Witness | Tales from the Scrap Sidings 2 adaptation

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 7 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 65

  • @22Tesla
    @22Tesla Год назад +59

    Not a bad adaptation! I'm glad to see some of my other works getting some love :) Loved it

  • @dragongamer7139
    @dragongamer7139 9 месяцев назад +6

    Loved that you used the Jedi theme to demonstrate Howard's passing.
    R.I.P. to a great engine

  • @bliaher1582
    @bliaher1582 9 месяцев назад +3

    You know the sound of distant British Rail diesels locomotives has always had an Erie tone. The sounds of diesel engines. The sound of horns as they pass in the distance. I've always loved it but yet feel unsettled by the sound.

  • @kidz4p509
    @kidz4p509 Год назад +8

    “Well, my story takes place not only a long time ago, but on another land. Once a safe haven, this place turned into a hunting ground. To be caught is a death sentence. When caught, a long, drawn-out death by slow dismemberment await. But what’s worse? To be on death’s door, or is it to be a... [Witness]?” - 22Tesla as Wolfgang Shepard.

  • @KelvinRogiers
    @KelvinRogiers Год назад +17

    Awesome job John, nice to see you used my BR Oliver, Scrap K1 and B17 reskins.

  • @matthewpowell2429
    @matthewpowell2429 Год назад +7

    This is close to how I imagined the passing of non-faceless engines in my AU. Interesting Adaption.

  • @An_Sudrian_LBSCR_Mogul
    @An_Sudrian_LBSCR_Mogul Год назад +23

    That was quite a story and a sad one too
    It hit a rage with those two Diesels taking the rest of Howard. In case this video was amazing ✨ *100/10*

  • @ciarangleeson2880
    @ciarangleeson2880 Год назад +17

    After seeing all the stories from the first season get adapted umpteen times, it’s nice to finally see that someone adapted a story from the second season.

  • @oliverhood1732
    @oliverhood1732 Год назад +20

    God seeing an engine pass away when they die in their sleep when you’re nothing more than a faceless engine and I think Howard is at a better place now

  • @carterher8082
    @carterher8082 Год назад +15

    This reminds me of the North vs the South during school
    I even saw Oliver talking with Jan and Bradley, but I still wonder how he feels about Howard though

    • @thomasnumber1609
      @thomasnumber1609 Год назад +5

      I bet Oliver feels bad for Howard. To see him alive one day & die the next, he thought he was going to burst into tears. I wish Howard did join Oliver on his escape to Sodor.

  • @peckettproductions
    @peckettproductions Год назад +27

    Wow what a story those poor engines..

  • @noorayneladha470
    @noorayneladha470 Год назад +19

    Damn now that was disturbing and grim I actually saw a steam engine die before my eyes. That must have been horrifying. Nice adaptation keep it up. 👍

  • @mcbenman1793
    @mcbenman1793 Год назад +18

    This is fantastic, always wanted an adaptation of this story. I love anything escape related. There have been so many great escape adaptations recently and this is just a cherry on that scrap cake. Well done. Keep up the great work

  • @VestedUTuber
    @VestedUTuber Год назад +8

    RWS: Cruel diesels and railway staff actively go out of their way to cut up steam locomotives for fun and profit on the mainland.
    IRL: Many steam locomotives in the UK were rescued because it was cheaper and quicker to cut up unpowered rolling stock, and then sell the locomotives whole for their scrap value. Locomotives were only dismantled if the scrapyard couldn't find a buyer for the intact engine.

    • @fanofeverything30465
      @fanofeverything30465 Год назад +1

      The former is more dramatic

    • @VestedUTuber
      @VestedUTuber Год назад +2

      @@fanofeverything30465
      True, it's just kinda surprising knowing how Awdry typically tried to keep things realistic.

    • @fanofeverything30465
      @fanofeverything30465 Год назад +1

      @@VestedUTuber Sometimes realism has to be sacrificed for drama Although I think some railway staff did go out of their way to scrap steam engines in real life

    • @VestedUTuber
      @VestedUTuber Год назад +3

      @@fanofeverything30465
      Forced scrapping did happen with some companies in the US. It's why there's no surviving NYC Hudsons, for example.

    • @fanofeverything30465
      @fanofeverything30465 Год назад +2

      @@VestedUTuber I know all about that Alfred E Perlman was the Head of New York Central and he wanted all their steam engines scrapped because he felt that if any survived it would make NYC look old for some reason

  • @OliverFeatherwing
    @OliverFeatherwing Год назад +10

    i love the star wars thing you did there

  • @Bulbasaur617
    @Bulbasaur617 Год назад +11

    This adaptation to this story isn't bad. I think it looks good. About time other stories, besides the most used ones, are adapted. Well done here.

  • @FictionalADDON
    @FictionalADDON Год назад +12

    Just hiding in plain sight.

  • @Zerneygreensaberman0728
    @Zerneygreensaberman0728 Месяц назад +1

    I love this video and rest in peace to you too Howard. You had a great life as a steam engine.

  • @ChrisMemphisBoy
    @ChrisMemphisBoy Год назад +6

    D5701 is probaly the biggest murderous psychopath in BoCos family

  • @grayscaleproductions8518
    @grayscaleproductions8518 Год назад +13

    13:29 RIP Howard

  • @EmmettDoyleDDR435
    @EmmettDoyleDDR435 Год назад +5

    0:05 Rotten Robbie with a green screen internet who made a short quote for all of us.

  • @evangaines2303
    @evangaines2303 Год назад +8

    Awesome remake, great job

  • @SPG69
    @SPG69 Год назад +8

    3:58
    Okay how did they not notice him? 😂😂
    I know it’s an adaptation but still, Oliver is sticking out like a sore thumb right now
    Good adaptation btw

    • @Optimaloptimus
      @Optimaloptimus 10 месяцев назад

      You would be impressed by how oblivious many people can be. Poor peripheral vision contributes to it as well as being distracted and not looking around.

  • @BrendynRobertson
    @BrendynRobertson Год назад +3

    This is a brilliant adaptation.

  • @nanisprestlye4830
    @nanisprestlye4830 Год назад +6

    *this a real witness* amazing work

  • @MrRocklover18
    @MrRocklover18 Год назад +6

    Love that intro 😂

  • @stuartbarclay7940
    @stuartbarclay7940 Год назад +8

    Great work, mate!

  • @phattrel6023
    @phattrel6023 11 месяцев назад +4

    This happened in 1967

  • @evanclarke5561
    @evanclarke5561 Год назад +2

    Poor Howard. Those diesels were very mean

  • @MSCPictures64
    @MSCPictures64 Год назад +12

    Nice remake John, 10 out of 10 😄

  • @RiverDoncaster
    @RiverDoncaster 8 дней назад

    XD I love the homage to Robbie rotten.And also the fact that you used it as a way to be like.Hey this is not child safe

  • @Kirby-jj6cy
    @Kirby-jj6cy 10 месяцев назад +1

    I cried at the part where he past away 😭

  • @Bomby_MVRail
    @Bomby_MVRail Год назад +6

    Dame it I was late!
    Because I had school

  • @thelegoboy55
    @thelegoboy55 Год назад +2

    This was a good story not scary but dark perfect for Halloween

  • @mcbenman1793
    @mcbenman1793 Год назад +4

    Can you do smokeless mainland please?

  • @jesperbergstrom5076
    @jesperbergstrom5076 8 месяцев назад +1

    I like the intro 😂 we are number one

  • @mcbenman1793
    @mcbenman1793 Год назад +2

    What station yarrd was the yard oliver hid in meant to be?

    • @J.Tstudioproduction6375
      @J.Tstudioproduction6375  Год назад +2

      Mostly the abandon Kirk Ronan branch route that was made by wildor wester, I use wayback machine to search the old archive of wildor wester old website to look or search for some of the old routes that were once made by him many years ago.

  • @kasiadupuis1159
    @kasiadupuis1159 Год назад +6

    Do smokeless mainland

  • @ThatdudenamedPizzaman
    @ThatdudenamedPizzaman Год назад +4

    Ight im giving you a like just for the intro

  • @jjmcnamee6404
    @jjmcnamee6404 Год назад +5

    Nice

  • @mergiesuda6888
    @mergiesuda6888 11 месяцев назад +1

    I felt bad for the engines.😢

  • @BNSF_8213
    @BNSF_8213 Год назад +2

    Nice, also, where'd you get the loco's/rolling stock at?