Texas professor FALSELY accuses class of using ChatGPT, fails them.

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 20 окт 2024
  • A Texas A&M-Commerce professor copied students essays into ChatGPT and gave out zeros if the chatbot said they cheated. The professor offered students to a chance to submit a new assignment by 5 p.m. Friday to not receive an incomplete for the class. Several students chose not to submit a new assignment and their diplomas are on hold.

Комментарии • 1,6 тыс.

  • @masterofwriters4176
    @masterofwriters4176 Год назад +30105

    This is why I’m recording my entire essay writing process start to finish to show i didn’t cheat. They even get the long pauses when i break down sobbing in the early morning.

    • @H0ldUp
      @H0ldUp Год назад +1462

      Does anyone else get a sudden rush of rage when their brain stops working, or is that just me🫥

    • @Armsmen
      @Armsmen Год назад +545

      @@H0ldUp No, I just get really confused about what’s happening or just can’t focus.

    • @andrewthomas817
      @andrewthomas817 Год назад +53

      that could be photoshoped

    • @penewoldahh
      @penewoldahh Год назад +36

      ​@@ThatBlockyMan exactly lmao

    • @Zoroaster4
      @Zoroaster4 Год назад +39

      ​@@ThatBlockyManI don't know. If it's a computer science course or something someone could probably write a realistic looking text to typing keyboard thingy ma jig. Just pretty much use a rubber ducky, where what looks like a flash drive but emulates a keyboard. It might take more time than writing a paper, but you can use it more than once. It will definitely take less time than 10 papers. Launch the program it picks a random time within set parameters for between each letter, then each word, then each sentence, paragraph, and so on. Just use screen capture or close up phone recording. Really anyway that would record the screen without recording the mouse or keyboard. I mean I could probably write a really basic version of it but probably wouldn't be sophisticated enough to fool anyone.

  • @mb-the-enby
    @mb-the-enby Год назад +18232

    ChatGPT told me that a paper I wrote in 2013 was written by ChatGPT

    • @dolandank4055
      @dolandank4055 Год назад +348

      Bruh

    • @JoshyHause
      @JoshyHause Год назад +560

      Essay writing algorithm websites have been around for as long as I was in high school. Though they just copied text straight from a single or couple sources.

    • @slurpy4548
      @slurpy4548 Год назад +310

      Oh so you're the guy with FiVe YeArS oF eXpErIeNcE in ChatGPT

    • @alexander-mauricemillamlae4567
      @alexander-mauricemillamlae4567 Год назад +182

      Maybe they based ChatGPTs algorithm on your paper! You should feel honored!

    • @JoshyHause
      @JoshyHause Год назад +31

      @@slurpy4548 Pre Alpha test team? :0

  • @CaTastrophy427
    @CaTastrophy427 Год назад +5592

    Didn't one of these AI checkers return "90+% AI written" for the US constitution?

    • @mycelia_ow
      @mycelia_ow Год назад +492

      Yes and It was 100% lol

    • @ImTheGuy
      @ImTheGuy Год назад

      I mean you weren't there, how do you know that Thomas Jefferson didn't secretly have a super AI that wrote the constitution.

    • @nunyabusiness5075
      @nunyabusiness5075 Год назад +543

      So which founding fathers had a time machine? Was that why they're considered ahead of their time? LOL

    • @Lobos222
      @Lobos222 Год назад +83

      I dont know, does copy paste everything from the UK and make some tweaks. Count as an original?

    • @supercellodude
      @supercellodude Год назад +70

      If the systems for checking written works for "AI authorship" are themselves machine-learning based, there's the setup for an arms race between Large Language Model developers and Verifier developers

  • @Boback111
    @Boback111 Год назад +7290

    Teacher using ChatGPT to grade essays? That sounds like cheating.

    • @corpsedancing
      @corpsedancing Год назад +54

      Pulled a mr garrizon

    • @Torpito0
      @Torpito0 Год назад +190

      Yes, technically it's their job to go through them & grade them one by one. Letting a robot grade his students essays is like cheating on his job & being lazy.

    • @MrPr1nglz
      @MrPr1nglz Год назад +11

      ​@@Torpito0 Except they were already looked at and how the teacher came to the conclusion it was made by chatGPT.

    • @TheUnderscore_
      @TheUnderscore_ Год назад +31

      I thought it was a "plagiarism" check, not an auto-grade.

    • @Whinywinston
      @Whinywinston Год назад +3

      @@Torpito0 well in that case students should do their own job too

  • @MisterRorschach90
    @MisterRorschach90 Год назад +4809

    I got a 0% on my English final in college. I knew this was wrong so I went to the professor and asked him what the deal was. He told me that I plagiarized the paper. I told him this was impossible. He pulled up their little search program to look for plagiarism and showed me the match. I then asked him to read the authors name out loud. He asked why and then read my name. I asked him how I could plagiarize myself. The final had the option of perfecting your midterm paper so I perfected it and part of the paper stayed the same because it was good enough. He basically forgot the instructions for his own final. Haha

    • @HProtagVtuber
      @HProtagVtuber Год назад +135

      Was he embarresed lol😊

    • @setlerking
      @setlerking Год назад +455

      Tbh to him, self plagiarism is a real thing. However this is hilariously stupid nonetheless

    • @setlerking
      @setlerking Год назад +273

      @@LycanKai14 passing off old works by yourself as if they’re new. Like using an old essay or text you’ve written about a topic and then claiming it is an independently and newly created work.

    • @sprshb1852
      @sprshb1852 Год назад +86

      @@setlerking Isn’t that just lying, not plagirising?

    • @ChrisTheWeak
      @ChrisTheWeak Год назад +29

      ​@@LycanKai14I don't know what it should be considered, but I know that at least at my school doing that in an essay would be considered plagiarism.

  • @koii55
    @koii55 Год назад +1197

    They’re obviously not a statistics professor. If the entire class apparently plagiarized, then the method for testing is probably inaccurate

    • @aeray3581
      @aeray3581 Год назад +24

      Exactly!

    • @gem9535
      @gem9535 Год назад +68

      Shh, that kind of logic requires thinking! You're scaring him!

    • @Ptoki1
      @Ptoki1 9 месяцев назад +28

      @@gem9535 english professor use logical thinking challenge (impossible)

    • @CrowAkechi_The_Luminary
      @CrowAkechi_The_Luminary 9 месяцев назад +9

      A lot of teachers just dont care to do that though, they just think they're right because they are the teacher

    • @ilyte1
      @ilyte1 8 месяцев назад +6

      ​@gem9535 What are you talking about? Teachers are authority and authority is never wrong

  • @ldragon4514
    @ldragon4514 Год назад +678

    Apparently the students put the professor’s thesis he wrote a couple years ago into chatgpt and asked chatgpt if it wrote it and SURPRISE chatgpt said it did.

    • @jackkraken3888
      @jackkraken3888 Год назад +50

      Wait it was ChatGPT all along?
      Always had been. (Bang)

  • @FantasmagoriaAhoy
    @FantasmagoriaAhoy Год назад +1675

    Teachers used to accuse their students of buying term papers with ZERO proof....and so the student had no recourse but to meet with them and plop all their references on the desk and pray that the teacher didn't have a score to settle with the Dean....

    • @myrhev
      @myrhev Год назад +22

      You mean offline? I may or may not have taken some classes for people and I may or may not have written papers for others. Either way, they always got all material involved in papers.

    • @0therun1t21
      @0therun1t21 Год назад +17

      That's what footnotes are for, to cite your references. Maybe you're talking about something I don't know about though, because I don't understand how this problem could occur in the first place.

    • @0therun1t21
      @0therun1t21 Год назад +2

      ​@@myrhev Yeah, I'm confused.

    • @OptimalOwl
      @OptimalOwl Год назад +9

      @@0therun1t21
      But wouldn't a guy being paid to write a paper put the references in the notes, the same as someone writing a paper for himself? If not, that's a pretty serious (and obvious) flaw in the scheme.

    • @FantasmagoriaAhoy
      @FantasmagoriaAhoy 6 месяцев назад

      ​@@0therun1t21I'm talking about stupid arrogant professors who just randomly accused students of buying papers onna website instead of writing them. Because there's no way they could conceive that a student the barely know could write a good paper. Literally no investigation. Just a baseless accusation.
      That's arrogance for you. It holds no reason.

  • @skellious
    @skellious Год назад +2769

    For anyone wondering chatGPT doesnt have any memory between sessions or people so it would have no way to know something was written with it. In theory you could ask it to guess how likely it was that chatgpt wrote it but it can't reliably estimate that and it will answer with full confidence that it can. This is called hallucination.
    If you want to see hallucination try asking it in detail about what happens in an episode of a TV show. It will get the character names right but the plot will be wrong, becuse it doesnt have details of the individual episodes. But it will happily make that all up and tell you its true.

    • @BlueScreenCorp
      @BlueScreenCorp Год назад +231

      It's almost like it's just an unthinking software program that people are giving waaaayyyy too much credit to

    • @_cloudface_
      @_cloudface_ Год назад +78

      It's basically like an advanced version of every other chatbot that's been around for the past 30 years but with better vocabulary and a wider pool of information to draw from.
      Despite myself I still anthropomorphize it and then get slightly frustrated when it doesn't remember something we discussed previously 😅 one time I was working on something with ChatGPT and then got logged out for a minute, lost everything and when I logged back in I couldn't remember the exact prompts etc I'd been using and of course ChatGPT had no idea what I meant by "reload that thing you just had on before" 🙄

    • @tylisirn
      @tylisirn Год назад +89

      @@_cloudface_ No, it's quite different from chatbots that we've had in the past (before since about couple years back). Rather, it's more closely related to the predictive text input from your cell phone. It's basically that on steroids. It tries to predict what text follows the input next.

    • @gorbonfree8245
      @gorbonfree8245 Год назад +7

      Yeah, ask it the plot of a game or movie and it goes wrong quick

    • @kyryloslav
      @kyryloslav Год назад +61

      I remember asking chatgpt for a statistics on some nieche subject, he gave me statistics with the source
      I googled the source and... There was no such paper. Authors were real, journal was real, but the paper didn't exist
      Then I asked it about this source, and it said (no joke, almost a direct quote)
      "I am sorry, that isn't a real document. I made it up"

  • @zuko83wangzi83
    @zuko83wangzi83 Год назад +513

    Professor better apologize to his students.
    And he should be heavily reprimanded.
    These are students lives in their hands.

    • @S0n0fG0D
      @S0n0fG0D Год назад

      ​@@Ometochtli and let me guess, he got in zero trouble for ruining students lives over his stupidity? Typical.

    • @justinkaufman495
      @justinkaufman495 Год назад +33

      ​@Ometochtli seems like it should be the other way around. The professor needs to provide proof that the students didn't write it they paid to be there and alot of them spent alot of time and effort writing those essays just to be told too bad try again because he wasn't smart enough to do a little bit of research into the technology first.

    • @princessthyemis
      @princessthyemis Год назад

      Yeah!!!

    • @AcidiFy574
      @AcidiFy574 Год назад +6

      Actually just cancel his career

    • @jsb7546
      @jsb7546 Год назад +1

      This is what people get for wanting a higher education. Join a trade instead

  • @luft9235
    @luft9235 Год назад +9615

    this is probably one of the most boring dystopian worlds ever

    • @ethanmoss883
      @ethanmoss883 Год назад +470

      When do we get to the cybernetics and shit 😂

    • @TheChivalricKnight
      @TheChivalricKnight Год назад +492

      This is just the filler content between the different "Regression of Human Rights" arcs.

    • @cryofpaine
      @cryofpaine Год назад +416

      Dystopian futures we predicted:
      Zombies
      Dictatorial-AI
      Children fighting in battle royale contests
      What we got:
      Republicans
      ChatGPT
      School shootings

    • @sexygirlmax2019
      @sexygirlmax2019 Год назад

      ​@@ethanmoss883oh dont worry, youll get to it. elon musk says lamguage will be obsolete within a few years because EVERYONE will have a neuralink implanted into their brain :))

    • @blueskyla7978
      @blueskyla7978 Год назад +24

      Oh it's only going to get worse.

  • @osman1345
    @osman1345 Год назад +197

    Imagine a professor robbing you 3-4 thousand dollars just because he feels like it….

    • @justinkaufman495
      @justinkaufman495 Год назад +12

      They do this all the time.

    • @aliasilver_636
      @aliasilver_636 Год назад +3

      3-4k....? Is that actually how much they spent on that unit? Because thats too much. I pay $300-400 per unit. 3-4k is more like a semester, all 4 units and every other expense.

    • @reddragonflyxx657
      @reddragonflyxx657 Год назад +10

      ​@@aliasilver_636 Texas A&M charges around $40k tuition for non-residents (if you add dorms and everything else it might be $70k), so if it's a 4 credit course with 16 credits per semester you're looking at $5000.

    • @thomasschulz2167
      @thomasschulz2167 9 месяцев назад +2

      Don't know if this is the standard across the US, but the College and Universities I've attended charge tuition by the hour then tack on quite a few fees. Last I saw, a credit hour was running about $400. With some math classes being a 5 credit hour course that's $2k before you tack on the fees. Minimum to be enrolled full time is 12 credit hrs so min $4800 a semester. And I know my engineering degree highly recommended 15-18 credit hour course loads to graduate on time.

    • @AK-jt9gx
      @AK-jt9gx 8 месяцев назад

      If this was really their last course before graduation, it could realistically be more than that.
      They could be barred from graduation at all for having “cheated”, and lose the entire value of the time and money they’re spent on this degree so far.
      If they’re allowed to retake the course, that’s at least an extra semester if not an entire year (worst case two years) extra that they don’t have their degree. They have to support themselves on a job that doesn’t require that degree in the meantime.

  • @kluckmeme
    @kluckmeme Год назад +1491

    Woah, he actually used it? That was a surprise.

    • @Shadow1Yaz
      @Shadow1Yaz Год назад +3

      Talk about a trust! 😂

    • @dragonflysword
      @dragonflysword Год назад +4

      How can you trust ever again, what's even real, am I losing my mind?😭

    • @dougied3449
      @dougied3449 Год назад +5

      That was lazy! Always use 3 sources and combine! It’ll be close but no cigar!

    • @waroftheworlds2008
      @waroftheworlds2008 Год назад +4

      ChatGPT can't do sources and text sounds like long winded nothingness. I tried using it once for laughs, but the total lack of substance is cringy

    • @JoshyHause
      @JoshyHause Год назад

      Lame plot twist ngl

  • @ddable.
    @ddable. Год назад +108

    Imagine being failed when your essay looks robotic because you're (almost) flawless in english.

    • @red_phoenix0570
      @red_phoenix0570 Год назад +20

      I'm not amazing at writing by any means but last semester (or two depending on where you start counting, I just finished this one) I received a very poor grade for an assignment partially due to the professor believing some sentences were plagiarized. he used the word "paraphragiarism" and said there was no way I could write that good. mind you, it wasn't the entire essay, just a few sentences. the other points were taken off because I didn't follow an outline that was not only not provided, but different from the outline that was provided.
      terrible class overall but that guy probably had some mental issues as I discovered later.

    • @mycelia_ow
      @mycelia_ow Год назад +24

      Many works by the founding fathers were ran though AI detection software and it claimed it was written by AI, so it's 100% an issue.
      Educators need to understand this tool is better used assisting with learning, rather than bypassing it. They assume it's only good for cheating when really it doesn't do it very well when the student doesn't put in much work.

    • @Picksle
      @Picksle Год назад +10

      robot does NOT mean flawless. I know I could write better than ChatGPT, mainly because it just strings meaningless words and phrases together.

    • @TSH425
      @TSH425 Год назад +2

      ​@@mycelia_ow exactly if ur using chatgpt u probably already have an idea or form of what u want to write and ur just using it for either extra ideas or to find a rough outline of how u want to write the essay no one uses chatgpt to copy and paste full essays 😂 only stupid teachers and old people who dont understand ai think people do that

    • @claritey
      @claritey Год назад +3

      I've heard that what AI looks for to detect AI writing is that it looks extremely average because that is how AI generates text by averaging together predictive responses.

  • @Omni_G
    @Omni_G Год назад +99

    Judges in the future: "If ChatGPT says you're guilty, you're guilty"

  • @kevl4n109
    @kevl4n109 Год назад +76

    3rd guy is the definition of “play dumb!”
    “Not that dumb!”

  • @matthewthomson6466
    @matthewthomson6466 Год назад +262

    Remember kids, if smearing the reputation and ruining people by debasing them in the public eye is the only way you can make them be reasonable, then by god, you must do it. It’s not your own decisions that took away your choices in moments like that.

  • @azerosblank5036
    @azerosblank5036 Год назад +26

    When the professor is too lazy to check your homework. That's one unprofessional professor that the University should take action against.

  • @hi5dude2
    @hi5dude2 Год назад +128

    This is so inspirational. Proof that even if you are dumb as a bag of bricks you can be a university professor too. Chase your dreams kids.

    • @CapitalWorksPro
      @CapitalWorksPro Год назад +8

      The world is scary when you learn that most people are good at one or two things. The rest of the work they do, they pretend to be good at.
      The world is held together by duct tape and bubblegum.

    • @mycelia_ow
      @mycelia_ow Год назад +1

      Mainly in America, high costs and low standards.

    • @BlackSakura33
      @BlackSakura33 Год назад +2

      It only works in USA.

    • @0therun1t21
      @0therun1t21 Год назад +2

      ​@@BlackSakura33 Thank you for proving O.P.'s point.

    • @your_-_mom
      @your_-_mom Год назад

      @@BlackSakura33 isn’t indias average iq lower than Pakistan which is in the low 90’s? You can’t be calling people stupid my man

  • @cannonballjenkins2757
    @cannonballjenkins2757 Год назад +28

    Fun fact: ChatGPT says that any work that's really good and doesn't show much emotion has a high chance of being generated by AI. This basically means that the AI is assuming the work you show it is AI because it's just that good, and that no emotion is shown.

  • @XperimentalOdin
    @XperimentalOdin Год назад +504

    Every single professor using chatGPT to check for students using chatGPT should be fired with no severance.

    • @Understanding_Gamer
      @Understanding_Gamer Год назад +26

      Then students caught using it should be expelled

    • @420.........
      @420......... Год назад

      @@Understanding_Gamer wtf, you hate tacos because you're insane

    • @blackvial
      @blackvial Год назад +10

      Let me guess, you got caught cheating more than

    • @Understanding_Gamer
      @Understanding_Gamer Год назад +1

      @@blackvial me or them

    • @mayab.8070
      @mayab.8070 Год назад +30

      @@Understanding_Gamer well yeah it's plagiarism, no one should be relying on chatgpt for something that important in an academic or professional setting

  • @nightshockplayz5894
    @nightshockplayz5894 Год назад +457

    I love how professors hate how we can use it to write an essay, but an engineering dean at UTD used it - and admitted to - using ChatGPT to write her college graduation commencement speech. I love the double standard.

    • @GodShadowdeath
      @GodShadowdeath Год назад +15

      Wolfram alpha baby stem has had ai for a decade

    • @aw3046
      @aw3046 Год назад +15

      My history teacher openly says he uses it, and even encouraged us to use it for revision

    • @chaddaifouche536
      @chaddaifouche536 Год назад +25

      @@aw3046 That seems really sketchy… There are legitimate uses for ChatGPT but for revisions it would be quite risky, ChatGPT can utter false statements with utmost confidence and even point his source (which often doesn't exist, doesn't pertain to the subject or outright tells the opposite but you would have to read them to know that).

    • @outdoorscholar6016
      @outdoorscholar6016 Год назад +34

      As someone in an academic profession, an essay is meant as a way of assessing that a student is actually retaining the information that’s being taught. Using ChatGPT to do that tells professors that you didn’t learn anything. If you needed an AI to write your essay, how can you prove that you are worthy of receiving that degree?
      A college graduation commencement speech is nowhere near as essential as an essay. Besides if you thought students were busy, wait till you hear the workload of their teachers. I’m sure that the teacher who did that used it for the sake of managing time better

    • @PrincessNinja007
      @PrincessNinja007 Год назад +20

      ​@@outdoorscholar6016
      Essays are only a measure of how well you can write an essay. Every finals week, I'd have about 6 ten-page papers to write, and every finals week, I'd end up turning in about three pages of essay, the sketch of my intro and conclusion paragraph, and the outline of all things I was trying to put into my essay but ran out of time looking for a segue.
      And somehow, working in the field about 5 years after college and a decade after high school, no one's asked me to write an essay.

  • @AndrewVan07
    @AndrewVan07 Год назад +18

    I was accused of using ai to write my essay in a book, the teacher had no proof. My computer friend even backed me up by saying there was no way to get into any open ai site on the school laptops as all of them were blocked. She apologized the next time I had that class with her saying another teacher showed her articles of college professors failing kids for using ai when they never did.

  • @thenecessaryevil2634
    @thenecessaryevil2634 Год назад +280

    One of my younger cousins had this happen a lot cause he's autistic and everything he writes gives a false positive for being AI written.

    • @morrigan9889
      @morrigan9889 Год назад +86

      Yep, I’m in college and autistic and it’s a living nightmare, funny thing is the checkers say IM chatGPT and that the GPT essays are human written

    • @thenecessaryevil2634
      @thenecessaryevil2634 Год назад +38

      @@morrigan9889 The checkers are really unreliable. Especially chatGPT itself. The full story on those students involved checking chatGBT results against 5 3rd party checkers and they found chatGBT has the highest failure both in false positives and negatives. It has to do with how it checks, blocking for phrases more common to the ai writting than actual student writing. But the longer gpt has-been online the less reliable its gotten on that.

    • @sylmaerie
      @sylmaerie Год назад +49

      i’m genuinely terrified of getting labeled as AI for similar reasons. i’m also autistic and i’ve always been a very skilled writer (other people’s words not mine) and while i personally feel like my writing is actually better than what chatgpt comes up with, i can’t help but be anxious that the checkers are not going to know the difference

    • @thenecessaryevil2634
      @thenecessaryevil2634 Год назад +32

      @@sylmaerie that's a real fear. People fearing ai will skynet us all are really overestimating what current ai can do. But ai screwing with education art ect and making it harder and harder to tell what is ai made and what isn't. Drawing artist are already starting to get mad about ai art generators stealing their art and making minute changes and their work basically stolen.

    • @sylmaerie
      @sylmaerie Год назад +13

      @@thenecessaryevil2634 yeah i’m with you 100%. i’m out of undergrad in a year (not considering grad school anymore atm but not because of this) and i’m going to be so upset if all the time and money i spent on college gets tossed away by being falsely accused of using AI. and the art stuff is really messed up. not only does it have potential to put real artists out of work but it’s also straight up stealing the work of other artists without their permission

  • @CarlosInfante-mx8hc
    @CarlosInfante-mx8hc Год назад +12

    Imagine being a 4th year university student and the professor want to fail you because you wrote how you were suppose to write!

  • @mikaeo23
    @mikaeo23 Год назад +89

    Teacher should be fired. Absolutely zero integrity or work ethic

    • @mycelia_ow
      @mycelia_ow Год назад +10

      Kinda odd of him to assume the AI has quantum memory. He's a professor ffs

  • @cusi9854
    @cusi9854 Год назад +12

    I once asked chat gpt about an essay I wrote 2 years before and he confirmed me that it was written by it

  • @dbdb4943
    @dbdb4943 Год назад +12

    Asking chatgpt if chatgpt wrote a paper doesn't work.

  • @idalystad
    @idalystad Год назад +11

    "Yes, this text is made by ChatGPT". The text was from my school exam yesterday, wich was supervised and without internet and any aids. Nice work ChatGPT 🙂

  • @sterlingnumerical8723
    @sterlingnumerical8723 Год назад +4

    this happened a few days ago in one of my high school classes for our final essay. the entire class got furious and the teacher finally conceded.

  • @pvpdavidlul9049
    @pvpdavidlul9049 Год назад +290

    I think Chatgpt can be a great source even if you’re not copying because you can see another way of how to write something without doing extensive research or asking someone else

    • @matthewgobbett
      @matthewgobbett Год назад +37

      The point of writing a research paper IS to do extensive amounts of research from both primary and secondary sources and then present an academic argument based upon your research.
      Chatgpt is just cheating, just as bad as paying for someone else’s essay or copying off your friend, and should be punished accordingly.

    • @Maplaplaplapla
      @Maplaplaplapla Год назад +33

      ​@@matthewgobbett If you're doing a paper, you'll need to cite sources. If you're going to use ChatGPT as a source, you'll be lacking those. It's a very good text generator, and that's a great real life use for it, when you collect the information and have ChatGPT help you form it into text.

    • @sylmaerie
      @sylmaerie Год назад +16

      @@matthewgobbett i agree with you that chatgpt really shouldn’t be used but i think what this person was saying is that it can be a way to figure out other ways of wording your ideas. the “without extensive research or asking someone else” i believe refers to not having to scour other resources looking for ideas about how to word the information you already gathered through your research. personally i think chatgpt is shit at wording things anyway so i wouldn’t use it but i don’t think this person meant asking chatgpt to answer questions in place of doing your own research, i think they just meant using it to figure out other ways to word something

    • @larsbirgerbergmal6230
      @larsbirgerbergmal6230 Год назад +7

      ​​@@matthewgobbettn the paper you are supposed to reasearch related topics.
      Sometimes the related topic isn't grammar or reformulations of text
      It's just as much cheating as getting help from your teacher on how to write your paragraphs after you described what you want written

    • @pvpdavidlul9049
      @pvpdavidlul9049 Год назад +1

      @@sylmaerie yes that was what I was trying to say

  • @wintersblackmamba
    @wintersblackmamba Год назад +9

    The funniest part of all of this is that someone put the teachers email into chatGPT and chatGPT claimed that they wrote that email 😭

  • @Borax_Sensei
    @Borax_Sensei Год назад +9

    If you put multiple famous novels and put "Did you write this" it will most likely say yes.

  • @champion8795
    @champion8795 Год назад +11

    In the Reddit thread people foind the professor and took his Ph.D thesis and asked ChatGPT if it wrote that... and it said yes.

  • @raquelalmeida9002
    @raquelalmeida9002 Год назад +17

    Well, if AI should not be used for school work, it should not be used to determine guilt either

  • @camohawk6703
    @camohawk6703 Год назад +8

    Smells like a good lawsuit.

  • @cfri9332
    @cfri9332 Год назад +9

    Guess these students weren't studying law.
    They should have just said "Proof?"

  • @danhatter6823
    @danhatter6823 Год назад +5

    Fun fact: 16 papers were tested on ChatGPT to see if it could correctly identify papers it did or didn’t write. It correctly identified 5 of the papers. That’s right, you’re more likely to correctly guess if an essay is written by ChatGPT by flipping a coin.

  • @TonklinFallen
    @TonklinFallen 9 месяцев назад +1

    Guilty until proven innocent.

  • @brianvalenti1207
    @brianvalenti1207 Год назад +4

    Students should get their money back for that class.

  • @theunkownviolinist
    @theunkownviolinist Год назад +2

    A professor using ChatGPT to grade assignments should be treated as the same level of academic dishonesty as a student using it

  • @LocoNeedAChickenWing
    @LocoNeedAChickenWing Год назад +10

    Professor should be fired

  • @Voxelize
    @Voxelize 8 месяцев назад +1

    The greatest irony of it all is that the CEOs of the companies these students will go to work for are going to ask them to use chatGPT to condense their emails and clean up reports.

  • @RachaelLongLastName
    @RachaelLongLastName Год назад +18

    That guy on the right was falsely accused of cheating and then he got publicly pressured to admit guilt even though he is CLEARLY innocent.
    WTF America

    • @beastwarsFTW
      @beastwarsFTW Год назад

      That professor doesn't represent the American population, incompetence is universal.

  • @NexusVFD
    @NexusVFD Год назад +2

    If he gets to just say they cheated the school should just get to revoke his teaching license for actually pulling that bullshit

  • @OctagonalSquare
    @OctagonalSquare Год назад +22

    Both glad and sad I graduated college before AI took off. Would have been a nice tool to check my work, and to learn more about (comp sci major) but also the fear of being falsely accused of using it to cheat would be horrible

    • @fss1704
      @fss1704 Год назад +1

      Heck it's easy to find out the proofread software to test, they're almost the same stuff almost always so even a concurrent online software to check using paraphrasing is indistinguishable.

  • @js1198
    @js1198 9 месяцев назад +1

    Chat gpt claimed to write the ENTIRETY of crime and punishment

  • @diablominero
    @diablominero Год назад +21

    ChatGPT is built to tell you what you want to hear. If it thinks you want it to take credit for writing a piece of text, it'll do it, whether or not it wrote the text.

    • @LycanKai14
      @LycanKai14 Год назад +1

      Me about to go on a date with ChatGPT

  • @Raikos100
    @Raikos100 Год назад +1

    If a student can't use chatGPT and rely their future career to it, a teacher shouldn't rely his profession work as well. How the tables turned

  • @_cloudface_
    @_cloudface_ Год назад +6

    Using chatGPT to see if someone else cheated and used chatGPT instead of solving the problem themselves is lovely irony 😀

  • @jeffg8952
    @jeffg8952 7 месяцев назад +1

    Imagine being told you can’t use chat gpt because it gives you wrong information then using it to decide students grade

  • @-Commit-arson-
    @-Commit-arson- Год назад +3

    If someone tries to frame me for chatgpt
    I’m suing for defamation

  • @sd1660
    @sd1660 Год назад +1

    Ridiculous considering the amount of courses I am now required to use programs and websites that GRADE MY ASSIGNMENTS so the teacher does not have to do it. Seriously some of these classes NOTHING is ever touched by the teacher. EVERYTHING is done for them. Hypocrisy at its finest.

  • @bunnycakes2305
    @bunnycakes2305 Год назад +4

    ChatGPT will probably claim credit for all the fanfic every written

  • @claudiomarvel
    @claudiomarvel Год назад +2

    Bruh, when I asked ChatGPT about whether it knows about a certain and specific law (of a my country), it proceed to get creative and made the heck up a new law. It wrote about article 29 of a certain code, but when I searched it for real, the code only have 18 articles.

  • @danchen8647
    @danchen8647 Год назад +3

    ChatGPT totally gaslighting the professor

  • @teamofone1219
    @teamofone1219 7 месяцев назад +1

    Ironic that teachers need to use Chatgpt to tell if someone used ChatGPT.

  • @SquiddyHiggenbottom
    @SquiddyHiggenbottom Год назад +5

    Prof: "Using ChatGPT to do your work for you is unethical!"
    Also Prof: * has ChatGPT do his work for him *

  • @Millenimorphose
    @Millenimorphose Год назад +1

    Tell me this prof doesn’t know how ChatGPT works without telling me this prof doesn’t know how ChatGPT works.

  • @bipolartorecovery1485
    @bipolartorecovery1485 Год назад +4

    I use it as a study tool but even then it contradicts Itself. It's only as accurate as a parent.

  • @darkcherryorchid
    @darkcherryorchid Год назад +1

    I've been running my papers through ZeroGPT just to see if anything comes up positive now bc I am terrified of having to fight my professors on something I'm not guilty of. The amount of false positives I've gotten and fixed by literally just removing commas from my sentences...

  • @AnyVideo999
    @AnyVideo999 Год назад +56

    Let them use chat GPT. An entire assignment would do poorly, but definitely students should use it for revision, suggestions, and translating bullet points. This will be the equivalent of calculators once the tech progresses. Your calculator can't solve every problem from scratch, but it helps a lot when you need it.

    • @raerohan4241
      @raerohan4241 Год назад +10

      Yeah, no. One of the reasons we have to write so many essays throughout our schooling is to help us practice how to communicate effectively. And effective commication is an essential skill in every single field and profession, without exception. More than that, even if you never work a day in your life, you still need to be able to communicate in order to properly exist in society. So we can't let students use crutches for these kinds of learning exercises if we're at all interested in making it easy for them to live in the future.

    • @mycelia_ow
      @mycelia_ow Год назад +13

      ​@@raerohan4241 I think you're misunderstanding, you should read up more on it and it's studied to assist students today. People way overestimate its ability to give you automatic good grades. It's best use case is assisting with learning, especially now with certain plugins.
      Sure student can try and cheat with it, but without doing any work themselves it's probably not going to end well. Many educators have come out against those advocating against it in education.

    • @eddiemarohl5789
      @eddiemarohl5789 Год назад +4

      ​@@raerohan4241 what he's saying is using it as a proofreader essentially going to office hours or using the writing center.

    • @TSH425
      @TSH425 Год назад +5

      ​@@raerohan4241 how old are u? Cause u def dont understand ai or chatgpt at all if u think u can use it to get a 100% on an essay without doing any work urself 😂 chatgpt and ai in general isnt good at all at writing essays all it's good for is giving u basic points and ideas of how or what to write about u cant just copy and paste a chatgpt essay and get total Mark's in fact u probably would fail if u tried I dare u go on chatgpt ask it to write an essay on an intensive topic and see how well it writes (rven if ur being hyper specific it'll turn out either shit or barly passable)

    • @Veganmilkdrinker
      @Veganmilkdrinker Год назад +1

      ​@Rae Rohan we should also take away students calculators so they can't use it as a crutch.

  • @greoge1381
    @greoge1381 8 месяцев назад +2

    The irony of telling people they cant use chatgpt for their essay writing (which i agree with) but then turning around and using chatgpt for the grading of those exact same essays will always be funny to me. "Rules for thee but not for me" vibes

  • @mrblahbah2522
    @mrblahbah2522 9 месяцев назад +3

    If your not allowed to use AI then teacher shouldn’t use AI to test essays

  • @shajebkhalid7853
    @shajebkhalid7853 Год назад +1

    "If you are using ChatGpt, grade yourself. You are paying for your own tuition. Why even pay tuition then? "

  • @AtlasNovack
    @AtlasNovack Год назад +10

    When I start teaching I'm doing in-class essays. There, problem solved.

    • @BlackSakura33
      @BlackSakura33 Год назад +3

      That's called exams. And that's how the civillised countries do it.

    • @AtlasNovack
      @AtlasNovack Год назад +2

      @@BlackSakura33 not all exams have essays, but you're right.
      In the US, typically the in-class essay IS the exam (usually for English or history classes) the latter of which is what I want to teach anyway

    • @humpteedumptee8629
      @humpteedumptee8629 Год назад +1

      Honestly this wouldn’t even be hard. As long as you can take your sources with you. Personally I am write 5-10 pages at anytime. In a straight line with no breaks. But I’m not trying to write a reference page and annotations out of memory.

    • @AtlasNovack
      @AtlasNovack Год назад +1

      @@humpteedumptee8629 Depends what the topic is, but usually I think it's okay

    • @nunyabusiness5075
      @nunyabusiness5075 Год назад

      And of course kids won't have smartphones when you start teaching. LOL When are you starting.....1995?

  • @fifiwashere3771
    @fifiwashere3771 Год назад +1

    This actually happened at my university too. The kicker is that one professor if mine was using ChatGPT as a part of an assignment in the middle of the semester, so my professor taught us all to use it. Then it backfired when 1/3 of the class got flagged

  • @Dibby98
    @Dibby98 Год назад +3

    Man that professor opened himself and the university to a litany of lawsuits

  • @toomanyhungrycats0554
    @toomanyhungrycats0554 Год назад +16

    I think chat gpt for essays is perfect

    • @_muppelpuppel_9773
      @_muppelpuppel_9773 Год назад +11

      It removes the one element being tested.
      You.
      If you didn't write the essay, you can not be reliably graded, meaning the teachers can't tell how far you've come.

    • @Tuna-else
      @Tuna-else Год назад +1

      chat got, paraphraser, replace words you wouldn't write with ones youd use, works for me every time

    • @ExtraTerrestrial29956
      @ExtraTerrestrial29956 Год назад +5

      It doesn't source information and honestly isn't that great. If you're talking about basic, elementary or even middle school essays, sure. Past that point, that essay could honestly be a C or worse

    • @average_person444
      @average_person444 Год назад +2

      ​@@ExtraTerrestrial29956 yeah. I've found that basically everything chatgpt writes is kinda boring and samey.

    • @bias9440
      @bias9440 Год назад +1

      @@average_person444 Maybe may not. In my experience its been good. Used it to write a college essay and asked it to make an arguement for gender abolition from the standpoint of existentialism and it made pretty good points. Then told it to make a essay for it

  • @grantharriman284
    @grantharriman284 Год назад +1

    Reminds me of a story from when my dad was in school. He had recently moved, so the teacher had never seen his writing before, and he wrote a paper with such clinical objective language that the teacher gave him a D, and "would have given [him] an F, but I couldn't find what book you copied it from". He is now an engineer. That's just how he writes on technical subjects.

  • @aggressiveaegyo7679
    @aggressiveaegyo7679 Год назад +3

    I take a simple extra step, throwing some phrases into the translator and translating them twice to return them to the first language. Or a spell checker. The meaning of the text does not change, but some words change.

    • @justinkaufman495
      @justinkaufman495 Год назад +1

      The grammar can also change doing that, and some sentences won't make sense which means you would fail for simple errors because words still get lost in translation.

  • @7F0X7
    @7F0X7 Год назад +1

    I've personally witnessed a recent grad at my job tell me he used AI to write his essays. Something has to be done.

  • @sylvernale
    @sylvernale Год назад +4

    I think there are decent tools for detecting chatGPT, but if you should know anything about chatGPT itself is that it wlii confidently lie to you

  • @TheRealScooterGuy
    @TheRealScooterGuy Год назад +1

    Plot twist: In the aftermath of all this, the students ran some published work by the professor through ChatGBT, and were told that ChatGBT wrote those papers as well. The professor had published that work years before ChatGBT existed.

  • @flamingwolfx
    @flamingwolfx Год назад +22

    Let’s not forgot these aren’t real creators this is just an out of touch company’s attempt to gain back media control. 10/10 propaganda tho

    • @Survivalist_Redo
      @Survivalist_Redo Год назад +1

      Oof

    • @noahanderson8688
      @noahanderson8688 Год назад +18

      I mean this seems like wp hired some guy to make tiktoks for them and I'm fine with it

    • @Trethan3266
      @Trethan3266 Год назад +20

      How was this propaganda?

    • @highwaydaytime7669
      @highwaydaytime7669 Год назад +1

      and?

    • @rinniegan
      @rinniegan Год назад +29

      Having a social media team that tries their best to convey news in an interesting way for tiktok so the current teens of america actually get some news isn't propaganda. The pledge of alligence is propaganda

  • @mymoldychungus8330
    @mymoldychungus8330 Год назад +2

    My English teacher did this to every student literally gave 13 people 0 out of 30 on an essay because he was paranoid

  • @primeministersinister625
    @primeministersinister625 Год назад +2

    Same energy as “you won’t always carry a calculator in your pocket”

  • @JacobAnawalt
    @JacobAnawalt Год назад +1

    That professor is a perfect example of smart, but not wise or lacking common sense and skepticism

  • @sapphired3101
    @sapphired3101 Год назад

    So glad I'm not alone in this. This morning my Literature teacher marked my essay exam with a "?". When I went on to consult her, she said that I had to recite it in full detail, when I started saying the main point of each paragraph, she then went on to say "Recite it as how you wrote it to prove you wrote it."

  • @Otoskire
    @Otoskire Год назад +2

    If chatGPT wasn’t capable of writing better essay than 80% of college students I think it’d be a cool way to edit your essay. Instead of having it peer reviewed you can ask it to offer synonyms to commonly used words and to look for spelling errors, although sometimes it’ll just lie to you and lead you to a worse essay.

  • @janbertguerrero6988
    @janbertguerrero6988 Год назад +1

    remember, school isnt about learning anymore, its just about passing

  • @jaguareagle7026
    @jaguareagle7026 Год назад +1

    We are at a point where some research papers even from the time of no ai will look similar to the current ones recording yourself is the easiest way to put yourself in safety

  • @pxkos
    @pxkos Год назад +2

    Even the AI itself tells you “I ain’t sure if I wrote this or not so imma make it a coin throw” because remember that ChatGPT doesn’t remember or keeps logs on what it says

  • @cal920c
    @cal920c Год назад +2

    This is why even teachers and professors need checks and balances too. Ridiculous.

  • @Name_23
    @Name_23 8 месяцев назад +1

    Professors never do this. The amount of harm you’ll cause to innocents always will outweigh the benefit of actually catching a cheater. Don’t completely rely on something you aren’t fully aware of how it operates either.

  • @calciumkid0568
    @calciumkid0568 Год назад +2

    I ask it questions and advice on how to write certain aspects but I would never submit a full blown essay written by it

  • @ImpossibleEvan
    @ImpossibleEvan Год назад +1

    X is for exempt while I is for incomplete

  • @NephiylusBaphson
    @NephiylusBaphson Год назад +1

    At this point, developers should just program it to deny that sort of requests until reliable.

  • @ClayAdams
    @ClayAdams Год назад +1

    This is exactly why Google initially came out saying AI content would be penalized in reading algorithms and then walked it back because even THEY don’t know if it’s legit or not. Comprehend that for a second. Even GOOGLE doesn’t know

  • @jabarzua
    @jabarzua Год назад +1

    I've tested that. I gave chatgpt paragraphs from some old essays written by me and asking if it had written it. It said yes and when I ask how does it know it said something like 'I've been trained with a lot of sources and none of them included this paragraph, so it must have been written by me'.

  • @darthhodges
    @darthhodges Год назад +2

    If a teacher can give a student a zero for using ChapGPT, can a school fire a teacher for using ChatGPT? Even if it's to see if students used ChatGPT?

  • @littleladybrooks6635
    @littleladybrooks6635 8 месяцев назад

    Never ask the tool used for cheating if they're used for cheating....

  • @elwen8525
    @elwen8525 Год назад

    Sometimes I wonder if it’s possible to sue a teacher for failing you for no reason

  • @Neris-of-the-other
    @Neris-of-the-other Год назад +1

    ChatGPTs whole thing is that it makes the text look as human-made as it can. It can't tell the difference any further than it already did in order to write like it thinks people write.

  • @GaeFrogs
    @GaeFrogs Год назад

    My teacher told me I used it for almost all my assignments but I finally convinced her I didn’t

  • @aaronbowie6339
    @aaronbowie6339 Год назад +2

    chatgpt cannot actually tell you if someone used it. I've tried it before and I used an essay that I actually wrote before I knew about chatgpt and it said it did write it and then doubled down and said that no it didn't.

  • @theguywhousedtocare
    @theguywhousedtocare Год назад +1

    Imagine using ChatGPT during work to grade the students essays but not allowing the students to use ChatGPT to the refer... 💀

  • @amethyst_cat9532
    @amethyst_cat9532 Год назад

    This is giving me flashbacks to that time someone who should've known better used ChatGPT to write a PUBLIC letter of condolence following a university shooting

  • @recoojones7874
    @recoojones7874 9 месяцев назад +1

    Chatgpt is designed to mimic human texting so using chatgpt to find out if something is written with chatgpt will usually give you false positives/negatives at least 50% of the tme

  • @pianovii3350
    @pianovii3350 Год назад +1

    ChatGPT is literally just an algorithm to predict what word is most likely to come next