Moses wasn`t an Israelite ?!

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 21 дек 2024

Комментарии • 106

  • @christopherwilson2785
    @christopherwilson2785 Месяц назад +7

    Ehhhh.... if he was adopted by Egyptians it only makes sense that he's gonna be given an Egyptian name.
    They probably deleted the first part of his name... leaving Moses

    • @threecheersforsweetrevenge8709
      @threecheersforsweetrevenge8709 Месяц назад +1

      @@christopherwilson2785 or maybe read Sargon the great story.

    • @llnam12
      @llnam12 Месяц назад +1

      The first part is Thut. Moses removed the "Thut" when he rebelled, forfeiting his grandfather's name. He was Thutmose III.

  • @doktortutankamazon31
    @doktortutankamazon31 Месяц назад +7

    Moses is a mythical hero. He did not even exist.

  • @tonygrowley5275
    @tonygrowley5275 Месяц назад +6

    MOSES WAS A MYTHOLOGICAL CHARACTER.

  • @SaintFort
    @SaintFort 2 месяца назад +9

    Moses is a myth or a legend. The Bible's story about him is not real.

    • @yuutonosuri772
      @yuutonosuri772 Месяц назад +1

      Ra'meses Ra'moses

    • @threecheersforsweetrevenge8709
      @threecheersforsweetrevenge8709 Месяц назад +2

      It’s based loosely on king Sargon the great story. I believe he was Akkadian

    • @SaintFort
      @SaintFort Месяц назад

      @@threecheersforsweetrevenge8709 How can we be sure that even the story of King Sargon is real?

    • @threecheersforsweetrevenge8709
      @threecheersforsweetrevenge8709 Месяц назад

      @@SaintFort Akkadian artifacts actually exist. Akkadian is one of the empires who used tablets. These tablets exist in the tens of thousands. They are being translated and the period right before the Bronze Age collapse is becoming clearer. History of west asia is not represented accurately in the Old Testament

    • @Bourourou5
      @Bourourou5 Месяц назад

      @@yuutonosuri772 Moses is an English translation, that's not his name, in French they call him Moise and that;s not his name either, it's like Jesus, that's not his name, so trying to find mystic hidden words, codes and names in a 16th century AD English translation of the bible is like looking at the return prophecy on a milk carton

  • @Kamarovsky_KCM
    @Kamarovsky_KCM 2 месяца назад +4

    Painful how most of the comments here is either conspiracist bullshit or religiois bullshit, neither of which engage with the historical and scientific approach presented in the video

  • @DjWesRolan
    @DjWesRolan Месяц назад +1

    This guy must’ve not have dug buried deep into a source material. The Egyptian themselves talked about Moses. They referred to him as a Jewish slave trader

    • @fordprefect5304
      @fordprefect5304 Месяц назад +1

      As the Jewish archaeologists Israel Finkelstein and Neil Silberman noted:
      [W]e have no clue, not even a single word, about the early Israelites in Egypt: neither in monumental inscriptions on the walls of temples, nor in tomb inscriptions, nor in papyri. Israel is absent - as a possible foe of Egypt, as a friend, or as an enslaved nation

  • @tbishop4961
    @tbishop4961 2 месяца назад +1

    Progressive revelation is not something the masses are willing to accept. It implies additional investment on their part

  • @WalterRMattfeld
    @WalterRMattfeld Месяц назад +1

    (23 October 2024) My studies suggest Moses wasn't an Israelite.
    So, who is he?
    He is a native Egyptian and a recast Pharaoh Ahmose I of Thebes, and the expeller of the Hyksos ca. 1550 BC.
    English Moses is Hebrew Moshe, Arabic Musa.
    The un-named Pharaoh who expelled Israel from Egypt, according to the Bible, is for me, Ahmose who expelled the Hyksos.
    No Hyksos ruler ever bore a name approximating that of a Hebrew Moshe, only Ah- Mose possesses a name approximating Moshe.
    So, by default, for me, Ah-Mose became a fictional Moshe in the Bible, the expelled Hyksos being transformed into a fictional expelled Israel.
    For details cf. Academia Edu Profile Walter R. Mattfeld, for my 56 scholarly papers on the subject of the Exodus and its pre-biblical origin in Egyptian annals of Ah-Mose I.

    • @fordprefect5304
      @fordprefect5304 Месяц назад +1

      No, he was a myth, just like all bible stories

    • @apromisedisland
      @apromisedisland  Месяц назад

      Thanks for the comment.
      Please check out this blogpost:
      mohammadhasanalgarhy.blogspot.com/2024/03/phao-ra-and-king-mose.html

  • @raymondtan3951
    @raymondtan3951 Месяц назад +1

    True, Moses wasn't an Israelite. He was born of a Hebrew Slave. The dark-skinned Hebrews are from Mesopotamia, in Sumeria where the Anunnaki Gods of the Sumerian first landed. 'Anunnaki' in Sumerian means 'Those from Heaven to Earth came'. In the OT, they're mentioned as the Anakites or Anakims. In reality, they're ET Beings of the Anakh Race from Sirius Star System. The Old Testament is basically the stories by the Anakh. T'anakh is the Hebrew Bible.
    The Jews plagiarized the Hebrew Bible and made it their Jewish Bible. The Rabbis claim the dark-skinned Hebrews were early Jews, whom we can see present day Israeli as fair-skinned Europeans? Just look at Netanyahu.
    Moses was as dark-skinned as a Hebrew or as an Egyptian Pharaoh?! He ne'er was an Israeli.

    • @thewkovacs316
      @thewkovacs316 Месяц назад +1

      you clearly have never been to israel

    • @Buruhkasar-z3
      @Buruhkasar-z3 Месяц назад

      Mesopotamian aren't so dark

    • @raymondtan3951
      @raymondtan3951 Месяц назад

      @ilmiPrabowo-l3x In the book The Akan, Other Africans and the Sirius Star system, written that historical accounts from ancient writers such as Herodotus and from more recent writers such as Robert Morning Sky and Robert Temple point to the fact that the Sumerians called themselves the “black-headed” while the Egyptians have also been known to call themselves the “black-footed”. Hence, there were in fact large populations of black peoples in Ancient Egypt as well as in Mesopotamia in Sumer.

  • @tuluvota
    @tuluvota 2 месяца назад +2

    trying to make sense from the present with hypotheticals 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @ivanj.conway9919
    @ivanj.conway9919 Месяц назад +1

    Don't you mean Hebrew? Wasn't this before the Israelites even, existed?

  • @undergroundriptiles7005
    @undergroundriptiles7005 Месяц назад +2

    He was. Read the Bible.

    • @fordprefect5304
      @fordprefect5304 Месяц назад +2

      You mean the book of fairy tales.
      Please explain why there is no evidence for any story in the bible

    • @undergroundriptiles7005
      @undergroundriptiles7005 Месяц назад +1

      @@fordprefect5304 there’s many evidences look it up.

  • @simonlawrence5740
    @simonlawrence5740 Месяц назад +1

    Moses and the burning bush is a prophecy writen on the walls of the perymids for the 21st centry he did not exist in that time he is here now quietly waiting on instuctions from the universe.😮

  • @llnam12
    @llnam12 2 месяца назад +4

    Moses's dad was a grandson of Joseph. Moses's mother was an Egyptian princess with Atlantean blood.

    • @tbishop4961
      @tbishop4961 2 месяца назад +4

      😂

    • @venugopalr5454
      @venugopalr5454 Месяц назад

      The Israel of old Testament isn't the Netanyshu, s Israel. We know both Testaments.
      Don't bluff & confuse bibilical Or rather pre binilical characters by portraying what they were not really according to the Gospel Stupid speaker

    • @tonygrowley5275
      @tonygrowley5275 Месяц назад +1

      ATLANTEAN ??!! AHAHAHAH

    • @undergroundriptiles7005
      @undergroundriptiles7005 Месяц назад +1

      That wasn’t his real mother. Read the Bible

  • @Buruhkasar-z3
    @Buruhkasar-z3 Месяц назад

    As a Muslim i tend to believe Akhenaten was the believer among the family of Pharaoh

  • @McCarthy1776
    @McCarthy1776 Месяц назад +1

    There's 0 evidence whatsoever that Moses even existed. Most historians think he's simply a mythological fictional character

  • @Karen_Dasso
    @Karen_Dasso Месяц назад

    What was his mothers language?

  • @thewarthogking8203
    @thewarthogking8203 2 месяца назад +3

    Video should end at 0:46 .

  • @Bourourou5
    @Bourourou5 2 месяца назад +1

    The bible doesn't say Egypt, it says Misrim, misrim is not Egypt. Bible also says Pharaoh, there were no Pharaoh in Egypt, so why do we keep repeating the same BS stories, deny them or make up some psychedelics' stories, time to consider that these stories happen somewhere else and in a small scale, stories of Bedouin tribe in southern Arabia...and Judaism satrted with Ezra, so no idea what you are talking about

    • @justinjustinallison4523
      @justinjustinallison4523 Месяц назад +1

      No pharaohs?

    • @fordprefect5304
      @fordprefect5304 Месяц назад +1

      @@justinjustinallison4523 He is correct on that point. The term Pharaoh came into being in the 8th century. They were kings in Egypt. See the Armana letters. The Israelites were a Bedouin Canaanite tribe that settled in the hills of Canaan in the 13th/12 century
      Credit Israel Finklestein

  • @peteram9527
    @peteram9527 Месяц назад

    Moses if he existed came later. The ancient Philistines were in the land of Canaan before Moses and they did not arrive until around 1250BC so he would have lived long after that date.

  • @Humayoun-f3p
    @Humayoun-f3p Месяц назад +1

    Well Netanyahu"s Polish, pretending to be a Jew.

  • @AGtheGEEK
    @AGtheGEEK Месяц назад

    Moses “name” isn’t a good point of argument. The ancient Greeks have three alternative stories of Moses and so does the Jews have an alternative story for Moses. One of the stories told as so.. “He was sent to Ethiopia on a death mission to fight the Ethiopians but actually wins the battle.. and the marries an Ethiopian and ruled for 40 years in Ethiopia.” Now this makes the Ethiopians the ??? I’m not going to say it but this story is from the Greeks and the Jews .

  • @SrikantaMahananda-gx4zr
    @SrikantaMahananda-gx4zr 2 месяца назад +1

    There is Jews mythology not Judaism

  • @peterleitner-z4i
    @peterleitner-z4i 2 месяца назад +2

    Well, if Moses wasn’t an Israelite than the whole bible story of the Exodus wouldn’t make any sense at all.

    • @apromisedisland
      @apromisedisland  2 месяца назад +3

      In fact, many scholars say that the Exodus isn’t a historical event and that there is no archaeological evidence on it. Please refer to the bibliography in the video description.

  • @Dave183
    @Dave183 2 месяца назад +2

    There will be some causal link between Abraham, Moses and Joseph. It is even possible that Moses and Abraham was the same person. [Just one theory.]

    • @tonygrowley5275
      @tonygrowley5275 Месяц назад +3

      THE BIBLE I A BOOK OF MYTHOLOGY.

    • @fordprefect5304
      @fordprefect5304 Месяц назад +1

      You left out the easter Bunny and Santa.
      Is the tooth fairy Christian?

    • @Dave183
      @Dave183 Месяц назад +1

      @@fordprefect5304 People, out there, have a free choice about what to believe. The Moses story contains a large amount of myth- but some of us reckon his life was based broadly- on actual events.

    • @fordprefect5304
      @fordprefect5304 Месяц назад

      @@Dave183 But you are wrong. Moses and Exodus are pure myths.
      NO evidence has ever been found to support Exodus.
      Plenty has been found to disprove it.
      By Israeli archeologists no less.

    • @fordprefect5304
      @fordprefect5304 Месяц назад

      @@Dave183 There is no evidence for Moses or the Exodus. Nothing in Egypt, Sinai or Canaan.
      But plenty of evidence to prove it never happened and was made up in the 6th century.

  • @Tanjutsu4420
    @Tanjutsu4420 2 месяца назад +1

    this should help we don't call someone Arab because they come from Arabia we call Arabia the land of the Arabs because there's Arab people there. now i cant just say you're not Arab if i don't know your family or you're not an Arab because you don't pray to mecca

  • @paulrodgers252
    @paulrodgers252 2 месяца назад +1

    where was Moses born not raised and was his born Mother from Israel? an other Words: his origin; In Judaism, Jewish descent is passed down through the mother's line.

    • @apromisedisland
      @apromisedisland  2 месяца назад +2

      There was neither Israel nor Judaism at his time, please watch my previous video “Moses knew nothing about Judaism.”

    • @paulrodgers252
      @paulrodgers252 2 месяца назад +1

      @@apromisedislandhow do you know? are you civil or military to begin with? civil, stayed in the City, scared of their own shadows, where as Military Officers: wrote the History and Live It on this Planet;
      He does not have to know about Judaism: In Judaism, Jewish descent is passed down through the Mother’s line. His born Mother: the one He was born from not his raised Mother: the one who raise him if different than his born Mother;

    • @scottydoesntno
      @scottydoesntno 2 месяца назад +1

      @@apromisedisland an Israelite is a descendant of Israel, as in a descendant of Jacob Jacob. An Israeli is a person from the state of Israel.

    • @tbishop4961
      @tbishop4961 2 месяца назад +1

      ​@@paulrodgers252 there wasn't a mother to child "jewish" tradition at this point

    • @paulrodgers252
      @paulrodgers252 2 месяца назад

      @@tbishop4961are you civil or military to begin with? civil do not have traditions be cause they cannot get to the word tradition be cause it located on military side of words and things; traditions is a military word and thing; and the Jewish have all ways be Military with suckie civil Officers;

  • @MattigityIsBombigity
    @MattigityIsBombigity 2 месяца назад +4

    What sorta late April fools joke is this?

    • @apromisedisland
      @apromisedisland  2 месяца назад +2

      It’s a plausible hypothesis, please refer to the bibliography in the video’s description.

  • @threecheersforsweetrevenge8709
    @threecheersforsweetrevenge8709 2 месяца назад +2

    Moses never existed that was Sargon story (reed basket, found by princess) the Old Testament is nothing but a condensed version of 10,000 years of west asia mythology adopted by the wandering outcast to ingratiate themselves with the locals

  • @DrawTheThinLine
    @DrawTheThinLine 2 месяца назад +1

    Here's a thought. Could Acken attan have been Moses? Christian's today say amen at the end of prayer to the hidden God.

    • @apromisedisland
      @apromisedisland  2 месяца назад +2

      Thanks for the comment. Some scholars did suggest this hypothesis. Yet, it’s highly unlikely.

    • @DrawTheThinLine
      @DrawTheThinLine Месяц назад

      @@apromisedisland thank you. 🤝

  • @mikep608
    @mikep608 2 месяца назад +1

    Moses was a Hebrew.

  • @humbledone6382
    @humbledone6382 2 месяца назад +3

    The Bible is historically accurate as proved over and over through archaeological finds. But hey, let’s make Julius Caesar black, and Alexander the Great Chinese! 😂

    • @apromisedisland
      @apromisedisland  2 месяца назад +4

      Actually, the only potential archaeological evidence about Moses is King Dedu Mose stele dating back to the 16th century BCE (Please refer to my previous video Phao Ra and King Mose). Other than that, there is no archaeological evidence neither on the exodus nor on Moses himself.

    • @charlesbranscomb8493
      @charlesbranscomb8493 2 месяца назад

      Why don't you tell the truth and call them all melenated b cause they were whites just got a large number real Europeans are same color as the so called blacks in America and the Africans

    • @mattgieseke8302
      @mattgieseke8302 2 месяца назад

      There’s actually zero archeological evidence whatsoever of Israelite slavery in ancient Egypt. You’re right that the Bible is treated as a historical document, and that it does have some verifiable accounts, but a whole hell of a lot of it has not been proven. Much of the reason it’s used as a source for the Bronze Age Eastern Mediterranean is that it’s the only record that mentions a lot of its events. It’s a pseudo-historical and mythological account of the Israelite people, much of which was oral history long before being written down in the Torah. It’s very similar to the Iliad; the Trojan War did happen, we have evidence that ancient Troy existed, but it probably didn’t happen exactly as Homer described

    • @threecheersforsweetrevenge8709
      @threecheersforsweetrevenge8709 2 месяца назад

      Wow just wow. Don’t procreate

    • @threecheersforsweetrevenge8709
      @threecheersforsweetrevenge8709 2 месяца назад

      @@apromisedislandexactly Moses story is adapted Sargon the great story