World War II - Part 1 (WWI)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 16 ноя 2023
- Dr. Roy Casagranda sets up the background to WWI and explains some of the moving parts of the brutal conflict. In parts 1 and 2, the question he's tying to answer is, "Why did WWII happen?"
I'm glad this professor wasn't at my university when I was studying; otherwise, I might have become a historian instead of an engineer. I love your lectures and appreciate the excellent work you do. Please keep it up!
What would be wrong with being a historian rather than an engineer? As an engineer, youre actually physically limited as to what youre able to produce on a mass scale, youre not “allowed” to change the system in a beneficial way, well you can.. But youll be buried or worse soon after. Free energy exists, research Electrostatics & Magnetism. Bees levitate as well as beetles, Its not “Gravity” its Magneto-Electric Levitation. (incoherent electrostatic acceleration, Between two Gaussian surfaces, One negative(earth) the other positive(Iykyk) Hint-2nd law Thermodynamics(Hot
What would be wrong with being a historian rather than an engineer? As an engineer, youre actually physically limited as to what youre able to produce on a mass scale, youre not “allowed” to change the system in a beneficial way, well you can.. But youll be buried or worse soon after. Free energy exists, research Electrostatics & Magnetism. Bees levitate as well as beetles, Its not “Gravity” its Magneto-Electric Levitation. (incoherent electrostatic acceleration, Between two Gaussian surfaces, One negative(earth) the other positive(Iykyk) Hint-2nd law Thermodynamics(Hot
@@thebash5656 that makes me think back to my school days, and how disinterested I was in History. As an adult now I am much more interested.
About to sit through this but how the hell am I supposed to pay attention to a dr. Casagranda talk if he's not gesticulating and pacing all over the place?!?! That's like %50 of the fun and the inculcating/inoculating prowess of this man. Praying for the quick mending of that ailed limb, that literal pillar of knowledge. Salam
Yes, praying he makes a speedy recovery.
My thoughts exactly, it was sad to see someone I care about in pain, but my next thought (a selfish one) was how would that work for me? but as usual he proved me wrong. He is just as engaging and informative as ever.
Salaams
True
@@parvezhussain691😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅 12:24 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
😅😅😅😅
I randomly came across this brilliant teacher a couple of weeks ago and I cant get enough of his lectures.
Good!!! He's amazing enjoy yourself
Same
ALGORITHMs man.
_Algorithm_ from the name of the ninth-century Arab mathematician _al-Khwarizmi_ as i learned from Dr. Roy.
The teacher speaks very well.
It s sad it does not make history but just an addition of prejudices.
I'd be careful about throwing around words like "brilliant." There's a lot of stuff he says that's just plain wrong.
When dr Casagranda drops his lectures, you know your in for a treat! It makes my day
you're*
I just found Dr. Casagranda a couple days ago. He's an amazing story teller as well as a deeply versed historian.
I couldn't remember how i found this man on RUclips, but he is by far the best teacher i have ever known.
Thank you again, I wish you a fast recovery of your injuries.
Hi Dr Roy, great lecture. Very engaging and informative. And many lols, though tough audience. Wanted to ask when you are dropping part 2?
When's number 2 coming
Me too😂😂
He’s an opinionated Marxist and would definitely have been a Nazi if he’d been in Germany in the 1930’s
I can recommend you to check Dr Michael Surgue's lectures on Philosophy too. He is another of my favorite ones
Never in my life I've wished to go to the US but now its become one of my aims in life to get to Austin and sit there in just one of Dr. Casagranda's lectures! The power of the talent of this man!
If you can, buy and wear a bulletprrof vest when you are there. Possibly a helmet too.
Haha In Texas? best advice you can receive ^ @@wari-bateshwar7461
@@wari-bateshwar7461 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
you and me both
It ain't that deep lmao
Wow, I have watched countless documentaries on WW1 and WW2, and this lecture has been the best. Thank you. I wish you had lectures on African history.
Hello everyone. I'm a German history student who happened upon this lecture. First and foremost, I must say I'm deeply impressed by the speaker's skills and the wealth of knowledge being shared here. However, I'd like to point out two minor errors that caught my attention.
When Dr. Casagranda began talking about Prussia, he mentioned that the Polish king called upon the Prussians to fight for him. In fact, the Prussians were one of the tribes living in the present-day Baltics who posed such challenges to the Polish kings. So, it wasn't the Prussians he called upon, but rather the Teutonic Order. This was a knightly order, akin to the Knights Hospitaller or the Knights Templar, founded during the First Crusade in the Holy Land, which, after the collapse of the Crusader states, sought territories. After an unsuccessful attempt in the Balkans, it established its own domain in the Baltics which was called Prussia much later. Following the Reformation, the Order's territory became a secular duchy, and because the last Grand Master came from the House of Hohenzollern, he became its duke. However, this line of the house eventually died out, and Prussia thus passed to Brandenburg, which was also ruled by the Hohenzollerns.
The second minor error concerns the statement: "Prussia is an army without a state." In fact, I'm not familiar with this exact phrase; rather, it's often quoted slightly differently: "Other states have an army, but the Prussian army has a state." This phrase doesn't originate from the time when the Teutonic Order conquered the territories of Prussia, but rather from the 18th and 19th centuries. Allegedly attributed to the French statesman Honoré Gabriel de Mirabeau, this statement refers to the militarization in Prussia, which began not until after the Thirty Years' War, flourished in the 18th century, and was further strengthened after the Napoleonic Wars through the "Prussian reforms."
The problem is he will never read this comment, and he will keep on repeating his error.
You're very well spoken and correct !!! I enjoyed reading your comment
Best of luck with your studies and may you continue to educate others with the knowledge you attain! Love and blessings to you
He is a political scientist not a historian but still one of the greatest lecturers I’ve seen. He’s also mistaken about French nobility in the French Revolution being quite summarily slaughtered. Koblenz comes to mind if not London.
those were not the only mistakes but it was a fun lecture
@@kudu2013 kudos to you too for the errors you may have caught albeit the professor has the perfect alibi with his political science degree.
Dr Casagranda makes history so exciting it's better than any movie, waiting impatiently for Salah Uddin part 2
This man is a time machine.
Brings to life the past like no other history book or historian
WOW
this time his time machine is spitting out a LOT of omissions and inaccuracies
@@bogeyb200 yeah, I recently found this guy on tittok. the man doesn't care for historical facts, just likes telling stories
@@bogeyb200 what main things do you think are majorly wrong/ommitted
@@irie1tes there are a ton of them.. Prof Casagrada is a very talented story teller, but he's also idelogically blinkered. I couldn't easily catch him on his tales of the Islamic Conquests, but Here he wanders into historical territory that I know extremely well and the entire tale is full of ideological twists and falsehoods.. the supposed "blooodthirst" comment, etc.. it's all very bad history. Also as mentioned below.. dead and completely wrong re main reasons for British to enter the war.
@@irie1tesmost of what he says abt WW2 is wrong, hes the equivalent of a teenager that skimmed the hoi4 subreddit and thinks hes a ww2 expert
Please, upload part 2. This was amazing and I could watch hours of Casagranda talk about this era of history for hours on end. It all is more than relevant now than ever and we need to talk about how everything happened in the first place.
Where is part 2? Don't tell me it still isn't up.
@@fluffycolt5608me rn. I need this part 2
@@fluffycolt5608I can’t find it anywhere!
What a cliff hanger. We want part 2!
When will part 2 be available?
I need part two! Come one Dr. give the people what they want!
Patience 🙏
Yeah. Part 2 is gonna be interesting. Can't wait.
Seriously! It's been 3 months. Where the heck is it!
Only if he uploads regularly his channels would be all I need. Please upload part 2 of the WW2
Can't do it. Broke his left hand walking home from this lecture. Seriously love the knowledge of history but not the lefty bias. Many other historians disagree.
Can't wait for part 2!
It's always a pleasure to hear Dr.Casagranda tell history, sometimes I think he was there and witnessed it for himself Incredible story teller
you never know. we have psychedelics ;)
@@hmdismailplz elaborate
Here is part 2 covering WW2
ruclips.net/video/IXU6mHcBfIc/видео.htmlsi=u-nJblp8_swcOddy
Salam from Ramallah Dr. Casagandra , may you please tell the story of the Nakba or Omar AlKhattab. My family sits and watches your lectures and in a time when school is shut because of the war , you bring knowledge and experience that even our best teachers can’t accomplish with a powerful engaging way. My children benefit immensely as do I. Also may you recover soon our thoughts and prayers are with you.
Salma brother from India. May Allah give justice and peace to the world.
Salam! My prayers and hopes are with the people of Palestine 🍉
He has done both videos, the Nakba was part and in ruclips.net/video/tYVi368vSYc/видео.html around the 1 hour mark he talks about the great leader
@@Azhar_shaikh1 Thank you 🙏 and Salam to you and your family brother
@@alandudov8876 Salam and thank you 🙏 May you live in peace and prosperity
I’m an academic person, at PhD level with twenty plus years of study and I feel like an excited High school student whenever this guy drops a video. His work on the Aztec empire v Spain was groundbreaking for me and helped with my own work . Well worth putting the time in.
I thought Dan Carlin's Hardcore History would always be the best World War series for me, but man, I loved this part 1 by Dr. Roy. Can't wait for second!
hey Dan is great too, and Roy together make magic
I'm always so happy to see Dr. Casagranda uploaded another one of his amazing lectures!
I feel like people who watch these lectures should be awarded academic credits. Always has such an insightful and illuminating account of the people, places and events from our past that continue to resonate today.
Lol it's history
I have more respect for this man than my actual teachers. The outpouring knowledge and intelligence with his unparalleled storytelling is fascinating. Massive respect Sir. Get well soon. 💙
maybe your teachers told less stretching of truth or omissions than the Professor does here.
Are you implying that some teachers are better than others? 😲/s
The proof is in the pudding for your dumbass eh.
Always excited when a new lecture is posted ! Please please do more on any topic! you have a way to make anything interesting and engaging! Also wishing you a speedy recovery professor
Professor Casagranda, In Darija Which Is Moroccan Arabic, The Term Casagranda or Its Meaning Is Often Given To People With Good Heart, Generous and Welcoming, Just So You Know.
Thank You For The Generosity Of Your Courses 🙏.
Alami Omar.
W3lasch katkdeb 3lih
@@Anouar6993 Bl3ks Sadi9i, Ma3na Dyal Smyto Hiya Dar Kbira
@@Anouar6993 😂😂😂😂
I say this without hyperbole. Best lecture I’ve ever listened to.
Because he provides background to the facts,not just facts.
These lectures are so important, especially now.
To Show us how believeable something wrong can be to the "uneducated" (about a certain topic)
Dr Roy, i could listen to your story-telling for hours, always captivating in a way that it sticks to my type of memory ,or, in general.
Bro, I was in need for some insight on the world wars, thank god this great teacher decided to make a serie!! 🎉
The man is a genius.I found him by chance and was hooked.I wonder how can someone remember dates so vividly and names! He throws around names from thousands of years ago and he is accurate..what a memory! Vow! He makes hearing history a treat.Thnx Dr.Casagranda.I lap up everything u post and I see and hear it again and again .Its the best audio to hear when I go for my walks.Previously I used listen to music.Not anymore..Salaam and respects from Pakistan.
One of the greatest pros for internet is Dr. Roy Casagranda, i appreciate the Austin school. Thank you
Watching as a Moroccan muslima from Belgium, Europe
Sir your mind is riveting. I feel like you are the Christian Nolan of history and human antropology. Thank you for uploading your lectures for the world to learn!
If you like this type of story telling ypu should listen to hardcore history by dan carlin. Its the best on the internet
@@mugiwara7347 thank you
Dat heb je mooi verwoord
@@silversurfer2140in het begin zei hij dat het heel moeilijk uit te leggen was omdat het niet lineair was, ik dacht gelijk aan de regisseur Nolan 😅 great minds think alike. Deze professor is gewoon geweldig 🫡🫡
@@mugiwara7347will definitly check it out, thank you
A bit with Prussia is a bit more complicated. Polish duke granted land to Teutons (Knighty Order) to defend agaisnt "real' Prussians that were pagan baltic people. Teutons were effective but also very ambitious and through machinations finally established independent state. State consisted of lands taken from polish dukes and conquered territories from Prussians(in series of papaly approved crusades). In conquest and administration they were very effective and very brutal creating suprisingly powerful medieval state. Large income was also generated from crusades, as western knights paid a lot to participate in holy raids againts pagans. After around 150years Poland finally consolidated and allied with LIthuanians to retake stolen lands and remove Teutonic threat. After series of wars Teutonic State was cut down to East Prussia only, and finally in 1525 they secularized into protestant Duchy of Prussia as vassal of Polish Kings. In 1618 the Prussian line of Hohenzollern has ended and Brandenurgian Hohenzollerns took over and formed personal union. Then in 1657 Duchy of Prussia became soveregin, in 1701 King in Prussia title was established. And then, after some 40-50 years , militarization really became so radical that we can say of state built around army.
This feels like im stealing education,like who do i pay for this? thanks
You could probably donate? I dunno! I agree haha. I've been holed up going on historical deep dives and reading so much it's been awesome !!! I hope you enjoyed the lecture as well, the internet is so awesome and we have so much info available to us crazy these videos don't have more views lol ppl busy looking at vapid and ignorant shit 😅
They are called massive open online classes, or MOOCs I've used Coursera, and Harvard has free classes. You hold a world of knowledge in your hand. All free. Don't feel bad, an educated public is vital. Be a lifelong learner. 🎉
You can pay me, I wouldn't mind!))
This is not a mooc @@Eurydice870
Me
Easily one of the greatest narrator I’ve seen on RUclips.
I wish you a speedy recovery Prof.
What a tidal wave of knowledge. And the narration skills to match.
I’ve come the good doctor on TikTok and he pops up all the time. I love history and he teaches so well. I love the content. Thx doc❤
Thanks Dr. Casagranda! Having the prowess and humor to take us back several centuries and different places and players to set up the whole lecture is masterful.
Wish I had a professor like this gentleman who actually has passion about history and preserving real history and culture having a little passion and with the humor you throw in now and then thank you for your time and knowledge it’s gratefully appreciated
I hope you get better soon, Doctor. Your way of delivering when pacing is simply, the best.
Hello Roy. Thank you for all the wonderful lectures. You have friends all over the world. I wish you fast recovery and much warm welcomes to come visit Bosnia Herzegovina.
i love watching/listening to Dr. Casagranda's lectures
can't wait for part II !
Certainly, you are among the great storytellers, your tangents are more interesting than most.
Thank you for this and keep posting!!
When you mentiond the breakdown of the nervouis system of the soilders due to artillery barrage, this remind me of Innocent Civilians in GAZA and those little children observing their hands constantly shivering. 😥
Wanna see u speak about salah ad-din part 2.. especially during these days when israel is becoming genocidal
I watched so many documentaries about WW1 but never I understood what happened in such details, thank you so much.
I so excited to watch this new series by this amazing professor. You're amazing sir!
Im impatiently waiting for part II now,and i never recall myself this anxious for a history class
So thank you for making it simple, enjoyable and as far as it gets to the truth.
I’m going to watch this video while seating instead of working around my little work shop to give a respect to Dr Roy❤❤I’m with you on this 😁❤Massive Respect!🙏🏻
Always beneficial to watch Dr Roy. Patiently waiting second part and whatever injured Dr Roy I hope you'll be fine soon!
Just goes to show we are intertwined with events through history. It’s just one looooong story. Events leading to another to another.
Need part 2
WE NEED PART 2 RIGHT NOW, PLEEAAASEEE !!! this is excellent, thank you so very much and greetings from Buenos Aires
Great story, as always! Minor correction: Deshima is an island in front of Nagasaki, not Hiroshima. Both cities were nuked, so it has no effect to the story.
Always so amazing to see a video from Roy pop up. Ok well I wont be doing that now❤❤ I will be doing this.
You interweave complex socio-historical moments to form an exciting well-rounded picture. Dr. Roy, Thank you so much. I am so glad that I found you. Take care of yourself! We need our truthtellers, now more than ever.
this is phenomenal!
can't wait for Part 2!
Ooh my fav Historian, just super stoked to watch all of this series, thanks ever so much!!
I am so glad I found this youtube channel. Please continue to keep up the fantastic work!
The neutrality and fairness in Dr Roy’s talks is impressive. His style of delivery and keeping listener interested throughout is just 💯.
There is no part 2 yet? I´m becoming addict to this lectures.
Thank your for the lecture professor. Waiting for part 2
I only discovered these lectures by Dr Casagrande a few weeks ago and I can't get enough of them! I do have to take issue with him over the end of WW1. In the final 3-4 months of the was, after the German offensive was stopped the German army was comprehensively beaten. The arrival of large numbers of US soldiers was a really crucial factor. After the war a myth arose that Germany's defeat was due to a collapse on the home front. This myth of "the stab in the back " was used by the Nazi's. It's simply not true, the army was beaten and that was like the last straw!
I just a finished a 6 hour documentary on WW 1 and 2,
glad I found more on the topic from this particular dr. He’s very informative.
His story is so inaccurate! Greece got independence in 1832, not in 1850’s. Russia didn’t declare war on Austria-Hungary, she only started mobilization and then Germany declared war on Russia on 1 August 1914 and Austria-Hungary followed on 6 August. The British didn’t want to enter the war. The Germans didn’t want to fight the English. Russia wasn’t the first to invade another superpower - the French attacked Germany on August 7, while Russia attacked Germany 10 days later. Britain was outbuilding the German navy because they had a doctrine of being stronger than two any other navies combined, so it wasn’t competition of Britain against Germany, but vice versa. He forgot to mention that Russia tried to seize the Hawaiis in early 19 century but was kicked out by the Americans. Japan annexed Korea in 1904, not in 1895. Alliance between England and France wasn’t the first in Europe, Germany and Austria had got it before. His gesturing doesn’t help to improve his narrative.
If your right then his numbers are off, slightly off, however. He contains so much historical facts that one might get some dates mixed up. With that being said he knows exactly what transpired chronically. History isnt just regurgitating dates, its what led up to each event, and he portrayed that perfectly.
Inaccurate history. Brits didn't turn down Kaiser offer to avoid war, they weren't even part of an alliance w French or Russia. They later in surprise decided to come in. Kaiser at best wanted Serbia to apologize as nation and be humiliated. So, no, Brits didn't cause ww1. When Historian makes up history it's sad. And no, 1 unit of black soldiers is not 1 of the 2 reasons the Germans didn't take Paris late in war, Paris was not threatened and no one thinks the blacks changed history. Again, if this guy will lie it ruins trust in everything he claims. If it's not stated in fact in a book don't trust some speech by professor I guess.
Awesome as always! Waiting for the next lecture!
Lovely and candid as always. Never a dull moment in history when Roy is delivering. Heal soon. Need part II asap. 😂
the best history professor ive ever come across. please upload an entire series with him. we need many part 2s as well. Austin School is luck to have him!
Enjoying your lectures as always 😍 Thank you professor!
Oh God, hope you get better the soonest Prof Roy. I’m Syrian and I appreciate the way you talk about Near East.
i swear to god i was sooooo excited when i saw the UPLOAD notification from Dr. Roy, Love your lectures Prof
When you are 45 and haven't had the patience for over 25 yrs to listen to a teacher.. and then comes Professor Roy Casagranda! Brilliant man ☕️👏
Wish you a speedy recovery so that you can do the next series part 5 of "Why did someone think it was a good destination?" talking about the colonial settler state of Israel and palestine
Eagerly waiting for part 2...
Samee
i love how he takes you back into history to actually understand the everyday perspective, sure anyone can just say what happened with some dates and events but he goes the extra mile
What an amazing lecturer, keeps you engaged throughout the whole talk.
Podcast!! Podcast!! Podcast!!
We want regular podcast!!!
On another note, may you get well very soon sir.
Small correction about Japan:
Christianity was not seen as evil but seen as threat because unlike with shinto and buddhist faith, the boss would no longer be Daimyo, Shogun or Emperor but God and perhaps Pope in Europe. Very simimar situation than with Christians early in Roman Empire. Also it was seen as negative influence for warriors as christians would be afraid the desth more as nobody wants to go hell (Which is why introducing buddhism to Samurai class was a big thing earlier)
Japan was not afraid of guns, but guns were essential to win a civil war, So Togukawa shogunate decided to ban guns from anybody else and restrict foreign trade (potential source of the guns). Thus making sure there would be no rebellions, This worked until Meiji restoration
What a vivid visual gut wrenching description of the trench warfare! Roy has exceeded his own high standards here.
Great talk, beautiful summary.
My grandfather was fighting 4th and 5th offensive with Tito and partisans in 1943..
My grandfather on the mother side was fighting against them in the same offensive,batlle off Neretva and Sutjeska in Yugoslavia
The other grandfather was in Devil's division off NDH., bloody Balkans
And I was in Sarajevo in Yugoslavia war's 92/95
And I am a historian so just recently founded Your's video classes Roy and for now You are my favorite historian,so❤
Hello to fellow 'historian psycho'😊
#Freepalestine🇦🇪
My next 2 hours are planned out. Thanks ❤
So happy I stumbled on to Dr.Casagranda. True enlightenment. Many thanks. Please upload part 2.
Hi I hope dr Roy sees my comment I assume he got more free time 😅 Dr Casagrande I'm a 42 years ol civil engineer currently studying Masters Regional Studies focusing on South East Asia at University of Tehran and want to wish you a quick recovery and know you're a inspiration for me to go back study my favorite subject and I got accepted to best institution in my country thank you for your passion for history and truth, I don't know why but at the start of every lecture I imagined you in Ronnie James Dio singing history and as so many other I want to ask you redo on sitting lecture, we want see you as we know you, love and respect from Iran
Please make a video about the creation of Israel and how it has nothing to do with judaism and everything to do with political games and manipulation. A genocide is happening, you need to educate people about this ! It's a moral duty
I agree!
If you know the answer then why ask?
Just stop
He may not be pacing, but if you pay attention you'll notice he leans from side to side occassionally, which is enough movement for me! hahaha Love this guy! I am tempted to pursue my PhD at his school, because I would LOVE to be in a classroom with him, lol
As someone who has listened to lecture after lecture, he is one of the best
I hope your leg would recover well. I haven't watched your videos for a few weeks.
You are my favourite historian.
Amazing storyteller. One of the best
Learning so much about real history and not the fiction we have been taught throughout the years. Love Dr. Roy's lectures, and think i was introduced to him through Tik Tok, yes shocking something educational on Tik Tok.
I have been reading history for 55 years. Never accept any historians take as the "real" history. As Napoleon said: "History is a set of lies agreed upon." I love this professors take on history. But you should read and listen critically. Never accept a narrative just because it is entertaining. But I do think this professor has a very interesting and unique take on history.
Thanks for this very interesting lesson. I feel like pieces of the history puzzle are finally assembling together!
"Wake up baby, new Roy video has dropped"
This guy's a genius ❤
Please, just give us part two! It is the way to lecture history which of I've always imagine to have!
I love your lectures. Remind me of sitting in World Civ and Greek Civ classes with a great professor I had
Beautifully narrated lecture
He is so confident in his inaccuracies. I actually have no idea why he feels qualified talking about WWII
Oh no someone is telling history in a way that isn't painted in my preferred shade of bias. The horror.
Salaam the Duke of story telling. Let dr Roy hold a series of lectures , in any place outside USA , say istanbul...where some of us can visit him , who are unable to visit USA.
In a museum in India, I saw a quote which read: "the Englishman flourishes, and acts like a sponge, drawing up riches from the banks of the Ganges, and squeezing them down upon the banks of the Thames."
Don't let this man talk about tanks please
where is the second part 😢
My attention span is around mere seconds to 10-15 mins max.
Watched the first 50 minutes without a single break.
What an astounding lecure that binds all these threads of history together. Each subject needs further reading and learning - obviously. But to assemble this greater picture - what an astonishing feat. Thank you! This reminds me of Hendrik Willem van Loon - he wrote about history before the 1st World War and found quite a unique voice of knowledge and fun doing it. History to enjoy, even if it is - and it is - horrible. Cheers*
Academia these days... always have to sprinkle in their personal political bullshit into everything... I dont care what you think/believe. I just care what you know. This was a rambling mess