@@theunknown2778 To be fair, didn't the other pilots do the exact the same thing? Minus the part where they wern't being attacked, they all reprogrammed their OS fairly quickly.
@@shade8816 Yeah they all did made me wonder how the Naturals were gonna even use them since the system for them wasn't even ready yet not until they went to ORB and Kira helped them with it.
It sounded more like he just messed around with some config files and rebooted a couple processes. I'm more than willing to accept that genetically enhanced humans might be able to code that fast. I just refuse to accept that the kernel recompiled that quickly.
Man this dub is kinda disappointing me. Certain lines that had no reason to be changed got changed. Like at 8:57, in the original Japanese and old dub he says “This is it?” because he’s surprised that the strike is so lightly equipped. Here they replaced it with “here we go!!”. It’s a small change, but it has a subtle effect on the scene. It goes from Kira being in a desperate situation and using poor equipment to defend himself to him being more aggressive and sure of his capability.
Agreed. Even the original dub had it better with Kira shouting "that's all there is?!" Like he is shocked and disgusted with the limited weaponry he had
@@ChrisTian-ed8ol That isn’t the reason. The dub was changed because the remaster has new footage and editing that is off from the original. The dub had to be remade but it was too difficult or more trouble than it was worth to get the original cast so we got a new one. Most of the lines are still the same anyways, but that change just bugged me.
@@bebopobama4686 Yeah, I found out after I posted. It sucks though, I still have all the old voices in my head. Do you know what happened to Ocean Studio? Edit: they still exist, I don't see why the studios were changed. Ocean seems to have English dubbed much of the Gundam series, unless Funimation controls the U.S. market to the point of pushing Ocean out.
Fun fact, ramius voice actress is the same one who voices carta from gundam ibo, but also satsuki from kill ka kill and casca from the first berserk anime and the trilogy movie.
its just imo, but its due to the plot, setting, and politics. i still need to watch all the other series, but definitely thought 0079 was a mess. the politics and space racism is heavily embedded into almost every character and is the direct correlation to everyones invilevment in fighting. the complications with Flay were the most interesting for how manipulative she was and what drove her to do what she did. most importantly for the anti-war gundam message it never hit me until Rau at the very end. His entire logical perspective in humans was the most literal and showed the genuine flaws to war compared to the usual sappy shit. Also the N jammer reasoning shows more why gundams need to be used. most importantly pit of the other stories, this seems to be the most likely thing to happen once we start enhancing fetal genes before birth
Other than illegally streaming it, there’s not really many other options. If you search up “Gundam SEED dub” here on RUclips, the first episode of the original dub has been uploaded in two parts, but that’s it. I’d highly recommend checking it out, just to get a sample of how much better the casting was.
man instead of redubbing seed they should have just dubbed on of the shows that haven't already gotten a dub like victory gundam or double zeta the original ocean dub for seed was one of that companys best dubs.
Before SEED I used to rag on them all the time for DBZ compared to Funimation but now listening to this it makes me cringe like never before to the point of almost making my ears bleed. I couldn't even watch these two episodes here, I just skipped around to hear voices.
hmm listening to this, most voices I can accept, Kira is the big outlier that I'm not so sure about. the pronunciations or Morgenroete, Murrue and Yamato are awkward so unless the canadians up there got them wrong initially this is gonna be a challenge to watch especially for best captain herself... that isn't Bright Noa, he's too iconic. surprised Natarle's last name was pronounced the same in both dubs
In this redub it's more like Crybaby Yamato!!! Brad Swaile's worst crying moments as Amaro Ray sounded better than the voice Max Mittelman gave Kira in this.
After looking at both versions, might be wrong. But I kinda prefer the old animation over the new touch ups. Like yeah it adds more detail and generally looks better but somehow ends up feeling more stiff, while the sd looks a bit rushed but has better motion to it, even with the reused stock.
I agree, they didn’t give it their all on the remaster and it shows. 10:33 is a brand new scene, and if they had redone a significant portion of each episode in that quality it would’ve been incredible. But instead they settled for scaling up the old footage to HD, brightening the colors and doing some overall sharpening, and occasionally throwing in new animation.
The redub is entirely not it’s even when he figures out there are only blades for weapons “here we go” was not the original, “this is it” the emotion the delivery was just so much better uggghhh
I don't know what this is, but it's not the original. I don't mind a little change but these guys can't even say his name right. (Kira Yamato) Ya Ma To
The original dub is much better compared to this. Sounds like some of the actors are overacting their parts and giving emotions in the wrong places. The original dub had better acting especially in the emotional parts. Re-dubbing the series was entirely unnecessary. They really need to re-released the original dub.
@@JamesButts-w7onot exactly. I’ll admit both dubs for Gundam SEED are good, but one Ocean dub that was redone before was better than the redo. Cardcaptor Sakura. Animax botched EVERYTHING! The jokes were funny in the Ocean dub, but in the Animax version, they weren’t.
I'm sure I could nitpick the specifics if I were bothered, but all in all my biggest gripe with this dub up front is that none of the characters sound distinct from one another. I'm not especially nostalgic for the original dub either, but I can at least give it credit for making sure I knew who was speaking and when just by listening to them. With this dub if I look away or if the characters aren't on screen then I have no clue who's saying what.
Kira and co. should have took off the moment Ramius wasn't looking, with one of them leaving behind a note reading "This is SO not our problem." just to piss her off. We probably wouldn't have a series (Unless Mu became the MC), but I wanna see Ramius throw a shitfit after losing her detainees.
It's not just the voices, some scenes now lack the emotion they had.. for example... Kira was worried when he saw all they had was a knife.. In this one, its like hes happy for the damn knife and ready for battle.. Also, in the OG Dubbed, he seemed way more concern about the fighting around civilians and even cried out "Stooop ittt", you can feel he only attacked because he HAD to.. in this, theres just this dull "noooooo" .. no what? Nothing set up that "nooo".. its just lame.. second episode and I quit... gonna look for the OG Thanks for uploading though... this rendition sucking isnt on you
It's best to watch the sub version. Funimation knew of the existence of the original dub from Ocean Studios via DVDs that were still out there but didn't ask for any to re-record for the remaster version.
Thanks for the upload of another full episode. I loved this show when I first saw it on tv in the early 2000s. I just wish they had the original actors redub it. I thought their voices really fit the characters and their acting was great. I wonder why they didn’t get the original voice actors back? Anime that have returned after many years lately have all had the original voice actors whenever possible. Like Fruits Basket and Yashahime. But my biggest complaint about this dub is that they changed name pronunciations. I wish they didn’t do that.
Funimation cheaped-out and didn't want to pay for the original cast to come back. Ocean Group charges more per hour of dubbing. I miss the old cast and directing too.
The simple answer, they were too cheap and don't know good voice acting if it bet them in the rear. They just wanted to sell it quick and for some of us we just went with it thinking it would be OK because they had a few decent VA's but nope it was terrible. And for some of those comments it wasn't funimation or rightstuf at fault here, funimation is only streaming the redub and rightstuf is only distributing it. The ones at fault are the people who dubbed it at NYAV Post who put no effort into it and Nozomi Entertainment. You can blame rightstuf for the overpriced ultra edition that didn't have half of the extras the Gundam 00 and Wing editions did though. I have found a few sites that had a spliced version of the HD version with the original dub and it was about 90% perfectly synced. So why couldn't they pay a team with technical resources to make it 100% instead of paying for a new voice cast that didn't do anywhere near as good as they did on their characters on Iron-Blooded Orphans. Sadly I will not post any link to said episodes as the powers that be are at work replacing every single version of the original dub with this new garbage resub across most anime streaming sites as I'm sure many have noticed. Also if your gonna pay for voice actors like Johnny Yong Vosh, Yuri Lowenthal, and Michelle Ruff, give them bigger roles than characters who have about 10 minutes or less of dialog through the whole series and die very quickly. Yuri should have been Kira, Johnny should have Athrun, and Michelle should have been Cagalli. Listen to them as Suzaku and Lelouch in Code geass and tell me they don't sound better than these new voices.
@@alexanderdrake7984 well sadly when I talked to rightstuf they admitted it was their call but both them and funimation whoever are idiots for choosing this va I love seed but I wont be buying this I'd rather keep the fan remaster and import the Japanese version then get this crap it's a insult
Kira Yamato don't talk similar to Io Fleming from Mobile Suit Gundam Thunderbolt. However, he does sometimes talk like Ryuji from Persona 5, but only when he gets angry or when he yells even during the battle.
Because they don't care about good voice acting, the actors just phoned it in basically. Disappointing because if uou watched Iron-Blooded Orphans they gave so much more of an emotional delivery than they did in this. Best example of knowing nothing about voice acting, they cast Johnny Yong Vosh, Yuri Lowenthal, and Michelle Ruff as Dearka, Miguel, and Aisha, very minor characters with less than 10 minutes time and who ended up dying quickly. Better casting would have been Yuri as Kira, Johnny as Athrun, and Michelle as Cagalli, right?
Because they didn't want to pay the original voice actors royalties. So they hired cheaper voice actors. Corporations have no problem betraying their fan bases to make more money.
Show was reformatted and they needed to change script. Easier to just redub it than edit original audio (probably something to do with licensing) and getting OG VAs is too expensive when cheaper alternative is available.
I'm absolutely hating this new dub. For the record, I have nothing against the voice actors & actresses themselves. I like their work in other shows they have been involved with. I just feel the casting choices in this dub are completely wrong. They don't fit their characters at all.
this dub just doesn't do it for me I like the HD and some new scenes but as someone sad below "it's not just the voices, some scenes now lack the emotion they had.. for example... Kira was worried when he saw all they had was a knife.. In this one, its like hes happy for the damn knife and ready for battle.."
Yes they remastered it and used Funimations VA's instead of the original Canadian VA's. The only good part about this remaster is hearing the voices of VA's like Johnny Young Bosch, Yuri Lowethal and Liza Ortiz ( glad to hear her again feels like a long time since I heard her).
The deliveries of the lines in this new dub are mostly fine, but hearing the changed pronunciation of names in this new dub is just painful. “Mariu Raymius,” “Lacoose Clyne,” “Deer-ka Elsman” etc. Also even though Lacus had a separate voice for her singing, which was a little jarring in the original dub, at least the singing was actually good. I respect that the new actress tried, but it’s just not at the same level. I could let it slide if that was the only thing they changed, but they also changed the lyrics, and it just doesn’t sound good, and it’s just agony to sit through. Some of the lines are also completely changed from their original meaning. One huge example is Lacus Clyne’s “What is it we should be fighting against? War makes that question very difficult.” This line represents one of the major themes of Gundam Seed: What should people really be fighting against? In the redub, this line became, “If we fight, we need something to fight for,” which is basically like saying, we need a reason to fight, which is not the same meaning at all.
I'm so glad you're uploading these. I have such fond memories of watching this on Toonami. I was skeptical about the re-dub, but with you releasing it like this, I think I'll become more acquainted with it.
@8:54 Dub ruined it. He's supposed to say in the Sub "That's IT!?" like he's pissed off all he has to fight this guy with is a pair of 2 kitchen knife daggers after unlocking the os configuration and saving his friends
Okay this needs to stop second Matthew Hill voice as kira yamato was way better. Plus Matthew Hill pronounce the names correctly. And I grew up watching Matthew Hill version of kira yamato it's way better when Matthew Hill speaks perfectly.
Yeah cause the show was reformatted and they needed to change script. Easier to just redub it than edit original audio (probably something to do with licensing) and getting OG VAs is too expensive when cheaper alternative is available.
This is the re-dub for the SEED HD Remaster. There were so many new scenes and recut scenes that they couldn't use the original dub for it, so they got NYAV Post to do a new dub for it.
@@ashurablaze7545 actually they could. They just cheaped out fans already. Made a port of the remaster with the bandai dubs a few yrs ago and the quality is the same. Rightstuf and funi. Take. Notes. Dont be cheap you will have fans not happy
@@animefrasier they don't know good voice acting, the majority of the cast did Iron-Blooded Orphans with such emotion yet they didn't ring any of it to this. I have also found the spliced HD versions with the original dub that were 90% perfectly synced which just irritated me that they didn't spend the time and money from redubbing it to instead sync it to a full 100% At the very least they should have changed the main character casting to Kira-Yuri Lowenthal, Athrun-Johnny Yong Vosh, and Cagalli- Michelle Ruff.
Show was reformatted and they needed to change script. Easier to just redub it than edit original audio (probably something to do with licensing) and getting OG VAs is too expensive when cheaper alternative is available.
@@collecter343the story. Didnt change so script would not change and it couldn't be licensing the Canadian VA dosent have hoops they just have to pay them the OG voice actors they just took the cheaper route and its gonna hurt them and their sales sadly and it's the fans who suffer
Morgan wrote? Kira Yah-mod-doh? The heck? I mean the voices are ok, but the verbiage and the changes to the original lines is sending me mixed messages here....I watched the whole episode but this is making me cringe, much like when the very first Sonic The Hedgehog's trailer came out. Or the Super Mario Bros live action movie. Or like going to the usual joint to get your favorite dish but they changed the recipe. I just don't know about this dub...... :/
Always loved how Kira changed the code for the Strike Gundam's OS system.
showing his jesus powers from the get go
@@theunknown2778 He's really something.
@@theunknown2778 To be fair, didn't the other pilots do the exact the same thing? Minus the part where they wern't being attacked, they all reprogrammed their OS fairly quickly.
@@shade8816 Yeah they all did made me wonder how the Naturals were gonna even use them since the system for them wasn't even ready yet not until they went to ORB and Kira helped them with it.
Honestly, I don't know how I feel about a redub for this. They've even changed some very iconic lines
Kira really re-coded an entire OS in 2 minutes while fighting
Well, yeah. He's a Coordinator.
@@wchan39 yia thats probably one of the dumbest parts of this show
It sounded more like he just messed around with some config files and rebooted a couple processes.
I'm more than willing to accept that genetically enhanced humans might be able to code that fast. I just refuse to accept that the kernel recompiled that quickly.
@@columb0012 calm down bro we all gundam fans here, lets keep it civil
well they are all "quantum computing interfaces" so it could be fast based on that.
a lame excuse but hey plot convenience. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Man this dub is kinda disappointing me.
Certain lines that had no reason to be changed got changed.
Like at 8:57, in the original Japanese and old dub he says “This is it?” because he’s surprised that the strike is so lightly equipped.
Here they replaced it with “here we go!!”.
It’s a small change, but it has a subtle effect on the scene.
It goes from Kira being in a desperate situation and using poor equipment to defend himself to him being more aggressive and sure of his capability.
Agreed. Even the original dub had it better with Kira shouting "that's all there is?!" Like he is shocked and disgusted with the limited weaponry he had
Do you know why the Dub was changed? It's all owned by Bandai/Sunrise entertainment.
@@ChrisTian-ed8ol That isn’t the reason. The dub was changed because the remaster has new footage and editing that is off from the original. The dub had to be remade but it was too difficult or more trouble than it was worth to get the original cast so we got a new one.
Most of the lines are still the same anyways, but that change just bugged me.
@@bebopobama4686 Yeah, I found out after I posted. It sucks though, I still have all the old voices in my head. Do you know what happened to Ocean Studio?
Edit: they still exist, I don't see why the studios were changed. Ocean seems to have English dubbed much of the Gundam series, unless Funimation controls the U.S. market to the point of pushing Ocean out.
I know right, Kira's frustration of the lack of weapons makes it more tense than just saying " HeRe wE gO!!!!"
So far I can get behind the dub for Tolle and Murrue Ramius. The line delivery with Murrue pointing the gun at the kids was well delivered.
Beside saying her name wrong >.>
🤷 Oh well. Life's too short.
Fun fact, ramius voice actress is the same one who voices carta from gundam ibo, but also satsuki from kill ka kill and casca from the first berserk anime and the trilogy movie.
Gundam is still number one mecha anime always will be.
Definitely at least not seed lol
But everybody dies which is sucks lol 😂
seed is best
@@alexalexander4694 what makes seed the best please elaborate?
its just imo, but its due to the plot, setting, and politics. i still need to watch all the other series, but definitely thought 0079 was a mess.
the politics and space racism is heavily embedded into almost every character and is the direct correlation to everyones invilevment in fighting. the complications with Flay were the most interesting for how manipulative she was and what drove her to do what she did. most importantly for the anti-war gundam message it never hit me until Rau at the very end. His entire logical perspective in humans was the most literal and showed the genuine flaws to war compared to the usual sappy shit. Also the N jammer reasoning shows more why gundams need to be used. most importantly pit of the other stories, this seems to be the most likely thing to happen once we start enhancing fetal genes before birth
Bring back Ed and Double D as Kira and Athrun (Eddy's VA played Rusty)
Eddy actually voiced Miguel.
ITS A GUNDAM!!!!!!!!!!!!
I couldn’t resist
It’s an angel !
Idk why people dislike this dub so much, it sounds completely fine, if not better than the original
some people can’t think objectively when it comes to something nostalgic, the old dub is terrible in comparison. so many errors in pronunciation
10:18 an unintentionally funny moment.
8:28... Should I be concerned that there are two "macxes" on the Gundam's OS?
Where can I find original version dub that everyone is mentioning. This one sounds kinda funny
Other than illegally streaming it, there’s not really many other options. If you search up “Gundam SEED dub” here on RUclips, the first episode of the original dub has been uploaded in two parts, but that’s it. I’d highly recommend checking it out, just to get a sample of how much better the casting was.
Kira Ya-mado?!?! 0 out of 10! 0 out of 10!!!! But I still wanna hear him scream out Athurn! When they’re both trying to kill each other.
His voice is a bit high pitched! Lol
That's how the name is SUPPOSED to be said.
The OG Dub had it wrong.
@@MasterSwo nah nah nah I’m with the OG dub. Ed and double Dee where my main gundam pilots
I thought it was cool the VA from seed both Kira and Athrun are played by the same people for Ed edd and Eddy that amazing voice acting
@@rudyking08 LOL don't put that image in my head! 😭
Murrue has to always jiggle as much as possible with every hit, it’s in the contract.
"All right then. I'm Mario Rammyus."
Bruh, what?
Aw yeah! We headin' into the cosmic era with this one!
Strike Gundam: You can’t do that Murrue They’re just kids!
3:16 - 3:40 Edited Quick Opening version.
22:03 - 22:22, 22:59 - 23:22 Edited Quick Ending version
man instead of redubbing seed they should have just dubbed on of the shows that haven't already gotten a dub like victory gundam or double zeta the original ocean dub for seed was one of that companys best dubs.
Before SEED I used to rag on them all the time for DBZ compared to Funimation but now listening to this it makes me cringe like never before to the point of almost making my ears bleed. I couldn't even watch these two episodes here, I just skipped around to hear voices.
''HOW DID YOU JUST DO THAT?!''
She just pressed a button, dude.
The new dub is fine, its just the other is so nostalgic and iconic for both the good and the bad
WHY would you change trevor duvall's voice? It was perfect.
OH SHIT
I'm not too upset about the re-dubbing of this show, since I do know some of the voice actors from other anime.
hmm listening to this, most voices I can accept, Kira is the big outlier that I'm not so sure about. the pronunciations or Morgenroete, Murrue and Yamato are awkward so unless the canadians up there got them wrong initially this is gonna be a challenge to watch especially for best captain herself... that isn't Bright Noa, he's too iconic. surprised Natarle's last name was pronounced the same in both dubs
This feeling is mutual
I couldn't watch. This new awful. Dub good search for the fanmade. Remaster of seed and destiny. If u like the bandai VA
Dub is not Canadian.
@@steeltalonsrule-k6g I know, I’m referring to the original Ocean Dub which was canadian
The dub was approved by sunrise and bandai. When ocean did it so I doubt they got it wrong. Just another thing that makes this redub cringe worthy
Kira is an excellent gundam pilot. 😀👍
Are you ready to learn the story of our lord and savior, Jesus Yamato?
Jesus yamato peeps where you at!!😝😂😂👏👏👏
Is this from something? I find it funny regardless, just curious
@@greenreaper3633 Gundam seed woman with purple shirt still alive
@@collinwmckinnon Gundam seed boy child with blue hair still alive
In this redub it's more like Crybaby Yamato!!!
Brad Swaile's worst crying moments as Amaro Ray sounded better than the voice Max Mittelman gave Kira in this.
i kinda miss the old dub where kira sees all he has is daggers and screams "THIS IS ALL THERE IS!?"
After looking at both versions, might be wrong. But I kinda prefer the old animation over the new touch ups. Like yeah it adds more detail and generally looks better but somehow ends up feeling more stiff, while the sd looks a bit rushed but has better motion to it, even with the reused stock.
I agree, they didn’t give it their all on the remaster and it shows. 10:33 is a brand new scene, and if they had redone a significant portion of each episode in that quality it would’ve been incredible. But instead they settled for scaling up the old footage to HD, brightening the colors and doing some overall sharpening, and occasionally throwing in new animation.
@@Argophobiac kind of a shame. It ain't my favorite gundam but it deserved better than judt pulling a dbz kai just with less time and production,
The redub is entirely not it’s even when he figures out there are only blades for weapons “here we go” was not the original, “this is it” the emotion the delivery was just so much better uggghhh
I don't know what this is, but it's not the original. I don't mind a little change but these guys can't even say his name right. (Kira Yamato) Ya Ma To
While I will always prefer the original voice for Rau, him having the voice of Griffith now is a genius move.
Thank you crunchyroll! These voice actors are fantastic!
The original dub is much better compared to this. Sounds like some of the actors are overacting their parts and giving emotions in the wrong places. The original dub had better acting especially in the emotional parts. Re-dubbing the series was entirely unnecessary. They really need to re-released the original dub.
Hell yea I agree
not at all. letting nostalgia get the best of you lmfao preferring an ocean dub more than anything else is like preferring a 4kids one
They already rereleased the Ocean dub. It’s on the special edition of the Blu-Ray release.
@@JamesButts-w7onot exactly. I’ll admit both dubs for Gundam SEED are good, but one Ocean dub that was redone before was better than the redo. Cardcaptor Sakura. Animax botched EVERYTHING! The jokes were funny in the Ocean dub, but in the Animax version, they weren’t.
100%
Two best friends when they were kids now they are fight on two different ways
I'm sure I could nitpick the specifics if I were bothered, but all in all my biggest gripe with this dub up front is that none of the characters sound distinct from one another. I'm not especially nostalgic for the original dub either, but I can at least give it credit for making sure I knew who was speaking and when just by listening to them. With this dub if I look away or if the characters aren't on screen then I have no clue who's saying what.
that says a lot about you and your hearing ability lol
@@JamesButts-w7o yeah, I can actually hear the budget cutting everyone else is deaf to.
Kira and co. should have took off the moment Ramius wasn't looking, with one of them leaving behind a note reading "This is SO not our problem." just to piss her off. We probably wouldn't have a series (Unless Mu became the MC), but I wanna see Ramius throw a shitfit after losing her detainees.
It's not just the voices, some scenes now lack the emotion they had.. for example... Kira was worried when he saw all they had was a knife.. In this one, its like hes happy for the damn knife and ready for battle..
Also, in the OG Dubbed, he seemed way more concern about the fighting around civilians and even cried out "Stooop ittt", you can feel he only attacked because he HAD to.. in this, theres just this dull "noooooo" .. no what? Nothing set up that "nooo".. its just lame.. second episode and I quit... gonna look for the OG
Thanks for uploading though... this rendition sucking isnt on you
totally agree dude while oceans dubs could be really hit or miss they did a really good job with most of the gundam dubs.
It's best to watch the sub version. Funimation knew of the existence of the original dub from Ocean Studios via DVDs that were still out there but didn't ask for any to re-record for the remaster version.
So are the ocean dubs the original English dubs that are better than these remastered versions?
@@randomgraham4302
Yes.
@@maverickhunterjames That would be Sunrise's decision, not Funimation.
Bring back the OG’s at least for the Movie
Sadly they didn’t bring them back
Thanks for the upload of another full episode. I loved this show when I first saw it on tv in the early 2000s. I just wish they had the original actors redub it. I thought their voices really fit the characters and their acting was great. I wonder why they didn’t get the original voice actors back? Anime that have returned after many years lately have all had the original voice actors whenever possible. Like Fruits Basket and Yashahime. But my biggest complaint about this dub is that they changed name pronunciations. I wish they didn’t do that.
Funimation cheaped-out and didn't want to pay for the original cast to come back. Ocean Group charges more per hour of dubbing. I miss the old cast and directing too.
Sunrise was cheap and wanted to keep everything in the US. Same reason why they couldn't get Kopsa, McNeil or Swaile for the cameos in Unicorn.
@@wingedswordslayer it wasent sunrise they only gave liscense rights. It was up to rightstuf to get the dubbing. Which they failed at
The simple answer, they were too cheap and don't know good voice acting if it bet them in the rear. They just wanted to sell it quick and for some of us we just went with it thinking it would be OK because they had a few decent VA's but nope it was terrible.
And for some of those comments it wasn't funimation or rightstuf at fault here, funimation is only streaming the redub and rightstuf is only distributing it. The ones at fault are the people who dubbed it at NYAV Post who put no effort into it and Nozomi Entertainment.
You can blame rightstuf for the overpriced ultra edition that didn't have half of the extras the Gundam 00 and Wing editions did though.
I have found a few sites that had a spliced version of the HD version with the original dub and it was about 90% perfectly synced. So why couldn't they pay a team with technical resources to make it 100% instead of paying for a new voice cast that didn't do anywhere near as good as they did on their characters on Iron-Blooded Orphans. Sadly I will not post any link to said episodes as the powers that be are at work replacing every single version of the original dub with this new garbage resub across most anime streaming sites as I'm sure many have noticed.
Also if your gonna pay for voice actors like Johnny Yong Vosh, Yuri Lowenthal, and Michelle Ruff, give them bigger roles than characters who have about 10 minutes or less of dialog through the whole series and die very quickly.
Yuri should have been Kira, Johnny should have Athrun, and Michelle should have been Cagalli.
Listen to them as Suzaku and Lelouch in Code geass and tell me they don't sound better than these new voices.
@@alexanderdrake7984 well sadly when I talked to rightstuf they admitted it was their call but both them and funimation whoever are idiots for choosing this va I love seed but I wont be buying this I'd rather keep the fan remaster and import the Japanese version then get this crap it's a insult
Kira Yamato don't talk similar to Io Fleming from Mobile Suit Gundam Thunderbolt.
However, he does sometimes talk like Ryuji from Persona 5, but only when he gets angry or when he yells even during the battle.
Where is the rest of the episodes? Can’t access them anywhere beside these 2 eps. Only sub available on sites
Wtf is up with this dub? This is one of the greatest Gundam series, the remastered HD version is perfect. Why release this?!
Because they don't care about good voice acting, the actors just phoned it in basically. Disappointing because if uou watched Iron-Blooded Orphans they gave so much more of an emotional delivery than they did in this.
Best example of knowing nothing about voice acting, they cast Johnny Yong Vosh, Yuri Lowenthal, and Michelle Ruff as Dearka, Miguel, and Aisha, very minor characters with less than 10 minutes time and who ended up dying quickly.
Better casting would have been Yuri as Kira, Johnny as Athrun, and Michelle as Cagalli, right?
one of the best . . . HA
I loved this when I was a kid
Because they didn't want to pay the original voice actors royalties. So they hired cheaper voice actors. Corporations have no problem betraying their fan bases to make more money.
@@chosenone3137 and their very dumb
Gundam Seed Season 1. 🤟
Seriously...wtf is up with this re dub..The other dub is perfect. This literally makes one of the best Gundam series sound like trash
Your comment is too kind, the proper words you are looking for are "disgrace " and "insult ".
Show was reformatted and they needed to change script. Easier to just redub it than edit original audio (probably something to do with licensing) and getting OG VAs is too expensive when cheaper alternative is available.
@@TheIrishRushin it is one of the best AU Gundam entries
@@yuyusha1478 It doesn't even make top 3 gundam shows. It's a direct rip off of the original show.
@@collecter343 or had repay all old voice actors
Number one mecha anime
Gurren Laggan would like to have a word with you.
I'm absolutely hating this new dub.
For the record, I have nothing against the voice actors & actresses themselves. I like their work in other shows they have been involved with.
I just feel the casting choices in this dub are completely wrong. They don't fit their characters at all.
did they remake this with different voice actors????
They did indeed.
Something always gets blown up.
Why there no episode 3 ?
*BEST STUFF EVEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEER!!!*
Are there more videos for Guandam seed?
Where is episode 3?, I can’t find it
Didnt mind the redub until i heards raus voice now it kinda has me sick lol
I actually prefer this version of Kira re-programming the Gundam. The original English dub Kira sounded like a surfer guy in that scene.
this is my 3rd time re-watching the series
Where are the rest of the episodes?
I can't find them on your channel and I can't find them on the Website crunchyroll?
They’re behind a paywall on Funimation’s website, unfortunately.
@@Argophobiac I see, thanks for the info 👍🏾
this dub just doesn't do it for me I like the HD and some new scenes but as someone sad below "it's not just the voices, some scenes now lack the emotion they had.. for example... Kira was worried when he saw all they had was a knife.. In this one, its like hes happy for the damn knife and ready for battle.."
This show is awesome
The show yes, the redub unfortunately no.
So where's Is the Rest Of the episodes and a good watch
Hope see next show episode 3
Is this the dub for the remastered version?
Yes unfortunately. This redub is a hit or miss for me, since I'm fond of the original dub.
Im surprised how well Yuri fits as a VA for Miguel lol
He deserved a bigger role than someone who dies right away,
Kira - Yuri Lowenthal
Athrun - Johnny Yong Vosh
Cagalli - Michelle Ruff
@@alexanderdrake7984 I agree.
He would have.
I am not surprised.
Flashbacks of my childhood, but the new voice actors are throwing it off. Not in a bad way, just different.
Yeah I cant watch it. Messing up the names. And words and the VA just awful
No it's a bad way, just disgraceful.
MAMORITAI SEKAI GA ARUNDA!!!
Did anyone else look at the thumbnail at first glance and think there was a GN drive cone sticking out of the Strike's back?
Wait, why are the voices different? Did they do a remake?
Yes they remastered it and used Funimations VA's instead of the original Canadian VA's. The only good part about this remaster is hearing the voices of VA's like Johnny Young Bosch, Yuri Lowethal and Liza Ortiz ( glad to hear her again feels like a long time since I heard her).
Ya new voice actors but they can’t even say their character names right ……. And not going to lie just lack in emotions
Where can i find the remastered ocean dub? This isnt it
they should have brought back the original voice actors, this feels flat to me; having watched the original dub, but I do love the new scenes
I love this Series of mobile suite Gundam seed
The deliveries of the lines in this new dub are mostly fine, but hearing the changed pronunciation of names in this new dub is just painful. “Mariu Raymius,” “Lacoose Clyne,” “Deer-ka Elsman” etc.
Also even though Lacus had a separate voice for her singing, which was a little jarring in the original dub, at least the singing was actually good. I respect that the new actress tried, but it’s just not at the same level. I could let it slide if that was the only thing they changed, but they also changed the lyrics, and it just doesn’t sound good, and it’s just agony to sit through.
Some of the lines are also completely changed from their original meaning. One huge example is Lacus Clyne’s “What is it we should be fighting against? War makes that question very difficult.” This line represents one of the major themes of Gundam Seed: What should people really be fighting against? In the redub, this line became, “If we fight, we need something to fight for,” which is basically like saying, we need a reason to fight, which is not the same meaning at all.
13:36 😂😂😂
its me or this one are a ending 1 new version
Its odd how you have this here but not on your actual service.
@8:16 when your IT skills kick in. This guy should get a job working at Google Fiber. Make internet faster and efficient.
Todomatsu takes the leading role! :)
Oh cool a dubbed SEED, finally found a reason to go back and watch
SEED & SEED Destiny been in dub since 2003 this dub is so trash compared to the early 2000’s dub actors
I'm so glad you're uploading these. I have such fond memories of watching this on Toonami. I was skeptical about the re-dub, but with you releasing it like this, I think I'll become more acquainted with it.
sigh... did the new vas even watch the old version? I miss Kira Yahmato not Yamahto
is this new remasted 1080 of gundam seed?
@8:54 Dub ruined it. He's supposed to say in the Sub "That's IT!?" like he's pissed off all he has to fight this guy with is a pair of 2 kitchen knife daggers after unlocking the os configuration and saving his friends
Kira YAMato wtf
It sounds soooo cringe and wrong
I want the old one back
It sounds soooo cringe and wrong
I want the old one back
Ocean Dub> every other Dub for gundam. This is fact.
Okay this needs to stop second Matthew Hill voice as kira yamato was way better. Plus Matthew Hill pronounce the names correctly. And I grew up watching Matthew Hill version of kira yamato it's way better when Matthew Hill speaks perfectly.
8:56 - Ocean Version - "Armor Schneider? THAT'S ALL THERE IS?" Guess the NYAV version is the proper meaning.
Did they re-dub this show? I swear the voices sound so different.
Yeah cause the show was reformatted and they needed to change script. Easier to just redub it than edit original audio (probably something to do with licensing) and getting OG VAs is too expensive when cheaper alternative is available.
@@collecter343 I’d rather them focus on dubbing a series like ZZ gundam that never had a dub than a garbage series like SEED tbh
@@RedComet-xu7iv That's for sure, though I'm not sure how many people cared that much for ZZ.
Some voices for the characters are different from when they first released this series of Gundam
This is the re-dub for the SEED HD Remaster. There were so many new scenes and recut scenes that they couldn't use the original dub for it, so they got NYAV Post to do a new dub for it.
@@ashurablaze7545 actually they could. They just cheaped out fans already. Made a port of the remaster with the bandai dubs a few yrs ago and the quality is the same. Rightstuf and funi. Take. Notes. Dont be cheap you will have fans not happy
@@animefrasier they don't know good voice acting, the majority of the cast did Iron-Blooded Orphans with such emotion yet they didn't ring any of it to this.
I have also found the spliced HD versions with the original dub that were 90% perfectly synced which just irritated me that they didn't spend the time and money from redubbing it to instead sync it to a full 100%
At the very least they should have changed the main character casting to Kira-Yuri Lowenthal, Athrun-Johnny Yong Vosh, and Cagalli- Michelle Ruff.
Show was reformatted and they needed to change script. Easier to just redub it than edit original audio (probably something to do with licensing) and getting OG VAs is too expensive when cheaper alternative is available.
@@collecter343the story. Didnt change so script would not change and it couldn't be licensing the Canadian VA dosent have hoops they just have to pay them the OG voice actors they just took the cheaper route and its gonna hurt them and their sales sadly and it's the fans who suffer
Why didn't they dub all 50 episodes?
The way they are pronouncing the names with this remaster is throwing me off.
The real question is is this the remastered dubbed?
yeah it is
Unfortunately
Rau and Mu sound awful. Mark Oliver did too good of a job as Rau originally and I sincerely hope they don't bring these actors back for Destiny redub.
why must they change voice actors and the dubbed script 😡
God they can't even say Thier name right, god this is live action avatar movie for saying name
Gundam series villains in a nutshell: “We do this for the sake of the civilian people!” *slaughters civilians without mercy*
It's dubbed here but not on my Crunchyroll roll subscription!
Y, know, Kira sounds like Armin in AOT.😎
Actually, saitama voices kira in this redub. This is Max's second gundam show that he's been on.
Morgan wrote? Kira Yah-mod-doh? The heck? I mean the voices are ok, but the verbiage and the changes to the original lines is sending me mixed messages here....I watched the whole episode but this is making me cringe, much like when the very first Sonic The Hedgehog's trailer came out. Or the Super Mario Bros live action movie. Or like going to the usual joint to get your favorite dish but they changed the recipe. I just don't know about this dub...... :/
I love the high def but why are all the voices different and sucky
How on earth does Murrue get pronounced like Maryue?
Thank you Verry Muchs
I’m going to try and buy the ocean dub