The thing you said about Aamir not acting like the little boy reminded me of a Tom Hanks' interview in Graham Norton where he said that the young actor playing Forrest used to pronounce hard g at the end of a sentence. So the director was trying to teach him speak like Tom. But Tom said that he would rather speak like the boy and this is how Forrest's accent became so unique. He even had cassettes of the way he used to speak. Wish Aamir had taken this inspiration and interacted with the little boy to understand how he was supposed to act.
Agreed. This is exactly a thing from Tom Hanks, in acknowledging and Appreciating the child artist, whereby continuing the similar trend in the Adult character, as well. In Hindi both child and adult expressive nature are way different, hence disconnecting entirely. And the most shocking is Aamir Khan is known to identify such things and implement accordingly. In anyways, he either missed this point or deliberately didn't want to acknowledge it. Eventually, this very thing has become loud by the audiences. Having PK character placed, entirely in a different movie. Kinda Lame. Moving on, I still will continue to have an immense respect towards, Aamir Khan's overall contributions, towards Indian Cinema.
I remember that interview of Tom Hanks at graham Norton's show....he had put so much effort those days to speak the dialect of the little boy that he imitated perfectly in the interview after so many years. As for Aamir Khan, can't believe he thought he could pull off a remake of a masterpiece like Forrest Gump ?!! What a grave mistake ....hope he learns from this and stays away from remaking classics and comes up with something original.BTW did jammy just say that Kareena's character was a step up from Jenny ?!! I disagree with that ...everything about Forrest Gump was perfection ! And no way a Bollywood knock off can come close from any aspect ...
How about not trying to do all of this in the first place. We know Aamir can do way better than this and is quite unexpected that he actually came up with this after months. A young artist would look up to a senior actor expecting to learn from his quality and creativity he or she adds into his or her movies, except you see the actor replicating the same story from 1994 legend which will ofcourse in general be good as there is slight changes to character and not so much of the story.
SRK's role in My Name is Khan was kind of similar to this Laal role of Aamir. SRK's expressions were normal and simple but Aamir is still playing the same role in Dhoom-3 and PK ! A talent like Aamir should have done justice to his tribute to Forrest Gump !
Srk was amazing you could see him with his autistic traits but also as a normal person with feelings and also empathize with him at times without pitying him... this weird wide eyed and haaan character does not geel grounded or real in anyway.... this film would have worked 7 8 years ago our audience have evolved sadly bollywood still making scripts suitable 7-8 years ago
Dude, why are you comparing SRK with Amir khan. Amir khan is always known for his movie choices not for his acting because most movies his expression are the same from 3 idiots to pk all are the same but SRK is different even better than salman, he may have bad choices of scripts but he can act from chak de india, Swades, my name is khan or kal ho naa ho and many.
Idk why more ppl aren't talking abt this but My Name is Khan is the absolute perfect adaptation of Forrest Gump in the sense that it actually "adapts" the story beats of the original novel and brings it into the current ongoings of the world but doesn't "remake" the original movie
One of reasons forest Gump worked was cuz it was a satire on the American imperialists nd industrialists that led to the vietnam invasion. The Americans resonated with that feeling. One of the other reasons laal singh chadda messed up it by its portrayal of the Indian army. Having seen ssb interviews at a very minimal level, the Indian adaption is nothing but a mere joke on the Indian army itself.
The army portrayal is one thing but I feel whats even more jarring is the portrayal of someone who is on the spectrum of autism: that becomes even more odd for me as its there to see through the entire running time
You can see he has given his heart. But when you're playing the title role, it can't go so horribly wrong. It's all over the place. Sometimes sincere, sometime animated, sometimes fidgety, theres no consistency at all
Saw the movie yesterday and it is quite a good adaption. Aamir’s acting initially may be debatable but his acting in last 30 minutes is simply amazing.
As a big admirer of Aamir Khan, i was really dissapointed by the trailer itself where his portrayal felt so over the top and cartoony. But i really hoped that i would go wrong when the movie released like alia bhatt proved me wrong in gangubhai where i didn't like her in the trailer but loved her in the movie. But the same didn't happen with Aamir Khan. His performance was so over the top and cartoony which made me have a hard time in the theatres.
The issue being that its consistently over the top and animated for 2 hours and 40 minutes. Never have I felt so uncomfortable looking at an Aamir performance. God knows what the memo was
To be honest as a normal viewer i loved the expressions of Aamir it added that childlike perspective to the movie plus it made me feel connected to the character of laal singh
Amir missed the point of Forrest Gump. Keeping aside the unnecessary boycott thing, the beauty of the original film is that Tom Hanks played the titular character in such a beautiful manner that it never felt over the top, whereas Amir was in Dhoom 3 mode and turned it up so much that it felt cringe and over the top.
The way mental health and conditions are depicted in the movies is the reason why many people don't seek help. The way he did this in trailer itself was an indication that it's going to become a cringe fest. Tom Hanks did it effortlessly and managed to make it intensely honest! Aamir might feel he looks the part, but he wasn't. It's an opportunity lost.
Don’t you think it’s because India is a lower middle income country with lack of infrastructure and history of imperialism? Let’s not loose ourselves that much in idealism
@@Pyasa.shaitan Art shapes up the world we are all living in. Visual mediums more than others in many cases. Movies have been a big reflection of the society we live in and they should be conscious about it. One of the previous movies of Amir Khan was Taare Zameen Par which captured the learning disabilities very accurately and provided a guidance to many people who could take benefit of it.
@@CrestlessWave How many people do think see these movies? How many people do think remember what they saw and try to think critical about it? Yes art shapes thinking, about it’s also a precious commodity preserved for the privileged & wealthy. If art would have shaped minds we wouldn’t have elected a fascist in government, who support trickle down economics.
I watched LSC movie today!!! Absolutely liked the movie!!! Aamir never disappoints us!!! Ignore all the negative reviews!!! Everyone will connect to the movie as there are all kinds of emotions in this movie (mother,friend,wife,son)...All the major events of Indian history are covered in this movie...This movie is perfectly adapted!!!
I really enjoyed the film. I was thoroughly entertained. Aamir was a bit over the top but it doesn't harm the essence of the film. I don't know what you all saw. The movie was beautiful.
Being a Punjabi, I agree with your point that in Jug Jug Jeeyo atleast Punjabis were shown normal and Punjabi wasn't used much and where used it was good ,Same in Shershah but In LSC 👎👎
Personally I don't understand this over representation of one set of minority. Watching Indian films you'll think it was all punjab and punjabis. Thank god for the south movies.
Aamir's acting was a mix of PK and Dhoom3 stammering. Didn't like his acting, it felt monotonous. Young Lal's expressions and calmness was really great to watch!! Forrest Gump is way better!!
Abe bsdk .. yha PE AK ko ek bimar ladka dikhana h.. or Jo junior LSC h wo bilkul Amir se match kr rha h.. story bht achi h... Tumlo jese ludu log yha Gyan dete ho.. q ki yh bat tum jante ho asal me tumhari koi sunta ni ...
One anecdote about Forest Gump is that Tom Hanks had worked and prepared his character w.r.t. how he looks, walks and talk. However, just before the shoot started, during the younger guys preparation, they noticed that the kid is not able to pick up the accent Mr Hanks had finalized and they found the kids original accent interesting. So Mr Hanks reworked on his accent and adopted the kids original accent.
Just as we feared, after seeing the trailer. So surprised Aamir performed this way after we have already seen what SRK did in My Name Is Khan in such a controlled, restrained manner. Aamir seems to have played this role out in a very 90's way. I think you made a very good point about how important it is for a director to be able to make those calls, and for an actor to be self aware enough to realise how the pitch may just be too off. Ab toh raita phel chuka, aur gol gappa bhi kuchal geya.
You know brother, i think srk in my name is Khan would have been more fit treatment of this character..albeit not that gloomy as SRK's performance.but yeah he felt organic there
@@utsav2776 agree completely.. business wise and as a trajectory of Indian cinema SRK was leaps ahead of Aamir who is perpetually stuck making remakes and copies of Christopher Nolan. Many are saying SRKs cameo is worth more than Aamir's acting in LSC Also it is well known that TZP was directed by Amole Gupte but Aamir sidelined him. RDB was well known for the sentimental value and great acting from Sidharth, Sharman, Kunal kapoor and Atul Kulkarniwhere Aamir was mediocre at best.
I am thinking of Shah Rukh in My name is Khan. Rizwan is shy and Laal is outgoing so they are different, but Shah Rukh's sincere portrayal makes Rizwan so endearing that I feel Aamir could have taken some notes from it.
SRK was playing character that had Asperger’s syndrome highly intelligent in the autism spectrum. Laal doesn’t have that condition, He is just mentally slow to understand things.
Aamir Khan's performance was decent but this movie is a true masterpiece. It's a shame that it failed due to toxic publicity. In time, people will realize that this movie is an underrated masterpiece.
@@thespiderman49 bro feel sorry for u that u spamming this comment again and again.People already have liked it no matter how much intellectual or not still it was good adaptation and will be huge hit
The ongoing Korean web series "Extraordinary Attorney Woo Young Woo" has portrayed the Autism way better than what Aamir Khan did in this movie. Even I think that attorney woo also sounds like caricaturish sometimes... But still it was way better than this... And SRK from "My Name Is Khan" is without any doubt best performance.
There was a time when I would blindly go watch Aamir's movies just to see his acting skills. But now, PK, Dhoom3 and LSC characters seem similar. I miss those performances from Sarfarosh and Gulam where he was just so authentic. In today's time, I think his performance Dangal was pretty good.
I watched LSC movie today!!! Absolutely liked the movie!!! Aamir never disappoints us!!! Ignore all the negative reviews!!! Everyone will connect to the movie as there are all kinds of emotions in this movie (mother,friend,wife,son)...All the major events of Indian history are covered in this movie...This movie is perfectly adapted!!!
@@forthright4882 kitne paise mile bhai? itni bakwaas movie...mai paise barbaad karke aaya...acting skills were nowhere near the movie of forest gump...why make a remake, when u can't provide the same level of acting
@@dinosaur669 aapko kitne pesa mile tum esa hamesha Boycott Boycott karte ho!!! Bhai movie sirf Aamir acting sey nahi chalti... movie story sey chalti h ...movie emotion sey chalti h...iss movie m mother , friendship, wife,son sabka impotance dikhaya gaya ... Important national events dikhaya gaya... mujhe bore bilkul nahi lagi...pata nahi aap log kyu pasand nahi h!!! May be there is hidden agenda for u to give negative reviews for this movie
@@forthright4882 important national event dikhaya gaya? gawar insaan...tell me jn which national event were there involvement of mentally challenged personal in the Indian armed forced, and that also in para troopers... chutiyo ki tarah dusro ki recommend kar rahe ho, when i clearly said i saw the movie and it was a pathetic one... gawar boycott karne waale dekhne nahi jaate movie... i watched the movie and it disgusted me... puja paath karne se malaria failta hai? mere secular nature ki wajah se movie dekhne gaay tha, but aamir is a pathetic moron, why not say namaz padhne se malaria failta hai? chutiya pehle khud snetiments hurt karte hai fir sorry bolte hai fir se hurt karte hai...get lost with ur useless critics... the movie is pathetic, the 28 crore in 3 days is a living proof...that the movie itself is pathetic tum jaise logo ko aamir gobar bhi dega to sona kahoge...u guys dont have any individual opinion... bus aamir ka movie hai to acha hai... thugs of Hindustan me bhi tum jaise chutiye the...jo keh rahe the achi movie bani...use to boycott bhi nahi kiya tha kisi ne...
@@thespiderman49 dont why he take so much time to make a movie , even to make a remake movie he is taking 3-4 years . even the orginal forrrest gump was made within months . Maybe the comeback will be after another decade
What disappoints you more is that you get a caricaturish performance by an actor like Aamir Khan. It would have been a pass if it was an actor who hasn't delivered memorable performances. I still get goosebumps thinking about the scene in Rang De Basanti when he breaks down while having food after the lathi-charge incident at India Gate. It really breaks your heart to see an actor as good as him make such choices.
Being from south India, I use your English reviews to decide if I want to watch a Bollywood movie or not. I regret that I didn't see this in theatres based on your review. All the negative that you pointed out was overshadowed by the positives. It's a wonderful feel good movie for me and an above average comedy drama. 🙏
@@gagansingh7026 scene to scene copy, doesn't mean inspiration, and you can't defend the movie as the makers themselves are saying that this is official remake of forrest gump, so yeah it is remake or you can say adaptation, but it is not an inspiration.
@@Scribbly_Chi_10 no one ever claimed this took inspiration from Forrest gump. It was known from the very beginning that this was supposed to be an "adaptation", which is exactly what it is.
Going by the trailer, this is no surprise. Aamir is over the top. I loved Dangal when I watched it in the theater. But with time, I've come to see the flaws. Instead of telling the story of two young girls in wrestling against a patriarchal background, Aamir has kind of forcefully tried to make it about his character, the girls' father. The scenes where he's locked up, running, crying. All unnecessary. Lending nothing to what was actually going on. Just a star trying to forcefully get into more scenes. Amir needs to tone it down. It's very off putting to see 'acting' as compared to actors who don't look like they're acting but just being.
true in case of Dangal , i thought the same wen i was watching the movie honestly 😅People are more matured now to understand the technical and emotional standpoint needed for the script nowadays and can clearly voice out wen its over the top n forced 🥵🧐
The child actor did such an amazing job. It's a shame to waste the amazing groundwork created for the character with such aplomb. The poise that Tom Hanks delivered was sorely missed. Even Rizwan Khan type of performance would have done the trick better over not being able to emulate Forrest. The PK/Dhoom3 pitch is just not it.
This is a huge difference between being a perfectionist and a self-proclaimed perfectionist.....sadly, aamir falls in the second category, his script choices might be, no doubt, unquestionable, but his acting in every film is not something that it should portray us as the greatest, (barring few exceptions like lagaan)....honestly, this "perfectionist" word only suits to late Irfan Khan❤
Lol you forgot 3 idiots,dangal,pk, how can someone be so foolish like you and public has set his name perfectionist ,he has never called himself perfectionist.
I Never supported the Boycott and watched second show in my city Nagpur, Eternity Mall....Now I m thinking that I should have supported the Boycott 😭😭😭😭😭😭....
Jammy explaining the good first and underwhelming later give me a gist of the film... I have already watched forest gump and for no remake can take it's place... Happy Rakshabandhan to all 💐
@@thespiderman49 Neither Amir could save the film, not your fake sympathy by spamming the comment section with the same copy pasted message will do any good.
@@thespiderman49 why to feel sad if Aamir have thought before working in laal singh chaddha and have worked in some other genre with an original content then he would have made a good comeback
I have no idea how I knew it but I KNEW this movie wasn't gonna be up to the mark like Amir's other movies.. The wide eyed act gets tiring to watch after a while 😩 the kids and Kareena actually did well as Jammy said👌
Unpopular opinion: I don't think Aamir has ever been a good actor.....his script choices have been quite amazing post lagaan but I never thought he was some absolutely amazing actor and also, I've never understood this "perfectionist" tag he's received his body transformation in Dangal was amazing and praiseworthy but it isn't some unseen feat he's achieved PS : I'm talking solely abt his ACTING not his film choices
No not unpopular opinion, but truth! Indian audience don't hv d mental faculties to discern good acting fm platonic, over d top acting. That's why Irffan, nawaz, kay kay, Raj kumar rao r not mass stars but mediocre lot like Khans, Kumar r. Actual movie enthusiasts r aware.
@@tiger3091 Bhai mere jab ghar mein khaane ko khaan anahi hai toh kisiko ko ghanta farak nahi padta kaun bhdiya actor hai kon nahi log bas enjoy karne jaate hai India mein
Weirdly I feel really sad because I don't want the movie to be bad and I feel bad for Amir khan bcoz he has worked on this for so long. Same with BRAMHASTRA, It is such a labour of love for all that worked behind this along with Ayan Mukherjee. I hope BRAMHASTRA delivers. I always root for good indian cinema when such fine and hardworking actors and directors are involved. I am a fan of some particular indivisuals in the industry, so I feel really sad when their films don't work.
No need to feel sad for anti India propaganda peddlers druggists and mafias. They deserve every bit of hate the masses give them for going against India and promoting nepotism
Bro, Kahe ka feel bad, film was not even original still failed to deliver. Don't know why this film's production and post production took so long. Amir performance was underwhelming, probably took this much time bcz of covid and some personal life problems. But 🤞 for brahmastra hope this film is good and worth the wait.
The most disappointing fact is that the movie might become a flop due to its content itself, yet it will give bliss to those who running so called boycott campaign. Not a fan of bollywood, yet don't like the negativity around it.
The issue with indian film industry is that the A list actors are just catering to their star power in the movie & not letting themselves into the character. If u see hollywood, the biggest of big actors just give up their stardom for character they are playing, so you see a character rather than an A list actor. Amir's acting is mediocre and the reason why he is a star is that he has done some really good films which returned profit. So bollywood fraternity placed him as top actor coz he promises a profit in the business. Though it is not the case in the recent time as Amir's film flops big time. He became egotistical to a point where the movirs he is doing getting the impact of it. There is said it.
he gave many mega hits. dont judge him based on one bad movie. its ok. he was not that great, at the same time he was not unwatchable also so chill. Dear RUclips Expert.
You said the point man! But the thing is the A-list actors in Bollywood were never great actors. They were always average whether it's SRK, Salman, Amir or even Akshay. Give them a character showcasing many emotions they fail or give average performance. I'd say that only Amir is one of them who wanted to do some meaningful (and by that I mean he also worked for it, transformed himself and did good acting, whether it's lagaan, dangal, taare zameen par) in Bollywood but he is failing lately. Apart from him SRK, Akshay, they are just doing business.
We made mediocre actors as A list actors. Whereas neglected amazing actors like nawaz pankaj kay kay manoj as side/supporting actors. that's our fault.
Boycott bollywood....i am from schedule caste...maa chudaaye bollywood ....bollywood ne aaj tak kisi SC/ST ko superstaar nahi banne diya ...bollywood ne kewal kapoor ,kher , roshan , kashyap, bajpayee , tripati ,khurana , sinha ,singh aur khans logon ko ijjat di hai
Making a remake of the movie that managed to snatch the academy award for best movie from 'The Shawshank Redemption', the highest-ever rated movie on IMDB, is not a child's play. LSC may be hit or flop, but it gives a clear message that its better not to touch classics. And I honestly believe that the people who'll watch LSC would be either die-hard Aamir fans or those who can't read even subtitles of Forrest Gump.
It shows ur immaturity. Many people like to watch the movies in their own language than reading subtitles. Language is an important tool of emotion. Just because u watched the original, it’s childish to underestimate the people who want to watch the movie in their language.
Forrest Gump is dubbed in Hindi. So, those who can't read subtitles, can see a Hindi Dubbed version. Original is original. Dubbed version is very near to original. Almost all remakes, which try to add something, fails. Specially, to the person who already saw the original movie. Because, our mind starts to comparing.
How Forrest ended up in USA army? During the Vietnam War era, between 1964 and 1973, the U.S. military drafted 2.2 million American men out of an eligible pool of 27 million. There is no draft system in India, not possible for mentally in stable to be selected.
Hey, I don't know if you read comments on old videos, but, I just watched Laal Singh Chadha on Netflix. To bo honest, I like it! It's wholesome! It's actually good if you don't watch it with the eyes of critic. I found Amir Khan's acting to be pretty good. He did manage to do a good job. It's a good movie in my opinion. If it was released in pre COVID era, it would've been quite a hit.
Why on the earth Aamir and the other creators of this movie thought that humming will be the best method of portraying the innocent yet intelligent kind of personality for Laal......Just can't understand
Tbh this movie hardly had any hype. I didn't know it'd be releasing today. Which pretty much sums it up. Even aamir who's known for his unique and extensive marketing, didn't promote it like his previous ventures. Most probably the makers saw the original again after completing this one and realized hugg dia😅
The Internet Reviews are divided into two different groups. One is only bashing the movie for no reason and one is only praising the whole movie without any reason. Both parties are ideologically driven to promote their agenda. But it’s good and Refreshing to see a actual honest unbiased opinion or judgment or a review from your side 🙏❤️ #TriedAndRefusedProduction Loved it
@@SahilJain6 I m not into “Paid German Shepherds” !!😂 These fringe-termites are mostly ideologically corrupted, manipulative hypocrites on sell, just for few easy Holliday-money from their masters !! THEY ARE ACTUALLY ON SELL 🤫 #DhruvRathee #OurOwnDesiGermanShepherd #GermanRathee
Dont worry no one in over seas talk about our shity love story movies but movie like dangal, my name is khan, aamir is perfectionist for a reason to bring a perfect revolution in 2000's Era when everyone was doing saas-bahu/pyar mohhabat type movies
Loved Bala and Mohammad friendship with LSC, I guess you are really reviewing this movie keeping Forest Gump in mind. Don’t forget most people haven’t watched Forest Gump and would love their stories.
Kuch bhi hojaaye idc brahmastra should not fail....I cant see 10yrs of ayan mukherjee's hardwork going into the drain 💔💔💔 It is a very important film for indian cinema ..i hope it turns out to be good 😶
Well you got it wrong - except stretch of last 10 min ( marriage - death and final school) it was a solid heartfelt movie - acting was more than competent- and brilliant song - in the world of bycott and OTT we are not realising theatres will soon closed - we are into the most pessimistic time or era- every thing get dissected by 10 % of people on internet which influencing majority-
The moment I heard about a remake with Amir, I was thinking about what Thanos was telling about balance to Gamora 🙄 A little towards one side or the other, it's ruined! Tom Hanks has balanced the original character so much that it's iconic. The fine line between perfect acting and overacting!
That's actually sad because I actually wanted this movie to give competition to original. I wanted it so good that international film audiences watch it and compare the both versions like happens with two versions of same screenplays i.e with CODA, A Star Is Born, West Side Story etc. Unfortunately, we were defeated miserably. Aamir should work on his acting skills.
We educated Indians understand Propaganda in movies. Don't show indirectly emotions for terroritst and don't show Indian army stupid. If Aamir has good intentions then give interview and talk about wrong things written in Quran. For knowledge go to Exmuslim Sahil or Adam Seeker youtube channel.
Agree when u say, the songs and kareena are the only saving grace of this movie! Wish kareena would do more movies, she is such a joy to watch on screen 💜 didnt understand the unnecessary comparison to jug jug n shershah though 😏 aamir just need to gracefully admit he went gravely wrong with his passion projects twice in a row and move on. Also goes to show the power and money these male superstars command, to audition kareena for this role but didnt care to check if he himself is capable of doing it! Also has a personal gripe towards this man for having had 2 marriages and leaving the kids fatherless, not cool 😡
Aamir is a brilliant actor. But he's far too powerful for lesser directors. He overrules them. He works best when his own spin on the character is kept in check. Take Ghajini for instance, Surya was phenomenal because he wasn't portraying a person who was angry, he was lost. Aamir on the other hand was just angry, I never felt he was lost in his own mind. The same was in Dhoom 3, way over the top and history has repeated itself with Lal Singh Chaddha. Innocence doesn't mean idiocy. Tom Hanks carried the innocence Aamir looks like a cartoon. Our actors need to take a backseat and allow the creators of these stories to portray their vision rather than hijacking the story tellers vision to feed their own grandioseness.
Absolutely right, though I haven't watched LSC, I completely agree with your comment. People like Aamir feel like they know too much to not take over the character, and that messses up the film itself. The actor should be a vessel for the character, but here its the other way around. I would like to highlight Randeep Hooda's performance in Sarbjit as an example of what I said.
His acting & expressions is same from the last few films & I don't find any variation in acting but amir is such a legend who gave so many great films .. For me in this film South star Naga chaitanya did so well 👍 ... One time watchable an emotional journey
My strong recommendation to everyone here is to watch telugu movie "Swati Mutyam" that was released in 1986. Kamal Hasan and Radhika are lead pair. Trust me, you'll thank me for this recommendation after watching it. It is said that Forrest Gump was made after being inspired by this movie. This movie is available with english subtitles. I hope that you'll watch it and appreciate the greatness of Indian Cinema
@@lakshimiakshithavoloju2006 The book you have mentioned is titiled same as movie i.e. Forrest Gump. It was written in 1986. Well the point here is, as said, the movie's team was actually inspired from Swati Mutyam when it was screened at some international film festival. Being inspired by the movie, they wanted to make a movie of similar theme, i.e a feel good life journey of an innocent man. They were equally impressed by the novel Forrest Gump, thus chose to use it for the movie after making changes to the certain areas of basic plot. One of the alterations in story from novels was climax. It is evident that the makers wanted to retain the feel good factor involved in Swati Mutyam.
@@LOKANATHAREDDYKATTA even the fether scene in forest gump was portrayed in kamal movie named guna. To describe kamal mental illness in that movie. Guna released before forest gump.
What about this ???? Movie is offensive to the Indian Army. Do the makers of LSC indent to condemn the Indian Army for defending the Nation from invaders? "I don't like the Army that kills people", says a misleading dialogue! How pathetic!!! Does Indian Army kill without reason OR only when attacked? Are the ones killed some random people, or are they enemy.
There must be a reason why Aamir didn't salute the Lady army personnel in a recent episode of KBC when Amitabh and all the audience were saluting her. Connect the dots sir
@@Anonymous-bf5fk Lie, right hand is visible and salute is done with right hand. Check again sir. You'll also find Aamir zipping his mouth when everyone was shouting "Vande Mataram"
And somebody in the comment section wrote that there was this line in which he said "me puja path nhi krta, usse malaria failta hai aur dange hote hain". I don't knwo the context behind it but that sucks lol. Why would he chose to have such kind of dialogue and line
exactly.... srk portrayal of khan in 2009 was way ahead of time whereas amirs portrayal of laal in 2022 where there is so much awareness looks so artificial
Kahe ka nail??? Ek dum bekar movie thi my name is khan. Chak de India aur Don chor do toh SRK kuch km nhi hai Salman se. Ekdm bakwas acting aur dono overrated
I actually really enjoyed the movie in theaters but completely agree that it’s really hard not to think of PK or dhoom 3 or 3 idiots in this movie - I especially did not even think about the fact that the crazed look went away in his elder age and wasn’t there in his childhood - so true ! The inconsistency doesn’t help . Nonetheless I enjoyed this story for what it was, and Kareena was an absolute essential she had a true complex character
I wish somebody from his crew dared to tell Amir to improve his acting otherwise it is gonna ruin this beautiful movie. Even in Thugs of Hindustan the worst part of the movie was his over the top character and acting. Very sad to see such minor mistakes which has huge impact on overall movie from such a great actor.
I really wonder how a performance can go so wrong. We all know Aamir Khan can be an amazing actor, so makes me think that even the most experienced actors sometimes don’t understand what the perception of their performance will be until long after they’ve given it, at which point it’s too late. Hope the best for his future projects.
Its the ability to perform different roles with great versatility that differentiates good actor from great actors. Vikram from deiva thirumagal and kamal from swathimutyam are some of the gems which portrays autistic people perfectly.
My god! Didn't thought that someone in this comment section would have known about vikram's portrayal in deiva movie. When you see Vikram in that movie you cannot draw similarities with any other character he has played, infact that's the thing with most of the characters he has played. I have seen his work and still I couldn't see him being same as he is in other movie. That is what acting is about. Whereas here Aamir looks like pk and Samar from dhoom.
Believe me, this will be a cult classic. Also people are missing the philosophy of advaitvaad of Shankaracharya which it is bringing up. There are so many philosophical layers which reviewers have not been able to comprehend.
THINGS JAMMY WONT TELL YOU - 1. There were many historical events shown but no mention of Kashmir Genocide. Importance to Rath Yatra where a masjid was demolished was given but no important to Genocide of 4,00,000 people ?? Afraid ? 2. In forest gump, gump saves an American army commander where's in LSC, lal saved a Pakistani terrorist and in rest of the movie, subliminal sympathy towards him is created. 3. Gump joins army because American army opened recruitment for all during Vietnam war where as there is no mention of Indian army opening recruitment for specially abled people like Lal. This movie is a pure Joke
Bang on! Every time I want to give Aamir the benefit of doubt and forget the past, he does it again. His ulterior motives are so clear. I'm done with you Aamir Khan ×
@@nknkannadiga9742 and believing in a desert warlord is not? See what his majhub has done to the world. Amir is a jihadist. He loves to promote nectrophile pedophile desert madman religion
Although I was very apprehensive regarding Aamir's performance when I watched the trailer I must say that it was a 'hit and a miss' portrayal by him where in some moments like when laal's mother dies, when laal talks to rupa in the last scene and when mohammad paaji's farewell scene Aamir did touch a note in me and having watched the original i was looking forward to these scenes. As for the other scenes, yes he was very over the top but the supporting cast except naga chaitannya made it tolerable especially the music of the film. So As a whole it worked for me better than I expected it to from the trailer!!
I felt only Kareena did well in that movie although it looked like her story was not properly written, when she was trying to jump from the building, I couldn't relate but she did justice to whatever she was given. Mohammad paji also did great compared to Aamir.
With the amount of network, money Bollywood has they should at least try experimenting with different stories, giving chances for new and talented actors rather than making remakes and adaptations. Audiences today have realised content is the King and they are tired and frustrated with mass hero - masala movies that eats your brain and waste your time & money.
You saw the collections of KGF, Pushpa and Sooryavanshi, right? Audience today wants that larger than life experience. It's unfortunate but I don't think a film like Kaahani will now be successful if released in theaters.
@@ishabargale3216 there's nothing wrong in making masala movies. I enjoy them a lot. I said unfortunate because a film like Kahaani has no place for a theatrical release in this day and age now. It's an OTT film now.
Sorry Jammy this is the first time that I disagree with your review. I just saw the movie & while Aamir’s portrayal comes of funny for the first 15-20 mins, it grew on me that I forgot about the comical nature of it. Sure there are some missteps through the movie but the Indian adaptation is fantastic & I was thoroughly engaged throughout visually & emotionally. Maybe a second viewing might make you feel the same way
I don't know how the movie is...but I think Rating movie on Imdb without even watching the movie is so foul... IMDb is a joke now. It's hard to find an unbiased review when every other review is polarizing
I feel the IMDb rating is only reliable after it has good number of votes to it. There aren't many platforms apart from rotten tomatoes to rate the movies globally.
Post Lagaan,I find stability is missing in Amir's acting and character.It appears like he is in some hurry to finish his lines and scene.That is the reason why it becomes difficult to emotionally connect with him.Totally opposite is the case with Shahrukh,that he tries too hard to dominate in each scene by occupying most of the shot and dialogue.Both actors should understand that they are the carriers of the story,not the story themselves.They can learn from their own previous films like Lagaan,Tare zameen par or Chakde.
I am worried sick for Brahmastra now given the state of LSC and Shamshera 😢 have already booked tickets for Saturday show LSC few days back and I am not happy about it now 🥺
You may actually like it; He didn't like Jug Jug Jiyo, but I really enjoyed it; now I'm planning to watch LSC on Saturday and let's see how it goes for me....
The truth is Aamir is not a great actor. He is convincing of course in all his movies but he doesn't have shades. His gift is picking good talent in his movies and getting that emotional connect with his audience. That's praiseworthy but his acting has never stood out to me since I have been watching him since the 90s.
I am glad it failed. I don't wanna see copies of movies or remakes anymore. This is the 21st Century: We have Torrent and several OTT platforms and can access any platform, even local ones through VPNs. We have great dubs from any language to anyone. I don't wanna see the excuse of remakes anymore.
Aamir Khan needs to stop playing younger character or hire a younger actor to play him in his 20's like the west does, for example moonlight each phases of the character is played by different actors. I think his efforts are genuine but it's not going in the right direction to where it needs to go, he needs some introspection with projects otherwise it will go against him in a long run.
You should stop criticizing Hindi movies for bad Punjabi, simply because it's a Hindi movie not a Punjabi film. Also, what is the point of examining such things with a magnifying glass, it's just a movie made for entertainment; your education and other real life commitments need this kind of attention. Also, Anil Kapoor, Neetu Kapoor, Varun Dhawan and Siddharth Malhotra are actual Punjabi's, so their Punjabi would obviously be better than Aamir Khan, who is not a Punjabi. You have clearly not learnt anything from the Sushant Rajput controversy; you are still playing to the gallery.
Iam happy that atleast kareena did a great job. Really hope she continues to do roles with lot of scope for acting coz she is very talented as an actor.
I was excited for this film feeling that maybe Aamir Khan will have his own performance stand out by staying true to the role. Forrest Gump has a very emotional and inspiring story. If the remake is given justice, it can easily strike a chord in anyone's heart, be it an Indian or not. This year I have rooted for so many Hindi films to be hit and to make an emotional connection with the audience. I was miserable when Shamshera flopped. I hope LSC becomes a BO hit tho
@@vreeshasingh2564 becuz Indians took bollywood so seriously, its become a part of their life which is stupid. they want to live in delusional world instead of living in reality and face life.
I’ve been a big fan of Aamir. He’s the son of great Tahir Husain saab. As his son, I’ve always felt that Aamir should’ve been a mass hero like Salman, but the people around him have turned him into a social activist. I saw the disaster LSC coming the moment I saw Kiran and Atul were involved in the creative process. They have their own political agenda. The thing about Forrest was that he used to think literally. There was a scene where Bubba gets shot and he asks why it happened. Thinking literally, Forrest replied, “Because you got shot!”. Forrest never tried to entertain the audience. He was stupid to other people, but his struggles were real. He tried to convey his lack of understanding through thinking literally, poor choices of word etc, . But here Aamir tried to manifest his simplicity through weird facial expressions. In South Asia, directors often think that’s how you show simplicity on screen. Kabir khan made the same mistake in Tubelight, even though Bajrangi character’s simplicity was more realistic. Advait is a mediocre director. I saw that in Secret Superstar. In every interview, Aamir keeps telling that he’s very careful about who is the director. But recently that hasn’t been the case. Because after terrible Secret Superstar and Dhoom 3, Aamir shouldn’t have worked with the directors again. But here we are There were many red flags in the trailer itself. First replacing the American football with sprint / race was a big mistake. They could’ve at least used rugby since the director took many creative liberties. I remember how funny Akshay was in Namaste London with that rugby scene. The humor in that scene took the movie to a different level. Second, replacing shrimp with underwear. I mean what they were thinking!! Naga’s character looked more like Chatur from 3 idiot. It would’ve been okay 15 yrs back. But now people are more exposed to South Indian movies, so the stereotype not gonna fly imo. Choosing Kargil War, World Cup, 1984, 26/11 is the easiest way to make a movie biased and prone to propaganda. And the writers couldn’t just resist the bait. There were many other historical moments in India which could’ve been more suitable and aligned with the humor and message of the movie The biggest casualty of LSC is the Jenny character. They just couldn’t understand her
Ppl around him havent turned him into a social activist.It is a conscious choice Aamir made and that worked for him! Similar to Akshay kumar..There's two genres that worked best in indian cinema..Romance and action..Romance was takn over by SRK n Action was taken over by Salman..The third would be comedy bt Aamir is not good at that..That just leaves out films with social messages..Aamir realised that if he doesnt stick to that genre he may disappear into oblivion...
@@shyamalidas2815 may be yes. But I say it's a good choice amir choose this path. His tare zamin par, rang de Basant, dangal vl speak fr himself even after 2 or more decades. Bt I don't think people vl remember these action n romantic movies
Review starts at 1:48 The Good - Music by Pritam (All Songs) Cinematography (Locations) Young Actors & Kareena Kapoor VFX (Turthful) Underwhelming: Punjabi Language Unconvincing & Forced (Chaitanya + Manav) Aamir same as in PK / Doesn't Understand that Less Is More
Flowed with it .. Not one of best of Aamir but definitely delightful lucid movie Loves it's cinematography, music and the amazing way a Hollywood classical masterpiece is Indianized. It never feels like in a others shoe..Loved how subtly different phases of Indian landscape and socio- political history is woven. And how beautifully and unpreachingly the message of " curing the malaria" is voiced. Rupa, Mhd Paaji and Lal's mother was so wholesome. Maybe when the context outside the movie will be forgotten , people will love it like Knockout, Salesman of the year, Wake Up Sid was liked or like lesser known beautiful movies such as Mee Rasqam, Lunana - a yak in the classroom, Skater Girl, Purna etc eventually are appreciated.
If you haven’t watched Forest gump which I am sure 80% of people in India haven’t , they would actually love this movie. I have watched both , and for the Indian twist this was FAMILY FRIENDLY, Whereas Forest gump is an Adult Film. The only part I didn’t like was the chaddi banyan sequence. I was satisfied he died 😂. Aamirs approach was good. But the wide eyes was not required. The young Laal was so natural. Aamirs felt like it was forced.
I think Kabir Singh did the best in terms of using Punjabi in a Hindi movie. It was real and the masses understood it as well. It is more to do with how comfortable the actor is with language and if he isn't comfortable then the language is sure to be butchered. Irrfan Khan was so comfortable in speaking the language of Paan Sing Tomar which added to his flawless performance.
"Luv Shuv te Chicken Khurana" is the best movie that used proper Punjabi. But when you want to reach so many people then you cannot have proper Punjabi. It is a double edge sword.
How dare you criticise Amir!!! You know he cried during the screening of this movie and you call him forced or caricaturish. This is the problem with today's generation, they don't appreciate fake tears of overhyped actors! #insertsarcasmhere
Sympathy and quality are 2 different things you know. Even I argue everywhere for Aamir for judging his movie without watching but this movie is just Average family entertainer compared to previous Aamir's movies.
The thing you said about Aamir not acting like the little boy reminded me of a Tom Hanks' interview in Graham Norton where he said that the young actor playing Forrest used to pronounce hard g at the end of a sentence. So the director was trying to teach him speak like Tom. But Tom said that he would rather speak like the boy and this is how Forrest's accent became so unique. He even had cassettes of the way he used to speak. Wish Aamir had taken this inspiration and interacted with the little boy to understand how he was supposed to act.
Agreed. This is exactly a thing from Tom Hanks, in acknowledging and Appreciating the child artist, whereby continuing the similar trend in the Adult character, as well. In Hindi both child and adult expressive nature are way different, hence disconnecting entirely. And the most shocking is Aamir Khan is known to identify such things and implement accordingly. In anyways, he either missed this point or deliberately didn't want to acknowledge it. Eventually, this very thing has become loud by the audiences. Having PK character placed, entirely in a different movie. Kinda Lame.
Moving on, I still will continue to have an immense respect towards, Aamir Khan's overall contributions, towards Indian Cinema.
Wow
Haha told you tingu aamir is a bad actor
I remember that interview of Tom Hanks at graham Norton's show....he had put so much effort those days to speak the dialect of the little boy that he imitated perfectly in the interview after so many years. As for Aamir Khan, can't believe he thought he could pull off a remake of a masterpiece like Forrest Gump ?!! What a grave mistake ....hope he learns from this and stays away from remaking classics and comes up with something original.BTW did jammy just say that Kareena's character was a step up from Jenny ?!! I disagree with that ...everything about Forrest Gump was perfection ! And no way a Bollywood knock off can come close from any aspect ...
How about not trying to do all of this in the first place. We know Aamir can do way better than this and is quite unexpected that he actually came up with this after months. A young artist would look up to a senior actor expecting to learn from his quality and creativity he or she adds into his or her movies, except you see the actor replicating the same story from 1994 legend which will ofcourse in general be good as there is slight changes to character and not so much of the story.
SRK's role in My Name is Khan was kind of similar to this Laal role of Aamir. SRK's expressions were normal and simple but Aamir is still playing the same role in Dhoom-3 and PK ! A talent like Aamir should have done justice to his tribute to Forrest Gump !
Dude SRK was exceptional in that film.....amir feels like cheap copy
Srk was amazing you could see him with his autistic traits but also as a normal person with feelings and also empathize with him at times without pitying him... this weird wide eyed and haaan character does not geel grounded or real in anyway.... this film would have worked 7 8 years ago our audience have evolved sadly bollywood still making scripts suitable 7-8 years ago
Aamir - cringeworthy & creepy.
Dude, why are you comparing SRK with Amir khan.
Amir khan is always known for his movie choices not for his acting because most movies his expression are the same from 3 idiots to pk all are the same but SRK is different even better than salman, he may have bad choices of scripts but he can act from chak de india, Swades, my name is khan or kal ho naa ho and many.
Bro for your knowledge
Srk character in MNIK is softly inspired from Dustin Hoffman character of Rain man movie
Idk why more ppl aren't talking abt this but My Name is Khan is the absolute perfect adaptation of Forrest Gump in the sense that it actually "adapts" the story beats of the original novel and brings it into the current ongoings of the world but doesn't "remake" the original movie
Nope
Yeah Shahrukh also looked believable as autistic person
True.
Aamir khan is King of Bollywood.
@@HabiburRahman-ws6un how so ?
One of reasons forest Gump worked was cuz it was a satire on the American imperialists nd industrialists that led to the vietnam invasion. The Americans resonated with that feeling. One of the other reasons laal singh chadda messed up it by its portrayal of the Indian army. Having seen ssb interviews at a very minimal level, the Indian adaption is nothing but a mere joke on the Indian army itself.
I feel sad for Aamir Khan because 4 years are wasted. I wish Aamir Khan next movie should be comeback film for him.
@@thespiderman49 definitely, it's a wasted opportunity
thats due to the lack of real world experience of the screenwriter, they also wasted the character of jenny , what a waste of a movie
The army portrayal is one thing but I feel whats even more jarring is the portrayal of someone who is on the spectrum of autism: that becomes even more odd for me as its there to see through the entire running time
Straightforwardness plus soldier job?
Never thought this day will come "Aamir Khan's acting is the worst part of this movie".
You can see he has given his heart. But when you're playing the title role, it can't go so horribly wrong. It's all over the place. Sometimes sincere, sometime animated, sometimes fidgety, theres no consistency at all
Now you have to take medicine🤣🤣🤣
Because he was trying to imitate tom hanks🙂 aamir is a very good actor, but Tom Hanks was literally on another level in that movie...
He is anyways a mediocre actor. Just got good directors and stories. Thats it.
What about thugs of hindustan, mela, awwal number, raja hindustani😂😂😂😂
Saw the movie yesterday and it is quite a good adaption. Aamir’s acting initially may be debatable but his acting in last 30 minutes is simply amazing.
As a big admirer of Aamir Khan, i was really dissapointed by the trailer itself where his portrayal felt so over the top and cartoony. But i really hoped that i would go wrong when the movie released like alia bhatt proved me wrong in gangubhai where i didn't like her in the trailer but loved her in the movie. But the same didn't happen with Aamir Khan. His performance was so over the top and cartoony which made me have a hard time in the theatres.
The issue being that its consistently over the top and animated for 2 hours and 40 minutes. Never have I felt so uncomfortable looking at an Aamir performance. God knows what the memo was
I feel sad for Aamir Khan because 4 years of hardwork are wasted . I wish Aamir Khan next movie should be comeback film for him.
Flop movie
Watched in theatres absolutely disappointed
Looks like news Documentary
Lol🤣
Bro movie is awesome dont spread hate I cant believe jammy didnt liked it ,it was more than amazing.
Classics are best left untouched. Can't believe Aamir wasted 4 years making a chor bazaar version of Forrest Gump
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Most of amirs movies after his 1 movie in a year are copies so that's his go to thing copy movies
And the movie is evergreen and relatable to anyone. Might as well have dubbed the original
🤣🤣🤣🤣
I feel sad for Aamir Khan because 4 years are wasted. I wish Aamir Khan next movie should be comeback film for him.
To be honest as a normal viewer i loved the expressions of Aamir it added that childlike perspective to the movie plus it made me feel connected to the character of laal singh
Amir missed the point of Forrest Gump. Keeping aside the unnecessary boycott thing, the beauty of the original film is that Tom Hanks played the titular character in such a beautiful manner that it never felt over the top, whereas Amir was in Dhoom 3 mode and turned it up so much that it felt cringe and over the top.
It was necessary 😀😀
I felt he's played the same character 3 times now - D3, PK and here.
As once a great men said "u never go full retard"
@@starlordbmt2157 Tropic Thunder. I get u man. I was going to quote it, but thought it might be a bit offensive.
@@veerhamira162 No it was not
The way mental health and conditions are depicted in the movies is the reason why many people don't seek help. The way he did this in trailer itself was an indication that it's going to become a cringe fest.
Tom Hanks did it effortlessly and managed to make it intensely honest!
Aamir might feel he looks the part, but he wasn't. It's an opportunity lost.
Don’t you think it’s because India is a lower middle income country with lack of infrastructure and history of imperialism?
Let’s not loose ourselves that much in idealism
@@Pyasa.shaitan Art shapes up the world we are all living in. Visual mediums more than others in many cases. Movies have been a big reflection of the society we live in and they should be conscious about it.
One of the previous movies of Amir Khan was Taare Zameen Par which captured the learning disabilities very accurately and provided a guidance to many people who could take benefit of it.
@@CrestlessWave
How many people do think see these movies?
How many people do think remember what they saw and try to think critical about it?
Yes art shapes thinking, about it’s also a precious commodity preserved for the privileged & wealthy.
If art would have shaped minds we wouldn’t have elected a fascist in government, who support trickle down economics.
I watched LSC movie today!!! Absolutely liked the movie!!! Aamir never disappoints us!!! Ignore all the negative reviews!!! Everyone will connect to the movie as there are all kinds of emotions in this movie (mother,friend,wife,son)...All the major events of Indian history are covered in this movie...This movie is perfectly adapted!!!
I really enjoyed the film. I was thoroughly entertained. Aamir was a bit over the top but it doesn't harm the essence of the film. I don't know what you all saw. The movie was beautiful.
Being a Punjabi, I agree with your point that in Jug Jug Jeeyo atleast Punjabis were shown normal and Punjabi wasn't used much and where used it was good ,Same in Shershah but In LSC 👎👎
👌👌
@@umeshmakhija5922 As a Punjabi, Shershaah's Punjabi was mediocre, even for Chandigarh ale. But it was only a little and the movie overall was amazing
We Tamils understand, I sincerely hope hindi cinema stop attempting to "portray us".
Personally I don't understand this over representation of one set of minority. Watching Indian films you'll think it was all punjab and punjabis. Thank god for the south movies.
In JJJ, Punjabi actors were running the show. So it had to be natural.
Aamir's acting was a mix of PK and Dhoom3 stammering. Didn't like his acting, it felt monotonous. Young Lal's expressions and calmness was really great to watch!!
Forrest Gump is way better!!
No! IT WAS A FANTASTIC MOVIE! WILL WATCH LAAL SINGH CHADDHA AGAIN
Abe bsdk .. yha PE AK ko ek bimar ladka dikhana h.. or Jo junior LSC h wo bilkul Amir se match kr rha h.. story bht achi h... Tumlo jese ludu log yha Gyan dete ho.. q ki yh bat tum jante ho asal me tumhari koi sunta ni ...
@@Bani_Maini 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Yeah it was obvious from trailer itself
@@Bani_Maini lol
One anecdote about Forest Gump is that Tom Hanks had worked and prepared his character w.r.t. how he looks, walks and talk. However, just before the shoot started, during the younger guys preparation, they noticed that the kid is not able to pick up the accent Mr Hanks had finalized and they found the kids original accent interesting. So Mr Hanks reworked on his accent and adopted the kids original accent.
Just as we feared, after seeing the trailer.
So surprised Aamir performed this way after we have already seen what SRK did in My Name Is Khan in such a controlled, restrained manner.
Aamir seems to have played this role out in a very 90's way.
I think you made a very good point about how important it is for a director to be able to make those calls, and for an actor to be self aware enough to realise how the pitch may just be too off.
Ab toh raita phel chuka, aur gol gappa bhi kuchal geya.
srk is god of acting
You know brother, i think srk in my name is Khan would have been more fit treatment of this character..albeit not that gloomy as SRK's performance.but yeah he felt organic there
@@abhisheksinghbhadoriya1926 atleast he doesn't abuse hindu
@@utsav2776 agree completely.. business wise and as a trajectory of Indian cinema SRK was leaps ahead of Aamir who is perpetually stuck making remakes and copies of Christopher Nolan. Many are saying SRKs cameo is worth more than Aamir's acting in LSC
Also it is well known that TZP was directed by Amole Gupte but Aamir sidelined him. RDB was well known for the sentimental value and great acting from Sidharth, Sharman, Kunal kapoor and Atul Kulkarniwhere Aamir was mediocre at best.
Srk would have been apt for the role
I am thinking of Shah Rukh in My name is Khan. Rizwan is shy and Laal is outgoing so they are different, but Shah Rukh's sincere portrayal makes Rizwan so endearing that I feel Aamir could have taken some notes from it.
Definitely!❤️
Liked Aamir too
Srk is srk when it comes to play characters.
SRK was playing character that had Asperger’s syndrome highly intelligent in the autism spectrum. Laal doesn’t have that condition, He is just mentally slow to understand things.
@@baronharkonnen7894 srk was exceptional only in swades, chak de india my name is khan and fan ❤❤❤
Aamir Khan's performance was decent but this movie is a true masterpiece. It's a shame that it failed due to toxic publicity. In time, people will realize that this movie is an underrated masterpiece.
When he said "The good" I was like,"Ahh Shit,here we go again"
I feel sad for Aamir Khan because 4 years are wasted. I wish Aamir Khan next movie should be comeback film for him.
@@thespiderman49 hv u been paid to comment this everywhere ? Get a life dude !
@@kenadams6839 I went to watch the movie and boy such a waste of time and money it was😭
@@thespiderman49 bro feel sorry for u that u spamming this comment again and again.People already have liked it no matter how much intellectual or not still it was good adaptation and will be huge hit
@@vinayakmishra754 people have liked it too so
The ongoing Korean web series "Extraordinary Attorney Woo Young Woo" has portrayed the Autism way better than what Aamir Khan did in this movie. Even I think that attorney woo also sounds like caricaturish sometimes... But still it was way better than this... And SRK from "My Name Is Khan" is without any doubt best performance.
Okay now we know that you watch korean web series and you're intellectual
Park eun bin is doing wonderful in that drama..amazing acting .
@@nacromancer6492 😂 bts bts bts
@@nacromancer6492 lmaoo
@@nacromancer6492 okay what🤣🤣🤣
There was a time when I would blindly go watch Aamir's movies just to see his acting skills. But now, PK, Dhoom3 and LSC characters seem similar. I miss those performances from Sarfarosh and Gulam where he was just so authentic. In today's time, I think his performance Dangal was pretty good.
I watched LSC movie today!!! Absolutely liked the movie!!! Aamir never disappoints us!!! Ignore all the negative reviews!!! Everyone will connect to the movie as there are all kinds of emotions in this movie (mother,friend,wife,son)...All the major events of Indian history are covered in this movie...This movie is perfectly adapted!!!
@@forthright4882 kitne paise mile bhai? itni bakwaas movie...mai paise barbaad karke aaya...acting skills were nowhere near the movie of forest gump...why make a remake, when u can't provide the same level of acting
@@dinosaur669 aapko kitne pesa mile tum esa hamesha Boycott Boycott karte ho!!! Bhai movie sirf Aamir acting sey nahi chalti... movie story sey chalti h ...movie emotion sey chalti h...iss movie m mother , friendship, wife,son sabka impotance dikhaya gaya ... Important national events dikhaya gaya... mujhe bore bilkul nahi lagi...pata nahi aap log kyu pasand nahi h!!! May be there is hidden agenda for u to give negative reviews for this movie
@@forthright4882 important national event dikhaya gaya? gawar insaan...tell me jn which national event were there involvement of mentally challenged personal in the Indian armed forced, and that also in para troopers... chutiyo ki tarah dusro ki recommend kar rahe ho, when i clearly said i saw the movie and it was a pathetic one... gawar boycott karne waale dekhne nahi jaate movie... i watched the movie and it disgusted me... puja paath karne se malaria failta hai? mere secular nature ki wajah se movie dekhne gaay tha, but aamir is a pathetic moron, why not say namaz padhne se malaria failta hai? chutiya pehle khud snetiments hurt karte hai fir sorry bolte hai fir se hurt karte hai...get lost with ur useless critics... the movie is pathetic, the 28 crore in 3 days is a living proof...that the movie itself is pathetic
tum jaise logo ko aamir gobar bhi dega to sona kahoge...u guys dont have any individual opinion... bus aamir ka movie hai to acha hai... thugs of Hindustan me bhi tum jaise chutiye the...jo keh rahe the achi movie bani...use to boycott bhi nahi kiya tha kisi ne...
@@forthright4882 lagta hai aapne forest gump nahi dekhe hai. Dekhe hote toh aap lsc bhul jaate.
The Good at first means you can skip it
The Bad at first means Don't miss
skip it 😉😅🤣
I feel sad for Aamir Khan because 4 years are wasted. I wish Aamir Khan next movie should be comeback film for him.
@@thespiderman49 yall saying the same sh%% to SRK. let's see wait for pathan
bakwas movie ....
@@thespiderman49 dont why he take so much time to make a movie , even to make a remake movie he is taking 3-4 years . even the orginal forrrest gump was made within months . Maybe the comeback will be after another decade
What disappoints you more is that you get a caricaturish performance by an actor like Aamir Khan. It would have been a pass if it was an actor who hasn't delivered memorable performances.
I still get goosebumps thinking about the scene in Rang De Basanti when he breaks down while having food after the lathi-charge incident at India Gate.
It really breaks your heart to see an actor as good as him make such choices.
My pov: Amir is an average actor but he used to choose better movies
same sentiment brother. I have not been bummed out like this in a long time
Bahubali = Nonsense🤣
Vikram = Garbage🤮
RRR = Waste🤢
Brahmastra = Time Waste 🤣
Avengers and Avatar = Useless😝
Only KGF🔥🔥 Bigger than Holywood
Whole World Waiting for KGF 3 masterpiece🔥..
@@moviez4u138 I hope this is sarcasm
@@moviez4u138 are u fine vro?
Being from south India, I use your English reviews to decide if I want to watch a Bollywood movie or not. I regret that I didn't see this in theatres based on your review. All the negative that you pointed out was overshadowed by the positives. It's a wonderful feel good movie for me and an above average comedy drama. 🙏
Movies like Forest gump and The Shawshank Redemption should be left untouch. Period!
Couldn't agree more!
True that ❤️❤️
True!
Yeah you should have also kept Forrest Gump spelling untouched !
@@ankurbhardwaj1057 its fine this is not an English class!
Keep aside story, music, direction, acting......I just wanted to know when will bollywood stop copying movies in name of inspiration?????
@@gagansingh7026 scene to scene copy, doesn't mean inspiration, and you can't defend the movie as the makers themselves are saying that this is official remake of forrest gump, so yeah it is remake or you can say adaptation, but it is not an inspiration.
@@gagansingh7026 nothing beats like original content boomer.
Rajamouli has got so much INSPIRATION from hollywood movies that he has not done a single original thing in his entire career
@@random-jn8ec He ripped off the Lion King for Baahubali and RRR's story was very generic. As a director he's amazing though.
@@Scribbly_Chi_10 no one ever claimed this took inspiration from Forrest gump. It was known from the very beginning that this was supposed to be an "adaptation", which is exactly what it is.
I can't believe I didn't watch this movie. It is such a beautiful movie and Amir was good. That childlike innocence was so on point.
Going by the trailer, this is no surprise. Aamir is over the top. I loved Dangal when I watched it in the theater. But with time, I've come to see the flaws. Instead of telling the story of two young girls in wrestling against a patriarchal background, Aamir has kind of forcefully tried to make it about his character, the girls' father. The scenes where he's locked up, running, crying. All unnecessary. Lending nothing to what was actually going on. Just a star trying to forcefully get into more scenes.
Amir needs to tone it down. It's very off putting to see 'acting' as compared to actors who don't look like they're acting but just being.
true in case of Dangal , i thought the same wen i was watching the movie honestly 😅People are more matured now to understand the technical and emotional standpoint needed for the script nowadays and can clearly voice out wen its over the top n forced 🥵🧐
Yet people ended up loving King Richard , which had similar issues for me
You didn't understand dangal or what? It was the story of mahavir phogat only...👀
Now this is just unnecessary criticism 😒
The movie itself was on the life of mahavir singh phogat
Hater listen
Where is it written that Dangal is about the girls?
Or did amir khan direct himself?
No and no
So you are wrong by default
It’s been 28 years since ‘Forrest Gump’ and no one thought it’d be nice to have it as a series since it’s episodic?
28 years
I feel sad for Aamir Khan because 4 years of his hardwork is wasted. I wish Aamir Khan next movie should be comeback film for him.
Good things come to and end
@@thespiderman49 bruh stop spamming ffs
@@thespiderman49 yes if he stops repeating his expressions in next film
The child actor did such an amazing job. It's a shame to waste the amazing groundwork created for the character with such aplomb. The poise that Tom Hanks delivered was sorely missed. Even Rizwan Khan type of performance would have done the trick better over not being able to emulate Forrest. The PK/Dhoom3 pitch is just not it.
This is a huge difference between being a perfectionist and a self-proclaimed perfectionist.....sadly, aamir falls in the second category, his script choices might be, no doubt, unquestionable, but his acting in every film is not something that it should portray us as the greatest, (barring few exceptions like lagaan)....honestly, this "perfectionist" word only suits to late Irfan Khan❤
👌
Lol you forgot 3 idiots,dangal,pk, how can someone be so foolish like you and public has set his name perfectionist ,he has never called himself perfectionist.
So true.
I feel sad for Aamir Khan because 4 years are wasted. I wish Aamir Khan next movie should be comeback film for him.
Hmm...true
I Never supported the Boycott and watched second show in my city Nagpur, Eternity Mall....Now I m thinking that I should have supported the Boycott 😭😭😭😭😭😭....
Congrats for wasting your time and money...
Support boycott
Thats how stupidity works without see the original and trailer properly u went to movie . Boycott is just publicity.
😂
Don't believe reviews, comparisons or propaganda, go and see this film without any influencing factors and you will really appreciate it.
IMHO those who wants to see the movie will see it irrespective of any reviews
Jammy explaining the good first and underwhelming later give me a gist of the film... I have already watched forest gump and for no remake can take it's place...
Happy Rakshabandhan to all 💐
I feel sad for Aamir Khan because 4 years are wasted. I wish Aamir Khan next movie should be comeback film for him.
@@thespiderman49 bro stop spamming this everywhere. We get. U r disappointed.
@@thespiderman49 Neither Amir could save the film, not your fake sympathy by spamming the comment section with the same copy pasted message will do any good.
@@thespiderman49 why to feel sad if Aamir have thought before working in laal singh chaddha and have worked in some other genre with an original content then he would have made a good comeback
I have no idea how I knew it but I KNEW this movie wasn't gonna be up to the mark like Amir's other movies.. The wide eyed act gets tiring to watch after a while 😩 the kids and Kareena actually did well as Jammy said👌
Kareena was amazing!
Yeah, I think his "wide eyed act" started way back in 3idiots... Check" Zoobie Doobie" song.😂
@@pathfinder289 he does that when his character gets excited or over hyped. watch andaz apna apna or ishq. he does that wide eyed thing there as well.
Laal Singh chada is a great movie and aamir khan acting was superb
Don't judge without watching movie
Unpopular opinion: I don't think Aamir has ever been a good actor.....his script choices have been quite amazing post lagaan but I never thought he was some absolutely amazing actor and also, I've never understood this "perfectionist" tag he's received his body transformation in Dangal was amazing and praiseworthy but it isn't some unseen feat he's achieved
PS : I'm talking solely abt his ACTING not his film choices
No not unpopular opinion, but truth! Indian audience don't hv d mental faculties to discern good acting fm platonic, over d top acting.
That's why Irffan, nawaz, kay kay, Raj kumar rao r not mass stars but mediocre lot like Khans, Kumar r.
Actual movie enthusiasts r aware.
So true... He's just overrated.
@@tiger3091 Bhai mere jab ghar mein khaane ko khaan anahi hai toh kisiko ko ghanta farak nahi padta kaun bhdiya actor hai kon nahi log bas enjoy karne jaate hai India mein
@@viveknaskar I'm talking abt his ACTING not his film choices
@@viveknaskar good movie
Weirdly I feel really sad because I don't want the movie to be bad and I feel bad for Amir khan bcoz he has worked on this for so long. Same with BRAMHASTRA, It is such a labour of love for all that worked behind this along with Ayan Mukherjee. I hope BRAMHASTRA delivers. I always root for good indian cinema when such fine and hardworking actors and directors are involved. I am a fan of some particular indivisuals in the industry, so I feel really sad when their films don't work.
Same
No need to feel sad for anti India propaganda peddlers druggists and mafias. They deserve every bit of hate the masses give them for going against India and promoting nepotism
Bro, Kahe ka feel bad, film was not even original still failed to deliver. Don't know why this film's production and post production took so long. Amir performance was underwhelming, probably took this much time bcz of covid and some personal life problems. But 🤞 for brahmastra hope this film is good and worth the wait.
BRAHMĀSTRA WILL DELIVER. 🤩
Amir ka lele fir
The most disappointing fact is that the movie might become a flop due to its content itself, yet it will give bliss to those who running so called boycott campaign. Not a fan of bollywood, yet don't like the negativity around it.
The issue with indian film industry is that the A list actors are just catering to their star power in the movie & not letting themselves into the character. If u see hollywood, the biggest of big actors just give up their stardom for character they are playing, so you see a character rather than an A list actor.
Amir's acting is mediocre and the reason why he is a star is that he has done some really good films which returned profit. So bollywood fraternity placed him as top actor coz he promises a profit in the business. Though it is not the case in the recent time as Amir's film flops big time. He became egotistical to a point where the movirs he is doing getting the impact of it. There is said it.
Actor driven industry
he gave many mega hits. dont judge him based on one bad movie. its ok. he was not that great, at the same time he was not unwatchable also so chill. Dear RUclips Expert.
You said the point man! But the thing is the A-list actors in Bollywood were never great actors. They were always average whether it's SRK, Salman, Amir or even Akshay. Give them a character showcasing many emotions they fail or give average performance. I'd say that only Amir is one of them who wanted to do some meaningful (and by that I mean he also worked for it, transformed himself and did good acting, whether it's lagaan, dangal, taare zameen par) in Bollywood but he is failing lately. Apart from him SRK, Akshay, they are just doing business.
We made mediocre actors as A list actors. Whereas neglected amazing actors like nawaz pankaj kay kay manoj as side/supporting actors. that's our fault.
Boycott bollywood....i am from schedule caste...maa chudaaye bollywood ....bollywood ne aaj tak kisi SC/ST ko superstaar nahi banne diya ...bollywood ne kewal kapoor ,kher , roshan , kashyap, bajpayee , tripati ,khurana , sinha ,singh aur khans logon ko ijjat di hai
Making a remake of the movie that managed to snatch the academy award for best movie from 'The Shawshank Redemption', the highest-ever rated movie on IMDB, is not a child's play. LSC may be hit or flop, but it gives a clear message that its better not to touch classics. And I honestly believe that the people who'll watch LSC would be either die-hard Aamir fans or those who can't read even subtitles of Forrest Gump.
That was the year of Pulp Fiction too.
It shows ur immaturity. Many people like to watch the movies in their own language than reading subtitles. Language is an important tool of emotion. Just because u watched the original, it’s childish to underestimate the people who want to watch the movie in their language.
Forrest Gump is dubbed in Hindi. So, those who can't read subtitles, can see a Hindi Dubbed version.
Original is original. Dubbed version is very near to original. Almost all remakes, which try to add something, fails. Specially, to the person who already saw the original movie. Because, our mind starts to comparing.
@@SidVidZid that was a good year for Hollywoods. I mean so many classics 🥰
@Aravind R 😂😂 boss language alone doesn’t makes a film to be watched. It’s an added flavor to many people. Ultimately the movie has to be good.
How Forrest ended up in USA army? During the Vietnam War era, between 1964 and 1973, the U.S. military drafted 2.2 million American men out of an eligible pool of 27 million.
There is no draft system in India, not possible for mentally in stable to be selected.
The young Laal is a promising actor. What a screen presence!
🤣🤣
he was actually sincere and nice!
I feel sad for Aamir Khan because 4 years are wasted. I wish Aamir Khan next movie should be comeback film for him.
@@TriedRefusedProductions Aamir was sincere too
@@thespiderman49 Kitna spam karenge re baba
That wide eye acting was cringe in some scenes...
Apologies if that hurt Amir Khan fans ,but it's true
✌️
That's all Aamir has when he has to portray characters who are mentality handicapped.
bro dekhna jau ya nahi?
Why to apologize? R they going to be h$$d u?
True
Hey, I don't know if you read comments on old videos, but, I just watched Laal Singh Chadha on Netflix. To bo honest, I like it! It's wholesome! It's actually good if you don't watch it with the eyes of critic. I found Amir Khan's acting to be pretty good. He did manage to do a good job. It's a good movie in my opinion. If it was released in pre COVID era, it would've been quite a hit.
Why on the earth Aamir and the other creators of this movie thought that humming will be the best method of portraying the innocent yet intelligent kind of personality for Laal......Just can't understand
Tbh this movie hardly had any hype. I didn't know it'd be releasing today. Which pretty much sums it up. Even aamir who's known for his unique and extensive marketing, didn't promote it like his previous ventures. Most probably the makers saw the original again after completing this one and realized hugg dia😅
The only hype it had was the negative hype by the boycott gang.
Aisa hota toh wo log OTT release karwaa lete bhaii
His overconfident! He thought his fans will watch..
Also the tamil dubbing was shit
@@ankitapattanaik6059 😁
In every review, Kareena is being unanimously lauded for her brilliant performance as Rupa. Great job Bebo!
The Internet Reviews are divided into two different groups. One is only bashing the movie for no reason and one is only praising the whole movie without any reason. Both parties are ideologically driven to promote their agenda.
But it’s good and Refreshing to see a actual honest unbiased opinion or judgment or a review from your side 🙏❤️
#TriedAndRefusedProduction
Loved it
You missed the third group, the legends like Dhruv Rathee who is saying it as masterpiece and even better than the original 😂😂
@@SahilJain6 I m not into “Paid German Shepherds” !!😂
These fringe-termites are mostly ideologically corrupted, manipulative hypocrites on sell, just for few easy Holliday-money from their masters !! THEY ARE ACTUALLY ON SELL 🤫
#DhruvRathee #OurOwnDesiGermanShepherd
#GermanRathee
@@SahilJain6 Bro really? 😂
@@SahilJain6 you mean dhru tatti😂
I never thought this day would come when I would question Aamir Khan's acting abilities.. for us he's the perfectionist
Bro this guy is below average dancer still he shows his skill. you yourself watch and perceive it Aamir is good by most viewers 's standard
@@talhaejax8589 I think most from muslim viewer
Dont worry no one in over seas talk about our shity love story movies but movie like dangal, my name is khan, aamir is perfectionist for a reason to bring a perfect revolution in 2000's Era when everyone was doing saas-bahu/pyar mohhabat type movies
@@belimvasim143 he always had a good script but he is a mediocre as a actor
Bhai kabhi ishq, mela, lagaan aur thugs of hindostan me amir ki acting ghatiya nahi dekhi ?
Loved Bala and Mohammad friendship with LSC, I guess you are really reviewing this movie keeping Forest Gump in mind. Don’t forget most people haven’t watched Forest Gump and would love their stories.
Kuch bhi hojaaye idc brahmastra should not fail....I cant see 10yrs of ayan mukherjee's hardwork going into the drain 💔💔💔
It is a very important film for indian cinema ..i hope it turns out to be good 😶
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I mean it it's a bad experience, it then has to fail,but yes,it shouldn't fail before it reaches the theatres or atleast when the reviews come out.
🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂
Agree Yaar!
if the content is bad, then its bound to be a flop
My name is khan was a better adaptation of Forrest Gump without being an ‘adaptation’ of Forrest Gump.
True
Absolutely right
Well you got it wrong - except stretch of last 10 min ( marriage - death and final school) it was a solid heartfelt movie - acting was more than competent- and brilliant song - in the world of bycott and OTT we are not realising theatres will soon closed - we are into the most pessimistic time or era- every thing get dissected by 10 % of people on internet which influencing majority-
I see some sensible comments ❤️among the Bhed chaal comments
The moment I heard about a remake with Amir, I was thinking about what Thanos was telling about balance to Gamora 🙄 A little towards one side or the other, it's ruined! Tom Hanks has balanced the original character so much that it's iconic.
The fine line between perfect acting and overacting!
Thanos is wise.
That's actually sad because I actually wanted this movie to give competition to original. I wanted it so good that international film audiences watch it and compare the both versions like happens with two versions of same screenplays i.e with CODA, A Star Is Born, West Side Story etc.
Unfortunately, we were defeated miserably. Aamir should work on his acting skills.
Haha they don't even like our original movies and you are talking about remakes?
We educated Indians understand Propaganda in movies. Don't show indirectly emotions for terroritst and don't show Indian army stupid. If Aamir has good intentions then give interview and talk about wrong things written in Quran. For knowledge go to Exmuslim Sahil or Adam Seeker youtube channel.
@@truth6074 exactly
Bollywood does not have the skills to remake any foreign film!
@@whatsinaname2706 mostly you're right, but Taxi No 9211 was a good remake of Changing Lanes, don't you think?
Agree when u say, the songs and kareena are the only saving grace of this movie! Wish kareena would do more movies, she is such a joy to watch on screen 💜 didnt understand the unnecessary comparison to jug jug n shershah though 😏 aamir just need to gracefully admit he went gravely wrong with his passion projects twice in a row and move on. Also goes to show the power and money these male superstars command, to audition kareena for this role but didnt care to check if he himself is capable of doing it! Also has a personal gripe towards this man for having had 2 marriages and leaving the kids fatherless, not cool 😡
Aamir is a brilliant actor. But he's far too powerful for lesser directors. He overrules them. He works best when his own spin on the character is kept in check.
Take Ghajini for instance, Surya was phenomenal because he wasn't portraying a person who was angry, he was lost. Aamir on the other hand was just angry, I never felt he was lost in his own mind. The same was in Dhoom 3, way over the top and history has repeated itself with Lal Singh Chaddha. Innocence doesn't mean idiocy. Tom Hanks carried the innocence Aamir looks like a cartoon. Our actors need to take a backseat and allow the creators of these stories to portray their vision rather than hijacking the story tellers vision to feed their own grandioseness.
Absolutely right, though I haven't watched LSC, I completely agree with your comment. People like Aamir feel like they know too much to not take over the character, and that messses up the film itself. The actor should be a vessel for the character, but here its the other way around. I would like to highlight Randeep Hooda's performance in Sarbjit as an example of what I said.
Very good observation.
True he even guides the musicians in his films I mean let them do the creative job why u forcing your opinion
Agree
Lawda actor
His acting & expressions is same from the last few films & I don't find any variation in acting but amir is such a legend who gave so many great films .. For me in this film South star Naga chaitanya did so well 👍 ... One time watchable an emotional journey
Thank you movie was so bad and his acting in this movie is not so great
Amir is legend 😂😂😂😂😂
My strong recommendation to everyone here is to watch telugu movie "Swati Mutyam" that was released in 1986. Kamal Hasan and Radhika are lead pair. Trust me, you'll thank me for this recommendation after watching it. It is said that Forrest Gump was made after being inspired by this movie. This movie is available with english subtitles. I hope that you'll watch it and appreciate the greatness of Indian Cinema
But forest gump movie itself was the adaption from the book..i don't no what the book name is...you can search in the Wikipedia...
@@lakshimiakshithavoloju2006 The book you have mentioned is titiled same as movie i.e. Forrest Gump. It was written in 1986. Well the point here is, as said, the movie's team was actually inspired from Swati Mutyam when it was screened at some international film festival. Being inspired by the movie, they wanted to make a movie of similar theme, i.e a feel good life journey of an innocent man. They were equally impressed by the novel Forrest Gump, thus chose to use it for the movie after making changes to the certain areas of basic plot. One of the alterations in story from novels was climax. It is evident that the makers wanted to retain the feel good factor involved in Swati Mutyam.
@@LOKANATHAREDDYKATTA even the fether scene in forest gump was portrayed in kamal movie named guna. To describe kamal mental illness in that movie. Guna released before forest gump.
What about this ????
Movie is offensive to the Indian Army.
Do the makers of LSC indent to condemn the Indian Army for defending the Nation from invaders? "I don't like the Army that kills people", says a misleading dialogue! How pathetic!!! Does Indian Army kill without reason OR only when attacked? Are the ones killed some random people, or are they enemy.
There must be a reason why Aamir didn't salute the Lady army personnel in a recent episode of KBC when Amitabh and all the audience were saluting her. Connect the dots sir
@@ketan7537 he said that the camera wasn't on him when he was saluting.
@@Anonymous-bf5fk Lie, right hand is visible and salute is done with right hand. Check again sir. You'll also find Aamir zipping his mouth when everyone was shouting "Vande Mataram"
And somebody in the comment section wrote that there was this line in which he said "me puja path nhi krta, usse malaria failta hai aur dange hote hain". I don't knwo the context behind it but that sucks lol. Why would he chose to have such kind of dialogue and line
@@ketan7537 but why would he choose not to salute when the entire crowd is?
If shahrukh khan was cast as Laal Singh Chaddha, he would have nailed it like he did in my name is khan.
exactly.... srk portrayal of khan in 2009 was way ahead of time whereas amirs portrayal of laal in 2022 where there is so much awareness looks so artificial
Kahe ka nail??? Ek dum bekar movie thi my name is khan. Chak de India aur Don chor do toh SRK kuch km nhi hai Salman se. Ekdm bakwas acting aur dono overrated
Sharukh is waste in front of amirs acting
@@himanshu0921 ☠️my name is khan bekar movie hai? Ganja phukke comments krta hai kya andhe hater ?
@@himanshu0921 this comment shows your taste of movie's.
I actually really enjoyed the movie in theaters but completely agree that it’s really hard not to think of PK or dhoom 3 or 3 idiots in this movie - I especially did not even think about the fact that the crazed look went away in his elder age and wasn’t there in his childhood - so true ! The inconsistency doesn’t help . Nonetheless I enjoyed this story for what it was, and Kareena was an absolute essential she had a true complex character
I wish somebody from his crew dared to tell Amir to improve his acting otherwise it is gonna ruin this beautiful movie. Even in Thugs of Hindustan the worst part of the movie was his over the top character and acting. Very sad to see such minor mistakes which has huge impact on overall movie from such a great actor.
are you twin sister of filmi indian deeksha sharma
I really wonder how a performance can go so wrong. We all know Aamir Khan can be an amazing actor, so makes me think that even the most experienced actors sometimes don’t understand what the perception of their performance will be until long after they’ve given it, at which point it’s too late. Hope the best for his future projects.
Your ability to find good in big banner films without receiving a single dime in sponsorship or suffering a blow to the head, continues to astound me
Its the ability to perform different roles with great versatility that differentiates good actor from great actors. Vikram from deiva thirumagal and kamal from swathimutyam are some of the gems which portrays autistic people perfectly.
My god! Didn't thought that someone in this comment section would have known about vikram's portrayal in deiva movie. When you see Vikram in that movie you cannot draw similarities with any other character he has played, infact that's the thing with most of the characters he has played. I have seen his work and still I couldn't see him being same as he is in other movie. That is what acting is about. Whereas here Aamir looks like pk and Samar from dhoom.
no one in india is close to kamal in terms of acting , vikram is not far behind
Commenting for better visibility and+1
@@TrendxTube the last court scene was really terrific so many emotions conveyed without uttering a single word
Can SRK in MNIK be considered?
Aah as expected.. Aamir has really been disappointing in this film. I really don’t understand why there was a need for this over the top over acting.
Believe me, this will be a cult classic. Also people are missing the philosophy of advaitvaad of Shankaracharya which it is bringing up. There are so many philosophical layers which reviewers have not been able to comprehend.
THINGS JAMMY WONT TELL YOU -
1. There were many historical events shown but no mention of Kashmir Genocide. Importance to Rath Yatra where a masjid was demolished was given but no important to Genocide of 4,00,000 people ?? Afraid ?
2. In forest gump, gump saves an American army commander where's in LSC, lal saved a Pakistani terrorist and in rest of the movie, subliminal sympathy towards him is created.
3. Gump joins army because American army opened recruitment for all during Vietnam war where as there is no mention of Indian army opening recruitment for specially abled people like Lal.
This movie is a pure Joke
Rightly pointed out...well researched mate
Now you know why boycott was happening and who is the so called writer of this movie.
Also he said that doing Pooja creates dange. I don't know why he opted for that line
Bang on! Every time I want to give Aamir the benefit of doubt and forget the past, he does it again. His ulterior motives are so clear.
I'm done with you Aamir Khan ×
@@nknkannadiga9742 and believing in a desert warlord is not? See what his majhub has done to the world. Amir is a jihadist. He loves to promote nectrophile pedophile desert madman religion
Don't miss " kartikeya 2" in Hindi this week
Honestly this was a good reamke and did do justice to forrest but an original will always be the original
Although I was very apprehensive regarding Aamir's performance when I watched the trailer I must say that it was a 'hit and a miss' portrayal by him where in some moments like when laal's mother dies, when laal talks to rupa in the last scene and when mohammad paaji's farewell scene Aamir did touch a note in me and having watched the original i was looking forward to these scenes. As for the other scenes, yes he was very over the top but the supporting cast except naga chaitannya made it tolerable especially the music of the film. So As a whole it worked for me better than I expected it to from the trailer!!
I felt only Kareena did well in that movie although it looked like her story was not properly written, when she was trying to jump from the building, I couldn't relate but she did justice to whatever she was given. Mohammad paji also did great compared to Aamir.
With the amount of network, money Bollywood has they should at least try experimenting with different stories, giving chances for new and talented actors rather than making remakes and adaptations. Audiences today have realised content is the King and they are tired and frustrated with mass hero - masala movies that eats your brain and waste your time & money.
You saw the collections of KGF, Pushpa and Sooryavanshi, right? Audience today wants that larger than life experience. It's unfortunate but I don't think a film like Kaahani will now be successful if released in theaters.
@@priyanshuagarwal2837 it's not unfortunate. What's wrong in
Wanting well made masala movies?
@@ishabargale3216 there's nothing wrong in making masala movies. I enjoy them a lot. I said unfortunate because a film like Kahaani has no place for a theatrical release in this day and age now. It's an OTT film now.
Bollywood filmmakers is worst storyteller in the world
Sorry Jammy this is the first time that I disagree with your review. I just saw the movie & while Aamir’s portrayal comes of funny for the first 15-20 mins, it grew on me that I forgot about the comical nature of it. Sure there are some missteps through the movie but the Indian adaptation is fantastic & I was thoroughly engaged throughout visually & emotionally.
Maybe a second viewing might make you feel the same way
Forrest gump feelings can never be remade again Tom Hanks just killed it totally in it 💛💎
@Sourav Patra can you suggest some Good films then?
I don't know how the movie is...but I think Rating movie on Imdb without even watching the movie is so foul... IMDb is a joke now. It's hard to find an unbiased review when every other review is polarizing
Reviews now a days are more predictable then any movie ever could be.
been saying this since 2019, its a sham and should not be considered to be an indicator to a films quality
I feel sad for Aamir Khan because 4 years of his hardwork is wasted. I wish Aamir Khan next movie should be comeback film for him.
I feel the IMDb rating is only reliable after it has good number of votes to it. There aren't many platforms apart from rotten tomatoes to rate the movies globally.
@@aayushagarwal5666 nope it is only reliable when movie isn't pan India, and when not everyone knows about it.
Very clean and unbiased review, good work
A big fan of you, Jammy!
As a literature graduate, I find your reviews highly accurate and unbiased!! Thank you for that!❤️
I feel sad for Aamir Khan because 4 years are wasted. I wish Aamir Khan next movie should be comeback film for him.
yo, what are your career options after getting a literature degree? I'd really like to know.
@@thespiderman49 stop spamming
Bahubali = Nonsense🤣
Vikram = Garbage🤮
RRR = Waste🤢
Brahmastra = Time Waste 🤣
Avengers and Avatar = Useless😝
Only KGF🔥🔥 Bigger than Holywood
Whole World Waiting for KGF 3 masterpiece
Unbiased...hahahha!
Post Lagaan,I find stability is missing in Amir's acting and character.It appears like he is in some hurry to finish his lines and scene.That is the reason why it becomes difficult to emotionally connect with him.Totally opposite is the case with Shahrukh,that he tries too hard to dominate in each scene by occupying most of the shot and dialogue.Both actors should understand that they are the carriers of the story,not the story themselves.They can learn from their own previous films like Lagaan,Tare zameen par or Chakde.
I am worried sick for Brahmastra now given the state of LSC and Shamshera 😢 have already booked tickets for Saturday show LSC few days back and I am not happy about it now 🥺
You may actually like it; He didn't like Jug Jug Jiyo, but I really enjoyed it; now I'm planning to watch LSC on Saturday and let's see how it goes for me....
The truth is Aamir is not a great actor. He is convincing of course in all his movies but he doesn't have shades. His gift is picking good talent in his movies and getting that emotional connect with his audience. That's praiseworthy but his acting has never stood out to me since I have been watching him since the 90s.
I am glad it failed. I don't wanna see copies of movies or remakes anymore.
This is the 21st Century:
We have Torrent and several OTT platforms and can access any platform, even local ones through VPNs.
We have great dubs from any language to anyone.
I don't wanna see the excuse of remakes anymore.
Vikram vedha: helloooo😁😆😂
@@laveenr I hope that fails too
Whole career of akshay kumar says hi
First time I see a video with English title about India, and the video is also in English! What a twist.
नमस्ते एस्पान्या से।
Aamir Khan needs to stop playing younger character or hire a younger actor to play him in his 20's like the west does, for example moonlight each phases of the character is played by different actors. I think his efforts are genuine but it's not going in the right direction to where it needs to go, he needs some introspection with projects otherwise it will go against him in a long run.
Cinematic liberty plus this guy is having anupumps syndrome
Extremely good point
True
You should stop criticizing Hindi movies for bad Punjabi, simply because it's a Hindi movie not a Punjabi film. Also, what is the point of examining such things with a magnifying glass, it's just a movie made for entertainment; your education and other real life commitments need this kind of attention. Also, Anil Kapoor, Neetu Kapoor, Varun Dhawan and Siddharth Malhotra are actual Punjabi's, so their Punjabi would obviously be better than Aamir Khan, who is not a Punjabi. You have clearly not learnt anything from the Sushant Rajput controversy; you are still playing to the gallery.
I only wanted to watch this movie because of Kareena Kapoor Khan and she did complete justice and it was her movie !
Iam happy that atleast kareena did a great job. Really hope she continues to do roles with lot of scope for acting coz she is very talented as an actor.
I was excited for this film feeling that maybe Aamir Khan will have his own performance stand out by staying true to the role. Forrest Gump has a very emotional and inspiring story. If the remake is given justice, it can easily strike a chord in anyone's heart, be it an Indian or not.
This year I have rooted for so many Hindi films to be hit and to make an emotional connection with the audience. I was miserable when Shamshera flopped.
I hope LSC becomes a BO hit tho
People are talking about his acting.. not criticising the direction,
So direction is also bad.. but what’s the acting 😭
Why should bad movies should get hit
@@vreeshasingh2564 becuz Indians took bollywood so seriously, its become a part of their life which is stupid.
they want to live in delusional world instead of living in reality and face life.
Another shamshera kinda day for you bro it seems😉
I still think Shamshera was much better than it got credit for 😔
Watched more than 100 reviews of lsc
Your review is so best🔥
I’ve been a big fan of Aamir. He’s the son of great Tahir Husain saab. As his son, I’ve always felt that Aamir should’ve been a mass hero like Salman, but the people around him have turned him into a social activist. I saw the disaster LSC coming the moment I saw Kiran and Atul were involved in the creative process. They have their own political agenda.
The thing about Forrest was that he used to think literally. There was a scene where Bubba gets shot and he asks why it happened. Thinking literally, Forrest replied, “Because you got shot!”. Forrest never tried to entertain the audience. He was stupid to other people, but his struggles were real. He tried to convey his lack of understanding through thinking literally, poor choices of word etc, . But here Aamir tried to manifest his simplicity through weird facial expressions. In South Asia, directors often think that’s how you show simplicity on screen. Kabir khan made the same mistake in Tubelight, even though Bajrangi character’s simplicity was more realistic.
Advait is a mediocre director. I saw that in Secret Superstar. In every interview, Aamir keeps telling that he’s very careful about who is the director. But recently that hasn’t been the case. Because after terrible Secret Superstar and Dhoom 3, Aamir shouldn’t have worked with the directors again. But here we are
There were many red flags in the trailer itself. First replacing the American football with sprint / race was a big mistake. They could’ve at least used rugby since the director took many creative liberties. I remember how funny Akshay was in Namaste London with that rugby scene. The humor in that scene took the movie to a different level. Second, replacing shrimp with underwear. I mean what they were thinking!! Naga’s character looked more like Chatur from 3 idiot. It would’ve been okay 15 yrs back. But now people are more exposed to South Indian movies, so the stereotype not gonna fly imo.
Choosing Kargil War, World Cup, 1984, 26/11 is the easiest way to make a movie biased and prone to propaganda. And the writers couldn’t just resist the bait. There were many other historical moments in India which could’ve been more suitable and aligned with the humor and message of the movie
The biggest casualty of LSC is the Jenny character. They just couldn’t understand her
Yeah but was not engaging here people have actually liked him but some didn't
Ppl around him havent turned him into a social activist.It is a conscious choice Aamir made and that worked for him! Similar to Akshay kumar..There's two genres that worked best in indian cinema..Romance and action..Romance was takn over by SRK n Action was taken over by Salman..The third would be comedy bt Aamir is not good at that..That just leaves out films with social messages..Aamir realised that if he doesnt stick to that genre he may disappear into oblivion...
@@shyamalidas2815 that could be true too
@@shyamalidas2815 may be yes. But I say it's a good choice amir choose this path. His tare zamin par, rang de Basant, dangal vl speak fr himself even after 2 or more decades. Bt I don't think people vl remember these action n romantic movies
Everyone is comparing amir's portrayal with PK. I am so shocked that no one is mentioning SAMAR from dhoom 3, the character is exactly same
Ikr
The young Laal's eyes just encapsulate you. They way he looks at his mother
Review starts at 1:48
The Good -
Music by Pritam (All Songs)
Cinematography (Locations)
Young Actors & Kareena Kapoor
VFX (Turthful)
Underwhelming:
Punjabi Language
Unconvincing & Forced (Chaitanya + Manav)
Aamir same as in PK / Doesn't Understand that Less Is More
Flowed with it ..
Not one of best of Aamir but definitely delightful lucid movie
Loves it's cinematography, music and the amazing way a Hollywood classical masterpiece is Indianized. It never feels like in a others shoe..Loved how subtly different phases of Indian landscape and socio- political history is woven. And how beautifully and unpreachingly the message of " curing the malaria" is voiced. Rupa, Mhd Paaji and Lal's mother was so wholesome. Maybe when the context outside the movie will be forgotten , people will love it like Knockout, Salesman of the year, Wake Up Sid was liked or like lesser known beautiful movies such as Mee Rasqam, Lunana - a yak in the classroom, Skater Girl, Purna etc eventually are appreciated.
If you haven’t watched Forest gump which I am sure 80% of people in India haven’t , they would actually love this movie. I have watched both , and for the Indian twist this was FAMILY FRIENDLY, Whereas Forest gump is an Adult Film. The only part I didn’t like was the chaddi banyan sequence. I was satisfied he died 😂. Aamirs approach was good. But the wide eyes was not required. The young Laal was so natural. Aamirs felt like it was forced.
Forest Gump should have been left alone☝🏻Amir totally messed it like RGV messed up with Sholey. We are sorry Tom Hanks🙏🏻
I think Kabir Singh did the best in terms of using Punjabi in a Hindi movie. It was real and the masses understood it as well. It is more to do with how comfortable the actor is with language and if he isn't comfortable then the language is sure to be butchered. Irrfan Khan was so comfortable in speaking the language of Paan Sing Tomar which added to his flawless performance.
"Luv Shuv te Chicken Khurana" is the best movie that used proper Punjabi. But when you want to reach so many people then you cannot have proper Punjabi. It is a double edge sword.
Movie was beautiful these are hindutva people trying to destroy the movie
How dare you criticise Amir!!!
You know he cried during the screening of this movie and you call him forced or caricaturish. This is the problem with today's generation, they don't appreciate fake tears of overhyped actors!
#insertsarcasmhere
You had me at first
Sympathy and quality are 2 different things you know. Even I argue everywhere for Aamir for judging his movie without watching but this movie is just Average family entertainer compared to previous Aamir's movies.
@@ishabargale3216 😁😁😁
@@infernalone8894 Amir is a hypocrite.
@@fayz221 how is he a hypocrite?