One thing you missed... go try parking both in a parking garage and see which one you buy. Too many people buy a HUGE SUV without realizing they can be quite challenging to manage as a driver. In contrast and minivan is one of the easiest vehicles to manage.
Yes! I downsized from a Tahoe to a Traverse and it's much easier to park! Also we live in a rural area with one lane roads and so much easier to pass other vehicles. We have had to replace drivers side mirrors on 2 vehicles because of farmers huge ones hitting ours. No problem now with the lower and smaller Traverse mirrors.
Most families who buy SUVs are really looking for a minivan. 3rd row comfort, cargo space, practicality, reliability, etc. Who cares what others think! Embrace the American Dream and suburban family culture!
I have always wanted the answer to be SUV but vans are so much easier. If it isnt moving the family around, I can easily take all the seats oit/fold down and fit 15 sheets of 8x4 plywood in it
@@carbeastsmIf you need towing, then good for you. But if you need maximum space then a minivan is much better. All I care about is space, not towing anything other than a kayak trailer.
My kids grew up riding our 2007 Odyssey and its still going strong more appropriate for a family. Never understood why "soccer Mom's" were embarrassed to be seen as soccer Mom's.
I've lived in snowier places than most, and most people get along just fine with a 2wd car. A minivan with snow tires is better in snow than an SUV on all seasons anyway... The type of vehicle doesn't really matter compared to tires and driver experience. And some minivans are awd
Carnival. It's really useful for a lot of side businesses as it can double as a small work van when you take out the seats. Some contractors are getting it for this reason
@@SuperFitness12 it’s has a lot recalls and problems… I traded mine in for the Honda Pilot… Space and awd drive and reliability!! The is Kia was wonderful and interior design excellent and above the competition but I am not sure about reliability.. The Kia carnival potentially has a defect in its cyclinder design… It’s burn coolant…
After dealers markup and interest rates and taxes and fees your going be paying 15-20k extra which offsets any fuel efficiency in the current market over the life of loan for the Sienna… Honda and Kia wins…
@@jocelyntimothe6763 Resale value is 2-3k difference and dealers do not give you a fair price typically. You got to sell it by your self…Battery replacement cost comes in after 150k which could be 2500-5000k which again offset fuel savings .. It all offsets For eg: Grand Highlander limited hybrid total cost with current market interest rates, dealer marks up and other fees is 70k+ for a limited hybrid that cost 55k over the financing period… The fuel savings is red and not worth it vs a regular v6 when the cost to acquire is so high…
I’m driving my second Yukon xl. The first I sold when I reached 260,000 plus miles. I’m a nurse and have to get to work in icy/ snow conditions. The 4 wheel drive handles great even on the hills I have to drive on
I had a 2013 Town and County 5 or 6 yrs ago. Traded for a Tahoe. The 3rd row with a bench was awful for my teens. The Traverse I just got feels so much like that minivan on the inside that I have went for the door handle on the left side so many times 😂 it has almost just as much room as that van and so easy to clean up with the leather seats and Weather Tech mats 🙌 enjoying the better gas mileage too 18(Tahoe) Vs 23(Traverse). Also impressed with the AWD! Had to drive uphill on a muddy/grassy graveyard road this morning and it done great! Looking frd to seeing how it handles snow this winter.
Get the carnival! Also watch these two videos… “Why minivans are actually the best vehicle to buy” made by Scotty Kilmer, and “These stupid trucks are literally killing us” made by Not Just Bikes.
She doesn’t know she’s talking about anybody that knows how to drive snow no it doesn’t matter how big your vehicle is as long as you know how to drive in snow when you have good tires on your car that’s all you need. Front wheel drive is perfect. All-wheel-drive even better.
I got a minivan. I took out the middle row seats and the back row folds into the floor. A full size air mattress fits perfectly in the back and laying down on it now! You can't do that in most suvs.
With no doubts Minivans are the ultimate people haul, even more ultimate if you have little ones. But their performance is where they lose their appeal to SUVs (in my opinion). If you have to worry about Terrain and weather than SUVs makes more sense. I own a minivan and also live where occasionally snows, so far even with some tricky weather my van did fine and isn’t awd. To this moment, considering our stage of life with 2 little ones minivan has been pretty cool. Can’t say how many times the sliding doors were life saving hahah. Or Having in laws and my parents visiting at same time and being able to take everyone in the same car to go out is pretty fun! 6 adults and 2 kids (in car seats) with a double stroller in the back and rooms for more junk! Hahah can’t beat that 😂
You shouldn't have a problem driving a van anywhere in the USA. The only problem would be off-road. 99.9% of people do not need to ever go off-road. Also, SUVs aren't that great at handling snow, either. Barely better than a minivan
We went from a 2018 Traverse to a 21 Sienna...and I'm missing the trunk space SO MUCH. I really thought I was trading up for sliding doors and more kid-friendly/family options...but there isn't much difference that benefits us other than the sliding doors. The seats don't come out, we have car seats in the captains chairs, so we can't take advantage of their ability to fold for more cabin space.. Now I'm back in the market for an SUV. 😅
Good feedback. But what about the car being hybrid? If you put down the car seats the traverse still has a bigger trunk space? I'm surprised! Reliability also should count for something right, Toyota sienna should have less wear and tear over the course of it's life right?
@@publicius7024 It may not be in cubic feet technically (I haven't looked to see what the Sienna is stated as having) but for sure the configuration like she stated is vertical space vs flat space. It just doesn't work out to be as beneficial if it's vertical trunk space. After living with it for 2 years I'm so surprised about that because somehow I seriously thought I would have more space in the van vs the traverse.
@@gzhen123 So the Sienna being a hybrid is actually one point I forgot to mention and it IS a huge factor that would hurt to go away from. 35mpg is really nice! We have 4 kids, so it isn't often we would put the back seats down to compare cargo space between the two. I don't honestly know if we ever did when we had the traverse. I would assume it's pretty similar. From what I can tell, the traverse was a bit tighter between the seating rows than the sienna, but it's because it has more trunk space and vice versa.
@@kristenkaufman163 good to know. The resale value for sienna is also probably amazing compared to the traverse. I feel you can't go wrong with the sienna, but if u didn't need the 3rd row maybe it would be better for ur family's needs. Either way, grass is probably greener. Traverse looks more badass haha
Went through the same journey when our second child came this year. The car we NEEDED was a minivan, but we bought the car we WANTED with the 2023 Yukon XL AT4. It looks great and we love it! The comfort of the extra large interior space for the family to relax while on the road, the trunk space for the double stroller and backup supplies and the peace of mind of the 4WD in our climate. Of course, it comes down to price and what one can afford without stressing the budget. I acknowledge we are blessed and fortunate to have the opportunity to choose. If it wasn’t the Yukon, then it would have been the AWD Pacifica! Highly recommend if you go the van route!
Had a mini van (Kia carnival). Got the new Honda Pilot… Best suv ever… All the space and features and built like a tank… Honda Pilot Touring is the way to go… Looks like a Range Rover but reliable… The new boxy aggressive looks and full size adult 3rd row is a big win!! I am big 6’0 225 and I fit comfortably in the 3rd row !!
Yukon is not comparable since theprice is so far out of reach, most people shopping for minivan or SUVs around 30-50k budget would most likely look at Honda pilot, Toyota Highlander, Traverse, ford explorer, or other 3 row SUVs in that price range
As a car enthusiast, I would pick the minivan over the SUV. If I’m not towing something, I don’t need the SUV. I have a kid so a van is still better even if the SUV is better in snow. Yes it snows where I live and sometimes it’s a few feet at a time. I just like the sliding doors and lower load floor.
@@brian0410 most suvs weight heavier and have way better cabin protection, A ford fiesta is similar in safety to a kia carnival which is one of the safest minivans
@@carbeastsm I know that. But smaller cars would be safer if we didn’t have such large trucks and SUV’s on the road. It has become a race for who has a bigger vehicle for “safety” trucks aren’t safe, mini vans and SUV/crossovers are as well as wagons.
Minivans all day. I drive in the snow with my two wheel low clearance but for severe weather we take my husbands all wheel suv. It boggles the mind when people say minivans are so much uglier than suvs (none luxury). None of them are beautiful. Our Porsche 911..stunning!
What vehicle would you all recommend for having 5 kids ages 7, 6, 4, 19 months, and a newborn? We’d need 2 infant car seats and 3 boosters to fit inside the vehicle. Thanks!
I have 3 greyhounds and have a Forester. The older one has trouble jumping into the back. Previously had a Town & Country which had Sto&Go & a much lower floor. Reliability was terrible. I was in Detroit with the T & C during a blizzard & had no trouble in the van while I saw 4wd vehicles overturned & sliding all over the place. I didn't even get wheelspin!
SUV. Because I need it to tow a boat, and we drive in the mountains and last year I almost got my family stuck in the snow in a small fwd SUV. It would have been bad if I wasn't able to get out, we were far from people. My family loves the outdoors and mountains. Minivan just can't do it. Honda Pilot Trail trim :)
As a married man with 3 young kids, I started with an SUV, then went to a minivan. I will not be going back to an SUV, at least until my kids are much older.
@@99SigP same here, although I rented both a minivan (Chrysler town and country, dodge grand caravan) and an SUV (2017 ford expedition). The suv has travel comfort for long distances as a rental car, BUT AWFUL gas mileage on city driving,, so bad nearly $85 per gas fill up. So in the end after trying both types, I bought the minivan (14 Chrysler town and country).
I have a 2013 Dodge Grand Caravan SXT and I love it for the space for my three children. However, I will say if you're going with a minivan you should go for one with tv's, power lift gate, auto sliding doors, and a good dash entertainment system. My van has none of those unfortunately.
The Yukon can be fuel efficient if you get the 3.0 Duramax. Its the best SUV engine by far with great fuel efficiency, smoothness, and lots of torque for towing. Plus it doesn’t have the V8 lifter problems like the 5.3 & 6.2.
Having a large diesel engine for short drives around town does not take advantage of diesel’s stronghold: efficient long distance cruising. Also diesel needs time to warm up to operating temperature in cold, and will have higher service costs than gas engine. Right now price of diesel fuel is also higher than regular gas, which makes it harder to break even on the initial extra cost of diesel.
This is a ridiculous comparison. The Yukon is a small school bus. Seriously, schools use them as small school buses. You need a palisade vs carnival. That is a really cost and class comparison.
We are looking at the Expedition Max so we can fit two dogs and a stroller in the back. The price difference has me questioning if it’s worth it every day.
You don't look big, unless your family are big people, you don't need SUV. It's more depreciation for vehicle that doesn't fit in garage. When you need SUV, just rent. $6 a gallon gas ought to help rationalize your decision. Woman up and defend yourself as minivan soccer Mom, you love enough to drive them to sports instead Bsitting home.
Aaarg why is this so hard! I want a suv where i can fit 3 car seats, no 3rd row, all wheel drive, good control on snow, that is not 60000$!!! If ibtake minivan then price is good but the rest not really 😢
I just drove a minivan about two weeks ago. I am getting a minivan.. still deciding Odyssey, Sienna, or carnival... Sienna can't take the second row seats out easily which is fucking dumb design toyota. Be better, be smarter. Also why the fuck is buying a spare tire even a thing? Honda odyssey.... so far everything looks good but the interior is outdated... do better honda Then the kia Carnival 2025 is sexy inside and out, new tech and all but the question is will it catch on fire and kill me and my family? And all these manufacturers and more dodge is another one, everyone can't seem to build a vehicle correctly right now. Wtf. Toyota lying about safety issues, i mean come on. Also GMC is one of the worst manufacturers out there. On some of their own vehicles, they wont even fix because they dont know how.... wtf?
One thing you missed... go try parking both in a parking garage and see which one you buy. Too many people buy a HUGE SUV without realizing they can be quite challenging to manage as a driver. In contrast and minivan is one of the easiest vehicles to manage.
Yes! I downsized from a Tahoe to a Traverse and it's much easier to park! Also we live in a rural area with one lane roads and so much easier to pass other vehicles. We have had to replace drivers side mirrors on 2 vehicles because of farmers huge ones hitting ours. No problem now with the lower and smaller Traverse mirrors.
Most families who buy SUVs are really looking for a minivan. 3rd row comfort, cargo space, practicality, reliability, etc. Who cares what others think! Embrace the American Dream and suburban family culture!
I have always wanted the answer to be SUV but vans are so much easier. If it isnt moving the family around, I can easily take all the seats oit/fold down and fit 15 sheets of 8x4 plywood in it
But suvs are safer,tougher and they can tow way more than minivan or normal vans😂
@@carbeastsmIf you need towing, then good for you. But if you need maximum space then a minivan is much better. All I care about is space, not towing anything other than a kayak trailer.
@@austinhernandez2716 safety?
@@carbeastsmhow is a modern minivan any less safe? If anything, it's the suv that's a hazard due to its higher rollover risk.
@@Loathsome_Lynx do you know what will happen if a small suv like a audi Q3 crashes into a large van like a mercedes sprinter ?
Minivan all the way!! And I’m a dude!!
It’s women that refuse to
Drive them
I think most minivan drivers are men at this point. These 3 row suvs only exist because women don't want to be called soccer moms.
Minivans are practical. SUV's are not , and they're even useless, even Dangerous.
It just doesn’t pleased in the eyes, long shape, I’d use it for family or business, personal, NO!
@@jocelyntimothe6763 you don’t get an suv if you don’t got a family
I put a Drum Kit, Two Basses, Amplifier, P.A System and Gig Bag and Two Drum Carts + 4 People in a 2018 Toyota Sienna!
My kids grew up riding our 2007 Odyssey and its still going strong more appropriate for a family. Never understood why "soccer Mom's" were embarrassed to be seen as soccer Mom's.
I've lived in snowier places than most, and most people get along just fine with a 2wd car. A minivan with snow tires is better in snow than an SUV on all seasons anyway... The type of vehicle doesn't really matter compared to tires and driver experience. And some minivans are awd
Minivans are no longer the official soccer mom cars. The modern SUVs have taken that title. Personally, I’d take the minivan.
Carnival. It's really useful for a lot of side businesses as it can double as a small work van when you take out the seats. Some contractors are getting it for this reason
Yea it’s good business vehicle…
But Honda Pilot is excellent for over all use
Contractors have been doing that for years starting with my 1995 Ford Windstar!
Like the Carnival so much better!
@@SuperFitness12 it’s has a lot recalls and problems… I traded mine in for the Honda Pilot… Space and awd drive and reliability!! The is Kia was wonderful and interior design excellent and above the competition but I am not sure about reliability..
The Kia carnival potentially has a defect in its cyclinder design… It’s burn coolant…
Team Sienna. AWD and 35mpg
I heard over 600miles full tank.
After dealers markup and interest rates and taxes and fees your going be paying 15-20k extra which offsets any fuel efficiency in the current market over the life of loan for the Sienna…
Honda and Kia wins…
@@persaud101 no, for resale value Toyota, cash or payment you’ll get ur money back, not kia
@@jocelyntimothe6763 Resale value is 2-3k difference and dealers do not give you a fair price typically. You got to sell it by your self…Battery replacement cost comes in after 150k which could be 2500-5000k which again offset fuel savings ..
It all offsets
For eg: Grand Highlander limited hybrid total cost with current market interest rates, dealer marks up and other fees is 70k+ for a limited hybrid that cost 55k over the financing period… The fuel savings is red and not worth it vs a regular v6 when the cost to acquire is so high…
Was on a waisting list, got it at sticker. Will refinance when interest rates drop
Almost pulled the trigger on an Odyssey (because of your review). Then you bought a Carnival. So I bought a Carnival.
Carnival Rocks! My #1 choice. Loving it.
The Carnival is really gorgeous!!
Just rented 2 Pacifica minivans in Maine! Such smooth driving and great cabs! Highly recommend ( and I’ve owned 4Surburbans ,and 1 expedition )
I prefer my Pilot with awd to my former minivan for winters in Maine
Vans for sure
I got the suburban. I feel like a tank in that think. Super secure especially in snow. I can fit everyone in there when they visit me.
I’m driving my second Yukon xl. The first I sold when I reached 260,000 plus miles. I’m a nurse and have to get to work in icy/ snow conditions. The 4 wheel drive handles great even on the hills I have to drive on
I had a 2013 Town and County 5 or 6 yrs ago. Traded for a Tahoe. The 3rd row with a bench was awful for my teens. The Traverse I just got feels so much like that minivan on the inside that I have went for the door handle on the left side so many times 😂 it has almost just as much room as that van and so easy to clean up with the leather seats and Weather Tech mats 🙌 enjoying the better gas mileage too 18(Tahoe) Vs 23(Traverse). Also impressed with the AWD! Had to drive uphill on a muddy/grassy graveyard road this morning and it done great! Looking frd to seeing how it handles snow this winter.
Best youtube channel I've ever stumbled upon!
I have an Odyssey and kids under 9. Love it for the practicality but our driveway is rough and for a few weeks every winter I'm stuck at home in it
That was the reason we had to get rid of our minivan 😩 our AWD Traverse handles ours well tho.
Can you do a video of the expedition max vs carnival? That would be helpful❤
I can tell you right now 20 reasons the carnival is better
@@YellowDoh I ended up getting the carnival lol for a great deal 2024 back in October
I’m still trying to decide between these two! HELP!
Get the carnival! Also watch these two videos… “Why minivans are actually the best vehicle to buy” made by Scotty Kilmer, and “These stupid trucks are literally killing us” made by Not Just Bikes.
@@YellowDohgoing to look these up now!! Thank you!!
We bought a Carnival this year and sold our expedition max. Just cant beat KIA's warranty. We have four kiddos and the van works great
Brokie move
@@michaelstevens04 What do you mean by that?
The utility aspects of minivans wins my heart any day. And they're pretty comfortable too. I don't care for luxury and looks.
She doesn’t know she’s talking about anybody that knows how to drive snow no it doesn’t matter how big your vehicle is as long as you know how to drive in snow when you have good tires on your car that’s all you need. Front wheel drive is perfect. All-wheel-drive even better.
Neither. Hi top 4 me.
Talk slower. Nd sub titles..
DeFinitley say nay to anything not AWD tho.😮
I got a minivan. I took out the middle row seats and the back row folds into the floor. A full size air mattress fits perfectly in the back and laying down on it now! You can't do that in most suvs.
With no doubts Minivans are the ultimate people haul, even more ultimate if you have little ones. But their performance is where they lose their appeal to SUVs (in my opinion).
If you have to worry about Terrain and weather than SUVs makes more sense. I own a minivan and also live where occasionally snows, so far even with some tricky weather my van did fine and isn’t awd. To this moment, considering our stage of life with 2 little ones minivan has been pretty cool. Can’t say how many times the sliding doors were life saving hahah. Or Having in laws and my parents visiting at same time and being able to take everyone in the same car to go out is pretty fun! 6 adults and 2 kids (in car seats) with a double stroller in the back and rooms for more junk! Hahah can’t beat that 😂
You shouldn't have a problem driving a van anywhere in the USA. The only problem would be off-road. 99.9% of people do not need to ever go off-road. Also, SUVs aren't that great at handling snow, either. Barely better than a minivan
We went from a 2018 Traverse to a 21 Sienna...and I'm missing the trunk space SO MUCH. I really thought I was trading up for sliding doors and more kid-friendly/family options...but there isn't much difference that benefits us other than the sliding doors. The seats don't come out, we have car seats in the captains chairs, so we can't take advantage of their ability to fold for more cabin space..
Now I'm back in the market for an SUV. 😅
Good feedback. But what about the car being hybrid? If you put down the car seats the traverse still has a bigger trunk space? I'm surprised!
Reliability also should count for something right, Toyota sienna should have less wear and tear over the course of it's life right?
No way the traverse has more trunk space. Not possible.
@@publicius7024 It may not be in cubic feet technically (I haven't looked to see what the Sienna is stated as having) but for sure the configuration like she stated is vertical space vs flat space. It just doesn't work out to be as beneficial if it's vertical trunk space. After living with it for 2 years I'm so surprised about that because somehow I seriously thought I would have more space in the van vs the traverse.
@@gzhen123 So the Sienna being a hybrid is actually one point I forgot to mention and it IS a huge factor that would hurt to go away from. 35mpg is really nice! We have 4 kids, so it isn't often we would put the back seats down to compare cargo space between the two. I don't honestly know if we ever did when we had the traverse. I would assume it's pretty similar. From what I can tell, the traverse was a bit tighter between the seating rows than the sienna, but it's because it has more trunk space and vice versa.
@@kristenkaufman163 good to know. The resale value for sienna is also probably amazing compared to the traverse. I feel you can't go wrong with the sienna, but if u didn't need the 3rd row maybe it would be better for ur family's needs. Either way, grass is probably greener. Traverse looks more badass haha
I've owned both. I'm currently driving a 2014 town and country.
Team minivan
Went through the same journey when our second child came this year. The car we NEEDED was a minivan, but we bought the car we WANTED with the 2023 Yukon XL AT4.
It looks great and we love it! The comfort of the extra large interior space for the family to relax while on the road, the trunk space for the double stroller and backup supplies and the peace of mind of the 4WD in our climate. Of course, it comes down to price and what one can afford without stressing the budget. I acknowledge we are blessed and fortunate to have the opportunity to choose.
If it wasn’t the Yukon, then it would have been the AWD Pacifica! Highly recommend if you go the van route!
Pacifica has the worst reliability ratings in its class. It has been marked as the worst mini van of 2023, it has a lot of issues and recalls.
@@palomashaw4351 now I feel less bad about going with the extra cost on the Yukon. Good thing
Had a mini van (Kia carnival). Got the new Honda Pilot… Best suv ever… All the space and features and built like a tank…
Honda Pilot Touring is the way to go… Looks like a Range Rover but reliable… The new boxy aggressive looks and full size adult 3rd row is a big win!! I am big 6’0 225 and I fit comfortably in the 3rd row !!
I would love a Yukon XL being I’m 6’7” but I can’t justify spending double the price of a Sienna for the cool factor.
no its perfectly justified i would so do it
Get the carnival
You probably get more space on a minivan.
It's not like the bloated Yukon is cool.
Top trim of sienna is just a little cheaper than a base suburban…..
Minivan, team Carnival specifically lol!
Minivan! I want those doors opened for me while I’m folding up the doona!
Yukon is not comparable since theprice is so far out of reach, most people shopping for minivan or SUVs around 30-50k budget would most likely look at Honda pilot, Toyota Highlander, Traverse, ford explorer, or other 3 row SUVs in that price range
As a car enthusiast, I would pick the minivan over the SUV. If I’m not towing something, I don’t need the SUV. I have a kid so a van is still better even if the SUV is better in snow. Yes it snows where I live and sometimes it’s a few feet at a time. I just like the sliding doors and lower load floor.
If i have a family i would never pick a minivan since suvs are safer
@@carbeastsm depends on the SUV. Some of them are quite the opposite of safe.
@@brian0410 most suvs weight heavier and have way better cabin protection,
A ford fiesta is similar in safety to a kia carnival which is one of the safest minivans
@@carbeastsm I know that. But smaller cars would be safer if we didn’t have such large trucks and SUV’s on the road. It has become a race for who has a bigger vehicle for “safety” trucks aren’t safe, mini vans and SUV/crossovers are as well as wagons.
@@brian0410 a mercedes gls and gle weights more than trucks like a ford f150,gmc sierra , dodge ram 1500 and chevy silverado and tahoe
Definitely SUV...But I'm wanting the Suburban
Get the Suburban with the 3.0 Duramax. The fuel savings is over a thousand dollars a year.
Yet people will still buy the Yukon for Status
Minivans all day. I drive in the snow with my two wheel low clearance but for severe weather we take my husbands all wheel suv.
It boggles the mind when people say minivans are so much uglier than suvs (none luxury). None of them are beautiful. Our Porsche 911..stunning!
Wait till those power sliding doors break. That'll cost you a small fortune
What vehicle would you all recommend for having 5 kids ages 7, 6, 4, 19 months, and a newborn? We’d need 2 infant car seats and 3 boosters to fit inside the vehicle. Thanks!
Easy. Toyota Sienna or Honda Odyssey
I have 3 greyhounds and have a Forester. The older one has trouble jumping into the back. Previously had a Town & Country which had Sto&Go & a much lower floor. Reliability was terrible. I was in Detroit with the T & C during a blizzard & had no trouble in the van while I saw 4wd vehicles overturned & sliding all over the place. I didn't even get wheelspin!
So get a reliable van. Poor dog.
SUV. Because I need it to tow a boat, and we drive in the mountains and last year I almost got my family stuck in the snow in a small fwd SUV. It would have been bad if I wasn't able to get out, we were far from people.
My family loves the outdoors and mountains. Minivan just can't do it. Honda Pilot Trail trim :)
As a married man with 3 young kids, I started with an SUV, then went to a minivan. I will not be going back to an SUV, at least until my kids are much older.
@@99SigP same here, although I rented both a minivan (Chrysler town and country, dodge grand caravan) and an SUV (2017 ford expedition). The suv has travel comfort for long distances as a rental car, BUT AWFUL gas mileage on city driving,, so bad nearly $85 per gas fill up. So in the end after trying both types, I bought the minivan (14 Chrysler town and country).
I have a 2013 Dodge Grand Caravan SXT and I love it for the space for my three children. However, I will say if you're going with a minivan you should go for one with tv's, power lift gate, auto sliding doors, and a good dash entertainment system. My van has none of those unfortunately.
Between those two Ill take the Carnival because it has more versatility.
Get the van. A solid third of the U.S. population lives in places where garages and parking spots don't have space for anything longer than 17'.
Mini van Best for everything
Team Honda odyssey and team Toyota sienna, I think they are both equally good
I see all those tiny women in the XL SUVs 😂 it looks so funny.
Still team minivan. When the kids get older I’ll get a suv
Just ditched our Honda Odyssey for a suburban. Will never go back. SUV all day for our family of 6
I mean if you drive on rough terrain constantly or got a trailer to tow I understand but other than that everything is just worse than a minivan bruh
Minivans don't have the ground clearance required to drive in the snow? Complete nonsense! Also, you don't need AWD to drive in snow.
I love S.U.V.s. I love Kia. P.K.
The Yukon can be fuel efficient if you get the 3.0 Duramax. Its the best SUV engine by far with great fuel efficiency, smoothness, and lots of torque for towing. Plus it doesn’t have the V8 lifter problems like the 5.3 & 6.2.
Having a large diesel engine for short drives around town does not take advantage of diesel’s stronghold: efficient long distance cruising. Also diesel needs time to warm up to operating temperature in cold, and will have higher service costs than gas engine. Right now price of diesel fuel is also higher than regular gas, which makes it harder to break even on the initial extra cost of diesel.
I can’t decide ! I owned a 2008 town & county and loved it but
You'll have to pull my Yukon XL and Tahoe from my cold, dead hands
I dont understand why city people are buying suv's. The mini van seams better if ur not going off road
Mini vans are huge
Love Yukon but mini vans are better for the money and everything u get
Kia carnival does everything the Yukon does for half the price.
Suv’s are better at:
Towing
Safety
Comfort
Speed
Torque
Power
Traction
Weight
Umm except eveything she listed that they don't
This is a ridiculous comparison. The Yukon is a small school bus. Seriously, schools use them as small school buses. You need a palisade vs carnival. That is a really cost and class comparison.
minivav team
We are looking at the Expedition Max so we can fit two dogs and a stroller in the back. The price difference has me questioning if it’s worth it every day.
The 3.0 Duramax in the Suburban & Yukon is a much better choice. Better fuel efficiency than the Ecoboost and much more reliable & smoother.
Minivan is Superior for families. All the mons that say " mini vsn aint cute' neither are you
She know FINE!!!!!!
Team Honda odyssey
I just bought one! Loving it
Honda transmissions are terrible. Had one blow up on me. #NEVERHONDAAGAIN
Toyota Sienna has AWD. 36 mpg.
Minivan
Team SUV all the way baby!!
I’m on team whitest pants, EVER
Next review:
Carnival Van -vs- Carnival Cruise
Give me both please!
If you don't tow, buy a van.
I grabbed a suburban for $6.5k
This girl needs to slow down her speech. She will never make it talking a little to fast
You don't look big, unless your family are big people, you don't need SUV. It's more depreciation for vehicle that doesn't fit in garage. When you need SUV, just rent. $6 a gallon gas ought to help rationalize your decision. Woman up and defend yourself as minivan soccer Mom, you love enough to drive them to sports instead
Bsitting home.
family? minivan
single? sport fun car
Go with a truck that can trace its lineage back to 1935-Suburban / Yukon XL. Carnival is shiny and new and will most likely jump timing
I asked my wife. A lot of moms dont want to be labeled as soccer moms, but if you are a mom and your kid plays soccer, then you are a???
Minivan!
Aaarg why is this so hard! I want a suv where i can fit 3 car seats, no 3rd row, all wheel drive, good control on snow, that is not 60000$!!! If ibtake minivan then price is good but the rest not really 😢
I want a carvinal 2025. But I dont want them to kill me by fire.
Suv yucon
Team lawnmowers in the background
👍
SUV🎉
Minivan for younger kids
Sienna!
Yukon
Suv
I take the
Minivan
You must work for Kia/Hyundai😂
The Yukon XL will outlast then minivan
Team SUV
Team Tahoe
I like the idea of a mini van but need the 4x4 of the full size suv. And we use it to tow regularly but a mini van could pull the trailer.
Team SUV!
Super useless vehicle 🤔
Who tf makes 60,000 😂 not even a year mini van you need two jobs
Im not buying no damn kia😆😆
Minivan all the way. All i see is ford expeditions and suburbans…. Yuck🤢 minivan is the way to go
I just drove a minivan about two weeks ago. I am getting a minivan.. still deciding Odyssey, Sienna, or carnival...
Sienna can't take the second row seats out easily which is fucking dumb design toyota. Be better, be smarter. Also why the fuck is buying a spare tire even a thing?
Honda odyssey.... so far everything looks good but the interior is outdated... do better honda
Then the kia Carnival 2025 is sexy inside and out, new tech and all but the question is will it catch on fire and kill me and my family?
And all these manufacturers and more dodge is another one, everyone can't seem to build a vehicle correctly right now. Wtf.
Toyota lying about safety issues, i mean come on.
Also GMC is one of the worst manufacturers out there.
On some of their own vehicles, they wont even fix because they dont know how.... wtf?
Mini van and I dont have rugrats
team suv all the way!
Why choosing a vehicle that don't make any sense like an SUV 🤔
@@saggioperduto_7566 personal preference & name me one van that is 4x4 like an suv 😙
@yuryhenrriquez1883 Toyota Sienna, Chrysler Pacifica, Mercedes-Benz sprinter, Ford transit and GMC savanna, all vans or minivans.
We have 4 kids from 7 weeks to 14 years; I will never own anything but an Expedition Max again (as long as I have kids at home)!