@@guney2998 I think that's because you were not upgrading the sign tree, I am seeing videos of witcher 2 and signs do some crazy shit, much better than they were in my playthrough
@@OcelotSF I mean... As a book fan, I was impressed by how much of the dialogue in the first Witcher felt like it came straight off the page. It was almost like I could recognize specific lines from my childhood reading. This close connection to the source material might be why the writing resonated so strongly.
@@MikeO7977 Because they often just straight up copied / paraphrased dialogues and events from the book. I like the storyline of the first Witcher game, but it's hard to deny that it's probably the least original out of all three.
That's it. Tw1 combat is the closest one to the books. Tw3, despite having the best plot, the combat felt very slow in terms of a witcher. Tw3 Geralt too is very weak against the soldiers.
Witcher 1 is something else. Potions usage, combat, bosses, nostalgia.. its something else after all these years. I gotta say i like that combat and still find myself playing it from time to time just because of that
I was so impressed that Ghost of Tsushima had those directional blood rails depending on the direction you were swinging. Now I see Witcher 1 has the same thing😂
Geralt had some underrated moves in W1, W2 combat felt the most realism-focused, despite its flaws. In W3 your sword basically becomes a steel lightsaber that neither armor nor bone nor monster hides can stop.
The Witcher 2 and 3 are great, but the depth of the alchemy and combat of the first game still seems to me to be the best in the saga. I remember using a MOD to zoom out the camera in Witcher 1 and the feeling of combat improved exponentially by being able to visually dominate the place where the fight would take place.
i really loved the fighting styles in the witcher 1 strong fast and group style really hope the bring it back in future games especially in the witcher 1 remake
I've tried the 1st game multiple times and I just don't see any redeemable parts to keep me playing. The combat, graphics and writing are all bad. I think 2 has the most style though and the coolest version of Geralt so it's definitely worth playing.
@@rtnKaran the problem for me in W2 and W3 was that it was the same cliched "souls-like" combat that basically every action TPP game has nowadays. Light attack, strong attack, dodge roll, drink potion, rinse and repeat. W1 just had something different. While it wasn't anything spectacular, it was for me the most engaging one, because you always had to pick the right style, you had to keep the combo flowing, drinking potions was something you had to do BEFORE combat and not in the middle of it. Plus, Geralt's fighting style was the closest one to the source material description I think. It was said that he was insanely fast, he was using a lot of spinning motions and that the witcher fighting style was unlike anything else. W1 captured that vibe perfectly - Geralt really moves unlike any other opponent, he utilises a lot of those "circular" movements (especially when fighting multiple opponents) and cuts so fast that some enemies get stunlocked chopped to pieces in the blink of an eye. In W2 and W3 Geralt kinda fights just like everyone else, except he occasionally uses signs and bombs.
We have the redkit. It's possible . Just no one is working on animations and the people that are, are just replacing the same animations " running / jog" with the same animations every other animations mod has. I'm trying to download the redkit to work on some idle animations and walking first. But I keep getting black screen so I have to reinstall the redkit for the 5th time.
Witcher 2 is and probably will be my favourite game ever. The story, fights, bosses, choices, characters, atmosphere, music everything is perfect. Even the graphics doesn't look outdated after so many years.
Imo the witcher 2 is the worst the witcher game, but i’m not saying that this game is shit, i finished it for 4 times and every time it was a great time 😅
Witcher 3: Getting grandmaster ursine armor, runewright it into medium class gear to take advantage of sign intenstity, runewright Whirl + Rend bonus + piercing cold mutation spam Aard and Quen on all of that. I almost never take damage, it's too OP
Man, those blood splatters on ground in Witcher 1 are really good looking, I totally forgot about those, they have received such a downgrade in Witcher 2, but extreme downgrade in Witcher 3.
The Witcher 3's combat is smooth and amazingly choreographed, but The Witcher 2's combat feels more impactful. It might be the very slight camera shake when you land a strike that just makes you see the impact
I'm playing the witcher 1 right now and so far my favorite mechanic is the style change, I wish we got a star wars game that takes some notes and implements it similarly. And also, the sex collectibles are funny.
It's cool how they took the "sword dancing" from the books in a quite literal way. No one fights like this, it's not "feasible", but Witchers are super human, so you take it for granted
I really love the combat stances you take, and how each one behaves. I was pretty miffed when I found out the following games didn't have that feature, it felt like something was missing.
Something I found funny is that with each games, Geralt's moves become more realistic, but less lore accurate, and flashy, as if he is getting less skilled
The sword combos and weight of your attacks in Witcher 2 feel so good. Witcher 3 attacks lack of combo variations and connect/continuations in animations - it just keep spinning 1-2 moves that regardless of the sword positions that it feels really janky. The whirl is pretty good tho
First game combat is about using effective stance in situation , while sometimes throw some signs, and watch the sword turns red to mash RMB. Occasionaly throw bombs and drink .It had flaws, but choreography was good and fights were enjoyable to watch and participate non the less. Also, no BS gear system, the basic sword u have given at the begining can carry you to the end even at harder difficulty. Same applyes to armour. Second game however is about not to get 2v1 situation (almost impossible), dont give enemy your back and positioning yourself to move freely and not being surrounded. And also, lots of luck with random enemy blocks and evades. While it is possible to work only on dodges, the "red engine" is rather sloppy in that regard. Unless you have dodge talent learned at least once, most of them dodges will be just showing opponent a hittable back (which they mostly hit). And dont start on random attack animation, which can ruin your positioning wery fast. For example, there is at least 4 moves that close gap between Gerald and target, sometimes he do whirlwind , which is mostly good, or he can roll in direction of target and do one poke , or he can do step ahead and do fast slash, but either way, if you fight with group of enemies (which is, again, almost always the case), and , by some unknown shinanigans the target will be in a middle of the crowd, you guessed it, Gerald will get shanked, since in this part they are no shy of attacking all at once. (sorry, i recently completend this trash of a combat game(with good storytelling tho) and had to rant about it somewhere) Third is for casuals tho.
Wild Hunt is the only one which uses the most realistic and reasonable dodge. No absurd rolling. It was partially aplied in 1, but was useless due to enemy animations. The fact that W2 had only roll dodge almost ruined combat.
Witcher 2 had the best feeling combat for me, you actually felt the impact when the sword hits. I like W3 combat more in a lot of ways but it feels like your sword just glides through the enemy with no impact
I miss how swift Geralt used to be in Witcher 1. He fought like a true witcher. Now for Witcher 2 the finishers were cherry on top. I never umderstood why CDPR decided to remove such cool finishers with some generic sword slashes.
Im playing witcher 3 rn, even without any idea about the game or lore, i fell in love with the game. Im kinda concerned if ill be able to enjoy part 1 and 2 because I've gotten used to good animation quality and i already know what's going to happen bow 💀
I wished they kept the combat stance of witcher 1 like Nioh. I started playing witcher 3 then 2 and now I'm playing 1. I thought the combat was pretty boring but it's actually fun. It's more unique than having fast and heavy attacks
Witcher 4? I cannot wait. Love the dismemberment in 3, what a game! My current play through I’m mainly going alchemy and vitality, all the abilities are viable if paired with others correctly.
The Witcher - 6 styles of main animations (3 for steel, 3 for silver), each one have 4 level progression and 1 special charging attack, that can ignite or blind enemy. And some for dagger and axes. Simple finishers. The Witcher 2 - 2 styles (light and heavy). Minor combo progression. Cool finishers. The Witcher 3 - 2 same styles, without animation progression. 2 special attack types. Simple finishers. That sucks. CDPR fucks up their unic witcher fighting styles with lore for boring mainstream system. I don't say that result is bad, it's just could be much more interesting.
The combat in Witcher 3 was supposed to be much better with a 'vital spot' system which was similar to Fallout VATS and MGS: Revengeance cutting. It's just that the game got downgraded heavily due to platform parity agreements and time limits.
As much as I love the witcher but they really need to remake the first and the second part. Seriously, I never had the chance of playing these games when they came out, but now I want to see how these 2 best made game from CDPR will look like with some of the witcher 3 gameplay material
@@N1k4_Gr1v No Remake 1 will be released after the release of Remake 4. The real premiere of The Witcher 4 is between 2026-2027 CDP will not release two games in the same year, so the real premiere of Remake is 2028 unless there are delays. 2025-2026 is not realistic or feasible.
@@ГеоргийМурзич damn yes, when you reach the high level perks of yrden it does a lot of damage and inflicts also various debuffs, it is only useless againts a boss near the end of the game that doesnt move, and in that way it doesnt trigger the effects of yrden. But against the 90% of the enemies that you encounter in the game is damn strong, I didn't expect it to be so broken XD
Witcher 1 was stupid easy once you figured the timings which were quite forgiving. Instead of fighting one vs one or one vs two, it was way more broken to let them crowd and use the group attack which inflicted more damage (due to a multiplier) with more opponents. In one combo you would have 5 bodies cut down.
The witcher 3 fight scene could have been better because there are loads of animations developed by Geralt in regard to his skills. Especially DLC Heart of Stone where Geralt can fully evolve his abilities to a next level.
WITCHER 1 gameplay is far better than sequels IMO. I've never felt borred by a succession of fights. Actually Witcher 2 and Witcher 3 are similar to a rolling simulator like FromSoftSHITware gameplay. In a way, it decreased a big part of the fun I expected to get when playing the sequel. I recently played Witcher 1 : the gameplay is still pleasant.
Witcher's 1 combat isn't bad in my opinion, it's just very interesting, i don't think any game before had an idea like this. Also, applaus to CDproject, usually as time flies and game get more releases something always get worse even if the whole is better. In witcher's case the combat system is genuily better with every release of the game, perfect example of learning and adapting.
@@GriffinTracker i don't know about 3 but def better than 2's generic ass. They literally created the book atmosphere faithfully and destroyed it in 2. Combat is a roll+click spam made obviously for console gamers, and hitboxes are broken. Alchemy sucks. Preparation is awful. Only good thing is story.
По-моему нам показали не всю боевую систему из первого ведьмака. Там вроде можно переключать лёгкие и тяжёлые удары, и при этом ведьмак меняет стойки. Ну а в третьем ведьмаке, просто доведённая до ума боёвка из второго.
Но всё таки по разнообразию ударов, смены стоек, я отдам предпочтение первому ведьмаку. А за зрелищность добиваний и отличной системе знаков третьему. Но за сюжет, локации и огромное разнообразие квестов, однозначно третий ведьмак.
The sword fighting style is the best in the first part of The Witcher. Just look at these movements of Geralt, you can immediately see that this is a unique witcher fighting style that is only subject to witcher reflexes and an ordinary person simply cannot perform all these movements. It's a shame that in the next games he already fights just like human.
First 10 hours of W1 was torture but after that it was a 25 hours of dream of witcher fan. Unfortunately after finishing game i couldn't play anything else two weeks
The reason Witchers do not fight like ordinary swordmen is because their reflexes and speed gives them the ability to use techniques normal humans cant do. This gives them the possibility to fight multiple people at once and do stuff that makes normal humans confused and bewildered. Witcher 1 does it right.
Witcher 3 would’ve been a lot better if you had more combat upgrades. When it comes to large crowds like that, I usually use whirl and if I have someone low on health at a distance, I use rend to split them in half.
The combat in Witcher 2 and Witcher 3 is more responsive and interactive. In The Witcher 1, it looks like you're just attacking as much as possible with little regard for the enemy attacks. In fact, those clips of The Witcher 1 remind me of Fallout 3 where two guys are standing out in the open and shooting each other until one of them dies.
Is it okay to use a dismemberment mod in witcher 3? :P Just asking cuz i am using one and I hope it does not interfere with some upcomings which I am not sure of yet?
Witcher 1 has the most spectacular combo styles. choosing the style for combos is promising. Witcher 2 has a better storyline, character abilities, potion making etc.
![Which Witcher School Are You? [The Lore Of Every Witcher School]](/img/1.gif)
In Witcher 1 combat is spamming Aard
In Witcher 2 combat is spamming rolls and Igni
In Witcher 3 combat is taking Quen and spamming Whirl
Spammed igni in the first one and aard in the second one😎
I barely used Quen in Witcher 3, mostly Igni in the first part and then freezing Aard later on
In W2 everything except quen was shit
@@guney2998 wtf you even talking about? ofc Quen is amazing sign but i think you don't even know how to correctly use other signs
@@guney2998 I think that's because you were not upgrading the sign tree, I am seeing videos of witcher 2 and signs do some crazy shit, much better than they were in my playthrough
The combat in The Witcher I is very accurate in terms of how Geralt would move and fight based on the book descriptions
Yeah ! the dodges especially were great in the 1st game.
because devs of 1st one were a closed circle group and fans of witcher books
@@OcelotSF I mean... As a book fan, I was impressed by how much of the dialogue in the first Witcher felt like it came straight off the page. It was almost like I could recognize specific lines from my childhood reading. This close connection to the source material might be why the writing resonated so strongly.
@@MikeO7977 Because they often just straight up copied / paraphrased dialogues and events from the book. I like the storyline of the first Witcher game, but it's hard to deny that it's probably the least original out of all three.
That's it. Tw1 combat is the closest one to the books. Tw3, despite having the best plot, the combat felt very slow in terms of a witcher. Tw3 Geralt too is very weak against the soldiers.
Witcher 1 first hours are like "wtf is this bullshit combat, what a shit game"
and then next hours are like "This is so great, Im addicted wow"
Haha , Exactly !!
it's the best out of the trilogy
Same opinion😅
I loved witcher 1. I enjoyed the combat system! The group style would massacre multiple opponents!
Unfortunately, my opinion didn't change throughout my playthrough...
Geralt from witcher 1 fights like a power ranger 😂😂😂
Also, in the witcher 3 footage you could have parried and used more signs!
Man said Power Ranger LMAOOOOO 😭😭😭😭
Holy shit this is spot on! 😂
Dont forget the INFINITY WHIRL!!!
"also", same for 1 and 2...
He actually fights like he supposed to. Pretty accurate to the book. And it was really fun in the game too.
Witcher 2 finishers are insane. I don't understand why CDPR didn't use these for The Witcher 3. Let's hope they will in the next game.
It takes freedom
Yeah ! Fingers crossed :)
Money
They were terrible and fucked your position and combat pace
Because they're TRASH. I want to play the game not watch a cutscene every time I kill someone
Witcher 1 is something else. Potions usage, combat, bosses, nostalgia.. its something else after all these years. I gotta say i like that combat and still find myself playing it from time to time just because of that
I was so impressed that Ghost of Tsushima had those directional blood rails depending on the direction you were swinging. Now I see Witcher 1 has the same thing😂
In The Witcher 1, the fight actually looks like you were fighting as a Witcher
its very impressive that even witcher 1 is not that bad to todays standards
Yeah , once you get used to the combat its fun !!
Also Subscribe for more comparison videos like this !!
@@rtnKaran i felt combat is the best part of it its hard to get but once you get it its rewarding
Yeah ! my thoughts exactly :)
By today's standards the combat is horrible...
Geralt had some underrated moves in W1, W2 combat felt the most realism-focused, despite its flaws.
In W3 your sword basically becomes a steel lightsaber that neither armor nor bone nor monster hides can stop.
Yeah ! I liked the different sword styles you could use in the 1st game. Felt very rewarding when used correctly.
*silver
From the perspective of the book lore, Geralt has enough power to chop armoured knights in a half.
The Witcher 2 and 3 are great, but the depth of the alchemy and combat of the first game still seems to me to be the best in the saga.
I remember using a MOD to zoom out the camera in Witcher 1 and the feeling of combat improved exponentially by being able to visually dominate the place where the fight would take place.
You could also experiment with different alchemy substances even if you didn't have the recipes .
@@rtnKaran Да, и рецепт "Слезы жен" очень поможет с начала игры, так как пить приходиться много)
I cant wait for the W1 remake.
Yeah ! me too.
Amen brother!
UE5 stuttermess with todays gaming politics involved.
CDPR is woke now. It means bad writing, messages, ugly women and other stupid "progressive" shit.
I want a TW1 with TW3 engine
I never saw Geralt wielding 2 swords at once in witcher 2. So badass
Yeah ! there were some great finishers in 2
в 1 части тоже есть спецприем, где он использует два меча
i really loved the fighting styles in the witcher 1 strong fast and group style really hope the bring it back in future games especially in the witcher 1 remake
I hope they remake it because atmosphere is dark and i love it
Witcher 1 - fighting mutants
Witcher 2 - fighting knights
Witcher 3 - fighting normal folks without armor
I can really appreciate the realism in 1, as in the realism of enemies not taking turns with you. They just go for it
Witcher 1 underrated game and I wish more people would play 1 and 2 before playing 3. Each game is a masterpiece in its own right
I've tried the 1st game multiple times and I just don't see any redeemable parts to keep me playing. The combat, graphics and writing are all bad. I think 2 has the most style though and the coolest version of Geralt so it's definitely worth playing.
I loved Witcher 1 in general, combat included. To me it was the best Witcher game.
Yeah ! Switching between fighting styles felt good . I miss that in other Witcher games.
@@rtnKaran the problem for me in W2 and W3 was that it was the same cliched "souls-like" combat that basically every action TPP game has nowadays. Light attack, strong attack, dodge roll, drink potion, rinse and repeat.
W1 just had something different. While it wasn't anything spectacular, it was for me the most engaging one, because you always had to pick the right style, you had to keep the combo flowing, drinking potions was something you had to do BEFORE combat and not in the middle of it. Plus, Geralt's fighting style was the closest one to the source material description I think. It was said that he was insanely fast, he was using a lot of spinning motions and that the witcher fighting style was unlike anything else. W1 captured that vibe perfectly - Geralt really moves unlike any other opponent, he utilises a lot of those "circular" movements (especially when fighting multiple opponents) and cuts so fast that some enemies get stunlocked chopped to pieces in the blink of an eye.
In W2 and W3 Geralt kinda fights just like everyone else, except he occasionally uses signs and bombs.
Lmao
LOL
The only witcher game this dude has played lmao
that dual sword kill at 2:00 is so cool. i wish they had something like that in the witcher 3.
Maximus did the same in Gladiator. Dope stuff
We have the redkit. It's possible . Just no one is working on animations and the people that are, are just replacing the same animations " running / jog" with the same animations every other animations mod has. I'm trying to download the redkit to work on some idle animations and walking first. But I keep getting black screen so I have to reinstall the redkit for the 5th time.
Witcher 1 is soo fun bro. i loved it more than W2
Witcher 2 is and probably will be my favourite game ever. The story, fights, bosses, choices, characters, atmosphere, music everything is perfect. Even the graphics doesn't look outdated after so many years.
Imo the witcher 2 is the worst the witcher game, but i’m not saying that this game is shit, i finished it for 4 times and every time it was a great time 😅
Congratulations. What you like best is a genetic style without character!
@@gnitzPR Witcher 2 story is way more RPG and non linear than witcher 3 which makes it better
i remember the first time i fight letho, fuking hell so hard
Witcher 3: Getting grandmaster ursine armor, runewright it into medium class gear to take advantage of sign intenstity, runewright Whirl + Rend bonus + piercing cold mutation spam Aard and Quen on all of that. I almost never take damage, it's too OP
Thanks !! I'll try that .
Man, those blood splatters on ground in Witcher 1 are really good looking, I totally forgot about those, they have received such a downgrade in Witcher 2, but extreme downgrade in Witcher 3.
The Witcher 3's combat is smooth and amazingly choreographed, but The Witcher 2's combat feels more impactful. It might be the very slight camera shake when you land a strike that just makes you see the impact
I hope they'll bring back stances combat in tw4, and use different moveset for silver and steel sword like tw1
I'm playing the witcher 1 right now and so far my favorite mechanic is the style change, I wish we got a star wars game that takes some notes and implements it similarly. And also, the sex collectibles are funny.
I just want to thank you for the video and say that you are an incredible and kind guy, very polite and nice here in the comments too, keep it up bro!
It's cool how they took the "sword dancing" from the books in a quite literal way. No one fights like this, it's not "feasible", but Witchers are super human, so you take it for granted
Witcher 1 combat is the best of the 3 once you get the hang of it
I really love the combat stances you take, and how each one behaves. I was pretty miffed when I found out the following games didn't have that feature, it felt like something was missing.
Something I found funny is that with each games, Geralt's moves become more realistic, but less lore accurate, and flashy, as if he is getting less skilled
The sword combos and weight of your attacks in Witcher 2 feel so good. Witcher 3 attacks lack of combo variations and connect/continuations in animations - it just keep spinning 1-2 moves that regardless of the sword positions that it feels really janky. The whirl is pretty good tho
Hes waving his sword like a wizard spamming his spells with a wand
gave me so much nostalgia for witcher 1. great game
Lmao what was that "auuaauugh" at 1:27
Battle noises , i guess ;)
Blood and oil stained sword on back in witcher 1 were pretty cool.
Yess !
First game combat is about using effective stance in situation , while sometimes throw some signs, and watch the sword turns red to mash RMB. Occasionaly throw bombs and drink .It had flaws, but choreography was good and fights were enjoyable to watch and participate non the less. Also, no BS gear system, the basic sword u have given at the begining can carry you to the end even at harder difficulty. Same applyes to armour.
Second game however is about not to get 2v1 situation (almost impossible), dont give enemy your back and positioning yourself to move freely and not being surrounded. And also, lots of luck with random enemy blocks and evades. While it is possible to work only on dodges, the "red engine" is rather sloppy in that regard. Unless you have dodge talent learned at least once, most of them dodges will be just showing opponent a hittable back (which they mostly hit). And dont start on random attack animation, which can ruin your positioning wery fast. For example, there is at least 4 moves that close gap between Gerald and target, sometimes he do whirlwind , which is mostly good, or he can roll in direction of target and do one poke , or he can do step ahead and do fast slash, but either way, if you fight with group of enemies (which is, again, almost always the case), and , by some unknown shinanigans the target will be in a middle of the crowd, you guessed it, Gerald will get shanked, since in this part they are no shy of attacking all at once. (sorry, i recently completend this trash of a combat game(with good storytelling tho) and had to rant about it somewhere)
Third is for casuals tho.
Wild Hunt is the only one which uses the most realistic and reasonable dodge. No absurd rolling. It was partially aplied in 1, but was useless due to enemy animations. The fact that W2 had only roll dodge almost ruined combat.
But you can roll from entemy attacks in tw3
I love how everybody has different witcher favourite game, thats the sign that every game is special ❤🔥
Witcher 2 had the best feeling combat for me, you actually felt the impact when the sword hits. I like W3 combat more in a lot of ways but it feels like your sword just glides through the enemy with no impact
The difference between witcher 2 and 3 is actually insane
yea 2 is better
@@ayoubmorjane7722 Story wise, fuck the witcher 2 combat
@@ayoubmorjane7722 are you smoking meth?
@@gyrozeppeli7296Nah no Yennefer, Ciri, Shani = worse game than the Witcher 3
Yeah !
I love that each game completely revamps the combat entirely. Each game feels unique 👍
witcher 1 combat is my trauma and i dont even remember what happened back in the day. So i have never played the first game lmao i need to start now
I lot of people give witcher 1 and 2 shit for their combat but they are actually fun if you bother learning the systems.
I miss how swift Geralt used to be in Witcher 1. He fought like a true witcher. Now for Witcher 2 the finishers were cherry on top. I never umderstood why CDPR decided to remove such cool finishers with some generic sword slashes.
Im playing witcher 3 rn, even without any idea about the game or lore, i fell in love with the game. Im kinda concerned if ill be able to enjoy part 1 and 2 because I've gotten used to good animation quality and i already know what's going to happen bow 💀
witcher 3 combat with igni sign combo always feels complete to me
Witcher 2 the best🎉🎉🎉
Absolutely not wtf, some of the worst combat ever
3 is better in every aspect
@@stormfall1130 exept for the plot, but otherwise yes
@@thebananaman5632Absolutely not wtf, some of the BEST combat.
@@L0STV1K1NG96 You are factually incorrect
I replaying Witcher 3 in 2024, it’s still amazing
Witcher 2 I sunk hours into that absolutely loved it
Witcher 1 combat was beautiful, 2 kinda meh and 3 just feels well polished and good.
I miss the crazy finishers of Witcher 2, would be great have these in W3
I wished they kept the combat stance of witcher 1 like Nioh. I started playing witcher 3 then 2 and now I'm playing 1. I thought the combat was pretty boring but it's actually fun. It's more unique than having fast and heavy attacks
Witcher 4? I cannot wait. Love the dismemberment in 3, what a game! My current play through I’m mainly going alchemy and vitality, all the abilities are viable if paired with others correctly.
The Witcher - 6 styles of main animations (3 for steel, 3 for silver), each one have 4 level progression and 1 special charging attack, that can ignite or blind enemy. And some for dagger and axes. Simple finishers.
The Witcher 2 - 2 styles (light and heavy). Minor combo progression. Cool finishers.
The Witcher 3 - 2 same styles, without animation progression. 2 special attack types. Simple finishers.
That sucks. CDPR fucks up their unic witcher fighting styles with lore for boring mainstream system. I don't say that result is bad, it's just could be much more interesting.
Exactly
The combat in Witcher 3 was supposed to be much better with a 'vital spot' system which was similar to Fallout VATS and MGS: Revengeance cutting. It's just that the game got downgraded heavily due to platform parity agreements and time limits.
let's not preteend witcher 1's combat or 2's qte combat were good man. even tw3 combat sucks
As much as I love the witcher but they really need to remake the first and the second part. Seriously, I never had the chance of playing these games when they came out, but now I want to see how these 2 best made game from CDPR will look like with some of the witcher 3 gameplay material
The only thing I want to see changed is only the combat mechanics
They're already making the Witcher 1 remake , hopefully they'll remake Witcher 2 , too !
@@rtnKaran they probably release it next year
@@N1k4_Gr1v
No Remake 1 will be released after the release of Remake 4.
The real premiere of The Witcher 4 is between 2026-2027
CDP will not release two games in the same year, so the real premiere of Remake is 2028 unless there are delays.
2025-2026 is not realistic or feasible.
@@marcinek8367 That's quite a far assumption
Witcher 1 fight like behind the scene of movie fight 😅😅
I love the witcher 1 gameplay, plus I've maxed Yrden and it is nuts
Interesting. Does it become useful, does it start to damage decently or what?
@@ГеоргийМурзич damn yes, when you reach the high level perks of yrden it does a lot of damage and inflicts also various debuffs, it is only useless againts a boss near the end of the game that doesnt move, and in that way it doesnt trigger the effects of yrden. But against the 90% of the enemies that you encounter in the game is damn strong, I didn't expect it to be so broken XD
Damn I wanted to write you here all the perks that you can unlock on Yrden but I can't find anything online, I should re-install the game :-P
Witcher 1: twirl attack
Witcher 2: tactical attack
Witcher 3: ballerina show
Haha !
I liked the combat style in The Witcher 1 the most.
in the witcher 1 they are all doing capoeira
Witcher 2 killing cinematic where lit 🔥
Fell inlove to this game i dont even know what was i doing and the story's progress shit getting good
Witcher 1 was stupid easy once you figured the timings which were quite forgiving. Instead of fighting one vs one or one vs two, it was way more broken to let them crowd and use the group attack which inflicted more damage (due to a multiplier) with more opponents. In one combo you would have 5 bodies cut down.
The blood trail effect in Witcher 1 is great, they shouldn’t have removed it
You can get blood trails mod for Witcher 3 from the steam workshop :)
@@rtnKaran that’s badass unfortunately I am on PlayStation. I will live vicariously through my steam brethren
Waiting for Witcher 4
Every game have its own vibe
🔥
The witcher 3 fight scene could have been better because there are loads of animations developed by Geralt in regard to his skills. Especially DLC Heart of Stone where Geralt can fully evolve his abilities to a next level.
WITCHER 1 gameplay is far better than sequels IMO. I've never felt borred by a succession of fights. Actually Witcher 2 and Witcher 3 are similar to a rolling simulator like FromSoftSHITware gameplay.
In a way, it decreased a big part of the fun I expected to get when playing the sequel.
I recently played Witcher 1 : the gameplay is still pleasant.
Fromsoftware shit? Leave drugs m8 you aré just talking nosense
I loved Witcher 1 combat.
👍
Witcher's 1 combat isn't bad in my opinion, it's just very interesting, i don't think any game before had an idea like this.
Also, applaus to CDproject, usually as time flies and game get more releases something always get worse even if the whole is better. In witcher's case the combat system is genuily better with every release of the game, perfect example of learning and adapting.
In my opinion w1 is the best 'witcher' game
Guess you never played the other 2
@@GriffinTracker i don't know about 3 but def better than 2's generic ass. They literally created the book atmosphere faithfully and destroyed it in 2. Combat is a roll+click spam made obviously for console gamers, and hitboxes are broken. Alchemy sucks. Preparation is awful. Only good thing is story.
@@GriffinTracker 300 hrs in W2 and 700 hrs in w3
Naaa 3 is good. 1 was good for its time. Never liked 2.
@@alexgalays910 okay. As I said earlier 'in my opinion '
По-моему нам показали не всю боевую систему из первого ведьмака. Там вроде можно переключать лёгкие и тяжёлые удары, и при этом ведьмак меняет стойки. Ну а в третьем ведьмаке, просто доведённая до ума боёвка из второго.
Но всё таки по разнообразию ударов, смены стоек, я отдам предпочтение первому ведьмаку. А за зрелищность добиваний и отличной системе знаков третьему.
Но за сюжет, локации и огромное разнообразие квестов, однозначно третий ведьмак.
I can't effin wait till they re make Witcher 1.
Me too !
The sword fighting style is the best in the first part of The Witcher. Just look at these movements of Geralt, you can immediately see that this is a unique witcher fighting style that is only subject to witcher reflexes and an ordinary person simply cannot perform all these movements. It's a shame that in the next games he already fights just like human.
played W3 for around 70h now, not even 40% finished but i now want to play W1 and im looking to save some money for W2!
First 10 hours of W1 was torture but after that it was a 25 hours of dream of witcher fan. Unfortunately after finishing game i couldn't play anything else two weeks
Lmao
The reason Witchers do not fight like ordinary swordmen is because their reflexes and speed gives them the ability to use techniques normal humans cant do. This gives them the possibility to fight multiple people at once and do stuff that makes normal humans confused and bewildered. Witcher 1 does it right.
weird how shaky camera witcher 2 has compared to first one, is the combat better in witcher1?
I guess it's because this specific gameplay was recorded on PC using mouse instead of a controller
Witcher 3 would’ve been a lot better if you had more combat upgrades. When it comes to large crowds like that, I usually use whirl and if I have someone low on health at a distance, I use rend to split them in half.
witcher 3 decapitation execution just...perfection!
Yess !
Aard Sweep with all the sign intensity and piercing cold is basically unstoppable
Yeah !
I didnt know there was a witcher 1 and 2.
w1 the best animation in his premier times
generally each witcher has very good fight's animation
Yess !!
for me the atmposphere of witcher 2 is the best, flotsam forest is sick
all i can tell is you shake your mouse too much it gives me motion sickness
Ведьмак 3 это реально танец с мечом. Лучшая боевка по сей день для меня.
The combat in Witcher 2 and Witcher 3 is more responsive and interactive. In The Witcher 1, it looks like you're just attacking as much as possible with little regard for the enemy attacks.
In fact, those clips of The Witcher 1 remind me of Fallout 3 where two guys are standing out in the open and shooting each other until one of them dies.
не знал что Гервант в первой части знает приёмы из ушу
Hey man, what PC specs do you have?
Cpu - amd 2600
Gpu - Rtx 2060
No parry, no whirlwind?
Witcher 1 combat is pretty fun and addictive, easily the best combat system in the whole franchise.
Is it okay to use a dismemberment mod in witcher 3? :P Just asking cuz i am using one and I hope it does not interfere with some upcomings which I am not sure of yet?
do W3 even need a dismemberment mod?
The witcher 2 actually looks pretty fire
Now we wait for witcher 4
the dancing 1,2 and 3
Against the mutants you must use STEEL!
The combat is the only thing that has always put me off from finally trying witcher 3.
There were finishers in witcher 1??????
Early witcher 2 combat Act 1 and hirst half of act 2 is the best in the franchise as it is the hardest.
Witcher 1 has the most spectacular combo styles. choosing the style for combos is promising.
Witcher 2 has a better storyline, character abilities, potion making etc.
I really wanna play Witcher 1 if I ever get a pc