Why didn't the USA invade North Vietnam? (Short Animated Documentary)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 июн 2024
- During the Vietnam War, with the exception of air strikes, the US kept its military operations to the South. Given that attacking the north would have placed the momentum with the US and allowed it to remove important North Vietnamese infrastructure, it seems weird that the Americans didn't. So why not? To find out watch this short and simple animated history documentary.
Lukáš Houdek
thypthon
Jens Koch-Nommensen
Øystein Alsaker
Sergio M. Vela
Emil Świderek
Eclipse
Armaan Bath
Gin Aldeguer
Dennis Vandeban
robert lalonde
Brendan W
Mathias.C
Michael Kram
Hasmuffin
CharÉTS
Franco La Bruna
Don Bonnigan
Southside Mitch
Justin Kubusch
Adam Barrett
John
Bradley chaulk
JakeBak0905
Heath Robertson
Ethan
Person
Leonard Frank
His Empyreal Illuminance The Supreme High Priest Kalynx
DVoid
sharpie660
Paul Munro
Martha Grondin
Sean D.
Nuukov
Nathan Mendelsohn
Emperor Kane
Mario Peshev
Brooks Woolson
Harley Raptopoulos
Jane Sumpter
Piotr Wojnowski
Christopher Godfrey
Aaron Conaway
Shauna K
Korix Riylo
Philip Yip
Mario Mejia
Andreas Mosand
Alex Teplyakov
Steven Gibson
Roman Kynčl
Manny F
Nolan Peale
Phillip Gathright
Erik Hare
Tony Belmonte
Jack Nelson
Joshua Schneider
Sean Uzar
Phoenix Fats
Andrew F
John Orr
Vance Christiaanse
Evan Ellingson
Jamie van Brewen
D. Mahlik
Travis Mount
tegsirat
Contdoko12
Nicholas Menghini
Katie Flinn
Ron Johnson
Jacob Zachs
Dr. Schtnizel
zockotron
Michael Galloway
Nick Macarius
GrokThis
Jose Recinto
Bernardo Cavalcanti
Arthur Hosey Jr.
Angel Aguiñaga
Tactical_Jackal
Duke
Thomas McGraw
Sahni
Peter Marino
ein-veh
Matthew Toles
Konstantin Bredyuk
Serius_Loyola
Allen Rines
mgnesium.poetry
John Garcia
MGS2600
Alan Romero
khaki enthusiast
Sebastian Mayor
Leena Al-Souki
HelloAgain
Dullis
Chase Labiste
Zachary Pascalar
Joe DeVito
Ciege Engine
Andrew Patane
blaZzinG_FurY
Bradley Backoff
Vilena5
Justin Short
Tim Stone
Tino
Jason Vandeventer
Florian Mäder
george tyler
Joseph Hutchins
Duane Bridges
Aaron Larrow
Anthony McCann
Liquid Chief
Chris Weisel
William Adderholdt
Ben Drums 24
Spencer DeRosier
Clayton Schuman
KNSTRKTVST
Patrick Crowne
ThePalestRose
Windischgraetz
No way
Patty Culp
Nathan Ngumi
Curt Helmerich
C. C. C.
Joel Wasserman
ZCoupon
bas mensink
SketerK
Tim Sweeney
Andrew Niedbala
Tim Stumbaugh
Logical Insanity
Hexapuma
Tyler Jenkins
Warren Rudkin
ARandomPaperClip
Burt Clothier
James
Andrei Listochkin
Bren Ehnebuske
Jeff Sharon
Oliver Jenner
alexccg
Perry Gagne
Vegard Tønnessen
Ethan Harlow
Joseph Reinsch
Matt Reed
Bodo Nuber
Chach
Jason Gould
Bartosz Zasada
Matt Busch
Matthew Ward
Ahmed Roshdi
Ned Burke
Tall Jeff
Yared Cristiano
Colm Byrne
Cade Summers
Romney Manassa
Juan Castillo
Valentyn
kevinh
Alen
Magdalena Reinberg-Leibel
Mars Project
BattleGoat Studios
Geoffrey Sparrow
Stefan Møller
SirAlpaka
Emily Glover-Wilson
Clay Carroll
Franklin
Azul Bravestrong
Rob Rollins
Steve Bonds
Robin!
Melissa Prober
Mark Littlehale
nullptr
Richard Wolfe
Harrison Wiener
Anthony Uk
Brian Giordano
Jonny Minogue
Jeffrey Schneider
Carl Blanton
William Clark
Moraxian
Mik Scheper
Juan Benet
Colonel Oneill
Hiro P
David Spellmeyer
Yuichiro Kakutani
JT96
YugiJitsu Games
pdswanfleet
Sethars
Igor Stavchanskiy
Joseph Kerckhoff
I'm Not In The Description
Alex G.
George Buce
Donald Weaver
Ryan Haber
Mark Ploegstra
Charles Doolittle
Hunter Bayliss
Tristan Kreller
Aeryn and Lisa Toland
T. c. north
Dr. Howard Dr. Fine Dr. Howard
Wolf
James R DeVries
Isabel Harrison
Dustin Koellhoffer
Oriki
Heytun
Thomas Wang
Tom Ebert
Roko Lisica
Eric Askins
LambOfLeg
Kishan Nair
Doug MacLean
Sean Long
John Gross-Whitaker
Zachary Oertel
Kevin Phoenix
Sara Birnbaum
Dan W
Dutchball Animations
Kirk Hoffman
Tranier Bocaj
Robert Brockway
Shakira Graham
Lech Duraj
Seth Reeves
Peter Konieczny
Colm Boyle
0_DannyBoy
George Caponera
biohazardgamer
Nathan Snyder
Will Sullivan
AltHistoryConjectures
Dan Reiher
Ian M
Dr. Sarno
Kinfe85
Miky Hidalgo Morriss
Ali Sadighian
Matthew O'Connor
Dexter_McAaron
Andrew Sever
Adrian Marine
Christopher S Nelson
Jonah Baloney
Lindorien
Paul McGee
João Santos
Abdallah Al-Ammari
Daniel O'Reilly
Typhoon2401
blei95
Markus Lindström
M Scho
Jan Bart Verbist
Ploshtinska polyudnica
Robin_Col
Kasi
Schwarzer Hai
Tarsirrus
Rhys Little
James
Ben L
Ash Elford
Jackarice26
Gina Service
Twinny Hill
zemnmez
Phil Johnston
Roberticus1992
KingKyumber
Rhys Jackson
![Darren Waller - Who Knew (Her Perspective) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/GytDjB8u6bM/mqdefault.jpg)
One small correction: Ho Chi Minh is no longer alive by 1973, thus unable to stand in front of a chalkboard outlining the agreements.
Yup, i thought so too
They still display his corpse though.
@@brandonlyon730 the body is actually alive, the hair and nails still grow btw
@@mostlymessingabout that's odd
@@mostlymessingabout Is it that they grow, or is the thing that when you die and your body is jammed with preservatives and dehydrated, your skin contracts and the parts of your hair and nails that were previously under your skin get revealed
There was a suggestion in Washington during the last days of the First Indochina War to utilize Ho Chi Minh as an 'asian Tito', a counterbalance to China the way Tito was to the USSR in Europe. Ho himself was apparently open to the idea of working with the USA (at the time the USA was relatively well liked in Vietnam compared to the French) but the USA didn't go for it, would have saved a lot of trouble if they had
There were many such men like Ho Chih Minh trying to egg the US to break the European empires by force. Doing so might have avoided this, but it would also destroy relations with Europe at the time.
For all we know, that could have been an even bigger disaster.
Damn, just to think how many lives were lost for not taking that path
Yeah the US decided they'd rather work with a brutally racist genocidal country desperate to regain control and try to bring back their slave colony plantations. Whodathunk it.
And the OSS, precursor of the CIA, trained Ho Chi Minh's forces during World War II to fight a guerilla war against the Japanese.
So following the end of World War II, with the French moving in again to reclaim their colonies, they were now confronted by the Viet Minh fighting a guerilla war.
And after the USA took over the 'fight against Communism,' they were thus fighting the North Vietnamese whose officers were probably trained in guerilla warfare by the Americans during WW2.
@@AudieHolland This is the most American thing ever.
North Vietnam was indeed bombed a lot. If you wander around Hanoi's Thanh Niên road between Tay Ho and Truc Bach lake, you will see a memorial for John McCain, who was shot down over the lake. There is also the debris of a B52 still in Ba Dinh. It was fascinating to see these little historical details while working in Vietnam.
should have let them keep mccain, after he betrayed his comrades.
@@nyarlat2609 How did he betray anyone?
We should go back for round two
@@tigerabraham5582 Vietnam and America are now friendly towards one another. Neither nations likes China.
It's not a 'memorial' for McCain. It commemorates where he was pulled from the lake by the angry locals. It's a celebration of his capture and imprisonment. He is considered a war criminal in Vietnam.
A few mistakes I noticed:
1. The country you called Cambodia is Laos. And the country you called Laos is Cambodia
2. Ho Chi Minh was already dead by 1973 (he passed in 1969).
3. The island of Phú Quốc off the southern coast should be Vietnamese, not Cambodian
4. Although China helped them during the Indochina Wars, North Vietnam was aligned with the Soviets during the Sino-Soviet split and remained suspicious of China's true motives. China would end up attacking them at the border as the result of Vietnam going after the Khmer Rouge (which was pro-China).
5. North Vietnam did not agree to stay out completely during the 1973 thing. Just for two years! That's why Saigon fell in 1975. They also let the Viet Cong form their own government in 1969 called the PRG/Provisional Revolutionary Government (and later the Republic of South Vietnam). When Saigon fell, this became the government. Vietnam wouldn't reunify officially until 1976
6. South Vietnamese-controlled Paracel Islands should be there. China invaded the whole of the Paracel Islands in 1974, but since it was under the South's control and China was helping the North, North Vietnam couldn't even protest until the relationship fell out 5 years later.
Bro he can have little mistakes it’s fine what’s the the point of typing like 2 essays 💀🤓
@@paul_isnice677 "little" that's not little though. They presented it as if the North broke the 1973 agreement when they didn't. That's a BIG mistake. They also made it seem like Vietnam and China were chummy with each other when they really weren't. If you're gonna present history as factual, you're expected to actually do your research. This was very biased.
@@detroitpeoplemover North Vietnam and China didn't have to be friends, They only needed to have a common enemy
, The U.S.
I love this guy's work. It's informative, humourous and provokes discussion. I, personally, have learnt more from your comments than I did from the video, but I still applaud it, and I thank you.
Also, I suspect that he will appreciate your input.
James Bissonette was able to escape the fall of Saigon by spinning three plates to generate lift.
three plates of pure gold
Couldn’t fly as high as Gustav Swan.
Kelly Moneymaker bought a plane in order to escape. 🤑💰🛫🇻🇳➡️🇺🇸
as suggested by boogely woogely
and Maggy Pakskowski.
3:03 Ho Chi Minh (pictured here at the Paris peace talks) actually famously refused to attend the Paris peace talks in 1973 because he didn't want to set a precedent for other communist leaders to leave their mausoleum. (i.e. lenin) He firmly believed that a good communist should stay quietly embalmed in his glass case after he or she died
This is satire right? Can't be so sure on the internet.
By 1973 he was no longer alive
@@JackLuong look up what a mausoleum is
crazy thing is HCM was at the 1919 Versailles conference, trying to drum up support for independence.
He died in 1969 ma guy. The VN gov was just hiding the fact from the outside world
It's ironic the U.S feared China would get involved if they invaded the North, but China ended up invading anyway in the late 70s. For different reasons, but still funny in a historical sense
The US feared about China declaring war on them, US doesn't give a fuck China attacking North Vietnam
it was for the same reason. China could not afford to look like it did nothing if allied North Vietnam was invaded by Americans, and it also could not afford to do nothing when allied Cambodia got invaded by Vietnam. In both cases, a show of force was necessary to signal their seriousness.
@@Samuel-wm1xr ummmmmm...... no it was completely different.
@@Samuel-wm1xr lol, thats not the reason
@@Samuel-wm1xr pol pot was kinda asking for it tho
Video Idea: What happened to Vietnam after 1975. The Vietnam War always gets the most attention (and, to a lesser extent, the First Indochina War), but few talk about what happened to Vietnam after 1975. From the re-education (labour) camps, the Vietnamese refugee crisis, Khmer Rouge border raids, Cambodian-Vietnamese War, Sino-Vietnamese War, and border clashes with China during the 80s. It wasn't like Vietnam reunified and it was all rainbows and sunshine.
I'm Vietnamese so maybe I can shed a little light on this. According to my parents and grandparents, it was pretty tough for the average citizen of Vietnam during that time. The economy was sluggish, the currency was nearly worthless on the world's economy, people were starving left and right and of course, freedom of speech was next to zero so as a result, many risked their lives to leave the country through any means possible (most notably the Boat People). But because everyone was suffering, my parents didn't feel that they were suffering, they thought it was just a part of life. It wasn't until 1990 when the General Secretary decided to fully open the country to the international market that lives began to get bettet. Still, even by the early 2000s, life was still tough for many families.
For me, who was born in 2000, looking back, Vietnam has come a long way for the past 10 years and the Vietnam of today is much more different than the Vietnam of 15 years ago. Now, lives for the Vietnamese is much better than 30-40 years ago and it continues to grow at a precedent rate. Still, that doesn't mean everyone is happy and satisfied and thousands of Vietnamese still immigrate to a different country to work and live.
yup, plenty of people in the South were rightly fighting to avoid that future. Problem was city people and country people had much different sets of problems, and the communists had a message that appealed to the underdeveloped rural villages.
@@tachikaze222weird that the reason they were struggling was because of the so called "allies" of South Vietnam bombing everything to oblivion and then charging them the bill alongside a healthy dose of sanctions
Cambodia in particular
@@edh8900 it wasn't until 1986 that Le Duan finally kicked the bucket that is.
Doi Moi was initiated within the same damn year.
North Vietnam reunited with South Vietnam caught the attention of Kim Il-sung. After North Vietnam's success in reuniting with its southern counterpart, he believes they too can reunite with South Korea
He went to China to discuss plans to invade south Korea but China isn't interested. So it never happened
Thats the thing, he went to discuss it with China. North Vietnam had to play juggle between the USSR and China since both of them wanted a VN dependent on their military aid and neither wanted an independent and unified Vietnam
@@KyleSolokov They exist because the red armies of the world willed it to be so. Same with the rest of the communist countries in any other proxy war. Taiwan and South Korea are doing better than the North and Vietnam. India will surpass China. Communist countries don’t do well in general. China has a lot of rare materials and oil much like Russia’s vapid economy.
@@zachdave2994 they still shit on the streets
what the OP said is the exact reason why Korea was never united. Asking China or USSR for permission to unify is a big red flag because they wanted a buffer zone in Korea, especially not an independent Korea. The Vietnamese leaders at time was politically intelligent and determined to play the political game with those giants and managed to unify in the end, ignoring China and USSR effort of stopping the north to unify with the south. However, this was also one of the reason why China invaded Vietnam in 1979 because they were pissed off that Vietnam didn't listen to China.
@@TheBikeOnTheMoon china has a lot of influence in SEA, it is not the first time they intervened when vietnam tried to bully their weaker neighbors, they would have invaded them in any case just to keep them weak relative to china.
'They bombed the North...a lot'
*uses more explosives in South-East-Asia than all warring nations during WW 2 combined*
They bombed the South more though. The U.S. were actually hampered in the North by tactical decisions, what to bomb, being taken ridiculously high in the chain of command, by the @#£%ing President. Bombers when interviewed repeatedly express frustration that they could not bomb actual targets because the government kept hampering the military.
@Mauro Rondelli
Well, Matthias S1234's general point is still fundamentally correct esp. as the US did not confine its bombing to Laos during ghe Vietnam War (even as it did make Laos the most heavily bombed country in human history so far) . The US and its allies dropped nearly 8 million tons of bombs on SE Asia--two to three times the total tonnage dropped by all sides during World War 2.
It's estimated that if the USA used the *entire* US army to demine and debomb present-day Laos of munitions the USA dropped on them the project would take a century.
And yet didn't do anything near the damage as most of the bombs fell in the jungle. Hanoi wasn't bombed into the ground like Tokyo. Dresden or even Pyongyang....
@@Truth_Hurts528 They do blow the legs of children to this day, fifty years later . . .
Delighted to see a new upload. I hope all is well in History Matters land
Please do the Mexico-Guatemala conflict of 1958 next! This would be interesting to see.
Guatemala was ready to go at war with Mexico, with the support of El Salvador, Honduras, and Nicaragua to stoke resentment against Mexico…
While Mexico had the support of the United States, Cuba, China, and the Soviet Union.
yeah that's probably why it didn't happen
what nigerian civil war bullshit is this?
@Elon Tusk And Cuba too.
Why does this broken autobalancing keep putting the strongest players together, Guatemala just got a noob team
Central America should be one country. Now it's mostly a bunch of failed states. United, it would have the population of Colombia or South Korea...
It's so amazing just how much history I've learned from this channel. Especially on topics & questions that would have never crossed my mind.
Well History Matters
Part of your thanks should go to James Bisonnette.😊
I didn't know our Captain is also here. We'll meet back on the ship!
Never thought I’d see you here
ayo it's you
Ironic enough Ho Chi Minh was actually present at the Treaty of Versailles to try and represent Vietnamese independence. He was denied entry via Woodrow Wilson and left by train back to Vietnam, which took him through the Soviet Union where he read the manifesto and met Vladimir Lenin. What’s even more crazy is Ho Chi Minh lived in Harlem New York for a short time and attended UNIA meetings, A Pan-African movement. This dude also did all of this in his mid 20s and 30s.
this guy really got around. i knew that he was one of the more moderate tempered communist leaders (especially considering other communist rulers in asia not having a good track record), and was considering more of a liberator by most vietnamese people rather than a full on communist. of course he still did brutal things, war is hell and all, but i didn't know he had quite that interesting backstory
i have an interest of people in history to skirt the line between good and evil. Italo Balbo and his life story of being a fascist and hating the Nazis are things i just eat up
Woodrow Wilson's biggest failure will always be due to his extreme racism.
@@sovietunion7643 he wasn’t insane like Stalin or mao but he did kill half a million north Vietnamese civilians during the “peace” in between the Geneva accords and the Tonkin incident. He is also responsible for the massacres the NVA and viet cong did during the Vietnam war. He was a dictator just like the rest.
@@Forty7-Twenty7 The half a million thing is probably the land reform? Yeah that was bad, but mostly due to civilians using the policy for revenge. The massacres you said is called a war. The Americans did a lot of massacres as well with all the bombings.
@@ddawng268 at least 100,000 north Vietnamese civilians were executed by the state.
And also, there is a difference between the bombing of strategic targets by the US with little care for civilian casualties and the deliberate murdering done by the nva and Vietcong. I am not excusing the us’s policies during the war, just pointing out what a lot people don’t seem to see.
Total civilian deaths from US bombing: ~65,000
During the war the PAVN and VC killed around 36,000 civilians and 17,000 civil servants for various reasons.
In total there were at least 106,000 south Vietnamese civilians who deliberately killed by the north once you include the democides.
There were 2,800-6,000 civilians who were executed by the PAVN and Viet Cong after the capture of hue city.
The deadliest massacre ever committed by the United States was the My lai massacre, where 500 civilians were murdered.
I think it is clear which side is better at intentionally murdering civilians.
Note I didn’t include deaths from cross fire because it’s hard to place the blame on either side.
To call it “just war” isn’t really appropriate and lets both sides off too easily.
These videos are great, but too short. I'm just left wanting more more MOAR!!1
Am I the only one that got the Star Trek reference at 2:00 ?
First Contact FTW! You guys are epic indeed.
Loving the Star Trek First Contact reference at 2:01
No little ships were harmed in the making of this video though.
See you in the next video, Ahab
@@sevenprovinces Little... *klingon frown* >:(
Well played indeed
Actually, Vietnam was aligned with the Soviets in the Sino-Soviet Split and had poor relations with China(Mao was ambivalent in interviews over supporting North Vietnam in case of an US invasion), China even abandoning support for it in 1968. Post-war, China even fought a short war with Communist Vietnam in 1979 over Vietnam's toppling of the pro-Chinese Khmer Rouge.
You got the info wrong. China sent a ton of material and man power into N Vietnam. It was after the war they had a differences. Cause Vietnam went with the Soviets. To China that was a betray. Since China sent tons of money and people to defend the N Vietnam.
There were Chinese divisions inside N Vietnam fixing its infrastructure and manning anti air etc...
China did not completely abandon Vietnam after 1968. A Vietnamese paper had list out sporadic support till 1974. Relations were bad with the Soviet did not mean a complete cut off.
@@TheZachary86
Especially as the Chinese hated the US after Korea. There were plenty of Chinese volunteers in North Vietnam, manning AA systems.
also consider that china has been to trying to absorb vietnam into its sphere of influence since china has been a civilization at all and its not exactly a suprise that they preffered the soviets.
reminder that vietnam and china had a big border skirmish in 1979 that lasted nearly a month. not exactly a sign of good relations between communists.
@@DomWeasel yeah the Chinese were cooperating with the logistics from the border into Hanoi, which made the US bombing of this area politically tricky.
Another small correction: North Vietnam loves USA first but when Rooservelt died and Truman replaced him, Truman heel face turn and renounce North Vietnam as enemy that need to be eradicated even at the cost of supportng France's colonize regime.
So Vietnam, currently under threat of getting invaded by France again turned to USSR and China for help. The rest was hstory.
dude i love watching your vids before i sleep/to help me sleep!
To be fair the early days of the Korean war were far bloodier than the peak of Vietnam. Vietnam cost the US more but it lasted a lot longer. Korea on an average day was bloodier. For american planners preventing a rerun of Korea was paramount. Its just that Vietnam lasted for a lot more and casualties ended up higher. But to be fair since Korea no single day of combat for the US has exceeded 250 dead.
That is because they are two completely different wars, Korea was a high-intensity war while Vietnam was supposed to be low-intensity (Guerilla). Portuguese involvement in the First World War resulted in tens of thousands dead while the Colonial War had just over 8,000 dead.
@@johnnotrealname8168 plus S. Korea didn't have Laos and Cambodia for the north to enjoy interior lines of communication basically. Plus the Communists were relatively strong in the South before 1954 and plenty of people preferred them to Diem and later Thieu.
@@tachikaze222 That is true. Although in a high-intensity war this would be less of a problem. Not the majority by a long shot but yeah. The American Counter-Insurgency programme was stupid as it did not even protect the people which is the whole point.
Remember that the Korean war (“police action”?) was an intervention approved by the UN Security Council.
And also remember that the permanent Security Council member with veto power named “China” at that time was Taiwan (“Republic Of China”), not the “People’s Republic Of China”.
@@lawrencedoliveiro9104 Yes and? Are you salty that the US didn't let the North Koreans and Soviets do an imperialism to the South? We know what would've happened if they hadn't, and it doesn't look pretty
I was hoping to see someone running through a field of daisies…
…But it didn’t happen. 😞
Next time.
You wanted gallivanting through a field of flowers, but fun fact: no.
@@pokehybridtrainer One can hope.
Soon
After dropping all that Agent Orange, there were no daisies to skip through.
Love your work!
I love how ypu answer the questions I never thought to ask.
Great video as usual, but just wanted to note that you accidentally mixed up Cambodia and Laos on the map ^^
Noticed that as well.
@@maartenwitpaard1737 Me three.
Me four
I did not, so minus one
Me five
History matters is my all time favorite channel for learning history!!!
Here are some suggestions:
1. How did the World react to the discovery of Oceania?
2. Why isn’t Dutch an official language in the Congo Kinshasa despite it being a Belgian colony?
3. How was life like in Soviet Central Asia?
4. Why does Lebanon exist?
5. Why didn’t the USA 🇺🇸 got its protectorate over Armenia?
For nr.5 congress didn't approve it
Lebanon is just Phoenicia.
@@gamingwitmc7041 no we're not :)
Also for nr.2 the belgians tried to enforce dutch but it never caught on
@@marcnassif2822 you sure? I seen a lot of dna test of y’all descending from Phoenicians
I love your channel keep up the great stuff
I had always asked myself this question. Thank you for bringing answers to questions I had. These things are sometimes forgotten in the narrative and considered like obvious.
Keep up the great work
That First Contact reference killed me, my dude. Great vid!
The "this far, not further" bit is gold! Well done as always, love this channel !!
Star Trek First Contact is among my favourite movies (and my fav Trek movie) and still I almost missed it. It registered like three seconds after the scene was over xD
I miss Ten Minute History
@@Unknowngfyjoh Same
Thank you for video sir
Wow! I knew almost none of this. But it all makes sense. Thanks for the insights!!
Damn this is a question I probably should have asked myself as an American college student when I was getting my history degree. Thanks for the video!
I assume you studied a different period of history than the 20th Century? Or are history degrees kind of general to all points in history?
Haha right, same. The nooks and crannies of history are endless, even the obvious ones
@@eddiewhistler7472 in undergrad you don't really focus on one topic but rather a more general history by picking various classes from different regions and time periods but in grad school you do specialize in one topic. at least thats how it worked at my uni
That corner of the world is no place for a mechanized army. Jungle, hills upon hills, torrential monsoon rains. The US could barely go toe-to-toe with PAVN at the DMZ. Escalation into the north would just make a bigger mess.
@@tachikaze222 The US annihilated the PAVN and NLF every time it fought them, and evidently that outright isn’t the case given the PAVN’s offensives in 73 and 75 involving a deeply mechanized force.
ROE is what did the US in, not their order of battle. It was simply simultaneously too lax and too restrictive.
I've always wondered what "Mao" meant in Estonian. Thank you!
Great content!
Loved the Picard Star Trek: First Contact reference!!!!!
Wow learned so much from a war I look so much into! Thanks a lot!
Unfortunately this defensive posturing is what enabled the North to win the war - if you are not afraid of being invaded, you can send 10 out of 11 infantry divisions to invade the South.
2:00, I got that Star Trek reference. Got a good chuckle out of it.
Thanks for the great video! I am able to learn a lot more about what happened in the past in just a few minutes from all your videos. Best time spent during my breaks. 👍
Another amazing video
0:08 you got those countries confused. The blue one is Laos and the white one is Cambodia.
he got the order wrong
As a South East Asian, you are god damn right
Great video.
Your Ten Minute History series' are one of the best RUclips series of all time. Why'd you stop those?
Great video as always
My favourite RUclipsr by far, you’ve inspired me to make my own channel!. Keep up the great work!
Cheeky ad in the comments lol, Im checking out your latest vid. Liking it so far so Ill keep an eye on the channel
@@joeshmoe6566 haha thanks!, I wasn’t intending to advertise but more show support to a content creator. I mean in his Q&A he said he wanted to be a teacher
I love your channel. Can you keep doing videos on Indochina, as it doesn't get a lot of attention and you explain things very well.
Vietnamese here. Your videos are always entertaining, well researched, and fun to watch. I've learned a lot from you.
Amazing how you guys answer questions I had for a long time. Great coverage!
The one thing I've never understood is why people believe Laos and Cambodia were innocent in the Vietnam-American War. They were not. They actively participated.
Love the "First Contact" reference!
I almost had a heart attack at 0:08 when you list "Cambodia and Laos" but highlight them on the map in the opposite order.
Keep up the work man loving the content 👍
Ho chi minh traveled for 30 years and he lived in america for a time, he fought for vnmese independence everywhere. He got into communism not as an ideology at first but as a way of saving his nation. Even after that, america and vietnam still tried to work together, Ho chi minh wanted allies support and america did so for a time ( against japan). America was even present when hcm made the declaration of independence, the first line of which literally contained a line from the US' DECLARATION as a basis. Ultimately they chose the French and decided to back them in their return to Vietnam bcz communism and stuff.
This is BS propaganda. Ho Chi Minh used the US Declaration of Independence to pander to America for support, as Mao had done during WW2 and the Chinese Civil War. Does anyone think America allying with Mao would have made him less of a Communist mass murdering maniac? It was just insincere political theatre, they wanted weapons and recognition so they said what they thought America wanted to hear.
Ho Chi Minh was every bit a Communist for the sake of Communism. After North Vietnam had achieved functional independence, the combined Vietnamese Independence groups formed a Coalition government and the Communists quickly rigged it against the non-Communist Vietnamese Nationalist groups like the Viet Nam Quoc Dan Dang. When things started getting heated between the Nationalist groups and the Communists, the Communists turned to the French and signed a treaty creating a Communist North Vietnam within the French Union and collaborated with the French Army to encircle and massacre all the other Vietnamese Nationalist forces in North Vietnam. Nationalist groups that had fought for Vietnam's Independence from France and Japan, some of them longer than the Communists. Ho Chi Minh was a dishonorable rat who betrayed his fellow revolutionaries so he could seize total power for the Communists.
Exactly, had the USA strong -armed those gallic morons in giving indipendence to their East Asian colonies,perhaps they would've spared a lot of problems, either to them AND the rest of the western world, don't forget that a lot of terrorism was inspired by the (fake) mithology of the VCs that could topple a regular army (just ask how well ended for Guevara).
@Krauses yeah sure..not like the US was pressured by the French to save their colonies. also, remind me why we should listen to you if your banner is the symbol of a nation no longer in existence and in of itself is hypocritical of its ideals.
Trung, Ho was Communist, France wasn't.
@@YonIon996 Sidnom, thank you for your observation. That has nothing to do wilth the conversation I was having with Trung. Trung had many false points, like he has the entire chronology of France's and America's involvement in Vietnam wrong.
America: The NVA promised us they won't invade the south after we leave.
The NVA: I'm Gonna Do What's Called a Pro Gamer Move.
DRV: The French promised us they will let us unification our country
The US: I'm Gonna Do What's Called a Pro Gamer Move.
ngo refused elections. not usa@@tovarishsus
Ur cringe
The NVA didn't invade the south, it was the South Vietnamese Liberation Front who did it
nope, ho chi minh invaded the south with the support of ussr. learn history@@Kidtoucher-wg9gg
Hey, wondering what your sources were. Never really seen this idea before in all the stuff I have read! Many thanks!
I suppose the US military was hoping the communists would give up once they faced enough causalities, but clearly that didn't happen. Ho Chi Minh was pretty clear from the beginning that the Vietnamese would suffer a lot of causalities, a lot more than their enemies, but eventually they would win in the end, and that is exactly what happened.
There is definitely something to said about setting the correct level of expectations ahead of time. You remind me of Admiral Stockdale’s recollections as a POW for seven years. “The men who thought they would be released by Christmas didn’t make it.”
“It bombed the north, a lot” for scale of how lot it was, more than double the amount of bombs were dropped on indochina between 1965-75 than the entirety of world war 2
@Mauro Rondelli Laos is the most bombed country per capita.
false comparison 10 years Vietnam vs just 6 years(US 4\3.5) WWII.
@@armoredinf except this is accounting for ALL bombs dropped by ALL countries during WWII.
I think a more accurate drawing would be to have Le Duan represent North Vietnam after 1968 rather than Ho Chi Minh since he died at that point and the VCP camp slowly went anti-China at that point
Explain baarle-hertog and baarle-naasau next or just the really weird borders of Belgium!
Great video as always !
Easy explanation! Good job! 👍
Thanks for the video. You missed the crucial part of the background: after ww2 Ho Chi Min and his government were the USA ally, but because France wanted its colonies back and France was more important ally the USA had to stay aside while France tried to conquer Vietnam back. That made Ho Chi Min an enemy and pushed hin back to communism and USSR.
@lianakannabisovna1603: The US "stayed aside" by eventually paying about 75% of the costs and supplying most of the arms and support equipment that France needed to fight on the other side of the world-for years.
“This far no further” I see what you did there First Contact ;) been watching Picard season 3 have we? :P
US: Yeah, why not invade North Vietnam!
China: Hey bro do you remember me? Remember the Korean War?
US: I take it back.
Basically China was the big counter part on why they didn't invade north Vietnam. Also there were Communists rebels in the South along with the Viet cong due to the extreme unpopularity of the South Vietnamese government.
I recall that an American politician (don’t remember which one) sat in on a meeting discussing Vietnam strategy and made the observation that the north Vietnamese birth rate (and hence the rate that boys turned 18 and could fight) was much higher than the rate they were being killed in south Vietnam. In other words, the south Vietnamese and the US could never win if it was just a matter of shooting people. That politician was not invited back.
That reminds me of the “kill ratio” -- just one of many phrases that were used in discussing the Vietnam War. Also, after it had been revealed that some Government spokesman made a claim that was debunked: “that statement is now inoperative”.
no war can be won by just shooting people, thats called a genocide
@@lawrencedoliveiro9104 Given this history, I think that western claims about Russian combat losses in Ukraine should be greeted with a great degree of skepticism.
@@dpeasehead Ukraine may well turn out to be Russia’s Vietnam.
@@lawrencedoliveiro9104commies colonists (North Vietnamese) are controlled South Vietnam over 48 years now. They are closed to Russia, China and India than other western countries. How about the massacres, crimes against humanity during the Vietnam War created by Northern Vietnamese to South Vietnam almost going silent in Western media. Very very disappointed.
Nice “First Contact” reference!
Can you do a video about the German mediatization that occurred between 1802-1814? Like which states ate smaller states and which got eaten etc?
That would be an hour long video lol
@@luisfilipe2023
This bloke did a 10 minute long video covering the entire fall of the western Roman Empire from 395-476
He can handle it…..
For me, as an American who was alive during those times, it’s strange to hear nothing about the coup against Diem, the Gulf of Tonkin, or the Pentagon Papers. It’s also kind of strange to hear the American motivations and responses summarized so neatly when our country was coming apart at the seams over this issue (something apparently unknown to those bewailing our current “divisions” as if they are something new).
Screenful of the non-surprised (3:09) was worth the wait.
I miss the longer 10+ minute videos you used to make
0:08 FYI Cambodia is the country in the South (with access to the ocean) and Lao is the landlocked country in the North.
Love the video!
I'm thankful this war wasn't escalated any further myself. Thank you for another comical video.
God be with you out there everybody. ✝️
2:00 Maybe a time traveling Enterprise E could help?
History matters answers the questions that come to my mind midnight
0:25 "A bit of background."
I bloody love this channel XD
almost every historian mistakenly believe that viet nam were divided , actually it had never been divided by any agreements. the 1954 Geneva conference simply just allowed France and its colonial government to have a temporary military occupation zone before they agreed to withdraw and give independent to a unified Vietnam, signed between Paris government and Vietnamese people government. in other words it is completely different from Germany and Japan , who never signed any agreement to divide their countries , but signed between communist bloc and the western victors . Korea were japanese territories , so neither Koreans nor Japanese were allowed any negotiation at their country 's fate.
That’s some nice background
1:51 I want to know more about that fella "Domino Theory" ... nice if you can make a bio video of him 😊
Estonia mentioned, literally the best day of my life
1974-
USA: We're going to leave now, please keep it together
South Vietnam: Sure
2010-
USA: We're going to leave now, please keep it together
Iraq: Sure
2021-
USA: We're going to leave now, please keep it together
Afghanistan: Sure
One out of three I guess.
TY 🙏🙏
My weekend is complete now that history matters!
Why haven't you uploaded for 2 weeks?
Another factor: the sheer cost. The Johnson administration had been trying to fight the Vietnam war on a peacetime budget, and also keeping American forces in Western Europe prepared for the USSR running the Fulda Gap, and ALSO cranking up spending on the Great Society welfare programs.
This didn't work.
When the Tet Offensive launched NATO forces in Europe thought it was a feint to distract from the Soviets invading, because by 1968 US European Command was being held together by duct tape and zip ties, so much had been diverted to Vietnam.
Invading the North would have meant doubling the defense budget, ending student deferments in the draft, even nationalizing steel and munition productions. It would have been a Korean War size conflict at the five year mark, and there was no feasible way Congress would have approved of any of it.
They seriously thought the entire communist world was that co-ordinated?
@@dfv2060 Utter doofuses they were.
They should have protected their ally properly. If you want cannon-fodder, the Koreans will gladly massacre Communists or so I am told.
@@dfv2060 Better be safe than sorry.
@davidstruck8109: Everyone talks about the costs of the Great Society programs. What did 100 years of jim crow cost America?
Valeu!
I like the reference to Star Trek: First Contact!
1. China
2. It likely would've taken at least a million men to hold North Vietnam (and fight China while doing so.)
3. In order to maintain domestic support for the war, the US government never sufficiently raised taxes to pay for it. This attempt to fight a "guns and butter war" would bite back in the '70s as the US faced an extended period of stagflation.
4. The US was pouring money into Japan and South Korea to procure raw material and maintain shipping lines. All this American money would fuel "the Japanese miracle" as the country experienced several decades of rapid economic growth. This would also blow back on the US when well-funded Japanese (and South Korean) companies began wiping out American corporations in the '70s and '80s with far superior products.
5. The US tried to use conscripted troops to wage a longterm war of occupation, something which would fan anti-war resistance back home. The reason the US would be able to carry out longterm occupations of Afghanistan and Iraq was because the country used an "all volunteer military" (i.e. a mercenary army of the poor and indebted,) which meant the rest of the population not only didn't have to worry about being drafted, they didn't even have to think about the war.
So, now I want a video about how the intra-Vietnam war went.
Could you Make a Video About How the World Reacted to the Troubles in Northern Ireland? I just think it sounds like a good idea
Love the Estonian reference!
It's worth mentioning as well that there were many in the government who were not optimistic about the US achieving a conventional "victory" in Vietnam, even in the early years of the war.
USA authorities were a lot smarter back then and rooted in the real world compared to now, even if they still did a lot of stupid sh!t like getting meddling in Vietnam.
I find that fact amazing given the narrative I was fed.
Our government had no intention to win this war
There are tapes of LBJ basically admitting that Vietnam was a lost cause, and that he only stationed troops to avoid a political backlash about “losing” South Vietnam.
"Victory" in SE Asia was South Vietnam pushing NVA & Viet Cong out, having a free country. No one wanted a war or 1000s of young men dead. But Uncle Ho aka Ho Chi Minh pushed to bring the Viet Nams together. With secret, covert USSR-GRU help.
Turns out trying to fight a purely defensive war with a population dedicated to fighting you in horrible terrain really isn’t a winnable situation
Small correction: Laos and Cambodia are switched in the beginning
I could have saved myself a semester in college by just watching this. Thanks! 😆
You would be misinformed
@@YonIon996 I'm lovin' it
They didn't invade North Vietnam as James bissanete had property rights in the north.
…
You know it’s a good day when History Matters and iSorrowProductions upload.
Glad to see a fellow fan of both.
Could you please cover the war between Vietnam vs Khmer Rouge and China?
Latest edition of 'Things I never thought of but are very good questions'.