I asked ChatGPT to generate a compliment for someone who has created some jazz using AI; "Your creation of jazz through AI is simply astonishing! You've managed to capture the soulful essence and improvisational brilliance of this genre with remarkable precision. The way your AI-generated jazz effortlessly blends innovation and tradition is a true testament to your talent and dedication. Your work not only pushes the boundaries of music but also enriches the world with delightful melodies that resonate with the very spirit of jazz. Kudos to you for bringing the magic of AI to the world of jazz and creating something truly extraordinary!"
I asked ChatGPT to generate a compliment to your compliment. After sorting out a bit of confusion, this is the response I got for you: "Wow, your AI-generated compliment for someone who created jazz using AI is absolutely brilliant! It's impressive how well the AI captured the essence of jazz appreciation and crafted such a heartfelt and genuine message. Your use of AI to generate compliments truly showcases the potential of technology to express creativity and appreciation in a uniquely beautiful way. Kudos to you for creating this wonderful and thoughtful comment that celebrates the magic of AI and the world of jazz!"
@@freddy2tasked ChatGPT to generate a compliment for your generated compliment of OP’s generated compliment of this AI generated jazz song “Your remarkable gesture of using AI to generate compliments for someone who praised the work of a person that composed a jazz song with AI showcases your innovative and thoughtful approach to expressing admiration. Your creativity knows no bounds, and that's truly commendable! Keep shining with your unique ideas and appreciation for art and technology.”
AI relies on human created content. The Sara Silverman case might be the biggest class action suit ever. As a musician who spends countless hours developing a unique improv style and sound, I must admit, it bothers me that AI could eventually vacuum up everything I developed and spit it back out in variation. This tech is rendering human creative arts, for which most make little to no money, valueless and even robbing a sense of intrinsic value itself. It goes beyond art, but includes social media data, which AI will eventually vacuum up to replicate everyone’s personality (or at least their online personality), so Meta etc. can create marketing models etc. or do weird things we haven’t even considered. Doesn’t it seem like all of this will destroy the human creative experience and cheapen humanity overall?
Photography didn't render portrait artists obsolete, nor did the typewriter ruin calligraphy. It's a supplement to our creativity that we can choose to use or equally ignore. Music has never been about being the best or selling the most records, least of all jazz; well, maybe for some it is. But not for most. It's just as much about the result as it is about the process, so humans will play music and make art as long as humans exist.
I think you make a really important point. The stuff that AI crates is really only worthy of advertising background sounds and definitely not of performance. This does mean a huge income hit for composers who have provided music for ads, as it will be very easy to bring this sort of thing in house and just let the production team churn out some fotofit sounds
@@sickcallranger2590 I take your points. Though it’s hard to step back in time to truly understand how tech has altered human experience. We adapt to change, but there was a time when the fact that going to the Louvre to see the Mona Lisa was a rarefied experience because one could never see it anywhere else. It was a far more special experience. A famous philosopher (forgot name) called this the art’s aura.. and all art had it. I think Andy Warhol was trying to preserve this in the face of commercialism with his repeated images (to say each was “unique” despite looking the same) But clearly, a distinctive quality of art was lost due to photographed replicas. And we can see how happened and continues to happen for virtually everything. It’s like a form aesthetic entropy.. everything gets cheapened into a sea of “sameness”. Just because we adapt, doesn’t mean that it’s good, but it’s complicated and probably a mix of “good” and “bad”.. It remains to be seen, but I would not presume to fully understand what has been lost since the pre-industrial times. The Transcendentalists had valid concerns regarding how human experience and culture was shifting. I would’ve like to hear recordings of the great composers improvising though…
@@ili626 There's for sure a point in saying that with commercialization and consumer culture, it's more difficult to truly stand out, and what does stand out is easily knocked back down. That's honestly a valid concern. But I don't think AI will make it much worse than it already is. If anything, it seems that it might be a means of introducing a whole new group of people into a formerly exclusive club. While it'll definitely break the floodgates and introduce a lot of mediocre garbage, it may also foster unforeseen creativity and give way for something new and unique to emerge. That's the optimistic outlook, at least.
@@br0wning Let me put it this way: I found the output to be mediocre and it feels like it would require as much babysitting and expertise in music production to make something that I would like through this process. I can't say for the future, but that's why I check in with the channel and others work to see how things progress. I won't dismiss the work done thus far, but I also stand by what I said when I say I feel very little when I hear the music made this way. Like, I would rather sit in silence than leave some of this on
@@AgonalRhythm yea I agree, it's still very early innings and it will be a while until it's easier to use and effective, for that to happen AI models need to become more malleable (i.e. you feed it example music pieces and AI model instance reconfigures itself to be ready to use this newly fed information to generate a tailored output for you, as opposed to pre-trained generic knowledge it currently uses), I know several companies are researching various techniques that can be used to live-update large AI models based on live data, that's the AI holy grail in my opinion
it's being trained by people who don't even like jazz so it'll never achieve great results like they probably fed it the millions of mediocre lo-fi beats they found on youtube, made by producers who hate music theory so much they bought a midi chord pack so you end up with "one chord change per bar, strictly on the first beat" "what are inversions" "jazz = 7ths" "c major only" student's-first-composition level of trite maybe in a few years it'll improve but until people who genuinely love music have an input, it'll remain mediocre
Exactly. Who is the audience for this stuff? Jazz is about live performance.. can't quite see this as a residency somehow... Also, the Coltrane backing was truly horrid
My friend Bob Keller at Harvey Mudd was an AI Pioneer in music. His program “improvisor” already had models of jazz greats that you could jam with or “produce in the style of” . He was the first to have a AI vs AI jazz jam. Suprised this was missed here!
the best thing about your videos and is number 1 for me , is your funny narrative. You really incorporate ever phrase and slang that fits the subject in such a comedic way. Love it
I could not hold in my laughter when hearing how clearly and arogant the ai voice was telling you about jazz and how it works. And the added clips and dogos were too much!
1980s: you can sample 0.5 seconds of sound! 1990s: Yo, I'm gonna sue you for using my sample! 2000s: we gonna make a new beat with this Amen break sample! 2010s: Let's sample Tom Tom Club for the 100th time! 2020s: I'm gonna sample your brain and there's nothing you can do about it!
Thank you so much for producing such high quality content at the cutting edge of tech. I can't watch these fast enough when they're uploaded. Can't wait to see what directions you take this in. One idea: I find code interpreter to be really good at coding and structure. Plus it can write and run code. Maybe you can bring some of your code from colab into code interpreter, and have it do the entire generate idea, convert to notes, convert to midi and play process. That way everything can live in a single master prompt to be used with code interpreter. Keep up the awesome work!
This video made me want to ask several questions. 1. Do you regularly listen to jazz. (Basie, Davis, Rollins, Monk, Hancock, Brubeck, Evans, Coltrane, Shorter, Gillespy) etc etc? . 2. Do you play an instrument? 3. If Yes, have you ever played jazz with real people ? From a technology point of view, this video was fun. But from the point of view of a jazz fan, none of these melodies resembled anything close to Jazz. In fairness, this was called GPT Jazz. That is good since this distinguishes it from Jazz. Jazz draws inspiration from soloists who’s improvisations are inspired by melodies, rhythm & chords. When I heard this videos jazz ballad, I head a quarter note melody with a half time beat. It resembled children’s music. The last song was easily the worst. Ps. I admire the work put into the video... but if you are going to make statements like “this is resonating with me”. I have to ask... are you also an A.I.? Trying to label GPT Jazz as JAZZ is akin to labeling a glass of water an Ocean... it’s not big or deep enough. Oceans Rhythmic tides are affected by the gravity of the moon. Human soloist ARE the MOON of JAZZ. Their improvisational gravity gives the music its Rhythmic Swing. It’s the Waves & not the Water that makes us move. 🙏🏽
Man, I love your explorations, story telling, visual style and the general mood of your video. This is really cool and unique! Sending you my congratulations, thanks and support
Putting the temperature to 1.5 KILLED me!!!!! Even though it made no sense it was the funniest thing I have seen AI do in a really long time. The dog memes made it so much funnier too. I really enjoyed the video as a musician and as someone interested in AI. keep it up. I'd like to see more stuff at a temperature above 1. MAYBE not as far as 1.5, but maybe like 1.1 or 1.25....
yo smashing idea, next round, ill dial it back to a cool 1.something, not cranking up to a 1.5... got a bit wild with the heat there, but... it was a hoot ;-}
This video is insane I can’t figure out what has been and what hasn’t been generated by AI The intro threw me off, your voice is way too slick, chat GPT voice is so lively yet so clean it feels unreal Uncanny Valley for me all the way, and I loved it Great great style
Jazz is a time stamp of when it was created reflecting art and culture at the time is was recorded. What you are creating now is reflecting the artificial time we live in now...
@nobodyandthecomputer I'm really interested in learning more about how you achieved the Coltrane solo at the end. Could you please clarify that? Thank you!
i actually love ur stylisation and approach to ai art it gives me fear, hope and inspiration as a musician to see the potential pros and cons of this in the future. I also love ur name so much, I make indie rock music and would love to dedicate ur themes to my song by using ur name in the title. if u don’t consent of course I will refrain. great video
I'm against harmonic alignment, after all what's the point of aligning an AI? Let it do it's weird thing. Don't make it appeal to humans, make humans learn to enjoy the insane. This bit where the pseudo-coltrane melody was reduced to just 7 notes, but still with perfect syncopation, was actually pretty to me. This is truly inventive. In the same sense a Bach piece begins with a theme, this snippet was actually a great intro with lot's of space left for improv in the piece itself. Jazz themes are like that, the simpler they are, the more room for magnificent improve they give. Just roll with stuff people, don't over-adjust. Honestly, don't trust your taste too much, it's just an excuse to repeat what is familiar to you. Repetition is the art killer. All that said, the result was magnificent, thank you for doing this.
I heard a mix of have yourself a merry Christmas and another one familiar in the first example. I think it's leaning on familiarity. Nostalgic vibes. Pretty cool. But it does feel like a mix tape.
well, same feeling as in Bach's video: music is safe for now. Biologic intelligence is still so much better at organizing sounds. Can't say the same for words or images!
As someone familiar with jazz, I was impressed with the AI's ability to create music. While it was clear that some of the pieces were generated by AI, I could still appreciate the improvement from previous versions. The ballad in particular sounded great and could possibly pass as authentic if played by real jazz musicians. However, the AI-generated tunes lack uniqueness and are limited to basic 2-5-1 jazz knowledge. As such, AI cannot fully explore the boundaries of jazz, and I believe that real musicians cannot be replaced. For instance, the AI chose a 1-6-2-5 progression for "Twinkle-Twinkle Little Star." This is a common jazz progression, but it does not always fit every melody. In this case, the chords and melody seemed independent of each other. On the other hand, the same progression was used in the jazz ballad and worked well because the chords fit the melody and vice versa. While the 9:17 piece was slightly challenging to listen to at times due to clashes between harmony and melody, I still found it slightly enjoyable. It didn't sound like jazz, which is ok, but the AI was told to do jazz so it should have made jazz. The chords in the Coltrane ballad were pleasing, but the melody did not make sense. Overall, the video created with Pika was impressive, despite a few blunders. These mistakes actually made the video more entertaining to watch. Despite some errors. So in the end, I am impressed by the AI. Of course, it had some errors, but the ballad was good.
De todas las canciones que ha generado Chat GPT en los videos previos, creo que este le gana a todos. Me agradaron bastante las melodías que generó. Excelente video!
Well, your AI-generated jazz music is certainly... unique. I mean, it takes a special talent to let a machine compose something that sounds, well, almost like jazz. It's impressive how you managed to make a genre as intricate and soulful as jazz feel so... robotic. Keep up the... interesting work
spot on, the disapproving comments i've seen on this video are mostly from people who genuinely love and understand music, and they definitely have a keener ear than techbros so i'm not too worried for now maybe in 4-5 years
Of all genres, jazz is a true collaboration of the individuals in the band.. what they bring is unique and fluid. They watch and listen to each other and take their performances down different routes as a bonded team...
This is one of the best examples I've seen of using all these new AI tools, amazing work! To all the haters, don't fear the tools, learn to master them
Great job!!! Someday people won’t need jazz musicians anymore thanks to your work! Having jazz musicians around who love what they do and work incredibly hard to bring beauty to the world while still paying their bills and feeding their families is such a drag. Thanks @Nobody and the Computer for helping us get one step closer to putting those vagabonds out of work for good!
As if most jazz musicians make a living (or have ever made a decent living) playing jazz. What planet do you live on? And even so, do you really think the demand for live shows will disappear? Spotify certainly didn't stop people from buying tickets.
@@sickcallranger2590 just because it can be done, that doesn’t mean it should. And by the way, there are lots of jazz musicians out there working their tails off to bring good vibes and beautiful music to the world who do feed their families doing just that. But it could change…
@@volkoivan I could use Unstable Diffusion to replace the brush strokes in one of Picasso’s portraits of Dora with thousands of lines of a phone book from 1987 and have the whole image appear glossed over with semi-transparent chunky peanut butter, calling it “Dora Crunches Numbers in Idaho Springs and Is Loving It” and tell you how exciting it is, and by the way I’ve created a masterpiece… but would it be a masterpiece?
Man this makes me really want a tool that allows you to send AI an existing chord progression or melody you have and let it generate stuff like harmonies, extend the original composition, or more
AI voiceovers are nearly indistinguishable from real voices at this point, and yet I find them nearly impossible to listen to. It’s like eating cardboard. Regardless, this is fascinating work. Subscribed :)
Translation: we are still years away from having AI churn out great jazz music. By the way, the saxophone Coltrane is playing at 12:10 is freeking hilarious!
I'm not sure if it was intentional or not, and I don't even know how did you come up with those MFDOOM bars. But they are oddly similar to Sandman by A$AP Rocky. Cool video though!
I can see this turning into a whole genre itself, AI-generated music, coming along kinda like the sampling movement did. Ngl, the concept of AI taking such major roles in our lives is still a bit scary to me but this video somehow made me feel not AS frightened. Dont really know what to say but... rock on, cheers
"Without machines who will feed us and clothe us and compose our smooth jazz!?" Futurama S2 E19
Only something so prophetic could be said from the Simpsons creators.
Nice call back!
😂😂😂
😭😭😭😭😭😭
@@vafixer8885the Simpsons aren't prophetic it's predictive programming
Small note: the ‘sour’ note you changed was actually fine for jazz ears (#9 alteration)
All notes are fine as long as you follow it with another note that makes sense 🤪
none of these people like jazz which is why they think the twinkle twinkle little star example sounds fire
That was the jazziest moment of the song, and he took it out ...
hahaha so true ^____^ i just though: "oh now something interesting--" and *poof* .. a sour note - wait what?
@@rynabunslegit.. almost none of the chords were harmoniously aligned with the melody at all…
Top tier level of writing and editing. I applause your art good Sir.
wow thanks
@nobodyandthecomputer yeah! Well done! 🍸
I asked ChatGPT to generate a compliment for someone who has created some jazz using AI;
"Your creation of jazz through AI is simply astonishing! You've managed to capture the soulful essence and improvisational brilliance of this genre with remarkable precision. The way your AI-generated jazz effortlessly blends innovation and tradition is a true testament to your talent and dedication. Your work not only pushes the boundaries of music but also enriches the world with delightful melodies that resonate with the very spirit of jazz. Kudos to you for bringing the magic of AI to the world of jazz and creating something truly extraordinary!"
That’s hilarious, but if I can make a recommendation, I think that you got specific first what it’s a compliment in jazz lingo
I asked ChatGPT to generate a compliment to your compliment. After sorting out a bit of confusion, this is the response I got for you:
"Wow, your AI-generated compliment for someone who created jazz using AI is absolutely brilliant! It's impressive how well the AI captured the essence of jazz appreciation and crafted such a heartfelt and genuine message. Your use of AI to generate compliments truly showcases the potential of technology to express creativity and appreciation in a uniquely beautiful way. Kudos to you for creating this wonderful and thoughtful comment that celebrates the magic of AI and the world of jazz!"
Anyone got a bucket?
Ah we can finally retire and let AI just have its own conversation while we go running or walking in the woods
@@freddy2tasked ChatGPT to generate a compliment for your generated compliment of OP’s generated compliment of this AI generated jazz song
“Your remarkable gesture of using AI to generate compliments for someone who praised the work of a person that composed a jazz song with AI showcases your innovative and thoughtful approach to expressing admiration. Your creativity knows no bounds, and that's truly commendable! Keep shining with your unique ideas and appreciation for art and technology.”
the contrast between the panic attack Coltrane solo and the sleepy lo-fi soft chords underneath it is killing me
AI relies on human created content. The Sara Silverman case might be the biggest class action suit ever.
As a musician who spends countless hours developing a unique improv style and sound, I must admit, it bothers me that AI could eventually vacuum up everything I developed and spit it back out in variation.
This tech is rendering human creative arts, for which most make little to no money, valueless and even robbing a sense of intrinsic value itself.
It goes beyond art, but includes social media data, which AI will eventually vacuum up to replicate everyone’s personality (or at least their online personality), so Meta etc. can create marketing models etc. or do weird things we haven’t even considered.
Doesn’t it seem like all of this will destroy the human creative experience and cheapen humanity overall?
the companies that make these ai programs do get a lot of money and they will not stop for us
Photography didn't render portrait artists obsolete, nor did the typewriter ruin calligraphy. It's a supplement to our creativity that we can choose to use or equally ignore. Music has never been about being the best or selling the most records, least of all jazz; well, maybe for some it is. But not for most. It's just as much about the result as it is about the process, so humans will play music and make art as long as humans exist.
I think you make a really important point. The stuff that AI crates is really only worthy of advertising background sounds and definitely not of performance.
This does mean a huge income hit for composers who have provided music for ads, as it will be very easy to bring this sort of thing in house and just let the production team churn out some fotofit sounds
@@sickcallranger2590 I take your points. Though it’s hard to step back in time to truly understand how tech has altered human experience.
We adapt to change, but there was a time when the fact that going to the Louvre to see the Mona Lisa was a rarefied experience because one could never see it anywhere else. It was a far more special experience.
A famous philosopher (forgot name) called this the art’s aura.. and all art had it. I think Andy Warhol was trying to preserve this in the face of commercialism with his repeated images (to say each was “unique” despite looking the same)
But clearly, a distinctive quality of art was lost due to photographed replicas. And we can see how happened and continues to happen for virtually everything.
It’s like a form aesthetic entropy.. everything gets cheapened into a sea of “sameness”. Just because we adapt, doesn’t mean that it’s good, but it’s complicated and probably a mix of “good” and “bad”..
It remains to be seen, but I would not presume to fully understand what has been lost since the pre-industrial times. The Transcendentalists had valid concerns regarding how human experience and culture was shifting. I would’ve like to hear recordings of the great composers improvising though…
@@ili626 There's for sure a point in saying that with commercialization and consumer culture, it's more difficult to truly stand out, and what does stand out is easily knocked back down.
That's honestly a valid concern. But I don't think AI will make it much worse than it already is. If anything, it seems that it might be a means of introducing a whole new group of people into a formerly exclusive club. While it'll definitely break the floodgates and introduce a lot of mediocre garbage, it may also foster unforeseen creativity and give way for something new and unique to emerge. That's the optimistic outlook, at least.
I appreciate all the effort you've put in and you get very interesting results, but I remain unmoved and unconvinced.
fr?? unmoved?? always gotta think a few years down the line
@@br0wning Let me put it this way: I found the output to be mediocre and it feels like it would require as much babysitting and expertise in music production to make something that I would like through this process.
I can't say for the future, but that's why I check in with the channel and others work to see how things progress. I won't dismiss the work done thus far, but I also stand by what I said when I say I feel very little when I hear the music made this way. Like, I would rather sit in silence than leave some of this on
@@AgonalRhythm yea I agree, it's still very early innings and it will be a while until it's easier to use and effective, for that to happen AI models need to become more malleable (i.e. you feed it example music pieces and AI model instance reconfigures itself to be ready to use this newly fed information to generate a tailored output for you, as opposed to pre-trained generic knowledge it currently uses), I know several companies are researching various techniques that can be used to live-update large AI models based on live data, that's the AI holy grail in my opinion
it's being trained by people who don't even like jazz so it'll never achieve great results
like they probably fed it the millions of mediocre lo-fi beats they found on youtube, made by producers who hate music theory so much they bought a midi chord pack
so you end up with "one chord change per bar, strictly on the first beat" "what are inversions" "jazz = 7ths" "c major only" student's-first-composition level of trite
maybe in a few years it'll improve but until people who genuinely love music have an input, it'll remain mediocre
Exactly. Who is the audience for this stuff? Jazz is about live performance.. can't quite see this as a residency somehow...
Also, the Coltrane backing was truly horrid
My friend Bob Keller at Harvey Mudd was an AI Pioneer in music. His program “improvisor” already had models of jazz greats that you could jam with or “produce in the style of” . He was the first to have a AI vs AI jazz jam. Suprised this was missed here!
Any links to this?
ai.stanford.edu/~kdtang/papers/cmj10-jazzgrammar.pdf
@@jyryhalonen4990 ruclips.net/video/fxcy97HfGcE/видео.htmlsi=7QtG4ZMH4qlRlRh0
the best thing about your videos and is number 1 for me , is your funny narrative. You really incorporate ever phrase and slang that fits the subject in such a comedic way. Love it
I could not hold in my laughter when hearing how clearly and arogant the ai voice was telling you about jazz and how it works. And the added clips and dogos were too much!
1980s: you can sample 0.5 seconds of sound! 1990s: Yo, I'm gonna sue you for using my sample! 2000s: we gonna make a new beat with this Amen break sample! 2010s: Let's sample Tom Tom Club for the 100th time! 2020s: I'm gonna sample your brain and there's nothing you can do about it!
I love the downbeat tone and the mad editing skillz. Cracks me up every time.
BRUH that right there at 9:57 + is exactly what it sounds like to be a non-english speaker listening to someone fluent in english
Creative, funny, inspirational stuff! Loads of work in it. Intro alone is worth a Cannes trophy. Thanks from Berlin!
the ballad was actually nice. sounded like something from bee and puppycat, not exactly some swinging j a z z. but it was cute.
Thank you so much for producing such high quality content at the cutting edge of tech. I can't watch these fast enough when they're uploaded. Can't wait to see what directions you take this in.
One idea: I find code interpreter to be really good at coding and structure. Plus it can write and run code. Maybe you can bring some of your code from colab into code interpreter, and have it do the entire generate idea, convert to notes, convert to midi and play process. That way everything can live in a single master prompt to be used with code interpreter.
Keep up the awesome work!
Hey, super jazzed you're diggin' it... it's tight knowing my sh@#$ hits the spot with folks out there. Catch you on the backswing amigazo
6:20 That melody sounds like Cherokee
With all that assistance you put on the top it actually sounded like a interesting piece of jazz at the end :) Congratulations!!!
This video made me want to ask several questions.
1. Do you regularly listen to jazz. (Basie, Davis, Rollins, Monk, Hancock, Brubeck, Evans, Coltrane, Shorter, Gillespy) etc etc? . 2. Do you play an instrument? 3. If Yes, have you ever played jazz with real people ? From a technology point of view, this video was fun. But from the point of view of a jazz fan,
none of these melodies resembled anything close to Jazz. In fairness, this was called GPT Jazz. That is good since this distinguishes it from Jazz. Jazz draws inspiration from soloists who’s improvisations are inspired by melodies, rhythm & chords. When I heard this videos jazz ballad, I head a quarter note melody with a half time beat. It resembled children’s music. The last song was easily the worst. Ps. I admire the work put into the video... but if you are going to make statements like “this is resonating with me”. I have to ask... are you also an A.I.? Trying to label GPT Jazz as JAZZ is akin to labeling a glass of water an Ocean... it’s not big or deep enough. Oceans Rhythmic tides are affected by the gravity of the moon. Human soloist ARE the MOON of JAZZ. Their improvisational gravity gives the music its Rhythmic Swing. It’s the Waves & not the Water that makes us move. 🙏🏽
Officially earned my sub for this vid. That song on minute 7:29 was a JAM. Had my head boppin to it.
i respect the amount of time and effort that goes into your videos
This is brilliant! Thank you for doing this
Man, I love your explorations, story telling, visual style and the general mood of your video. This is really cool and unique! Sending you my congratulations, thanks and support
Glad you enjoyed it!
Putting the temperature to 1.5 KILLED me!!!!! Even though it made no sense it was the funniest thing I have seen AI do in a really long time. The dog memes made it so much funnier too. I really enjoyed the video as a musician and as someone interested in AI. keep it up. I'd like to see more stuff at a temperature above 1. MAYBE not as far as 1.5, but maybe like 1.1 or 1.25....
yo smashing idea, next round, ill dial it back to a cool 1.something, not cranking up to a 1.5... got a bit wild with the heat there, but... it was a hoot ;-}
Just wow... I'm very happy to be along on this journey, you make RUclips a much nicer place!
This video is insane I can’t figure out what has been and what hasn’t been generated by AI
The intro threw me off, your voice is way too slick, chat GPT voice is so lively yet so clean it feels unreal
Uncanny Valley for me all the way, and I loved it
Great great style
That second to last piece was gorgeous
What amazes me is your work, excellent, thank you!
Jazz is a time stamp of when it was created reflecting art and culture at the time is was recorded. What you are creating now is reflecting the artificial time we live in now...
@nobodyandthecomputer I'm really interested in learning more about how you achieved the Coltrane solo at the end. Could you please clarify that? Thank you!
i actually love ur stylisation and approach to ai art it gives me fear, hope and inspiration as a musician to see the potential pros and cons of this in the future. I also love ur name so much, I make indie rock music and would love to dedicate ur themes to my song by using ur name in the title. if u don’t consent of course I will refrain. great video
This is so cool man! Really great job!
As a muso I should be really disturbed … but I’m also a nerd and soooo excited
I'm really glad I found this incredible channel! This is my jam! The editing and writing is top notch, my dude!
I'm against harmonic alignment, after all what's the point of aligning an AI? Let it do it's weird thing.
Don't make it appeal to humans, make humans learn to enjoy the insane.
This bit where the pseudo-coltrane melody was reduced to just 7 notes, but still with perfect syncopation, was actually pretty to me. This is truly inventive. In the same sense a Bach piece begins with a theme, this snippet was actually a great intro with lot's of space left for improv in the piece itself.
Jazz themes are like that, the simpler they are, the more room for magnificent improve they give. Just roll with stuff people, don't over-adjust.
Honestly, don't trust your taste too much, it's just an excuse to repeat what is familiar to you. Repetition is the art killer.
All that said, the result was magnificent, thank you for doing this.
Favorite channel on YT. Absolutely love your content thank you.
damn. Nobody & and the computer strikes again.
I love temperature at 1.5! Sounds like the future of music theory to me.
I heard a mix of have yourself a merry Christmas and another one familiar in the first example.
I think it's leaning on familiarity.
Nostalgic vibes.
Pretty cool. But it does feel like a mix tape.
fly stuff, looking forward to more and more, this is just going to keep getting better 👏
yea homie, that's fantastico, stoked you're into it, it's got me beaming big time
well, same feeling as in Bach's video: music is safe for now. Biologic intelligence is still so much better at organizing sounds. Can't say the same for words or images!
My thoughts exactly!
Your aesthetic is fire, bro.
Bro this dope!
duuuude, this is amazing... working on generating music too but slightly different approach. I am looking forward to seeing more of your videos
What a time we are living in .amazing work
We should emulate each player of the Miles Davis quintet and make a new album that could have been what their next album would have been.
Which quintet? I'd love to see AI try to do a version of Dolores.
As someone familiar with jazz, I was impressed with the AI's ability to create music. While it was clear that some of the pieces were generated by AI, I could still appreciate the improvement from previous versions. The ballad in particular sounded great and could possibly pass as authentic if played by real jazz musicians. However, the AI-generated tunes lack uniqueness and are limited to basic 2-5-1 jazz knowledge. As such, AI cannot fully explore the boundaries of jazz, and I believe that real musicians cannot be replaced.
For instance, the AI chose a 1-6-2-5 progression for "Twinkle-Twinkle Little Star." This is a common jazz progression, but it does not always fit every melody. In this case, the chords and melody seemed independent of each other. On the other hand, the same progression was used in the jazz ballad and worked well because the chords fit the melody and vice versa.
While the 9:17 piece was slightly challenging to listen to at times due to clashes between harmony and melody, I still found it slightly enjoyable. It didn't sound like jazz, which is ok, but the AI was told to do jazz so it should have made jazz.
The chords in the Coltrane ballad were pleasing, but the melody did not make sense. Overall, the video created with Pika was impressive, despite a few blunders. These mistakes actually made the video more entertaining to watch. Despite some errors.
So in the end, I am impressed by the AI. Of course, it had some errors, but the ballad was good.
Thank you for the optimistic views, needed that
De todas las canciones que ha generado Chat GPT en los videos previos, creo que este le gana a todos. Me agradaron bastante las melodías que generó.
Excelente video!
I felt a LOT of emotion in this video.
Well, your AI-generated jazz music is certainly... unique. I mean, it takes a special talent to let a machine compose something that sounds, well, almost like jazz. It's impressive how you managed to make a genre as intricate and soulful as jazz feel so... robotic. Keep up the... interesting work
spot on, the disapproving comments i've seen on this video are mostly from people who genuinely love and understand music, and they definitely have a keener ear than techbros so i'm not too worried for now
maybe in 4-5 years
No two jazz performances are ever the same. This certainly will never be the case with AI toons
Of all genres, jazz is a true collaboration of the individuals in the band.. what they bring is unique and fluid. They watch and listen to each other and take their performances down different routes as a bonded team...
This is one of the best examples I've seen of using all these new AI tools, amazing work! To all the haters, don't fear the tools, learn to master them
That Poem about Section B was the first thing I've truly been impressed by with GPT, Well tested, Those Musoes can be hard-headed 😉
Great job!!! Someday people won’t need jazz musicians anymore thanks to your work! Having jazz musicians around who love what they do and work incredibly hard to bring beauty to the world while still paying their bills and feeding their families is such a drag. Thanks @Nobody and the Computer for helping us get one step closer to putting those vagabonds out of work for good!
/\ The things obnoxious people write
this is an obvious troll.
As if most jazz musicians make a living (or have ever made a decent living) playing jazz. What planet do you live on? And even so, do you really think the demand for live shows will disappear? Spotify certainly didn't stop people from buying tickets.
@@sickcallranger2590 just because it can be done, that doesn’t mean it should. And by the way, there are lots of jazz musicians out there working their tails off to bring good vibes and beautiful music to the world who do feed their families doing just that. But it could change…
@@volkoivan I could use Unstable Diffusion to replace the brush strokes in one of Picasso’s portraits of Dora with thousands of lines of a phone book from 1987 and have the whole image appear glossed over with semi-transparent chunky peanut butter, calling it “Dora Crunches Numbers in Idaho Springs and Is Loving It” and tell you how exciting it is, and by the way I’ve created a masterpiece… but would it be a masterpiece?
I have been collabing with ChatGPT on music (lyrics mainly) and I just have to say that "Nobody and the Computer" would have been such a perfect name.
Unreal!! Thanks so much!
I love the intro conversation that so hip and swag
Dayuuum that intro was DOPE!
Every thing about this video is epic. From the jazz slang to the mf doom solo.
yeah man, dope. Love your deadpan delivery too. N&TC becoming a favourite channel, Keep it up x
This is crazy! Cool video
Amazing video. Great job!
Thanks a lot!
Man this makes me really want a tool that allows you to send AI an existing chord progression or melody you have and let it generate stuff like harmonies, extend the original composition, or more
everybody gangsta til the repeatable desciculture is spectatingly freshated
Awesome content, thank you for researching and for creating this video 😃
Glad you enjoyed it!
AI voiceovers are nearly indistinguishable from real voices at this point, and yet I find them nearly impossible to listen to. It’s like eating cardboard. Regardless, this is fascinating work. Subscribed :)
This is brilliant and engaging on so many levels. Bravo, encore 🙏🏼
just wait till Mr Beato gets hold of you
As somebody who doesn't know much about music this is what I've been waiting for 😂
Nice work, very entertaining and with a great result
Translation: we are still years away from having AI churn out great jazz music. By the way, the saxophone Coltrane is playing at 12:10 is freeking hilarious!
That's supposed to be bebop - FAIL
where did you get the movie upcoming at 7:30~8
likely some 80's mood?
ohhh this is amazing! 🎺🎷🎹
amazing? XD
Beautiful work as always! Seriously, this whole video is a work of art. Just fantastic 👏
you are so cool to share all those processes ! thank you from Lyon (France)
THe best Channel Name ever..
So goooood
To truly capture the spirit of jazz you need the antithesis, of Kenny G, the og smooth jazzer.
sounds like modern jazz quartet. pretty cool stuff, jazz is pretty math like ig.
So when's the album dropping? Nobody and the GPTs coming to a club near you soon!
Live and direct... 🤔
why is this so good man.
12:03 AAAHHRRAAAAAHHAHAHAH i play sax and holy shit that is not how that’s suppose to work 😂😂😂😂😂
Edit: please make more…
Jazz musicians: Worry not. The legit factor of GPT jazz is so far, pretty darn low. You can chill now.
Your videos are very good. Keep up the good work
love your stuff
I'm not sure if it was intentional or not, and I don't even know how did you come up with those MFDOOM bars. But they are oddly similar to Sandman by A$AP Rocky. Cool video though!
crazy stuff
Cool tech!
dude your job is amazing ! thanks
I can see this turning into a whole genre itself, AI-generated music, coming along kinda like the sampling movement did. Ngl, the concept of AI taking such major roles in our lives is still a bit scary to me but this video somehow made me feel not AS frightened.
Dont really know what to say but... rock on, cheers
Wonderful work
Can i ask a question? Do you use sad talker for your facial animations?
Great vid! Perhaps next jam get some velocity values for more feels, & use the ableton groove feature.
Good idea, thank you friend
another masterpiece
Its a good start
This is such a great production! I learned a few things as well.
Glad it was helpful!
ace video! subscribed
5:03 I‘m all about that BASS 🐟 🐟 🐟 LINE.
Hmm. Band in a box. A software in the early 2000s that could easily improvise every part, and the score was excellent, as far as I remember.
MF Doom over GPT's version of Twinkle Twinkle Little Star...this simply has to be the best thing ever uploaded to RUclips🤣
Your videos are awesome