Here is some fatherly advice to all of you out there. NEVER, leave your car to be worked on. Schedule appointments and tell them ahead of time that you will be waiting for your car to get done. ALWAYS, ask for your old parts back. If any shop tells you that you have to leave your car, they are probably overbooked and won't have the time to properly repair your car, or they want to do something shady. Asking for your old parts is legal, and it helps you see work is being really done.
Not everyone has hours to sit and wait for a repair. Sure if it is an oil change...sit around and wait...But if you are having an engine rebuilt...You do not want to sit around and wait for that. And sure you can ask for the parts back...As long as you know what you are looking at or have someone who does know look at it...If you don't it is kind of pointless since they could give you whatever parts they had laying around from another model car and you wouldn't know...
Very good advice. Also ask to see what they recommend fixing on your car. They will escort you into the shop. Don’t just take their word that it needs it. I’m the one that’s always out there watching them work. I agree with getting the parts back that you can, but some parts have a very high core charge and not everybody can afford to pay that. You can always ask to see your part after the car has been worked on and not keep it. And parts like an alternator you can usually see after it’s been put in.
The judge was so mean to this plaintiff for no reason!! My goodness… This does happen! My dad had this same issue! And they refunded twice! For both transactions!
@marleonetti7 i believe her over them, they put the old one in, and regardless, it's their fault, so they should take the loss. She didn’t need a brand new alternator.
Sometimes the judge just goes off and doesn’t fully listen to a story and I’ve seen where she has missed stuff and evidence because she just goes off and stay one track minded.. that’s why people need to keep all of their evidence and receipts
Point was they diagnosed her car wrong alternator was not the problem so why should she pay for a new one when she never needed it. Clearly they didn't know what they were doing. And probably never put a new one in and just said they did. I don't trust mechanic shops
And Stealerships are better, their diagnosis was that the drive belt needed replacing, drive belts drive the alternator. What was their other diagnosis, that's right she had the wrong oil, she had oil that is exactly the same as there Stealership branded oil that costs 200% more.
@@heatherdowhaluk2128 absolutely, but sometimes there are cores on certain parts. At my shop, we take pictures of both parts and before/after installation. It shows that we did the work.
JM acting extra funky today.... U can always tell when she ain't in the mood... She doesn't smile... She sits there with her face all pinched smh... I believe the plaintiff
Exactly . She needs a chill pill . They had to give her a refund the same exact way she paid. She made two separate payments so the only way they could give her a refund is to refund it how she paid them.
In another thread I have people jumping on me about how the plaintiff was completely ripped off regarding her alternator, and it's like: "Guys, why did she want $3k instead of just the rest of the refund she said she was owed 🤷♀️"
If the Judge would of listened to her, she was asking for the return of uber and time wasted and the price she paid the other mechanic for the dry belt.
good vs loyal. he didn’t say loyal. he could have meant she was a good customer because she paid without a problem, picked up in a timely manner, and/or was still polite when she brought the car back.
I think instead of going all unhinged, explain to the plaintiff that what she was saying didn’t make sense so she ruled against her. No one EVER gets the point or understands when you are ranting and raving🤷🏽♀️
@@rosssims7224 duh…of course it’s TV (clearly). But, she does teachable moments all the time. This would have been a good time to explain it to her🤷🏽♀️
She's always disrespectful towards women, especially Blk women... she literally started yelling and making up her own scenario. The defendant didn't even have to speak for himself.
@@MsBizzyRaethe years the young lady spent with her parents would have been a better time for her parents to explain. People need to stop looking at teachers and judges to explain life…that’s the job of parents. And I think this judge gets tired of hearing women say they’re not responsible for anything about a car because they don’t know anything about a car. Don’t buy a car without a mechanic with you…duh!!
There was no malice involved in this particular case… so why yell at the plaintiff like that. I would be pissed if someone diagnosed the wrong repair due to incompetence. The plaintiff should’ve got a statement from the dealership that fixed it properly.
She lied. Plain and simple. No shop out there is going to spend 2+ hours putting the old alternator back in. I guarantee that old alternator was out of his shop that same day. Chances are, the alternator was bad and the belt was slipping. One shop swapped the alternator, and the dealership swapped the belt. End result is a fixed car.
@@bryanhenderson9637 well I disagree a shop made a mistake on my car earlier this year… and they comped the labor. He may have had no intention of giving her a full refund but that doesn’t mean he didn’t say it.
This judge can be annoying sometimes but in this case, she was being a bit harsh on the plaintiff because she left out a lot of information and made it seem as if the defendant did absolute nothing. The defendant refunded her some money back and changed out the alternator for her like she asked. The defendant even dropped her off home because she didn’t have a ride! That’s why the judge kind of got on her because she made it seem like they were refusing to help her when they did help her.
Just so it's clear we never asked for any service other than to drop my car fo breaking down. They said it was something that it was not. And if u noticed while on the phone with the manager he said he told her no refund because they did the work but never explained how she magically got $200 from them because he did promis her a full refund. And remember they was just about to put in a second alternator. because they again misdiagnosed the problem. Her saying just give me my money back and we'll call it saves them the cost of a second alternator+labor and even if the had done it it wouldn't fixed the issue. So I can definitely see why they would refund her.
I love love watching court show. Judge Malian doesn’t know enough about cars to know it doesn’t cost $620 anywhere to replace an alternator and as well do it twice. Labor is standard $75 an hour. They beat that woman. The belt that turns the alternator was the issue. It cranks the alternator that powers the engine. I’m a few years older than the judge. Her yelling has pissed me off. She doesn’t know inside voice and never wants to be wrong. One litigant I’ve seen told her to stop yelling and being disrespectful just because you wear a robe.
Judge or not, you do not have to talk to someone like that to get your point across. If the plaintiff would’ve spoken to JM in the same manner, it would be an immediate contempt of court. So give respect to get it. And I would’ve told JM just that.
“Hating” on who or what? That woman with her poor speech and fake lashes and hair has nothing JM needs to hate on. She goes through the evidence and files before the show is taped. She already knows who is in the wrong before the show is taped and aired.
@@Tahihathat women with fake lashes and hair is pretty asf regardless. Yall be so busy tryna tear black women down it’s ridiculous. I’m pretty sure without the lashes and hair , her face card will still never decline baby .
That's what I said. Point of calling was to find out how the deal was set. All he said was I give no refund because we did the work and part costs him money. I believe this young lady.
The Judge was totally wrong on this case. The plantiff clearly said she dont know about cars. The mechanic sold her a new alternator or claimed he did. When she only need a 30 to 40$ drivebelt. They took advantage of that girl
She’s not wrong. The judge goes through all the files and evidence before the show is ever taped and aired. She already knows what the facts are before the show is aired.
@dj_tarheel Funny nobody agreeing with you. Shops always take advantage of people that don't have knowledge of cars. Especially Women. All that car needed was a 30$ belt
Wondering why the judge didn’t point out the inconsistencies in the stories. She admitted he gave her $200, but manager says NO REFUND at all. That statement needed attention
Except for the eyelashes. Spiders for eyelashes or old man bushy eyebrows for eyelashes do not look good. Especially when they are so heavy it makes you look droopy eyed...
The manager said he couldn't give her any refund because they did he work.... but magically gave her $200?! The judge should've picked up on that. Or asked for the tracking number of the alternator they sent back.
@@swin3492 I thought she say they told her they took out the new one and put the old one back , that is why they was giving her back all her money and because they did not , she took them to court . Well in that case she look like a fool .
What’s wrong with this Judge today ! That was soooo wrong ,can’t she just deliver the verdict respectfully . We’re not here to witness your disrespect 😡
So can we finally admit JM has biases and treats people accordingly. Compare her attitude with this woman vs her attitude with the white med student who drunkenly damaged the Uber drivers car....
Why didnt kniw it all judge ask the manager why he gave her the 200.00 refund when he said he didnt give her the money back instead of assuming they settle on the 200.00. Because she'd already made up her mind
WOW.... I just finished the video. The Judge's conduct was appalling! The plaintiff was respectful the entire time. I don't know if it's a race issue, on other cases the litigants are nasty to Milan and Milan has NEVER been this rude back to them. WOW. JUST WOW.
Apparently you didn't watch the same video I did. She, the Plaintiff, is obviously a drama queen. She thinks she's all that and she ain't. Just look at the fake eyelashes.
Normally, the drive belt and alternator are recommended to be replaced at the same time. She didn't have proof from the dealer saying the other place misdiagnosed the problem (unless I missed it). But her original mechanic should have changed BOTH the drive belt and alternator at the same time... more than likely the drive belt was worn out already. Drive belts (depending on the age and miles of the car) is wear and tear just like the other stuff she bought at the dealer. As a side note, if the alternator was the problem the shop should have given her a failed charge slip.
I agree with the judge. As soon as she said, they put the old alternator in days later that’s such BS like they just have it laying around for her. I’m so sure.
This judge is horrible sometimes. She thinks she knows everything. Also it doesn’t take 2hrs for an alternator. My husband just had his replaced and it was less than an hour. SMH it’s like the older she gets the grumpier she becomes like judge Mathis 😒
I think being a judge takes a toll on them after a while, I mean really dealing with people and their bs all day. I think it’s fair to say that and reasonable for them to get grumpy.
Older cars may take an hour, a lot of newer cars can take longer because things like alternators are shoehorned in, meaning you may have to take a few other things out to get to it.
Because people think they can sue for their "time" but time (unlike wages) is NOT a LEGAL reason to sue. It's no better than suing for someone hurting your feelings. Get a spine and grow TF up
This lady can be a real 🐝 at times. She just be acting old and irritated retire already , instead of taking your irritation out on litigants that are respectful
What I do know is that when we purchase a new alternator they always trade the old one in for a discount on the new one. She also said it was the principle that he promised her a full refund. That was the crust of the whole lawsuit.
Depends on the business and their policies. Big corporations are more likely to stick to the refund policy while privately owned shops can work to their discretion on how to handle refunds or making things right.
@@glitter_and_spice1589 Yet, They charged her & she paid for something they didn't make right "fix". They were negligent, period. Every time, I have gotten my alternator, water pump and fuel pump replaced.. they informed me that the price included the belts being replaced, because they come off to get to the part therefore they replace the belts as part of the service, due to wear/tear on the belts, it's usually time & overall best to change them at the same time.. ANY MECHANIC SHOP KNOWS THAT! Plus, doing so eliminates the exact issue she had... Now, had they changed the belt as well.. she would've never known she never really needed the alternator. the judge got this one wrong!
Regardless if she got a "brand new alternator" or not! That wasn't the problem with her car and therefore shouldn't haven't to pay for it. The mechanic should eat that cost. They should have done a full diagnostic to find out what was truly wrong. They made this girl replace her alternator when it was fine and the judge thinks she should still pay some of it because she got a brand new one? She didn't ask for a brand new one Judge! She asked for her car to be fixed and they didn't fix it. So yeah give her all her money back. It's really simple.
Yea JM was stank. Sometimes I feel like these tv judges try to model after judge Judy but they miss the mark. This was difficult to watch. Kind of glad this show ended because of this. Even the guy at the end gives off a nasty attitude.
They charged her & she paid for something they didn't make right "fix". They were negligent, period. Every time, I have gotten my alternator, water pump and fuel pump replaced.. they informed me that the price included the belts being replaced, because they come off to get to the part therefore they replace the belts as part of the service, due to wear/tear on the belts, it's usually time & overall best to change them at the same time.. ANY MECHANIC SHOP KNOWS THAT! Plus, doing so eliminates the exact issue she had... Now, had they changed the belt as well.. she would've never known she never really needed the alternator. the judge got this one wrong!
She should have gotten a separate report from that dealer as to what exactly was making it vibrate. And it sure as heck wasn't oil or a cabin filter. LOL It sounds to me like maybe she had a broken belt on one of her tires. If the air filter is really, really bad, then it could cause the engine to not run so well but definitely not make a car shake. I don't know what she was trying to describe but an alternator is not going to make your car shake either. Can I believe the reason the judge was yelling at her is because she was talking BS!
What's also funny the Judge didn't even know what the alternator core was cause she asked the defended...then flips out on the plaintiff like she now knows cars smh again 😂😂😂 bottom line the mechanics didn't know what they were talking bout and take advantage of folks who don't knows cars I see it happen ALLLLLL THHHHEE TIMMMMEEEE!!!
The fact that the original mechanic didn’t know it was the belt, they were already down there and could see it. She should have won on the strength of them misdiagnosing the problem.
It has nothing to do with the Alternator! They just saw her a a Woman that knows nothing about Auto Repairs! I would contact the District Attorney’s Office…
Here is some fatherly advice to all of you out there.
NEVER, leave your car to be worked on. Schedule appointments and tell them ahead of time that you will be waiting for your car to get done.
ALWAYS, ask for your old parts back.
If any shop tells you that you have to leave your car, they are probably overbooked and won't have the time to properly repair your car, or they want to do something shady. Asking for your old parts is legal, and it helps you see work is being really done.
Thank you as someone who never had a father ❤❤❤
Thank you
Not everyone has hours to sit and wait for a repair. Sure if it is an oil change...sit around and wait...But if you are having an engine rebuilt...You do not want to sit around and wait for that. And sure you can ask for the parts back...As long as you know what you are looking at or have someone who does know look at it...If you don't it is kind of pointless since they could give you whatever parts they had laying around from another model car and you wouldn't know...
Thank you SO much for the advice, Dad!
Happy Father's Day to you.
Very good advice. Also ask to see what they recommend fixing on your car. They will escort you into the shop. Don’t just take their word that it needs it. I’m the one that’s always out there watching them work. I agree with getting the parts back that you can, but some parts have a very high core charge and not everybody can afford to pay that. You can always ask to see your part after the car has been worked on and not keep it. And parts like an alternator you can usually see after it’s been put in.
The judge was so mean to this plaintiff for no reason!! My goodness… This does happen! My dad had this same issue! And they refunded twice! For both transactions!
Why is she yelling like that!!! The judge is on one today 🥴
Cause the Plaintiff was wrong in this case. Got ZERO!
@@trekgirl65 no she wasn't those people are scammers and the judge is an envious fool!
@@ltsoul9751 she got a new alternator installed into her car , so she was NOT scammed .
@marleonetti7 i believe her over them, they put the old one in, and regardless, it's their fault, so they should take the loss. She didn’t need a brand new alternator.
@@ltsoul9751 she lied about them putting the old alternator back into her car , she got caught .
JM was being extremely nastyyyyy!!!! Shouting at the plaintiff who wasn't even being rude.
Sometimes the judge just goes off and doesn’t fully listen to a story and I’ve seen where she has missed stuff and evidence because she just goes off and stay one track minded.. that’s why people need to keep all of their evidence and receipts
JM TURNING INTO A YOUNGER J. JUDY. SO RUDE!
They read the case beforehand. I think she’s less patient after hearing cases all day and she already has her mind made on what the verdict is.
Wow, Judge, you did her really bad she did not deserve that 😢. She was being honest, I believe her. Can't believe you shouted at her like that
No judge didn’t like her suing for “wasting her time”
Judges are human as well
Plaintiff’s skin is lovely.
Yes a Klingon with great skin 😂
Thats what bothered her@@AlessandroCalzaStudio
But she needs to take those stupid things off her eyes.
Point was they diagnosed her car wrong alternator was not the problem so why should she pay for a new one when she never needed it. Clearly they didn't know what they were doing. And probably never put a new one in and just said they did. I don't trust mechanic shops
Right give her her money back because y’all was just guessing shit
And Stealerships are better, their diagnosis was that the drive belt needed replacing, drive belts drive the alternator. What was their other diagnosis, that's right she had the wrong oil, she had oil that is exactly the same as there Stealership branded oil that costs 200% more.
My uncle is a mechanic and he told me always ask for the old parts back so you are sure they put new parts in
@@heatherdowhaluk2128 absolutely, but sometimes there are cores on certain parts. At my shop, we take pictures of both parts and before/after installation. It shows that we did the work.
Her alternator was the problem... They repeated that several times.
The judge called the shop owner who said it was the alternator... Lol @ you
JM acting extra funky today.... U can always tell when she ain't in the mood... She doesn't smile... She sits there with her face all pinched smh... I believe the plaintiff
Well, not to mention separate credit card transactions do have to be refunded separately.
She lied about the alternator. Did you miss that?
So do I. Alternator DOES NOT cost $620. Maybe at a Mercedes dealership
Exactly . She needs a chill pill . They had to give her a refund the same exact way she paid. She made two separate payments so the only way they could give her a refund is to refund it how she paid them.
I'm guessing that you don't know enough about cars to know that what the dealer did would not have fixed the problem she said she was having.
Had she came in asking for the other 300 and not the 3k. She might have seemed more honest and less greedy.
In another thread I have people jumping on me about how the plaintiff was completely ripped off regarding her alternator, and it's like: "Guys, why did she want $3k instead of just the rest of the refund she said she was owed 🤷♀️"
Facts
The judge was yelling over her when she was explaining why she asked for 3K.
If the Judge would of listened to her, she was asking for the return of uber and time wasted and the price she paid the other mechanic for the dry belt.
Why she so mad at the plaintiff? The plaintiff was never disrespectful. 👀
She kept lying
No I don’t think she was lying they played her
I said the same thing 😡
Imagine someone lying to ur face that will piss you off
JM doesn't like money 5:37 grubbers.
He says, she's a good customer. Yet that was her first time there. 😂
Exactly!!!! Liars😡
good vs loyal. he didn’t say loyal. he could have meant she was a good customer because she paid without a problem, picked up in a timely manner, and/or was still polite when she brought the car back.
I think instead of going all unhinged, explain to the plaintiff that what she was saying didn’t make sense so she ruled against her. No one EVER gets the point or understands when you are ranting and raving🤷🏽♀️
It’s called TV. Obviously the drama is dialed up by her.
@@rosssims7224 duh…of course it’s TV (clearly). But, she does teachable moments all the time. This would have been a good time to explain it to her🤷🏽♀️
She's always disrespectful towards women, especially Blk women... she literally started yelling and making up her own scenario. The defendant didn't even have to speak for himself.
@@MsBizzyRaethe years the young lady spent with her parents would have been a better time for her parents to explain. People need to stop looking at teachers and judges to explain life…that’s the job of parents. And I think this judge gets tired of hearing women say they’re not responsible for anything about a car because they don’t know anything about a car. Don’t buy a car without a mechanic with you…duh!!
Wow judge Milan you looking real shady 🤦🏻♀️ this young lady was very polite and thorough and had all proof and you still treated her like that
Man I been said this bih racist
There was no malice involved in this particular case… so why yell at the plaintiff like that. I would be pissed if someone diagnosed the wrong repair due to incompetence. The plaintiff should’ve got a statement from the dealership that fixed it properly.
It’s pretty spiteful to sue for $3000 over this. 🤷♂️
But JM is doing too much.
She lied. Plain and simple. No shop out there is going to spend 2+ hours putting the old alternator back in. I guarantee that old alternator was out of his shop that same day. Chances are, the alternator was bad and the belt was slipping. One shop swapped the alternator, and the dealership swapped the belt. End result is a fixed car.
@@bryanhenderson9637 That’s a TON of assumptions. You’d be surprised what is told to a pretty lady when a guy thinks he has a shot.
@@teeshante It's no assumption. No shop out there will swap the alternator back with the old one.
@@bryanhenderson9637 well I disagree a shop made a mistake on my car earlier this year… and they comped the labor. He may have had no intention of giving her a full refund but that doesn’t mean he didn’t say it.
The judges energy was chaotic on this episode. Slamming her hands. Yelling. Ewww
Litigants can never give a straight answer. Always going around and around in circles avoiding very simple questions
Sick of her yelling
She keeps her cool more than I could. People flat out lying under oath!!? SMH.
@@M2161 I totally understand that but Judge Judy doesn’t give off this energy and the litigants are the same there.
@@tt.reactions well good thing she's not judge judy and she is her own person.
This judge can be annoying sometimes but in this case, she was being a bit harsh on the plaintiff because she left out a lot of information and made it seem as if the defendant did absolute nothing. The defendant refunded her some money back and changed out the alternator for her like she asked. The defendant even dropped her off home because she didn’t have a ride! That’s why the judge kind of got on her because she made it seem like they were refusing to help her when they did help her.
Just so it's clear we never asked for any service other than to drop my car fo breaking down. They said it was something that it was not. And if u noticed while on the phone with the manager he said he told her no refund because they did the work but never explained how she magically got $200 from them because he did promis her a full refund. And remember they was just about to put in a second alternator. because they again misdiagnosed the problem. Her saying just give me my money back and we'll call it saves them the cost of a second alternator+labor and even if the had done it it wouldn't fixed the issue. So I can definitely see why they would refund her.
The judges does not know what the people told her!! All that yelling at the plaintiff is unnecessary! 😠
This is why I always call my dad for a second opinion before paying for mechanic work!
Some people don't have a dad or a mum
I wish I had a dad. And even so, some men don’t know crap about cars. So good thing, you got a dad that can help.
I love love watching court show. Judge Malian doesn’t know enough about cars to know it doesn’t cost $620 anywhere to replace an alternator and as well do it twice. Labor is standard $75 an hour. They beat that woman. The belt that turns the alternator was the issue. It cranks the alternator that powers the engine. I’m a few years older than the judge. Her yelling has pissed me off. She doesn’t know inside voice and never wants to be wrong. One litigant I’ve seen told her to stop yelling and being disrespectful just because you wear a robe.
Judge or not, you do not have to talk to someone like that to get your point across. If the plaintiff would’ve spoken to JM in the same manner, it would be an immediate contempt of court. So give respect to get it. And I would’ve told JM just that.
She didn’t let her speak fr she over talking her and didn’t let finish .. was judge hating today hmmm it’s giving
“Hating” on who or what? That woman with her poor speech and fake lashes and hair has nothing JM needs to hate on. She goes through the evidence and files before the show is taped. She already knows who is in the wrong before the show is taped and aired.
@@TahihaYou’re disgusting to even speak on this young ladies appearance.
@@Tahihathat women with fake lashes and hair is pretty asf regardless. Yall be so busy tryna tear black women down it’s ridiculous. I’m pretty sure without the lashes and hair , her face card will still never decline baby .
Why she didn’t ask the Manager- Why did he refund her any funds anyway?!!
I was waiting on that question to..
That's what I said. Point of calling was to find out how the deal was set. All he said was I give no refund because we did the work and part costs him money. I believe this young lady.
To😮@@joelmontoya7298
Ppl pls get conversations in writing!!! The defendant know he was wrong. And why is JM yelling! She’s mad at her for what?
Defendant was definitely not lying. As soon as that old alternator comes out they have to send it to the manufacturer as part of the core charge.
The Judge was totally wrong on this case. The plantiff clearly said she dont know about cars. The mechanic sold her a new alternator or claimed he did. When she only need a 30 to 40$ drivebelt. They took advantage of that girl
She’s not wrong. The judge goes through all the files and evidence before the show is ever taped and aired. She already knows what the facts are before the show is aired.
Stop it judge was perfectly right Lmmfao when you change parts like an alternator it’s smart to change all the belts especially on an older car
@@Tahiha Funny knowbody agreeing with you🫡
@dj_tarheel Funny nobody agreeing with you. Shops always take advantage of people that don't have knowledge of cars. Especially Women. All that car needed was a 30$ belt
Wondering why the judge didn’t point out the inconsistencies in the stories. She admitted he gave her $200, but manager says NO REFUND at all. That statement needed attention
Her hair AND makeup is bomb 💣😍
Thank you!
Except for the eyelashes. Spiders for eyelashes or old man bushy eyebrows for eyelashes do not look good. Especially when they are so heavy it makes you look droopy eyed...
Beautiful!
@@Gunnerb52shut up
@@TheMissNewNew32 Poor cupcake...Did it hit too close to home and trigger you? Poor thing.
Why was the Judge so rude and mean to the plantiff? That was so uncalled for and disgusting honestly
Facts... Just funky acting today
Yeah she had a bad attitude for no reason
Sometimes being a beautiful black woman is a disadvantage.
Fact Are Facts...everyone wants to be loud nowadays
Why not a Judge?...
That’s why I love the video of her busting her ass on T.v😂
why give a partial refund if he says he isn't giving one, she never f*cking listens
Milian is getting on my nerves she seems to believe anybody who is not black these days
Definitely reads that way
Huh? Is the defendant not as well?
She's a foreigner
This is why women, and men, should understand something about cars. Just the basics.
What the! Judge Milian was so unhinged that day. She was going thru something for sure
They were playin' her.
Unnecessary smh. I see why ppl be getting smart with her afterwhile
The manager said he couldn't give her any refund because they did he work.... but magically gave her $200?! The judge should've picked up on that. Or asked for the tracking number of the alternator they sent back.
She Lost All Credibility when she sued for $3,000 for wasted time.
Exactly
I believe the plaintiff 100%
Me too
Not me
I don't. She lied and said they put her old alternator back. Girl, bye. Bad lie.
@@swin3492 I thought she say they told her they took out the new one and put the old one back , that is why they was giving her back all her money and because they did not , she took them to court . Well in that case she look like a fool .
I believe her too, where she went wrong was being greedy should have only sued for the 300 not 3000
What’s wrong with this Judge today ! That was soooo wrong ,can’t she just deliver the verdict respectfully . We’re not here to witness your disrespect 😡
you are disrespectful.
What a crybaby u are..smh
No but the show is for the drama.
Performing unnecessary work is the nucleus of all repair work. Gone are the days of trustworthy mechanics...count a 15-20 % loss all repair work
Is it time to retire from the bench? This was a bit unhinged. Aside from that, how does a $620 bill transfer into a $3,000 lawsuit?
So can we finally admit JM has biases and treats people accordingly. Compare her attitude with this woman vs her attitude with the white med student who drunkenly damaged the Uber drivers car....
Some of those 3rd rate shops do be actin' this way. I believe the plaintiff.
I believe her
If she didn’t ask for 3000 I think she would have been believed and won.
3000 was for punitive
People sue for punitive all the time …it’s to deter the defendant from doing ish like that
These lashes need to stop lmao, can't even see her eyes
A bad alternator isn’t go to cause a car to shake.
Why didnt kniw it all judge ask the manager why he gave her the 200.00 refund when he said he didnt give her the money back instead of assuming they settle on the 200.00. Because she'd already made up her mind
That part
Great point 👍🏾
She was fine, the Judge that is. And the plaintiff got ZERO!
She’s so unprofessional…. Why is she still up there 😂😂😂😂
Unprofessional how?? You clearly have never been before a judge before.
@@Tahiha I have once and trust me she is not it. What a joke.
WOW.... I just finished the video. The Judge's conduct was appalling! The plaintiff was respectful the entire time. I don't know if it's a race issue, on other cases the litigants are nasty to Milan and Milan has NEVER been this rude back to them. WOW. JUST WOW.
Yeah it’s a race thing. And it’s unfortunate cause when you see one side of people from that segment of society it can make you kinda jaded.
I want to be wrong but this is her M O especially with black women
@newbeginning8095 sure it could only be a race thing. Definitely couldn't be that the plaintiff is a greedy liar suing for 10x the amount she paid
Apparently you didn't watch the same video I did. She, the Plaintiff, is obviously a drama queen. She thinks she's all that and she ain't. Just look at the fake eyelashes.
Judge was great and to the point, you missed many points of the case. Plaintiff was wrong and wrong. Bye.
Sista needs to hold back on the lashes
How to spot liar...when a person talks too much 😂
Something wasn’t right today with the Judge cuz she was wrong on this 1. That attitude was uncalled for
No attitude from the Judge. You must hate going to a real court, for they act the same with people who disrespect the system.
Yep that was a waste of time. She know darn well you can’t sue for word of mouth. And no they’re not giving you the money back
Normally, the drive belt and alternator are recommended to be replaced at the same time. She didn't have proof from the dealer saying the other place misdiagnosed the problem (unless I missed it). But her original mechanic should have changed BOTH the drive belt and alternator at the same time... more than likely the drive belt was worn out already. Drive belts (depending on the age and miles of the car) is wear and tear just like the other stuff she bought at the dealer.
As a side note, if the alternator was the problem the shop should have given her a failed charge slip.
She is so rude to the plaintiff
I don't know much about cars but definitely know that shaking had to be something other than an alternator
it depends on what she means by shaking. sometimes the engine will shake when it’s about to die or really clsoe to dying. Maybe that’s what she meant.
I believe the plaintiff !! But when ya come to court YOU HAVE TO HAVE PROOF !! If he said that shit she should have made sure it was in writing ✍🏾 ❤
As a Female who doesn’t know anything about cars… I bring someone who does 😳
I agree with the judge. As soon as she said, they put the old alternator in days later that’s such BS like they just have it laying around for her. I’m so sure.
Dear Plaintiff, you didn’t deserve the mistreatment by the shop and by the judge!😳😤🥺
This judge is horrible sometimes. She thinks she knows everything. Also it doesn’t take 2hrs for an alternator. My husband just had his replaced and it was less than an hour. SMH it’s like the older she gets the grumpier she becomes like judge Mathis 😒
Facts... She's just getting old and ornery
Agreed
I think being a judge takes a toll on them after a while, I mean really dealing with people and their bs all day. I think it’s fair to say that and reasonable for them to get grumpy.
Depends on the car.
Older cars may take an hour, a lot of newer cars can take longer because things like alternators are shoehorned in, meaning you may have to take a few other things out to get to it.
When people continually say "To be honest", or phrases of that ilk, I usually believe them very little.
Why does JM always ask who's going to pay her for her time when she makes over $5,000,000 a year??
And why is she so miserable?
Because people think they can sue for their "time" but time (unlike wages) is NOT a LEGAL reason to sue. It's no better than suing for someone hurting your feelings.
Get a spine and grow TF up
This lady can be a real 🐝 at times. She just be acting old and irritated retire already , instead of taking your irritation out on litigants that are respectful
You are the old and rude one. She has a new court show, you can watch it early in the morning. Bye.
the plaintiff is pretty , But the judge didnt have to be rude like that
What I do know is that when we purchase a new alternator they always trade the old one in for a discount on the new one. She also said it was the principle that he promised her a full refund. That was the crust of the whole lawsuit.
She got ZERO!
Plaintiff is pretty.
Makeup
Pretty....ridiculous
@@dance4life1208her skin is clear and she has nice features , why you hating 😂
@@summerbaby634you think you can see her skin ? 😂
@@twill1007 I must have good video quality 😂
Judge Milian be mad as hell when she don’t know what’s going on 🤣🤣🤣
If the judge gets paid to listen to cases, then there’s no time wasted. Lack of professionalism!
wrong dude......
She reviews these cases before hand so she knows what's going on. She's annoyed for a reason
In order to refund you they have to do it in the manner it was charged. They are refunding the transaction
Depends on the business and their policies. Big corporations are more likely to stick to the refund policy while privately owned shops can work to their discretion on how to handle refunds or making things right.
Great point
@@glitter_and_spice1589 Yet, They charged her & she paid for something they didn't make right "fix".
They were negligent, period. Every time, I have gotten my alternator, water pump and fuel pump replaced.. they informed me that the price included the belts being replaced, because they come off to get to the part therefore they replace the belts as part of the service, due to wear/tear on the belts, it's usually time & overall best to change them at the same time.. ANY MECHANIC SHOP KNOWS THAT! Plus, doing so eliminates the exact issue she had... Now, had they changed the belt as well.. she would've never known she never really needed the alternator.
the judge got this one wrong!
Plaintiff got ZERO! Watch the video again, at the end, you missed it.
No they don't, obviously 🚗🚗🚗
The judge was rude and wrong. Wow
Why the Judge shouting like a banshee!!
Because she can...
@@lindarocks209 because shes a loud spicy Latino.
the plaintiff made perfect sense smh
She was nasty as hell to the plaintiff
I think the judge getting tired of dealing with the same stuff over and over and over again but damn judge take a break 😂
Regardless if she got a "brand new alternator" or not! That wasn't the problem with her car and therefore shouldn't haven't to pay for it. The mechanic should eat that cost. They should have done a full diagnostic to find out what was truly wrong. They made this girl replace her alternator when it was fine and the judge thinks she should still pay some of it because she got a brand new one? She didn't ask for a brand new one Judge! She asked for her car to be fixed and they didn't fix it. So yeah give her all her money back. It's really simple.
LOL 😂SHIMMY AND SHAKING 😅
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂IKR LMBO ON THAT TERM
NoDiddy
Unfair judgement. How come the mechanics misdiagnosed twice? -INCOMPETENCE. Why did the judge not address this?
Where’s Adrian ? Judge Milan showed her hate in this one.
JM in her feels today! 😂
Yea JM was stank. Sometimes I feel like these tv judges try to model after judge Judy but they miss the mark. This was difficult to watch. Kind of glad this show ended because of this. Even the guy at the end gives off a nasty attitude.
They charged her & she paid for something they didn't make right "fix".
They were negligent, period. Every time, I have gotten my alternator, water pump and fuel pump replaced.. they informed me that the price included the belts being replaced, because they come off to get to the part therefore they replace the belts as part of the service, due to wear/tear on the belts, it's usually time & overall best to change them at the same time.. ANY MECHANIC SHOP KNOWS THAT! Plus, doing so eliminates the exact issue she had... Now, had they changed the belt as well.. she would've never known she never really needed the alternator.
the judge got this one wrong!
Can business stop sending people that have basically nothing to do with the case?
They do the same in the real world, just visit your local small claims court. See it up close and personal.
8:13 a bad alternator is NOT going to cause the car to shimmy and shake. It could cause starting issues if the battery is NOT being recharged..
She should have gotten a separate report from that dealer as to what exactly was making it vibrate. And it sure as heck wasn't oil or a cabin filter. LOL
It sounds to me like maybe she had a broken belt on one of her tires. If the air filter is really, really bad, then it could cause the engine to not run so well but definitely not make a car shake.
I don't know what she was trying to describe but an alternator is not going to make your car shake either.
Can I believe the reason the judge was yelling at her is because she was talking BS!
The judge was really slow on this one lol
Yup surfacing belt sounds about right
Shaking cars are from tune ups cause of misfires of spark plugs and ignition coils not ALTERNATORS smh
What's also funny the Judge didn't even know what the alternator core was cause she asked the defended...then flips out on the plaintiff like she now knows cars smh again 😂😂😂 bottom line the mechanics didn't know what they were talking bout and take advantage of folks who don't knows cars I see it happen ALLLLLL THHHHEE TIMMMMEEEE!!!
The fact that the original mechanic didn’t know it was the belt, they were already down there and could see it. She should have won on the strength of them misdiagnosing the problem.
Another case where the judge had biases and act erratic
These mechanics always getting over on people. $600 for an alternate was a scam to begin with.
Yeah, it never takes as long as they say it takes. What we pay for is their lunch breaks
The judge looks unwell?
She looks like brooke
500.00 plus for an alternator. That shows they are rip off
Right, and they would have to take separate refunds if paid with a credit card. That is how it works.
Part + labor it’s a deal…I’d be spending over $850 just for the part if I brought my car in 🥴🤣
@tristyy404 well come to me love I can put it on in 15mins. If tour paying 850.00
That's normal
It's parts and labor 500. Mine was 600. It's like ppl just talk to hear themselves
The judgement was unfair..
Idk i believe the plaintiff. I feel like they did tell her she could have a refund but then just changed their mind.
It has nothing to do with the Alternator! They just saw her a a Woman that knows nothing about Auto Repairs! I would contact the District Attorney’s Office…
Well DAGGGGGGG Judge!
THE PLAINTIFF HAD NO PROOF; stop getting mad cause the Judge isn’t the NICEST😂 LOL
What a well raised lady. Hmmm suing for $3000. Really? Get a life