Soul Music From a true genuine authentic soul brother. He's a soul man. Bob thanks you are the world's eternal soul brother.... "I'm commenting through these tears"....
6:13 - "I’m going out of my mind, oh, oh / With a pain that stops and starts / Like a corkscrew to my heart / Ever since we’ve been apart." You win Nobel Prizes when you write like that. Simply magnificent!
Even better than that try another line from the same song, the most desperate, painful and beautiful plea to a lover that's ever been set to music, "I can change I swear/ Ah, see what you can do." Search your own life and you'll remember a moment when this line was applicable. Devastating and genius.
LOVE IS SO SIMPLE ,I FEEL LIKE I AM JUST WITH THEM AS I LISTEN TO THIS SONG ,I FEEL SO ALONE ANYMORE SO MANY OF MY FRIENDS HAVE PASSED AWAY AND TIMES ARE SO DIFFERENT I FEEL QUIET NOW EXCEPT THROUGH MUSIC WHICH BRINGS LIFE TO ME AND MY HEART ❤️ 💙 💜 SHINES AGAIN,I SURE LOVE THIS AND I THANK YOU
My favorite Bob voice was from this era. I bought Biograph when I was 18 & first heard studio version 2 of this song. Played the hell out of it. It was anguishing then & still is now.
I'm jealous of all of Bob's fans who got to see The Rolling Thunder Review in person - I agree with other comments that performances were incredible by all the musicians he chose to compliment his singing. The instrumental solos in this particular song bring up so many emotions making it an incredibly sad love song at the same time. My fav arrangement.
In May 41 God gifted the world Robert Zimmerman. He truly did. In September 83 he gifted the world Amy Winehouse. Catherine Bush in 58. Lennon in 40. The list goes on. All these great writers and singers and musicians. That’s where Heaven is to be found.
Can you IMAGINE what The Rolling Thunder Review was like - all those WONDERFUL artists travelling with him on the 'TRAIN' - the SPIRIT that motivated them and kept them HIGH - the MUSIC - the CAMARADERIE - the LOVE - an EVENT without par - - before or since. Martin Scorsese made a great documentary about it that's pretty mind blowing.
That eerie wailing violin played against the backdrop of those constantly crashing cymbals really starts to whipsaw you. Then there are Bob's long, drawn out often sarcastically rendered lyrics. (You're a big girl all the waaaaaaay). The mournfulness is almost too much to bear. Thankfully those chirpy little acoustic notes remind us that all is not lost. There are fresh seeds being planted in the dead of this terrible winter.
“I can change I swear…” and ofc “ oh I know where I can find you..ohhhhh in somebody’s room”. Brings tears and bad memories everyone has in their lives through breakups.
You're right, this is the best live version of this (or any?) song. THe 1976 RTR was so much more emotional than 1975, and the playing by his band of outlaws was out of this world. Even the wrong notes were right!
You know what's funny? People usually prefer the 1975 leg of the Rolling Thunder Revue. Personally I think both are fantastic and I can't choose just one. I mean, the versions of It Ain't Me Babe and Isis in 1975 were fucking amazing but this version of You're A Big Girl Now and Shelter From The Storm (which are from the second leg) are also extremely majestic. That's why I think this might be one of the finest periods of Bob's carreer (from 1974 to 1977)
I WAS ON THE ROAD TO NOWHERE, NOW WE CROSS SHADOWS ON THE PATH, WE WERE WALKING BACKWARDS WHEN UP ROSE THE GROUND FRAGRANCES OF FLOWERS FILLED THE AIR THERE WAS SINGING ,OF LITTLE CHILDREN PLAYING IN THE STREETS OF FLOURISHING ,MY RICHES WERE RUNNING BAREFOOT ,THE GREEN GRASSES COMFORTING THEIR FEET , THEIR INNOCENCE CAUGHT THE SON S ATTENTION, THEIR JOY FILL THE AIR AS THEIR LAUGHTER MADE SMILE. TEARS FILLED MY EYES .WHEN THEY CAME IN AS THE DUST WAS WASHED AWAY , WITH MY TEARS OF APPRECIATION SWEET SMELLS OF ALABASTER FILL THE AIR AS OUR SENSES CAME ALIVE TO YOUR TRUTH ALIVE IN THE DOORWAY OF TIME.AS OU TURN TO SEE , WHO WAS LEFT OUT THERE YOU LEFT A KEY WITH A NOTE , WHAT A BEAUTIFUL SOUND .JESUS
This is simply fantastic. I have always respected Bob for constantly challenging his arrangements of songs ~ this delivers here, sung with a ton of soul!
Tremendous job! The slideshow focuses mostly on my favorite stage of the many turnings of Dylan, the Rolling Thunder Review. Immaculate timing of showing Bob hammer down on his guitar while the band orchestrates what may be Dylan's most painful song. Great work!
This is from the best complete show recorded of the 2nd leg of RTR at the warehouse May 3rd 1976,very easy to find and great other versions of songs from that time
Astonishing stuff. I'm constantly amazed by all these uncanny rearrangements that all somehow seem to work (and whisper it...even better than the studio versions!)
Same here!! Its amazing and agree they are better than the studio versions! He reminds me of hendrix in that way, something was always added to the songs they played live never would they play anything note for note from the record
That song brought me to tears!!! It was so beautiful! Really had all of my emotions brought to the surface! Never mind about me how are you feeling since you are back from the hospital!!!!! Hope you are eating well, and drinking loads of liquids. And above all get a lot of rest!!!! Love ya Bob and the Video was so extra special. Thank you so very much for sharing this with me! Love ya truly❤️🙏and have a fantastic and get a really rested day! ❤️Kathie
Goodness! He always had a great arrangement for this one on the historical RTR Tour .just a guess, but I think, one of the great poets favorites..Shh..he might hear
Michael McLoughlin I saw "The Rollomg Thunder Revue" live at MSG in N.Y. There It was a benefit to raise money for Ruben Carter's defense fund, Mohammed Ali showed up. He couldn't believe that the women in the audience would rather go with Bob Dylan than him. The crowd was so big outside the garden that the police ordered 'them to open up & start selling tickets. They were afraid of a riot. Yeah,😀😀 I was young then.
The most beautifully heartbreaking track I will ever hear. This is very much a public performance-directed version though, lacking the no exit, cruel intimacy of the Blood On The Tracks version.
Wandsworth Road Vauxhall London July 2010. Going to feckin 30th party of Olivia whom I managed well not really cos managing ppl not my thing in her job til 2008. Was with my friend Caroline now in NZ her flat round corner. Was supposed to be feckin Sandy from Grease but the curls fell out before I got there.
wow that sounds great, thanks for posting ! wish i knew where this concert was. It definitely sounds like it's from around the time of the Blood on the Tracks recording, mid 70s. Sounds like a Dylan guitar solo. Nice one. thanks again xo
Here's the entire rolling thunder review tour both the 75 and 76 legs ruclips.net/p/PL6uEQrBrQ3lCVsOHTFpvnNhYmeq5FB7bZ Some concerts have fantastic audio and of course some of the shows had bad audio recording but it's still fantastic that they exist. Enjoy
@@TheMrTslab - How and WHERE you CAME IN seems more IMPORTANT as you get "older" I was born in England in my grandmother's home - but I was RE-BORN ( had the 'LAST RIGHTS' ) at St. Joseph's Hospital in Burbank, CA. I'd had a brain hemorrage. A MAGICAL occasion - I met my guardian angel - he said "Do you wanna GO ON or do you wanna GO BACK?" Meaning - go on to that amazing LIGHT you see in front of us - OR - go back to your family on earth? - 2 beautiful daughters in my hospital room, waiting for me to regain consciousness.- I had been UNCONSCIOUS for THREE DAYS and they didn't know what to do. I regained consciousness and there was a great CELEBRATON. But I discovered that I had "lost"my LEFT BRAIN (from the aneurism) and was now functioning with just my RIGHT BRAIN. What a REVELATION ! Changed my life. I consider myself REBORN - like Bobby said : "DIED and WAS REBORN and then MYSTERIOUSLY SAVED". Born, the first time, in 1943 - that makes me 76 now - in Earth terms - but I was REBORN in October 1998 -that makes me 21 now and I'm having an AMAZING life this time around! We're having a 21st birthday bash! MAY GOD BLESS and KEEP YOU ALWAYS BOBBY - MAY YOU STAY "FOREVER YOUNG"
@@angelicaluce3230 That is Beautiful. I hope your 21st Birthday is glorious. On my 21st I packed up my truck and left the Northland for Austin, Texas. 40 years ago. I was reborn on that trip, passing through a Rainbow in Oklahoma. The cab of my truck was filled with color. Unbelievable as a I retell it, but it happened. I am a little envious of your NDE, but your story fills me with the spirit. Thank you.
Who doubt me. You did not total but god carried me through the silence dark year. Then he gave water of the spirit and he gave me gift of sight. He gave me light he gave me life morning light just like you. He sent the holy spirt to me 9ne of healing but it through his hand and no other man. Ok
![Bob Dylan - Sara (Live at Madison Square Garden - 1975) [Rolling Thunder Revue]](/img/1.gif)
Dear God ~ thank you for Bob Dylan
Great words, i agree
Amen 🙏🏻
Happy that I have been able to enjoy this man's genius and art. ♥
Amen to that
Amen ❤🙏
Soul Music From a true genuine authentic soul brother. He's a soul man. Bob thanks you are the world's eternal soul brother.... "I'm commenting through these tears"....
One thing good about being as old as I am...I saw the 1976 Rolling Thunder Review. What a wild thing it was.
Where do I post the hate mail, Donna? Robin Witting, England
6:13 - "I’m going out of my mind, oh, oh / With a pain that stops and starts / Like a corkscrew to my heart / Ever since we’ve been apart." You win Nobel Prizes when you write like that. Simply magnificent!
best lines ever!! IMO
Even better than that try another line from the same song, the most desperate, painful and beautiful plea to a lover that's ever been set to music, "I can change I swear/ Ah, see what you can do." Search your own life and you'll remember a moment when this line was applicable. Devastating and genius.
Right on Brother - Genius
Sonny Young - fking A right !
Soy el 464Capicúa gracias Roberto (spanish)
Rolling Thunder - had I only a time machine, I would have followed that thing around like a Deadhead.
I still am
I would have been there too mate 👊
Was it possible that he could ever change for her?
Why? The tour was a bust...
it can"!t be beaten its so awesome every song
LOVE IS SO SIMPLE ,I FEEL LIKE I AM JUST WITH THEM AS I LISTEN TO THIS SONG ,I FEEL SO ALONE ANYMORE SO MANY OF MY FRIENDS HAVE PASSED AWAY AND TIMES ARE SO DIFFERENT I FEEL QUIET NOW EXCEPT THROUGH MUSIC WHICH BRINGS LIFE TO ME AND MY HEART ❤️ 💙 💜 SHINES AGAIN,I SURE LOVE THIS AND I THANK YOU
I know how you feel.
That's exactly how I feel. I'm almost 71 yrs. old. Yesterday Robbie Robertson passed away at 80. Sad.😢
"Time is a jet plane and it goes too fast"
❤❤❤Mr. Bob Allen Dylan ❤❤❤
he spills his heart out on the stage floor, and his musicians follow him into Heaven
A real tear jerker Bob is pouring his heart, his voice and lyrics make want to bring tears to my eyes. Amazing good job, Bobby.😢❤ we love you.
Love this song and all the photos what can I say he is just fantastic thanks you
May be my favorite version of my favorite song.
My favorite Bob voice was from this era. I bought Biograph when I was 18 & first heard studio version 2 of this song. Played the hell out of it. It was anguishing then & still is now.
I'm jealous of all of Bob's fans who got to see The Rolling Thunder Review in person - I agree with other comments that performances were incredible by all the musicians he chose to compliment his singing. The instrumental solos in this particular song bring up so many emotions making it an incredibly sad love song at the same time. My fav arrangement.
I agree
Like Woodstock, the number of people who “saw” exceeds the actual number by an order of magnitude (in Woodstock’s case, by 2 or 3 orders, lol)
I hear you It must have been out of this world ...
In May 41 God gifted the world Robert Zimmerman. He truly did. In September 83 he gifted the world Amy Winehouse. Catherine Bush in 58. Lennon in 40. The list goes on. All these great writers and singers and musicians. That’s where Heaven is to be found.
So many many man beautiful photos here. What a life. What an artist. What a beautiful man.
Wow. Absolutely incredible version. Best ever. I play this on my piano. This version unreal.
Rollingthunder was his greatest sound
Yes i still love himin everything he sings
Man was in great pain. Artist at his highest.
I absolutely and definitely agree.
spread the word barbara
Best live version I've heard
Can you IMAGINE what The Rolling Thunder Review was like - all those WONDERFUL artists travelling with him on the 'TRAIN' - the SPIRIT that motivated them and kept them HIGH - the MUSIC - the CAMARADERIE - the LOVE - an EVENT without par - - before or since. Martin Scorsese made a great documentary about it that's pretty mind blowing.
Not a train tho- buses.
I think he was going thru some really hard things at that time don't know regrets maybe it was his best music from the heart I love it lots of pain
divorce, his cheating: i can change, i swear (but it was too late)
May God bless and keep you ALWAYS, Bob!
That eerie wailing violin played against the backdrop of those constantly crashing cymbals really starts to whipsaw you. Then there are Bob's long, drawn out often sarcastically rendered lyrics. (You're a big girl all the waaaaaaay). The mournfulness is almost too much to bear. Thankfully those chirpy little acoustic notes remind us that all is not lost. There are fresh seeds being planted in the dead of this terrible winter.
Don't forget the tickling of those piano keys
A song Hank Williams would’ve been proud of. ‘I can change I swear Ohhhhhhhhhhhh’
How many times has that phrase been used throughout civilisation?
“I can change I swear…” and ofc “ oh I know where I can find you..ohhhhh in somebody’s room”. Brings tears and bad memories everyone has in their lives through breakups.
I love this live version. The music pause is brilliant. Selah it's like stop and think about what I'm saying. Beautiful
this shows once again his class⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Always listening to Bob's tunes, singing just for you
WHAT A TROOPER - My God! Don't ever forget - WE LOVE YA BOBBY!
This song never fails to get me. Brilliant, aching. Possibly my favorite Bobby D song ever.
best live version and great pictures
You're right, this is the best live version of this (or any?) song. THe 1976 RTR was so much more emotional than 1975, and the playing by his band of outlaws was out of this world. Even the wrong notes were right!
You know what's funny? People usually prefer the 1975 leg of the Rolling Thunder Revue. Personally I think both are fantastic and I can't choose just one. I mean, the versions of It Ain't Me Babe and Isis in 1975 were fucking amazing but this version of You're A Big Girl Now and Shelter From The Storm (which are from the second leg) are also extremely majestic. That's why I think this might be one of the finest periods of Bob's carreer (from 1974 to 1977)
Bob Dylan a master piece and thanks for the pictures
I WAS ON THE ROAD TO NOWHERE, NOW WE CROSS SHADOWS ON THE PATH, WE WERE WALKING BACKWARDS WHEN UP ROSE THE GROUND FRAGRANCES OF FLOWERS FILLED THE AIR THERE WAS SINGING ,OF LITTLE CHILDREN PLAYING IN THE STREETS OF FLOURISHING ,MY RICHES WERE RUNNING BAREFOOT ,THE GREEN GRASSES COMFORTING THEIR FEET , THEIR INNOCENCE CAUGHT THE SON S ATTENTION, THEIR JOY FILL THE AIR AS THEIR LAUGHTER MADE SMILE. TEARS FILLED MY EYES .WHEN THEY CAME IN AS THE DUST WAS WASHED AWAY , WITH MY TEARS OF APPRECIATION SWEET SMELLS OF ALABASTER FILL THE AIR AS OUR SENSES CAME ALIVE TO YOUR TRUTH ALIVE IN THE DOORWAY OF TIME.AS OU TURN TO SEE , WHO WAS LEFT OUT THERE YOU LEFT A KEY WITH A NOTE , WHAT A BEAUTIFUL SOUND .JESUS
This is simply fantastic.
I have always respected Bob for constantly challenging his arrangements of songs ~ this delivers here, sung with a ton of soul!
Mamma mia, meravigliosa versione dylaniana di questa straordinaria song! :-)
Periodo magico
Tremendous job! The slideshow focuses mostly on my favorite stage of the many turnings of Dylan, the Rolling Thunder Review. Immaculate timing of showing Bob hammer down on his guitar while the band orchestrates what may be Dylan's most painful song. Great work!
A masterpiece by The Master.
This song had a great arrangement throughout the 1976 leg of the tour.
"And I'm back in the rain, and you are on dry land."
Dylan lyrics ALWAYS work for me. Always so honest. Oh, (and) if dog's run free . . .
Great photo slide show.....captured me along with lyrics to match. Thanks
The sound tears your heart out
Love this. I've always been in the rain.❤️❤️
Michael McLoughlin
This is another great song "Time is a jet plane, it moves too fast-all too true."
I love this Dylan song.
May 3rd 1976. Live at The Warehouse bootleg. Feckin’ brilliant!
I just got the Rollin thunder review haven't listened to it yet but I love this song
Amazing performance of this song that is in my top 7 songs! ✨🤍✨
Love his song.
Most Beautiful Moving Version
Love This One 🌸🧡🧡🌸
De todas as canções fabulosas de Dylan esta é uma das melhores. Obrigado
Just perfection.
This is from the best complete show recorded of the 2nd leg of RTR at the warehouse May 3rd 1976,very easy to find and great other versions of songs from that time
easy to find video's of it?
So great, i love these live performances of Bob. By the way, once i have seen him...
Fantastic, thank you for preserving and posting
Fantastic.
Wonderful! Robin Witting, England
🎶💚More💜Then💛Beautiful
❤️Amazing💙Music😍.🎶
🎃🌟🌜❤️🍀🙏
Astonishing stuff. I'm constantly amazed by all these uncanny rearrangements that all somehow seem to work (and whisper it...even better than the studio versions!)
Same here!! Its amazing and agree they are better than the studio versions! He reminds me of hendrix in that way, something was always added to the songs they played live never would they play anything note for note from the record
wish they had released this leg of the tour as well
Everything else, I love except I don't have this album, but I am going to find out soon, and get this masterpiece!
get more blood more tracks awesome best album ever penned
Fantástico.
Wonderful version.
Happy Belated 78th! Thank you for everything Mr. Dylan
Thanks Mou!
That song brought me to tears!!! It was so beautiful! Really had all of my emotions brought to the surface! Never mind about me how are you feeling since you are back from the hospital!!!!! Hope you are eating well, and drinking loads of liquids. And above all get a lot of rest!!!! Love ya Bob and the Video was so extra special. Thank you so very much for sharing this with me! Love ya truly❤️🙏and have a fantastic and get a really rested day! ❤️Kathie
I’m just like that bird - I hope you can hear me singing through these tears.
I love it too.
Escutei muito nos anos 70.
Goodness! He always had a great arrangement for this one on the historical RTR Tour
.just a guess, but I think, one of the great poets favorites..Shh..he might hear
Hey Bob, we L❤️ve the Photos.❤️♥️❤️🇺🇸🤩🙏✌️🍀♥️💙💚💛💜🖤😁😎🤩
Btw this song is amazing
There’s one there of the train from Dublin to Belfast
The Bob Dylan dump on RUclips brought me here. One of my favorites ❤️
Amazing as ever
🌹
lovely little film ♥️
Michael McLoughlin
I saw "The Rollomg Thunder Revue" live at MSG in N.Y. There It was a benefit to
raise money for Ruben Carter's defense fund, Mohammed Ali showed up. He
couldn't believe that the women in the audience would rather go with
Bob Dylan than him. The crowd was so big outside the garden that the police ordered 'them
to open up & start selling tickets. They were afraid of a riot. Yeah,😀😀 I was young then.
Bob always cool as F. The clothes. To die for.
The most beautifully heartbreaking track I will ever hear. This is very much a public performance-directed version though, lacking the no exit, cruel intimacy of the Blood On The Tracks version.
Yeah, that's pretty perfect alright.
I always wondered
About the seven thunders
I woke up and heard a bird “doing” my phone alarm. So it was “Singin’ a song for me at it’s own expense”. So I started hearing this song.
life is beautiful
@@Jerry11201tis
Wandsworth Road Vauxhall London July 2010. Going to feckin 30th party of Olivia whom I managed well not really cos managing ppl not my thing in her job til 2008. Was with my friend Caroline now in NZ her flat round corner. Was supposed to be feckin Sandy from Grease but the curls fell out before I got there.
wow that sounds great, thanks for posting ! wish i knew where this concert was. It definitely sounds like it's from around the time of the Blood on the Tracks recording, mid 70s. Sounds like a Dylan guitar solo. Nice one. thanks again xo
It's been recorded in 1976 on the second leg of the Rolling Thunder Revue. It's from his brilliant live album "Hard Rain".
@@RichardLimbert I think the Hard Rain version was from a different night of the tour all respect
rolling thunder tour 1976
yes bob
I hope you can hear me singing thru these tears Reina.
Reina Jane
Does anyone know who plays the acoustic guitar solo on these versions?
love you so
Bob can't stand you so.
Why is this not on certain setlists of RTR I google? And it's not on the spotify one either.
Here's the entire rolling thunder review tour both the 75 and 76 legs ruclips.net/p/PL6uEQrBrQ3lCVsOHTFpvnNhYmeq5FB7bZ Some concerts have fantastic audio and of course some of the shows had bad audio recording but it's still fantastic that they exist. Enjoy
@@Theimbennn oh what a nice gift. thanks, person.
Piont is any one can make it because we are independent individuals include you and your
It's at The New Orleans Warehouse Evening, 3rd of May, 1976. You're welcome. :)
Anyone knows which day/date and venue iz this from?
the warehouse may 75 76
Hats off to Hibbing and Duluth.
I always tell folks I was born in the same hospital. St. Mary's.
@@TheMrTslab - How and WHERE you CAME IN seems more IMPORTANT as you get "older" I was born in
England in my grandmother's home - but I was RE-BORN ( had the 'LAST RIGHTS' ) at St. Joseph's Hospital in Burbank, CA. I'd had a brain hemorrage. A MAGICAL occasion - I met my guardian angel - he said "Do you wanna GO ON or do you wanna GO BACK?" Meaning - go on to that amazing LIGHT you see in front of us - OR - go back to your family on earth? - 2 beautiful daughters in my hospital room, waiting for me to regain consciousness.- I had been UNCONSCIOUS for THREE DAYS and they didn't know what to do. I regained consciousness and there was a great CELEBRATON. But I discovered that I had "lost"my LEFT BRAIN (from the aneurism) and was now functioning with just my RIGHT BRAIN. What a REVELATION ! Changed my life.
I consider myself REBORN - like Bobby said : "DIED and WAS REBORN and then MYSTERIOUSLY SAVED". Born, the first time, in 1943 - that makes me 76 now - in Earth terms - but I was REBORN in October 1998 -that makes me 21 now and I'm having an AMAZING life this time around! We're having a 21st birthday bash!
MAY GOD BLESS and KEEP YOU ALWAYS BOBBY - MAY YOU STAY "FOREVER YOUNG"
@@angelicaluce3230 That is Beautiful. I hope your 21st Birthday is glorious. On my 21st I packed up my truck and left the Northland for Austin, Texas. 40 years ago. I was reborn on that trip, passing through a Rainbow in Oklahoma. The cab of my truck was filled with color. Unbelievable as a I retell it, but it happened. I am a little envious of your NDE, but your story fills me with the spirit. Thank you.
What does it profit a man if he trades the world for his very soul
dylan didn't sold his soul, it was a joke
100 % @@bruxoroki
Where? When?
Ohhhhhhhho
Who doubt me. You did not total but god carried me through the silence dark year. Then he gave water of the spirit and he gave me gift of sight. He gave me light he gave me life morning light just like you. He sent the holy spirt to me 9ne of healing but it through his hand and no other man. Ok
So much better than the album version
Love it
we're all leaving here soon