Salman Rashid Conflicts of History and Identity Crises | Ali Abbass Talks
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 фев 2025
- #salmanrashidconflictsofhistoryandidentitycrises #salmanrashidconflictsofhistoryandidentitycrisis #salmanrashidconflictsofhistoryandidentitycrisisreaction #salmanrashidconflictsofhistoryandidentitycrisesand #salmanrashidconflictsofhistoryandidentitycrisesandcrime #salmanrashidconflictsofhistory #salmanrashidconflictsofhistoryinurdu #salmanrashidconflictsofhistoryand #salmanrashidconflictsofhistoryandculture #conflictsofhistoryandidentitycrises #conflictsofhistoryandidentitycrisisaudiobook #conflictsofhistoryandidentitycrisesand #conflictsofhistoryandidentitycrisesandjustice
Rashid sir is one of very few brave Pakistani.
Salman Rasheed ji is one of the well read personalities of Pakistan. His presentation of historical and geographical facts always mesmerises me. I listen to his enlightening videos. Respect you from a Bharatiya. 🙏
You are absolutely right
Lets keep a clear distinction between Islam and colonialism. To be a Muslim you do not have to be a Turk, a Persian or an Arab.
Persians and Turks keep their ethnic names from their cultures. Being Muslim doesn't mean you forget your soil, DNA or culture.
Never surrender your indigenous identity,
Never forget the history of your ancestors, Never quit your language.
Native Pride. Son of Soil.
Alhamdulillah Proud to be Punjabi Arain❤
Arains are no Brahmins …….
Arain is Maali caste (Gardener) in Punjab.
@@malikahmad8170In Punjab Haryana and Rajasthan only one caste dominates over all other castes. That caste is Jat or Jatt.
@@PunjabiMuslim510 our beloved general Zia (some call him shaheed also) was arain too:-
@@SonOfSindh-u3y Chal oye Tera piyo wa Arain Punjabi Maa na de
After Prof. Ishtiaq Ahmed now I found a true historian. I salute him.
पाकिस्तान कि सच बोलने वाली आखरी पिढी है अहमद साहब
❤❤❤ हिम्मत है आपकी ❤जो सच बोल रहें हो❤❤❤
زبردست سائين
Great man
Excellent
Salman sahab ki baaten hein to kadvi lekin hein sachhi.
It is next to impossible to expect something good in the country
Thanks Jinnah for separating us & dividing us. Otherwise, we would have to deal with all the thugs which ruled pakistan later on. The bloodshed that is going on in 2 separated parts of India ( Pak & Bangla) along with Afghanistan would have left us nowhere. We would have to keep the Muslims happy with various compromises.
Momin culture is hugely toxic,i had first hand experience.
Not felt good , felt sad , anyways history can't be changed . Sir is very great . Have tremendous knowledge of the entire Hind
Salman Rashid ji's name meaning -
Salman- safe
Rashid - rightly guided
In Sanskrit - "safe" means - Rakshit
Guide means- Nayak
His name translation in hindi or sanskrit-
"Rakshit Nayak" 😊😊👍👍
Rashid (Persian) is derived from Rakshit from Sanskrit. Entire Persian mother tongue is Sanskrit.
@@ac_te_c_Rashid is Arabic not Persian. And persian and sanskrit originate from indo Iranian language, from 1700 bc, no one is mother tongue of anyone
@@mrkps1986 What ever you believe is your personal understanding. Real evidence even anthropology tells different story then what you believe, for your information Indo Aryan theory is west prpaganda, our History is known for 15000 BCE (Before Common Era)).
@@ac_te_c_ 👏👏👏
@@mrkps1986 You are correct word Rashid has Arebic Root.. not Persian. I apologise for the same.
Marked words of Sir Salman we changed our Religion but not our father
Salman sahab is a diamond ❤
Great personality
🎉 Vadde Paaji di Balle balle 🎉
Paaji j mai kadi Lahore aaya taa tuhanu pakka milna Party de dena Murshid 😂
If arains are arabs how hindhu arain people formed that means arain is also a hindhu caste converted largely to islam because of greed the british cences also shows their hindhu decrease in data
The 1881 Census of India detailed the Arain population was 795,032 in Punjab, of which 791,552 (99.56 percent) were Muslims, 2,628 (0.33 percent) were Hindus, 848 (0.11 percent) were Sikhs, and 4 (0.0005 percent) were Christians.[16][a]
As of 1931 Census of India, out of the total Arain population of 1,331,295 in Punjab, 1,330,057 (99.91%) were Muslims, 1,146 (0.086%) were Hindus, 67 (0.005%) were Sikhs and 5 (0.00038%) were Christians
Request: Sir Salman Rashid Sahab may kindly consider exploring the various pieces of history of the entire subcontinent, expanding over the geographical boundaries of present day Pakistan. His valuable insights with regard to the various lopsided history books still in circulation in India would be very much enriching, to set the the record straight.
Host is in loss of proper words, most of the time.
You are right actually Salman was in hurry due to his session in SLF and was trying to trying to quit and that's why you could feel that I was trying to grab as much I could.
Age factor or because of chosing the right/soft words.
One of the best debates i have watched in my life.
Mughals are also Turks ... Turkaan e Mughliya
آرائیوں اور اوان تو انگریز دور میں عرب ہونے کا دعوی کیا کیوں کہ ان کو دلیر بننے کے لئے عرب لباس پہنا۔ تاکہ انگریز فوج میں زیادہ سے زیادہ بھرتی دیکر زمینیں وغیرہ حاصل کریں۔ لوگ سید بنے تاکہ نذرانہ کے نام پر پیسے حاصل کر سکیں۔
میں بہت غور سے سن رہی تھی لیکن آخر میں جو گھٹیا بات ان کو خوش کرنے کے لئے کی جن کی پورا وقت برائیاں کرتے رہے تو انکی کسی بات پر اعتبار کرنے کو دل نہین کیا۔ فھڑی چوری اور ملک ریاض سے پلاٹ لینے کا الزام جس پر لگا رہے ہیں اس نے پورے پیسے دے کے گھڑی لی۔ اور ملک ریاض نے جو پلاٹ دیا اس پر یونیورسٹی ہے جہاں غریب بچے پڑھتے ہیں۔ اتنی کوشش کے بعد بھی ایک کیس کرپشن کا نہین نکال سکے اسکے خلاف۔ چلو پتا چل گیا کہ آپکا باپ کون ہے بڑے ہسٹورین ہو کر ایک کیس کا مطالعہ نہیں کرسکے۔ اتنا پڑھ لکھ کر انہی کو سپورٹ کرنا جو ہمین یہاں تک پہنچانے کے ذمہ دار ہیں تو لخ دی لخ لعنت آپکے تاریخی مطالعے پر
Great job by Salman Rashid
Sir, sword has been the main instrument of making muslims.
It was done 1st by Muhammad followed by Abu Bakr in Arab peninsula.
Umardid the same with persia with a huge bonus of trained standing
persian army.
Withina period of about 20 years entire middle east has become muslim with the help of swords.
In fact islam always had a standing army all through its history.
As a result as of now 95% of muslims globally are non Arabs/mawalis/ pseudo Arabs suffering from identity crisis leading to instabilities.
Perfect analysis perfect 👌. But No One could convert india 😂
Stay Blessed 😇🙏
We Muslims will now have to find our roots so that we can now recognize our real religion and follow it. I have now left Islam and Namaaz and in the future I will make my children follow the religion of their roots.but will take you to Islam and not to Islam
Radcliffe refused payment for his services.
This program preferably should be in Punjabi
Kasana are gujjar. U r a gujjar right?
If you want to correct history change that hybrid name 'pakistan' , find out the realistic name of the area which is Sindh .
Mughal bhi Uzbekistan me fargana or samarkand k hi turk thy vo bhi kam nahi thy convert karne me . Sare ek hi thali k chatte batte thy . Ye unke bhi baap thy conversation of kashmiri pandits into muslim by Aurangzeb.
हिन्दू समाज हिन्दू संस्कृति और हिन्दू धर्म ही पाकिस्तान बांग्ला देश कश्मीर की असली पहचान है उसी में खुश और तरक्की कर सकते है
Yes this dude is correct. Let alone Subcontinent all of Europe, Americas and Australia were Hindu.
Muslims dislodged Hindus from every where by force. 😂
Hinduism is only born in the 19th century.
The English pronunciation of Ali Abbas is as bad as his Urdu pronunciation. Sometime I felt as if a kid is asking random aimless questions.
The majority of the people in the Indus Valley converted to Islam through the efforts of Sufi missionaries. There was no mass forceful conversion. The spread of Islam was largely a gradual process influenced by various factors including the work of Sufi missionaries.
I would also be interested to know how the shoodra ancestors of this baba were treated by their Brahmin masters before the so called "bad Turks" came and rescued them from perpetual humiliation.
This is just another type of propaganda.
Why are you judge people you will best in English but plz don't judge someone and last thing don't lose someone confidence
@Offmusic-u3f That wasn't my intentoin. His previous podcast on the water related issue was very informative. I was genuinely impressed and complimented him for leading such a thoughtful discussion on an important topic. His guests also conducted themselves in a mature and educated manner. I would have been just as justified in criticizing him if the conversation had lacked focus or included random and sometimes childish questions. Salman Rashid can be just as much of a propagandist as the state. He has a tendency to exaggerate issues and making fun of his own people. Not everyone claims Arab ancestry, the overwhelming majority is attached to this land both emotionally and mentally and consider it to be their ancestral homeland. He also portrays Muslim rulers as entirely negative, and he is also full of prejudice agianst Pashtuns/Afhgans. Would he bother to tell us how the uppers caste Hindus treated the Hindus of the lower castes before the arrival of Islam I this region? What was the relation between Hindus and Budhists? The peaceful albeit gullible Punjabi Muslims were tricked into leaving their culture, history and language by the bad people from UP, but who forced the Hindu Punjabis to shun their mother tongue in favour of Hindi?
@@User-b-o9h Dear Bro really Thank you for your constructive criticism I always take it positive. I'll work on these things. You are always welcome to criticize according to your knowledge and opinion. . However Salman Rashid also has pointed out the Class based society and the brutalities of Barhamns as major reason of local support for Arabs during Chuch and Raja Dhahir era.
Thankful once again Bro.
Sir, very good historical analysis. Kindly inform about first arrival of syyd or sharif in India who are the major fuedal of Sind and Punjab.
@@Ehsan-bm2st However different Historical books quote various timings but Ummayad period was the starting era for Alids emigration.
Indus Valley people at least since the time of Indo Aryans have been settling down in waves in the gangetic plains bringing with them their culture languages tech and DNA.
India means land of Indus. The world has made a mockery of this word by assigning it to every Tom tick & Harry...
Sindh _ Hind are interchangeable and the terms define the people of the land no matter what their relgion.
It was never a monolith. Always a land of diversity and multiple faiths philosophies.
How would it sound if I mixed up Hegel Neitche Marx Heidegger Germanic folk relgion into a cocktail 🍸 and called it German ism. Would it make sense to have contradictory ideologies and faith all mashed up forcefully in to a colonial stereotyping of all German people especially when not all of them live in a single state.
I don't know how and when we started accepting this sort of denigrating nonsense about our selves but it should've ended with the decolonising process and independence.
Alas we're still not there.
Btw can Persianism be a relgion ? Esp entailing monotheism polytheistic panentheistic ideas plus philosophies all cooked in to a sticky broth. Good luck to anyone consuming it.
People are now calling it sanatan. I don't know whether it's an original name or a modern take on it.
South asia has been turned into a laughing stock. Thanks to our own fundamentalists.
Why can’t mentioned Mehpal of punjab and jay pal of Lahore who keep provocations? Punjabi forgivinen three time by Mehmood Ghazanvi then finally he decided to chased them down to all the way into deep India
I condemn the host's introduction. He was unprepared for the guest, and the talk did not flow. If you're inviting someone who is Salman Rashid, do some research and ask questions with context.
Hindu vegetarian the aur muslims non veg. Isliye khana alag banta hoga.
Kisne kaha hindu vegetarian the Bhai hindus b non vegetarian hote hai or proudly non vegetarian hona chahiye
I condemn the killings of both sides. Not at all justified killings of muslims in India even if the train full of dead bodies coming to India. At least both sides should have given safe passage both sides. It all started by muslims in Rawalpindi The first few trains of dead bodies originated from Pakistan. Like dr rashid forefathers, almost all Hindu Sikhs were under the wrong impression that after partition we continue to stay and live in Pakistan.
Sikh kyon Hindu ke saath ho liya?
@aadilansari5997 kyounki 1. Sikh know their roots from sanatan dharma all our gurus birn and brought up on hindustan and from hindu santan family whereas even though almost all the muslims converts in Hindustan have their roots and legacy on this land yet they connect themselves with Arabs. Arabs kicks indian and pak muslims in their bums as also said by dr Rashid himself.
2 we cherish and concede indus valley our legacy where as muslim not.
3 in partition muslims raped killed hindus and Sikhs both without discrimination.
@@aadilansari5997 kyonki sikh dharti ke lal bane rahe, sindhu ghati mohanjodaro se, santana Dharma se tute nahi jabki muslmano apna baap badal kar Arbin, taimur lungra, gaznavi aur gauri ko tasleem kar liya. Sikh nahi bhule Guru Nanak aur unke Walid SANATANI HINDU HI THE. MAT BHULO MUGALTE MEIN NA RAHO JI IS BARE SAGIR AUR KHITTE.MEIN RAHNA WALA HAR SAKSH CHAHE AB HINDU HAI, MULLA HAI YA SIKH YA KALA MASIH HAI USKA WIRSA SANATANI HIND HAI ARBI YA CHANGEZI NAHI HAI. PAKISTHANI APNA WIRSA BHOOL CHUKE HAI OR ARBON KO APNA BAAP TASLEEM KAR LIYA HAI JABKI ARBI PAKISTANI AFGHANI KO GHASS BHI NAHI DALTE.
kyonki sikh dharti ke lal bane rahe, sindhu ghati mohanjodaro se, santana Dharma se tute nahi jabki muslmano apna baap badal kar Arbin, taimur lungra, gaznavi aur gauri ko tasleem kar liya. Sikh nahi bhule Guru Nanak aur unke Walid SANATANI HINDU HI THE. MAT BHULO MUGALTE MEIN NA RAHO JI IS BARE SAGIR AUR KHITTE.MEIN RAHNA WALA HAR SAKSH CHAHE AB HINDU HAI, MULLA HAI YA SIKH YA KALA MASIH HAI USKA WIRSA SANATANI HIND HAI ARBI YA CHANGEZI NAHI HAI. PAKISTHANI APNA WIRSA BHOOL CHUKE HAI OR ARBON KO APNA BAAP TASLEEM KAR LIYA HAI JABKI ARBI PAKISTANI AFGHANI KO GHASS BHI NAHI DALTE.
@aadilansari5997 kyonki sikh dharti ke lal bane rahe, sindhu ghati mohanjodaro se, santana Dharma se tute nahi jabki muslmano apna baap badal kar Arbin, taimur lungra, gaznavi aur gauri ko tasleem kar liya. Sikh nahi bhule Guru Nanak aur unke Walid SANATANI HINDU HI THE. MAT BHULO MUGALTE MEIN NA RAHO JI IS BARE SAGIR AUR KHITTE.MEIN RAHNA WALA HAR SAKSH CHAHE AB HINDU HAI, MULLA HAI YA SIKH YA KALA MASIH HAI USKA WIRSA SANATANI HIND HAI ARBI YA CHANGEZI NAHI HAI. PAKISTHANI APNA WIRSA BHOOL CHUKE HAI OR ARBON KO APNA BAAP TASLEEM KAR LIYA HAI JABKI ARBI PAKISTANI AFGHANI KO GHASS BHI NAHI DALTE.
Hoist is not prepared
This much truth will end his life. If you think in this way you will come to think that no one wanted Pakistan only Jinnah wanted that.
I salute Salman Rashid for telling us about the true History of Our old india.
Salman Rashid Sahab ,the community you are talking about is suffering from " Societal Depression ",since centuries !!!
duniya ki sari Barkat dariyai Sindh ki Jameen mein hai bhai logon main bheel bol raha hun