Black September was a civil war. Jordan gave citizenship to all Palestinians and annexed the west bank. The west bank is either Jordanian or Israeli, and since Jordan rescinded their claim, it is solely Israeli territory.
Then that's sad that their 'motherland' doesn't want to take them back in but has such a huge border wall to block them out (even stronger than Israel's wire fencing that they bulldozed down) :(
I'm an Iranian, Monarchist, I think Judea and Samaria belongs to Israel, King Cyrus the Great helped the Jews and believed those lands belongs to jews, he even helped in financing the rebuilding of temple if I'm not wrong, he said I can give the money but I bring egyptians architects to help jews to rebuild it. Anyway there is an ancient bond between Iranians (Persians) and Jews, may Israelites live in peace in their eternal holy land.
Thanks! We made a video about Cyrus the Great and the 2nd Temple: ruclips.net/video/kXAXkvZrABg/видео.html And a video about Iran and Israel bond: ruclips.net/video/hnsFGDhT9ek/видео.html
Sometimes I watch Dominic Lieven on RUclips, who writes about empires, and, for better or worse, empires were mostly broken up in the 20th century, partly because of nationalism. One could argue that perhaps the Ottoman Empire (until 1914, or the Persian Empire) were better at accommodating diverse populations and religions than the situation we have today. However, in these empires everyone was a subject, not a citizen, and that would be difficult for people to accept today.
And now you are okay with the Israelis fake citizenry of Europeans attacking the very nation that saved them time and time again. or are these just European imposters, who are part of the European union as they are European, but also claim to be from the Middle East through their adopted religion through conversion, who claim membership in the African Union, beats me on what grounds, and wants to claim the Americas and the world since some Jews lived in those pats of the world. With this logic, the whole world belongs to them. Strange that a Iranian, favors the claim of the Israeli enemy, bent on the destruction of Iran, his own ancestral homeland. You seem to either be a traitor or an imposter, or a Zionist bot.
I don't understand, why 1967? On May 15, 1948, one day after the establishment of the State of Israel, the surrounding countries attacked Israel. In this war, Trans-Jordan occupied much of the area west of the Jordan, including Jerusalem. This annexation was illegal. The Six-Day War followed in 1967, again between Israel and its surrounding neighbors. Israel regained control of the 1948 territories, including Jerusalem and Sinai. After giving Sinai to Egypt in 1979, Israel now controls almost exactly the territory that was allocated to the Jewish people in the Mandate for Palestine, as far as the part west of the Jordan. The West Bank and Jerusalem are also included. This territory has never been assigned by law to any other nation other than Israel. According to the Mandate, Jews are allowed and even encouraged to live in any part of Palestine.
exactly the 1920 San Remo Agreement (League of Nations) is still valid under international law. As long as there is no new division, it all belongs to the Jewish Homeland from the River to the Sea (Named like this in 1920).
I am an Ex-Muslim from Iran and I am sure that the majority of Iranians stand with Israel and hate the Islamic regime of ayatollah in Iran. The friendship between Iran and Israel is not something new, It has very ancient historical roots from over 2500 years ago When King Cyrus the Great peacefully conquered Babilon and freed all Jewish people from bondage. ❤️✡️🇮🇱✡️❤️
For reference, the comment by @mreza84 is what US/Israeli propaganda on the internet looks like. Iranians hate Israel, so this is an example of "big lie" propaganda with a "shill from the crowd" stance.
I swear channels like yours are better at making Palestinians sympathetic than most of the actual Free Palestine movement That's the power of actual information and a genuine intent for understanding, more powerful than spreading propaganda and hatred
if that so?? then why hes ONE PART not tell full issues? like hey!!! the thief is allowed to have the house but the owner have NO RIGHT TO LIVE EVEN!! what about the ever expiosn settlement eh?
This is one of the best pieces Unpacked has put together. It is as fair and balanced accounting as you are going to get from a pro-Israeli source, which is much more than you'll ever get from the other guys. Nice job guys.
You forgot one important fact. The Hashamite reign on Jordan (Trans-Jordan) is a colonial force backed by the British since 1917. 70% of Jordanians are Palestinians and should get back their real land.
@@mikeparkes2355 There is a nerative out there. It's partial and mostly un true. Do you want to push the nerative or do you want to talk about what is true? The jews come from the land of Israel. Abraham is buried in Hebron. All our history is here. All our religion is here. Yep, this is my land. Do other people live here too? Yes. Do they have equel rights? All citizens of Israel have equel right. Does Israel occupy more lands? Partly We left Gaza in 2005 and for the past year we are at war with Hamas after their attak on Oct. 7th 2023. We do control parts of Judeah and Sumaria (the West Bank) and the PA controls most of it. There is a lot of terror coming from there too. 2 days ago a suicide bomber tried to level a synagogue in Tel Aviv. Everything here is true. Look it up.
@@dhyana87658 It was called Syria-Palestina under the Otoman Empire. It included today's Syria, Lebanon, Jordan and Israel. After WWI the British and French divided the land. The Balfur decleration of 1917 promised the Israel (and arguably Jordan) part for building a home for the Jewish people. Since 1917 til 1948, the British (in their Mandate) tried to avoid that decision and stopped Jews from entering the land (the White Book for example) and encouraged Arabs to come. More than 50% of the Arabs in Israel in 1948 came after 1917. Those are all facts that you can check.
Not true. He already explained how there was a period of peace and economy and cultural exchange. Moreover, all the three villages attacked on October 7th are peace believers, free of religion minded people, they chose to give jobs and help those in Gaza. That’s how they knew which houses to go to, who were unarmed and weak. The betrayed the only ones that were literally, giving them a chance to prove that they are right.
U want the people of gaza to befriend the people that are ok with ethincally cleansing them, unaliving them, graping them, oppressing them, Imprisoning them without evidence, accusing them of terror without evidence, restricting them, spying on them exc.... This is one sided. The moment the Israeli people come our and condemn their cgovernment peace will never prevail. Revenge will be sort. The palestinians deserve justice.
The media worldwide is working hard every day to insure this remains the case. The abject and complete ignorance of people about this situation and their passionate and violent dedication to retain this ignorance is the height and glory of news media and journalists, in league with the Arab controlled UN.
On 1967 Jurden and Israel agreed that Israel will take the west bank and that is because Jorden does not want the Palestinians people. But other than that this is very accurate.
Or signing a peace deal for a more and more generous two state solutions up to 7 times now! You have to fight wars with the pen and paper not guns and murder. The only people who suffer from any war is the innocent. They could have built and expanded if they just worked more bureaucratically. But here we are watching this unfold.
@@Musicinternal Arafat declined the camp David peace deal as he was out for himself he wanted to keep the struggle with Israel going if he could make the gazans bleed, the world would donate more money & more $$$$ from Iran for the cause. It was also in Irans best interest to keep the struggle going.
@janettedewar6617 do you need reminding that Palestinians have every right to refuse any deal, after all this is their land. There is only a one state solution as Israel has made certain a two state solution is not possible; Palestine, with a one person, one vote system, and current occupants can choose to integrate or move elsewhere.
There's a factual error at 14:57 when it's said that "Hamas won 44% of seats in the Palestinian Legislative Council" in the 2006 election. 44% was the percentage of votes achieved by Hamas, but they won 74 of the 132 seats in the PLC (i.e., 56% of the seats).
It is extremely important because it shows that it was actually Fatah who orchestrated a coup - with IL and US support. All parties running in that election, including H...s were approved by IL and the US. If they didn't want them to run for the votes they could have banned them to do so. Not real democracy but who cared at that point. But after they won the election it was the coup against the election results that kept Fatah in power in the West Bank. The coup was unsuccessful int Gaza where H...s replied with extreme brutality. But any other narrative of the story is mere lie.
It seems balanced to someone who is not really versed in the conflict. It doesn't cover much Israeli wrongdoing unfortunately. And I mean what Israel has been doing outside the wars. Since you-know-who has ruled 17 out of the last 28 years to be more specific. Well, he seems like he knows how to hold on power and that happens by severely mistreating whoever is less mighty. So much for humans being different from animals. October 7th happened entirely directly due to his policies. Avoiding any and all solutions and furthermore expanding and pressuring the neighbours.
Jewish population of the Arab world 1947: over a million 2020: under 100,0000 Between the river and the sea Arab population 1947: 500,000 2020: 7 million Who exactly is committing genocide and ethnic cleansing?
And the Druzs, and Christians were forced or killed out as well. Most of this misery occurred right after the Nakba in 1948, after Izreal won the war. No one talks about the 700,000 Jews that were forced out and murdered in Lebanon, Syria, Egypt and Jordan as they ran to the homeland of Izreal for their own survival.
I have to say, you did a great job! Covering most important historical facts, and always clearly stating that those who suffer are the normal people on both sides. Thank you for the great job, I will share this video with all I know!
But why dont he do a ducumentary on the bad and evil side of what isreal Goverment is really doing to the gaza people... This shows owns the oppresso❤..
i get the feeling that this is a good attempt of explaining the situation. A 21 minute explanation will always miss some details and it is not for me or many others to say (or think) that those missing details would change the explanation entirely.
Nice one sided history of Gaza where it looks like Israel did nothing wrong in effecting Gazans and Palestinians in mass. You might have thrown in the over 14 mass*acres that Israel is responsible for as well as the good ole occasional "mowing of the lawn" that Israel would gleefully do.. If you're going to portray the light in one way, maybe you can cover the full size of the case to make this acceptable as a good report of the facts. (I will see how long this post remains).
The discussion in this war is absurd. First. Israel acted selflessly to live in peace with the Palestinians in Gaza. It was more than a decade ago when Israel itself relocated thousands of individuals living in Gaza with lethal force from their homes to follow the agreement, which obligated the Palestinians in return to stop any kind of aggression towards Israel. The Palestinians had the chance to build a safe, functional, and prosperous livelihood. But the first thing the Palestinians did in return was to elect a government that enshrined the goal of destroying Israel in their constitution. The elected government followed through with its promise. Since its founding, thousands of rockets have flown into Israel. Dozens of civilians died in terrorist attacks. Millions of aid funds - intended for civilian purpose - were misused to build rockets, tunnels, and other nonsense. The crimes committed on October 7th like raping women, killing children, or kidnapping a baby, was Humus has been doing for years. Secondly. Israel behaved more humanely in this conflict than any other conceivable party in any imaginable conflict. It allowed Palestinians to work in Israel, receive medical care or even migrate into their country. During war, they warn civilians where their military is operating. They admit collateral damage and apologize for it. They saved Sinwar’s life giving him a lethal brain surgery. They treated the daughter of Haniyyas daughter for her complex disease in Israel. While Humus was building rockets and tunnels with all the foreign aid, Israel supplied their civilians with free water and electricity. The situation is clear. In no other conflict the responsibility for the suffering has been so one sided and clear - in no other conflict have the perpetrators been held accountable so weakly. The same goes for any related conflict: Hezbollah, Houthis, etc…the more peacefully you try to live with them, the more visible their genocidal intents becomes. People with voice and power who claim to reject war have the duty to unequivocally name the culprit of this war and do everything in their power to eliminate them. Everything else is responsibility for the resulting suffering and will extend it.
And when the Jewish settlements in Gaza were evacuated, they left all the flourishing hot-houses etc. so the Gazans could grow their own food, and within weeks, they were all trashed. Why? Because their leaders want the people to be poor and miserable so they can blame Israel!
Upon a written peace agreement between Egypt and Israel Egypt, who owned Gaza, gave it to Israel. There was No written agreement between Egypt and Arabs "Palestinians" Gaza belongs to them.
They didn't give it to Israel they just didn't take it back. The international community always tried to put legs in Israel's path and by pressuring Israel using the palestinians as a tool they can play like an ally economicallyy while attacking Israel politically.
Exactly. International law states that an occupied territory is land taken by a country from another country, Israel occupied Gaza until Egypt rescinded their claim to the territory, thus making it solely Israeli land.
@@TheWorldsBestPilotthat and the fact that what is now called Gaza was part of ancient ersatz Israel. It along with what was given to make Jordan was also suppose to be part of the reestablished Jewish homeland. League of Nations.
Netanyahu elected Hamas…..Always look at the agenda….Synagogues of Zionist Satans Servants…it not about religion it’s about Money always with The Weat…Look up The Gas and oil they know is under GAZA…Shameful
Gaza and the coast were occupied by the Philistines thousands of years ago. They were taken over and disappeared from history as Philistines, but many of the people stayed in the surrounding area. Inland Palestinians were Semitic people from the area going back about 8-10 thousand years, from Philistines, Canaanites, and other local tribes of the times and then including migrant people from the immediate areas of north Egypt, Jordan, southern Lebanon, Syria. Palestinians have a similar yet separate identity from other Arab countries. Such as the countries of Europe are similar but have their own history and cultures. The Jews came onto the picture as a story of Abraham from Babylonia. They likely converted some local tribes to Judaism as Islam didn't come into existence until after Christianity of the 1st century. Most of the Jewish left a couple thousand years ago, but those that stayed were treated well and lived without conflict and free to practice their religion. Palestine was a thriving, busy, farming, fishing and trade hub for 400 years under the Ottomans until WW1. Goods from all over the region were transported through the port, spices, goods, grains etc from Africa and Asia were brought to the area for trade and transport. Palestine itself was particularly known for olive products, wool, fine soaps, pottery, glass, and produce. It was the hundreds of thousands of European refugees that immigrated into Palestine and with an army, forced 700,000 native Palestinians off their heritage farms, lands, villages around Jerusalem, the north, west bank etc. The Israeli army was violent killing people and executing children and elders and burning homes. Nearly a million displaced people. This is called the "Nakba" Some left to Jordan or Egypt but many went to Gaza.
Palestinians are newcomers to the area. They came in the 1930s for British jobs. Their ancestral homes are in Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, and Turkey.
They were basically sharecroppers land was owned by absentee landowners. Have to remember the area we call Israel was terrible for agriculture. Besides the religious sites it was pretty much worthless before the Jews started irrigation projects to create farmland.
It true when the jews settled in the land the land was desolate and with lot of swamps. The jews dried the swamps and fight desess like malria, after that many Arabs from Arabs countries came to palestina to find jobs. look at potos from the beginning of the 19th century and see how desolate and empty was the land. And read what people like Mark Twin wrote about the land. The Arabs don't accept the right of Israel to exist in any borders and any size because they claim to return of refugees into Israel border of 1948. That israel can not accept. What about 850000 jews refugees from Arabs countries that came to Israel after they suffered from pogroms and Humiliation in the Arabs countries. And the jews really lived in the Arabs countries for generations not like most of the Arabs that arrived to palestina in the 19th century.
Even if that were true, which it isn't entirely, the people of Gaza would still have more association with the Levant than the Eastern Europeans, Central Europeans, and American Europeans who arrived in 1947/1948.
You're presentation is great. I usually agree with all your podcasts and find them accurate and interesting. I just need to correct a few points. I think you've colored the facts with a western outlook. And some are misinformed entirely. Saying it's occupied is an Arab/Russian invention. There was absolutely no need to give anything back accordingto international laws. The only thing the arabs want is a Jewish free Israel under their rule. And Arafat ימ"ש is recorded saying we can lie to Israel and to the West to achieve our goals. He actually rejected agreements that gave them loads of territory and autonomy. The biggest obstruction to piece are the Arabs because they don't want piece they want to rule the whole world. They are religious fanatics, racist, and believe only in sharia law. You can't handle them with talking and giving away, in the Arab world they consider you a joke. They only understand strength. At the end of our prayers 3 times a day one of the last things we say is what the children in Shushan told Haman: עוצו עיצה ותופר דברו דבר ולא יקום כי עמנו ק-ל "They can plan plans and talk talks but nothing will be fullfilled because G-D is with us." I believe this goes for the Israeli government as well. G-D has saved us from our own stupidity. The only reason Israel still exists is miraculous, and because G-D promised it and he wills it. And for the Arabs that is one of the biggest threats. That they see G-D is not on their side.
On Arafat lying - you should know that in Islam it is perfectly fine to LIE to those you are negotiating with, if you need to to get the result you want ! For Islam the only thing that matters is the end result. As in CONVERT or SUBDUE or KILL all those you come across in order to spread Islam - an actual instruction in their 'book' !!! So do not be surprised at Arafat !
WHAT A LOAD OF BS. FROM BOTH SIDES. WHO ARE YOU KIDDING. I KNEW WHOSE SIDE HE WAS ON WITHIN 10 SECS OF HIM SPEAKING. AND EVERYONE APPLAUDING THIS ARE EITHER ISRAELI, ZIONISTS OR INHUMANE 😠 😡
1:31 I just want to make a note here. The term Palestinian for non Israelis would not have been used in 1967. Until the 70s they were just called Arabs. It wasn’t until the PLO was founded that they adopted the Palestinian identity. Edit: I do not mean that nobody identified themselves and called themselves Palestinian until the 70s. Everybody (including Jews) called themselves Palestinian for years and years. But, what started in the 70s was the strict Arab Palestinian identity of today. Edit 2: This really shouldn’t be that controversial. The modern Palestinian identity that refers strictly Arabs who are non Israeli started with the formation of the PLO in the 1970s. Before that Palestinian was a term for all people who lived in the region of Palestine. PM Golda Mier even talked about this development and how it didn’t make sense, as she should be considered Palestinian cause she lives in that region. The term Palestinian switches meaning. You can look it up.
@@nickydabas1622 all people who lived in the region used to be called Palestinian. I have old Jewish Israeli relatives who still sometimes call themselves Palestinian. The idea of a strictly Arab Palestinian identity only comes about when the PLO is established. Do your history.
I second the remark made by @richwilson1788 - one has to be very careful when describing events in this ambiguous ways. Facts are that three Arab states neighbors of Israel have been planing to attack Israel. They have initiated what were clearly preparations for war, that included the Egyptian army moving into the Sinai peninsula having expelled the UN forces that have been there since 1956, the closing of the Straits of Tiran, the only exit for Israel from the Red sea and the later unvailed phone call between Egypt's Gamal Abdel Nasser and King Houssein of Jordan.
Thanks for making videos that arent just bashing the other. This conflict, this war and all its horrors, will not have a simple ending. I feel sadly this will take generations, third parties, and a LOT of money to rebuild beautiful Gaza, to heal both people groups. There is ao much talk about hatred but not about what has happened and what has to happen next.
🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸Well researched description🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸of this intractable conflict🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🔥🔥🔥Sykes-Picot agreement of 1917🔥🔥🔥is the beginning of this unfortunate situation between two brotherly peoples🔥🔥🔥
Exactly. If the Gazans (Hamas) weren't so deadset on fighting Israël and making Gaza into a warzone, too unsafe for people to visit, they could have had so many opportunities to develop the land. Just like any other country with a Mediterranian Sea coastline, they could have prospered. So sad.
@@mq2311 Netanyahu doesn't want Gaza empty. It's an impossible task. Most Israelis simply see Gaza as an irrelevant shthole. They want hostages, Hamas no longer a threat, then the rest of Gaza can f right off to do whatever people do in shtholes. It'd be much better if Egypt kept Gaza. Realistically, no one wants that place other than religious nutjobs.
But the Palestinians are the colonists. The name Jew comes from people from Judah. It is the Jewish nation that has been repeated colonized throughout history, but this region is their ancestral land
🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸Well researched description🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸of this intractable conflict🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🔥🔥🔥Sykes-Picot agreement of 1917🔥🔥🔥is the beginning of this unfortunate situation between two brotherly peoples🔥🔥🔥
You forgot the ones that stayed and live in peace and have the same rights as anymore that lives in Israel. Remember it was Israel before Mohammad was even born
They gave Gaza (part of Israel) for peace, the General minister Arielle Sharon at that time unfortunately already deceased, all settlers had to leave their homes with protest of course, and what did these murderers do with it, it is unbelievable, shma Israel chai 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇩🇪🇮🇱🇮🇱
@@nickydabas1622 Nah, Ariel Sharon, the person stupid enough to give Palestinians Gaza as a gesture of peace. Thinking that Palestinians won't shoot themselves in the foot like always.
It’s interesting how he ends this narrative about who owns the land. I’m Jewish, born in the former Soviet Union. From my childhood, I remember constantly being reminded of our identity and being shown the door, being told that we were not welcome there. I was born there, but that doesn’t mean I-or we as Jewish people-have the right to claim Russian, Ukrainian, Polish, or any other European or Middle Eastern territories as our own, even though Jews lived there for hundreds of years. Israel is our ancestral land. Palestinians are squatters in our land in the same way we were in Europe. There will never be peace between us and them; they are too violent to live near us in peace.
U are absolutely correct mate…even india has the same problem in kashmir …all these treaties and accords are like toilet papers to these islamic jihadis
At 1:00 and already I smell b/s: "Israelis were certain that they were on the brink of extinction"... Uh... No... Egypt closed the Straits of Tiran to block Israeli shipping, then moved defense forces to its border to defend against any possible Israeli attack or invasion. Israel decided to attack Egypt, along with Jordan and Syria, and having destroyed all their air forces in that offensive attack, was easily able to defeat them all. There was no danger to "The Jewish state".
@ryanmoore2447 there is no such thing as ‘Palestinian’ land. ‘Palestina’ is the old greco-roman renaming of JUDEA AND SAMARIA, cradle of JEWISH civilisation, by Roman invaders. After the fall of Ottoman Turk occupation, the land was under British Mandate that partitioned the territory into Israel and Jordan (1946).
Almost right. 'Syria Palestina' was the name given to the whole of Israel by the Romans, after they quashed the Bar Kochva revolt in A.D. 135. 'Palestina' is Latin for 'land of the Philistines', and the Romans chose that name as a deliberate insult to the Jews, because the Philistines had been Israel's ancient enemies. (By Roman times, they had long since ceased to exist as an identifiable ethnic group.) However, there has never, at any time in history, been an independent sovereign state called Palestine, it was only ever a part of Greater Syria. Arabs living in Israel simply called themselves 'Arabs' until the mid 1960's. The British were given the Mandate for Palestine in 1920, following WW1 and the collapse of the Ottoman Empire. At that time, Palestine included what is now the Kingdom of Jordan, and all of it was designated as a homeland for Jews. Then we gave 78% of it (early 1920's not 1946), the area to the east of the River Jordan, to a minor Saudi prince, because we wanted oil, leaving only the area to the west of the river for a Jewish homeland. The eastern area was designated as a homeland for Palestinian Arabs! In 1922, all 51 members of the League of Nations approved this arrangement. After WW2, the U.N. took over all the rulings of its predecessor, so they still stand. Therefore, all the area 'from the river to the sea' belongs to Israel. Q.E.D.!
@ronnyfokaha, its their ancestoral homeland, they were forced out by different occupiers thoughout history, then forced out of their host countries like egypt etc where they migrated to. So here they just came back. Current palis are from neighboring arab countries, why dont these arab countrirs take them in?
The 1987 Intifada was planned also. Between 1967 and 1986 the Arabs in the West Bank DID have autonomy - the civil service that performed under Jordanian rule continued under Israeli rule - until Arafat ordered the workers to quit their jobs. At that point Israel had to choose between leaving the Arabs without vital services or taking active control of the area. Israel made the compassionate decision to take control and Arafat used this as his excuse to order the Intifada. And of course it spread also to Gaza.
really the Gazans & all their terrorists couldn't run a dog show. Hamas & the PLO & PLA could not agree on anything then another terrorist organisation appeared in Gaza noone knew who they were. Hamas did one thing the PLO did another. bickering, fighting gazans killing gazans. etc. Chaos. The middle east is rife with muslims having sex with animals even dolphins.
What you said is really where the solution have been, right under their very noses. If only the Israel or Palestinian Government or authority at the first place should have said that, they are the administrative or governing authority of the territory, but whoever has been here ever since whether Arabs, Palestinians or Jews, you still have the personal right of ownership to any peace of land you own. By then, the people will be happy to be a part of a state that recognises their existence at the personal level without regards to their ethnicity, religion or whatever. There would not be any problems like today they are facing.
Very wrong: Territories that Israel obtained in the Six-day 1967 War were not "conquered" territories as you erroneously say. They were "re-possessed" territories taken back by Israel from the 1948 Arab invaders- Egypt (Gaza), Jordan (West Bank); and Syria (Golan), who illegally and forcefully invaded and seized the territories from the new State of Israel and held them illegally for 19 years until 1967. These territories were allocated to the Jewish people worldwide in the San Remo Resolution of 4-24-1920 by the lawful sovereigns at the time, the Supreme Allied Powers post WW 1 (UK, France, Italy, Japan and the US as observer), and codified unanimously by the League of Nations (54 nations), in the League of Nations Mandate for Palestine-Israel. Your mis-statements are an affront to international law and the Rules-based order that most of the world ascribes to. Indeed, in 1948 the US, the USSR and many other nations "recognized" the new State of Israel, and the UN accepted Israel as a member state. Israel avoided applying its legal sovereignty to Gaza for the sake of a potential peace treaty with the Arab population. But alas the Arabs were not and are not interested in peace. They are interested in full domination by force, and reject international law. Now that Israel has re-possessed Gaza for the second time, after the failed Gaza withdrawal of 2005 and the illegal HAMAS takeover and unprovoked attack of 10-7-2023, Israel has no choice but to evacuate the hostile elements of the Gaza population for their safety and the safety of the Israeli survivors of the HAMAS 10-7-23 attack, who do not want and cannot live within walking distance of such a vile, dangerous population. The gross Arab lie of Jewish land theft that you seem to promote, (intentionally or unintentionally), will not bring justice to the Gazans or the Israelis, and the indigenous Jewish People will fight and secure its ancestral, historic, religious, and legal rights in all the Palestine/Israel-Mandate lands, including Gaza. Arabs are welcome to exercise their claims to sovereignty in the nearby Palestinian Arab majority state of Jordan that is currently ruled by a non-Palestinian, King Abdullah, who refuses to accommodate Palestinian Arab aspirations of sovereignty in Jordan, or they can exercise their aspirations of sovereignty in their ancestral land of Arabia. And leave the Jews alone in their ancestral land of Judea-Israel.
More voices need to be heard from both people's with the same mindset set like yours brother unfortunately it's the extremists on both sides making noise and being high on hate like you said in the end the land belongs to both of you praying for peace in the holy land 🤲🙏
I love it how your channel explains these complicated issues as objectively as you can. That's why I love your channel. Usually, media outlets are one sided but you try to represent both sides. Please keep the great job
To correct you Israel was not afraid of a war in 1967 but wanted it, it launched a offensive war to gain territory and to at least use it as barging chip.
@@UNPACKED lol why you only providing links to your one sided of the story videos? Stop trying to rewrite history. All people should be treated EQUAL. Israel does not want equal rights for ALL the people in greater Israel
@tomjones9082 Be it Zeus, Jesus, Krishna, they are but fabricated characters of Heathen Man worshiping his own fragile, pathetic Ego, ABOMINATIONS to the CREATOR, WHO Commanded that HE alone is to be worshiped!
The people who throw rockets are those people who's ancestor stays there since 4000 years ago without leaving towards those who just settled ( and claimed sovereignty) in early 20th century.
The Jews were complaining to each other about Jesus, because he had said, I am the bread that came down from heaven.‘ ‘Surely this is Jesus son of Joseph’ they said. ‘We know his father and mother. How can he now say, “I have come down from heaven” ?’ Jesus said in reply, Stop complaining to each other. ‘No one can come to me unless he is drawn by the Father who sent me, and I will raise him up at the last day.I am the bread of life3 It is written in the prophets: They will all be taught by God, and to hear the teaching of the Father, and learn from it, is to come to me. Not that anybody has seen the Father, except the one who comes from God: he has seen the Father. I tell you most solemnly, everybody who believes has eternal life. I am the bread of life. Your fathers ate the manna in the desert and they are dead; but this is the bread that comes down from heaven, so that a man may eat it and not die. I am the living bread which has come down from heaven. Anyone who eats this bread will live for ever; and the bread that I shall give is my flesh, for the life of the world.’
@@AL-wn2tt the Jews of that time and this time didnt care about Jesus other than that he was making trouble with the Romans during a time of political unrest when Jewish rights to practice their faith and culture was being threatened.
@@pamelakoretsky9909all the first Christians were Jews. Many Jews loved Jesus and without Jews his message and Christianity would not have gone around the world.
But the Quran also makes it clears that the Jews (Bani Israel) were disinherited from the land for their rebellion against God's laws and slaying of his prophets.
In 1906, the Palestinians arrived in Gaza. They fled from Saoudi Arabia and were called the Rashidis at that time. Al Saoud and his tribe freed Mekka from the future Palestinians. What was the reason??
@@UNPACKED You guys are some of the best resources on the web. Your material is fact-checked and approachable and your presenters are capable and relatable. With that in mind, whoever controls the microphone controls the narrative. Take control of the language and you remove your opponent's ability to frame the narrative. Easy to say. Hard to do. I've discussed this with SCN in the States about how to better control the narrative to deter artificial sympathy for antisemites. Best of luck!
@@janettedewar6617 in their hearts after suffering 80y inder the Jews, after all the "wars" slughterings. There will be raage in everryone who is loosing family members. Also THE BABIES, you yous its totally fine when they are getting killed? Do you think brother, father of a baby, whom before that killed his mom - you really think they will stay in order like dogs amd saying: yes, yes Israeli maste🤢 check the resistance in ww2-the both netenjahu and n@7/ regime are based on superiou race-hiw historyy turns murdered became the murderers and Ge****** comitters-same what thei ancestors went thru-inteserstog frpm psyhciological stand point how it happens. Mingboggling
Egypt was offered Gaza back in 1978 Camp David peace accords after they lost the Yom kippur war they started was lost . They rejected Gaza back yet chose Sinai desert instead even though Gaza was part of Egypt and half of Gaza Palestinians are Egyptian. Israel gave Gaza back to Arabs in 2005. Judaiah Sumeria ( West Bank) was part of Israel. Not accurate history. Arabs attacked 1929 before Zionism. Roman Emporor Hadrian renamed Israel Palestine after Philistines Assyrian Greeks not Arabs not Muslims after Bar Kochba rebellion against Rome by Jews was lost in 135ce . Quran says Israel 🇮🇱 43 times no Palestine in Quran.
Wow. So many things in this video, that I didn't know.... Todah on this superb journalism. The internet needs to watch this video. Kudos to the production team.
God Bless Israel.❤ Jerusalem, Judea, and Samaria “ Jesus said - You will be my witnesses in Jerusalem and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the end of the earth” - these are the last documented words Jesus spoke to his disciples before He ascended into heaven (Acts 1:8). John 4 - says "Salvation to mankind will come from the Jews" Amen❤
1. God forbids idol worship. 2. Praying to saints or Mary or Jesus who are creations instead of praying only to God who is the creator is idol worship in Judaism and Islam and in some Christian sects. 3. Jews and Muslims love Christians by explaining that the messiah in Tanakh is a human biological descendant of the messiah king David through the messiah king Solomon meaning the messiah is not God and not a Trinity with God. 4. Jews and Muslims love Christians by explaining that the messiah in the Quran is a human who did not descend from the messiah king David because a person who has no biological father inherits no tribe in Judaism. 5. Jews and Muslims love Christians by explaining that in Gospel of John 20:17 Jesus said he did not die on the cross meaning no one sacrificed him and he explains that he is a human and he is not God. 6. Jews and Muslims love Christians by explaining that not all Christians believe that Jesus is God or that Jesus is a Trinity with God.
When is Christianity not idol worship? See 1. Appalled Christian Caller! "You call my religion idolatry?" Rabbi Tovia Singer responds See 2. Christian shocked when Rabbi Tovia Singer defends Unitarians while teaching Torah. See 3. What did Jesus write? Rabbi Tovia Singer responds. See 4. Is Christianity Idolatry? Christian Challenges Rabbi Tovia Singer.
When is Christianity idol worship? See 1. Former Pastor expresses his fear of leaving the Church with Rabbi Tovia Singer. See 2. Is Christianity Idolatry? Rabbi Tovia Singer. See 3. Ex-Mormon turned Christian wants the Truth. Rabbi Tovia Singer. See 4. Did Jesus die for my sins? Rabbi Tovia Singer See 5. The Disputation in Barcelona - Ramban (Nachmanides) debates before King James of Aragon. Rabbi Tovia Singer. See 6. How did idolatry invade the Church? Rabbi Tovia Singer. See 7. The barrier between God and man: Jesus. Rabbi Tovia Singer.
GAZA could have been a transport and resort hub but it was not to be. Annexation, become a new Miami or Costa del Sol with 7 miles of pristine beaches and develop airports, transport hubs, harbors and specialized crops Link GAZA like St Martins (French-Dutch) with Egyptian Sinai, duty free and open passport for residents and tourists This may require the populace of GAZA to be moved to US Democrat cities or the UK or Ireland where they are supported
1. unlikely.. what western nation in their right mind would want to import terrorists ? ok.. maybe russia, or north korea, or even hungary now that it's been turned into a dictatorship. eg: look at what's happened in Germany. they accepted almost a million refugees from the middle east 4 years ago. Those refugees have caused so much trouble that the govt. is now looking at shutting down mosques.
I am so happy I found this RUclips channel. I value and appreciate the honest truth (this YT channel provides) in regards to the history and current affairs of Israel.
1. The Palestinian flag was invented in the 1960s when Palestinian identity was created. 2. "Palestinians with Israeli citizenship" are Israeli Arabs, descendants of Arabs who didn't leave in 1948. There are 2 million and are 20% of Israeli population, they are Israelis exactly like Jews and have full rights. A majority support Israel. 3. West Bank belonged to Jordan before 1967 and people living there were Jordanians, Gaza belonged to Egypt before 1967 and people there were Egyptians. 4. Arabs were not ethnically cleansed in 1948, the opposite, they fled and are the ones who tried to ethnically cleanse the Jews before 1948. In 1948 all Arab countries attacked the new Israeli state after refusing the 1947 UN partition plan. 5. The UN and Arab countries created refugee status that passes through generations, as political tool against Israel. They also created "right of return", there is no such thing anywhere else in the world. 6. So the "Nakba" (catastrophe) is about the fact that they lost the war that they started and left their homes (most of them voluntarily) because of war that they themselves started. 7. And as we all know very well, there is no genocide in Gaza, there is a war, that again they themselves started.
@igbadumefavour Look I'm going to say this simply, Ashke-nazi came over from Europe in the 1940s they are not Indigenous to that land. They are white Eastern Europeans whose ancestors converted to Judaism in the Rhineland what is now known as Germany. Therefore these people have no connection to the holy land. In fact, these people are not Semitic.
@@xersesshadowblade1193 Only a small fraction of Israelis are Ashkenazi; more came from Iberia and more still from the Middle East. Basically every Jew that survived the massacres in Iraq and Yemen ended up in Israel. "Palestinians" came from Egypt as colonizers; very few of them lived in the area before the Jews returned. Most of the people living in what is now Israel were Christians and Druse, not Muslims. So-called "Palestinians" should go back to where they belong, except no one wants them. With good reason, too.
Thank you, for this simple explanation (non-complicated). I started to overly judge Jews for the Gaza massacres but it is not that simple. Peace for Isreal and freedom for Palestine. ❤
Jerusalem, Judea, and Samaria “ Jesus said - You will be my witnesses in Jerusalem and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the end of the earth” - these are the last documented words Jesus spoke to his disciples before He ascended into heaven (Acts 1:8). John 4 - says "Salvation to mankind will come from the Jews" Amen❤
One thing I would say is that these wars over religious prejudices always happen to be out of misinterpretation or ignorance to some of the most important points in both the Shariah and the Jewish Teachings about coexistence with the others, like we have the idea in the Islamic teachings insisting to respect others and never despise them even if they have what could contradict to their beliefs (both the Sharia and the Sunnah), an example from Sunan Al-Tirmidhi: On the authority of Anas ibn Malik (may Allah be pleased with him), he said: “It reached Safiyyah that Hafsah said, ‘[She is] the daughter of a Jew,’ so she cried. The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) entered upon her while she was crying and said, ‘What makes you cry?’ She said, ‘Hafsah said to me, ‘I am the daughter of a Jew.’ The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said, ‘You are the daughter of a prophet, your uncle is a prophet, and you are married to a prophet. What does she boast about to you?’ Then he said, ‘Fear Allah, O Hafsah.’” Here, Safiyyah is a Jewish wife of the Prophet Muhammad, and recieved abuse and criticism from the Muslim wives antisemitically, therefore, she went to complain about that to the prophet, and instead of defending his other Muslim wives, he had encouraged Safiyyah to be proud of her Jewish lineage, proving that avoiding the Jews should be in a general sense, in other words, avoiding commitment to Judaism much like any other non-Islamic religion Islamic studies had told to avoid, but nor the Quran nor the Hadiths had obliged the Muslims to be "aggressive" or "antisemitic" at the Jews "just because they are Jewish"... And the similar idea comes to Judaism in the concept of "Goyim", much like the Quran, the Goyim are considered against God, and the same goes with the Kuffar and the Mushrikīn "Pagans" in the Quran, but despite this, neither both religions had insisted to fight the people who follow a religion that contradicts with the other for no just reason, according to Leviticus 19:34, and Surah Al-Hujurat 49 : 13, both talks about how we should coexist with each other! And now with the situation of Palestine and Israel, it is more of a topic that relies on Justice than Religion and Theology, both have a history, both have an identity in this land, as all the Arabs (whether they are Palestinians or not), and the Israelites are all belonging to Shem (or Sām in Arabic), giving us all the identity of semitism, therefore fighting against each other does not make anything better, and would lead to possible regrets in the future... I wish both sides know that even tho they have their own traumas, it is immoral to eliminate the neighbors for their culture or religious identity, and now, I'd say, that from the river to the sea, there will be peace and empathy! Salam and Shalom from an Arab Jew! ❤️🖤🤍💚🤍💙🤍💙🤍
Why didn't you mention the Jews who lived in Gaza for centuries who were all driven out and their land stolen by Arabs in 1929. You didn't bother to mention how Egypt treated Gaza before 1967. Leaving out those important contexts makes this an incomplete story.
The answer is that the Palestinians don't leave Israelis alone. The age-old Palestinian hobby is constantly starting wars with a vastly superior military power ie Israel, getting smashed, then crying. So maybe the great big thing they could try, is stop attacking Israel. Israel is in Gaza right now because Hamas attacked Israel on Oct 7, kidnapped hundreds of hostages. Logically, the only things Hamas needs to do is surrender unconditionally and release all hostages. They could have done it at any time in the last 10 months. The only reason you would blame Israel for the war is if you're stupid or you're a Hamas supporter.
did anyone remember how gazans tried to overthrow jordan?
The U.K created monarchy* that collaborated with zionists.
you mean their original country
Black September was a civil war. Jordan gave citizenship to all Palestinians and annexed the west bank. The west bank is either Jordanian or Israeli, and since Jordan rescinded their claim, it is solely Israeli territory.
That will make the palestinian Israelite
@@christmamina5273 Palestinians are Arab, Israelites were the ancestors of Judeans who are today Jews. So no
You must admit - some of the Gaza population were migrants from Egypt. Actually many of them
I believe over half are. and the rest from the neighboring Arab countries. Both Jews and Arabs have a linage genetically back to the Caanites.
The most common family name in Gaza is Al-Masri (from Egypt)
most of them
Then that's sad that their 'motherland' doesn't want to take them back in but has such a huge border wall to block them out (even stronger than Israel's wire fencing that they bulldozed down) :(
And Begin and Ben-Gurion were native-born Israelis?
I'm an Iranian, Monarchist, I think Judea and Samaria belongs to Israel, King Cyrus the Great helped the Jews and believed those lands belongs to jews, he even helped in financing the rebuilding of temple if I'm not wrong, he said I can give the money but I bring egyptians architects to help jews to rebuild it. Anyway there is an ancient bond between Iranians (Persians) and Jews, may Israelites live in peace in their eternal holy land.
Thanks! We made a video about Cyrus the Great and the 2nd Temple: ruclips.net/video/kXAXkvZrABg/видео.html And a video about Iran and Israel bond: ruclips.net/video/hnsFGDhT9ek/видео.html
@@UNPACKED "If the Jews didn't exist, the anti Semite would invent them", Jean-Paul Sartre
Sometimes I watch Dominic Lieven on RUclips, who writes about empires, and, for better or worse, empires were mostly broken up in the 20th century, partly because of nationalism. One could argue that perhaps the Ottoman Empire (until 1914, or the Persian Empire) were better at accommodating diverse populations and religions than the situation we have today. However, in these empires everyone was a subject, not a citizen, and that would be difficult for people to accept today.
And now you are okay with the Israelis fake citizenry of Europeans attacking the very nation that saved them time and time again. or are these just European imposters, who are part of the European union as they are European, but also claim to be from the Middle East through their adopted religion through conversion, who claim membership in the African Union, beats me on what grounds, and wants to claim the Americas and the world since some Jews lived in those pats of the world. With this logic, the whole world belongs to them. Strange that a Iranian, favors the claim of the Israeli enemy, bent on the destruction of Iran, his own ancestral homeland. You seem to either be a traitor or an imposter, or a Zionist bot.
Good old claptrap!
I don't understand, why 1967? On May 15, 1948, one day after the establishment of the State of Israel, the surrounding countries attacked Israel. In this war, Trans-Jordan occupied much of the area west of the Jordan, including Jerusalem. This annexation was illegal. The Six-Day War followed in 1967, again between Israel and its surrounding neighbors.
Israel regained control of the 1948 territories, including Jerusalem and Sinai. After giving Sinai to Egypt in 1979, Israel now controls almost exactly the territory that was allocated to the Jewish people in the Mandate for Palestine, as far as the part west of the Jordan. The West Bank and Jerusalem are also included. This territory has never been assigned by law to any other nation other than Israel. According to the Mandate, Jews are allowed and even encouraged to live in any part of Palestine.
exactly the 1920 San Remo Agreement (League of Nations) is still valid under international law. As long as there is no new division, it all belongs to the Jewish Homeland from the River to the Sea (Named like this in 1920).
By your logic all Palestinians (the people that come with the land) are Israeli citizens and the IDF has been killing 40,000 Israeli citizens
I am an Ex-Muslim from Iran and I am sure that the majority of Iranians stand with Israel and hate the Islamic regime of ayatollah in Iran. The friendship between Iran and Israel is not something new, It has very ancient historical roots from over 2500 years ago When King Cyrus the Great peacefully conquered Babilon and freed all Jewish people from bondage. ❤️✡️🇮🇱✡️❤️
You are joking right? Either that you are a paid Israeli hasbara agent.
I’m also an ex-Muslim and your comment sounds like bs
If so, why don't the Iranian people overthrow the regime that has sent them back to the middle-ages?
For reference, the comment by @mreza84 is what US/Israeli propaganda on the internet looks like. Iranians hate Israel, so this is an example of "big lie" propaganda with a "shill from the crowd" stance.
Being an ex-Muslim doesn't make you an Israel supporter.
I swear channels like yours are better at making Palestinians sympathetic than most of the actual Free Palestine movement
That's the power of actual information and a genuine intent for understanding, more powerful than spreading propaganda and hatred
if that so?? then why hes ONE PART not tell full issues? like hey!!! the thief is allowed to have the house but the owner have NO RIGHT TO LIVE EVEN!! what about the ever expiosn settlement eh?
@@Sploberrie
You must have watched some other video!
@@skeletonking4119lol that's because u get yo info from Propaganda channels. If jews won that land in 1948,that means They own it fool..
Giving Jewish land for peace never worked out
Neither has giving Muslim land. They'll take it and just keep attacking.
Physco theif nation wearing little hats 😂
When did they try it?
@@willythemailboy2 but who bomb em and says WHY DONT YOU HAVE PEACE??!?!?!? WHY DO YOU ATTACK ME TERROIST!> i just want YOUR LAND AND ITS RICH OIL!
Lookup the 2005 disengagement.
Lookup the Oslo accords.
This is one of the best pieces Unpacked has put together. It is as fair and balanced accounting as you are going to get from a pro-Israeli source, which is much more than you'll ever get from the other guys. Nice job guys.
"Those who fail to learn from history are doomed to repeat it "
Winston Churchill
winston was very racist..
You forgot one important fact. The Hashamite reign on Jordan (Trans-Jordan) is a colonial force backed by the British since 1917. 70% of Jordanians are Palestinians and should get back their real land.
Where are that real land ... gaaza ?
I'm assuming that you are on your real land?
@@mikeparkes2355
There is a nerative out there. It's partial and mostly un true. Do you want to push the nerative or do you want to talk about what is true?
The jews come from the land of Israel. Abraham is buried in Hebron. All our history is here. All our religion is here. Yep, this is my land.
Do other people live here too? Yes.
Do they have equel rights? All citizens of Israel have equel right.
Does Israel occupy more lands? Partly
We left Gaza in 2005 and for the past year we are at war with Hamas after their attak on Oct. 7th 2023.
We do control parts of Judeah and Sumaria (the West Bank) and the PA controls most of it. There is a lot of terror coming from there too. 2 days ago a suicide bomber tried to level a synagogue in Tel Aviv.
Everything here is true. Look it up.
Actually Palestina is a land región and incluyes also, sirya and Jordan
@@dhyana87658
It was called Syria-Palestina under the Otoman Empire. It included today's Syria, Lebanon, Jordan and Israel. After WWI the British and French divided the land. The Balfur decleration of 1917 promised the Israel (and arguably Jordan) part for building a home for the Jewish people.
Since 1917 til 1948, the British (in their Mandate) tried to avoid that decision and stopped Jews from entering the land (the White Book for example) and encouraged Arabs to come. More than 50% of the Arabs in Israel in 1948 came after 1917.
Those are all facts that you can check.
Man these two peoples will never see eye to eye
Why? Semites hating each other 🙏
Bloodthirsty Muslims will never see eye to eye with anyone
Not true. He already explained how there was a period of peace and economy and cultural exchange. Moreover, all the three villages attacked on October 7th are peace believers, free of religion minded people, they chose to give jobs and help those in Gaza. That’s how they knew which houses to go to, who were unarmed and weak. The betrayed the only ones that were literally, giving them a chance to prove that they are right.
U want the people of gaza to befriend the people that are ok with ethincally cleansing them, unaliving them, graping them, oppressing them, Imprisoning them without evidence, accusing them of terror without evidence, restricting them, spying on them exc....
This is one sided. The moment the Israeli people come our and condemn their cgovernment peace will never prevail. Revenge will be sort. The palestinians deserve justice.
The media worldwide is working hard every day to insure this remains the case. The abject and complete ignorance of people about this situation and their passionate and violent dedication to retain this ignorance is the height and glory of news media and journalists, in league with the Arab controlled UN.
On 1967 Jurden and Israel agreed that Israel will take the west bank and that is because Jorden does not want the Palestinians people.
But other than that this is very accurate.
70% of jordan's population is palestinien , why dont they want the west bank today?
Both occupied Palestine illegally. Self Determination was promised by the UN.
@@tradeprosper5002
Occupy is illegal.. so your statement is just wrong
Refusing Israeli citizenship when offered, big mistake, big!!
Or signing a peace deal for a more and more generous two state solutions up to 7 times now! You have to fight wars with the pen and paper not guns and murder. The only people who suffer from any war is the innocent. They could have built and expanded if they just worked more bureaucratically. But here we are watching this unfold.
@@Musicinternal Arafat declined the camp David peace deal as he was out for himself he wanted to keep the struggle with Israel going if he could make the gazans bleed, the world would donate more money & more $$$$ from Iran for the cause. It was also in Irans best interest to keep the struggle going.
@@Musicinternal It was far from generous, the European colonists got way to much
Uh, no thanks. The world is repulsed by Iz and its actions.
@janettedewar6617 do you need reminding that Palestinians have every right to refuse any deal, after all this is their land. There is only a one state solution as Israel has made certain a two state solution is not possible; Palestine, with a one person, one vote system, and current occupants can choose to integrate or move elsewhere.
There's a factual error at 14:57 when it's said that "Hamas won 44% of seats in the Palestinian Legislative Council" in the 2006 election. 44% was the percentage of votes achieved by Hamas, but they won 74 of the 132 seats in the PLC (i.e., 56% of the seats).
Unpacked does not know real history or research.
Important point.
It is extremely important because it shows that it was actually Fatah who orchestrated a coup - with IL and US support.
All parties running in that election, including H...s were approved by IL and the US. If they didn't want them to run for the votes they could have banned them to do so. Not real democracy but who cared at that point. But after they won the election it was the coup against the election results that kept Fatah in power in the West Bank. The coup was unsuccessful int Gaza where H...s replied with extreme brutality.
But any other narrative of the story is mere lie.
This is one of the best and balanced videos I have seen. Thanks for this!
Lier
You are even less informed than the OP
It's propagandistic idiocy.
Why does it start in 1967? The Jewish didn't attack in 1948 - but the video just says "the Jewish state battled it's neighbors" ...
It seems balanced to someone who is not really versed in the conflict. It doesn't cover much Israeli wrongdoing unfortunately. And I mean what Israel has been doing outside the wars. Since you-know-who has ruled 17 out of the last 28 years to be more specific. Well, he seems like he knows how to hold on power and that happens by severely mistreating whoever is less mighty. So much for humans being different from animals. October 7th happened entirely directly due to his policies. Avoiding any and all solutions and furthermore expanding and pressuring the neighbours.
Jewish population of the Arab world 1947: over a million
2020: under 100,0000
Between the river and the sea Arab population
1947: 500,000
2020: 7 million
Who exactly is committing genocide and ethnic cleansing?
And the Druzs, and Christians were forced or killed out as well. Most of this misery occurred right after the Nakba in 1948, after Izreal won the war. No one talks about the 700,000 Jews that were forced out and murdered in Lebanon, Syria, Egypt and Jordan as they ran to the homeland of Izreal for their own survival.
they moved to israeli occupied palestine
@@annankhan7397They we’re brutally expelled to Israel. Luckily they had Israel as a safe home.
Yup! That is the truth@@Musicinternal
@@jordanjay1479 i cant believe your gullible.
I have to say, you did a great job! Covering most important historical facts, and always clearly stating that those who suffer are the normal people on both sides. Thank you for the great job, I will share this video with all I know!
But why dont he do a ducumentary on the bad and evil side of what isreal Goverment is really doing to the gaza people... This shows owns the oppresso❤..
@@lamarcurtis1582 not able to write country's name "Israel" correctly is a clear sign you live outside the objective reality.
we can talk about it which historical facts do you want to start with??????????
@@DjTaz8023 which ones?
@@oborotenn i think i put enough question marks...
i get the feeling that this is a good attempt of explaining the situation. A 21 minute explanation will always miss some details and it is not for me or many others to say (or think) that those missing details would change the explanation entirely.
I crossed paths with King Hussein (the junior) once. He had 70 slaves that travelled with him. The slaves wore mink stoles and armani suits.
Nice one sided history of Gaza where it looks like Israel did nothing wrong in effecting Gazans and Palestinians in mass.
You might have thrown in the over 14 mass*acres that Israel is responsible for as well as the good ole occasional "mowing of the lawn" that Israel would gleefully do..
If you're going to portray the light in one way, maybe you can cover the full size of the case to make this acceptable as a good report of the facts. (I will see how long this post remains).
The discussion in this war is absurd. First.
Israel acted selflessly to live in peace with the Palestinians in Gaza. It was more than a decade ago when Israel itself relocated thousands of individuals living in Gaza with lethal force from their homes to follow the agreement, which obligated the Palestinians in return to stop any kind of aggression towards Israel. The Palestinians had the chance to build a safe, functional, and prosperous livelihood. But the first thing the Palestinians did in return was to elect a government that enshrined the goal of destroying Israel in their constitution. The elected government followed through with its promise. Since its founding, thousands of rockets have flown into Israel. Dozens of civilians died in terrorist attacks. Millions of aid funds - intended for civilian purpose - were misused to build rockets, tunnels, and other nonsense. The crimes committed on October 7th like raping women, killing children, or kidnapping a baby, was Humus has been doing for years. Secondly. Israel behaved more humanely in this conflict than any other conceivable party in any imaginable conflict. It allowed Palestinians to work in Israel, receive medical care or even migrate into their country. During war, they warn civilians where their military is operating. They admit collateral damage and apologize for it. They saved Sinwar’s life giving him a lethal brain surgery. They treated the daughter of Haniyyas daughter for her complex disease in Israel. While Humus was building rockets and tunnels with all the foreign aid, Israel supplied their civilians with free water and electricity. The situation is clear. In no other conflict the responsibility for the suffering has been so one sided and clear - in no other conflict have the perpetrators been held accountable so weakly. The same goes for any related conflict: Hezbollah, Houthis, etc…the more peacefully you try to live with them, the more visible their genocidal intents becomes.
People with voice and power who claim to reject war have the duty to unequivocally name the culprit of this war and do everything in their power to eliminate them. Everything else is responsibility for the resulting suffering and will extend it.
And when the Jewish settlements in Gaza were evacuated, they left all the flourishing hot-houses etc. so the Gazans could grow their own food, and within weeks, they were all trashed. Why? Because their leaders want the people to be poor and miserable so they can blame Israel!
That's why I don't feel sorry for them
Palestinians hate Jews more than they love their own children. I don't see that ever changing.
Keep tellling yourself that. While you live on their land.
@@jonathanludd It's not their land, and never was. They were the colonizers and got kicked out. Deal with it.
Who Owns the Gaza Strip? = THE LORD bestowed that and greater area of land to the Jews.
Upon a written peace agreement between Egypt and Israel Egypt, who owned Gaza, gave it to Israel. There was No written agreement between Egypt and Arabs "Palestinians" Gaza belongs to them.
They didn't give it to Israel they just didn't take it back.
The international community always tried to put legs in Israel's path and by pressuring Israel using the palestinians as a tool they can play like an ally economicallyy while attacking Israel politically.
It would not be a problem if the Gazans really did build a state - but they chose to build a terrorist machine instead.
Exactly. International law states that an occupied territory is land taken by a country from another country, Israel occupied Gaza until Egypt rescinded their claim to the territory, thus making it solely Israeli land.
Even Mousa Abu Marzouk said 75% of people in Gaza had no claim on Israeli land or Gaza.
@@TheWorldsBestPilotthat and the fact that what is now called Gaza was part of ancient ersatz Israel. It along with what was given to make Jordan was also suppose to be part of the reestablished Jewish homeland. League of Nations.
Israel gave gazans a full city and infrastructure in 2005. Moved all Israelis out. Gave Gazans the keys. They elected hamas. And here we are.
Netanyahu elected Hamas…..Always look at the agenda….Synagogues of Zionist Satans Servants…it not about religion it’s about Money always with The Weat…Look up The Gas and oil they know is under GAZA…Shameful
Blockade.
Gaza and the coast were occupied by the Philistines thousands of years ago. They were taken over and disappeared from history as Philistines, but many of the people stayed in the surrounding area.
Inland Palestinians were Semitic people from the area going back about 8-10 thousand years, from Philistines, Canaanites, and other local tribes of the times and then including migrant people from the immediate areas of north Egypt, Jordan, southern Lebanon, Syria.
Palestinians have a similar yet separate identity from other Arab countries. Such as the countries of Europe are similar but have their own history and cultures.
The Jews came onto the picture as a story of Abraham from Babylonia. They likely converted some local tribes to Judaism as Islam didn't come into existence until after Christianity of the 1st century.
Most of the Jewish left a couple thousand years ago, but those that stayed were treated well and lived without conflict and free to practice their religion. Palestine was a thriving, busy, farming, fishing and trade hub for 400 years under the Ottomans until WW1. Goods from all over the region were transported through the port, spices, goods, grains etc from Africa and Asia were brought to the area for trade and transport. Palestine itself was particularly known for olive products, wool, fine soaps, pottery, glass, and produce.
It was the hundreds of thousands of European refugees that immigrated into Palestine and with an army, forced 700,000 native Palestinians off their heritage farms, lands, villages around Jerusalem, the north, west bank etc.
The Israeli army was violent killing people and executing children and elders and burning homes. Nearly a million displaced people. This is called the "Nakba"
Some left to Jordan or Egypt but many went to Gaza.
Palestinians are newcomers to the area. They came in the 1930s for British jobs. Their ancestral homes are in Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, and Turkey.
They were basically sharecroppers land was owned by absentee landowners. Have to remember the area we call Israel was terrible for agriculture. Besides the religious sites it was pretty much worthless before the Jews started irrigation projects to create farmland.
Not true. In 1880 there were around 300.000 Arabs living in this land.
Please cite
It true when the jews settled in the land the land was desolate and with lot of swamps. The jews dried the swamps and fight desess like malria, after that many Arabs from Arabs countries came to palestina to find jobs. look at potos from the beginning of the 19th century and see how desolate and empty was the land. And read what people like Mark Twin wrote about the land. The Arabs don't accept the right of Israel to exist in any borders and any size because they claim to return of refugees into Israel border of 1948. That israel can not accept. What about 850000 jews refugees from Arabs countries that came to Israel after they suffered from pogroms and Humiliation in the Arabs countries. And the jews really lived in the Arabs countries for generations not like most of the Arabs that arrived to palestina in the 19th century.
Even if that were true, which it isn't entirely, the people of Gaza would still have more association with the Levant than the Eastern Europeans, Central Europeans, and American Europeans who arrived in 1947/1948.
You're presentation is great. I usually agree with all your podcasts and find them accurate and interesting.
I just need to correct a few points.
I think you've colored the facts with a western outlook.
And some are misinformed entirely.
Saying it's occupied is an Arab/Russian invention.
There was absolutely no need to give anything back accordingto international laws. The only thing the arabs want is a Jewish free Israel under their rule.
And Arafat ימ"ש is recorded saying we can lie to Israel and to the West to achieve our goals. He actually rejected agreements that gave them loads of territory and autonomy. The biggest obstruction to piece are the Arabs because they don't want piece they want to rule the whole world.
They are religious fanatics, racist, and believe only in sharia law. You can't handle them with talking and giving away, in the Arab world they consider you a joke.
They only understand strength.
At the end of our prayers 3 times a day one of the last things we say is what the children in Shushan told Haman:
עוצו עיצה ותופר דברו דבר ולא יקום כי עמנו ק-ל
"They can plan plans and talk talks but nothing will be fullfilled because G-D is with us."
I believe this goes for the Israeli government as well.
G-D has saved us from our own stupidity.
The only reason Israel still exists is miraculous, and because G-D promised it and he wills it.
And for the Arabs that is one of the biggest threats. That they see G-D is not on their side.
You just describe the so called Israël actually Thank you for your support for palestine 🇵🇸
@naymatunc-rc6vs where's Palestine never heard of it!!
@@chanaselwyn9265the palestinian people Palestine wont dissapear just because you have no knowledge
On Arafat lying - you should know that in Islam it is perfectly fine to LIE to those you are negotiating with, if you need to to get the result you want ! For Islam the only thing that matters is the end result. As in CONVERT or SUBDUE or KILL all those you come across in order to spread Islam - an actual instruction in their 'book' !!! So do not be surprised at Arafat !
Well said!
Very neutral report without propaganda 👏👏
Actually, it is pretty supportive of Arab propaganda, with only a light leaning towards Israel.
NEUTRAL 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 You have got to be kidding me.
Not at all
@@nickydabas1622 Yes, it was very factual.
This is one of the most informative and well balanced videos I've seen on this conflict. We need to find a way for peace and to share the land.
WELL BALANCED 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 I still cannot get used to the BS that comes out of the mouths of Israelis, Zionists & their supporters.
amazing video explaining the situation perfectly from both sides 👏
that’s very hard to do
WHAT A LOAD OF BS. FROM BOTH SIDES. WHO ARE YOU KIDDING. I KNEW WHOSE SIDE HE WAS ON WITHIN 10 SECS OF HIM SPEAKING. AND EVERYONE APPLAUDING THIS ARE EITHER ISRAELI, ZIONISTS OR INHUMANE 😠 😡
not really both sides.
1:31 I just want to make a note here. The term Palestinian for non Israelis would not have been used in 1967. Until the 70s they were just called Arabs. It wasn’t until the PLO was founded that they adopted the Palestinian identity.
Edit: I do not mean that nobody identified themselves and called themselves Palestinian until the 70s. Everybody (including Jews) called themselves Palestinian for years and years. But, what started in the 70s was the strict Arab Palestinian identity of today.
Edit 2: This really shouldn’t be that controversial. The modern Palestinian identity that refers strictly Arabs who are non Israeli started with the formation of the PLO in the 1970s. Before that Palestinian was a term for all people who lived in the region of Palestine. PM Golda Mier even talked about this development and how it didn’t make sense, as she should be considered Palestinian cause she lives in that region. The term Palestinian switches meaning. You can look it up.
The Arab's know that too but they do not want to admitted! Brit's are know as FOX are trouble maker's! ❤️💪🇮🇱🙏🕊️
Unpacked does not understand history here.
Typical pathological liar. Funny my husband has been Palestinian since he was born in 1963.
@@nickydabas1622 all people who lived in the region used to be called Palestinian. I have old Jewish Israeli relatives who still sometimes call themselves Palestinian. The idea of a strictly Arab Palestinian identity only comes about when the PLO is established. Do your history.
@@dallasgrey4247 READ YOUR FIRST STUPID ANSWER AGAIN DH
"Israel went to war with its neighbors". No, Israel was *attacked* by its neighbors leading to a war that Israel defended and won.
I second the remark made by @richwilson1788 - one has to be very careful when describing events in this ambiguous ways. Facts are that three Arab states neighbors of Israel have been planing to attack Israel. They have initiated what were clearly preparations for war, that included the Egyptian army moving into the Sinai peninsula having expelled the UN forces that have been there since 1956, the closing of the Straits of Tiran, the only exit for Israel from the Red sea and the later unvailed phone call between Egypt's Gamal Abdel Nasser and King Houssein of Jordan.
Thanks for making videos that arent just bashing the other. This conflict, this war and all its horrors, will not have a simple ending. I feel sadly this will take generations, third parties, and a LOT of money to rebuild beautiful Gaza, to heal both people groups. There is ao much talk about hatred but not about what has happened and what has to happen next.
🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸Well researched description🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸of this intractable conflict🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🔥🔥🔥Sykes-Picot agreement of 1917🔥🔥🔥is the beginning of this unfortunate situation between two brotherly peoples🔥🔥🔥
They have nice beaches it could've been a jewel of a place
That is why Isreali is killing ppl to get the beach to earn tourist...Gaza Strip is big money for Nathanyhu
land only blooms under the people that God gave it.
ps. I see what you did there ( jew el )
Exactly. If the Gazans (Hamas) weren't so deadset on fighting Israël and making Gaza into a warzone, too unsafe for people to visit, they could have had so many opportunities to develop the land. Just like any other country with a Mediterranian Sea coastline, they could have prospered. So sad.
@MJKJ70 that is way Nathanyhu needs Gaza empty so he can rebuild for tourism and earn money...
@@mq2311 Netanyahu doesn't want Gaza empty. It's an impossible task. Most Israelis simply see Gaza as an irrelevant shthole.
They want hostages, Hamas no longer a threat, then the rest of Gaza can f right off to do whatever people do in shtholes.
It'd be much better if Egypt kept Gaza. Realistically, no one wants that place other than religious nutjobs.
But the Palestinians are the colonists. The name Jew comes from people from Judah. It is the Jewish nation that has been repeated colonized throughout history, but this region is their ancestral land
You my friend are amazing. Thank you. By far the cleanest perspective of this conflict! I took a lot from this!
🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸Well researched description🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸of this intractable conflict🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🔥🔥🔥Sykes-Picot agreement of 1917🔥🔥🔥is the beginning of this unfortunate situation between two brotherly peoples🔥🔥🔥
This was refreshing to see an unbiased presentation on a very complicated subject with no easy solutions
This entire channel is 100% biased. It’s practically a front for Hasbara propaganda
This channel is subtle in it's bias for sure. He speaks to an audience looking for platitudes, for neutrality....and fails💯💯💯.
Very good video! Finally one that shines more light on the matter from a rather neutral perspective and a more extensive timeline. Thanks!
You forgot the ones that stayed and live in peace and have the same rights as anymore that lives in Israel. Remember it was Israel before Mohammad was even born
They gave Gaza (part of Israel) for peace, the General minister Arielle Sharon at that time unfortunately already deceased, all settlers had to leave their homes with protest of course, and what did these murderers do with it, it is unbelievable, shma Israel chai 🇮🇱 🇮🇱 🇩🇪🇮🇱🇮🇱
And the whole world is rallying against Israel for her generosity,
You mean Ariel Sharon the war criminal 🤔
Without usa support, kharael will deport
@@mounafmakhlouf6665 germany also stay on the side of Israel, we love USA,,,
@@nickydabas1622 Nah, Ariel Sharon, the person stupid enough to give Palestinians Gaza as a gesture of peace. Thinking that Palestinians won't shoot themselves in the foot like always.
Best video about gaza.
True but not about Israel
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
It’s interesting how he ends this narrative about who owns the land. I’m Jewish, born in the former Soviet Union. From my childhood, I remember constantly being reminded of our identity and being shown the door, being told that we were not welcome there. I was born there, but that doesn’t mean I-or we as Jewish people-have the right to claim Russian, Ukrainian, Polish, or any other European or Middle Eastern territories as our own, even though Jews lived there for hundreds of years. Israel is our ancestral land. Palestinians are squatters in our land in the same way we were in Europe. There will never be peace between us and them; they are too violent to live near us in peace.
1000%
Utter bS
U are absolutely correct mate…even india has the same problem in kashmir …all these treaties and accords are like toilet papers to these islamic jihadis
European Jews ? Some of these people look European not Middle Eastern I.e converts
@AL-wn2tt so what's your point?
At 1:00 and already I smell b/s:
"Israelis were certain that they were on the brink of extinction"...
Uh... No...
Egypt closed the Straits of Tiran to block Israeli shipping, then moved defense forces to its border to defend against any possible Israeli attack or invasion.
Israel decided to attack Egypt, along with Jordan and Syria, and having destroyed all their air forces in that offensive attack, was easily able to defeat them all.
There was no danger to "The Jewish state".
Who owns Gaza? Palestinians, not Hamas.
@ryanmoore2447 there is no such thing as ‘Palestinian’ land. ‘Palestina’ is the old greco-roman renaming of JUDEA AND SAMARIA, cradle of JEWISH civilisation, by Roman invaders. After the fall of Ottoman Turk occupation, the land was under British Mandate that partitioned the territory into Israel and Jordan (1946).
Almost right. 'Syria Palestina' was the name given to the whole of Israel by the Romans, after they quashed the Bar Kochva revolt in A.D. 135. 'Palestina' is Latin for 'land of the Philistines', and the Romans chose that name as a deliberate insult to the Jews, because the Philistines had been Israel's ancient enemies. (By Roman times, they had long since ceased to exist as an identifiable ethnic group.) However, there has never, at any time in history, been an independent sovereign state called Palestine, it was only ever a part of Greater Syria. Arabs living in Israel simply called themselves 'Arabs' until the mid 1960's.
The British were given the Mandate for Palestine in 1920, following WW1 and the collapse of the Ottoman Empire. At that time, Palestine included what is now the Kingdom of Jordan, and all of it was designated as a homeland for Jews. Then we gave 78% of it (early 1920's not 1946), the area to the east of the River Jordan, to a minor Saudi prince, because we wanted oil, leaving only the area to the west of the river for a Jewish homeland. The eastern area was designated as a homeland for Palestinian Arabs! In 1922, all 51 members of the League of Nations approved this arrangement. After WW2, the U.N. took over all the rulings of its predecessor, so they still stand. Therefore, all the area 'from the river to the sea' belongs to Israel. Q.E.D.!
Double check your story you forgot to mention that they came from Europe
Oh, you mean this theory? ruclips.net/video/cw0G9COpeMY/видео.html
Or this? ruclips.net/video/nq-emTGIgaI/видео.html
@@UNPACKEDthose israeli women really had a good english accent
not all and i can say that on the arabs in gaza west bank alot migrated during british mandate cuple hundred thousands
check your sources: where did all these Arabs came from after 1850 and again in high numbers after 1918?
@ronnyfokaha, its their ancestoral homeland, they were forced out by different occupiers thoughout history, then forced out of their host countries like egypt etc where they migrated to. So here they just came back. Current palis are from neighboring arab countries, why dont these arab countrirs take them in?
The 1987 Intifada was planned also. Between 1967 and 1986 the Arabs in the West Bank DID have autonomy - the civil service that performed under Jordanian rule continued under Israeli rule - until Arafat ordered the workers to quit their jobs. At that point Israel had to choose between leaving the Arabs without vital services or taking active control of the area. Israel made the compassionate decision to take control and Arafat used this as his excuse to order the Intifada. And of course it spread also to Gaza.
really the Gazans & all their terrorists couldn't run a dog show. Hamas & the PLO & PLA could not agree on anything then another terrorist organisation appeared in Gaza noone knew who they were. Hamas did one thing the PLO did another. bickering, fighting gazans killing gazans. etc. Chaos. The middle east is rife with muslims having sex with animals even dolphins.
Yes, 💯 . And then when Israel withdrew from Gaza the got accused of "leaving Gaza without resources."
@@ericah6546
Sounds like Israel at least tried … again and again.
How anyone can make Gaza a rallying cry is very much beyond me.
God bless and protect Israel, from a South African supporter 🇮🇱🇿🇦
no doubt a white South African
@@janmariablackwell8138 No, just a South African who knows the difference between good and evil...
@@paraweir and yet here you are supporting the very people who support apartheid
@@janmariablackwell8138 I hate to break it to you, bro, but the majority of ALL race groups support Israel.
Let’s not kid ourselves, this is a religious war….
Stay strong Isreal
These discussions are complicated by a confusion between personal ownership of land, and administration of a territory.
What you said is really where the solution have been, right under their very noses.
If only the Israel or Palestinian Government or authority at the first place should have said that, they are the administrative or governing authority of the territory, but whoever has been here ever since whether Arabs, Palestinians or Jews, you still have the personal right of ownership to any peace of land you own.
By then, the people will be happy to be a part of a state that recognises their existence at the personal level without regards to their ethnicity, religion or whatever.
There would not be any problems like today they are facing.
Extremely one sided. Look elsewhere for clarity on this Matter.
Keep in denial
Very wrong: Territories that Israel obtained in the Six-day 1967 War were not "conquered" territories as you erroneously say. They were "re-possessed" territories taken back by Israel from the 1948 Arab invaders- Egypt (Gaza), Jordan (West Bank); and Syria (Golan), who illegally and forcefully invaded and seized the territories from the new State of Israel and held them illegally for 19 years until 1967. These territories were allocated to the Jewish people worldwide in the San Remo Resolution of 4-24-1920 by the lawful sovereigns at the time, the Supreme Allied Powers post WW 1 (UK, France, Italy, Japan and the US as observer), and codified unanimously by the League of Nations (54 nations), in the League of Nations Mandate for Palestine-Israel. Your mis-statements are an affront to international law and the Rules-based order that most of the world ascribes to. Indeed, in 1948 the US, the USSR and many other nations "recognized" the new State of Israel, and the UN accepted Israel as a member state. Israel avoided applying its legal sovereignty to Gaza for the sake of a potential peace treaty with the Arab population. But alas the Arabs were not and are not interested in peace. They are interested in full domination by force, and reject international law.
Now that Israel has re-possessed Gaza for the second time, after the failed Gaza withdrawal of 2005 and the illegal HAMAS takeover and unprovoked attack of 10-7-2023, Israel has no choice but to evacuate the hostile elements of the Gaza population for their safety and the safety of the Israeli survivors of the HAMAS 10-7-23 attack, who do not want and cannot live within walking distance of such a vile, dangerous population. The gross Arab lie of Jewish land theft that you seem to promote, (intentionally or unintentionally), will not bring justice to the Gazans or the Israelis, and the indigenous Jewish People will fight and secure its ancestral, historic, religious, and legal rights in all the Palestine/Israel-Mandate lands, including Gaza. Arabs are welcome to exercise their claims to sovereignty in the nearby Palestinian Arab majority state of Jordan that is currently ruled by a non-Palestinian, King Abdullah, who refuses to accommodate Palestinian Arab aspirations of sovereignty in Jordan, or they can exercise their aspirations of sovereignty in their ancestral land of Arabia. And leave the Jews alone in their ancestral land of Judea-Israel.
Thank you for this concise history. 🇨🇦❤️🇮🇱
This givaway was nevertheless brought about by colonial powers and went directly against the wishes of the local population.
Repossessed the territory sans it's non-jwish population???? It hasnt claimed territory if it doesn't absorb its population.
More voices need to be heard from both people's with the same mindset set like yours brother unfortunately it's the extremists on both sides making noise and being high on hate like you said in the end the land belongs to both of you praying for peace in the holy land 🤲🙏
I love it how your channel explains these complicated issues as objectively as you can. That's why I love your channel. Usually, media outlets are one sided but you try to represent both sides. Please keep the great job
Nice story for sure, however you forgot to mention one very important detail… the will of God for his people Israel
Great comprehensive history
Stay safe my brother...
To correct you Israel was not afraid of a war in 1967 but wanted it, it launched a offensive war to gain territory and to at least use it as barging chip.
You sure about that? ruclips.net/video/KqS8BQDjYpw/видео.htmlsi=6Q85WMB60At5MXZg
@@UNPACKED lol why you only providing links to your one sided of the story videos? Stop trying to rewrite history.
All people should be treated EQUAL. Israel does not want equal rights for ALL the people in greater Israel
Thank you for your bravery in tackling this complicated and sensitive subject.
Israel occupancy 4,000 years
Christians 2,000 years
Islam 1,400 years.
Holy Land is Israel and Israel is Holy Land.
No dispute please
Christianity is the morphing LAST BEAST, Enemy of Gd and His Chosen.
This is all the land of Zeus, the Original an true God
@tomjones9082 Be it Zeus, Jesus, Krishna, they are but fabricated characters of Heathen Man worshiping his own fragile, pathetic Ego, ABOMINATIONS to the CREATOR, WHO Commanded that HE alone is to be worshiped!
As Jeremiah prophesied, the Gentiles will come to see that they have inherited only Lies, Emptiness in which there is nothing of any avail!
The people who throw rockets are those people who's ancestor stays there since 4000 years ago without leaving towards those who just settled ( and claimed sovereignty) in early 20th century.
You are a great historian...please make more
If you believe in the bible and the Quran, the Jews owns Gaza 1000BC when king David establised the kingdom of Israel. Even the Quran mentioned this.
The Jews were complaining to each other about Jesus, because he had said,
I am the bread that came down from heaven.‘
‘Surely this is Jesus son of Joseph’ they said. ‘We know his father and mother.
How can he now say, “I have come down from heaven” ?’
Jesus said in reply,
Stop complaining to each other.
‘No one can come to me unless he is drawn by the Father who sent me,
and I will raise him up at the last day.I am the bread of life3
It is written in the prophets:
They will all be taught by God,
and to hear the teaching of the Father,
and learn from it, is to come to me.
Not that anybody has seen the Father,
except the one who comes from God: he has seen the Father.
I tell you most solemnly, everybody who believes has eternal life.
I am the bread of life. Your fathers ate the manna in the desert and
they are dead; but this is the bread that comes down from heaven,
so that a man may eat it and not die.
I am the living bread which has come down from heaven.
Anyone who eats this bread will live for ever; and the bread that I shall give is my flesh, for the life of the world.’
@@AL-wn2tt the Jews of that time and this time didnt care about Jesus other than that he was making trouble with the Romans during a time of political unrest when Jewish rights to practice their faith and culture was being threatened.
@@pamelakoretsky9909all the first Christians were Jews. Many Jews loved Jesus and without Jews his message and Christianity would not have gone around the world.
But the Quran also makes it clears that the Jews (Bani Israel) were disinherited from the land for their rebellion against God's laws and slaying of his prophets.
Ok, this isn't just propaganda. The history is well covered.
In 1906, the Palestinians arrived in Gaza. They fled from Saoudi Arabia and were called the Rashidis at that time. Al Saoud and his tribe freed Mekka from the future Palestinians. What was the reason??
Cover Operation SIG and Arafat's relationship to the KGB, please.
You got it! ruclips.net/video/pZLDnqDJ0x0/видео.htmlsi=OFkDm3IAD-uh_jeU
@@UNPACKED yophi. So with the understanding that "Palestine" has only ever existed to undermine Jews, why do we continue to use the term?
We don’t shy away from the realities, but the terminology is helpful in communicating that reality to the world.
@@UNPACKED You guys are some of the best resources on the web. Your material is fact-checked and approachable and your presenters are capable and relatable.
With that in mind, whoever controls the microphone controls the narrative. Take control of the language and you remove your opponent's ability to frame the narrative.
Easy to say. Hard to do. I've discussed this with SCN in the States about how to better control the narrative to deter artificial sympathy for antisemites. Best of luck!
God bless Israel and keep them safe.
God, keep Gazans safe too 🙏
What about lithe countries? Does your God care about Palestinians?????
@@gasperstarina9837 But he isn;t is he? He knows what is in a mans heart & the world now knows what lies in the heart of a Gazan we've seen it.
@@janettedewar6617 in their hearts after suffering 80y inder the Jews, after all the "wars" slughterings. There will be raage in everryone who is loosing family members. Also THE BABIES, you yous its totally fine when they are getting killed? Do you think brother, father of a baby, whom before that killed his mom - you really think they will stay in order like dogs amd saying: yes, yes Israeli maste🤢 check the resistance in ww2-the both netenjahu and n@7/ regime are based on superiou race-hiw historyy turns murdered became the murderers and Ge****** comitters-same what thei ancestors went thru-inteserstog frpm psyhciological stand point how it happens. Mingboggling
Nah
Great Video
Egypt was offered Gaza back in 1978 Camp David peace accords after they lost the Yom kippur war they started was lost .
They rejected Gaza back yet chose Sinai desert instead even though Gaza was part of Egypt and half of Gaza Palestinians are Egyptian.
Israel gave Gaza back to Arabs in 2005.
Judaiah Sumeria ( West Bank) was part of Israel.
Not accurate history.
Arabs attacked 1929 before Zionism.
Roman Emporor Hadrian renamed Israel Palestine after Philistines Assyrian Greeks not Arabs not Muslims after Bar Kochba rebellion against Rome by Jews was lost in 135ce .
Quran says Israel 🇮🇱 43 times no Palestine in Quran.
Wow. So many things in this video, that I didn't know.... Todah on this superb journalism. The internet needs to watch this video. Kudos to the production team.
God Bless Israel.❤
Jerusalem, Judea, and Samaria
“ Jesus said - You will be my witnesses in Jerusalem and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the end of the earth” - these are the last documented words Jesus spoke to his disciples before He ascended into heaven (Acts 1:8).
John 4 - says "Salvation to mankind will come from the Jews" Amen❤
Both cults of Jesus have STAINED the Land of the Living with the Blood of Gd's Firstborn Son, Israel the Jews, His High Holy Ones.
Christianity is the morphing LAST BEAST, Enemy of Gd and His Chosen!
1. God forbids idol worship.
2. Praying to saints or Mary or Jesus who are creations instead of praying only to God who is the creator is idol worship in Judaism and Islam and in some Christian sects.
3. Jews and Muslims love Christians by explaining that the messiah in Tanakh is a human biological descendant of the messiah king David through the messiah king Solomon meaning the messiah is not God and not a Trinity with God.
4. Jews and Muslims love Christians by explaining that the messiah in the Quran is a human who did not descend from the messiah king David because a person who has no biological father inherits no tribe in Judaism.
5. Jews and Muslims love Christians by explaining that in Gospel of John 20:17 Jesus said he did not die on the cross meaning no one sacrificed him and he explains that he is a human and he is not God.
6. Jews and Muslims love Christians by explaining that not all Christians believe that Jesus is God or that Jesus is a Trinity with God.
When is Christianity not idol worship?
See 1. Appalled Christian Caller! "You call my religion idolatry?" Rabbi Tovia Singer responds
See 2. Christian shocked when Rabbi Tovia Singer defends Unitarians while teaching Torah.
See 3. What did Jesus write? Rabbi Tovia Singer responds.
See 4. Is Christianity Idolatry? Christian Challenges Rabbi Tovia Singer.
When is Christianity idol worship?
See 1. Former Pastor expresses his fear of leaving the Church with Rabbi Tovia Singer.
See 2. Is Christianity Idolatry? Rabbi Tovia Singer.
See 3. Ex-Mormon turned Christian wants the Truth. Rabbi Tovia Singer.
See 4. Did Jesus die for my sins? Rabbi Tovia Singer
See 5. The Disputation in Barcelona - Ramban (Nachmanides) debates before King James of Aragon. Rabbi Tovia Singer.
See 6. How did idolatry invade the Church? Rabbi Tovia Singer.
See 7. The barrier between God and man: Jesus. Rabbi Tovia Singer.
Thanks for the informative video
GAZA could have been a transport and resort hub but it was not to be.
Annexation, become a new Miami or Costa del Sol with 7 miles of pristine beaches and develop airports, transport hubs, harbors and specialized crops
Link GAZA like St Martins (French-Dutch) with Egyptian Sinai, duty free and open passport for residents and tourists
This may require the populace of GAZA to be moved to US Democrat cities or the UK or Ireland where they are supported
1. unlikely.. what western nation in their right mind would want to import terrorists ? ok.. maybe russia, or north korea, or even hungary now that it's been turned into a dictatorship. eg: look at what's happened in Germany. they accepted almost a million refugees from the middle east 4 years ago. Those refugees have caused so much trouble that the govt. is now looking at shutting down mosques.
Well balanced account of the history. Hard to find on this topic. Well done. Thanks.
HARD TO FIND BECAUSE ITS BS
I am so happy I found this RUclips channel. I value and appreciate the honest truth (this YT channel provides) in regards to the history and current affairs of Israel.
1. The Palestinian flag was invented in the 1960s when Palestinian identity was created.
2. "Palestinians with Israeli citizenship" are Israeli Arabs, descendants of Arabs who didn't leave in 1948. There are 2 million and are 20% of Israeli population, they are Israelis exactly like Jews and have full rights. A majority support Israel.
3. West Bank belonged to Jordan before 1967 and people living there were Jordanians, Gaza belonged to Egypt before 1967 and people there were Egyptians.
4. Arabs were not ethnically cleansed in 1948, the opposite, they fled and are the ones who tried to ethnically cleanse the Jews before 1948. In 1948 all Arab countries attacked the new Israeli state after refusing the 1947 UN partition plan.
5. The UN and Arab countries created refugee status that passes through generations, as political tool against Israel. They also created "right of return", there is no such thing anywhere else in the world.
6. So the "Nakba" (catastrophe) is about the fact that they lost the war that they started and left their homes (most of them voluntarily) because of war that they themselves started.
7. And as we all know very well, there is no genocide in Gaza, there is a war, that again they themselves started.
@igbadumefavour Look I'm going to say this simply, Ashke-nazi came over from Europe in the 1940s they are not Indigenous to that land. They are white Eastern Europeans whose ancestors converted to Judaism in the Rhineland what is now known as Germany. Therefore these people have no connection to the holy land. In fact, these people are not Semitic.
@@xersesshadowblade1193 "Palestinians" are almost entirely Egyptian colonists who came after the Ottomans were kicked out.
@@willythemailboy21 Aske-nazis they came from eastern europe
@@xersesshadowblade1193 Only a small fraction of Israelis are Ashkenazi; more came from Iberia and more still from the Middle East. Basically every Jew that survived the massacres in Iraq and Yemen ended up in Israel. "Palestinians" came from Egypt as colonizers; very few of them lived in the area before the Jews returned. Most of the people living in what is now Israel were Christians and Druse, not Muslims.
So-called "Palestinians" should go back to where they belong, except no one wants them. With good reason, too.
@@xersesshadowblade1193 untrue. i have the same haplotype as Mary Magdelan.
Thank you for a very insightful video! Great content!
These are some of the most informative videos from a very nuetral perspective 👏
israel, they're ones that propped up hamas and now they're struggling to beat them
Absolutely brilliant story telling.
YOU ARE RIGHT. STORY BEING THE OPERATIVE WORD 😂😂😂😂
Excellent summary. Well done.
Thank you, for this simple explanation (non-complicated). I started to overly judge Jews for the Gaza massacres but it is not that simple. Peace for Isreal and freedom for Palestine. ❤
🇮🇱♥️🇮🇱♥️🇮🇱♥️🇮🇱🙏🙏🙏
very well done video, great narrative 👍👏👍
Yo. This is the most even handed commentary I had ever seen in english speaking media
Good presentation
Jerusalem, Judea, and Samaria
“ Jesus said - You will be my witnesses in Jerusalem and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the end of the earth” - these are the last documented words Jesus spoke to his disciples before He ascended into heaven (Acts 1:8).
John 4 - says "Salvation to mankind will come from the Jews" Amen❤
“Ye worship ye know not what: we know what we worship: for salvation is of the Jews.” John 4:22. The words of Jesus Christ, the Son of God.
Thank you. Great job. ❤😢
One thing I would say is that these wars over religious prejudices always happen to be out of misinterpretation or ignorance to some of the most important points in both the Shariah and the Jewish Teachings about coexistence with the others, like we have the idea in the Islamic teachings insisting to respect others and never despise them even if they have what could contradict to their beliefs (both the Sharia and the Sunnah), an example from Sunan Al-Tirmidhi:
On the authority of Anas ibn Malik (may Allah be pleased with him), he said: “It reached Safiyyah that Hafsah said, ‘[She is] the daughter of a Jew,’ so she cried. The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) entered upon her while she was crying and said, ‘What makes you cry?’ She said, ‘Hafsah said to me, ‘I am the daughter of a Jew.’ The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said, ‘You are the daughter of a prophet, your uncle is a prophet, and you are married to a prophet. What does she boast about to you?’ Then he said, ‘Fear Allah, O Hafsah.’”
Here, Safiyyah is a Jewish wife of the Prophet Muhammad, and recieved abuse and criticism from the Muslim wives antisemitically, therefore, she went to complain about that to the prophet, and instead of defending his other Muslim wives, he had encouraged Safiyyah to be proud of her Jewish lineage, proving that avoiding the Jews should be in a general sense, in other words, avoiding commitment to Judaism much like any other non-Islamic religion Islamic studies had told to avoid, but nor the Quran nor the Hadiths had obliged the Muslims to be "aggressive" or "antisemitic" at the Jews "just because they are Jewish"...
And the similar idea comes to Judaism in the concept of "Goyim", much like the Quran, the Goyim are considered against God, and the same goes with the Kuffar and the Mushrikīn "Pagans" in the Quran, but despite this, neither both religions had insisted to fight the people who follow a religion that contradicts with the other for no just reason, according to Leviticus 19:34, and Surah Al-Hujurat 49 : 13, both talks about how we should coexist with each other!
And now with the situation of Palestine and Israel, it is more of a topic that relies on Justice than Religion and Theology, both have a history, both have an identity in this land, as all the Arabs (whether they are Palestinians or not), and the Israelites are all belonging to Shem (or Sām in Arabic), giving us all the identity of semitism, therefore fighting against each other does not make anything better, and would lead to possible regrets in the future...
I wish both sides know that even tho they have their own traumas, it is immoral to eliminate the neighbors for their culture or religious identity, and now, I'd say, that from the river to the sea, there will be peace and empathy!
Salam and Shalom from an Arab Jew!
❤️🖤🤍💚🤍💙🤍💙🤍
Why didn't you mention the Jews who lived in Gaza for centuries who were all driven out and their land stolen by Arabs in 1929. You didn't bother to mention how Egypt treated Gaza before 1967. Leaving out those important contexts makes this an incomplete story.
A very informative video. Thank you.
why dont u talk about the 10s of thousands of children and women getting annihilated , are they hamas too?
The white liberal democrat knows whats best for Gaza. Let them go there and build back better.
Wow! What a powerful video
occupation is still occupation even if they "leave" the region
I’M HOOKED TO YOUR CHANAL FOREVER!!!!!! THANK YOU GOD BLESS YOU AN ALL PEOPLE OF ISRAEL!!!
I feel like Israel was constantly trying to appease cannibals until Oct.7
You'll get over it, feelings are not facts
thanks for the great info
CANT UNDERSTAND WHY THEY DONT LEAVE THE PALESTINIANS ALONE
It's them who refuse peace, surrender or even statehood.
you sound like a naive child who never opened a book
The answer is that the Palestinians don't leave Israelis alone. The age-old Palestinian hobby is constantly starting wars with a vastly superior military power ie Israel, getting smashed, then crying.
So maybe the great big thing they could try, is stop attacking Israel.
Israel is in Gaza right now because Hamas attacked Israel on Oct 7, kidnapped hundreds of hostages.
Logically, the only things Hamas needs to do is surrender unconditionally and release all hostages. They could have done it at any time in the last 10 months.
The only reason you would blame Israel for the war is if you're stupid or you're a Hamas supporter.
Great video. This is well put together and definitely lots of main points covered here. Very accurate.
Thus report didn't give history justice. It is one sided claiming that the occupier is a victim.