Love the analysis, but I want to point out one small bit that is erroneous: you say that for Han China, climbing up to Tibet is difficult, but immediately after that you mention that India could move across the Himalayas ... this is untrue in every sense. The Indian side of the Himalayas rises like walls, while the Tibetan side is a comparatively much more gradual gain (or drop, depending on how you are traversing) in elevation. For decades, in Indian policy circles, this relative ease of Chinese movement compared to the insane difficulty of Indian troop movement has been discussed ... and there's still no obvious solution (other than maintaining specialized mountain corps along the Tibetan border). There were analysts in India until the mid-1990s who pushed for a complete lack of road infrastructure in the Indian Himalayas just so that in the event of a war, the Chinese army would not be able use roads to progress any further. I say this as someone who has worked with such policy makers AND as an avid mountaineer on the Indian Himalayas. But one can also see this difference clearly just from Google Earth.
The USA, Canada, Australia, and Nordic countries have sparsely populated regions (the contiguous USA even smaller without Alaska) yet they're stereotyped as having great geographies and economies.
The USA's geographic superiority isn't a stereotype. It's a proven, measurable fact. Just one example: the continental US has more miles of navigable rivers than the rest of the world combined. Read that again. MORE than the ENTIRE rest of the world.
weird music choices in this video, not sure if anyone else picked up on that, but some of them were very jarring and uncomfortable to the ear, like, i nearly just closed down the video and left kind of uncomfortable
It would be AMAZING to get a video to about Uzbekistan from an Uzbek🤗 I feel like geographically, nationally or geopolitical Uzbekistan is never represented
The editing on this video is so weird personally I find the swaying back and forth of the map pretty annoying and the sad music was too loud compared to the voice. Lastly the video is called insane weakness yet those seem like very manageable weaknesses, almost every country has borders and who is going to attack through the mountains as was pointed out there is few people living there, the only real weakness would be Tibet in a conflict with India but that's also a normal weakness for many countries to have a river originating from outside their country.
The blue area was a old china , at that time the other area was invaded by near nomadic tribes for 3 thousand years. When ching empire occupied the ming dynasty, insistently ching empire& Communist party ruled it . It plays a defence buffers. Somedays i hope that they will be free from china Thanks for your posting.🌻
If you're doing two more video's on this I'd really recommend confirming your pronunciation on specific terms, there was a LOT of very poor pronunciation in this video, to the point where both me and my partner kept going "What?". I've watched a lot of your content, this was a pretty weak video though sadly, lots of aspects to improve, that other people have already commented on too.
People speaking a language not native to them are going to mispronounce things sometimes, get over it and use common sense to figure out what he's saying.
@@thunderstrucktb4758 I mean I understand that, but many were so bad as to be unrecognisable to someone with knowledge of the correct words to say. Someone with no knowledge will not understand that. And in the future will be confused
To be fair, in his defense, RUclips is an international platform that brings in content creators and viewers globally; It would be wrong to say that his accent is poor, considering that accents, by themself, are subjective and are inherited differently across regions. Although, I understand that you're addressing the fact that his accent doesn't follow one of the popular choices out there (let that be American, British and so on) but overall, as a non-native English speaker, his accent was relatively easier than a lot of my experiences.
Excellent book that deals with not only constraints of Chinas geography, but also how geography shapes geopolitics is "Prisoners of Geography: Ten Maps That Tell You Everything You Need to Know About Global Politics"
Love the analysis, but I want to point out one small bit that is erroneous: you say that for Han China, climbing up to Tibet is difficult, but immediately after that you mention that India could move across the Himalayas ... this is untrue in every sense. The Indian side of the Himalayas rises like walls, while the Tibetan side is a comparatively much more gradual gain (or drop, depending on how you are traversing) in elevation. For decades, in Indian policy circles, this relative ease of Chinese movement compared to the insane difficulty of Indian troop movement has been discussed ... and there's still no obvious solution (other than maintaining specialized mountain corps along the Tibetan border). There were analysts in India until the mid-1990s who pushed for a complete lack of road infrastructure in the Indian Himalayas just so that in the event of a war, the Chinese army would not be able use roads to progress any further. I say this as someone who has worked with such policy makers AND as an avid mountaineer on the Indian Himalayas. But one can also see this difference clearly just from Google Earth.
You just inspired me to do the same exact topic but about India :) Thank you
The USA, Canada, Australia, and Nordic countries have sparsely populated regions (the contiguous USA even smaller without Alaska) yet they're stereotyped as having great geographies and economies.
The USA's geographic superiority isn't a stereotype. It's a proven, measurable fact. Just one example: the continental US has more miles of navigable rivers than the rest of the world combined. Read that again. MORE than the ENTIRE rest of the world.
weird music choices in this video, not sure if anyone else picked up on that, but some of them were very jarring and uncomfortable to the ear, like, i nearly just closed down the video and left kind of uncomfortable
stop being an ass 😂 it's like light jazz, blues and atmospheric music.
6:58
I didn't know that you were Uzbek
So you are from Uzbekistan 😲😲😲😲😲
It would be AMAZING to get a video to about Uzbekistan from an Uzbek🤗 I feel like geographically, nationally or geopolitical Uzbekistan is never represented
So, basically those are China's Siberia?
Yep, China's Siberia but more like they are not cold of freeze like Siberia
The editing on this video is so weird personally I find the swaying back and forth of the map pretty annoying and the sad music was too loud compared to the voice. Lastly the video is called insane weakness yet those seem like very manageable weaknesses, almost every country has borders and who is going to attack through the mountains as was pointed out there is few people living there, the only real weakness would be Tibet in a conflict with India but that's also a normal weakness for many countries to have a river originating from outside their country.
Welcome to RUclips
I felt frequently showing maps helped clarify the points the author was making.
What dialect is that?
The blue area was a old china , at that time the other area was invaded by near nomadic tribes for 3 thousand years. When ching empire occupied the ming dynasty, insistently ching empire& Communist party ruled it .
It plays a defence buffers.
Somedays i hope that they will be free from china
Thanks for your posting.🌻
Spoiler: they won't. They'll go back to putting their forehead on the floor before the Chinese emperor. Cope and seethe.
❤️🇧🇩 Amazing
Wrong.
First and angry 😤
Meybe second and confused why you're angry
@@husseinmusse6826 life issues 😩
YES 100K!
Rome and England were ruled by foreign ethnicities too.
Almost every country with a long history has had foreign rulers at one point or another.
If you're doing two more video's on this I'd really recommend confirming your pronunciation on specific terms, there was a LOT of very poor pronunciation in this video, to the point where both me and my partner kept going "What?". I've watched a lot of your content, this was a pretty weak video though sadly, lots of aspects to improve, that other people have already commented on too.
People speaking a language not native to them are going to mispronounce things sometimes, get over it and use common sense to figure out what he's saying.
@@thunderstrucktb4758 I mean I understand that, but many were so bad as to be unrecognisable to someone with knowledge of the correct words to say. Someone with no knowledge will not understand that. And in the future will be confused
To be fair, in his defense, RUclips is an international platform that brings in content creators and viewers globally; It would be wrong to say that his accent is poor, considering that accents, by themself, are subjective and are inherited differently across regions. Although, I understand that you're addressing the fact that his accent doesn't follow one of the popular choices out there (let that be American, British and so on) but overall, as a non-native English speaker, his accent was relatively easier than a lot of my experiences.
Excellent book that deals with not only constraints of Chinas geography, but also how geography shapes geopolitics is "Prisoners of Geography: Ten Maps That Tell You Everything You Need to Know About Global Politics"
Lol China isn’t the biggest
Yaayy over 100k subs 👏🥳
Yay! Thank you and Thank you soo much for your support all these times, I really appreciate it :)