Stanton has had a huge downfall and thats just a fact. I still love how hard he used to hit the ball and how he doesn’t have a leg kick and yet still demolished the ball.
Exactly. Remember a couple of years ago when it turns out Judge was living with a broken rib for like a year? Yankees have THE WORST medical staff in the entire league
I'm a bonafide Yankee hater, but even trying to be objective, Cashman is a POS. He's gotta be the worst GM in the league unless Arte Moreno loses Ohtani _and_ Trout this offseason.
*Giancoward. Begged and cried, waived a full NTC to be traded to one of the MLB FINAL FOUR PLAYOFF ELITE of 2017(HOU, NYY, LAD, CHC). Wanted the easy route to the ring. You Pinstripe Nazi fvcks wanted to be tough guys and trade for him? Now fvcking deal with it.
Stanton is overpaid right now and isn't producing like he should but no player should ever get insulted by there own team or owner no matter how they feel i don't blame him if he wants to leave
Yankee fan here. Yes Stanton's injuries are annoying and never been a big fan of him, but for Cash to say that he purposely injures himself as part of his game is complete disrespect. No player player across any sport chooses to injure themself. Also, Cash picked him up from Miami too. Cash is the epitome of vain.
I'm not a yankees fan, but some of the stuff I've heard cashman say/do over the years kind of irritates me, like the way he spread the Jeter contract negotiations info to the media, the way he low-balled judge before free agency, and now the Giancarlo Stanton stuff. How does he get away with this bull-s, maybe it's because everyone always re-signs with the yankees/cashman's past success. No one ever seems to hold him accountable for the way he disrespects players. Maybe you guys could tell me more, I'm from the outside so looking in.
Even as a Red Sox fan, I feel bad for the guy. He's an amazing hitter if healthy. But he just can't stay on the field. Had a bad year this year as well. I bet the Yankees wish he'd held up more like David Ortiz or Jim Thome and hit tons of HR on his way to the HOF.
As a Yankee fan, I actually appreciate FINALLY a transparent comment from someone in charge. All of last year and frankly most of Stanton's tenure in NY, people have always called to get rid of him. Now management speaks up and says what the fans say and he gets chastised. Cash hasn't said anything not true. Stanton needs to man up and accept facts. He needs to get better at playing through pain and maybe alter his approach at fitness. If someone is that easily going to be hurt all the time, maybe playing the game isn't the best option anymore and instead should retire and save his body the stress.
As a Yankee fan, I'll happily admit Stanton has issues. But what Cashman did was bone headed at best. At best he pissed off one of the highest paid players on the team, at worst he has now damaged the relationship with Stanton and done nothing to promote his trade value. Just further proof Cashman should be out on his ass looking for another job
Look back at Cashman's scouting and draft picks.. Aaron Judge. That's it. That's the only HOF quality player that Cashman has drafted/scouted. 20+ years, one guy. The most overrated GM (YES-man) that is still employed in baseball. Been calling for his firing since 2014. If Yankees fans dont see Cashman as the problem, then good luck to mediocrity for another few years as long as he's there.
Most Yankee fans will agree with me when I say: Please, Please trade him to anyone who will take him. Even if you have to eat alot of the money. He's been paid 10's of thousands times the amount most of us will see in a lifetime before he was 30 years old. I don't care if Cashman hurt his ego.
I’m only 3 minutes in but there’s something up with the Yankees rehab team because you have players like Rizzo’s concussion go unchecked for 3 months and Stanton injuries that are common in sports but could also preventable to some degree (ie: change up stretches, yoga, before/after sports therapy… my mind is going black at the moment on specific name 🤦♀️) But I say this as a former gymnast and personal trainer. Im far from an expert on this but the Yankees have been called out for being cheap - remember when players had to pay for wi-fi on the team plane & we’re only called out when a reporter when that randomly came out from a player? Bad news is, tears can be reoccurring and can sideline you. I feel really bad for Stanton because it’s not like he is some lazy guy & you know he hears all the talk from fans & reporters (I highly doubt he listens to sports radio!)
I like Stanton but when we signed him, I knew he was going to breakdown. I feel sorry for the guy I know he wanted to be out there but we didn’t need him in the first place.
I mean Cashman isn't wrong I love Giancarlo but he's been healthy for one season in NY. Last season and a half he can't hit the fastball which was his go 2.
and this guy related the Marlins tenure in a jaded way. He only played over 125 games in 3 of the 8 seasons there. The injury thing started early and often.
And I can't forget his (lack of) defensive skills hurt too. In Game 3 of the 2022 ALCS, the Astros had the bases loaded with no one out, Mancini hit a fly ball to left, and after Stanton, playing LF for that game, made the catch, all runners on base advanced because he backtracked and didn't have much on the throw.
I wonder if stantons batting stance changing over the years was forced by the injuries. His front foot is much further foward and ahead of his rear foot by a good bit in the batters box, where it used to be much further back. Or maybe it was just in an effort to try and pull the ball a tad less.
I saw him discussing it somewhere in a video years ago, his swing path works better with a closed stance (he changed his stance in July 2017 I think, and then hit like 15 homers in August and won MVP)
I remember Stanton being soooo streaky. There were times that any partial mistake he would hit out or he’d even homer on great pitches out of the zone.
I've said it before, if you're on a max contract in New York, the tail end of those years are not going to be pretty. You know what you're signing up for and the same will happen with Judge.
Hal is probably putting the pressure on Cashman. The Yankees business model is to always make the playoffs, especially with what they charge fans. This is probably the first time after George passed where he has real pressure along with trying to appease the fans. Maybe saying how unwanted Stanton is by the organization will lead to a buyout. I just don't see (nor should he) him taking a dime less than his original contract regardless of what another franchise may offer.
Stanton is absolutely injury prone as an individual, but the fact that there's no mention of how the medical and training staff can't keep their $30mil/ year asset on the field is wild. Muscle strains and tendon inflammation issues are not freak accidents like a fastball to the face or broken bones - those are things the strength and conditioning trainers should be working on daily.
I think the medical staff is hamstrung though, no pun intended. If Stanton gets appropriate time off, he's missing too much time; if he's put out there too early, his injuries are likely to return. Not a great situation to be in for anyone.
His reputation is just so tarnished now which is sad because i genuinely want stanton to succeed. He doesnt have the accolades like trout or the long careers like nelson cruz but when he has a full healthy season hes genuinely on a path to become a hof
And even if people think the Yankees have to eat all of this, the Marlins will still have to pay Stanton $10M a year from 2026-2028 😮 He could be anywhere in the league and still be the 3rd/4th highest salary on the Marlins in those years (much like Scherzer still getting $15M from the Nationals, or Griffey Jr a few million from the Reds)
Pro contracts should come with stipulations about performance if they’re not able to perform at the level that they signed at, they should have reduced salaries so the payment is after the year of employment… Injuries aside that’s what insurance is for .. Stanton looks scared at the plate now…
Needs a team where he won’t deal with the scrutiny the Yankee fans drop on players for not hitting a home run every day. I think he could pull a Belli and have a resurgence with a team that doesn’t have major expectations like the Angels, Cardinals, or Giants.
he would fit the Angels perfectly, they thrive on packing the IL. Maybe if he could stay on the field to a sensible degree, and put the ball in play more often...
You cannot pay the man that much money and not have "major expectations". He will be booed wherever he goes if he continues to not hit, strike out and get injured watching game films.
Always wanted the Mets to sign Stanton, since he used to kill us when he was a Marlin. Never anticipated all of these injuries for him. To Cashman's credit, maybe he meant that Stanton's style of play leads to his injuries.
Giancarlo has had two consecutive bad seasons of batting under .220 and I cannot see him ever hitting above .250 again. His legs are shot so he’s an outfield and base running liability. Strictly DHing isn’t fair to Judge and others who need to be off their feet once or twice a week. Bottom line: Stanton is useless. He still has 4 seasons and over $100 M owed to him. The Players Union will not allow the Yankees to pay off less than 75 cents on the dollar. Only a 100% payout is acceptable. Thanks, Brian Cashman!!
The Stanton deal was disaster and I never wanted him, but I like him personally. He is certainly trying. And let's face it, the Yankees keep telling him how great his exit velocities are, so he's going to keep overexerting himself and getting hurt. They're not really steering him in the right direction. Cashman seems to be exploiting the fact that he's clearly un-fireable.
I'm not a yankees fan, but some of the stuff I've heard cashman say/do over the years kind of irritates me, like the way he spread the Jeter contract negotiations info to the media, the way he low-balled judge before free agency, and now the Giancarlo Stanton stuff. How does he get away with this bull-s, maybe it's because everyone always re-signs with the yankees/cashman's past success. No one ever seems to hold him accountable for the way he disrespects players. Maybe you guys could tell me more, I'm from the outside so looking in.
I mean yeah he gets hurt a lot and he’s got that big contract…but man he was one of the very few that showed up during the playoffs. Not his fault the others faltered during that time…the most important time of the year, too.
What I hate about modern MLB is that people obsess about how far a ball is hit or its exit velo.. But at the end of the day all home runs are equal.. You dont get extra runs for a 500 footer ... Call me old school but I respect the guys that consistently bat above .260 with a good mix of power and average and some speed always helps.. I still value Rbis and big hits over War and think alot of analytics are detached from the flow of the game..
Does anybody know if Stanton has a no-trade clause? I’m curious since I’ve read rumors the NYY are open to trading him (and his contract) so maybe the “insult” was a tactical move to intentional anger Stanton thus making more amenable to waiving his no-trade clause (if one even exists)? Any Yankees fans know?
It’s very VERY sad that as a society we have reached this point: A grown man playing a sport for HUNDREDS of MILLIONS of dollars per year could possibly be insulted by his GM telling the truth. I’m a Stanton fan and would love to see him MASH like he is capable of doing in a lineup consisting of Volpe, Dominguez, Judge, Soto, Stanton, Wells, Torres. But I don’t think Stanton can stay in the lineup. And he shouldn’t be upset when confronted with the truth. IF he was providing the value that they were expecting when they traded for him, there wouldn’t have been the nearly fruitless LF search from last season. There might not even be the same impetus to HAVE TO get Soto. Stanton has underproduced and should be upset at being called on it by anyone.
In fairness to Cashman, I think what he meant by "part of his game" is 'part of what he brings to the table.' Still not a nice thing to say but quite different from suggesting he's missing playing time on purpose.
Might leave? He should have been gone long ago, for he has looked like an amateur chasing curves and sliders way out of the strike zone for years now. He can't even hit .200.
Ain't no one gonna value stanton as much as the Marlins and Yankees did. If he wants to bounce and retire somewhere like the Reds or Kansas City, feel free. How he's handled NYC? You mean handling reporters while playing badly? Woo. Play well and be terrible in the press room and you'd literally be the biggest star in the game.
Hey Giancarlo, do you know what fan bases shower love on their players? Both the Giant's and the Card's. Good luck with the rest of your stay in New York. - Signed: A salty fan from San Francisco who still remembers you declining a trade to the Giants.
Cashman: "Giancarlo getting hurt is a part of his game... ...just like Harrison Bader, Carlos Rodon, Frankie Montas, Anthony Rizzo, Jasson Dominguez, etc.
It sucks because when Derek Jeter traded him to the Yankees, we were supposed to have a player that helped bring championships to the Bronx. A player that eventually hits 500 home runs and celebrate that milestone. A player that broke records in post season. A freak player that hit different type of home runs thst you don’t ever see in baseball behind another freak that hit the longest home runs in Aaron Judge. We only got that in spurts. This was supposed to be mantle / maris. They were never on the field at the same time to have that chemistry as 2-3 hitters. I love Stanton, but, instead of being part of Yankees history as one of the most feared 2-3 hitters ever, we’re gonna look back and say what could’ve been. It was something that just never happened. And that really sucks. Stanton is one of the best homerun hitters I’ve ever seen. He just couldn’t stay on the field here.
there are generally two types of injury in sport. Trauma and acute. Trauma can be attributed to luck, ie getting hit in the face with a ball. Could have happened to anyone, sadly, it happened to Giancarlo. Then there is acute, strained hamstring, strained bicep etc. those injuries are mostly the result of repetitive movements of muscles that are not in peak physical condition or are biomechanically misfiring. I would never accuse a pro athlete of not being in peak physical condition but something is definitely off here. This falls on the Yankees training staff, too, for not recognizing and dealing with this adequately. There is also a host of other issues like diet, offseason routine, maybe he has a personal trainer who is leading him in another direction. Either way its sad to see, and its sad to see preventable injuries hold him back.
Only 5 players have hit a ball 120+ mph those being O'Neil Cruz, Gary Sánchez, Judge, and Acuña who have each done it once and Stanton who has done it a insane 14 times 6 of them coming in 2021
I don't understand how you equate stating that an injury prone player is injury prone is "talking him down" or "having no faith." I think he is talking of him at exactly the right level ahd having faith that Stanton will continue to deliver what he has delivered. Stanton may willing to play somewhere else? Who would want him for $128 million? Tampa pays their entire team $75 mil. If I were Yankees GM, I'd give him 2 more months, after which he will be playing somewhere else: Wilkes-Barre.
he was already injury riddled before he went to NY. 5 out of 8 seasons for Marlins less than 125 games. And, getting hit the face was one of the 3 seasons over 125 games.
@@strange-universe The above-vodeo does a good job of explaining why the characterization of "injury riddled" is moronic. Does it occur to you that there is a difference between repetitive motion injury - guys just inuring themselves by running, throwing or swinging - verses collision injuries. Because EVERYONE is going to miss games after being hit in the face with a pitch. But not everyone injures himself running the bases. Too subtle? And why did you make you cutoff 125 games? Why not 116? Because that way you'd get stuck saying he had 6 out 8 on healthy seasons?
Perhaps Brian is trying to light up a fire in Giancarlo (sort of the way he did with Judge in 2022) or maybe wants him to request a trade. As a Yankee fan, I’m frustrated with Giancarlo & I imagine Brian is also. But don’t think the timing was smart, since Giancarlo has the same agent as Yamamoto, who the Yankees want.
Yeah but I’m glad he didn’t come to SF. I like Stanton a lot, but especially now with Ohtani as a FA, we have a chance at getting him much more than if Stanton and Judge were here
For some reason or another, baseball players over 6'3" (6' 4" and up) tend to be more injury prom and not long lasting. I think that the strikes zone and the way pitchers pitch taller players puts them at a disadvantage because of the strike zone and how they have to stand at the plate and swinging somewhat uncomfortable that over the long run it catches up to them. Most great hitters of all time have been between 5'10" and 6'1" (without lying about their which they often do, adding at least 1 inch, like Vladimir Jr who is about 5'11" and lists himself as 6'2").
I believe it comes down to how much force that a larger player can generate; you can generate force by being explosive ( heavy on quick-twitch muscles, leading to quicker movements; and speed=power, ask any football player), but you can also generate force through generating more leverage (having longer limbs; the reason tall, lanky players are sometimes described as having "wiry strength") Most of the elite power hitters are some combination of long-limbed (or large in general) and explosive; smaller power hitters have a tendency to generate power through explosiveness and barrel accuracy (like a Mookie Betts or Jose Altuve; hopefully Corbin Carroll can join that group) Now, the more force a player generates the harder it is to direct that force (that's why hitters with elite bat speed have a tendency to swing-and-miss), and if it isn't directed effectively it can lead to joint wear (because it's difficult, if not impossible, to train tendon/ligament strength) and injury. Big, muscle-bound guys have a tendency to be lacking in the flexibility department, and a lack of flexibility is almost by definition a lack in range of motion. Abruptly going beyond normal range of motion is one of the quickest ways to cause injury. And that's not even considering efficiency (or inefficiency) of mechanics. Hopefully that helps!
@@ShiroiKiba Veryey true....But I have seen great hitters like Pete Rose, Rod Carew, Ken Griffey Sr and Jr, Paul Molitor, Manny Ramirez, Adrian Beltre, and many others. They have several things in common. They were not very tall, eye-level closer to the strike zone and not having to make a significant physical adjustment as they swam, and did not have significantly long extremities (arms).
As a Yankees fan I think it’s terrible what Cashman said about Stanton. He’s the general manager he put a team together and now it’s not making the playoffs he’s trying to wiggle his way out of the mess that he made of the team. Maybe it’s Cashman who isn’t as good as he used to be.
I could see the Giants trading a couple of prospects who don't look like they'll get to the majors for Stanton, and the Yankees taking it to get him off their payroll.
I agree with your analysis, but funny Cash takes that shot, or maybe it's totally expected since he and Boone are just as bad for the team and the easiest thing to do is always blame someone else. As long as Cash and Boone are there I have no hope on the Yankees!
Station would be better served accepting a trade to a west coast team, where the weather is better and he doesn't have to sit in cold environments between innings, allowing muscles to tightened,, nerve conduction velocities to diminish. Once an athlete sustains a grade II Hamstring strain, the probability that that muscle will sustain a re-injury under stress is probably 100%, because muscle and tendon strains heal via scar tissue filling in the partial tear defect. Scar tissue is weaker to torsional and shear stresses than the original muscle fibers and therefore more apt to rupture during the eccentric phase of muscle contraction during the swing phase of running gait, when the Hamstrings are activated to effectively decelerate the rapidly extending knee flexing hip. During this phase of gait, the Hamstrings are contracting, but lengthening (being stretched, analogous to an athlete performing forced negative arm curls, extending the elbows from a flexed position, carrying a heavy load while contracting the Biceps muscle group). Greater forces are applied to muscles during eccentric (muscle is contracting , but lengthening) then during concentric (muscle is contracting and shortening) muscle contractions, placing the muscle at greater risk of injury. As a Sports Scientist/Exercise Physiologist, Biomechanist, and Human Performance Specialist, having worked with many professional and olympic athletes, invented or exercise and military equipment, an performed research on Hamstring injuries, I can without hesitation state that 99.999% of physicians and physical therapists do not know how to properly rehabilitate Hamstring Injuries, because they have failed to read the scientific literature on the subject, period. Grade II Hamstring injuries require in excess of one year to heal, and the healed by-product of the injury will always represent a weakened functional entity compared to the original un-injured muscle, prone to re-injury and progression of the grade II to a complete rupture, Grade III, requiring surgery. I posted this at the time of Staton's injury, and was very concerned for his welfare, when the Yankees had him return to play after just 2 months, a period grossly insufficient to permit healing of a grade II Hamstring strain. This was in effect medical malpractice, if the treating physician signed off on his return to play.
Cashman had a month where people werent chanting fire cashman and it went to his head. It seems like recently hes been just baiting the fans. "i know my jobs safe so lets see how much i can piss off the people who wanted me gone"
Stanton just has to change his batting stance, He needs to bring his left leg/foot more towards third base. Look at his pre-Yankee years. He should stand more like Judge. This is how he used to stand.
When he came to the Yankees I said wow 2 huge monster power players this is going to be very sick & intoxicating having two updated home run hitting monsters on the Yankees but as the years have gone by I've heard more about judge then about Stanton then his injuries it made me think about the Carl pavano situation yeah the 40 million dollar pitching bust the Yankees signed he hardly pitched was on the injury list often he was just sitting back and getting paid his millions till the Yankees finally got rid of him look like they're going to have to do the same with Stanton sadly what a waste of millions of dollars so many Yankee fans wanted him and judge to destroy the other teams bashing them to death with monster home runs shots like mantle & maris did in the 60s it didn't workout well at all the last 4in a half years with Stanton at least too much money too many injuries the marlins were smart in getting rid of him they saw what the Yankees didn't see he only looked good visually but productively he was a waste of time and money and a major disappointment to all Yankee fans who hoped for his very best which lasted for only 1 season and he's been a bomb ever since that's very sad to Yankee fans 😢 we just need to find another to take his place that all
"Stanton was able to get a front row dugout seat for Jose Altuve's homerun in Game 6 (of the 2019 ALCS)"... Haha. So funny. Ironically, Altuve was the AL MVP when Stanton got his NL MVP award in 2017.
My god, my managers and directors are always critiquing my performance. If I whined about their criticisms when it’s valid, I’d be laughed out if the building.
Stanton has permanent injuries. He will never be great again. No team will want him after they see his physical so he is staying with the Yankees till that contract is done.
Always been a huge Giancarlo fan. However, if the legs are gone and he can’t move quickly enough to spray the ball according to where it’s pitched, than it’s just sad.
Oh please let this happen? Please John Carlo, go somewhere else and find your fountain of youth. I have no doubt you'll go to Minnesota and hit 60 bombs next year while stealing 30 bases and playing in 150 games.
I hated the trade when it happened. Another power right handed bat when the yanks clearly needed a leftie. That being said, he actually played well for a while and had that monster post season. It’s just sad that his body broke down. Time to move on
"Brian Cashman says he loves Stanton and thinks he will stay healthy, and there are zero implications Stanton will ever leave" That better? I made it actual clickbait
Stanton has had a huge downfall and thats just a fact. I still love how hard he used to hit the ball and how he doesn’t have a leg kick and yet still demolished the ball.
Trading for Stanton was the worst move by the Yankees
He still hits it hard he just doesn't hit it enough. He did one 119.5 mph this year. Second hardest behind Acuna 121.2
@vidowatcher91 great information thanks I wouldn't have guessed this I would've guessed elly 2nd
Easy to launch the ball when you're juiced 😂
@@ronnieortiz6803true which makes Stanton’s abilities that much more impressive since he doesn’t juice
Blaming a player for being injury prone after the Rizzo concussion situation this year is wild to me
Exactly. Remember a couple of years ago when it turns out Judge was living with a broken rib for like a year? Yankees have THE WORST medical staff in the entire league
Cashman is a literally a tyrant dawg 😭
I'm a bonafide Yankee hater, but even trying to be objective, Cashman is a POS. He's gotta be the worst GM in the league unless Arte Moreno loses Ohtani _and_ Trout this offseason.
Head injuries are difficult to diagnose.
@@SupraFootwear2013they clearly didn't tried. They run the whole organisation like it's still 2003.
As a Yankee fan, I appreciate what he has done for us despite the injuries, but he has to go unless something drastically changes for him.
How do you move him with that contract though? This is why I don't like the mega long contracts for anyone.
@@Curly_Maple If I’m Cahsman, DFA Stanton and swallow my pride and admit I’ve made a huge mistake
*Giancoward. Begged and cried, waived a full NTC to be traded to one of the MLB FINAL FOUR PLAYOFF ELITE of 2017(HOU, NYY, LAD, CHC). Wanted the easy route to the ring. You Pinstripe Nazi fvcks wanted to be tough guys and trade for him? Now fvcking deal with it.
@@michaeld808sI swear Yankees fans milk “ DFA” so hard and don’t understand what it actually means
he's done nothing for us except under perform
I also really want the Yankees to fire Cashman but unfortunately that’s probably not going to happen
Cashman is the one who needs to get fired not Boone.
I really hope the Yankees keep him for years to come. He’s doing a great job.
@@patrickthompson8142 he is great player. But his body is breaking down and he is now a liablility.
I dream of the day we fire Cash.
@@Dempsey222 I meant Cashman. Yankees must keep him at all costs
Stanton is overpaid right now and isn't producing like he should but no player should ever get insulted by there own team or owner no matter how they feel i don't blame him if he wants to leave
Yankee fan here. Yes Stanton's injuries are annoying and never been a big fan of him, but for Cash to say that he purposely injures himself as part of his game is complete disrespect. No player player across any sport chooses to injure themself. Also, Cash picked him up from Miami too. Cash is the epitome of vain.
Purposely injures himself? Do you know how to read? Thats not what he said
I'm not a yankees fan, but some of the stuff I've heard cashman say/do over the years kind of irritates me, like the way he spread the Jeter contract negotiations info to the media, the way he low-balled judge before free agency, and now the Giancarlo Stanton stuff.
How does he get away with this bull-s, maybe it's because everyone always re-signs with the yankees/cashman's past success. No one ever seems to hold him accountable for the way he disrespects players.
Maybe you guys could tell me more, I'm from the outside so looking in.
@@TheRealSandorClegane Cash said it's part of his game, implying that's how he chooses to play the game.
Getting Stanton off the books opens up so many possibilities this could be a effort to get it to waive his no trade clause
He Never said he purposely injures himself
Even as a Red Sox fan, I feel bad for the guy. He's an amazing hitter if healthy. But he just can't stay on the field. Had a bad year this year as well. I bet the Yankees wish he'd held up more like David Ortiz or Jim Thome and hit tons of HR on his way to the HOF.
As a Yankee fan, I actually appreciate FINALLY a transparent comment from someone in charge.
All of last year and frankly most of Stanton's tenure in NY, people have always called to get rid of him. Now management speaks up and says what the fans say and he gets chastised. Cash hasn't said anything not true. Stanton needs to man up and accept facts. He needs to get better at playing through pain and maybe alter his approach at fitness. If someone is that easily going to be hurt all the time, maybe playing the game isn't the best option anymore and instead should retire and save his body the stress.
As a Yankee fan, I'll happily admit Stanton has issues. But what Cashman did was bone headed at best. At best he pissed off one of the highest paid players on the team, at worst he has now damaged the relationship with Stanton and done nothing to promote his trade value. Just further proof Cashman should be out on his ass looking for another job
Look back at Cashman's scouting and draft picks.. Aaron Judge. That's it. That's the only HOF quality player that Cashman has drafted/scouted. 20+ years, one guy. The most overrated GM (YES-man) that is still employed in baseball. Been calling for his firing since 2014. If Yankees fans dont see Cashman as the problem, then good luck to mediocrity for another few years as long as he's there.
@@MerpTimethat’s what happens when u only use the eye test and not analytics when scouting
He needs to go
Most Yankee fans will agree with me when I say: Please, Please trade him to anyone who will take him. Even if you have to eat alot of the money. He's been paid 10's of thousands times the amount most of us will see in a lifetime before he was 30 years old. I don't care if Cashman hurt his ego.
🫡👍🏼
Yankees would have to cover most of the salary not maybe
I’m only 3 minutes in but there’s something up with the Yankees rehab team because you have players like Rizzo’s concussion go unchecked for 3 months and Stanton injuries that are common in sports but could also preventable to some degree (ie: change up stretches, yoga, before/after sports therapy… my mind is going black at the moment on specific name 🤦♀️) But I say this as a former gymnast and personal trainer. Im far from an expert on this but the Yankees have been called out for being cheap - remember when players had to pay for wi-fi on the team plane & we’re only called out when a reporter when that randomly came out from a player? Bad news is, tears can be reoccurring and can sideline you.
I feel really bad for Stanton because it’s not like he is some lazy guy & you know he hears all the talk from fans & reporters (I highly doubt he listens to sports radio!)
I like Stanton but when we signed him, I knew he was going to breakdown. I feel sorry for the guy I know he wanted to be out there but we didn’t need him in the first place.
You're looking at Aaron in 3 years... He's also a big guy that will prove to be injury prone signed to a massive contract.
I mean Cashman isn't wrong
I love Giancarlo but he's been healthy for one season in NY.
Last season and a half he can't hit the fastball which was his go 2.
and this guy related the Marlins tenure in a jaded way. He only played over 125 games in 3 of the 8 seasons there. The injury thing started early and often.
ill give stanton credit. he has handled nyc amazingly considering everything.
He grew up in another media city in the west
And I can't forget his (lack of) defensive skills hurt too. In Game 3 of the 2022 ALCS, the Astros had the bases loaded with no one out, Mancini hit a fly ball to left, and after Stanton, playing LF for that game, made the catch, all runners on base advanced because he backtracked and didn't have much on the throw.
Watch him go to another team and hit 35 HRs
And bat .180.
Look at every player who left the yankees. I bet he could
and hit .215 and cant' run because, you know, he'll HURT himself. ENJOY!!!
@@GeraldM_inNCbatting average doesn't mean a thing these days apparently.
I wonder if stantons batting stance changing over the years was forced by the injuries. His front foot is much further foward and ahead of his rear foot by a good bit in the batters box, where it used to be much further back. Or maybe it was just in an effort to try and pull the ball a tad less.
I think his stance is psychological. He got drilled in the face while still with Miami and he probably thinks, in his head, he is more protected.
I saw him discussing it somewhere in a video years ago, his swing path works better with a closed stance (he changed his stance in July 2017 I think, and then hit like 15 homers in August and won MVP)
That Mike Fiers fastball to his face affected him forever because he’s afraid to stand closer to the plate.
I remember Stanton being soooo streaky. There were times that any partial mistake he would hit out or he’d even homer on great pitches out of the zone.
3:09 Stanton played 7 games in the 2020 postseason not 1 he hit .308, .387, 1.038, and 1.425 probably his best performance in the postseason
Maybe he should have accepted that trade to the Cardinals or Giants.
I always thought he would've been much happier at home in Cali with the Giants.
Would be funny if he joined dodgers
Anything longer than a 4-5 year contract is completely nuts
I've said it before, if you're on a max contract in New York, the tail end of those years are not going to be pretty. You know what you're signing up for and the same will happen with Judge.
Stanton is horrendous. What a disgrace to see the guy run at a 30% pace on the bases. He should retire.
Hal is probably putting the pressure on Cashman. The Yankees business model is to always make the playoffs, especially with what they charge fans.
This is probably the first time after George passed where he has real pressure along with trying to appease the fans. Maybe saying how unwanted Stanton is by the organization will lead to a buyout.
I just don't see (nor should he) him taking a dime less than his original contract regardless of what another franchise may offer.
Stanton is absolutely injury prone as an individual, but the fact that there's no mention of how the medical and training staff can't keep their $30mil/ year asset on the field is wild. Muscle strains and tendon inflammation issues are not freak accidents like a fastball to the face or broken bones - those are things the strength and conditioning trainers should be working on daily.
I think the medical staff is hamstrung though, no pun intended. If Stanton gets appropriate time off, he's missing too much time; if he's put out there too early, his injuries are likely to return. Not a great situation to be in for anyone.
Former Yankees doing better after leaving the club. Sounds like there’s a climate problem.
A cultural problem
Like who?
Who is doing better after leaving the Yanks ? Which players are having respectful careers after bombing in New York
Edit: Besides Sonny Gray lol
@@MikeHart72 Sonny Gray doesn't count, the guy was terrible the moment he arrived. Just couldn't handle playing in meaningful games.
@@1Plebeian Yes I know. I’m just trying to get this guy to respond. Obviously he knows nothing and is just repeating things he hears
I think one issue with Stanton is his size and that could possibly be a reason for his injuries
His reputation is just so tarnished now which is sad because i genuinely want stanton to succeed. He doesnt have the accolades like trout or the long careers like nelson cruz but when he has a full healthy season hes genuinely on a path to become a hof
And even if people think the Yankees have to eat all of this, the Marlins will still have to pay Stanton $10M a year from 2026-2028 😮 He could be anywhere in the league and still be the 3rd/4th highest salary on the Marlins in those years (much like Scherzer still getting $15M from the Nationals, or Griffey Jr a few million from the Reds)
Stanton dislocated a tear duct when he read this post.
Hey dude. Just wanted to say I love your content, your my favorite MLB content creator besides JOMBOY. Keep it up!
Pro contracts should come with stipulations about performance if they’re not able to perform at the level that they signed at, they should have reduced salaries so the payment is after the year of employment…
Injuries aside that’s what insurance is for ..
Stanton looks scared at the plate now…
The players union is going to love that
Gincarlo Stanton hit a Walk off Grandslam last year, which was the wildest moment I ever saw at yankee stadium and Judge hit no. 60 that night
Imagine the Yankees could have two 45 plus homer per year guys if Stanton was healthy
Rizzo healthy in his Cub prime in Yankee stadium I think could been 40+. Donaldson too.
and still miss the playoffs due to poor defense, strike outs and poor game management. HORRAY!!
@@naturallawman2965 Gary too! But he didn’t.
3:17 what? He had one of the greatest postseasons ever that year wtf he hit like 8 homers
*6
👍
One year?
They should just trade him & Rodon to the Angels for Rendon. At least Rendon can play the field & only has 2 yrs left.
Forget 140k, those are rookie numbers. We want 200k subscribers
Needs a team where he won’t deal with the scrutiny the Yankee fans drop on players for not hitting a home run every day. I think he could pull a Belli and have a resurgence with a team that doesn’t have major expectations like the Angels, Cardinals, or Giants.
giants low expectations is insane
not hitting a home run every day? he’s a DH with a sub 100 ops+ lmao
Not sure the Cards or Giants fanbases would welcome him after he declined trades to those franchises in 2017.
he would fit the Angels perfectly, they thrive on packing the IL. Maybe if he could stay on the field to a sensible degree, and put the ball in play more often...
You cannot pay the man that much money and not have "major expectations". He will be booed wherever he goes if he continues to not hit, strike out and get injured watching game films.
I think that Stanton needs to call it quits and he needs to retire
Always wanted the Mets to sign Stanton, since he used to kill us when he was a Marlin. Never anticipated all of these injuries for him. To Cashman's credit, maybe he meant that Stanton's style of play leads to his injuries.
Giancarlo has had two consecutive bad seasons of batting under .220 and I cannot see him ever hitting above .250 again. His legs are shot so he’s an outfield and base running liability. Strictly DHing isn’t fair to Judge and others who need to be off their feet once or twice a week. Bottom line: Stanton is useless.
He still has 4 seasons and over $100 M owed to him. The Players Union will not allow the Yankees to pay off less than 75 cents on the dollar. Only a 100% payout is acceptable. Thanks, Brian Cashman!!
It's not an insult if it's true.
Empathy? Professionalism? Social skills?
Stanton has to go !!! I know nobody wants his contract but he needs to go ! Dude is very fragile!
Great job on this video from the real Cam Maybin awesome stuff
The Stanton deal was disaster and I never wanted him, but I like him personally. He is certainly trying. And let's face it, the Yankees keep telling him how great his exit velocities are, so he's going to keep overexerting himself and getting hurt. They're not really steering him in the right direction. Cashman seems to be exploiting the fact that he's clearly un-fireable.
I'm not a yankees fan, but some of the stuff I've heard cashman say/do over the years kind of irritates me, like the way he spread the Jeter contract negotiations info to the media, the way he low-balled judge before free agency, and now the Giancarlo Stanton stuff.
How does he get away with this bull-s, maybe it's because everyone always re-signs with the yankees/cashman's past success. No one ever seems to hold him accountable for the way he disrespects players.
Maybe you guys could tell me more, I'm from the outside so looking in.
he's a dipshit. It comes out more when he's under stress.
Thank god he didnt leave he needs to strike out more along with judge who forgot to hit
I mean yeah he gets hurt a lot and he’s got that big contract…but man he was one of the very few that showed up during the playoffs. Not his fault the others faltered during that time…the most important time of the year, too.
Yup, he was the best Yankee hitter those playoffs. Judge did show up.
Not this year.
his name is Mike
What I hate about modern MLB is that people obsess about how far a ball is hit or its exit velo.. But at the end of the day all home runs are equal.. You dont get extra runs for a 500 footer ...
Call me old school but I respect the guys that consistently bat above .260 with a good mix of power and average and some speed always helps.. I still value Rbis and big hits over War and think alot of analytics are detached from the flow of the game..
Dodgers need a corner outfielder/DH👀
maybe
They don’t need him
Bro, dodgers are too smart to do that
He did grow up a Dodgers fan. 👀
But the money would be best invested in Ohtani and the prospects to build for the future.
@@marcitos_9329 I doubt they’ll have enough for him tho
Does anybody know if Stanton has a no-trade clause?
I’m curious since I’ve read rumors the NYY are open to trading him (and his contract) so maybe the “insult” was a tactical move to intentional anger Stanton thus making more amenable to waiving his no-trade clause (if one even exists)?
Any Yankees fans know?
Stanton has a full no trade clause. He'd have to approve any trade. No matter the deal he can just say no and it's over... no deal
Interesting.
Thanks for that.
It’s very VERY sad that as a society we have reached this point: A grown man playing a sport for HUNDREDS of MILLIONS of dollars per year could possibly be insulted by his GM telling the truth. I’m a Stanton fan and would love to see him MASH like he is capable of doing in a lineup consisting of Volpe, Dominguez, Judge, Soto, Stanton, Wells, Torres. But I don’t think Stanton can stay in the lineup. And he shouldn’t be upset when confronted with the truth. IF he was providing the value that they were expecting when they traded for him, there wouldn’t have been the nearly fruitless LF search from last season. There might not even be the same impetus to HAVE TO get Soto. Stanton has underproduced and should be upset at being called on it by anyone.
Anthony Rendon sends his regards. It can be worse.
In fairness to Cashman, I think what he meant by "part of his game" is 'part of what he brings to the table.' Still not a nice thing to say but quite different from suggesting he's missing playing time on purpose.
Might leave? He should have been gone long ago, for he has looked like
an amateur chasing curves and sliders way out of the strike zone for years
now. He can't even hit .200.
Ain't no one gonna value stanton as much as the Marlins and Yankees did. If he wants to bounce and retire somewhere like the Reds or Kansas City, feel free. How he's handled NYC? You mean handling reporters while playing badly? Woo. Play well and be terrible in the press room and you'd literally be the biggest star in the game.
Hey Giancarlo, do you know what fan bases shower love on their players? Both the Giant's and the Card's. Good luck with the rest of your stay in New York.
- Signed: A salty fan from San Francisco who still remembers you declining a trade to the Giants.
Cashman: "Giancarlo getting hurt is a part of his game...
...just like Harrison Bader, Carlos Rodon, Frankie Montas, Anthony Rizzo, Jasson Dominguez, etc.
No shot you included Dominguez on there 🤡
He should come to the Astros and platoon left field/DH with Yordan Alvarez!
No way, he's not worth league minimum
I was never a fan of the trade. But it was honestly a prelude to how bad Cashman would handle the “baby bomber” era.
Nah they stuck with that contract 😂
It sucks because when Derek Jeter traded him to the Yankees, we were supposed to have a player that helped bring championships to the Bronx. A player that eventually hits 500 home runs and celebrate that milestone. A player that broke records in post season. A freak player that hit different type of home runs thst you don’t ever see in baseball behind another freak that hit the longest home runs in Aaron Judge. We only got that in spurts. This was supposed to be mantle / maris. They were never on the field at the same time to have that chemistry as 2-3 hitters. I love Stanton, but, instead of being part of Yankees history as one of the most feared 2-3 hitters ever, we’re gonna look back and say what could’ve been. It was something that just never happened. And that really sucks. Stanton is one of the best homerun hitters I’ve ever seen. He just couldn’t stay on the field here.
there are generally two types of injury in sport. Trauma and acute. Trauma can be attributed to luck, ie getting hit in the face with a ball. Could have happened to anyone, sadly, it happened to Giancarlo. Then there is acute, strained hamstring, strained bicep etc. those injuries are mostly the result of repetitive movements of muscles that are not in peak physical condition or are biomechanically misfiring. I would never accuse a pro athlete of not being in peak physical condition but something is definitely off here. This falls on the Yankees training staff, too, for not recognizing and dealing with this adequately. There is also a host of other issues like diet, offseason routine, maybe he has a personal trainer who is leading him in another direction. Either way its sad to see, and its sad to see preventable injuries hold him back.
Only 5 players have hit a ball 120+ mph those being O'Neil Cruz, Gary Sánchez, Judge, and Acuña who have each done it once and Stanton who has done it a insane 14 times 6 of them coming in 2021
These long-term contracts based on one or two years of great performance almost never pay off.
I don't understand how you equate stating that an injury prone player is injury prone is "talking him down" or "having no faith." I think he is talking of him at exactly the right level ahd having faith that Stanton will continue to deliver what he has delivered.
Stanton may willing to play somewhere else? Who would want him for $128 million? Tampa pays their entire team $75 mil.
If I were Yankees GM, I'd give him 2 more months, after which he will be playing somewhere else: Wilkes-Barre.
he was already injury riddled before he went to NY. 5 out of 8 seasons for Marlins less than 125 games. And, getting hit the face was one of the 3 seasons over 125 games.
@@strange-universe The above-vodeo does a good job of explaining why the characterization of "injury riddled" is moronic.
Does it occur to you that there is a difference between repetitive motion injury - guys just inuring themselves by running, throwing or swinging - verses collision injuries. Because EVERYONE is going to miss games after being hit in the face with a pitch. But not everyone injures himself running the bases. Too subtle?
And why did you make you cutoff 125 games? Why not 116? Because that way you'd get stuck saying he had 6 out 8 on healthy seasons?
Perhaps Brian is trying to light up a fire in Giancarlo (sort of the way he did with Judge in 2022) or maybe wants him to request a trade. As a Yankee fan, I’m frustrated with Giancarlo & I imagine Brian is also. But don’t think the timing was smart, since Giancarlo has the same agent as Yamamoto, who the Yankees want.
Only thing about him that's impressive is his exit velocities. That's it.
finally
This wouldn't have happened if he went to the Giants. He would have been THE household name, and fans would have loved him.
Yeah but I’m glad he didn’t come to SF. I like Stanton a lot, but especially now with Ohtani as a FA, we have a chance at getting him much more than if Stanton and Judge were here
He sadly didn't fully live up to the hype
i am just glad that most of the star players on my team is being treated well
Cashman is great at building teams. Other people's teams thst is. When was the lasr time they developed a player who became a star?
For some reason or another, baseball players over 6'3" (6' 4" and up) tend to be more injury prom and not long lasting. I think that the strikes zone and the way pitchers pitch taller players puts them at a disadvantage because of the strike zone and how they have to stand at the plate and swinging somewhat uncomfortable that over the long run it catches up to them. Most great hitters of all time have been between 5'10" and 6'1" (without lying about their which they often do, adding at least 1 inch, like Vladimir Jr who is about 5'11" and lists himself as 6'2").
This is the dumbest shit I’ve read all day. And in no way, shape or form, even remotely true.
I believe it comes down to how much force that a larger player can generate; you can generate force by being explosive ( heavy on quick-twitch muscles, leading to quicker movements; and speed=power, ask any football player), but you can also generate force through generating more leverage (having longer limbs; the reason tall, lanky players are sometimes described as having "wiry strength")
Most of the elite power hitters are some combination of long-limbed (or large in general) and explosive; smaller power hitters have a tendency to generate power through explosiveness and barrel accuracy (like a Mookie Betts or Jose Altuve; hopefully Corbin Carroll can join that group)
Now, the more force a player generates the harder it is to direct that force (that's why hitters with elite bat speed have a tendency to swing-and-miss), and if it isn't directed effectively it can lead to joint wear (because it's difficult, if not impossible, to train tendon/ligament strength) and injury.
Big, muscle-bound guys have a tendency to be lacking in the flexibility department, and a lack of flexibility is almost by definition a lack in range of motion. Abruptly going beyond normal range of motion is one of the quickest ways to cause injury.
And that's not even considering efficiency (or inefficiency) of mechanics. Hopefully that helps!
@@ShiroiKiba Veryey true....But I have seen great hitters like Pete Rose, Rod Carew, Ken Griffey Sr and Jr, Paul Molitor, Manny Ramirez, Adrian Beltre, and many others. They have several things in common. They were not very tall, eye-level closer to the strike zone and not having to make a significant physical adjustment as they swam, and did not have significantly long extremities (arms).
As a Yankees fan I think it’s terrible what Cashman said about Stanton. He’s the general manager he put a team together and now it’s not making the playoffs he’s trying to wiggle his way out of the mess that he made of the team. Maybe it’s Cashman who isn’t as good as he used to be.
It's sad actually really sad how his production has diminished
I could see the Giants trading a couple of prospects who don't look like they'll get to the majors for Stanton, and the Yankees taking it to get him off their payroll.
As a long time O’s fan i just love Cashman still has a job😂
I agree with your analysis, but funny Cash takes that shot, or maybe it's totally expected since he and Boone are just as bad for the team and the easiest thing to do is always blame someone else. As long as Cash and Boone are there I have no hope on the Yankees!
Station would be better served accepting a trade to a west coast team, where the weather is better and he doesn't have to sit in cold environments between innings, allowing muscles to tightened,, nerve conduction velocities to diminish. Once an athlete sustains a grade II Hamstring strain, the probability that that muscle will sustain a re-injury under stress is probably 100%, because muscle and tendon strains heal via scar tissue filling in the partial tear defect. Scar tissue is weaker to torsional and shear stresses than the original muscle fibers and therefore more apt to rupture during the eccentric phase of muscle contraction during the swing phase of running gait, when the Hamstrings are activated to effectively decelerate the rapidly extending knee flexing hip. During this phase of gait, the Hamstrings are contracting, but lengthening (being stretched, analogous to an athlete performing forced negative arm curls, extending the elbows from a flexed position, carrying a heavy load while contracting the Biceps muscle group). Greater forces are applied to muscles during eccentric (muscle is contracting , but lengthening) then during concentric (muscle is contracting and shortening) muscle contractions, placing the muscle at greater risk of injury. As a Sports Scientist/Exercise Physiologist, Biomechanist, and Human Performance Specialist, having worked with many professional and olympic athletes, invented or exercise and military equipment, an performed research on Hamstring injuries, I can without hesitation state that 99.999% of physicians and physical therapists do not know how to properly rehabilitate Hamstring Injuries, because they have failed to read the scientific literature on the subject, period. Grade II Hamstring injuries require in excess of one year to heal, and the healed by-product of the injury will always represent a weakened functional entity compared to the original un-injured muscle, prone to re-injury and progression of the grade II to a complete rupture, Grade III, requiring surgery. I posted this at the time of Staton's injury, and was very concerned for his welfare, when the Yankees had him return to play after just 2 months, a period grossly insufficient to permit healing of a grade II Hamstring strain. This was in effect medical malpractice, if the treating physician signed off on his return to play.
Cashman had a month where people werent chanting fire cashman and it went to his head.
It seems like recently hes been just baiting the fans. "i know my jobs safe so lets see how much i can piss off the people who wanted me gone"
BC could have said that about a number of players. Shouldn't have singled him out. Players have injuries. Even Judge
Betcha he hits better somewhere else. Can’t stand the bright lights of NY
Bet ha he doesn’t do much better anywhere else. His body has broke down to the point he can’t barely run
Stanton just has to change his batting stance, He needs to bring his left leg/foot more towards third base. Look at his pre-Yankee years. He should stand more like Judge. This is how he used to stand.
When he came to the Yankees I said wow 2 huge monster power players this is going to be very sick & intoxicating having two updated home run hitting monsters on the Yankees but as the years have gone by I've heard more about judge then about Stanton then his injuries it made me think about the Carl pavano situation yeah the 40 million dollar pitching bust the Yankees signed he hardly pitched was on the injury list often he was just sitting back and getting paid his millions till the Yankees finally got rid of him look like they're going to have to do the same with Stanton sadly what a waste of millions of dollars so many Yankee fans wanted him and judge to destroy the other teams bashing them to death with monster home runs shots like mantle & maris did in the 60s it didn't workout well at all the last 4in a half years with Stanton at least too much money too many injuries the marlins were smart in getting rid of him they saw what the Yankees didn't see he only looked good visually but productively he was a waste of time and money and a major disappointment to all Yankee fans who hoped for his very best which lasted for only 1 season and he's been a bomb ever since that's very sad to Yankee fans 😢 we just need to find another to take his place that all
"Stanton was able to get a front row dugout seat for Jose Altuve's homerun in Game 6 (of the 2019 ALCS)"... Haha. So funny. Ironically, Altuve was the AL MVP when Stanton got his NL MVP award in 2017.
Make it worse that stanton agent is the same agent whom Yoshinobu Yamamoto currently have the same player that the Yankees want
My god, my managers and directors are always critiquing my performance. If I whined about their criticisms when it’s valid, I’d be laughed out if the building.
Stanton has permanent injuries. He will never be great again. No team will want him after they see his physical so he is staying with the Yankees till that contract is done.
Such a BS video...i've got problems with Cashman, but all he stated were facts, and it was not meant as an insult.
Always been a huge Giancarlo fan. However, if the legs are gone and he can’t move quickly enough to spray the ball according to where it’s pitched, than it’s just sad.
Steroid withdrawal
Oh please let this happen? Please John Carlo, go somewhere else and find your fountain of youth. I have no doubt you'll go to Minnesota and hit 60 bombs next year while stealing 30 bases and playing in 150 games.
Let’s hope he leaves
I hated the trade when it happened. Another power right handed bat when the yanks clearly needed a leftie. That being said, he actually played well for a while and had that monster post season. It’s just sad that his body broke down. Time to move on
Come to the Nats, Stanton… you deserve to rep the Nation’s Capital.
headline is nothing but clickbait and a lie smh
"Brian Cashman says he loves Stanton and thinks he will stay healthy, and there are zero implications Stanton will ever leave"
That better? I made it actual clickbait
I find it unacceptable for guys to sign these big long term contracts and lose more than 1 season to injury. I just find it unacceptable.
Cashman might’ve not been diplomatic. But he might’ve lit a fire under Stanton to play better.
You forgot to mention Schwarber’s massive .6 WAR lol