Here's the list of products reviewed. More details in the video description. Thank you! DeWalt: amzn.to/3ayJ4g9 AC Delco: amzn.to/3nzWtbr Ingersoll Rand: amzn.to/3rg59pF Milwaukee: amzn.to/2WxKUWk Ridgid: amzn.to/3h60iTm
I don't get it. How do you measure TORQUE ... in PSI ..? ... per square INCH ..?? What!? It's just twisting force. Irrespective however many inches it's "across." Even if it's legitimate, it's not intuitive. Can we please stick to lb-ft ..? In fact, when I asked AI: _Can electric impact wrench measure torque in PSI ..?_ ...and it said: _Electric impact wrenches measure torque in Newton meters (Nm), not PSI._ So how the heck is this supposed to make sense on an intuitive level !?
Project Farm has a reputation of doing this well, which in turn is why I'm watching. There's plenty of youtube shills around and some tests can be faked (not saying they are).
@Incog Nito Consumer Reports has been selling car reviews for over a decade at this point. They consistently give high ratings to certain car manufacturers.
@@TehButterflyEffect Absolutely untrue. You are confusing 'Consumer Reports' with the other fake review brands 'Consumer Guide', 'Consumer Review' or any name that sounds like Consumer Reports. Over the decades many fakes have been created by the manufacturers to confuse and obfuscate the truth. The real one never sells anything, they buy all of the products (including cars) without anyone knowing who they are, meaning just a regular consumer buying a product. No advertising EVER and never any involvement from manufacturers. The car surveys are massive with thousands of members of the Consumers Union providing their results. Outliers are thrown out and the results are quite scientific. Of course if you like some brand that does poorly in their results I can not help with that. I suggest a change of loyalty in that case.
@@tjboylan20 I have a ton of DEWALT batteries because 3 of the 5 tools I have have shit the bed. Only 1 of 4 Milwaukee’s have died on me and that’s because I dropped it 150ft.. and it still worked for another year. Easy for me to never buy another yellow tool.
@@ProjectFarm my dad had an IR 231c for years and I used it for years as well... it was great... but it seems when the electric game got introduced IR couldn’t adapt as quickly
He did a torque wrench test a while back, and it seemed like the icon brand from harbor freight was the beas bang for the buck. It was even more accurate than snap on.
I'd love to see a revisit of this. Milwaukee and Makita in particular have come out with new models for sub-compact impact wrenches and Ridgid's wrench has supposedly gotten more compact with more power. I'd also love to see how brands like Ryobi, Craftsman, and Kobalt hold up.
You know it defiantly makes companies nervous about their claims. If it says can drop it from 10ft high, PF will drop it from 10ft high. You dont makes a claim that PF wont test. Great channel as always
"So I've gathered the least expensive ring, a standard price gemstone ring and a high priced luxury diamond ring to put it to the test. So first off we..."
I’ve had the Milwaukee for about 3 years now and it’s been a great impact. There is a noticeable power difference between the 2 and 4 amp hour batteries
@@TehKaiser I disagree, we use and abused milwaukee stuff at work and have had few failures. Ever used a Sawzall in muddy water? How about an impact and battery that have been sitting out in -20*f all night, or dropped an impact from 35 ft into some grass (oops), anyway, with as few failures I've seen and all the abuse we put through our tools I'm pretty confident whenever I pick up a red tool.
@@TehKaiser Milwaukee tools are tough as nails man. I work in a swing stage some times and I have NOTHING but red tools for a reason. I dropped an m18 impact (my bit broke and I basically had all my weight into it and it crushed my hand and fell) from 6 stories in the air, it smacked a sidewalk and slammed into the building. I was scared, but it was fine. The battery no longer shows how full it is, but it works. A buddy dropped a 25ft magnetic tape measure from 12 stories, landed on pavement, left a hole big enough for the table to sit into, it still works just fine. We abuse these tools, even my personal tools and not only have they impressed me, but they've made me into a purist. Until another brand makes a tool worth switching for, ill pay for red everytime.
@@ProjectFarm Instead if you holding a drill (a shirt with your face on it doesn't feel like it's your thing) perhaps the design has the tip of a pen pointing at a warranty or claim of some kind?
Me: sees how Milwaukee performs in these videos Me: looks at my Ryobi collection Ryobi: =c Me: (pats tools) "it's ok, we barely do any tough work anyway!" Ryobi: c=
I have a Ryobi impact driver and it was pretty shit, says it has 270Nm of maximum torque but it struggled to remove wheel nuts torqued to 115Nm and couldn't remove my transmission drain nut when it was brand new right out of the box. It was heavy too. Just bought the M12 Milwaukee set (3/8 Fuel impact, 3/8 Fuel ratchet, tyre inflator, 2 and 4 Ah batteries and charger for AU$644) yesterday, looking forward to using it more in the future
I bought a Milwaukee after watching this review. I was not disappointed. My kit came with 2a & 6a batteries, the 6a really makes a huge difference to it's torque capabilities. Keep up the good work
It's not 2A or 6A, its 2Ah or 6Ah. Both have the same Power. In DC devices it's still P=U*I, the Volts and Amps in both batteries are the same. But the 6 Ah battery last longer.
@@MaxFitz-Gibbon the terminology is irrelevant. Your opinion is flawed. Due to the characteristics of lithium ion batteries, the larger battery gives more torque for longer. I know because I have the tool.
Ok can we just appreciate the fact that this man not only spends all of his time and money on making these fantastic videos for us, but also finds time to listen to and respond to so many comments? These are the footsteps more channels need to follow in. Keep up the amazing work!
I really do appreciate his reviews but as far as spending the money he actually makes money I think this channel is worth somewhere around two or $3 million lol. It’s not charity work but honestly he deserves whatever he gets.
I just wish Rigid was more consistent with Its quality. Milwaukee is nearly always a top finisher, DeWalt is usually good, some times average. (Things change though) Inconsistency is why these reviews are invaluable.
Hey man, it's been a really long time since I've left a comment, but I just wanted to say I'm so happy for you for making it so far with your channel. You have not changed a BIT since you started, and that's amazing. You provide a ton of information and value for so many people. Keep being awesome.
Would love to see this test again comparing the newer brushless models vs old, missing Ryobi, and also a short drop test. Lot of the impacts that are more enthusiast quality usually pickup some heavy use damage over time. Milwaukee and DeWalt are seen at a lot of construction sites for a reason.
This is what happens when you slap you brand on a CHEAP chinesse product. I mean, almost all of the tools are Chinesse, there is nothing wrong with it. But you need to pick a good quality one or design yourself and ask a factory to produce it .... IR = go for the cheap one
I was looking at the Ridgid 1/2 impact a couple weeks ago at Home Depot for $140, then saw that they had a combo deal offering the 1/2 impact AND the 3/8 impact for $170. Couldn't pass up a deal like that!
I didnt see the voltage in the video and i didnt think you were correct about those 12v, but after looking it up... damn. I still think Ridgid is great value for the price, both it and Milwaukee being very compact and yet the most powerful. Pretty neat that you can stuff so much in such a small package.
Exactly right. I would say throw the m18 3/8 up against the rigid in this video to get a fair comparison...but it’s a sub compact category. The m18 is over 6 inches in length. So all in all, once again, a great video comparison.
Milwaukee doesn't fuck around. I've demolished a couple of the 1/2" m18 fuel impacts and they even beat a couple of the older 3/4" electric impacts with ease.
+1 I would like to see this one www.homedepot.com/p/RYOBI-ONE-18V-Cordless-3-Speed-1-2-in-Impact-Wrench-Kit-with-1-4-Ah-Battery-Charger-and-Bag-P261K/313581565
I was literally just looking at high torque impacts saying to myself, "project farm should test these high torque impacts" (milwaukee, kobalt xtr, Rigid, Dewalt, etc. ) Great test on these subcompacts though! Hopefelly, the high torque test is soon to come. 👀
The Mac tools 1/2 gun is the same specs as the dewalt 3/4 inch gun but you don’t get the chemical resistant case on the dewalt and obviously it’s a 3/4 so most people would need a step down adaptor
I just bought a ridgid 3/8, 1/2, 1 battery, and a charger all for $200 on sale at Home Depot. Normal price is $400 so I’d say I got a hell of a deal. Great comparison and just short of Milwaukee makes me happy.
I got a similar deal with their compact circular saw, drill, 2 batteries and charger. If you catch em at the right time home depot has some incredible deals at least with ridgid tools
I’d like to see a similar comparison of 1/2” impact wrenches from these companies plus the new Kobalt XTR line from Lowe’s and Earthquake from Harbor Freight. Great stuff!
There's a reason all my battery tools are Will-fawk-ye. Consistently top 3 in almost every comparison except price on everything I buy. Plus they just have good design - the yard tools (still waiting on a lawnmower, but I digress) with the quick-lok system just makes trimming my trees and hedges, and other yardwork a breeze, and storage is now 1/4 of the space it used to take up with gas tools, because most of the tools are just a detachable head that you swap out. My drills, impacts, circular saws, tablesaws, oscillating tools, miter saws, rotary hammer, and I'm sure I'm forgetting a few all use the M18 batteries, and the 12Ah ones last me most of the day regardless of the tool I'm using. My "home tools" use the M12 batteries (along with my heated winter gear), I have the headlamp and heated gloves that use their USB rechargeable batteries, and I'm starting to look at their MX lineup as well, since I bought the powerbank "generator" and light tower that run on the MX batteries. Of all the Milwaukee stuff I own, my only complaint is that the heated gloves are advertised as working gloves but they're light-duty at best. For over $200 I was expecting them to be way more durable than they are. Oh, and the miter saw stand's material supports are flimsier than I'd like. Not a shill, just a tradesman who happens to love the brand.
I agree I have the milwaukee and recently but the 4.0mah battery on it and it actually made a big different from the 2.0mah battery power, speed and of course battery life wise
@@netsai61 heavy doesn't bother me - I work with far heavier tools. What matters to me is that I only have to carry one spare battery, or don't have to run back and forth to my charger all day long.
I have this exact Ingersoll Rand impact. I love it, and it’s lasted years of being dropped and over used in high torque use settings (since as we can see, it’s not the strongest impact). I’m probably going to try a new brand when it bites the dust so these tests help.
Your tests are well thought out, and your reviews are unbiased. I am really grateful for your videos. You have become the gold standard for real world testing. Thank you.
search it on here there is many tests like this with Makita up against these brands and even the new Ryobi HP+ line,,,,,but I can tell you the outcome from having watched them many times,,,,,,the makita is very simlar priced to the dewalt, millwaukee in that range,,,the makita is about the same level in power and run time as the dewalt and rigid ,,,,,bottom line though is if you want the best just get the millwauke and be done,,,,,,not to sound like a fan boy but millwaukee has been on the war path to crush the competition it seems because the pretty much do in every area tested.
I recently bought the M12 stubby. I’ve changed struts, tie rods, bearings, rotors, brakes, cv axle and ball joint. It has been successful with everything I’ve throw at it with the exception of a stuck bolt on a suspension part. One of the best car tools I’ve ever purchased. Saves so much straining with a ratchet.
@@Danielxperez14 I’m not a mechanic. Just a diy guy working on my own cars. I’m sure some will say more torque is better. The M12 has been enough for me.
@@subver6787 yea I’ll probably get that one whenever I need it, I ended up getting the 3/8 stubby and so far it’s been great taking lug nuts off of my canams and other things, not much rust where I’m from(Cali)
@@QuantumMind88 That's also a good point! I work at a shop where we have access to high pressure air, so it can be beneficial to take advantage of it. But no doubt. Battery is better in nearly every way (besides maybe fluid resistance)
@@jacobharryman822 Look at the heat all of the tools produced. Some hot enough to boil water. Air tools do not get hot and are not effected by environmental contaminates. Cordless is great but for severe duty cycle air is still amazing. We had 3hp air grinders at may last job they could run endlessly. The harder you worked them the colder they got to the point that frost would form around the exhaust. When we did the same job with electric grinders we would have to use 2 so one could cool while the other was in use.
@@geoffmooregm try that in winter the air tool just freeze and become useless Battery impact are so much practical and fast in the road truck no need to start the engine for the compressor wait till its full,unroll the air hose and pray it don't freeze pefore you are done
Could you do something with fishing line? Strength test, visual test in different conditions, cut resistance, how easy to tie a knot with it i guess lol just shooting one out there
I'm not suprised the Milwaukee stubby did so well. I use mine daily, that thing is a power house for its size. Probably my favorite tool for how light and powerful it is.
I know Ridgid isn't the best out there but they make good tools for the money. The thing I like most about them though is that if you buy the kits from Home Depot you can sign up for Ridgids LSA, which will pretty much let you bring it back to the store for a new one if it ever breaks, for life.
@@KonaPony That doesn't mean that all tools will be equal. Dewalt Black and Decker power tools are both owned by SBD that doesn't mean they're the same quality.
@@ProjectFarm I second this. My partner is getting into some hobbies that might require a "Dremel" tool and your channel has done the best work I've seen for practical reviews.
I work with people that have the snap-on one and my Forman ended up selling his snap-on and getting the milwaukee 12v stubby like mine. Milwaukee make the snap-on look like that ac delco.
@@getskared seems like all tool truck brands lack in the electric sector. I'm still a milwaukee fan boy though because they don't alter their battery form factor frequently
@@logan9334 I have all Ridgid gen4x at home and they just won't die! I do love Milwaukee though, I am a Steamfitter by trade so we beat the hell out of our tools and both of those brands far outshine any DeWalts or any other brands we end up with. Also we use a lot of Wright Open end wrenches and they're freakin tough
EDIT: Per request here are the rough torque values compared to an old school air impact wrench assuming that's a 3/4" bolt: Milwaukee: 227ft-lbs, Rigid: 195ft-lbs, DeWalt: 113 ft-lbs, IR: 74ft-lbs, ACDelco: 31ft-lbs 7:00 Interesting, we basically the same set up we're running to test torque on larger impacts. Very cool!
Thank you yet again for a great review. I find it incredible that 2 of the 5 brands tested sell a product that is not able to do the most basic tasks adequately.
I have the Milwaukee. It is highly impressive. Very small and packs a huge punch. Just rebuilt my entire steering and front/rear suspension on my 96 ram 3500 dually with this tool. Takes lug nuts off easily and it's only a 12v 3/8
Man I’m looking at the same job! Getting a Red Head Steering gear box and need to pull the Steering Vacuum/Pump housing to replace O-Rings. New hoses all around since it’s all original on the truck. 98 Ram 3500 Dually. Any tips man, did you end up using a breaker bar or was the Milwaukee your go to for any bolts? Gonna order a pitman arm puller but otherwise these Impacts are what I’ve been researching to make my life a bit easier. I’m a Dewalt guy but many folks I came up working with in the maintenance shop had either Milwaukee, Mac (Which is basically Dewalt), or Snap-On.
Ditto.. I still use daily one of the early composite body 1/2" drive air impacts I bought in the mid 90's. The end of the anvil is broken off so it doesn't retain sockets, the fwd & rev buttons popped out a few years back so I change directions using a pocket screwdriver on the internals but doggone it it just keep works working and has never been sent off for repair. It's like me... old, worn out and ought to be retired but still doing the job! 😉
Bought the 5 piece set from HD two years back, I have yet to make them breathe hard , only drawback is they are a bit hefty but you're getting a free workout.
Well, the 18V Rigid outperformed the 12V Dewalt, anyway... The Rigid SHOULD have beat everyone since it was the only 18V impact wrench in the lineup. The fact that the 12V Milwaukee beat the 18V Rigid...
@@l00nybin I have the 1/2" M18 mid torque wrench (450 ft lbs tightening and 600 ft lbs busting) and it's much easier to handle than the massive high torque one (insane 1400 ft lbs busting). I guess it's not compact though (maybe sub compact)
Just wanted to say thank you. I've been a fan since the seafoam test days and I'm sure it's not the first time somebody has told you that your channel is a service to the community.
@@ProjectFarm I would like to see both sizes of the Ridgid 1/2 impact tested. They make a 4 mode and bigger 6 mode impact. I have the 4 mode and it is tough but not 20 year old rusted exhaust bolts tough lol
Great job on this review, as always. Another consideration when purchasing is Ridgid's lifetime service warranty that also includes the batteries (providing the tools and batteries are registered after purchase) I recently had one of my 18v batteries fail from my drill/driver combo and Ridgid replaced it for free. I think they are the only brand that offers this coverage.
One caveat to their Lifetime Service Agreement (LSA) regarding the chargers/batteries is, they have to be purchased as a combo with a tool in order to be covered. A charger/battery purchased separately doesn't qualify for the LSA.
Test electric snow blowers! One stage vs two stage! EGO has a brand new one out. They claim it is equivalent to gas ones. I would love to hear you say "we're going to test that"!
Its super cool to see how project farms testing has gotten more fair and in my oppionion scientific over the years. In one test he torqued everything down to 100 ft/lb and got wildly different results out of the impacts like with the dewalt. One nut got delt with quickly. The other was an imoveable object. Just goes to show how torque readings may not actually tell you how tight something is. From what i understand lubricating the bolts and removeing 25-33% of the torque (i most commonly hear 30%) since the lubricant gives you a more accurate and even stretch but this means that you can easily overtorque something and cause plastic deformation. Im pretty sure there is also some more scientific system where you torque it to a certain spec using a torque meter and then tighten it down further by rotating it a certain number of degrees. I believe this is because it becomes more and more difficult to get an accurate reading as the bolt stretches. (Ex: torque down to 60 ft/lb then rotate an aditional 30°) i believe this is what the manual tells you to do on some cars when torqing down the cylinder head. (But do not quote me or take any of this as fact im just a nerd that misremebers stuff not an engineer)
@@1djbecker I figured that, but I’m considerably less likely to buy ac delco for my next part, knowing their name means so little to them they’d sell it to any cheap trinket willing to pay for the right.
@Rocket Pliance ACDelco licenses their name to Mobiletron for tools. They don't have anything to do with the design or quality control. 'Durofix', who nominally imported this tool, is a five-ish person U.S. distribution center in Rancho Cucamonga. Most of their operation appears to be the accounting of importing products and paying the name license fees. Masterforce a house brand name for Menards. Masterforce hand tools used to be sourced from the top-notch suppliers, but they have switched away from that. Menards might contract with Mobiletron/Durofix to have their 'Masterforce' name printed on some generic tools, but there doesn't appear to be any other connection.
@@ProjectFarm Long time wrench spinner here. Everyone I know in the mechanical trade rid themselves of their snapon/bosch/makita electronics and almost all exclusively run M12 tools.
@@MrAPCProductions True dat, brother ! I have em all. 'Cept the monster 1/2 impact. Hope they can make it a bit smaller framed . Snapperhead is in big trouble, don't know how they hang on, old dinosaurs like me have everything, and Snappy quality is being challenged on Amazon every day.
I’m so happy to see ridgid do so well. I’ve always loved their tools. I’ve had a set of cordless impact and drills from them since 2013 and they still operate like new. I’ve been building furniture and cabinets with them, as well as working on the road installing tubs and showers and I gotta say I’ve more than got my money back.
Don’t tell Milwaukee fanboys that. They’ll tell you that Rigid tools are made with playdough and glitter and that’s their red tools were forged in the fires of mount doom.
I think the one area where the Rigid may have been an unfair comparison in this review is that it is an 18V platform that also weighs close to a pound more than the Dewalt. Don’t get me wrong, the Ridgid for the money is a great buy! I just think it is impressive that the Dewalt was the second cheapest and also the 2nd best performing 12volt system, only to the Milwaukee costing 2x as much. For such a lightweight tiny thing, that’s where the Dewalt seemed to be a Best Buy. If weight isn’t a concern, then the Ridgid takes too honors for best bang for the buck. It seems like the Dewalt DCF890 may have been a better comparison to that Ridgid model. All in all, though, this has still become one my absolute favorite testing channels. I have my notifications set for when every new video comes out!
@@ProjectFarm Also something important to point out is that the Ridgid has a lifetime service agreement for free battery replacement and tool repair when you register them. I have used Ridgid now for 11 years and had several batteries replaced for free, and no tool failure as yet but comforting to know that there will be free repair.
I love mine as well. I like the colors, the price, the quality, the feel. Just everything about them. Oh ya, and lifetime guarantee. Who else does that?
Your seemingly unscientific common sense testing is actually very scientific without the egg head or test tubes. Your relentless pursuit for true performance comparisons is commendable, don't change your format or your principles. You have my and others respect. Happy xmas.
Used DeWalt for many years on five separate work trucks before switching to all Ridgid. Lifetime warranty when you register and it has paid dividends with the batteries after 4 - 5 years. They have held up great getting abused by employees on a daily basis.
I'm in the market for a new impact wrench. Unfortunately, I'm already heavily invested in batteries for Dewalt and their tools. But I'm not impressed with the results for this particular tool. Albeit, that oddball Milwaukee battery may justify a slight deviation from the norm, without feeling the need for a total tool conversion. Until my OCD really kicks in. Thanks for the awesome content!
The DeWalt 12 volt 1/2" impact actually outperforms the Milwaukee M12 according to the torque test channel. Some people find the kit (tool battery and charger) on sale for $99. Around Father's Day or around Black Friday are the best deals.
@Zachary P In my opinion, Ryobi is not midrange... I'd Put Ryobi/Ridgid as entry-level/DIYer. then Dewalt/Milwaukee as midrange. lastly, if you're in the long haul, Makita. This is for electric power tools.
Milwaukee is a very solid brand, the extra money gets you extra features and reliability in nearly every case. Dewalt gives the impression that 20v is better than 18v, while using the same number of 18650 cells. Milwaukee 18v batteries achieve the same working and peak voltage as dewalt 20v batteries.
It's just a marketing strategy. Dewalt uses peak to show consumers a bigger number on the box. It's same strategy that Internet providers claim 100 Mb instead of 12.5 MB.
@@CalebsCars my mac has rubber for drop protection and is supposed to be chemical resistant. It helps, especially on the Batteries. Im always dropping my half in impact because im a klutz.
I picked up the Ryobi today. Interestingly, it has a mode selector that is very similar to the Ridged. Same 1,2,3,A settings. Of course, Ryobi, Ridged, and Milwaukee is all from the same company.
I actually have a ton of Milwaukee powertools but have never researched how to use their warranty. Never had a M18 break so just didn't care to research. How would I go about a warranty claim? Is it free Milwaukee paid shipping there and back for a tool still covered under warranty? I still have every receipt too.
The Rigid standard warranty is 3 years, and if you send in the required info within 90 days of purchase, you will get their lifetime warranty. Got their 1/2 compact unit.
@@markb4656 Thank you. That is very useful. Just so everyone knows it is only available if the rigid tools or products were purchased from home depot. For the lifetime warranty.
@@henri6595 Yes, it's free shipping to Milwaukee and then back to you. Just go on Milwaukee's website and click on support and then click on eService Tool Repair. When you click on eService Tool Repair, you will have to register an account and then it will ask you all the info that's needed.
Here's the list of products reviewed. More details in the video description. Thank you!
DeWalt: amzn.to/3ayJ4g9
AC Delco: amzn.to/3nzWtbr
Ingersoll Rand: amzn.to/3rg59pF
Milwaukee: amzn.to/2WxKUWk
Ridgid: amzn.to/3h60iTm
I don't get it. How do you measure TORQUE ... in PSI ..? ... per square INCH ..?? What!?
It's just twisting force. Irrespective however many inches it's "across."
Even if it's legitimate, it's not intuitive. Can we please stick to lb-ft ..?
In fact, when I asked AI:
_Can electric impact wrench measure torque in PSI ..?_
...and it said:
_Electric impact wrenches measure torque in Newton meters (Nm), not PSI._
So how the heck is this supposed to make sense on an intuitive level !?
It's harder to trust online reviews now, which is why we need channels like this.
True story
Thanks!
Project Farm has a reputation of doing this well, which in turn is why I'm watching.
There's plenty of youtube shills around and some tests can be faked (not saying they are).
Agreed!
@Cortez Using fake reviews is fraud.
This channel is what Consumer Reports promised to be. Unlike CR, this channel actually delivers.
Thank you!
I wholeheartedly agree.
They got caught selling good ratings to the highest bidder.
@Incog Nito Consumer Reports has been selling car reviews for over a decade at this point. They consistently give high ratings to certain car manufacturers.
@@TehButterflyEffect Absolutely untrue. You are confusing 'Consumer Reports' with the other fake review brands 'Consumer Guide', 'Consumer Review' or any name that sounds like Consumer Reports. Over the decades many fakes have been created by the manufacturers to confuse and obfuscate the truth. The real one never sells anything, they buy all of the products (including cars) without anyone knowing who they are, meaning just a regular consumer buying a product. No advertising EVER and never any involvement from manufacturers. The car surveys are massive with thousands of members of the Consumers Union providing their results. Outliers are thrown out and the results are quite scientific.
Of course if you like some brand that does poorly in their results I can not help with that. I suggest a change of loyalty in that case.
You should do a "Best of the year". A list of all the winner products.
Great recommendation! Thank you
I bet Milwaukee is up there for sure
Best comment of the year for this channel 👍
Do an all-time best for everything you have tested! That would then become my Bible for purchases!
And compare them! Even when it doesn't make any sense 😂😂😂
Project Farm: WERE GONNA TEST THAT
manufacturer: starts sweating nervously . . .
LOL
Milwaukee: we got this! Lol
One thing they cannot complain about: fairness and being an unbiased review.
by far one of the best comments!!!!! so true
In some cases, mfr gets on the phone and calls his accountant about the liquidation process.
You can’t even imagine how much money you have saved for those who carefully watch your reviews!
The only problem is if you buy the best tool for everything the battery will be the problem because of all the different charges
Very true! I've even switched my oil brand after watching his oil challenge.
@@tjboylan20 I have a ton of DEWALT batteries because 3 of the 5 tools I have have shit the bed.
Only 1 of 4 Milwaukee’s have died on me and that’s because I dropped it 150ft.. and it still worked for another year.
Easy for me to never buy another yellow tool.
@@kc510 I accidentally ended up with Ridgid tools. I've been happy with them and P Farm has confirmed that they are a good choice.
@@l00nybin yep, loving that walmart full synthetic 5w30.
Online ratings keep getting more and more useless, which is why we need channels like this.
Thank you very much!
Many are fake or paid reviews. Amazon is turning in to a cesspool of chinese made garbage with fake 5 stars.
I buy something from Amazon then they start sending other stuff for free if you give them 5 stars
@@jeff59rt whhhaaatttt??????
@@jeff59rt do they ask you to do that somehow?
As someone who isn’t really into sports these videos have become my outlet for rooting for a team and hoping they win
Thanks! Glad you enjoy!
Lol
Ingersoll Rand seems like they are taking advantage of their name and just up marking bad quality tools it also happened on another one if his videos
Theyve been in the decline for a while unfortunately
I was thinking the same thing.
Great feedback. I was expecting great things from IR. I've used their pneumatic tools for years
They need to stick with what they good at, air tools
@@ProjectFarm my dad had an IR 231c for years and I used it for years as well... it was great... but it seems when the electric game got introduced IR couldn’t adapt as quickly
Id like to see you do a paper towel comparison. Paper towels are important in the shop. Do mechanic towels work better than Bounty?
Great suggestion! Thank you.
under rated comment
This is a very good idea.
Bounty is going to win, I also put it on top of my Ridgid vacuum filter it saves me some work and money.
Milwaukee branded paper towel in 3, 2, 1... introducing “Absorbzall”
Can we get an accuracy test of different torque wrenches as well as torque sticks?
Great suggestion!
I second the torque sticks. Also interested in how accurate air pressure “tire pressure” testers are
He did a torque wrench test a while back, and it seemed like the icon brand from harbor freight was the beas bang for the buck. It was even more accurate than snap on.
@@russellullyatt1153 I bought one of the cheap 12v tire pumps and the gauge on it was off by 15% or so.
@@russellullyatt1153 I second the motion for tyre pressure inflators/guages.
I'd love to see a revisit of this. Milwaukee and Makita in particular have come out with new models for sub-compact impact wrenches and Ridgid's wrench has supposedly gotten more compact with more power. I'd also love to see how brands like Ryobi, Craftsman, and Kobalt hold up.
Thanks for the suggestion.
I've had a Porter Cable 20V for a few years that I love. Would like to see this added to see how it stacks up.
Also Snap-On and Matco!
ya re do this topic. definitely add the budget brands
I love when he's going over the specs and says, "we're gonna test that."
Thank you very much!
I want a tee shirt that says that...
@@kameljoe21 Chinese advert coming up
...I felt that
You know it defiantly makes companies nervous about their claims. If it says can drop it from 10ft high, PF will drop it from 10ft high. You dont makes a claim that PF wont test. Great channel as always
Absolutely love when you say , “AND WE’RE GONNA TEST THAT!”
Thanks!
Never gets old hearing it for me. Makes me smile every time. Iconic by now.
I *really* appreciate your editing style. No filler, it's whittled down to pure action!
I appreciate that!
Honestly you hit it right on the head. This channel is all business. No flash needed
Main reason I watch this channel honestly
No BS straight to the point!
Girlfriend says i love you, me: we are gonna test that 😂
"So I've gathered the least expensive ring, a standard price gemstone ring and a high priced luxury diamond ring to put it to the test. So first off we..."
LOL
I've got to know how this works out for you
@@Adamk24 To be impartial, wouldn't you need 3 identical girlfriends?
@@greendryerlint "nearly" identical
I’ve had the Milwaukee for about 3 years now and it’s been a great impact. There is a noticeable power difference between the 2 and 4 amp hour batteries
Thanks for the feedback.
What sockets fit the 3/8 impact
@@marquis2428= plenty SAE or MM; Kobalt on the low end, Astro on the upper end
@@marquis2428 3/8" drive ones...
@@marquis2428 technically anything, so long as it uses an adapter or fits 3/8
Project farm - "driven to outperform, we're gonna test that!"
Milwaukee- "bring it..."
Thanks for watching!
Milwaukee are glass cannon tools. The perform well and feel good but they will break easy. Like BMWs, Range Rovers, etc.
@@TehKaiser I disagree, we use and abused milwaukee stuff at work and have had few failures. Ever used a Sawzall in muddy water? How about an impact and battery that have been sitting out in -20*f all night, or dropped an impact from 35 ft into some grass (oops), anyway, with as few failures I've seen and all the abuse we put through our tools I'm pretty confident whenever I pick up a red tool.
@@TehKaiser Milwaukee tools are tough as nails man. I work in a swing stage some times and I have NOTHING but red tools for a reason. I dropped an m18 impact (my bit broke and I basically had all my weight into it and it crushed my hand and fell) from 6 stories in the air, it smacked a sidewalk and slammed into the building. I was scared, but it was fine. The battery no longer shows how full it is, but it works. A buddy dropped a 25ft magnetic tape measure from 12 stories, landed on pavement, left a hole big enough for the table to sit into, it still works just fine. We abuse these tools, even my personal tools and not only have they impressed me, but they've made me into a purist. Until another brand makes a tool worth switching for, ill pay for red everytime.
@@TehKaiser The hell you talking about? We beat the piss out of ours installing solar panels on hot roofs. NEVER any issues.
When can we get a shirt that says "WE'RE GONNA TEST THAT!" With a caricature of you holding an impact drill???
Great suggestion!
@@ProjectFarm Instead if you holding a drill (a shirt with your face on it doesn't feel like it's your thing) perhaps the design has the tip of a pen pointing at a warranty or claim of some kind?
@@Leron... I'm waiting for the "Which pen points the best?" test 🤣
Someone get this guy an Avatar.
by the way the merch link in the description isn't clickable. you need to add in front to make it clickable
Me: sees how Milwaukee performs in these videos
Me: looks at my Ryobi collection
Ryobi: =c
Me: (pats tools) "it's ok, we barely do any tough work anyway!"
Ryobi: c=
lol Thanks for sharing.
@@ProjectFarm Video Idea- Multi tool comparison... cheap $20 multi tools VS $125 Leatherman multi tools
@@ProjectFarm video idea old corded tools from 70s 80s compared to the new models today
I feel the same way when they do video reviews of ar style rifles & they pick on my PSA babies. We just watch till the bad man goes away. Lol
I have a Ryobi impact driver and it was pretty shit, says it has 270Nm of maximum torque but it struggled to remove wheel nuts torqued to 115Nm and couldn't remove my transmission drain nut when it was brand new right out of the box. It was heavy too. Just bought the M12 Milwaukee set (3/8 Fuel impact, 3/8 Fuel ratchet, tyre inflator, 2 and 4 Ah batteries and charger for AU$644) yesterday, looking forward to using it more in the future
I bought a Milwaukee after watching this review. I was not disappointed. My kit came with 2a & 6a batteries, the 6a really makes a huge difference to it's torque capabilities. Keep up the good work
Thanks, will do! Thanks for the feedback.
It's not 2A or 6A, its 2Ah or 6Ah. Both have the same Power. In DC devices it's still P=U*I, the Volts and Amps in both batteries are the same. But the 6 Ah battery last longer.
@@MaxFitz-Gibbon the terminology is irrelevant. Your opinion is flawed. Due to the characteristics of lithium ion batteries, the larger battery gives more torque for longer. I know because I have the tool.
@@MaxFitz-Gibbonakshually 👆🤓
@@MaxFitz-Gibbon bigger battery goes harder
Please keep testing tools, manufactures keep claiming stuff and we need to test those claims. 💪🏼
Great point!
Ok can we just appreciate the fact that this man not only spends all of his time and money on making these fantastic videos for us, but also finds time to listen to and respond to so many comments? These are the footsteps more channels need to follow in. Keep up the amazing work!
Thanks, will do!
The amount of editing he does is staggering. So many cuts, really makes the video snappy and informative.
I'm a big long time fan of this channel. But come on fellas, with a million and a half subscribers this is a business at this point.
I really do appreciate his reviews but as far as spending the money he actually makes money I think this channel is worth somewhere around two or $3 million lol. It’s not charity work but honestly he deserves whatever he gets.
@@markzanetti6228
An honest business.
I think you should also give a Pinocchio award to the tool that didn't reach any of its claims.
That would be funny
I second this, but then he might get into hot water with some brands and then he'd have to deal with lawyers.
Thanks for the feedback.
@@urielcantarero4965 The video tape of his test would inform all lawyers of nothing here
The manufacturers probably use other methods besides PF to test those claims
I’ve got the Ridgid stubby and love it. With the 4ah it’s killer. Good deals and amazing warranty too
Thanks for the feedback.
I just wish Rigid was more consistent with Its quality. Milwaukee is nearly always a top finisher, DeWalt is usually good, some times average. (Things change though)
Inconsistency is why these reviews are invaluable.
Which one to Rigid or Milwaukee, Need to work on my truck.
Hey man, it's been a really long time since I've left a comment, but I just wanted to say I'm so happy for you for making it so far with your channel. You have not changed a BIT since you started, and that's amazing. You provide a ton of information and value for so many people. Keep being awesome.
Hey, thanks!
The “250 pounds of nut-busting torque” gave me a chuckle
Who doesn't love to bust a nut? 🤣
Same😁
I once dated a woman with that feature. Unfortunately, she was a bit of a ball-breaker
"And we're gonna test that" 😂
Anyone else chuckle as he said “Nut busting torque”
🤭🤭🤭🤭🤭
My ex-wife had plenty of nut-busting torque.
Not more than my girlfriend
IDK sound like he talking about my wrist. 😆
😏
Would love to see this test again comparing the newer brushless models vs old, missing Ryobi, and also a short drop test. Lot of the impacts that are more enthusiast quality usually pickup some heavy use damage over time. Milwaukee and DeWalt are seen at a lot of construction sites for a reason.
I know who the king of county is, but you're definitely the king of product testing! Great video! Huge thumbs up.
Wow, thanks!
Whom might that be sir?
You should check out Chris fix and Rat Rod Bob
You must be taking about George Strait!!!
My favorite part is when he says, "we're gonna test that"
Or “that’s a lot of damage!”
Glad to hear!
Project Farm is one of the channels that has earned the right to have every ad play fully so he gets every cent per view.
Thanks for watching!
Couldn’t agree more. I do the same!
Adblock. No ads.
I read through the comments while the ads play lol
@@iamtheoffenderofall I turned off my Adblock specifically for Project Farm.
I love how you get right to the info and don't waste the viewers time. Keep it up, very valuable information.
Thanks, will do!
Dear god, ingersol are utterly useless and expensive. Again...
@David Klein Yes they should stick with pneumatic stuff
Their pneumatic tools are second to none.
This is what happens when you slap you brand on a CHEAP chinesse product. I mean, almost all of the tools are Chinesse, there is nothing wrong with it. But you need to pick a good quality one or design yourself and ask a factory to produce it .... IR = go for the cheap one
They still make the best air powered impact guns though.
Rhight! It's so upsetting seeing just how bad some of the tools and products perform, thank you PF
Perfect editing as usual... "We're gonna test that!"
Thanks again!
I watched one of the first few videos a couple weeks ago, it was super informative as usual but it was great seeing the progress made by this channel.
This dude is literally straight up vibin.
Thank you very much!
What the hell does that even mean.
@@taylorkelly6145 "This dude is literally straight up vibin" translated:
This gentleman is, in fact, really calm/relaxed/chill/cool.
@@taylorkelly6145 😂😂😂
@@AllHailNannerpuss Thank you for the urban language translation.
Cheers
I was looking at the Ridgid 1/2 impact a couple weeks ago at Home Depot for $140, then saw that they had a combo deal offering the 1/2 impact AND the 3/8 impact for $170. Couldn't pass up a deal like that!
Nice! Thanks for sharing.
Best part of 2020? Finding this man's channel and reviews. 💯 😎👍🏼
Thank you very much!
Oh man, if you're new here, get binge watching. This channel is amazing
It is by far the best channel for tests. Before I buy anything I check with PF first to see if there was a test on them
Yo that red boi got the balls
Yes the Milwaukee does have decent performance and provides substantial torque considering it's compact size.
You already know 🤣
With the 6ah battery its nuts
Wassup Matt. Milwaukee FTW. I have the m12.
And the Milwaukee busts them nutz. All kinds of nutz.
The fact that Milwaukee is 12v and beats a 18v ridged is insane
Imagine being on the ring in a supercar being passed by a hatchback. There's usually always good reason.
I didnt see the voltage in the video and i didnt think you were correct about those 12v, but after looking it up... damn.
I still think Ridgid is great value for the price, both it and Milwaukee being very compact and yet the most powerful. Pretty neat that you can stuff so much in such a small package.
@@vavra222, 4:18 M12 model is 12V. OP is correct that Milwaukee is beating a compact impact with a sub-compact....
Exactly right. I would say throw the m18 3/8 up against the rigid in this video to get a fair comparison...but it’s a sub compact category. The m18 is over 6 inches in length. So all in all, once again, a great video comparison.
@@replynotificationsdisabled Top Gear VW golf gti
Proved to me that Milwaukee is worth the few extra bucks! Have the M12 ratchet and now just ordered the impact. Appreciate what you do!!
Thanks!
milwaukee is doing this on 12volts thats impressive..
You should see how it performs with a 6.0 AH battery. I love mine.
@@Joetechlincolns same here, I can pull both front wheels, calipers, and brackets off my truck, reinstall and still have 50-75% battery left
Milwaukee doesn't fuck around. I've demolished a couple of the 1/2" m18 fuel impacts and they even beat a couple of the older 3/4" electric impacts with ease.
Thanks for watching!
That is VERY true. Nice point! I am bought into their 18V line, but am definitely looking at adding some 12V tools in the near future!
Do a 1/2" impact next, including Makita and Ryobi
And harbor fright.
Yes
+1 I would like to see this one www.homedepot.com/p/RYOBI-ONE-18V-Cordless-3-Speed-1-2-in-Impact-Wrench-Kit-with-1-4-Ah-Battery-Charger-and-Bag-P261K/313581565
Thanks for the video idea.
I was literally just looking at high torque impacts saying to myself, "project farm should test these high torque impacts" (milwaukee, kobalt xtr, Rigid, Dewalt, etc. ) Great test on these subcompacts though! Hopefelly, the high torque test is soon to come. 👀
Milwaukee’s are the best Mac tools 1/2 is second best.
The Mac tools 1/2 gun is the same specs as the dewalt 3/4 inch gun but you don’t get the chemical resistant case on the dewalt and obviously it’s a 3/4 so most people would need a step down adaptor
@@X5XST4RK1L3R Makita and Ingersoll also
I have the Milwaukee mid torque 600 ft pounds. It does the job very well.
Project Farm confirmed NSA spy.
I just bought a ridgid 3/8, 1/2, 1 battery, and a charger all for $200 on sale at Home Depot. Normal price is $400 so I’d say I got a hell of a deal. Great comparison and just short of Milwaukee makes me happy.
I got a similar deal with their compact circular saw, drill, 2 batteries and charger. If you catch em at the right time home depot has some incredible deals at least with ridgid tools
Can we do a “Are torque sticks accurate” video and “Best drill/impact bits” because WERE GONNA TEST THAT
Great suggestion! Thank you!
Best drill/impact bit videos already exist on his channel
@@alex_thecarguy Not torque sticks, just bits were tested here.
@@dc5723 I didn't say torque sticks
I’d like to see a similar comparison of 1/2” impact wrenches from these companies plus the new Kobalt XTR line from Lowe’s and Earthquake from Harbor Freight. Great stuff!
Thanks for the suggestion.
@@ProjectFarm I second that
That's where I was planning g to drive to Lowes.
Same - just picked up the Ryobi 600 ft lb impact for $99. Would love to see how it compares.
I'd also love to see the HF Earthquake tested against any of them. Even a video with just an update adding it in.
"We're going to test that" - The crowd cheers!
_(trademark signature saying)_
Thank you!!
Just found out that you can buy t-shirts that say this on his website if you're interested (I am)
@@user-njyzcip Thanks! Going to buy one :) project-farm.com/
Purchased!
Pf: “the highest costs over 300 dollars”
Me: Milwaukee fs
It's impressive how well Milwaukee did, all while utilizing a smaller battery than the competition.
There's a reason all my battery tools are Will-fawk-ye. Consistently top 3 in almost every comparison except price on everything I buy. Plus they just have good design - the yard tools (still waiting on a lawnmower, but I digress) with the quick-lok system just makes trimming my trees and hedges, and other yardwork a breeze, and storage is now 1/4 of the space it used to take up with gas tools, because most of the tools are just a detachable head that you swap out. My drills, impacts, circular saws, tablesaws, oscillating tools, miter saws, rotary hammer, and I'm sure I'm forgetting a few all use the M18 batteries, and the 12Ah ones last me most of the day regardless of the tool I'm using. My "home tools" use the M12 batteries (along with my heated winter gear), I have the headlamp and heated gloves that use their USB rechargeable batteries, and I'm starting to look at their MX lineup as well, since I bought the powerbank "generator" and light tower that run on the MX batteries.
Of all the Milwaukee stuff I own, my only complaint is that the heated gloves are advertised as working gloves but they're light-duty at best. For over $200 I was expecting them to be way more durable than they are. Oh, and the miter saw stand's material supports are flimsier than I'd like.
Not a shill, just a tradesman who happens to love the brand.
Milwaukee and Makita usually skookum, can't go wrong. Buy once, cry once.
I agree I have the milwaukee and recently but the 4.0mah battery on it and it actually made a big different from the 2.0mah battery power, speed and of course battery life wise
But it cost the most and second heaviest
@@netsai61 heavy doesn't bother me - I work with far heavier tools. What matters to me is that I only have to carry one spare battery, or don't have to run back and forth to my charger all day long.
I think you need to sell boxer shorts with your catch phrase “we’re gonna test that” printed on them.
Or nut busting torque?
@Scott Duffy 200 pounds of nut busting torque, on the back.
@Scott Duffy Either one, consumer's choice for those so inclined. Not that there's anything wrong with that.
I think "We're gonna test that" would be a good slogan for a condom company. "Nut busting torque" would make for the lonely man's arm tattoo.
I have this exact Ingersoll Rand impact. I love it, and it’s lasted years of being dropped and over used in high torque use settings (since as we can see, it’s not the strongest impact). I’m probably going to try a new brand when it bites the dust so these tests help.
Thanks for the feedback.
I don't need one, but sure as hell I am gonna watch the whole video. Thanks
Thanks for watching!
Your tests are well thought out, and your reviews are unbiased. I am really grateful for your videos. You have become the gold standard for real world testing. Thank you.
Thank you very much!
I'd like to see Makita in a test like this, they have a subcompact line too.
search it on here there is many tests like this with Makita up against these brands and even the new Ryobi HP+ line,,,,,but I can tell you the outcome from having watched them many times,,,,,,the makita is very simlar priced to the dewalt, millwaukee in that range,,,the makita is about the same level in power and run time as the dewalt and rigid ,,,,,bottom line though is if you want the best just get the millwauke and be done,,,,,,not to sound like a fan boy but millwaukee has been on the war path to crush the competition it seems because the pretty much do in every area tested.
the 1/2 inch is a good one as well as the 3/8th's impact shown in the video.
Thanks for the video idea.
I just got a Ryobi 18v lithium 3/8 compact brushless impact. has 160 ft/lbs which isnt bad for a compact impact. Was hoping to see Ryobi in there
There needs to be an addendum video with Makita and Bosch!
I recently bought the M12 stubby. I’ve changed struts, tie rods, bearings, rotors, brakes, cv axle and ball joint. It has been successful with everything I’ve throw at it with the exception of a stuck bolt on a suspension part. One of the best car tools I’ve ever purchased. Saves so much straining with a ratchet.
Thanks for sharing.
So it’s not necessary to buy a 1/2” m18 high torque impact? I need a impact for diying car maintenance
@@Danielxperez14 I’m not a mechanic. Just a diy guy working on my own cars. I’m sure some will say more torque is better. The M12 has been enough for me.
@@Danielxperez14get an m18 high torque for over 250 lb tq . Like the well rusted old bolts and muts. Maybe acle bolts. Etc.
@@subver6787 yea I’ll probably get that one whenever I need it, I ended up getting the 3/8 stubby and so far it’s been great taking lug nuts off of my canams and other things, not much rust where I’m from(Cali)
Man, that's twice that Ingersoll Rand let us down :(
I guess they should stick to air tools.
No need to even get back into the air tool game considering everything is cordless now.
@@QuantumMind88 That's also a good point! I work at a shop where we have access to high pressure air, so it can be beneficial to take advantage of it.
But no doubt. Battery is better in nearly every way (besides maybe fluid resistance)
@@jacobharryman822 Look at the heat all of the tools produced. Some hot enough to boil water. Air tools do not get hot and are not effected by environmental contaminates. Cordless is great but for severe duty cycle air is still amazing.
We had 3hp air grinders at may last job they could run endlessly. The harder you worked them the colder they got to the point that frost would form around the exhaust. When we did the same job with electric grinders we would have to use 2 so one could cool while the other was in use.
@@geoffmooregm the heat energy is lost at your air compressor
@@geoffmooregm try that in winter the air tool just freeze and become useless
Battery impact are so much practical and fast in the road truck no need to start the engine for the compressor wait till its full,unroll the air hose and pray it don't freeze pefore you are done
I was in harbor freight the other day and a guy was watching project farm on his phone all loud, trying to decide what he wanted to get lol.
Thanks for sharing!
Could you do something with fishing line? Strength test, visual test in different conditions, cut resistance, how easy to tie a knot with it i guess lol just shooting one out there
Thanks for the video idea.
I'm not suprised the Milwaukee stubby did so well. I use mine daily, that thing is a power house for its size. Probably my favorite tool for how light and powerful it is.
Thanks for the feedback.
4:25 “The Milwaukee has 250 ft/lbs of nut-busting torque” 😂
I lost it at that part
Nut busting is the best
I literally came to the comments section for that sole reason
My girlfriend has more.
@@milesparris4045 “we’re going to test that”
What would you do if you lost your pointing pen? I feel like its a part of the channel lol
lol. I've misplaced it a couple of times and I won't film without it.
@@ProjectFarm "High end pens? Let's test that!"
I think a pen comparison video should be on the horizon...
You are the first and only channel I will ever support financially. Thank you!
I appreciate it!
Money well spent. We should all pay him as our product consultant. Hes probably the most qualified for the position! 👍
I know Ridgid isn't the best out there but they make good tools for the money. The thing I like most about them though is that if you buy the kits from Home Depot you can sign up for Ridgids LSA, which will pretty much let you bring it back to the store for a new one if it ever breaks, for life.
Thanks for the feedback.
You're the best "comparison channel" on YT. Thanks!
Thank you very much!
Milwaukee was expected.
Ridgid was impressive.
Thank you very much!
Milwaukee, Ridgid and Ryobi are all owned by the same parent company TTI.
@@KonaPony That doesn't mean that all tools will be equal. Dewalt Black and Decker power tools are both owned by SBD that doesn't mean they're the same quality.
Surprised by the Dewalt fail here.
@@KonaPony personally, I've had Ryobi for years. I like them.
You should do a Rotary/“Dremel” tool comparison. Or you could do a comparison of the different brands of cutting disks. Have a merry Christmas.
Thanks for the video idea. Merry Christmas!
@@ProjectFarm I second this. My partner is getting into some hobbies that might require a "Dremel" tool and your channel has done the best work I've seen for practical reviews.
That Milwaukee compact is the best power tool I have ever purchased. Absolutely worth the extra cash!
Thanks for sharing.
You should make a little podium for the winning tools to stand on!
Thanks for the suggestion!
@@ProjectFarm or a badge considering the varying sides
It would have been amazing to see snap on loose to Milwaukee again.
I work with people that have the snap-on one and my Forman ended up selling his snap-on and getting the milwaukee 12v stubby like mine. Milwaukee make the snap-on look like that ac delco.
Great suggestion! Thank you.
@@logan9334 snap on does NOT make good power tools though, none of those expensive brands make tools any better than DeWalt does
@@getskared seems like all tool truck brands lack in the electric sector. I'm still a milwaukee fan boy though because they don't alter their battery form factor frequently
@@logan9334 I have all Ridgid gen4x at home and they just won't die! I do love Milwaukee though, I am a Steamfitter by trade so we beat the hell out of our tools and both of those brands far outshine any DeWalts or any other brands we end up with. Also we use a lot of Wright Open end wrenches and they're freakin tough
EDIT: Per request here are the rough torque values compared to an old school air impact wrench assuming that's a 3/4" bolt:
Milwaukee: 227ft-lbs, Rigid: 195ft-lbs, DeWalt: 113 ft-lbs, IR: 74ft-lbs, ACDelco: 31ft-lbs
7:00 Interesting, we basically the same set up we're running to test torque on larger impacts. Very cool!
Except he's just showing PSI, which means what?
Thank you!
@@ItsMrAssholeToYou @torquetestchannel can you do the math since you have all this data?
@@MustangAficionado Done
Thank you yet again for a great review. I find it incredible that 2 of the 5 brands tested sell a product that is not able to do the most basic tasks adequately.
You are welcome! Thanks for the feedback.
I have the Milwaukee. It is highly impressive. Very small and packs a huge punch. Just rebuilt my entire steering and front/rear suspension on my 96 ram 3500 dually with this tool. Takes lug nuts off easily and it's only a 12v 3/8
Thanks for sharing.
Man I’m looking at the same job!
Getting a Red Head Steering gear box and need to pull the Steering Vacuum/Pump housing to replace O-Rings. New hoses all around since it’s all original on the truck.
98 Ram 3500 Dually. Any tips man, did you end up using a breaker bar or was the Milwaukee your go to for any bolts?
Gonna order a pitman arm puller but otherwise these Impacts are what I’ve been researching to make my life a bit easier. I’m a Dewalt guy but many folks I came up working with in the maintenance shop had either Milwaukee, Mac (Which is basically Dewalt), or Snap-On.
I am old enough to remember a time that IR was a high end brand, not just overpriced junk.
Ditto.. I still use daily one of the early composite body 1/2" drive air impacts I bought in the mid 90's. The end of the anvil is broken off so it doesn't retain sockets, the fwd & rev buttons popped out a few years back so I change directions using a pocket screwdriver on the internals but doggone it it just keep works working and has never been sent off for repair. It's like me... old, worn out and ought to be retired but still doing the job! 😉
me too, i didnt know it was sold out to china junk
Thanks for the feedback.
I learned after buying a small sander and it overheated and became useless during its first job.
@@billman6364 they just license the battery powered tools compressors and air impacts are still.good
I've been looking at 3/8 impacts after the Precision Transmission channel got one. Exactly the video I needed! Thanks!
Thank you very much!
Thank you very much for all of your efforts, you are very much appreciated. Your accuracy, diligence and commitment to each project is admirable!
You are very welcome
Test 1/2 in impact guns. Do the hydraulic ones too!
Great video idea!
Ridgid outperforming Dewalt! Did not see that one coming. Glad to see I can expand my Ridgid tool collection 💕🤗😸👍
Bought the 5 piece set from HD two years back, I have yet to make them breathe hard , only drawback is they are a bit hefty but you're getting a free workout.
Well, the 18V Rigid outperformed the 12V Dewalt, anyway... The Rigid SHOULD have beat everyone since it was the only 18V impact wrench in the lineup. The fact that the 12V Milwaukee beat the 18V Rigid...
@@l00nybin Yeah, throw a milwaukee 18V impact wrench in there (mid or high torque) and it would annihilate the rigid
@@ZILLA.... it's also bigger, though. Does the M18 Fuel line even have a compact impact wrench? I've only seen the big one.
@@l00nybin I have the 1/2" M18 mid torque wrench (450 ft lbs tightening and 600 ft lbs busting) and it's much easier to handle than the massive high torque one (insane 1400 ft lbs busting). I guess it's not compact though (maybe sub compact)
Just wanted to say thank you. I've been a fan since the seafoam test days and I'm sure it's not the first time somebody has told you that your channel is a service to the community.
You are welcome!
I use that Milwaukee stubby every day at work. It's a beast!
Thanks for sharing!
Mine is amazing! Would definitely recommend it!
Is this the appetizer to the long awaited 1/2” cordless impact test?
Yes it is. Which brands would you like tested? Thank you very much!
@@ProjectFarm Milwaukee, Snap-on, Ryobi, Dewalt, IR, Makita.
@@ProjectFarm I would like to see both sizes of the Ridgid 1/2 impact tested. They make a 4 mode and bigger 6 mode impact. I have the 4 mode and it is tough but not 20 year old rusted exhaust bolts tough lol
@@ProjectFarm Makita, for sure! (Current company default choice)
Makita!!!
When he says what a product can output. He says what it is and then laughs in its face and says we’ll test that hahaha lmao
Great job on this review, as always. Another consideration when purchasing is Ridgid's lifetime service warranty that also includes the batteries (providing the tools and batteries are registered after purchase) I recently had one of my 18v batteries fail from my drill/driver combo and Ridgid replaced it for free. I think they are the only brand that offers this coverage.
Thank you very much!
One caveat to their Lifetime Service Agreement (LSA) regarding the chargers/batteries is, they have to be purchased as a combo with a tool in order to be covered. A charger/battery purchased separately doesn't qualify for the LSA.
@@21psd All batteries are covered now. They changed it.
@@redman3741 that's great news, thanks. I see they now finally have a 3/8" 18V Ratchet. My next purchase whenever they're available.
Can you do video comparing floor jacks. Thank you 🙏
Great suggestion! Thank you.
I hit like before the video even starts. That’s confidence in a nutshell.
Thanks so much!
I do the same. I know it will be a quality review.
No doubt and totally agree!!!!
Test electric snow blowers! One stage vs two stage! EGO has a brand new one out. They claim it is equivalent to gas ones. I would love to hear you say "we're going to test that"!
Well, it's simple physics. They can't work unless you're lugging around a 220V extension cord or a pallet of batteries.
I don’t know, the battery powered chainsaws certainly kept up with the gas equivalent!
Thanks for the suggestion.
Its super cool to see how project farms testing has gotten more fair and in my oppionion scientific over the years.
In one test he torqued everything down to 100 ft/lb and got wildly different results out of the impacts like with the dewalt. One nut got delt with quickly. The other was an imoveable object. Just goes to show how torque readings may not actually tell you how tight something is. From what i understand lubricating the bolts and removeing 25-33% of the torque (i most commonly hear 30%) since the lubricant gives you a more accurate and even stretch but this means that you can easily overtorque something and cause plastic deformation.
Im pretty sure there is also some more scientific system where you torque it to a certain spec using a torque meter and then tighten it down further by rotating it a certain number of degrees. I believe this is because it becomes more and more difficult to get an accurate reading as the bolt stretches. (Ex: torque down to 60 ft/lb then rotate an aditional 30°) i believe this is what the manual tells you to do on some cars when torqing down the cylinder head. (But do not quote me or take any of this as fact im just a nerd that misremebers stuff not an engineer)
I can’t understand why the CEO of AC Delco thought making a drill was a good idea.
because $$$
AC Delco licenses their name for non-automotive products. They don't control the quality, they just cash the check.
@@1djbecker I figured that, but I’m considerably less likely to buy ac delco for my next part, knowing their name means so little to them they’d sell it to any cheap trinket willing to pay for the right.
@Rocket Pliance ACDelco licenses their name to Mobiletron for tools. They don't have anything to do with the design or quality control.
'Durofix', who nominally imported this tool, is a five-ish person U.S. distribution center in Rancho Cucamonga. Most of their operation appears to be the accounting of importing products and paying the name license fees.
Masterforce a house brand name for Menards. Masterforce hand tools used to be sourced from the top-notch suppliers, but they have switched away from that. Menards might contract with Mobiletron/Durofix to have their 'Masterforce' name printed on some generic tools, but there doesn't appear to be any other connection.
Everyone already knows how spicy the fuel is 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️
lol. Nice!
@@ProjectFarm Long time wrench spinner here. Everyone I know in the mechanical trade rid themselves of their snapon/bosch/makita electronics and almost all exclusively run M12 tools.
@@MrAPCProductions True dat, brother ! I have em all. 'Cept the monster 1/2 impact. Hope they can make it a bit smaller framed . Snapperhead is in big trouble, don't know how they hang on, old dinosaurs like me have everything, and Snappy quality is being challenged on Amazon every day.
Milwaukee socket sets are expensive but definitely high quality.
@@sampantiliano they're nothing to write home about. Sunex is probably the best for the money and set options
I’m so happy to see ridgid do so well. I’ve always loved their tools. I’ve had a set of cordless impact and drills from them since 2013 and they still operate like new. I’ve been building furniture and cabinets with them, as well as working on the road installing tubs and showers and I gotta say I’ve more than got my money back.
Great to hear!
Don’t tell Milwaukee fanboys that. They’ll tell you that Rigid tools are made with playdough and glitter and that’s their red tools were forged in the fires of mount doom.
@@narlycharley Lmfao so true lol
I think the one area where the Rigid may have been an unfair comparison in this review is that it is an 18V platform that also weighs close to a pound more than the Dewalt. Don’t get me wrong, the Ridgid for the money is a great buy! I just think it is impressive that the Dewalt was the second cheapest and also the 2nd best performing 12volt system, only to the Milwaukee costing 2x as much. For such a lightweight tiny thing, that’s where the Dewalt seemed to be a Best Buy. If weight isn’t a concern, then the Ridgid takes too honors for best bang for the buck. It seems like the Dewalt DCF890 may have been a better comparison to that Ridgid model.
All in all, though, this has still become one my absolute favorite testing channels. I have my notifications set for when every new video comes out!
I bought the Ridgid. It's pretty awesome and powerful. Love the auto setting.
Nice! Thanks for sharing.
Glad to see Rigid made the line up this time! All of my power tools are Rigid and I swear by them!
Thanks for sharing.
@@ProjectFarm Also something important to point out is that the Ridgid has a lifetime service agreement for free battery replacement and tool repair when you register them. I have used Ridgid now for 11 years and had several batteries replaced for free, and no tool failure as yet but comforting to know that there will be free repair.
I love mine as well. I like the colors, the price, the quality, the feel. Just everything about them. Oh ya, and lifetime guarantee. Who else does that?
The Ridgid tool really exceeded my expectations, based on my previous experience with other Ridgid tools. I was impressed.
I like rigid is an american version of aeg i love their tools
Your seemingly unscientific common sense testing is actually very scientific without the egg head or test tubes. Your relentless pursuit for true performance comparisons is commendable, don't change your format or your principles. You have my and others respect. Happy xmas.
Thanks! Merry Christmas!
All my battery tools are ridgid and nothing has let me down yet.
Thanks for sharing.
6 year old dewalt and batteries are perfect.
@@meax2499 how do you like it so far?
@@helpallofem4428 cant knock that lifetime service agreement as long as you get all the paperwork done
Used DeWalt for many years on five separate work trucks before switching to all Ridgid. Lifetime warranty when you register and it has paid dividends with the batteries after 4 - 5 years. They have held up great getting abused by employees on a daily basis.
I'm in the market for a new impact wrench. Unfortunately, I'm already heavily invested in batteries for Dewalt and their tools. But I'm not impressed with the results for this particular tool. Albeit, that oddball Milwaukee battery may justify a slight deviation from the norm, without feeling the need for a total tool conversion. Until my OCD really kicks in.
Thanks for the awesome content!
You are welcome!
The DeWalt 12 volt 1/2" impact actually outperforms the Milwaukee M12 according to the torque test channel. Some people find the kit (tool battery and charger) on sale for $99. Around Father's Day or around Black Friday are the best deals.
DeWalt is the midrange, Milwaukee is High-end
what brand do pros use?
@@MrDaldagnuur DeWalt had always been reliable and good for a great price, but best brands are usually the most expensive
Thanks for the feedback.
@Zachary P In my opinion, Ryobi is not midrange... I'd Put Ryobi/Ridgid as entry-level/DIYer. then Dewalt/Milwaukee as midrange. lastly, if you're in the long haul, Makita. This is for electric power tools.
Milwaukee is a very solid brand, the extra money gets you extra features and reliability in nearly every case. Dewalt gives the impression that 20v is better than 18v, while using the same number of 18650 cells. Milwaukee 18v batteries achieve the same working and peak voltage as dewalt 20v batteries.
Dewalt and mac batteries interchange. Its helped me a great deal. Js
That's just marketing. "20v Max" or "M18 Fuel"
It's just a marketing strategy. Dewalt uses peak to show consumers a bigger number on the box. It's same strategy that Internet providers claim 100 Mb instead of 12.5 MB.
@@2tirefire79 Dewalt makes the mac impacts. Same company makes them both. Same exact tool. Tool truck one cost more.
@@CalebsCars my mac has rubber for drop protection and is supposed to be chemical resistant. It helps, especially on the Batteries. Im always dropping my half in impact because im a klutz.
Would have loved to see how the Ryobi and Makita performed in this group.
I just got the Ryobi compact 18v brushless 3/8 impact and I think its gonna be badass. It has 3 speeds also.
@@cashen7384 yeah, Ryobi has come a long way. Still not top end, but excellent for the price!
Thanks for the video idea.
I've been impressed with Ryobi so far. With both performance and of course price.
I picked up the Ryobi today. Interestingly, it has a mode selector that is very similar to the Ridged. Same 1,2,3,A settings. Of course, Ryobi, Ridged, and Milwaukee is all from the same company.
"Nut busting torque". Milwaukee marketing doesn't mess around.
He forgot to add that the Milwaukee also has the best best warranty at 5 years.
I actually have a ton of Milwaukee powertools but have never researched how to use their warranty. Never had a M18 break so just didn't care to research.
How would I go about a warranty claim? Is it free Milwaukee paid shipping there and back for a tool still covered under warranty? I still have every receipt too.
Great point!
The Rigid standard warranty is 3 years, and if you send in the required info within 90 days of purchase, you will get their lifetime warranty. Got their 1/2 compact unit.
@@markb4656 Thank you. That is very useful. Just so everyone knows it is only available if the rigid tools or products were purchased from home depot. For the lifetime warranty.
@@henri6595 Yes, it's free shipping to Milwaukee and then back to you. Just go on Milwaukee's website and click on support and then click on eService Tool Repair. When you click on eService Tool Repair, you will have to register an account and then it will ask you all the info that's needed.