Jenkaldo you should create a perfect player from all countries in the World Cup plus teams that didn’t make it but are good like Italy Scotland Holland
Jenkaldo could you do an experiment with Dunfermline or all Scottish Championship teams with rich finances and a big tv deal and see how long it takes for them to overtake Celtic and become a force in Europe?
Just letting but I've heard putting 20 Eccentricity on a 'keeper isn't too good. It means he's more likely to go rushing off his line or try to take on outfield players when in possession of the ball. Heads up. Awesome video by the way though, would love to see more of this! Edit: If you want to truly make the keeper perfect, maybe try making his hidden attributes perfect also, apart from the negative aspects like Controversy and Injury Proneness. Sorry for the speech!
What would happen if the worst manager possible had perfect reputation, knew every signle language, has Continental Pro?? I have seen mediocre managers get an excellent job just because of their reputation. So I would like to see if he would just lose every game-get sucked-get an even better job-again from the start. (For some reason I expect some comments about Moyes...)
If you want those stats to be more accurate - turn that league and the individual cup comps to "high detail" in the preferences menu (it's set to normal by default, unless you are managing in that league). It means it uses the match engine and not the reputation engine to generate results and thus gives much more accurate results much like you would get if you were managing him yourself! No more 20 cleansheets with a under 7 rating.
I wouldn't be surprised to see him win the Golden Ball, even as a keeper. He's just too good, especially keeping 32 clean sheets in his first full year at Man City.
This is a great experiment, would be interested to see his long term legacy. Especially at international level! Those clean sheets will be soooo beneficial in Euro and World Cup
Yeah you should really have went into his hidden stats and made his Important Matches and Consistency both 20's and Eccentricity should only be an average 10 or something otherwise he'll end up like Barthez, a world class goalkeeper but capable of stupid lost his head moments.
If i were to make the perfect keeper I'd sort out the hidden attributes such as consistency and reduce the negative attributes like eccentricity aswell like other commenters have said. Personally i would also make them retired from internationals, even with their 1 for injury proneness it still means less chance of getting injured and excelling for the club. Id also mess with the balance of hidden attributes to give them the born leader personality, in my experience its better than model pro or perfectionist ones. Only ever had Veron with it at Estudiantes but he was amazing for me well into his 40s,i kept makong sure he played enough games to not want to retire.
Years ago my mate created the dirtiest team he could in an old football manager game. The match highlights were hilarious and at least one of his players was sent off in every fixture. The team came bottom of the table despite some very close games and lots of injuries! How about trying this scenario in FM18?
10:32 His bravery has droped because of the injury. It is quiet annoying when it happens to a defencive midfilder/defender. I dont know how it will affect the Goalkeeper. Maybe his dives??
you got to build him bit by bit not to exeed those values... and then it seams you forgot the most important stats lige "consistancy" and "important games"
I had a regen GK who was basically de gea in terms of stats and he was poor for my team!! I ended up selling him after 3 seasons for a ludicrous amount despite the fact that his performances were average at best!!
Why are you keep doing it in England and English nationality... That makes it bound for him to be in England forever... Plus I bet you load just English language where you should load 6 Top countries... Should start in some small country... It would be more interesting moves of clubs...
20 in eccentricity and aggression is bad. And stats like off the ball, jumping reach and pace is useless for a GK. What are his hidden attributes? If he has no loyalty, consistency, professionalism and if he has high injury proness, dirtiness and controversy. He's not a perfect player. 😉
Aerial reach is much more important than jumping reach, pace helps coming off the line, and why the OP said aggression is a bad attribute (as long as we're all talking like we know best, they're attributes, not stats) I have no idea. Aggression is a key stat for a lot of positions, it's how much they assert themselves in a challenge. You know those times when a ball goes right up in the air and two players run in for it? The one that wins it has the highest aggression. In a large percentage of circumstances it's actually more important than bravery.
you cant give 20 in everything.! the game does not support it.. its has to match the recommended value that you can find using ingame editing tool. also why would you give him 20 in tendency to punch the ball? also the perfect keeper comes not just from stats but how he fits in the the tac and teammate aspects..
Reset football, no Reputation anywhere No Clubs, competition or Player with reputation Also every single Player gets released No finances, let the pyramid built itself again in time .
Henry C in the ore game editor yes unless you set a soecif rating but once a game is loaded it will generate a score somewhere in that area and can be different every game
♫♫ 219 cm with 69 Kg, yet he still has 20 stamina, 20 fitness and 20 strenght. that hilarious. Please, be more realistic if you want to make it a perfect stat, at least give him a perfect/ ideal body weight ♫♫
Let me know if you guys have any suggestions for other experiments!
Jenkaldo you should create a perfect player from all countries in the World Cup plus teams that didn’t make it but are good like Italy Scotland Holland
please make the experiment the best player but always move to promotion club every 1 or 3 season
Jenkaldo could you do an experiment with Dunfermline or all Scottish Championship teams with rich finances and a big tv deal and see how long it takes for them to overtake Celtic and become a force in Europe?
Put the world’s best GK, D, M & F into a non-league club. Fix it so they can’t move. Can 4 players take them to the Prem?
Hey mate love your video. Would love to see an Australian experiment with the national team or the leagues here in australia.
Just letting but I've heard putting 20 Eccentricity on a 'keeper isn't too good. It means he's more likely to go rushing off his line or try to take on outfield players when in possession of the ball. Heads up.
Awesome video by the way though, would love to see more of this!
Edit: If you want to truly make the keeper perfect, maybe try making his hidden attributes perfect also, apart from the negative aspects like Controversy and Injury Proneness. Sorry for the speech!
Tendency to punch should be a 10 as well as Eccentricity. Important matches and Consistency are good ones to have at 20 as well
Similarly, rushing out is also a tendency (at least IIRC).
What would happen if the worst manager possible had perfect reputation, knew every signle language, has Continental Pro??
I have seen mediocre managers get an excellent job just because of their reputation. So I would like to see if he would just lose every game-get sucked-get an even better job-again from the start.
(For some reason I expect some comments about Moyes...)
If you want those stats to be more accurate - turn that league and the individual cup comps to "high detail" in the preferences menu (it's set to normal by default, unless you are managing in that league). It means it uses the match engine and not the reputation engine to generate results and thus gives much more accurate results much like you would get if you were managing him yourself! No more 20 cleansheets with a under 7 rating.
I wouldn't be surprised to see him win the Golden Ball, even as a keeper. He's just too good, especially keeping 32 clean sheets in his first full year at Man City.
This is a great experiment, would be interested to see his long term legacy. Especially at international level! Those clean sheets will be soooo beneficial in Euro and World Cup
Jenkaldo, The Perfect Keeper MUST Have 20 Consistency
Yeah you should really have went into his hidden stats and made his Important Matches and Consistency both 20's and Eccentricity should only be an average 10 or something otherwise he'll end up like Barthez, a world class goalkeeper but capable of stupid lost his head moments.
Finally! I’ve been waiting for this experiment.
Be great to see how he's getting on with England and if he takes them to tournament success!
If i were to make the perfect keeper I'd sort out the hidden attributes such as consistency and reduce the negative attributes like eccentricity aswell like other commenters have said. Personally i would also make them retired from internationals, even with their 1 for injury proneness it still means less chance of getting injured and excelling for the club. Id also mess with the balance of hidden attributes to give them the born leader personality, in my experience its better than model pro or perfectionist ones. Only ever had Veron with it at Estudiantes but he was amazing for me well into his 40s,i kept makong sure he played enough games to not want to retire.
Gets a clean sheet every 2 games but only get a 6.82.... smh
I was looking for these kind of videos so when I saw this I had to sub for more of this and your other content
Years ago my mate created the dirtiest team he could in an old football manager game. The match highlights were hilarious and at least one of his players was sent off in every fixture. The team came bottom of the table despite some very close games and lots of injuries! How about trying this scenario in FM18?
10:32
His bravery has droped because of the injury. It is quiet annoying when it happens to a defencive midfilder/defender. I dont know how it will affect the Goalkeeper. Maybe his dives??
That man city season seems pretty true to real life. Minus the 0 losses.
you got to build him bit by bit not to exeed those values... and then it seams you forgot the most important stats lige "consistancy" and "important games"
Great video! Keep it up
Didn't play as his reputation wasn't set to maximum or near maximum, that's why his value didn't rise.
It's fun when manchester united and man city are gonna finish with basically the same points like fm said
Would be more fun if you created a perfect player and made them play for the same team for their whole career and see if they can bring them to glory
he was probably unable to play early on due to being locked in the cafeteria to put some weight on!
Liked as from Hartlepool
Perfect defender and perfect midfielder
I had a regen GK who was basically de gea in terms of stats and he was poor for my team!! I ended up selling him after 3 seasons for a ludicrous amount despite the fact that his performances were average at best!!
I feel keepers are massively underpowered in this game, hence the experiment!
11:12
Lacazette with the goal!!
Should Eccentricity be high? I always thought you wanted that stat to be low to avoid him making mad decisions and such
Tendency to punch = 20 ... This consider bad right? a perfect keeper should have low tendency to punch
20 on every stat actually isn't the perfect goalkeeper, 20 on tendency to punch that means he'll try to punch more than save etc
why did you make him English? that means he's set up to fail when he's like 27, 28, poor, poor Scott Moloney
That first full season with Man City winning the league with 100 points.....City have just finished the season on 100 points IRL !!
Maybe he's not doing well because you have a 2m tall goalkeeper who weighs 69kg... he's going to be blowing in the wind!
8:28
Lol we all noticed the City part a few seconds before(8:17)!!!hahahahaha
(Edit: wrong Scott Molony, wrong City...)
7:20 I play for Barrow AFC 🤣
Why are you keep doing it in England and English nationality... That makes it bound for him to be in England forever... Plus I bet you load just English language where you should load 6 Top countries...
Should start in some small country... It would be more interesting moves of clubs...
Nope, France, Eng, Spain and Italy are loaded. I do it in England because that's where I'm from...
Jenkaldo I know that it is something in a game that makes it rare for English players to move out of England just like in real life.
Brant Hall when you're playing, that's your answer 😉 check how many English players ever move out of country if you do simulation...
How do you simulate? I am not getting the simulation option. Can you plz help me in that?
20 in eccentricity and aggression is bad. And stats like off the ball, jumping reach and pace is useless for a GK. What are his hidden attributes? If he has no loyalty, consistency, professionalism and if he has high injury proness, dirtiness and controversy. He's not a perfect player. 😉
Jumping reach is a key stat for keepers! It helps them claim crosses!
Aerial reach is much more important than jumping reach, pace helps coming off the line, and why the OP said aggression is a bad attribute (as long as we're all talking like we know best, they're attributes, not stats) I have no idea. Aggression is a key stat for a lot of positions, it's how much they assert themselves in a challenge. You know those times when a ball goes right up in the air and two players run in for it? The one that wins it has the highest aggression. In a large percentage of circumstances it's actually more important than bravery.
One more part plz :)
FYI - Height doesn't matter, I created an amazing 5ft tall goalkeeper and he still became the best in the world.
How many goals did he score? Must have got a fair few if penalty and free kick taking were both 20.
you cant give 20 in everything.! the game does not support it.. its has to match the recommended value that you can find using ingame editing tool. also why would you give him 20 in tendency to punch the ball?
also the perfect keeper comes not just from stats but how he fits in the the tac and teammate aspects..
He had 2 England U21 caps when at Hartlepool lol
Not that unusual, Jack Butland got his first senior call up when he was in league 1.
Lucas Teixeira big difference between league 1 and non-league lol
True I was thinking that Hartlepool were still league two.
Is it possible to have the best keeper stay in a bad team and see how far can he carry them?
yeah.. Lev Yashin carried his team to all kinds of championships.. carried soviet union to european championship as well.
So Scott here is nearly half a metre longer than I am, yet we weigh the same? Sure.
Come on mate imagine a 212 cm guy with 69 kg... I don't know if it affects anything in the game but he would be slim as fuck
Goalkeeper is too tall, being tall helps but if with jump you can catch the ball that extra height just gonna fuck you up when the ball is low.
Reset football, no Reputation anywhere No Clubs, competition or Player with reputation
Also every single Player gets released
No finances, let the pyramid built itself again in time .
GK average rating is broken
what if every player in every team has 200 CA 200 PA
for a youth player does it not register potential as -10 anymore?...It used to be that way..
Henry C in the ore game editor yes unless you set a soecif rating but once a game is loaded it will generate a score somewhere in that area and can be different every game
You can always remove all the OLD GK in the game and add in young GK with shitty stats. Then they will use your GK. Simple really.
only 13k subs. Are you serious?
Put the eccentricity down. Then you will see him move on.
And this season city had 101 how
Very far from "perfect" to be honest - as some of the goalkeeping stats should be 1 instead of 20, to be perfect :-)
CHECK OUT THE WORLD CUP AND HOW HE AND ENGLAND DID!!!
Weird he's not gaining weight? Or is that normal?
♫♫ 219 cm with 69 Kg, yet he still has 20 stamina, 20 fitness and 20 strenght. that hilarious. Please, be more realistic if you want to make it a perfect stat, at least give him a perfect/ ideal body weight ♫♫
After this whole episode can you create a perfect Nigerian Player. Please and Thank you.
Wtf does that mean?
Ok.
learn the basic before do experiments
Some stat best keep as low as possible
The first few years is because of crap coaches.
Work on editing
My bad, put this out in a hurry.
Jenkaldo good conent
That's anorexic...