As salaamu alaykum brothers, sisters, friends and foes. Please like, share and comment on this video, as well as subscribing to the 5Pillars RUclips channel! Jazakallah khayran.
What the hell u scumbags talking about. Muslims killed millions of hindus. They smashed thousands of temples. They wrote it down themselves many o fthem did do u want me to put those references up for u? The whole world knows this.
Sheikh Adnan Rashid is a don... before his talk on Indian Muslim scholars, I literally had no idea how important and what kind of role Indian Islamic scholarly thought has played in Islamic history. Would love to hear more about the Central Asian scholars.. i know Bukhari (RA) is from Uzbekistan ashamed to say I dont know anyone else from that part of the world. Africa as well. In the UK most of us have been bought up with the Saudi scholars and the students of Madinah, which is good but its great to hear Islamic takes from other parts of the world.
Imam "Muslim" r.a is also from the central Asian side,he belonged to a city called Nishapur,imam termezi r.a, also belonged to us,, you should also know that imam abu khanifa in reality belonged to the centeral asian territory,his father r.a migrated to Baghdad in the time of hazrat ali r.a, and was the direct student of hazrat ali r.a..if you learn just Urdu, you will come across the ocean of knowledge insha Allah.. besides that,,my brother you should know that, the salafies/madkhalis, wahabis are a political party more than a religious one,,it took its current form after 1980s, after the Iranian shiaas khumenis revolution, for the race of , the leader of the Muslims world.. they started to begin calling every single Muslim,as a kharijis, misguided, non Muslims,bedghati etc etc..
@@nee1008Hinduism have multiple gods with different beliefs or nuances and each group believing in a separate god. Muslims were a majority and a power so the British needed to equalise that by consolidating smaller faiths groups under one umbrella. It would be like the Abrahamic faiths uniting all from the same source.
The word "Hindu" was originally a Persian word for the ethnicity who lived in the Indus Valley civilization. It did not denote a religion. So both Pagans and Muslims were also called Hindu. The British turned it into a word to group all the various ancient Pagan religions, cults and cultures in the subcontinent who did not ascribe to Islam. They were basically trying to pit the non Muslims against the Muslims because at the time Muslims were the largest religious grouping that threatened British power. It was a sophisticated way to alienate Muslims as foreigners by stripping them of their Hindu ethnic identity. It's similar to how European Colonial powers managed to alienate European Muslims as "Turks" despite most Muslims not being Turkic. Even the Ottoman Royalty themselves were less than 5% Turkic by the 18th century. And the Ottoman court language itself had less than 10% Turkic words. The only reason Turkey is called Turkey today is because a European backed secularist dictator calling himself "father of the Turks" forced everyone to speak Turkish in the early 1900s.
@@Lagosawee looks like you do not understand the religion base of India . Sanatan is ideology of all the religions of India . Abrahamic religions do not belong in India !!! Abrahamic religions believe in conquering and bloodshed !! No king of India has ever invaded the land of their neighbours !!. Adnan Rashid has a hatred of all non Muslims and especially Indians because he is a loyal Pakistani . Pakistan is a shit hole and their leader Jinnah was a pork eating and whiskey drinking . Mr Adnan what is the state of minorities in Pakistan and Bangladesh !!!. Non Muslims in Muslim countries are treated as second class !!!. When Muslim invaders came to India they came and killed in the name of Allah !!! They killed millions of Hindus an destroyed thousands Mandirs !!! The Muslims burnt a 3000 year old library !!!. Now it has come full circle and the the Hindus are in charge of India . India is a Hindu country and there will be no gazwe hind !!!. In all Muslim countries they shout and scream " kill the kafirs " !!!. In the name of blasphemy a Christian colony was burnt to the ground by Muslims . The churches and bibles were burnt . Islam belongs in the desert of Arabia !!!. Adnan your forefathers were Hindus !!!. Hating your heritage is what converted Muslims do !! Why don't to go on RUclips and speak to Adam Seeker or Sahil ???. Why isn't Pakistan a peaceful place ??? You have a Muslim government and Pakistan is 97% Muslim .
48:46 Hindus are not divided by Rajputs, Jats, Marathas. The religion is called as Sanatan Dharma. Jats Marathas Rajputs are identities of particular states. Like for ex: Marathas live and belong to Maharashtra, Jats and Rajputs mainly from Punjab & Haryana and Rajasthan resp.
They were in the past. Are you stupid? Listen to him from a neutral point of view. He has listed historians. Check the sources. Emotional Indians lmao.
1947 - about 100.000 muslims met their demise during the height of Kashmiri fragmentation. Some of their surviving descendants, well they... you do the math.
@@soedirmanfighter5319 so? Two wrongs don't make one right. What happened in 1947 cannot be settled for by the genocide of those who probably didn't have any direct role in what you are talking about. Islam mein fasaad ko pasand nahi kiya gaya hai. Repeating what others have done to us is not going to make us look better or bigger than them in character. Islam kal bho akhlaaq se phaila tha, aaj ke halaat mein bhi akhlaaq se failega aur hamesha akhlaaq hi uski sab se badi wo taaqat hogi jo use doosron se differentiate karega
There are 33 million ethnic Pashtuns in Pakistan, Pakistans involvement (while some mistakes were made) in Afghanistan was to remove the Soviet influence from the region. On Bangladesh, that was a failure of the leadership at the time, most Pakistanis have no issue with Bengalis, however there was a leadership in charge of Pakistan at the time which handled things badly, PM Imran Khan acknowledges these mistakes.
The leadership in Pakistan was terrible at that time and still is. The Pakistani military regularly take over and politicians are even worse because they sew ethnic division to get votes. The problem is that some Bengalis decided to use this situation to go full nuclear and help India destroy the subcontinent's only Muslim state. The same thing happened years ago when the Bengalis decided to side with the British against the Mughals, kicking off the British Indian Empire. The British paid them back by cutting Bengal in half and destroying it's economy.
@@SandiegoRockstar The leadership today is a lot better than it was then. That is a fact. As far as the military taking over, at times coups have been essential. I don't see Imran Khan as a promoter of ethnic division, rather the opposite, and someone many Pakistanis respect. The likes of Zardari and Altaf of the MQM are history, and not respected at all. The ANP have been massively corrupt and are no longer a force in KP. - On Bangladesh, they're now a reality, i hope they prosper and advance, i know many on the ground don''t have hatred for Pakistanis at large.
@@SandiegoRockstar The bengalis didnt side with the british against the Mughals. The British empire and the bengal subah fought in three different battles and bengal lost and got invaded. The british then created the east india company in bengal and looted the whole subah. And regarding the 71 conflict between Pakistan and Bangsladesh, after theyve been massacred (murdered, raped and pillaged) and largely because they were ethnic bengali and seen as a lower. There is no blame on them for india assisting them against oppression but then people like yourself want to mention the One muslim state? When they were massacaring the bengalis there was no Muslim, Islam or Ummah there but as soon as india got involved and relieved them from oppression pakistanis decide to use islam and muslim to guilt trip them, absolutely hypocritical. The blame for the destruction of the muslim state goes to West Pakistan, if were being entirely honest.
@@stranger7660, it sounds like you have not heard of Mir Jaffar. Like Mujeeb ur Rahman, he was a Bengali nationalist leader who sold out the Mughals to the British, giving them their first entrance to the subcontinent. He actually appears in the top ten list of traitors in history. listverse.com/2012/06/19/10-notable-traitors-in-history/
@@stranger7660 your right, Pakistan responded to Mujeeb ur Rahman's war with barbarity and massacres which is why I said Pakistani leadership was terrible. But don't try to hide the fact that Mujeeb ur Rahman also carried out massacres of his own. His daughter still executes political opponents to this day, especially those that criticize India.
The economy is actually quite resilient, check out the book "Pakistan a hard country", Pakistans shadow economy is close to 50% of nominal GDP. There was a balance of payments issue, which has been dealt with thanks to support from the Saudis, along with deep corruption, which is being rooted out. If anything Pakistans economic trajectory is upwards.
@@entername_ Export numbers have gone up, check the statistics. This political instability is bad and Pakistan still needs to expand it's export base further, and once it does that, to a serious degree, these BOP issues and having to go to the IMF will be ancient history. I see Technology as the one area that can add to exports in a big way in the medium term. Another short term issue has been the global rise in commodity prices. A lot of Pakistan forex reserves (which in turn have been built up (in part) by borrowing) are spent on importing oil and gas, so any increase in commodity prices is going to affect the value of the rupee. The way to deal with this is domestic E&P in the energy space, this needs multiple sectors to be in sync, also domestic focus on renewables beyond hydro. 2 of Pakistans biggest issues right now are export numbers that are not good enough to stave off BOP issues and adequately deal with the debt situation, and issues around energy. If these are properly dealt with, and we see the sort of GDP growth rates seen elsewhere in Asia, Pakistan becomes one of the strongest economies globally.
It's the constitution of india that promises equality for all citizens And it was served until the politically crippled ideology of hindutva came into existence Savarkar was nothing but a bigoted communist with no moral sense or anything
TTP were RAW funded and backed, this has been shown through depositions and statements by its former members such as E Ehsan. K Yadav (a RAW agent) who was caught admitted to the RAW support for groups with similar aims to the TTP
He talks about minority y don't he talk y all minorities in Pakistan has come to fall of almost 2% and on the other hand c the Muslims in India from 7-8% to 17%😂😂😂😂
From where did u get this data From WhatsApp University Hindus were both in Pakistan... when combined .. after partition Bangladesh had more Hindus .. It was obvious Hindu population of current Pakistan will decrease If u have any other proof .. but authentic u r free to give it
48:55 Another widely spread propaganda. Brahmins, Khastriya, Vaishya, Shudras are not caste. According to Sanatan Dharma, its varna system. Basically it means : Brahmins are teachers of religion, Khastriyas are warrior class, Vaishyas are businessmen, shudras are working class or peasants
It is caste. Brahmins are considered superior to Khastriya, Vaishya and Shudras. Shudras are at the lowest denomination. Stop lying. Everybody knows how sick the caste system is in Sanatan Dharma. Don't you see how poorly Dalits are treated in India?
haha, the game in the start. I think I would make the same choices as him. btw your pronunciation of Jinnah was hilarious, when you said Allama Iqbal, then I understood who the other person could be. good stuff.
What hinduphobia? Since independence we voted for Hindu parties , even today Aimim which is vocal for Muslims has only one seat in Parliament and you say there is hinduphobia, come to your senses . Hindus don't want to accept that the problem is with them .
Sir,it is really commendable that you recognize india was under feudal rulers both hindus and muslims over parts of india before 1947 with the central authority of British crown.
34:37, exactly the same point was taken by the Muslim scholars before 1947,of not dividing the india, and eventually the Muslims will come to power even if the sistem is "democrazy "..
My message to my Muslim brothers in the from the sub continent Afghanistan Bangladesh India & Pakistan Oh Muslims of the sub continent UNITE under the Kalima. One Ummah.
I believe there was a great time in Islam, first of all when Prophet was there, then there was the time about around the year 800 i believe in Bagdad, then of course Ottoman Empire. And the beautiful and rich period when India was ruled by Muslims - sorry Hindus. Allah knows his plans. It's almost too much to hear how Muslims are being oppressed. Especially in India!
@@syedwaseemakram7006 Destroy toh kiya na Waseem sahab , ek baari kro ya 10 baari . Toh mere bhai Mongols also destroyed University of Baghdad only once . When you condemn it , condemn this as well . One sided approach doesn't work.
Democracy for muslims of India is bad because muslims cannot rule but these two muslim debaters live in a democracy called England where they are minority but living and expressing their ideas freely. This freedom is provided by democracy even if you are in minority. The Muslim league wanted power to rule not the freedom of democracy.
I think Br.Adnan says Dr. Israr as bias bcz he is Pakistani. Bcz I dont think Dr.Israr Rahimahumullah even can come closer to Dr.Zakir Rahimahumullah in case of success, influence and knowledge in different field like Quran and Sunnah and fiqa ,Quran and Hadith understanding, comparative religions ,science,talent, understanding of grammartical and linguistic Arabic. Dr.Israr Rahimahumullah is better as speaker not as Knowledge. BCZ Dr.Israr quotes many Daif Hadith also ,I like Dr.Zakirs understanding of Hadith and his differenciation among Sahih or Daif Hadith.Dr.Zakir provide Fatwas of Muhaddis from Salaf .
that's not the sunni perspective, Qassem Suleimani was one of the people who helped Iraqis and Kurds against ISIS and helping the Palestinian resistance against Israelis we are seeing the fruits now in 7th of October
Allah gave a chance to Indian Muslim by secular constitution and teachings of Gandhi and Jawahar Lal nehru. Past seventy years of peace we didn't use the chance to introduce Islam to Indian people.
Islam did not need introduction to Indians. Islam is already well introduced into hearts and minds of Indians. Indian Hindus, especially educated Hindus, learn about Islam from young age because Muslim culture is part of Indian culture. We don't see South Asian Muslims as the "other", but we "Hindus" (actual term is Dharmic) have a very ancient culture that dates back to 3000BCE to the creation of the Rig Vedas, and that comforts us. We fundamentally believe in reincarnation and karma, and these are things that all the great early Indians espoused including Siddhartha Gautama the Buddha. So for educated Hindus, Islam is an important part of Indian culture, but we have our own great belief system that is compelling.
59:24 Modi went to Lahore to meet Nawaz Sharif on his birthday. What did India get ? Attack on Pathankot Airbase. Vajpayee met Nawaz Sharif in 1999 : Kargil happened. 2 years later : Attack on Indian parliament happened.
Dilly , it took me 6-8 podcast of yours to see mindset , respect !! But why do you interview only people of one ideological aspect ? That too a Pakistani mindset !!
58:00 Precisely! I would go a step further and say it's time to reunite India. If West and East Germany can be united why can't India and Pakistan ? Without Sindh there can be no Hind. It's to reunite the borders of Bengal and Punjab.
Why break our country in name of religion why divided our country into Bangladesh and Pakistan no trade until kashmir is accepted as part of india and gives Gilgit baltistan back to us and Pakistan accept their ancestors were hindu forcefully converted and come back to faith of their ancestors kashmir is name given after Hindu sage rishi kashyap most kashmiri are hindu converted from kashmiri Pandits kashmir was is and will always be integral part of India and Hindu hatred in Pakistan stops
Islamic empire spead by sword but islam as a faith never forced it spread by sufies and people got tired from your vrna vyavstha , You people proved that jinnna was right Hindus are not trustworthy.
It is a huge country. That logic is applicable to Pakistan but not India. The logic and its application by these debators is totally hilarious and hypocritical.
Where are all the minorities in Pakistan?? India has a large and prosperous Muslim population, this guy is lying and talking half truths. Please talk about forced conversions In Pakistan and the flight of of Pakistani minorities to India and why Indian. Muslims minorities are not fleeing to Pakistan?
Are you kidding me he's a complete idiot and i'm not saying this just because i hate him or anything but i'm saying that because he's an absolute fool and idiots like these are created a generation of idiots and the worst part is these type of mindset people are everywhere in pakistan and south asia and i'm saying that as a muslim
Sahaba traveled to deferent places to propagate Islam. But jinna and sir said only think about Muslim community. Not about Islam. Maudoodi and abulkalam asaad think about Islam and it's propagation.
Having half the world's Muslim population (600M people) live under Hindu majoritarian rule would not help Islamic propagation in any way. Islam has propagated much faster when a Muslim state exists.
@SandiegoRockstWhy the fuck we muslims are living in dichotomous thinking that we have come from ruler to ruled category nowadays government is not so strong it is only for show the community holding larger business and education lives best lives not the one who lives not everymuslim had ruled india
Adnan doesn’t half talk crap Iram are the only Country fighting isis and the west wtf has Sunni Islam done for the world ??? And last time I seen Yemen it was Saudi who was bombing Yemen full of crap !
Wow this was so interesting - I had no idea about half of the history of India other than the fact that it was ruled by Mughals for a long time. Despite being Muslim myself, I do think there would have been some forceful conversions here and there - the Mughals were far from perfect and did discriminate from time to time. Also I was quite shocked to hear that the Maratha empire was devastating for India - I will do my own research into this. Furthermore has anyone realised that some of the MOST islamophobic ethnicities of India tend to be the Marathas and Gujaratis?
As salaamu alaykum brothers, sisters, friends and foes.
Please like, share and comment on this video, as well as subscribing to the 5Pillars RUclips channel!
Jazakallah khayran.
This was disappointing. How are you doing a podcast with Adnan Rashid for only an hour and a half?
@@criteriagoodmanners you had us in the first half not gonna lie
What the hell u scumbags talking about. Muslims killed millions of hindus. They smashed thousands of temples. They wrote it down themselves many o fthem did do u want me to put those references up for u? The whole world knows this.
Please include the list of books highlighted in the podcast. Really insightful and very informative. Jzk
A democracy is two wolves and a sheep, deciding on dinner.
One of the best ones thus far, keep it up inshallah. Muslims in the uk can really do with a history lesson.
A highly informative discussion.
A lot to digest and certainly a must watch for all.
Jazakallah khayran!
I am india lucknow adnan rashid truth speech
Pakistani aur mugal ki aulad yahi soch sakte hai
Please do some more pocasts on history with Ustad Adnan. It was very informative and educational.
Future podcasts with Adnan Rashid are already in the pipeline!
We are still waiting alhamdullilah
@@5Pillars
been two years and still nothing
@@5Pillars any updates on this
@@5Pillarsnever happened
Sheikh Adnan Rashid is a don... before his talk on Indian Muslim scholars, I literally had no idea how important and what kind of role Indian Islamic scholarly thought has played in Islamic history. Would love to hear more about the Central Asian scholars.. i know Bukhari (RA) is from Uzbekistan ashamed to say I dont know anyone else from that part of the world. Africa as well.
In the UK most of us have been bought up with the Saudi scholars and the students of Madinah, which is good but its great to hear Islamic takes from other parts of the world.
The islamic history of bengal is very rich
Imam "Muslim" r.a is also from the central Asian side,he belonged to a city called Nishapur,imam termezi r.a, also belonged to us,, you should also know that imam abu khanifa in reality belonged to the centeral asian territory,his father r.a migrated to Baghdad in the time of hazrat ali r.a, and was the direct student of hazrat ali r.a..if you learn just Urdu, you will come across the ocean of knowledge insha Allah.. besides that,,my brother you should know that, the salafies/madkhalis, wahabis are a political party more than a religious one,,it took its current form after 1980s, after the Iranian shiaas khumenis revolution, for the race of , the leader of the Muslims world.. they started to begin calling every single Muslim,as a kharijis, misguided, non Muslims,bedghati etc etc..
One suggestion: pls let ustad Adnan speak...
Masha Allah, great video ,I am big fan of Ustad Adnan❤.
May Allah's piece and blessings be upon you both❤.
Really appreciate you raising 1971 - need to ask the tough questions. The credibility of the podcast has gone up in my eyes.
Good podcast. Very informative. Thank you 5 Pillars.
Thank you for watching!
The British dived Muslims and Hindu but how did they create Hinduism ? Hinduism is much older than all 3 Abrahamic religions
I'm a Hindu. I think Hindus were always there but the banner of Hinduism may of been created by the British. He may have a point there
@@sugs1191yes, most probably he means the banner of Hinduism
@@nee1008Hinduism have multiple gods with different beliefs or nuances and each group believing in a separate god. Muslims were a majority and a power so the British needed to equalise that by consolidating smaller faiths groups under one umbrella. It would be like the Abrahamic faiths uniting all from the same source.
The word "Hindu" was originally a Persian word for the ethnicity who lived in the Indus Valley civilization. It did not denote a religion. So both Pagans and Muslims were also called Hindu. The British turned it into a word to group all the various ancient Pagan religions, cults and cultures in the subcontinent who did not ascribe to Islam. They were basically trying to pit the non Muslims against the Muslims because at the time Muslims were the largest religious grouping that threatened British power. It was a sophisticated way to alienate Muslims as foreigners by stripping them of their Hindu ethnic identity. It's similar to how European Colonial powers managed to alienate European Muslims as "Turks" despite most Muslims not being Turkic. Even the Ottoman Royalty themselves were less than 5% Turkic by the 18th century. And the Ottoman court language itself had less than 10% Turkic words. The only reason Turkey is called Turkey today is because a European backed secularist dictator calling himself "father of the Turks" forced everyone to speak Turkish in the early 1900s.
@@Lagosawee looks like you do not understand the religion base of India . Sanatan is ideology of all the religions of India . Abrahamic religions do not belong in India !!! Abrahamic religions believe in conquering and bloodshed !! No king of India has ever invaded the land of their neighbours !!. Adnan Rashid has a hatred of all non Muslims and especially Indians because he is a loyal Pakistani . Pakistan is a shit hole and their leader Jinnah was a pork eating and whiskey drinking . Mr Adnan what is the state of minorities in Pakistan and Bangladesh !!!. Non Muslims in Muslim countries are treated as second class !!!. When Muslim invaders came to India they came and killed in the name of Allah !!! They killed millions of Hindus an destroyed thousands Mandirs !!! The Muslims burnt a 3000 year old library !!!. Now it has come full circle and the the Hindus are in charge of India . India is a Hindu country and there will be no gazwe hind !!!. In all Muslim countries they shout and scream " kill the kafirs " !!!. In the name of blasphemy a Christian colony was burnt to the ground by Muslims . The churches and bibles were burnt . Islam belongs in the desert of Arabia !!!. Adnan your forefathers were Hindus !!!. Hating your heritage is what converted Muslims do !! Why don't to go on RUclips and speak to Adam Seeker or Sahil ???. Why isn't Pakistan a peaceful place ??? You have a Muslim government and Pakistan is 97% Muslim .
One of the best podcasts yet !!!! Really informative mashallah
Thank you for watching and commenting!
Love the historic discussions!
48:46 Hindus are not divided by Rajputs, Jats, Marathas. The religion is called as Sanatan Dharma. Jats Marathas Rajputs are identities of particular states. Like for ex: Marathas live and belong to Maharashtra, Jats and Rajputs mainly from Punjab & Haryana and Rajasthan resp.
They were in the past. Are you stupid? Listen to him from a neutral point of view. He has listed historians. Check the sources.
Emotional Indians lmao.
you are divided by current hare krishna vs those who view them as modern day heretics vs hindutva
Just one question, what about those Pakistanis who caused the genocide of Kashmiris in the 1990's why doesn't anyone talk about it
1947 - about 100.000 muslims met their demise during the height of Kashmiri fragmentation. Some of their surviving descendants, well they... you do the math.
@@soedirmanfighter5319 so? Two wrongs don't make one right. What happened in 1947 cannot be settled for by the genocide of those who probably didn't have any direct role in what you are talking about. Islam mein fasaad ko pasand nahi kiya gaya hai. Repeating what others have done to us is not going to make us look better or bigger than them in character. Islam kal bho akhlaaq se phaila tha, aaj ke halaat mein bhi akhlaaq se failega aur hamesha akhlaaq hi uski sab se badi wo taaqat hogi jo use doosron se differentiate karega
Source: bjp news
@@shazsayyed5269Let's face it. Modi is just another Anti - Christ like Obama
An episode 2 with ustad adnan on Islamic history! Would love to pick HIS brain on this❤️😂
Already in the pipeline!
Always a pleasure listening to Ustad Rashid. I discovered him much later on than most, but have been in awe of his knowledge since.
Assalamu Alaikum!
I really admire Adnan Rashid sir, when ever I listen to him, its always to imformative and its give an excellent perspective❤
Always like listening to Ustadh Adnan Rashid
There are 33 million ethnic Pashtuns in Pakistan, Pakistans involvement (while some mistakes were made) in Afghanistan was to remove the Soviet influence from the region.
On Bangladesh, that was a failure of the leadership at the time, most Pakistanis have no issue with Bengalis, however there was a leadership in charge of Pakistan at the time which handled things badly, PM Imran Khan acknowledges these mistakes.
The leadership in Pakistan was terrible at that time and still is. The Pakistani military regularly take over and politicians are even worse because they sew ethnic division to get votes. The problem is that some Bengalis decided to use this situation to go full nuclear and help India destroy the subcontinent's only Muslim state. The same thing happened years ago when the Bengalis decided to side with the British against the Mughals, kicking off the British Indian Empire. The British paid them back by cutting Bengal in half and destroying it's economy.
@@SandiegoRockstar The leadership today is a lot better than it was then. That is a fact. As far as the military taking over, at times coups have been essential. I don't see Imran Khan as a promoter of ethnic division, rather the opposite, and someone many Pakistanis respect. The likes of Zardari and Altaf of the MQM are history, and not respected at all. The ANP have been massively corrupt and are no longer a force in KP. - On Bangladesh, they're now a reality, i hope they prosper and advance, i know many on the ground don''t have hatred for Pakistanis at large.
@@SandiegoRockstar The bengalis didnt side with the british against the Mughals. The British empire and the bengal subah fought in three different battles and bengal lost and got invaded. The british then created the east india company in bengal and looted the whole subah. And regarding the 71 conflict between Pakistan and Bangsladesh, after theyve been massacred (murdered, raped and pillaged) and largely because they were ethnic bengali and seen as a lower. There is no blame on them for india assisting them against oppression but then people like yourself want to mention the One muslim state? When they were massacaring the bengalis there was no Muslim, Islam or Ummah there but as soon as india got involved and relieved them from oppression pakistanis decide to use islam and muslim to guilt trip them, absolutely hypocritical. The blame for the destruction of the muslim state goes to West Pakistan, if were being entirely honest.
@@stranger7660, it sounds like you have not heard of Mir Jaffar. Like Mujeeb ur Rahman, he was a Bengali nationalist leader who sold out the Mughals to the British, giving them their first entrance to the subcontinent. He actually appears in the top ten list of traitors in history.
listverse.com/2012/06/19/10-notable-traitors-in-history/
@@stranger7660 your right, Pakistan responded to Mujeeb ur Rahman's war with barbarity and massacres which is why I said Pakistani leadership was terrible. But don't try to hide the fact that Mujeeb ur Rahman also carried out massacres of his own. His daughter still executes political opponents to this day, especially those that criticize India.
This was an amazing podcast. Looking forward to the next one
The economy is actually quite resilient, check out the book "Pakistan a hard country", Pakistans shadow economy is close to 50% of nominal GDP. There was a balance of payments issue, which has been dealt with thanks to support from the Saudis, along with deep corruption, which is being rooted out. If anything Pakistans economic trajectory is upwards.
@@entername_ Export numbers have gone up, check the statistics. This political instability is bad and Pakistan still needs to expand it's export base further, and once it does that, to a serious degree, these BOP issues and having to go to the IMF will be ancient history. I see Technology as the one area that can add to exports in a big way in the medium term. Another short term issue has been the global rise in commodity prices. A lot of Pakistan forex reserves (which in turn have been built up (in part) by borrowing) are spent on importing oil and gas, so any increase in commodity prices is going to affect the value of the rupee. The way to deal with this is domestic E&P in the energy space, this needs multiple sectors to be in sync, also domestic focus on renewables beyond hydro. 2 of Pakistans biggest issues right now are export numbers that are not good enough to stave off BOP issues and adequately deal with the debt situation, and issues around energy. If these are properly dealt with, and we see the sort of GDP growth rates seen elsewhere in Asia, Pakistan becomes one of the strongest economies globally.
Muslim talking about secularism being as islamic nation 😂😂😂😂
It's the constitution of india that promises equality for all citizens
And it was served until the politically crippled ideology of hindutva came into existence
Savarkar was nothing but a bigoted communist with no moral sense or anything
How dare you not make another episode?
TTP were RAW funded and backed, this has been shown through depositions and statements by its former members such as E Ehsan. K Yadav (a RAW agent) who was caught admitted to the RAW support for groups with similar aims to the TTP
😅😅😅
He talks about minority y don't he talk y all minorities in Pakistan has come to fall of almost 2% and on the other hand c the Muslims in India from 7-8% to 17%😂😂😂😂
From where did u get this data
From WhatsApp University
Hindus were both in Pakistan... when combined .. after partition Bangladesh had more Hindus ..
It was obvious Hindu population of current Pakistan will decrease
If u have any other proof .. but authentic u r free to give it
And Muslim population in India grow from 7 to 17% 😂😂😂😂 this is just a WhatsApp University fact
Hindu people doesn't celebrate muslim population's Increment in india
@@Mnbvv531take back ur muslim brothers..we don't need them😂😂😂
@@Mnbvv531can’t come with comeback and use WhatsApp university 😂😂😂
Adnan Rashid has a great overview of geopolitical situation of the sub contient.
48:55 Another widely spread propaganda. Brahmins, Khastriya, Vaishya, Shudras are not caste. According to Sanatan Dharma, its varna system. Basically it means : Brahmins are teachers of religion, Khastriyas are warrior class, Vaishyas are businessmen, shudras are working class or peasants
It is caste. Brahmins are considered superior to Khastriya, Vaishya and Shudras. Shudras are at the lowest denomination. Stop lying.
Everybody knows how sick the caste system is in Sanatan Dharma.
Don't you see how poorly Dalits are treated in India?
@@maquacr7014 So by your logic Islam is the religion of terrorism
@@harinair3881 no thats just a figment of your poo filled imagination
@@maquacr7014 that's culture created by the British not the religion, read more jihadi
@@gunner9936 The caste system was followed way more before the british came. Not everybody is a stupid whatsapp university graduate like you.
Loving this podcast. Amazing guests. Please continue the good work.
haha, the game in the start. I think I would make the same choices as him. btw your pronunciation of Jinnah was hilarious, when you said Allama Iqbal, then I understood who the other person could be. good stuff.
Exactly choses the same choice,as i would have.. Masha Allah
Muslim should speak against ghazwa e hind and hinduphobia for betterment of india
Why don't you talk about akhand bharat 😂.
What hinduphobia? Since independence we voted for Hindu parties , even today Aimim which is vocal for Muslims has only one seat in Parliament and you say there is hinduphobia, come to your senses . Hindus don't want to accept that the problem is with them .
Sir,it is really commendable that you recognize india was under feudal rulers both hindus and muslims over parts of
india before 1947 with the central authority of British crown.
A second podcast with Adnan Rashid is Overdue.
Keep up the awesome information going 👏
Dilly u looked young 3 years ago.
May Allah makes it easy for you my brother.
We need part 2
34:37, exactly the same point was taken by the Muslim scholars before 1947,of not dividing the india, and eventually the Muslims will come to power even if the sistem is "democrazy "..
My message to my Muslim brothers in the from the sub continent Afghanistan Bangladesh India & Pakistan
Oh Muslims of the sub continent
UNITE under the Kalima. One Ummah.
India under Hindu rule: has exported Indian culture overseas
India under Muslim rule: didn’t consider Indian culture worth exporting
Maratha called Borgi they raided so many times during Nabab of Aliwardi And so on the Britishers crushed them very well
I believe there was a great time in Islam, first of all when Prophet was there, then there was the time about around the year 800 i believe in Bagdad, then of course Ottoman Empire. And the beautiful and rich period when India was ruled by Muslims - sorry Hindus. Allah knows his plans. It's almost too much to hear how Muslims are being oppressed. Especially in India!
Who told you Muslims are oppressed in India? From where do you get all this shit ?
Yeah ,It was also Prophecy or future predictions in Quran that Muslim would rule from west to east and to north and south.
Allhamdullellah for islam
Is maratha and marasi caste the same thing?
Can you please record a podcast with Adnan Rashid where you will ask him about the Muslim destruction of Nalanda and other Indian universities
Nalanda was destroyed three times only one of those was destroyed by a muslim.
@@syedwaseemakram7006 Destroy toh kiya na Waseem sahab , ek baari kro ya 10 baari . Toh mere bhai Mongols also destroyed University of Baghdad only once . When you condemn it , condemn this as well . One sided approach doesn't work.
Jazak Allahu khyran brother
Democracy for muslims of India is bad because muslims cannot rule but these two muslim debaters live in a democracy called England where they are minority but living and expressing their ideas freely. This freedom is provided by democracy even if you are in minority. The Muslim league wanted power to rule not the freedom of democracy.
MASHAALLAH, MAY ALLAH BLESS YOU BOTH ABUNDANTLY IN THIS LIFE AND NEXT.... AMEEN
Jazakallah khayran for your kind words and ameen to your dua!
Beautiful video bro , one of the best teachers Adnan rasheed
mA great podcast, would like to see Ustad Adnan again on the podcast with more info on Muslim rule in India.
😂😂😂 the intro mash Allah, May Allah swt preserve our ustadh Adnan Rashid but very informative thank you.
I think Br.Adnan says Dr. Israr as bias bcz he is Pakistani.
Bcz I dont think Dr.Israr Rahimahumullah even can come closer to Dr.Zakir Rahimahumullah in case of success, influence and knowledge in different field like Quran and Sunnah and fiqa ,Quran and Hadith understanding, comparative religions ,science,talent, understanding of grammartical and linguistic Arabic.
Dr.Israr Rahimahumullah is better as speaker not as Knowledge. BCZ Dr.Israr quotes many Daif Hadith also ,I like Dr.Zakirs understanding of Hadith and his differenciation among Sahih or Daif Hadith.Dr.Zakir provide Fatwas of Muhaddis from Salaf .
Adnan fans assemble
Alhamdulillah good discussion
*_Liked, commented and shared for the benefit of others._*
Jazakallah khayran!
wow it was very informative.
want to hear more from him about Indian subcontinent Islamic history.
Speacially After mughal Period.
that's not the sunni perspective, Qassem Suleimani was one of the people who helped Iraqis and Kurds against ISIS and helping the Palestinian resistance against Israelis we are seeing the fruits now in 7th of October
Allah gave a chance to Indian Muslim by secular constitution and teachings of Gandhi and Jawahar Lal nehru.
Past seventy years of peace we didn't use the chance to introduce Islam to Indian people.
Islam did not need introduction to Indians. Islam is already well introduced into hearts and minds of Indians. Indian Hindus, especially educated Hindus, learn about Islam from young age because Muslim culture is part of Indian culture. We don't see South Asian Muslims as the "other", but we "Hindus" (actual term is Dharmic) have a very ancient culture that dates back to 3000BCE to the creation of the Rig Vedas, and that comforts us. We fundamentally believe in reincarnation and karma, and these are things that all the great early Indians espoused including Siddhartha Gautama the Buddha. So for educated Hindus, Islam is an important part of Indian culture, but we have our own great belief system that is compelling.
@@VedJoshi..
What are the fundamental of your belief?
@@malamakkavuWhat is urs tell 😂😂
I agree with you
What is the alternative of democracy ,which can be implemented in Muslim countries practically.
insha'Allah.. I believe Allah will help our muslim only need to be done come back to way Allah
What Pakistani shaytanic army did in Muslim of Bangladesh, I still remember and cry, i can’t believe a Muslim army can become so evil. Allahuakbar…
Which book did ustadh adnan mention please?
Amazing stuff
Ustaad Adnan Rashid learning history because of u so I can put these Hindus straight with facts
The hell will you teach us?🤣
Good video but brother Dilly please don't interrupt your guests
59:24 Modi went to Lahore to meet Nawaz Sharif on his birthday. What did India get ? Attack on Pathankot Airbase.
Vajpayee met Nawaz Sharif in 1999 : Kargil happened.
2 years later : Attack on Indian parliament happened.
Easter egg right at the end 🤪
I would love to see Adnan Rashid cream Tarek Fatah in an argument.
Tarek would shit his indian made pants
I love adnan rashid and Pakistan but we will not forget the crimes of Zia ul haq
Dilly , it took me 6-8 podcast of yours to see mindset , respect !!
But why do you interview only people of one ideological aspect ? That too a Pakistani mindset !!
58:00 Precisely! I would go a step further and say it's time to reunite India. If West and East Germany can be united why can't India and Pakistan ? Without Sindh there can be no Hind. It's to reunite the borders of Bengal and Punjab.
No, I’m alright thanks 🙏
Fuck your country we’ll burn it to the ground one day
@@DubSalvationunite for regional purposes only without it brown people will be played and unfortunately Hindus have been compromised
Dude , imagine Muslims from Pakistan and bangla annex India, it will become an Islamic country, sharia galore, ur nunni gets nipped ...
very inspirational
Being into music is not bad man, but drinking is
Why break our country in name of religion why divided our country into Bangladesh and Pakistan no trade until kashmir is accepted as part of india and gives Gilgit baltistan back to us and Pakistan accept their ancestors were hindu forcefully converted and come back to faith of their ancestors kashmir is name given after Hindu sage rishi kashyap most kashmiri are hindu converted from kashmiri Pandits kashmir was is and will always be integral part of India and Hindu hatred in Pakistan stops
Islamic empire spead by sword but islam as a faith never forced it spread by sufies and people got tired from your vrna vyavstha ,
You people proved that jinnna was right Hindus are not trustworthy.
1:02:00
HISTORY expert but what was taught in Pakistan.. 🙆♂️🤦♂️😂
King akbar before his death he was praying five times a day
He should have asked shah waliyyullh or ibn taimiyya instead of imam Ahmed
It is a huge country. That logic is applicable to Pakistan but not India. The logic and its application by these debators is totally hilarious and hypocritical.
Great discussion, but chewing paan is considered haraam?
A very hate-filled podcast. Just what I expected. Good Going.
How is it hate filled you idiot? Are you Pakistani?
সৃজন: এটাই ইতিহাস৷ মনমর্জী ইতিহাস কোন ইতিহাস নয়, বরং আইডিয়োলজী
Where are all the minorities in Pakistan?? India has a large and prosperous Muslim population, this guy is lying and talking half truths.
Please talk about forced conversions In Pakistan and the flight of of Pakistani minorities to India and why Indian. Muslims minorities are not fleeing to Pakistan?
Pakistan's fanaticists get imprisoned by state while India fanaticists ( recently rapists ) got protected by ruling party
There is big hindu minority in Pakistan, stop watching godi media and their lies.!!!!
I would prefer abdul hamid khan was political king over auranjeb who was military supermacist
erdogan. the secularist is a 'better politician.'
right.
MashaAllah
So your saying America did a good job for the sunnis
Wasnt ilama iqbal associated with freemasons of thhat time?
Both of these guys, are ignorant to the cores. Now wonder looking at their background
This man Adnan Rashid ustaad should get global coverage who can treat history
Are you kidding me he's a complete idiot and i'm not saying this just because i hate him or anything but i'm saying that because he's an absolute fool
and idiots like these are created a generation of idiots and the worst part is these type of mindset people are everywhere in pakistan and south asia
and i'm saying that as a muslim
I wanted to know about 1971 from him.
Amazing podcast. Much prefer a discussion like this than the debates Adnan has at SC as those just become a bit of a shouting match
Sahaba traveled to deferent places to propagate Islam.
But jinna and sir said only think about Muslim community.
Not about Islam.
Maudoodi and abulkalam asaad think about Islam and it's propagation.
Having half the world's Muslim population (600M people) live under Hindu majoritarian rule would not help Islamic propagation in any way. Islam has propagated much faster when a Muslim state exists.
@SandiegoRockstWhy the fuck we muslims are living in dichotomous thinking that we have come from ruler to ruled category nowadays government is not so strong it is only for show the community holding larger business and education lives best lives not the one who lives not everymuslim had ruled india
Adnan doesn’t half talk crap Iram are the only Country fighting isis and the west wtf has Sunni Islam done for the world ??? And last time I seen Yemen it was Saudi who was bombing Yemen full of crap !
U sound like a knowledgable stupid
Women and children 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 as usual narrative .
51:00 Moguls fighting parathas haha
Wow this was so interesting - I had no idea about half of the history of India other than the fact that it was ruled by Mughals for a long time.
Despite being Muslim myself, I do think there would have been some forceful conversions here and there - the Mughals were far from perfect and did discriminate from time to time.
Also I was quite shocked to hear that the Maratha empire was devastating for India - I will do my own research into this. Furthermore has anyone realised that some of the MOST islamophobic ethnicities of India tend to be the Marathas and Gujaratis?
woooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooh 49: 51 completely lie
That old married 6 year old girl how can he be god
Forst of all he is not god for us by the way youre rabindranath tagore married a 8 year old😂.
Aurangzeb was a great leader