4 Way Street for having a live version of the Hollies classic “King Midas, in reverse”, it’s worth the price of admission… I got to meet Graham Nash a few years ago, and I told him that King Midas was my favorite song by the hollies and he told me, “I wrote that song you know!”
CSNY did down by the river live on a short-lived American TV show called the music scene in 1969. It could be easily found on RUclips. It is so good it makes you wish that they had gone through with recording a studio version of the song.
While this is primarily a Beatles focused channel, the rest of the music world adds layers of flavor, like the icing on a cake. So much of it is interconnected and worth exploring. Keep up the great work, and don’t hesitate to dive into other fantastic artists and genres along the way! My older cousins were into the folk hippy thing at the time, wonderful memories of acoustic guitars around a bonfire at Santa Monica beach…
Hollies-Byrds-Springfield!! Incredible music and musicians!! And the vocals!! Still a favorite on the turntable regularly! Andrew! Great work! 🤗😘thank you
I’m a huge fan of Neil Young and I love the CSNY phase of his career. The Fillmore East, while short lived, is the site of so many amazing shows by huge artists of the period. This was indeed a happy period by this group of extraordinarily talented musicians with very, shall we say, difficult personalities. All great songwriters, but their harmonies on songs like Helplessly Hoping rise to the level of The Beatles and The Beach Boys. Wonderful to think that those problematic personalities could find their unity in songs composed for disparate voices coming together so beautifully. Thanks for these forays into “beyond the Beatles” music. They show your love of music and your wonderful articulation of that love in these videos.
Well I guess I’ll have to break down and acquire one of these! Loved CSN & CSNY, Stills, Neil Young, anything Graham Nash, David Crosby, Buffalo Springfield and The Byrds. Harmonies were king back then in the sixties (& ‘70s). Such a plethora of lyrical integrity too. Great installment to your other brilliant episodes. Thanks Andrew (and Rhino) for a fantastic review. Looking forward to next week! Cheers
As much as I love your focus on the Beatles, I'm glad to see a variety too. CSN(&Y) are my favorite band from the era and I'm happy to learn more about them, too.
I just listened to this album for the second time and I love this album a lot… it was such a special combination of voices and songs… I hope David is at Peace… thank you for the music that you heard and shared with us 🌻
I pre-ordered the CD version back several months ago. I received it sometime toward the end of October. I can't stop listening to it. It is one of the best live recordings I've ever heard. Fantastic !!!
Your assessment of CSNY Fillmore E '69 is spot on. Live recording of the time. For me, best performances are in the acoustic set and they're still messy. Nash on pump organ is a treat. "Sea Of Madness," I believe filled out CSNY Woodstock '69, but is nice to have in original context.❤
This album is such an enjoyable listen. I've always been a fan of 4 Way Street, which this shares a similar vibe to. I like this era because the acrimony was still in front of them, which just highlights how amazing the music and vocal blend was. Thanks for the "Beatles breather", Andrew. We've certainly have a lot of fab releases coming at us to parse out.
Well THANK YOU Andrew! I now know what I want for Christmas! I LOVE CS&N and CSN&Y. I remember hearing them for the first time on my sister's Woodstock soundtrack 8 track tape. I was going through the channels to hear The Who and their (CSN&Y) performance preceded it. I was blown away by their harmonies and became a fan on my first listen. Thanks for sharing!
I picked this up when it came out, and every time I listen to it, I like it more. It sounds great and the performance is very good. I have quite a few recordings from the fillmore east, and they all sound great. Whenever a band would play there, they gave it their all.
I listened to the acoustic sides without distraction on my plane ride home yesterday. I thought it was fantastic! I am indeed a discerning die-hard CSN(Y) fan, and Stephen & Neil truly delivered the goods on this release. I've decided to order the LP after seeing this video. I don't really understand the complaints about sound quality and tape hiss. It lives in the music! This is 55 years old! It's incredible we even get to hear this in 2024! I enjoy the musical detours you've had lately on your channel.
I believe the recording of Sea Of Madness from the Fillmore is the one used on the Woodstock soundtrack. Neil Young wasn't happy with the actual Woodstock performance so it was replaced.
CSN&Y is one of my favorite bands. Naturally I ordered it and received it on day 1. It's a must buy!! I was blown away by the quality of the mastering and production of the vinyl. It's just outstanding. It took me back to the old days of live rock and roll venues of the day. The day when tickets were $3.00 or cheaper. My brother and I have sought the best Deja Vu album pressing and believe we have agreed which one it is, but I'll allow you, Andrew, to address that issue another time. 😊
Loving this, CSNY are superb their harmonies are amazing and the guitar work off the scale. Re rumours I will say right up front something I have always said that despite being a huge diehard Beatles fan rumours is my favourite album of all time and for me the highest compliment I can give it is that it is as good as any Beatles album, the only album of theirs to do this but there I have said it. If I had to take 10 albums on a desert island there would be rumours and 9 Beatles albums lol. Another great upload, you are spoiling us this week sir!
@@madteam3parents773 you mean better than rumours? obviously tastes are personal for me rumours is the best album ever made each song flows into the next effortlessly and each song is top draw writing and playing. CSNY are great and this album is great news to have available so i'm looking forward to getting it
It's a wonderful live recording. I recently purchased a clear vinyl copy. Sounds marvellous. Along with Joni Mitchell's Carnegie Hall 3-disc it's become my favourite live album from that era.
Seems a little pointless to me, especially considering the ridiculous price. I did buy the American CD set, but that was just a dumb nostalgia thing. I made a display of them for my office wall. I only listened to, "Beatles '65." Once.
Brilliant, as always. Thank you. A great review. If you ever have the time and the inkling, a review of The Kinks Arista years would be awesome too. At any rate - BRAVO for all that you give us!
Ok- I gotta get this. I saw Crosby-Nash on tour in 1972, my dad insisted on chaperoning me (afraid I might smoke “The Devil’s Lettuce” at the show… 😂. Probably a smart move actually, though I had already tried MJ by then!). I saw CSN on their last tour a few years ago, and they were still amazing. Harmony singers are hard to find. All four of these guys were/are in the groove as harmony goes. This sounds like I may ask “Santa” (my awesome wife) for this, this Xmas. Thanks for your informative Fun videos. I never miss a one. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Very cool diversion, Andrew. I was intrigued by this one too and put it on my (admittedly yards-long) listen-soon list. I should put it higher to the top!
Great video Andrew I picked this album up at my local store a few weeks back. Top notch h pressing and a brilliant track listing of early classic songs. I would recommend it to any music fan
I'm just going to come out and say this good sir, I really love your channel! I look forward to your videos every week and I always have fun with them. Thanks for everything you do! 😁👍
Excellent review Andrew. This looks like something I definitely need to pick up. I am unsure if all four shows were recorded, but the two full band tracks that appear on the Woodstock soundtrack LP were taken from this set of shows. In any case, when they were on (having a good night) and together, they were amazing.
I guess I'll have to get this. I haven't listened to those guys for years, but I may have been at that concert. I was at ONE of them that week, anyway. Now, I was definitely there the night Mott The Hoople recorded THEIR live album at the Uris. That was quite a surprise to see when it came out.
I’m not the biggest fan of CSNY - however, “Country Girl” is stunning. Neil compiled it from 3 unreleased songs from the Buffalo Springfield era and it’s one of the best things they ever did. Neil doesn’t like CG that much himself as he never performed it ever again after 1970 - what does Neil know? It’s only the last 15 years or so that Neil finally realized what his fans really want. I will check this out, they all hated Crosby before he died - and they sadly all had their reasons for that hatred. Now that Crosby is gone it must be a bittersweet moment for them to release this album, but I’m glad they did, because when CSNY were good they were great, it just didn’t happen as often as it should have done.
Thanks Andrew. I’m a big CSNY fan. I’ve just got to get this album. It was always a bit disappointing on 4 Way Street with just a fragment of Suite: Judy Blue Eyes so I’m really looking forward to hearing that. Surprised there is no Almost Cut My Hair on the electric side…..but then you can’t have everything.
Cant believe i missed thrm playing in the student lounge in Iowa city back in 1970 .. walked right past them after class.. did see the nitty gritty dirt band tho.
I helped out a little bit on the 2019 Rhino Woodstock box set. It was the producer, Andy Zax, who discovered that the versions of Sea Of Madness and Wooden Ships on the original 1970 Woodstock soundtrack album were from the Fillmore. Different night than this album, but still the Fillmore (probably overdubbed too, but I don’t know that for sure). The actual Woodstock versions are on the 2019 Woodstock box set.
I'm going to seek this out and give it a listen! For my part, I really like when you cover non-Beatles stuff, it's always interesting. Branching out is good for the channel, and I must think it makes it at least a bit more interesting for you too. While I understand this is a Beatles' based channel - the Beatles virtually invented the music scene in the '60's and influenced everything that happened during their time as an active band, and a great deal of the music that came later - even music decades down the line. So why not cover other music? Without the Beatles, none of the other stuff would have happened at all - or if it did, it would have sounded very, very different. I find what you guys do to be very entertaining and informative. Keep up the excellent work! I'm looking forward to the "Living in the Material World" review.
Hi Andrew - thanks for the great review. I am a massive CSN&Y fan. Of interest is the "red" Woodstock poster, with the list of bands. The right hand column states the Jeff Beck Group ?? What poster is that? Hmmm - They didnt actually appear at Woodstock, but WOW wouldnt it have been great. That would have been around the Truth album period - that would have been great. I guess the CD is equally great sound?. I recently bought a RED vinyl copy of the Yardbirds "Roger The Engineer" 50th anniversary edition. I also have the 2CD release of the exact same album. The vinyl blew me away, just how great it sounded, I then put the CD on and WOW - that was equally amazing, I just couldnt tell the difference. Am not into that argument anyway, but I just thought I would try it anyway. Cheers Doug (from Down Under)
What's great is CSN&Y was formed at Peter Tork's house. All of them, except for Graham Nash, appeared on Monkee recordings. Steve Stills went to the Audition for the Monkees. After being turned down, because of his teeth, he went back to his apartment and his roommate thought that it was funny. Stills told him to audition to see how he does. And that's what Peter Torkelson did. When Peter got the call, he left "Buffalo Phish" and they got Nail Young to replace him. Neil Young had auditioned for Motown as he was in a band with Rick James. Rick James was AWOL from the Navy, he was told to turn himself in. Not sure, but David Crosby, in the Byrds in June of 1967 was on a bill with Buffalo Springfield that was introduced by Peter Tork.
@@Parlogram Here's something else for you. That's Mike Nesmith in the video for "A Day in the Life". I have seen a picture of George Harrison with Peter Tork (with his Banjo) also in the DVD menu for "Wanderwall Music" is a short Sitar and Banjo duet. I Could be wrong with this, but the song "Randy Scouse Git" was about Paul McCartney. What happened to Paul McCartney and Jane Asher...hmmm.
One other thing. I don't know if there are many of us old farts here, but don't you guys miss the bands that did an acoustic set followed by an electric set? That kind of just faded away sometime in the '70s. A damned shame.
I don't know what it is about the rock music industry that they continue to fail to release complete editions of an album or event. Four songs left out! (One for each band member? :-) I wonder if there'll be a deluxe version a couple of years from now with one or two more tracks, and then another one with the remaining numbers. That seems to be the industry pattern, and I'd really like them to BREAK that pattern already. They could take a leaf from the jazz industry, especially Mosaic Records, which tend to release complete sets. But then, they couldn't double-dip, and triple-dip, and... I bought the CD version of this album - a single CD with the same 17 tracks as the vinyl. I've only listened to a couple of numbers so far, because I was hoping this would be the concert from which the version of "Wooden Ships" came that appears on the "Woodstock" 3-LP set. It's not, though the arrangement is close, but the version on "Woodstock" is superior, containing better guitar solos and Stephen Stills' scat singing over one of them. (The version they performed at Woodstock, which appears on the "Back To The Garden" deluxe box, is inferior to both, probably because they were still figuring out the precise aspects of the arrangement.) The real reason I haven't listened to the whole album is that there are just so many discs clamoring for my attention right now - old AND new! It's nice that you brought up "4-Way Street", but a fuller comparison might have been useful. There are more songs from "Deja Vu" on "4-Way", and Neil's selections are different ones. The real surprise is that there's not that much duplication between the two sets. There's more political content on "4-Way", specifically "Chicago" from Nash and "Ohio" from Young, along with "Find The Cost Of Freedom". But the version of "Carry On" on "4-Way" is going to be hard to top. It's long, and it's rocking all the way through. I don't mind the occasional deviation from Beatles content on this channel, but it seems that lately, it's been almost one-to-one. I understand that sometimes it's tough to say something new about the 60-plus year career of the greatest band of all time. But it sounds like you've got some real good Beatles content coming, so I'll look forward to that - as well as another request to cover Cream when you do decide to deviate. Thanks for your time, Andrew!
Good point about the difference in material coved by this and "4-Way." Considering that they came together so quickly as a band, they sure came up with a lot of material fast. I guess having four writers in a four-piece band helps. And I don't mind Andrew's deviations at all. As long as he doesn't stray beyond the '70s, I'm in!
Well, they do do a Beatles song so go for it! Four Way Street was a very formative album for me as I had just started listening to music as a lifestyle/statement etc. Memorable quote from it by Neil Young - "This song starts out slow and then fizzles out all together." Describes a couple of his best songs!
Andrew, I never saw CSN&Y live but I did see Neil Young with the Stray Gators in 1972 when they were touring the newly-released Harvest album. Fantastic! Hard to believe there was a time when we had never heard Heart of Gold... I have read that there was some trickery involved in the production of the Woodstock soundtrack album, and that the version of Sea of Madness included on Woodstock was in reality recorded at the Fillmore East several weeks later. Do you know anything about this? Cheers from Canada!
All the drama associated with CSNY continued up into the present. This makes me think had there been Beatle reunion, that there also might have been continued drama.
Magnificent again. Crosby and Nash were enourmously popular in Holland in the Seventies and of course "Deja Vu" was the door opener. Not that many bands have gone for extensive harmonies the way CSNY did since the Beatles showed what they can do for you. Or they just moved away from the multi-vocal approach over the years. Well, the Beach Boys used it a lot, but pushd it a little too far in my opinion, and the Bee Gees falsettoed themselves into wishful oblivion. If I were too pick a soundtrack fot the Woodstock-years, CSNY would always open it.
Andrew sounds like a great live album! One quick fact believe it or not our Beatle George turned down Crosby Stills Nash on Apple Corp. That was a mistake for sure David Crosby came to Apple offices in 1969 to get a record deal a contract but our sweet Beatle George said No what was He thinking!!!! This would have helped Apple as a company!!! The Beatles sure missed Brian Epstein!!! That is the only reason why The Beatles broke up besides Not touring the second and only two reasons!! Those 2 things sped up the decline of The Beatles and Apple because in my opinion if Brian Epstein would have been there who knows Apple would have had a stable of acts including CSN. I love CSN &Y The Beatles made some dumb business decisions!!! I know we're talking about the live album CSN&Y but The Beatles have a connection here! CSN&Y ARE a classic band in the Rock'n'roll hall of fame !! What was George Harrison thinking!!! Thanks Andrew great live album and review!
It was a blessing in disguise. Apple was on shaky ground, to begin with, and considering how the Beatles were robbed of their music catalog, CSN would have never owned their music if they had signed on to Apple. Allen Klein would have gotten a hold of their music, and that would not have sat well with Stephen Stills, who once gave one of his songs away early in his career (the song "Sit Down, I Think I Love You," which was recorded by the Mojo Men, but his version appeared on Buffalo Springfield's debut album). That experience prompted Stills to maintain creative control of his songs in his other bands and as a solo artist, and it was partly the reason why he was rejected for the Monkees besides his "bad teeth." Considering what the Monkees, especially Mike Nesmith and Peter Tork (who got the role instead of Stills), went through with Don Kirshner, it was also a blessing in disguise. As we all know, infighting among the Beatles resulted in their personal lives spilling onto the professional; other artists, such as David Bowie, were also rejected by Apple. James Taylor had the good sense to leave Apple when things were rough and wanted Peter Asher to continue producing his albums after Asher went to WB, though it took Paul to get JT out of his Apple contract. From what I read, one of the reasons that George turned them down was his beef with Graham Nash. Nash had been a member of the Hollies, which rivaled the Beatles musically in the UK, so there was some competition. George wrote the song "If I Needed Someone" for the Rubber Soul (UK)/Beatles Yesterday and Today (US) albums. Unfortunately, the Hollies released their version before George, which caused hard feelings between George and Nash's band. Another reason mentioned was that CSN played Paul's "Blackbird" for their audition, which didn't sit well with John (who was in la-la land with Yoko, to put it mildly, at the time) since it was Paul's song they were playing. The Beatles had 4 strong personalities while CSN, sometimes CSNY, also had 3 to 4 strong personalities, and yes, they all fought; maybe the Beatles saw CSN as a threat to them and rejected them. If Brian Epstein had lived, would he have run Apple?? He would have, except that NEMS would have morphed into Apple and perhaps managed other bands, especially Badfinger, and possibly spared them of the tragedies the band went through. He would have continued to keep the Beatles' egos in check and perhaps kept Yoko out of the studio.
@tammylewis2408 Great information learned alot from your reply! You nailed alot of stuff that we didn't know especially Stills bad teeth! Thanks friend!
I have to say, after looking through my collection, I have everything that Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young ever released. Solo and group, from Buffalo Springfield, the Byrds and some of the early Hollies’s material. Graham Nash is the one who held the band together, he was the glue. When the Beatles broke up this was a great group to transition to. Great harmonies and great songs. Neil Young was an added bonus, but not a necessary one. Neil being a pretty selfish person was better as a solo artist, as you can hear from the CSN ‘77 release. Rumor has it that Neil was seen roaming outside the recording studio during the 1977 sessions and wisely the band did not invite him to participate. Possibly due to telling Stephen Stills during the 1976 Still-Young tour to “eat a peach” and promptly quitting the tour, leaving Stephen to finish the tour solo. Hands down this is their best live album, recorded before the rot set in. Great video and review Andrew, totally agree with everything you stated.
I'd be curious to know how that Rumours sounds. I bought a recent pressing made in Canada, and sadly my native country has let me down, it's terrible! Lousy mastered-from-digital sound and crammed grooves that add up to a less-than-stellar experience.
I think this is overall a better album than 4 Way Street because of the inclusion of Down By The River, but there is a serious lack of Nash and Crosby songs on this double album. Might this have something to do with Stills and Young putting this album together?
I refused delivery of my copy. Many negative reviews prior to yours. And it took two weeks to be delivered from within California - totally unacceptable. I have the CSN four disc box set from the 1990s and it has all the best released, live and unreleased tracks that I believe are superior in quality to this live release.
Four way street is a fantastic album but the box set of 1974 live is not so hot. I am really looking forward to hearing this from a golden era for these guys. I was never a fan of their 'electric' live performances, for me it just did not work. As David Crosby once said of their friends in the Grateful Dead - 'They could not sing like us and we could not play like them'. If you want a great live album then it is worth checking out 'Another stoney evening' by Nash and Crosby.
Oh my, Andrew.. hope you're not losing your ideas for topics. In case you're polling, no interest here. How's about a topic on Mersey Beat or rare Liverpool groups or releases?
I had 4 way street and On The Way home sounded way better than the Buffalo Springfield version. I am listening to the Filmore on Spotify and all the acoustic stuff is near mono, which is disappointing. The electric stuff is in visual stereo. If you compare 4 way to Filmore, 4 way's stereo is wide on all tracks and has a crisper cleaner sound and the audience is well miked. Listen to 4 Way Street and I think you'll like it better than Filmore
…as an original fan it’s far too late to care…imagine a classic Swing Big Band releasing an album of live tracks from the 1930s 55 years later in the mid 1980s…it did not happen…and having recently watched the 1976? Wembley stadium debacle i’m hugely de-incentivized to listen…
Hello, can you please explain in my opinion you are the No1 channel concerning Beatles recordings yet you cannot play Beatles music of any useful length, yet there are a multitude of other channels where copyright doesn't seem to be a concern, what is the discrepancy if there is one, I have been listening to your channel for a good few years and find it very odd,,,, cheers.
I don't know, maybe I'll have to give it another go, but when I received a promo copy of this a while ago, I couldn't believe how bad the sound quality was. Tape hiss all over the place.I know this was recorded in 1969, but, modern technology should have been able to take it out. And frankly, except for the few live "electric" songs performed at the end, the rest of the performances seem really flat and lifeless.
4 Way Street for having a live version of the Hollies classic “King Midas, in reverse”, it’s worth the price of admission… I got to meet Graham Nash a few years ago, and I told him that King Midas was my favorite song by the hollies and he told me, “I wrote that song you know!”
CSNY did down by the river live on a short-lived American TV show called the music scene in 1969. It could be easily found on RUclips. It is so good it makes you wish that they had gone through with recording a studio version of the song.
I loved that show! That's the one that Steinberg hosted, right? I always liked him. Okay, I'm off to look for that here on RUclips!
@@michaelrochester48 that was a great performance too!
While this is primarily a Beatles focused channel, the rest of the music world adds layers of flavor, like the icing on a cake. So much of it is interconnected and worth exploring. Keep up the great work, and don’t hesitate to dive into other fantastic artists and genres along the way! My older cousins were into the folk hippy thing at the time, wonderful memories of acoustic guitars around a bonfire at Santa Monica beach…
Hollies-Byrds-Springfield!! Incredible music and musicians!! And the vocals!! Still a favorite on the turntable regularly! Andrew! Great work! 🤗😘thank you
Many thanks! Glad you enjoyed it!
Great review, Andrew. I found it to be a very satisfying listen in a way that Four Way Street never managed to be for me.
It is much better than Four Way Street ! That album is kinda boring to listen to, while this new live release is a great live show !!
Hi Andrew, I love the sound of the harmonies!!! The label design is eye catching too.
I’m a huge fan of Neil Young and I love the CSNY phase of his career. The Fillmore East, while short lived, is the site of so many amazing shows by huge artists of the period. This was indeed a happy period by this group of extraordinarily talented musicians with very, shall we say, difficult personalities. All great songwriters, but their harmonies on songs like Helplessly Hoping rise to the level of The Beatles and The Beach Boys. Wonderful to think that those problematic personalities could find their unity in songs composed for disparate voices coming together so beautifully. Thanks for these forays into “beyond the Beatles” music. They show your love of music and your wonderful articulation of that love in these videos.
Thank you. Glad you enjoy them!
Well I guess I’ll have to break down and acquire one of these! Loved CSN & CSNY, Stills, Neil Young, anything Graham Nash, David Crosby, Buffalo Springfield and The Byrds. Harmonies were king back then in the sixties (& ‘70s). Such a plethora of lyrical integrity too.
Great installment to your other brilliant episodes.
Thanks Andrew (and Rhino) for a fantastic review. Looking forward to next week!
Cheers
I think you'll enjoy it!
As much as I love your focus on the Beatles, I'm glad to see a variety too. CSN(&Y) are my favorite band from the era and I'm happy to learn more about them, too.
I just listened to this album for the second time and I love this album a lot… it was such a special combination of voices and songs…
I hope David is at Peace… thank you for the music that you heard and shared with us 🌻
Glad you enjoyed it!
I pre-ordered the CD version back several months ago. I received it sometime toward the end of October. I can't stop listening to it. It is one of the best live recordings I've ever heard. Fantastic !!!
Thank you so much, Andrew! And thank you so much for everything you do! I wrote a book about Woodstock, so I had to some of this stuff ;-)
Glad you enjoyed it! What’s the name of your book?
Your assessment of CSNY Fillmore E '69 is spot on. Live recording of the time. For me, best performances are in the acoustic set and they're still messy. Nash on pump organ is a treat. "Sea Of Madness," I believe filled out CSNY Woodstock '69, but is nice to have in original context.❤
Thanks to all those unsung studio heroes, making what is good even better. It's truly an art in itself.
This album is such an enjoyable listen. I've always been a fan of 4 Way Street, which this shares a similar vibe to. I like this era because the acrimony was still in front of them, which just highlights how amazing the music and vocal blend was. Thanks for the "Beatles breather", Andrew. We've certainly have a lot of fab releases coming at us to parse out.
Cheers Pete
Well THANK YOU Andrew! I now know what I want for Christmas! I LOVE CS&N and CSN&Y. I remember hearing them for the first time on my sister's Woodstock soundtrack 8 track tape. I was going through the channels to hear The Who and their (CSN&Y) performance preceded it. I was blown away by their harmonies and became a fan on my first listen. Thanks for sharing!
Thanks for watching!
I picked this up when it came out, and every time I listen to it, I like it more. It sounds great and the performance is very good. I have quite a few recordings from the fillmore east, and they all sound great. Whenever a band would play there, they gave it their all.
This is a very nice video, and I'm glad that you made it. I am very glad to see that there is more music from CSN+Y, and I look forward to getting it.
Glad you enjoyed it!
I listened to the acoustic sides without distraction on my plane ride home yesterday. I thought it was fantastic! I am indeed a discerning die-hard CSN(Y) fan, and Stephen & Neil truly delivered the goods on this release. I've decided to order the LP after seeing this video.
I don't really understand the complaints about sound quality and tape hiss. It lives in the music! This is 55 years old! It's incredible we even get to hear this in 2024!
I enjoy the musical detours you've had lately on your channel.
Thanks! Lots more to come.
I believe the recording of Sea Of Madness from the Fillmore is the one used on the Woodstock soundtrack. Neil Young wasn't happy with the actual Woodstock performance so it was replaced.
@@spicy321 Indeed you are correct! The versions of Sea Of Madness and Wooden Ships on the Woodstock soundtrack LP are both from the Fillmore East. :-)
No. Stephen Stills replaced Wooden Ships.
CSN&Y is one of my favorite bands. Naturally I ordered it and received it on day 1.
It's a must buy!! I was blown away by the quality of the mastering and production of the vinyl. It's just outstanding.
It took me back to the old days of live rock and roll venues of the day. The day when tickets were $3.00 or cheaper.
My brother and I have sought the best Deja Vu album pressing and believe we have agreed which one it is, but I'll allow you, Andrew, to address that issue another time. 😊
Loving this, CSNY are superb their harmonies are amazing and the guitar work off the scale. Re rumours I will say right up front something I have always said that despite being a huge diehard Beatles fan rumours is my favourite album of all time and for me the highest compliment I can give it is that it is as good as any Beatles album, the only album of theirs to do this but there I have said it. If I had to take 10 albums on a desert island there would be rumours and 9 Beatles albums lol. Another great upload, you are spoiling us this week sir!
Better than 4 Way Street?
@@madteam3parents773 you mean better than rumours? obviously tastes are personal for me rumours is the best album ever made each song flows into the next effortlessly and each song is top draw writing and playing. CSNY are great and this album is great news to have available so i'm looking forward to getting it
It's a wonderful live recording. I recently purchased a clear vinyl copy. Sounds marvellous. Along with Joni Mitchell's Carnegie Hall 3-disc it's become my favourite live album from that era.
I certainly did enjoy this detour, Andrew. That said, I’m really looking forward to your take on the US mono box!
Seems a little pointless to me, especially considering the ridiculous price. I did buy the American CD set, but that was just a dumb nostalgia thing. I made a display of them for my office wall. I only listened to, "Beatles '65." Once.
Thank you Andrew. I’ve got mine coming this Tuesday. Can’t wait.
Hope you enjoy it!
Brilliant, as always. Thank you. A great review. If you ever have the time and the inkling, a review of The Kinks Arista years would be awesome too. At any rate - BRAVO for all that you give us!
Glad you enjoyed it and thanks for the suggestion!
Thank you, Andrew!!! This video offers a fine review of an unexpected LP of a group of musicians so important back then! Again thank you for this!🎉
Glad you enjoyed it!
Ok- I gotta get this. I saw Crosby-Nash on tour in 1972, my dad insisted on chaperoning me (afraid I might smoke “The Devil’s Lettuce” at the show… 😂. Probably a smart move actually, though I had already tried MJ by then!). I saw CSN on their last tour a few years ago, and they were still amazing. Harmony singers are hard to find. All four of these guys were/are in the groove as harmony goes. This sounds like I may ask “Santa” (my awesome wife) for this, this Xmas. Thanks for your informative Fun videos. I never miss a one. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Thank you! Glad you anjoyed it.
Very cool diversion, Andrew. I was intrigued by this one too and put it on my (admittedly yards-long) listen-soon list. I should put it higher to the top!
Great video Andrew
I picked this album up at my local store a few weeks back. Top notch h pressing and a brilliant track listing of early classic songs. I would recommend it to any music fan
Glad you enjoyed it!
I love The Beatles , but I always enjoy your reviews on other bands and their music too. Keep up the great work Andrew!
Thanks, will do!
I'm just going to come out and say this good sir, I really love your channel! I look forward to your videos every week and I always have fun with them. Thanks for everything you do! 😁👍
Thanks. I appreciate that!
Great review Andrew. I really don't like live albums much and passed on this but thanks to your review I'm going to get this.
Andrew, we'll stay at
I wait for the new ones
videos.
Congratulations on your
research.
Excellent review Andrew. This looks like something I definitely need to pick up. I am unsure if all four shows were recorded, but the two full band tracks that appear on the Woodstock soundtrack LP were taken from this set of shows. In any case, when they were on (having a good night) and together, they were amazing.
I guess I'll have to get this. I haven't listened to those guys for years, but I may have been at that concert. I was at ONE of them that week, anyway. Now, I was definitely there the night Mott The Hoople recorded THEIR live album at the Uris. That was quite a surprise to see when it came out.
Thanks for your great review.
Thanks for watching!
I’m not the biggest fan of CSNY - however, “Country Girl” is stunning. Neil compiled it from 3 unreleased songs from the Buffalo Springfield era and it’s one of the best things they ever did. Neil doesn’t like CG that much himself as he never performed it ever again after 1970 - what does Neil know? It’s only the last 15 years or so that Neil finally realized what his fans really want. I will check this out, they all hated Crosby before he died - and they sadly all had their reasons for that hatred. Now that Crosby is gone it must be a bittersweet moment for them to release this album, but I’m glad they did, because when CSNY were good they were great, it just didn’t happen as often as it should have done.
Thanks Andrew. I’m a big CSNY fan. I’ve just got to get this album. It was always a bit disappointing on 4 Way Street with just a fragment of Suite: Judy Blue Eyes so I’m really looking forward to hearing that. Surprised there is no Almost Cut My Hair on the electric side…..but then you can’t have everything.
Don't just be a Beatles channel, Andrew. Just be a purveyor of fine quality music and related sixties content!
Thanks for the review, Andrew. I think there's as many versions of Rumours as there are of DSOTM ;)
I'm total agree with you,I bought my copy in double cd and Vinyl,its a wonderful edition,hystoric document❤
Cant believe i missed thrm playing in the student lounge in Iowa city back in 1970 .. walked right past them after class.. did see the nitty gritty dirt band tho.
this channel is grand.
Thank you!
Andrew, besides that I love all this, you may as well do the Doors while you're at it. Carry on!
Good call!
Well that puts CSN&Y on my wantlist!
I helped out a little bit on the 2019 Rhino Woodstock box set. It was the producer, Andy Zax, who discovered that the versions of Sea Of Madness and Wooden Ships on the original 1970 Woodstock soundtrack album were from the Fillmore. Different night than this album, but still the Fillmore (probably overdubbed too, but I don’t know that for sure). The actual Woodstock versions are on the 2019 Woodstock box set.
Thanks for the info!
The first time I went to a Neil Young concert, it was the Time Fades Away tour. I also have the original live album. I am still waiting for the CD.
Time Fades Away IS on CD legally. It was finally released as a standalone CD in July 2022.
@@treadman28 Thanks but it took awhile.
Interesting. This is the first positive review I've seen of this set.
Nice episode! I would love to see you tackle some of The Who’s albums in the future.
Looking forward to your upcoming Beatles content. - Roger
Thanks Roger! I will be covering a Who album in a few weeks time.
if i remember right, the complete september run at the fillmore used to be on wolfgangs vault and has been bootlegged ad nausseum
CSNY had great harmonies.
I'm going to seek this out and give it a listen! For my part, I really like when you cover non-Beatles stuff, it's always interesting. Branching out is good for the channel, and I must think it makes it at least a bit more interesting for you too. While I understand this is a Beatles' based channel - the Beatles virtually invented the music scene in the '60's and influenced everything that happened during their time as an active band, and a great deal of the music that came later - even music decades down the line. So why not cover other music? Without the Beatles, none of the other stuff would have happened at all - or if it did, it would have sounded very, very different. I find what you guys do to be very entertaining and informative. Keep up the excellent work! I'm looking forward to the "Living in the Material World" review.
Glad you enjoy the videos. Lots more to come!
great review!
Thank you!
thanks for the infomercial....
Bet you’re fun at parties… lol! 🙄
cover looks beautiful! by the way cs&n was another dads favorite group
Hi Andrew - thanks for the great review. I am a massive CSN&Y fan. Of interest is the "red" Woodstock poster, with the list of bands. The right hand column states the Jeff Beck Group ?? What poster is that? Hmmm - They didnt actually appear at Woodstock, but WOW wouldnt it have been great. That would have been around the Truth album period - that would have been great. I guess the CD is equally great sound?. I recently bought a RED vinyl copy of the Yardbirds "Roger The Engineer" 50th anniversary edition. I also have the 2CD release of the exact same album. The vinyl blew me away, just how great it sounded, I then put the CD on and WOW - that was equally amazing, I just couldnt tell the difference. Am not into that argument anyway, but I just thought I would try it anyway. Cheers Doug (from Down Under)
Cheers Doug! Thanks for watching!
In 2019; The 4 way street album has been reissues as a triple vinyl.
Thanks for that. I love C S N & Y
What's great is CSN&Y was formed at Peter Tork's house. All of them, except for Graham Nash, appeared on Monkee recordings. Steve Stills went to the Audition for the Monkees. After being turned down, because of his teeth, he went back to his apartment and his roommate thought that it was funny. Stills told him to audition to see how he does. And that's what Peter Torkelson did. When Peter got the call, he left "Buffalo Phish" and they got Nail Young to replace him. Neil Young had auditioned for Motown as he was in a band with Rick James. Rick James was AWOL from the Navy, he was told to turn himself in. Not sure, but David Crosby, in the Byrds in June of 1967 was on a bill with Buffalo Springfield that was introduced by Peter Tork.
Great story! Thanks for watching!
@@Parlogram Here's something else for you. That's Mike Nesmith in the video for "A Day in the Life". I have seen a picture of George Harrison with Peter Tork (with his Banjo) also in the DVD menu for "Wanderwall Music" is a short Sitar and Banjo duet. I Could be wrong with this, but the song "Randy Scouse Git" was about Paul McCartney. What happened to Paul McCartney and Jane Asher...hmmm.
The full album is available to listen to on the Rhino RUclips channel
Legendary Band
__ Harvest
__ Crosby Stills & Nash (debut album)
And Deja vu -- All Brilliant __
One other thing. I don't know if there are many of us old farts here, but don't you guys miss the bands that did an acoustic set followed by an electric set? That kind of just faded away sometime in the '70s. A damned shame.
Thanks Andrew, heard this was a good one..✌️. Edit: that Garrod turntable is beautiful..did i spell that correctly?
Glad you enjoyed it, Dave. It’s Garrard by the way 😉
I don't know what it is about the rock music industry that they continue to fail to release complete editions of an album or event. Four songs left out! (One for each band member? :-) I wonder if there'll be a deluxe version a couple of years from now with one or two more tracks, and then another one with the remaining numbers. That seems to be the industry pattern, and I'd really like them to BREAK that pattern already. They could take a leaf from the jazz industry, especially Mosaic Records, which tend to release complete sets. But then, they couldn't double-dip, and triple-dip, and...
I bought the CD version of this album - a single CD with the same 17 tracks as the vinyl. I've only listened to a couple of numbers so far, because I was hoping this would be the concert from which the version of "Wooden Ships" came that appears on the "Woodstock" 3-LP set. It's not, though the arrangement is close, but the version on "Woodstock" is superior, containing better guitar solos and Stephen Stills' scat singing over one of them. (The version they performed at Woodstock, which appears on the "Back To The Garden" deluxe box, is inferior to both, probably because they were still figuring out the precise aspects of the arrangement.) The real reason I haven't listened to the whole album is that there are just so many discs clamoring for my attention right now - old AND new!
It's nice that you brought up "4-Way Street", but a fuller comparison might have been useful. There are more songs from "Deja Vu" on "4-Way", and Neil's selections are different ones. The real surprise is that there's not that much duplication between the two sets. There's more political content on "4-Way", specifically "Chicago" from Nash and "Ohio" from Young, along with "Find The Cost Of Freedom". But the version of "Carry On" on "4-Way" is going to be hard to top. It's long, and it's rocking all the way through.
I don't mind the occasional deviation from Beatles content on this channel, but it seems that lately, it's been almost one-to-one. I understand that sometimes it's tough to say something new about the 60-plus year career of the greatest band of all time. But it sounds like you've got some real good Beatles content coming, so I'll look forward to that - as well as another request to cover Cream when you do decide to deviate. Thanks for your time, Andrew!
Good point about the difference in material coved by this and "4-Way." Considering that they came together so quickly as a band, they sure came up with a lot of material fast. I guess having four writers in a four-piece band helps. And I don't mind Andrew's deviations at all. As long as he doesn't stray beyond the '70s, I'm in!
Well, they do do a Beatles song so go for it! Four Way Street was a very formative album for me as I had just started listening to music as a lifestyle/statement etc. Memorable quote from it by Neil Young - "This song starts out slow and then fizzles out all together." Describes a couple of his best songs!
Andrew, I never saw CSN&Y live but I did see Neil Young with the Stray Gators in 1972 when they were touring the newly-released Harvest album. Fantastic! Hard to believe there was a time when we had never heard Heart of Gold...
I have read that there was some trickery involved in the production of the Woodstock soundtrack album, and that the version of Sea of Madness included on Woodstock was in reality recorded at the Fillmore East several weeks later. Do you know anything about this?
Cheers from Canada!
All the drama associated with CSNY continued up into the present. This makes me think had there been Beatle reunion, that there also might have been continued drama.
I already like this album better than 4 Way Street. It’s superior to any bootleg of the era I’ve owned.
Which album would you recommend. 4 way street or the new Filmore release. On a budget.
Magnificent again. Crosby and Nash were enourmously popular in Holland in the Seventies and of course "Deja Vu" was the door opener. Not that many bands have gone for extensive harmonies the way CSNY did since the Beatles showed what they can do for you. Or they just moved away from the multi-vocal approach over the years. Well, the Beach Boys used it a lot, but pushd it a little too far in my opinion, and the Bee Gees falsettoed themselves into wishful oblivion. If I were too pick a soundtrack fot the Woodstock-years, CSNY would always open it.
Andrew sounds like a great live album! One quick fact believe it or not our Beatle George turned down Crosby Stills Nash on Apple Corp. That was a mistake for sure David Crosby came to Apple offices in 1969 to get a record deal a contract but our sweet Beatle George said No what was He thinking!!!! This would have helped Apple as a company!!! The Beatles sure missed Brian Epstein!!! That is the only reason why The Beatles broke up besides Not touring the second and only two reasons!! Those 2 things sped up the decline of The Beatles and Apple because in my opinion if Brian Epstein would have been there who knows Apple would have had a stable of acts including CSN. I love CSN &Y The Beatles made some dumb business decisions!!! I know we're talking about the live album CSN&Y but The Beatles have a connection here! CSN&Y ARE a classic band in the Rock'n'roll hall of fame !! What was George Harrison thinking!!! Thanks Andrew great live album and review!
Thanks John. Glad you enjoyed it!
It was a blessing in disguise. Apple was on shaky ground, to begin with, and considering how the Beatles were robbed of their music catalog, CSN would have never owned their music if they had signed on to Apple. Allen Klein would have gotten a hold of their music, and that would not have sat well with Stephen Stills, who once gave one of his songs away early in his career (the song "Sit Down, I Think I Love You," which was recorded by the Mojo Men, but his version appeared on Buffalo Springfield's debut album). That experience prompted Stills to maintain creative control of his songs in his other bands and as a solo artist, and it was partly the reason why he was rejected for the Monkees besides his "bad teeth." Considering what the Monkees, especially Mike Nesmith and Peter Tork (who got the role instead of Stills), went through with Don Kirshner, it was also a blessing in disguise. As we all know, infighting among the Beatles resulted in their personal lives spilling onto the professional; other artists, such as David Bowie, were also rejected by Apple. James Taylor had the good sense to leave Apple when things were rough and wanted Peter Asher to continue producing his albums after Asher went to WB, though it took Paul to get JT out of his Apple contract.
From what I read, one of the reasons that George turned them down was his beef with Graham Nash. Nash had been a member of the Hollies, which rivaled the Beatles musically in the UK, so there was some competition. George wrote the song "If I Needed Someone" for the Rubber Soul (UK)/Beatles Yesterday and Today (US) albums. Unfortunately, the Hollies released their version before George, which caused hard feelings between George and Nash's band. Another reason mentioned was that CSN played Paul's "Blackbird" for their audition, which didn't sit well with John (who was in la-la land with Yoko, to put it mildly, at the time) since it was Paul's song they were playing. The Beatles had 4 strong personalities while CSN, sometimes CSNY, also had 3 to 4 strong personalities, and yes, they all fought; maybe the Beatles saw CSN as a threat to them and rejected them.
If Brian Epstein had lived, would he have run Apple?? He would have, except that NEMS would have morphed into Apple and perhaps managed other bands, especially Badfinger, and possibly spared them of the tragedies the band went through. He would have continued to keep the Beatles' egos in check and perhaps kept Yoko out of the studio.
@tammylewis2408 Great information learned alot from your reply! You nailed alot of stuff that we didn't know especially Stills bad teeth! Thanks friend!
I think I prefer this over 4 Way Street. It’s a great album.
What are the songs that were omitted from the LP?
My copy of Live At Fillmore East is on clear vinyl.
I have to say, after looking through my collection, I have everything that Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young ever released. Solo and group, from Buffalo Springfield, the Byrds and some of the early Hollies’s material. Graham Nash is the one who held the band together, he was the glue. When the Beatles broke up this was a great group to transition to. Great harmonies and great songs. Neil Young was an added bonus, but not a necessary one. Neil being a pretty selfish person was better as a solo artist, as you can hear from the CSN ‘77 release. Rumor has it that Neil was seen roaming outside the recording studio during the 1977 sessions and wisely the band did not invite him to participate. Possibly due to telling Stephen Stills during the 1976 Still-Young tour to “eat a peach” and promptly quitting the tour, leaving Stephen to finish the tour solo. Hands down this is their best live album, recorded before the rot set in. Great video and review Andrew, totally agree with everything you stated.
Thank you, Sir.
I noticed on Amazon US there is a EU edition.Would you know if there is a difference.
I'd be curious to know how that Rumours sounds. I bought a recent pressing made in Canada, and sadly my native country has let me down, it's terrible! Lousy mastered-from-digital sound and crammed grooves that add up to a less-than-stellar experience.
I think this is overall a better album than 4 Way Street because of the inclusion of Down By The River, but there is a serious lack of Nash and Crosby songs on this double album. Might this have something to do with Stills and Young putting this album together?
Does it include three unreleased recordings of them fighting backstage?
I refused delivery of my copy. Many negative reviews prior to yours. And it took two weeks to be delivered from within California - totally unacceptable. I have the CSN four disc box set from the 1990s and it has all the best released, live and unreleased tracks that I believe are superior in quality to this live release.
Nice if you don't have any CSN and Y albums. The biggest negative is the price. It's far too expensive in the UK on both vinyl and cd.
Another "lost" tape found.
Four way street is a fantastic album but the box set of 1974 live is not so hot. I am really looking forward to hearing this from a golden era for these guys. I was never a fan of their 'electric' live performances, for me it just did not work. As David Crosby once said of their friends in the Grateful Dead - 'They could not sing like us and we could not play like them'. If you want a great live album then it is worth checking out 'Another stoney evening' by Nash and Crosby.
Oh my, Andrew.. hope you're not losing your ideas for topics. In case you're polling, no interest here. How's about a topic on Mersey Beat or rare Liverpool groups or releases?
There's room for everyone including Merseybeat.
I had 4 way street and On The Way home sounded way better than the Buffalo Springfield version. I am listening to the Filmore on Spotify and all the acoustic stuff is near mono, which is disappointing. The electric stuff is in visual stereo. If you compare 4 way to Filmore, 4 way's stereo is wide on all tracks and has a crisper cleaner sound and the audience is well miked. Listen to 4 Way Street and I think you'll like it better than Filmore
…as an original fan it’s far too late to care…imagine a classic Swing Big Band releasing an album of live tracks from the 1930s 55 years later in the mid 1980s…it did not happen…and having recently watched the 1976? Wembley stadium debacle i’m hugely de-incentivized to listen…
Hello, can you please explain in my opinion you are the No1 channel concerning Beatles recordings yet you cannot play Beatles music of any useful length, yet there are a multitude of other channels where copyright doesn't seem to be a concern, what is the discrepancy if there is one, I have been listening to your channel for a good few years and find it very odd,,,, cheers.
I’d like to know the answer too. Maybe you should ask them.
@@Parlogramit was a sincere question, no need to be silly about it!
@@marcmarcello981 Sorry, but I really have no idea.
No it's not by a long chalk
Why can’t we just get black. These color pressings are getting out of hand
My copy is on black vinyl.
@@Parlogram it was really about the Fleetwood Mac and the other one you talked about.
I really don't care for Neil Young.
Why is it important that you post that? I don't think anyone cares!
I don't know, maybe I'll have to give it another go, but when I received a promo copy of this a while ago, I couldn't believe how bad the sound quality was. Tape hiss all over the place.I know this was recorded in 1969, but, modern technology should have been able to take it out. And frankly, except for the few live "electric" songs performed at the end, the rest of the performances seem really flat and lifeless.
I’d rather have some tape hiss than digital noise reduction.
@@Parlogram To each their own. But for me the tape hiss is more than just a little, it's really prominent and for me distracting as all heck.
I'd have to skip Our House. I find it childish.
Your comment is childish.