century is US poltical support for Ethiopia"s bteakup and loss of its ancient Red Sea coastal lands and ports.
All Western powers and almost all Arab countries supported anti government Ethiopian rebels for several decades and engineered the fall of Ethiopia's military government in 1991 and allowed Eritrea( Ethiopia's ancient Red Sea lands) to be an indipendent country.
There is no moral ground for US, European Union, and Arab countries to oppose the business deal between Ethiopia and Somaliland.
All Africans and black people of the world should support Ethiopia's peaceful effort to access the ports in Somaliland.
Anyone opposed to Ethiopia's agreement with Somaliland should also derecognize Eritrea as a nation and tell Eritrean government to lose their sovereignty.
What kind of twisted way of seeing this issue is? This is not a deal of business, one party wants to go to another´s land to set up a navy army on foreign soil, with all the history of Ethiopia always saying that even Muqdisho is theirs, and somalis shoudl be happy with it? Gtfo.
@@aninfinitelyvixxedvip6 Twisted??..only because its out of your perspective zone. Ethiopia is not the first country to make a deal with Somaliland to construct a base. We only needed port access to accommodate our people, and we will continue looking for opportunities to improve our economy and our region as a whole too. Please accept the fact that Somaliland has been running as an independent country for years. You have had several discussions, but everything has failed. It has been over three decades, and as I look at this issue, Somaliland will continue as an independent state, whether you like it or not, or whether Ethiopia recognizes it or not. Ethiopia's recognition of Somaliland has nothing to do with against any integration. It's up to Somaliland to decide to be under Somalia, and they already showed their stance a long time ago. Unless this is pure hatred towards Somaliland and Ethiopia's cooperation for growth, stop making the nonsense and seeing the issue in a twisted way (claiming Muqdisho as theirs... blah blah).
@@OneLove377 Yes twisted! COntorted and inverted. Ethiopia has no right to Somelia nor Sl nor any other region of SOmalia. Ethiopia should stop its exapansionism, and start making normal trades like normal countries.
We see Ethiopia for what it is, and we hear their language (Even From the mountain to the sea it is our, Muqdisho is ours). You can laugh, but for us somalis this is not a laughing matter but an existential threat. And Ethiopia will be dealt accordingly.
@@aninfinitelyvixxedvip6 Bro stop acting like you have right over Somaliland. They already made their decision. I can see why now they do not want to be united. Somaliland did whats best for themselves, this deal can change their lives and others too. Instead of making nonsense claims, its better to accept the reality and start moving forward like rational individuals united for progress.
@@OneLove377 Bro I am Somaliland
Ethiopia declared a war on Somalia by encroaching on its territorial waters and hence should revive the Greater Somalia by claiming the Ogaden as part of the Somali peninsula.Its time to also stop appeasing the secessionist administration in Hargeisa and should take steps to held the treacherous warlord Muse bihi Abdi to count.
I don't agree the professorwith last anaylisis by saying this port deal with Ethiopia, somaliland will pave the way to more international recognition. keep in mind, Somaliland is part of Somalia and it can not sign any treatries with foreign countries. . whatever happens, Ethiopia will pay the price for their reckless move. Vica Somalia.
Ahmed Abiy doesn't want democracy or federalism. He wants to be king from 1600 century. Stop the wars in ethiopian and work for the unity of ethiopia 🇪🇹.
Somaliland is not a part of Somalia, it’s a different country and we are against this MOU signed by the Somaliland President and the Ethiopian PM. Ethiopia wants to take over our country and we can’t let that happen
Somaliland was colonial border. Why every one ignores somaliland historical border.
Somaliland is independent for last past 33 years and has it;s own government; where were somalia was then since 1991 now coming up with excuses; leave ethiopia alone.
Stfu . Leave Somali sea alone . Show me where somaliland is located on the map of its “independent “ 🤣
Actually somaliland was independent country in 1960 before somalia. Somaliland is the mother country of the union with Somalia and the united nation chair belongs originally to somaliland, so somalia is illegally sitting in UN today, but diplomatic world want that way cuz somalia is the puppet of anyone who pays money.
Somaliland had its independence before Somalia since 1960 June 26
Okay why they are waited Somalia 🇸🇴 😂😂😂😂
ONE SIMPLE QUESTION?????.CAN ANYBODY TELL ME, IN 1960 WHICH PART OF SOMALIYA GOT THEIR INDEPENDENT FIRST?????.AND WHAT BORDERS WAS THAT BASED?????.SEARCH IT UP!!!!!!
Somaliland (26th June 1960) older than Somalia (1st July 1960).
Somaliland gained independence’s from United Kingdom 🇬🇧 and Somalia gained independence’s from UN trusteeship.
Done ✔️
We somalis will never allow an inch of our land and despite being weak we are warriors and capable of defending our land and ithopia know us well, the term somaliland its for all somali people terrotory and if every tribe in the continent decalares estate then we will have different africa.
Somaliland was a British protectorate. After gaining it's independence from Britain. After 4 days of being independent, it joined the ather somalia with was gained independence from Italy. For that being, somaliland has its colonial boundaries. Somaliland is not secessionist.
Somaliland is just a city in somali
Hooyda somaliyaba was kufurta hooyda no somalia allshaba dwon somalia dwon ehiopion somalnd ❤❤❤ guuul
As Somaliland citizen, I call upon the FGS to back off and mind their own business! Somaliland and Somalia had so far been engaged in 12 internationally observed meetings in Djibouti, UAE, Turkey and UK to discuss how best to agree on way forward. Sadly, they have all been fruitless, because of Somalia's weak governance arrangement and clan driven agenda.
Somaliland under Ethiopia by 2030. We have plans to take the whole land not just the port. Your militery is weak and your politician corrupt 😂😂😂
U dont want to be part of somalia right? Dhulbahante and warsangeli dont wanna be part of Somaliland. Do you respect that? Just like you wanna be respected
Somaliland have a it's colonial boundary, Somaliland take its independent Britain 1960 26 June, Somaliland also Hava a one man one vote, free elections, it's constitution, it's own money, flag, so there is nothing wrong with dealing Ethiopia? These Memorandum just need more discussion and examine, no rush at all, But one thing is important Ethiopia had a previous agreement with former Somalia president Mr. Farmaajo which he signed 4 ports to Ethiopia. That is not denible and gives full authorization if federal government claims any rights that Ethiopia to join Somaliland deal. So it's done .
The Somaliland case is different and not secessionism.
In fact, historically Somaliland is older than Somalia.
On the contrary, Somaliland has never been part of Somalia but Somaliland and Somalia tried to form a union after the colonial independence.
Somaliland gained independence. British on 26 June 1969 while Somalia got independence on 1 July 1960.
The two countries tried to form a unitary state called the Somali Republic but failed in the first place when Somaliland rejected the referendum of the union in 1963.
From there, Somalia completely overpowered and wiped out Somaliland's history until Somaliland deposed Somalia in 1991 ever since the two countries went in different directions.
Somalia become for the last 30 years the most failed state in the world. While Somaliland becomes the most democratic state in East Africa.
Somaliland has legal rights to be re recognised.
Funny joke btw your biggest regions (awdal and khatuma) don't wanna do anything with you so the question is ? Is Somaliland going to get independence with only two regions?
sam_ft007 Stop ✋ the jealousy and the propaganda
@@aminajama160 alright, best of luck with tugdeer and waaqoyi galbeed 🙏
Africa wake up, you know Somaliland was recognized before Somalia
It's very sad to have someone that is not familiar with somaliland's history is giving a chance to cover the story.
If he did his homework he would know that Somaliland is within its original Colonial boundaries and that it was a formal British protectorate that formed a union with Somalia a formal Italian colony and it was called the Somali Republic. The union was dissolved in 1991 where each country went its separate way Somaliland became the Democratic Republic of Somaliland... Somalia became the federal of Somalia and the agreement is no longer valid.
There are so many regions in Ethiopia who are fighting for independence, does that mean Ethiopia is going to grant their independence?
SOMALILAND HAD INTERNATIONALLY KNOWN BORDERS!!!!!.SEARCH IT UP!!!!!!.EDUCATE YOUR SELF!!!!!.
The regions in Ethiopia who want an independent state cannot be equated with Somaliland which received its independence from Britain in 1960 and willfully joined their brothers in Somalia.
Don’t confuse the two and don’t look at this case with tribal lens. Look at it as international borders.
Somalia has the option of accepting the inevitable and build a brotherly relationship with somaliland and not forcing it.
If Ethiopia is interested in the sea port for trade of which they have 19 % of Port of berbera agreement why do they want to have a military base in somalia? Is that not a sinister move of a bad neighbors?
Ethiopia is not smart enough to know this; Africans should keep the borders as they were 1960, otherwise an other waves of separatist movements can rise up even inside Ethiopia. We Somalis know this.
The biggest antiblack antiAfrican US international poltical mistake of 20th century is US poltical support for Ethiopia"s bteakup and loss of its ancient Red Sea coastal lands and ports.
All Western powers and almost all Arab countries supported anti government Ethiopian rebels for several decades and engineered the fall of Ethiopia's military government in 1991 and allowed Eritrea( Ethiopia's ancient Red Sea lands) to be an indipendent country.
There is no moral ground for US, European Union, and Arab countries to oppose the business deal between Ethiopia and Somaliland.
All Africans and black people of the world should support Ethiopia's peaceful effort to access the ports in Somaliland.
Anyone opposed to Ethiopia's agreement with Somaliland should also derecognize Eritrea as a nation and tell Eritrean government to lose their sovereignty.
So independance from colonial powers is good but independance from a failed state is bad? Why the double standards?
@@Lausanamo The failed state is theirs whether they like it or not, and this none of other people´s business.
@@aninfinitelyvixxedvip6 De jure no one recognizes Somaliland, but de facto it is a relatively stable state in Africa. It has been independant for thirty years, longer than the baltic states. It is a very legitimate state.
Ethiopia is divided already and has several internal civil wars.
33 years to be exact Somaliland is not Somalia💯
SOMALILAND IS FREE COUNTRY IN HORN AFRICA BUT NOTHING CAN DONE OUR NATION AND FREE EVERY ONE WHERE EVER YOU ARE
CORRECTION SOMALILAND AND SOMALIA WERE TWO DIFFERENT COUNTRIES AND TWO DIFFERENT COLONIAL BOUNDARIES BETWEEN THEM GREAT BRITAIN AND ITALIA.SOMALILAND GOT ITS INDEPENDENCE FIRST FROM GREAT BRITAIN ON 26 OF JUME IN 1960 AND SOMALIA GOT THEIR INDEPENDENCE FROM ITALI IN 1ST OF JULY IN 1960 THEY THEN FORM A UNITY BETWEEN THE COUNTRIES VOLUNTARILY WHICH COLAPSED IN 1991,SOMALILAND THEN RECLAIMED ITS IN INDEPENDENCE ON 18 MAY 1991 SO THEREFORE THERE IS NOTHING SOMALIA CAN DO DIPLOMATICALLY ABOUT THIS HISTORICAL DEAL BETWEEN THE BROTHERLY COUNTRIES.
na amuse. we are the same, you just have kibir in your heart.
Somaliland is not part of Somalia. Somaliland gained its independence from the UK on June 26, 1960, and united with Somalia. Three decades of civil war and the loss of many lives of Somalilanders after the country regained its sovereignty in 1991.
Moreover Somaliland has made numerous bilateral agreements with the United States, the United Arab Emirates, and the United Kingdom without any coordination with Mokadisho, so this agreement is just as valid as any other.
Somalia cannot stop this agreement.
Somaliland is legally apart of Somalia and has never been recognized as a country by anyone. Somalia can easily appeal to the UN
@@divinechariot5542 u lie to yourself 😂 it doesn’t matter if we recognize or not we were always two different countries go back to the history dump ass koonfur iyo waqoyigalbeed somaliland get their independence in 1960 June and u guys get your independent July can u tell we were together back then shut up and educate yourself
it will!!!! and i who has Hargeisa roots will be the first to defend the greater somali sovereignty
Why some politician cheet their people and land ?
Somalia Somali baa leh inta ka xun ayakay utaala
@@Hanad_Samale we ssc are not part of your imaginary qabiil land
You said the AU has not recognized Somaliland because of the longstanding policy of not interfering with the boundaries left by the colonialists.
This does not apply to Somaliland got its independence in 26 of June 1960.
It was recognized by thirty five countries that included Egypt, China, Ethiopia, France, Ghana, Israel , Libya and the Soviet Union.
They then united with Somalia on 1st July 1960 without any conditions.
The union didn’t work as Somaliland was regarded as any other province of Somalia and their rights were usurped.
They then took back their independence so the reason given by the AU is lame.
Where you guys been when Ethiopian lost two port and become landlock country the largest population in the world?
These guys dreamed, the day dream that will not happen Insha Allah without permission the federal government of Somalia 💪💪🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴
All SOMALILAND people broke away to somalia country since 1960 the people of SOMALILAND doesn’t want to participate somalia country we are now self declared and state and we don’t accept to interfere our independent country
The international cummunity and other organizations such the IGAD, the OU,, UN , EC have been doing superb job and doing the right thing by holdoing off sl"s recognition quest, which has little merit, because Somalia and somali land are inseparable and the same legally, linguistically, historically, geographically culturally , religiously, ethnically or communal wise etc. speaking.
Ethiopia just signed a deal giving them access. What do you mean it won't happen? Ethiopia is already preparing to so and has it's military ready to move to establish the port. What is The Federal Republic of Somalia going to do?
@@TheMafia24 NOTHING! BECAUSE REPUBLIC OF SOMALILAND HAS EVERY LEGAL RIGHT TO SIGNED WHATEVER IT WANTS
FAKE NEWS!
UMADA SOMALILAND shares NOTHING with those from trust somalia-italia
stop spreading misinfo
In terms of colonialism borders, somaliland was somaliland British protectorate and had borders with Italian somaliland today known somalia ,Ethiopia and French somaliland known today Djibouti 🇩🇯
Did some/anyone told to AU (African union) that Somaliland has its own colonial boundery.
I born and live in Haigeisa the capital city of Somaliland . No way we can accept to give or rent a portion of our land or sea to Ethiopia Historically ERITREA suffered because of such this decision and it took them after a lot of blood shed and destruction and humiliation . We don't want dark future and suffering long live Somaliland
Stop lying
Lie you’re from Somalia
Somalia is nation started from Somaliland June 26, 1960, Somali Italian, (now uses name Somalia) became part of Somalia July 1st, 1960. People need to know Somaliland is Somalia. Second, The British colonized Somaliland, is not even in original unity or land. There is state called Khautomo. They are not part of this deal of Somaliland want to have its own nation. Very small tribe that live in Burco, Hargaisa and Barbara wants to be a nation. This is as low as Somalis can be. Just to be President Somali tribe wants to be it's own land! people do research.
Somaliland claim is supported by African charter unlike the so called journalist mentioning of other hot spots in Africa. Somaliland was an independent country before joining Somalia
You people should block from doing any deal without your government approval
Somaliland separated from Somalia in 1960 and gained independence from England
Really so why the hell African Union recognize Eritrea 32 years ago when by separated from her motherland Ethiopia now cannot do on Somalia case why is that sir please explain to me after all Somaliland been separated 30 years ago from Somalia recognized or not
We dont want the detriment of the republic of somalia. We are one people, stop dividing us.
Ethiopia is jeopardizing the security of it's people there are millions of Somali ethnic living in Ethiopia that are not happy with this kind of infringement.....,all somalis living around the world are willing to defend there land ,sea and air with there lives come what may
Arab League, US condemn Ethiopia-Somaliland Red Sea deal
It warned against exploiting conditions "to extract part of Somali territory in violation of the rules and principles of international law, and in a way that threatens the territorial integrity of Somalia as a whole woow how about Palestine international law
The legality of the somali Republic can only legal when the stakeholders have come to note that we united with italian somaliland our own willing with out conditions. Therefore, we have the right to bleach the union because there are no conditions that can be an obstacle to independent
There are and those are plenty. Besides as a Muslim you cannot give away a Muslim land to a non-Muslim. They are already celbrating saying that tehy finally have the sea. I thought it was borrowing, but they think they own it. Worrisome.
as Somali this is a sign of war, Ethopia is an aggressive state, they have problem with every state in East Africa and Egypt, and we don't want Ethiopia in our land, Threatening to invade one country and violating the integrity of another are hostile acts in the part of Ethiopia that very much show why East African countries aren't too keen in making deals with Ethiopia. we will fight for our land.
@bukhariapdelahi7072 don't explain to me about the current status of Ethiopia even I'm not defending it if you going a war with Ethiopia it's upto you but for the past 15 yrs your government was distracting,underestimating this issue for a long therefore we as s/landers we have the right to choice to deny as yours if you have any concern condemn your fragile system of government
@@khaledali5093what you mean we?? You are literally selling our land to our enemy, country, we all know ISAAQ was always a cuck when it comes to other foreign countries, waligiinba waa laidin gumaysan jiray nacalaa idin dhalaye
@@khaledali5093 We condemn all the sellout politicians, who for a short term success have been poisoning the minds of the people. The blame is solely on the somalis whether in south or north. Shame on them.
Ethiopia could have just invaded and taken the land. What the **** is failed state Somalia going to do about it? 🤔
Somaliland has the authority to sign agreements with any authority as it wishes, and doesn’t require notice or acceptance from anyone else
Actually, Somaliland and Somalia both had recognized borders on 1960 when they formed the union, so that clause of AU (respecting 1960 colonial borders) would not apply to Somaliland as it was an independent country, but the problem is, AU, just as most of it's members are, is not a place where facts matter, otherwise, it would have treated the issue of Somaliland and Somalia as two states that formed a failed union and for the good of both people and Horn of Africa, Somaliland's decision to pull out of this failed union must be respected. Not doing so, means just a cause for more fighting, unstability and suffering for both people and the region.
It's unfortnate and not fair for both people of Somaliland and Somalia, an important matter like this to be left on the hands of this body. This union's Human and Peoples' rights stipulates thar " freedom, equality, justice and dignity are essential objectives for the achievement of the legitimate aspirations of the African peoples". Why then not respecting the rights, the dignity and the anspiration of people of Somaliland? Why holding Somaliland hostage and denying their rights!
I would like to Somalia ( south somalia) DEAL WITH IT!!
Somallyland is not a recognized Country. Ethiopias problem is lack of educated people in the governance!! It's amazing how the current head of the country lied about his educational background and this is what you get. He just finished highschool!!
Its not about taking back or envading ur land its all about give n take... No need to shout about it, easy Politics.
Somalia has not prove that they recognise by the UN in 1960 but Somaliland has that recognition in 26 June 1960 Somaliland has legal documents to challenge Somalia if they try to interfere the agreement between Somaliland and Ethiopia
Somalia will conquer those Somaliland cuz you piece of shit
I know you Oromo and trying to spread false information here😃.
@@nuraali5514 usheeg sxb, kuwaan nacalaa kutaale.
Damn on you saying somalia is very weak , it is not how you thing , somalia is Avery strong Independent government that has the ability to hold their country and keep it from external invasion.
and eritrea and south sudan didnt open pandoras box
We may claim back Somali region of Ethiopia then aka Ogaden.
It should be claimed back. Ethiopians mainly oromo are like israelis they think they own everything and are greedy like the israelis. So they shoudl be kept always very far.
Never dreamed of unethical country like Ethiopia can go head to head with Somalis for provocations and injustice. Somalia as people and nation never bind with foreign forces and ARE NEVER EVER WEAK BUT KIND AND BREAVE. One thing is for sure; they know how to kick the ass of Ethiopians!
There’s no such a thing as Somaliland.There’s only 🇸🇴 Abiy will regret this.
Stop crying, we as somaliland had enough of this nonsense
War won’t benefit any one . By trying to grab part of Somalia , Ethiopia is making a fatal mistake . With all the internal conflict and violence , it’s worsening diplomatic raw with Eritrea , it’s is a big mistake for Ethiopia to add Somalia to its list of enemies.
MOU between Ethiopia and Somaliland state is NULL AND VOID. Somaliland state of Somalia is part of Somalia and it can't make such agreement. Ethiopia broke the warm relationship with Somalia at moment and forgot the history between the two countries. Ethiopia wants to take over Somali sea for good not for renting or business partnership that is not possible. Ethiopia should stay away from Somali sea. If they want to use port for business purposes, let them continue to use Berbera Port without problem.
Somalis should thank Ethiopia help them a country again.
Notice the presenter had asked an important question to the guest speaker at 1:40.
His response was ‘The AU is not recognised Somaliland because of their longstanding legacies of the organisation of African unity and the AU to respect the colonial boundaries of the independent African states’
He’s blatantly chatting nonsense because, it’s well acknowledged that Somaliland was an independent nation before many of other African nations in 1960s. Somaliland joined a union with the south to establish a republic. However, this unification never materialised and Somaliland subsequently decided to withdraw from this failed union in 1990s and inherited their colonist borders it already had.
So the OAU, AU and this gentleman is chatting absolutely nonsenses.
Somaliland ❤❤❤ Somaliland ❤ Somaliland ❤
Colonial boundaries doesn't apply here. Somaliland was a sovereign country (June 26, 1960), before unifying with Somalia.
The territorial boundaries also differe with the 2 distinct colonial powers (Britain and Italy). Therefore, the justification of the professor holds "no water". Please, read more on the history of the 2 nations.
Deny or accept Somaliland is a regional government under Somalia
Why dont you call isaaq land bcze the name somaliland applies all somali territory and all the tribes in the north somalia are againest to devide our people and thats why recently dhulbahante tribe refused to be part of Isaaq rule so as godabirasay and wersangali and even some isaaq clans.
You are so delusional !
Don't panic with nothing u yourself have never went in schl
You are wrong. Somalia never been colonised, but they were invaded by the European countries but the fought back not a day have the surrendered just like Afghanistan, the land that was invaded is called SOMALIA Those who invaded are the Greeks and the British and the Italians and the French who invaded a land that is 60% Somali and 50% Afar. The British invaded Juba land and Barbara, while the Italians invaded Barbara 1915 kicked out the British but the British recapture. The tribes that fought with the British were the Ogaden and Dhulbahante in Somaliland while the Isaaq were working with the British even lead the British army to Juba land. Read the Book's that has been written by the British Empire such as Madmuller or Through Juba land. The idea that Isaq uniting with the south is complete joke..
That's dream and it will never come true.
Comen Ethiopia Remember 1977 soomaali guul🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴
We do remember, that your bombastic leader tried to invade the great Ethiopia and his dream was to make Somalia Africa's Singapore now only singers and poor has left because of his mistaken actions😂
@@Ethiopia_the_great نحن كصوماليين ما نحب التوبي الزريحه عشان اكثر عدوها من اثيوبي عندنا ولكن مهما كان ما تاخذ ارلنا ولا مبلغتنا ولا بحرنا ولا برننه معليش الاثوبيا لا تحلموا لا تحلموا معلش.
@@Ethiopia_the_great እኛ እንደ ሶማሌዎች ምስኪን ቱቢን አንወድም ምክንያቱም ከኢትዮጵያውያን የበለጠ ጠላቶች ስላሏቸው ነገር ግን ምንም ቢሆን ገንዘባችንን፣ ገንዘባችንን፣ ባህርችንን፣ አገራችንን አይወስዱም ይቅርታ ኢትዮጵያውያን አትመኙ። ህልም አታድርግ ይቅርታ።
@AaminoAbdulle-xv3yf I am not understanding what you are saying ,use English
Somaliland decided everybody else is an auxiliary, over 30 years Somaliland exhibited exemplary democracy in the region the world has to respect the people of Somaliland’s best interest. Somalia’s obstruction of the peace, development and regional cooperation of Somaliland might cost its existence. Being an enemy to Ethiopia is a suicidal attempt of Somalia. Remember both ways war & peace Ethiopia played important role in Somalia’s so if Somalia blocks Ethiopia’s interests surly Ethiopia applies ways to destabilize Somalia. The choice left to the people of Somalia, truly this move doesn’t cost Somalia nothing except being instrument to Ethiopia’s enemies Somaliland has been a country 30years ago and won’t comeback. Remember the world is not a fair place, no international law, foreign government, rule of law,…
I never seen such problem country like ethiopia river problem border problem regional problem internal tigria oromo amahara region also eritrea country jabuti somalia egpty sudan south sudan kenya what is wrong with ethiopia leaders
Ethiopia already has 330,000sqkm of somali lands that we already want back and after centuries of being neighbours they should know this will start a war in which Ethiopia will not recover from.. they should trade lightly
Look at Somali land vs Somali in 30 years we have better development and growth. All you see in Somali is chaos. This deal with Ethiopia is a lease nobody is stealing land the Western countries do this all the time. Somali can't tell us what to do this is a great deal actually Ethiopia giving a lot in this deal that will help Somali land growth.
Somaliland has a right to get full recognition 👏 👌
Ashabab is on the way Addis ababa
In 1970s and 1980s Somalia helped the Tigrian and Eritrean rebels that overthrew the Ethiopian military government.
Somalia, Egypt, and a host of Arab nations played a key role in Ethiopia's loss of Red Sea access and Eritrea's Independence.
Now what? You harvest what you sow.
It's Smalia's turn to cry. Ethiopia has both economic and historical justification to recognize Somaliland as independent country and sign defence and business contracts.
Egypt and those particular anti- Ethiopian Arabs has no moral ground to keep Ethiopia landlocked. They financed the Eritean rebels and caused Ethiopia to lose the ancient Red Sea coast with the ports.
Somalia has to recognise Somaliland right now Ethiopia port deal can be canceled because its not yet signed or even Approved by Somaliland Parliament. If somalia recognise Somaliland then many African countries will follow suit including Ethiopia later Somaliland as an Independent country they can deal whoever they want but right Ethiopia making deal while Somaliland is regarded under the international law as part of Somalia then its naked aggregesion and clear violation of Somalia Sovereignity that is what is causing this. Problem solved If Somaliland is recognised by Somalia also abiye chose poor diplomacy
shut up. you dont know how to deal with ethiopians, give them an inch and they will claim ur land like jews. u dont know how to take care of ur "country" thats why somalia has to save you from this atrocious deal.
somaliland is not party of somalia we gained our independence 26 1960 from uk the first enemy have our country is somalia they fought us every side economey , politically, militry but we never give up we are going foward untill we reach our goal recognition and i hope we will reach one day insha allah l love my country somaliland❤❤
Somaliland and Somalia were two independent countries, then joined to make the Somali Republic in 1960. The terms of unity were immediately violated by Somalia, particularly power sharing where among other things the 1st two presidents and the first two prime ministers were taken by Somalia. Then just when things started more fair and for the first time Somaliland was given the post of prime minister in 1969, the military made a coup within months to sabotage this. From there started 20 years of oppression which became finally a massive genocidal campaign to the people of Somaliland. Without grievance of all this happened. people of Somaliland came together and made their minds. This has resulted the Somaliland people to disband the union and restore its lost sovereignty in 1991, by declaring the Republic of Somaliland to restore their independence. Since then Somaliland has been peaceful, independent and democratic country. Ever since the reclamation of its freedom, Somaliland neutral did not interfere Somalia affairs, where the later has done all sorts of things to aggravate Somaliland. Now Somaliland has became tired of the fruitless talks with Somalia (13 rounds over the last decade), therefore its compelled to take a different approach after 63 years of destruction and wasted time. Thank you for the upload.
Is good for Somalis it can unite us to defeat ethiopia..maybe we'll get back ogaden Region at the end...
Great Somalia is coming soon..🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴
IF AU CAN RECOGNIZE SOUTH SUDAN THEY CAN RECOGNIZE SOMALILAND I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY THE DOUBLE STANDARD PLEASE RECOGNIZE SAHARAWI REPUBLIC TOO