Please add the performer's names to your description: Gary Hoffman and Frank Peters. Wonderful performance. They deserve to be credited before the final announcement.
I just went to this video and I was stunned by the performance. I am a big fan of Olivier Messiaen even before I delved deeper in cello learning. Love the cellist's performance. I couldn't move to another vid till this vid was done playing. 🍸
It's a movement from the quartet for the end of time. Expensive to purchase and I don't think available separately. Still in copyright so you won't find a legal download.
Certainly beautifully played but but those are not the slurs carefully written by the composer. And the metronome changes with the dynamics, which is a mistake. It’s beautiful but it’s not supernatural as it’s supposed to be. It’s heartily, it’s romantic.
There is the question of whether the slurs are bowing markings or are there to highlight components of Messiaen's mode (a 'tweak' on one of his 'modes of limited transposition') and/or the components of the additive rhythm. Also, he didn't want his 'worshipful' music played mechanically. For example, the first of the 'Vingt Regards...' looks as mechanical as this but must be played "con amore". Similarly, this piece is to be played "majestueux, recueilli, tres expressif".
@@markgcarroll Mark, you may be right but nonetheless the piece sounds much better with original slurs. Messiaen (or Pasquier) even noted ups and downs to avoid any misunderstanding, and the composer’s care to slur on the cells of his modes are just signs of his genius. In any case one can play beautifully even respecting the stillness of metronome…
Messiaen's slurs and bowing markings are practically impossible at this speed, so I like the cellist prioritising tone quality. And if you listen to Messiaen playing his own pieces, he's very flexible in rhythm and tempo so I don't think he would have minded that much
Please add the performer's names to your description: Gary Hoffman and Frank Peters. Wonderful performance. They deserve to be credited before the final announcement.
Peace on Earth now, says composer.
god, this is such a beautiful piece of music
only performance I've ever heard which is slower than the MM! Beautifully controlled.
I just went to this video and I was stunned by the performance. I am a big fan of Olivier Messiaen even before I delved deeper in cello learning. Love the cellist's performance. I couldn't move to another vid till this vid was done playing. 🍸
Meraviglioso ! Messien and Mr Hoffman
How can you upload a performance of this quality, of this masterpiece, and not tell us who the performers are? I believe the cellist is Gary Hoffman.
I wrote this before hearing the announcement at the end. I stand by my comment, though.
I strive to play with this much passion one day
Just one day?
Si deseáramos calcular la sensibilidad e inteligencia musical de Olivier Messiaen, haría falta una grúa para izar montañas.
Sublime. Perfect.
❤️❤️❤️❣️❤️❤️
The cello looks great.
❣
it's a coughing epidemic! and lovely playing, by the way
Hope this trend will diminish after Covid times, now that everyone thinks twice before they randomly decide to clear their throught.
Where do I find the sheet music for this, I have been looking everywhere?
It's a movement from the quartet for the end of time. Expensive to purchase and I don't think available separately. Still in copyright so you won't find a legal download.
@@CarolHaynesJ Thanks for the information!
Imspl
Braw choon
this is to slow???
Absolutly not ! In my opinion the most respectfull interpretation ever.
Semi-quaver = 44
Certainly beautifully played but but those are not the slurs carefully written by the composer. And the metronome changes with the dynamics, which is a mistake. It’s beautiful but it’s not supernatural as it’s supposed to be. It’s heartily, it’s romantic.
blah blah blah
There is the question of whether the slurs are bowing markings or are there to highlight components of Messiaen's mode (a 'tweak' on one of his 'modes of limited transposition') and/or the components of the additive rhythm. Also, he didn't want his 'worshipful' music played mechanically. For example, the first of the 'Vingt Regards...' looks as mechanical as this but must be played "con amore". Similarly, this piece is to be played "majestueux, recueilli, tres expressif".
@@markgcarroll Mark, you may be right but nonetheless the piece sounds much better with original slurs. Messiaen (or Pasquier) even noted ups and downs to avoid any misunderstanding, and the composer’s care to slur on the cells of his modes are just signs of his genius. In any case one can play beautifully even respecting the stillness of metronome…
@@andreacavuoto Ah, I had forgotten that there are bowing markings (up and down), thanks for the reminder.
Messiaen's slurs and bowing markings are practically impossible at this speed, so I like the cellist prioritising tone quality. And if you listen to Messiaen playing his own pieces, he's very flexible in rhythm and tempo so I don't think he would have minded that much
Please stop coughing.
Unbelievably noisy audience.