Spectacular. No matter how many times I hear this symphony, I still get chills when the horn players stand "so as to drown out everything…even the trumpets."
This is great!! I love Fabio Luisi's interpretation is fantastic! As a horn player, I enjoy seeing the climax of the Finale being played by the 7/8 horns without support from a trumpet and trombone as Mahler himself placed in the score as an option. I often wonder why Mahler did not utilize 7-8 Wagner tubas instead of standard horns in this passage. Anyone who has heard the Universal Studios fanfare cannot tell the difference between the horn and the tuben until they know exactly where one ends and the other begins and even then it is not so obvious except the tuben project more. My graduate horn professor often referred to these tuben as 'horns on steroids'. I would love to see a performance of this Symphony where the horn players would put down the horns and take up the tuben for these last several minutes of this work. I really do believe Mahler would approve.
Wunderschöne und detaillierte Aufführung dieser spätromantischen und melodisch komponierten Sinfonie mit seidigen Tönen aller Streicher, milden Tönen aller Holzbläser und brillanten Tönen aller Blechbläser. Der zweite Satz klingt echt kräftig und auch beweglich. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im veränderlichen Tempo und mit möglichst effektiver Dynamik, als wäre er ein zweiter Mahler. Wunderbar vom Anfang bis zum Ende!
@@scottmiller6495 What's with the multiple exclamation marks? One is more than sufficient! And so what? I belong to those many and I still think the 1st is heavily overperformed and overrecorded.
Nice interpretation of one of my favourite composers, the feeling is just wow, a mix of different emotions. That's why I love Mahler, Rachmaninov and Wagner.
So true. Same tremendous video quality in Mahler 2, also in the same magnificent hall in Munich, conducted by the Russian guy, Valery Gergiev, who lost his position there because of the Ukraine war
Bravo! Great interpretation, especially the account of the trio-very characterful. And based on the pictures I’ve seen Maestro Luisi looks like Mahler. 👏👏👏👏♥️🎶🎻🎵
Try "Rafael Kubelik Mahler 1" with the Bavarian Symphony Orchestra on youtube. The studio version (Deutsche Grammophon) is even better. Many, including me, regard his interpretation as the best version.
Don't be misunderstood. This version with Luisi and the Staatskapelle Dresden is one of the best I've heard. I just wanted to check some parts of the symphony and ended in listening to almost everything. And everything was done with precision and perfect expression. So, the applause at the end was very well earned.
Fabio Luisi is currently the chief conductor of the NHK Symphony Orchestra in Japan, so I have listened to his performances many times. And I can hear all of his performances sound like opera. Even Brahms and Beethoven. But this performance sounds like a symphony. He's a great conductor!
Like most conductors he slows down at (in this performance) 44:46-45:03 even though the score is marked "a tempo." This destroys the contrast with the later recurrences of the motif, when the score does indicate a change in tempo. Jascha Horenstein is one of the few who follows the score at this point, and the movement benefits tremendously.
I find the termpi in this performance often inexplicable. He slows and speeds the scherzo very oddly, bringing it almost to a halt and then zooming back at breakneck speed. In the third movement when the clarinets break into the 'parodie', the score is marked 'nicht schleppen', which Maestro Luisi interprets as 'race away so fast it's like a new piece of music has begun'. This performance has lovely moments, but the symphony's shape is lost with all the odd tempi.
Interesante, épico, victorioso y esplendoroso, eso es una sinfonía de Mahler, puede que hayan mejores interpretaciones pero por lo menos pude disfrutar una vez más de este TITAN DE LA MÚSICA, la melodía de los cornos en la marcha del finale me recuerdan siempre al coro "Aleluya" de El Mesías de Händel, tal vez haya sido inintencional de la pluma de Mahler, pero se siente victorioso como el triunfo de un gladiador quien pasa su niñez en el campo para luego ser convocado a una batalla astral. GRACIAS MAHLER Y GRACIAS DW CLASSICAL MUSIC.
Certainly not a metronome conductor! As noted by many below, style, knowledge, interpretation and delivery are variable and personal. I enjoy the variety of comments of the conductors and orchestras noted below. I would be pleased to listen to, and see many of the conductors and orchestras not on you tube who are/were the 'greats' of their time if they did Mahler. I wonder what Mahler would say in this and other postings if he were able to comment.
2022.5.1 3:48🌿thanks I was awake halfway. Symphony No. 1 in D major (1884-88) - The subtitle "Giant" derived from Jean Paul's novel has finally been deleted by Mahler himself.
Interesting how there seems to be no joy written on the musician's faces. Dresden thing? Touring thing? Conductor thing? The ghost of Celi hanging in the hall, threatening to fire anyone who screws up on the spot?
I can't help seeing in this Italian conductor some mimicry of Bernstein's gymnastics and hyper-animated gesticulation on the podium, even embellished by Fabio Luisi thanks to the turbulence in his long, flowing romantic hair style. All those younger directors have studied Bernstein's antics in his performances very carefully. By contrast, you see none of this in Valery Gergiev's interpreting Mahler.
Original hatte das Mahler als Gruppensolo gedacht. Aber es klang so schlecht dass er es mit einem Bass machen wollte, Mahler hat das selbst geändert. Aber Bravo für Kontrabass Gruppen! Sauber und schöne Linie!
Spectacular. No matter how many times I hear this symphony, I still get chills when the horn players stand "so as to drown out everything…even the trumpets."
We're glad you enjoyed it. Make sure to follow us in order to not miss out in the future 😊
Magnificent. I also love the journey of the conductor’s hair from the beginning of the piece to the end
😂😂😂😂😂😂 that has me sniggering... my family are looking at me wondering. 😮😂❤
@@maddannafizz 😂😂😂
Fabio Luisi becomes more and more one of my favourite Mahler conductors. His energy is not often seen :D
It was Bernstein, Abbado and Tennstedt and many other greats from the recent past, now you have Dudamel and this guy among many others!!!!!
Fabio Luisi from a distance does look quite like Gustav Mahler!
Doesn,t he though !
Fabio have more better hair)
@@scottmiller6495 JEWS JEWS JEWS !)
Fabio is more like Beethoven
with a fever of 40°
This is great!! I love Fabio Luisi's interpretation is fantastic! As a horn player, I enjoy seeing the climax of the Finale being played by the 7/8 horns without support from a trumpet and trombone as Mahler himself placed in the score as an option. I often wonder why Mahler did not utilize 7-8 Wagner tubas instead of standard horns in this passage. Anyone who has heard the Universal Studios fanfare cannot tell the difference between the horn and the tuben until they know exactly where one ends and the other begins and even then it is not so obvious except the tuben project more. My graduate horn professor often referred to these tuben as 'horns on steroids'. I would love to see a performance of this Symphony where the horn players would put down the horns and take up the tuben for these last several minutes of this work. I really do believe Mahler would approve.
Thanks for sharing your insights and opinions with us and our community. This is very valuable!
This conductor is incredible, superb discovery!
This brother is a monster. How does he get his bands to play so well??????????!!!!????? Damn!
This is the oldest band in the world. They've been around for 500 years. It's very hard to make them play *NOT* well.
Absolutely spectacular performance!
Bravo DW Classics for this and other stupendous performances!! 👏👏👏 You are promoting the best in German culture!!
We're glad you enjoyed it. Make sure to follow us for the latest uploads 😊
Wonderful, wonderful performance, and excellent video production. Thank you and congratulations to you all.
We're glad you enjoyed it! 😊
Very beautiful. Respect conductor and orchestra.
A very fantastic performance worthy of a standing ovation, Bravo !!!!!!
Top top notch orchestra. This orchestra always delivers a spectacular performance.
One of the BEST under Maestro Fabio Luisi!!!
Wunderschöne und detaillierte Aufführung dieser spätromantischen und melodisch komponierten Sinfonie mit seidigen Tönen aller Streicher, milden Tönen aller Holzbläser und brillanten Tönen aller Blechbläser. Der zweite Satz klingt echt kräftig und auch beweglich. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im veränderlichen Tempo und mit möglichst effektiver Dynamik, als wäre er ein zweiter Mahler. Wunderbar vom Anfang bis zum Ende!
Absolutely spectacular Mahler 1st ! One of the best renditions. Proud of Fabio Luisi ,who is from Genoa, my hometown...
We're glad you liked the concert! Subscribe to our channel for the latest uploads.
Loved watching the director in this video.
55:02 What an Epic and powerful finale!
One of them !!!!!
It’s so interesting to hear Mahler 1 interpreted by so many different orchestra and conductors! It’s always such a treat
As much as I like the work, I think it being overperformed. It's probably one of the most recorded symphonies ever.
@@Quotenwagnerianer And the Best 1st Symphony of all time by any composer in classical music history !!!!!
Many people consider Mahler one of the greatest if not thee greatest composer of symphonies of all time !!!!!
@@scottmiller6495 What's with the multiple exclamation marks? One is more than sufficient!
And so what? I belong to those many and I still think the 1st is heavily overperformed and overrecorded.
@@Quotenwagnerianer You may be right but many people including myself love it, thank you.
Beautiful music 🎶 Thank you and the Conductor for making the day more memorable with gorgeous sounds! Love your music❤ 🌹🌹🌹
Our pleasure - we're glad you enjoyed it 😊
I love Mahler❤️
Late lunch goes well with Mahler! Thank You Ladies and Gentleman 😎
Hmm, I'm at dinner time: Miso soup.
Mahler the God
of his symphonies 😮 ❤
Musik für's Herz ❤ und die Seele. Einfach wunderschön!!!
I love this performance - so fresh and outdoors-y.
Nice interpretation of one of my favourite composers, the feeling is just wow, a mix of different emotions. That's why I love Mahler, Rachmaninov and Wagner.
Rachmaninoff is too technical and Tchaikovsky influence; Stravinsky, Mahlër and Wagzist better
Espetacular interpretação. Amei. Gravação muito boa também.
Excepcional video, por la magnífica interpretación, de la Sinfonía Titán de Malher, además por la excelente caludad de la Televización.
So true. Same tremendous video quality in Mahler 2, also in the same magnificent hall in Munich, conducted by the Russian guy, Valery Gergiev, who lost his position there because of the Ukraine war
Roo Bookaroo, muchas gracias.
What an ending!!!! BRAVO
It's pretty good but I like when the ending to this epic symphony has the bass drum and typany go Boom Boom, it's more Exciting!!!!!
Bravo! Great interpretation, especially the account of the trio-very characterful. And based on the pictures I’ve seen Maestro Luisi looks like Mahler. 👏👏👏👏♥️🎶🎻🎵
too strident.. Trio was awful. . dumped it half way
Love the interpretation - great performance!
Extraordinaria interpretación
BRILLIANT.THANKYOU
Wonderful!
❤❤❤❤❤
This is the best Mahler 1 I have ever heard. BRAVO FABIO
Try "Rafael Kubelik Mahler 1" with the Bavarian Symphony Orchestra on youtube. The studio version (Deutsche Grammophon) is even better. Many, including me, regard his interpretation as the best version.
Thanks for sharing your recommendation with us and our community!
We're glad you liked it! Make sure to follow us for the latest uploads.
Don't be misunderstood. This version with Luisi and the Staatskapelle Dresden is one of the best I've heard. I just wanted to check some parts of the symphony and ended in listening to almost everything. And everything was done with precision and perfect expression. So, the applause at the end was very well earned.
Thank you and big congratulations to DW Classics. I hope it will stream more.
We are glad you enjoyed it! 😊
Stunning! The most exciting Mahler First I've yet heard,
We're glad you enjoyed it. Make sure to follow us in order to not miss out in the future 😊
The third movement is soo good 🗣️‼️‼️
Very nice..
Very good
Amazing.
Bellissima❤️
"Evening D'Albert! Masterful performance my friend."
Maestro Fabio Luisi has it all
Heard him conduct a transcendent "Goetterdaemmerung" on a broadcast from the Met. Since then, he's known in our house as Fabuloso Luisi.
For a moment I thought Beethoven was conducting, looking at the cover pic!
Bravo maestro.
12:15 | 12:22 | 12:49 | 15:41 Proud horse trot | 18:55 Winner | 22:39 Proud horse again | 23:36 Winning again | 37:10
37:24 | 38:37 | 45:04 Ending preview | 46:36 | 49:43 curious | 53:29 | 53:54 | 56:33 Triumphant finale
Saw him conduct Mahler 5 recently. He is absolutely amazing!
Que maravilha começar meu dia ouvindo essas magníficas melodias!
❤🎼🎶🎶🎶🎵🎷🎺🎻📯
To watch Maestro Luisi attack the finale was quite something! By the way, the horn theme in the finale was inspired by Hans Rott.
It's not much of a theme.
@@davidalderson4980 099⁹⁹
Fabio Luisi is currently the chief conductor of the NHK Symphony Orchestra in Japan, so I have listened to his performances many times. And I can hear all of his performances sound like opera. Even Brahms and Beethoven. But this performance sounds like a symphony.
He's a great conductor!
Thanks for sharing your impressions of the concerts with us.
Bravo Maestro Luisi, schone grusse von Kontrabassist Graz synphonische orkestar Branislav Misina
Happy Birthday Gustav Mahler 🌹🌹🌹
Wonderful
We're glad you enjoyed it. Make sure to follow us for the latest uploads!
Like most conductors he slows down at (in this performance) 44:46-45:03 even though the score is marked "a tempo." This destroys the contrast with the later recurrences of the motif, when the score does indicate a change in tempo. Jascha Horenstein is one of the few who follows the score at this point, and the movement benefits tremendously.
I find the termpi in this performance often inexplicable. He slows and speeds the scherzo very oddly, bringing it almost to a halt and then zooming back at breakneck speed. In the third movement when the clarinets break into the 'parodie', the score is marked 'nicht schleppen', which Maestro Luisi interprets as 'race away so fast it's like a new piece of music has begun'. This performance has lovely moments, but the symphony's shape is lost with all the odd tempi.
Amazing performance, I love that part I love that part of the symphony: 39:45
There has tristan and orientalism elements
Bravo Favio!!! Qué emoción!
Interesante, épico, victorioso y esplendoroso, eso es una sinfonía de Mahler, puede que hayan mejores interpretaciones pero por lo menos pude disfrutar una vez más de este TITAN DE LA MÚSICA, la melodía de los cornos en la marcha del finale me recuerdan siempre al coro "Aleluya" de El Mesías de Händel, tal vez haya sido inintencional de la pluma de Mahler, pero se siente victorioso como el triunfo de un gladiador quien pasa su niñez en el campo para luego ser convocado a una batalla astral. GRACIAS MAHLER Y GRACIAS DW CLASSICAL MUSIC.
🙄
The description above is not correct. The performance took place at the Philharmonie in Gasteig (Munich), not at the Kulturpalast (Dresden).
Thanks you for your comment, you are right! We have corrected the description. 😊
Thanks you-- thought that hall looked familiar and I've never been to Dresden...
This is the man who should be artistic director of the metropolitan opera.
Love the 3rd movement, wonderful
Certainly not a metronome conductor! As noted by many below, style, knowledge, interpretation and delivery are variable and personal. I enjoy the variety of comments of the conductors and orchestras noted below. I would be pleased to listen to, and see many of the conductors and orchestras not on you tube who are/were the 'greats' of their time if they did Mahler. I wonder what Mahler would say in this and other postings if he were able to comment.
What a performance!
56:39 everyone loves a crazy conductor in a epic finale!!!!
Dresden & Fabio Luisi는 명불허전
Excellent performance. Wonderful orchestra, but now go and see Kubelik perform same work.
Kubelik’s Mahler cycle is to die for my friend, and his interpretation of the first stands out above the rest, for me at least.
Wanderful orchestra.good audio
Sonido espectacular. La interpretación, magistral.
Bravissimo.
2022.5.1 3:48🌿thanks
I was awake halfway.
Symphony No. 1 in D major (1884-88) - The subtitle "Giant" derived from Jean Paul's novel has finally been deleted by Mahler himself.
ohne zu schleppen, top
Interesting to hear this piece interpreted by Mahler himself. Lol
I was thinking that as well, a resemblance to Mahler
Esecuzione delicata forse nello spirito del maestro Malher
Nada como um italiano regente !! As caras e bocas dele são ótimas !
great
👍 Güzel insanlar ,teşekkürler.
Aeterna Glory,, Lux and Thank you Sirs
素晴らしい
Are you sure that this is the (old) Kulturpalast concert hall and not the Philharmonie in Munich?
Thanks you for your comment, you are right! We have corrected the description. 😊
Ganz toll.
Why would anyone state the conductor is as good as the composer when the composer is Mahler?
素晴らしいマーラーですね。
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
On the 3rd movement... It wasn't supposed to start with SOLO Bass?
This is Franz Welsar Most!!
it's always like i died and went to heaven in the 3rd movement at 32:50
What‘s happening at 3:03 ? Some unconventional percussion? 😉
But Gustav Mahler would have appreciated the noise 😄
¡YO LO ESCUCHE Y LO APRUEBO!
Interesting how there seems to be no joy written on the musician's faces. Dresden thing? Touring thing? Conductor thing? The ghost of Celi hanging in the hall, threatening to fire anyone who screws up on the spot?
Maestro really should wear a helmet for this piece.
I can't help seeing in this Italian conductor some mimicry of Bernstein's gymnastics and hyper-animated gesticulation on the podium, even embellished by Fabio Luisi thanks to the turbulence in his long, flowing romantic hair style. All those younger directors have studied Bernstein's antics in his performances very carefully. By contrast, you see none of this in Valery Gergiev's interpreting Mahler.
Bernstein conducted only with his face.
3rd movement, it's a solo of 1 doublebass, not a group!!!
A me mi garba!
😌
The conductor over exaggerated
But it does the job :)
Hello..
Fabio Luisi looks like my 9th grade data processing teacher, Mr. Grenzebach. He could recite the counties of California in alphabetic order.
😂
Original hatte das Mahler als Gruppensolo gedacht. Aber es klang so schlecht dass er es mit einem Bass machen wollte, Mahler hat das selbst geändert. Aber Bravo für Kontrabass Gruppen! Sauber und schöne Linie!
How many calories did that conductor burn during this?
这是继滕斯泰特和阿巴多以外听过的最平衡的马一！
54:35
39:45
1:37:15
This guys haircut is literaaly a copy of Mahler. It is really killing me.