Which Had the Superior Military: First or Second World War Germany?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 окт 2017
- This is unadorned/unfinished audio of a Dan Carlin discussion about which German military was superior, the First or the Second World War version. Unlike the approach in traditional Hardcore History releases, brevity wins out over depth in this attempt at short-form content from a traditionally long-form creator (note that it is still 50 minutes!)
www.dancarlin.com/dc-donate/
/ dancarlin
If Dan were a teacher, he'd be the kind of person to have students ditch other classes to attend his.
M Jin I would without a doubt
that's cause students don't like rigorous academic material. like learning math without proof
lack of absolute proof makes a light academic class not!
I totally would skip everything to attend Dan's classes.
he'd also be the kind to actually have you read all those damned books he makes you buy and also wouldn't make you buy his own books... since they're audio books and you can get them free online.
Dan, you got to name this format softcore history...
Bahahahahaha perfect!
I spat out my drink.
someone on the Dan Carlin Subreddit mentioned calling this type of podcast Softcore History as well.
YES
Ingimar Sverrisson Can we start a hashtag trend for this?
Give.
This.
Man.
Money.
Gives this mans a show netflix
@@christx2580 it would be ruined because they would recreate it to be unrealistic. Half the armies would be women in wheelchairs and Hitler would be transgender haha
@@MaeMaeTube what a moronic comment
Anthony Drake he’s right you stupid fuck, been living under a rock lately?
Done.
This is the nicest comment section on RUclips. I love it.
AlbertJustice your mom
:P
Give it time haha
There we go, that's better.
Idk, I think Jordan Peterson may have Dan beat. :D
EDIT: Didn't expand replies when I wrote my comment. Sort yourself out.
shhh
At about 2:20 the term Dan is looking for is "Diesel Punk".
Keep it coming, Dan.
Dan is a bad man.. pls wake up.
How do you mean, Generation X?
So true!
Is this a 2017 release? A recent upload of a vintage episode? Regardless i am rubbing my hands w anticipation...
@Jacob Gold He's doing a new, more off-the-cuff style of HH, and this is the pilot! Just released.
You're the best, Dan. Please don't ever give up on your series
Bento Box
Bento Box
Bento Box
Bento Box
Over my college career, I've gone from not really caring for history to taking an extra minor in it just for fun, all thanks to great teachers and speakers on history, not the least of which is Dan. Thanks for helping to spark my interest in such fascinating topics!
Also, at 2:20, I believe the term after steampunk that you're looking for is film serial, a la Indiana Jones
Q
@@GatsbyCioffi kjkn iikikko kbooik might. L mm .mkmokko mmmkojk kooo.ookk
Best voice in podcasts
hi bye seriously he's the best
Got the right amounts of heart, drama, and grit. I listen to him before bed a lot!
>short form content
>video is almost an hour long
Thats Dan for you... May he never change!
Full lenght edition: 20+ hrs
Blitz edition: 5-6 hrs
Relative to that, this really is quite short.
They'll be up to 5 hours within 10 episodes
If that means we'll be getting them more than twice a year, I'm entirely fine with that.
Besides, we all rewatch them a dozen times anyway.
I give it two episode
1st. Dan is the man. Going back to school to earn a history degree because of Dan.
Joshua that’s awesome. Good for you dude. I’m a history teacher. Go for it !
Thanks man! That’s what I want to do! I want to teach children history, so they won’t repeat it!
I'm in school right now getting a history degree. I want to be a professor because of Dan
Joshua yes yes yes!!! Bravo brother. Open kids eyes. It’s an amazing thing!
Lethal FPS awesome. Good for you. 👍
Please make more of these Dan, your opinions and arguments are always fascinating
Awsome man i love this. Your normal stuff is amazing too. Keep it up. The more material the beter
Your work is absolutely fascinating.
Waiting for Dan Carlin's COLD WAR
Cam Rackam it already exists 'destroyer of worlds'
olha2 Destroyer of Worlds is hardly the whole cold war
check out his episode called Meandering Through The Cold War
meandering through the cold war is just a summary of general effects and origins of the cold war
Cam Rackam "The destroyer of worlds" it's so fucking good I listen to it all the time it scares me to tears
Dan not only helped me realize my passion for history, but for learning in general. What a gift! Thank you, Dan.
Dan, I have been watching RUclips for years. I have never felt compelled to comment on a video. I do now for the first time. This "short form" format is a perfect stop gap solution for the all too long, but understood gap between HH episodes. Please keep these coming, and thank you for the incredibly hard work that goes into all of the content you put out.
This is absolutely amazing work, more of this Dan please! As long as it does not interfere with your work on the long form regular Hardcore History and doesn't burn you out!
It's like Christmas morning every time a new Dan Carlin video/podcast is released. Love the new idea to get more content out. Thanks!
I love the military-boxer comparison. Great stuff!
I see a hardcore history update, I don't care what it is, I jump right on that
when was that?
To paraphrase Capt. Kirk, 'We trust your opinions more than we trust most peoples facts'
^^ this!
I've had a few runs of bad luck here in the last month with my vehicle that has cost me quite a bit, but I will be sending you a small donation here very soon for all of your work. I thank and appreciate you for taking the time and effort to make these "shows" for people like me. I'm still catching up and your projects, but you have literally changed my view of the entire world. Thank you
Dan, I loved it. This is a fantastic idea for a supplemental show. I would love to listen to one of these a month, either in your main hardcore show or a new podcast. This was fantastic and I'm amazed how even in short form you can be so though provoking. Excellent work, hope to see more.
THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!!! This is great idea you have to get more content out. Having a new piece of Dan Carlin in my life on a closer-to-monthly basis is a life improving thing if there ever was one..
Great work Dan !
Also, whoever does the art work for each Hardcore History on your website is one super talented dude/gal.
Listening to you explore this topic was a gem. I hope this idea of "short" podcasts sticks. We'd love to hear from ya more often.
Blueprint for Armageddon and Ghosts of the Ostfront taught me more about the World Wars than 2 semesters worth of classes in college. Overall, Hardcore History is more effective at teaching history than my classes for my BA History degree. I'm going to ask Santa to give me all of the episodes for Christmas
Dan is a modern day story-teller, and I do not mean that in the sense of anything bad or derogatory. When he talks about history his 'format' is one would more expect from someone who was really good at telling stories to a large audience. Imagine if Dan were telling stories around a campfire about Beowulf or Gilgamesh. That's what he does when he talks about history and I love it.
Personally the story of the Gutenberg Bible was the one that looked me down my path of understanding the world. The hardcore history about munster Germany, which was that?
Daniel
Prophets of Doom is the episode i believe.
Dan Carlin would be the first one to call you out on that nonsense. You can't beat experts in the field. It is something that ALL AMERICANS just cannot wrap their heads around for some reason. I had Egyptian History course taught by a guy who knew Arabic, Greek, Latin, Hieroglyphs, German and English. And who had personally been to Egypt like 20 times. Dan would certainly have something interesting to say about Egypt in general I am sure. He isn't teaching me better through Audio only what nonsense.
@@ExecutiveChefLanceyeah how many professors have expertise on that level though? For all we know dude went to a some community college in bumfuck, Nebraska. There are absolutely droves of professors completely devoid of passion, expertise, or the ability to teach. Your experience is not universal.
Such an amazing man to listen to. Thanks so much for this amazing series, Dan. Please keep it coming!
Dan, I love this idea and hope you keep it up. Thank you for the effort and time you put into your work.
I have been waiting for this throw away line to be elaborated on for so long. Thank you so much Dan
Amazing stuff as usual, Dan! I can only think of one downside to these shorter episodes...
And that's that they leave me desperately wanting more!
I discovered your content recently and I haven't been able to stop watching! Love your content Dan!
I really like this format, especially the deep-dive into an aspect of a theme or concept touched upon in some of the podcast series.
*FINALLY* Dan discovers RUclips. (Quick, Ben, while he's dipping his toe in the water, push him in!!!)
Me2 lol if there is a " Ben"
Get in there!!
Thanks Dan. You are the reason I am captivated by history as a hobby!
well thats sad . lol History is the greatest subject , it allows us to look back at our faults & right them & the story telling is simply amazing ... History = Hot Sweaty Sex
Anything that results in more new occurrences of Dan speaking into my ears per month is something I support. Wonderful episode, Dan. Keep it up!
Much appreciated Dan. Look forward to more of these.
Love your work in ANY form, and the idea of having more than 2 shows a year is very enticing. I like the idea of these "short ones" sprinkled between the larger works.
Amazing job! Thanks for the upload
This is great! I've been listening to HH for close to ten years, and I really enjoyed this one hour one-off.
From what I've seen, I enjoy whatever I get from you and the team.
Any content is great content.
If doing this scratches an itch right now, then I'll gladly receive the benefit.
I appreciate this so much! Thank you for this content!
Love this! Anything to keep us going in between Hardcore Histories!
Hey Dan! Big fan. Love this new quick format. Keep em comin
Discovered you and your wirk a bit late, but I LOVE what you do mate, particularly this type of podcast. Thoroughly agree, by the way, but having someone like yourself really articulate it for me is a real gift, so thanks for your work! 😃
I look forward to your history shows more than anything else on the radio or even tv or the movies. Thank you from Canada!
i love dan carlin's perspective it takes in so much scope from all sides to form a narrative, its truly art
Wonderful program, thank you!
Hello Dan, Håvard from Norway here. I loved this "teaser", please make a full lenght episode if you can. But most important; keep the hardcore history coming, reguardless of what the topic is. I love youre show!!!
Always enjoy your work. Listen to each one 5-20 times
Definitely keep this series going, Dan! This is great!
Thanks for the series so far absolutely amazing
I could listen to you ramble about anything history related. You always have interesting topics and tangents. Great voice too.
Love it Dan. I think this is something hat you can flow off of in a short form and we love those moments in the podcast! Well done. Fanboy moment over, as you were ;)
Very much enjoyed this expansion on the point made in Blueprint for Armageddon that I also picked up on first time I listened to that series. The format reminds me of the early HH episodes in that it is a shorter take on a single question or comparison, and I would love to see these become a regular thing to fill the gap between the full-length 'deep dive' episodes.
If this becomes a new podcats, it might become my favourite one! I’ve always loved your Blitz episodes, and your musings on history.
You asking fun questions like-Were previous gens tougher, did Caesar start a genocide, was Alexander just like Hitler, WWI vs WWII German military-Is why I love Hardcore History so much!
These questions are fun to theorise, and debate about, and stay with you the most. I’m very excited!
Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU Dan. Love this format as an add-on to the long-form shows. There's NO one doing it as well as you do.
Great work Dan .. looking forward to hearing more
Excellent!
Happy for the new content.
Just yesterday I listened to Episode 1 and 2. Thought I'd make it through all the classic Hardcore History before a new one came out.
Happy to be proven wrong!
Happy to be proven wrong!
These podcasts are ridiculously and consistently great
Excellent love this format in between full episodes! I am a huge Great War buff this along with your amazing “Blueprint to Armageddon” has capture my attention. Most 20th century history enthusiasts focus on WW2 so being able to listen to additional content on the First World War is music to my ears, I read and watch anything I can get my hands on regarding The Great War, and compared to WW2 there is far less out there, so I very much appreciate this. Keep up the amazing work!!
Hey David what resources would you recommend to get a good general overview of WWI? Thanks!
@@RoryAbcoe “The First World War” by Martin Gilbert is great. Also listen to Dan Carlin’s Blueprint to Armageddon. It’s a great series
I miss these. Thanks for putting this up Dan!
Awesome, Dan. So happy when i saw this in my feed
Keep it coming man...been listening for a decade and it just keeps getting better
Greaaaaat!! I hope you make more like this!
Awesome conversation and points!
Very cool. Keep it coming!
You got me into this stuff, man. love the podcast
This is great, keep the short form stuff coming.
Thanks for all the great content!
I really like the content my friend. Keep pushing.
I have listened to Blueprint at least 6 times and this is good stuff. PLEASE DO MORE!
Love the format. Keep it up!
Dan I love this concept
Thank you Dan, you are easily one of my top five favorite story tellers, and if the question of whom has the greatest speaking voice comes up Dan Carlin is an answer I would accept. This reminds me of your first episode by the way, Alexander vs Hitler a personal favorite of mine.
Man, getting in on a Dan Carlin video before 300 views??? I feel so special
John Holden you are a certain kind of special.:p
I bet he last time you were so early the Kaiser was still a thing.
Thanks for letting us hear this, Dan! Huge fan.
We need more, more, more of your work please.
Great listen Dan - thanks for the effort!
This was (of course) again a great story Dan, love any content you create. So, shorter+more frequent equals awesome.
If you can insert this in your regular podcast feed it would be appreciated. My car is not really okay with RUclips playing 😉.
Understand completely if you cannot do this though for the reasons mentioned.
Great stuff Dan. Keep em coming
Absolutely amazing! I love this channel so much!
I love when people say dan doesn’t have proofs for many of his episodes. He literally reminds you he’s not a historian like every hour. Oh, and every single citied book is available to buy on amazon from his website. Lazy people kill me man.
We would be more than happy to pay more for more content dan. I don't think I've ever used the word more 3 times in one sentence but you get the point.
Hey Dan, adore all your work! Just wanted to let you know, the genre/theme for the "mid 20th century steam punk" you were referring to is known as Diesel Punk.
Dan, please make more of these!
Dan you could do a “light notes” version of the show; easy on you, easy to find content & it could answer some FAQs. You the man!
Please Dan do more of these. We love your content
Dan, if you were to publish one of these a month, I would personally love it. I would also be impressed if you were able to pull it off! The amount of effort you put into these shows is the reason we are interested.
This stuffed me up. No podcast, just found this randomly. I’m shocked I could have missed it
Absolutely can't wait to listen to it on the drive to work tomorrow. Been waiting patiently for a new Common Sense as well. I like hearing your perspective on the madness of our current political situation. Every week something new happens and I wonder "Is this what Dan's gonna talk about next episode?"
Glad to see you on RUclips!!!
Dan Carlin I love you man. The topics you cover and how you cover them is incomparable.
Interesting Dan, love it! Keep it up!
Dan. KEEP IT UP. Whatever the format. I love your shows! Thank you.
Yes, please keep doing these shorter ones between complete episodes, it's a great idea!
You do any type of content you want I've never been disappointed or uninterested
Amazing Dan. Thanks so much!
Loved it. More little shows to fill the time and catch up is a great idea